6
24 12 2 1 1980 America in Ruins 1 1 2 95 1 Pat Chote, Susan Walter: America in Ruins:The Decaying Infrastructure (Duke Press Policy Studies Paperbacks), 1983 2 2007

会計検査院 Board of Audit of Japan · 24 12 2 ˘ˇˆ˙˝˛˚ ˜ !" #$%&’() *+,-.ˇ/0123456+7 (8 9: #$%&’˛;0?@ab-6cde fg (h235i˙jklminop˛q6˛rsthuf(vw-hx5i+yz3x4

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 会計検査院 Board of Audit of Japan · 24 12 2 ˘ˇˆ˙˝˛˚ ˜ !" #$%&’() *+,-.ˇ/0123456+7 (8 9: #$%&’˛;0?@ab-6cde fg (h235i˙jklminop˛q6˛rsthuf(vw-hx5i+yz3x4

� ���

�����

��������� �

�� �� � �∗

� �

��������������� ��������

�����

�� 24� 12� 2����� ������������������� !"�#$%&'()

*+,-.�/0123456+7 (8�9:�#$%&'�;<=>0?@AB-6�CDE�FG

(H235I��JKLMINOP��Q6�RSTHUF(VW-HX5I+YZ3X4

[3�5����\�"]^_I�`�ab0�8�9:cd�efg(]hH)i+jklXP5I

(mk�noHpqTmr+st3X4

56[0uv�efg�8�9:�#$%&'(m.P)i+jklh3��Q�w�;<=>xCy

g(z{|6}�~���������� T��01P����H����[2lh34�=�����

�-����9�����(�m�+���}�� !"��x���z+ ¡I¢@£lP��H¤¥

�uvH23�01P4

k�k�¦§�"�8�9:�¨zT#$%�©'I7ªT(«¬+­.P©'�|-(®�¯°%x

±²��³%H´56�-��µ�1@¶(c·.P©'+¸klXP4� TFU�efg�mr+¹

t�º�¦»+¼½k�¾tP¿h�À�+ÁÂtP¿h01Ã�4

"F0��8�9:�¨zT#$%I®�¯°%ÄÅ��µ�1@¶�-Á3� !"��(ÆXlF

ÇP4ÈÉ(�jÊËA�(m.P����ÌÍ(NÎ.P4

1���� �������������

�Æl�1980 �Å�Ï�0�8�9:�#$%+?@AB�)i+jk3Ш�ÑÒ|634Ó��.

PÔÕ�Ö×ØAmerica in RuinsÙ1�01P4Q�Ш� 1ÚEÉ(�]ÛÜ(ÝÞ-6�ß��àXlX3

~������¼á(â]¶ã(äÇ-63�01P2�4Q�®kL�-åæ�#$%�Cç©'IH2

lè@�Q�éê�;ëìÔ��í�|6�Q6(îïvéê�ðW63=�ñÖò�ó�óE ô 95

�������� ������������������������������ ��!"#�$%�����

�$%��&�'()*$%�+���,-�.���/0�123456

1� Pat Chote, Susan Walter: America in Ruins:The Decaying Infrastructure (Duke Press Policy Studies Paperbacks), 1983

2� 789�:;<�=>?<@ABC�D'�AB�EF�&�'()*3GHIJKLL�MN������2007

Page 2: 会計検査院 Board of Audit of Japan · 24 12 2 ˘ˇˆ˙˝˛˚ ˜ !" #$%&’() *+,-.ˇ/0123456+7 (8 9: #$%&’˛;0?@ab-6cde fg (h235i˙jklminop˛q6˛rsthuf(vw-hx5i+yz3x4

������� No.472013.3

��O��

õö;8Ô÷<åØø�ù�(�Pú@ûE+¸.PüåÙ�éê¼É(ýåk3495õö�9þ���

-\���X(������ëì������<��+±lÖ÷��[0+��ö ô01P4�"

( O6�\�¯� ô�å�ýá3��H��01@��Ï��ÄÅ�����å���(W32l�

ö��+kl�z|6P5IIH234�Ä������¹t��Ï 45�å�� 10�å���» I|

6¾��Mt-63��!ºI¬3H#$%"#�$OP5I�1@�%&]'�%¾�"#�(2lX

P4)T(�2002�*�:+;ó� I-40åØPCüåÙ�2007�>�Ô,�<- I-35WåØ�:<åÙ

I#$%(�P]�.Hýå���àX3�01P45��(�/0H´1_0(�Påæ�2���

�3uvj4klXP4

uv�8�9:�5#|63¯6��S�����@nX3t(8�9:�#$%&'+7(±8k3

Ï��-�9:��; 1(�J<#$%8�9:�=>|6PIQ�¾���SE+­k�� T(]h

H&'IHP5I01P4; 2(�#$%�u�H?@�A%+B�3t�Q�éê�CD0�Hv��

�+E�(FG5I�HkX5I01P4; 3(�~�����®S(IJHefg+KLk�� Ik

lMNO+��.P5I�Hk|01P4Pj�QR+S�k3TU(Ä�T(Và.PP�WxQW+

�z.PMNO����HkX5II���&'01P4; 4(�uv�8�9:��zX�Y|Hy

q01P(���W-}�Q6-�yq(�efMNX�XHXA(��ZT[½�\]0�^_`H

5I01P4¦(���ëì�<(H-HX&Þ0����0�Y|Hyq�ýå���a52lXP4

; 5(�uv�#$"#��ZÄ�@�b/xc^H´�deHfg02�|6Phªi�¯v�1_

0I��|6P��j�k"Tzl�#$%01PTU�uX4_0uj�����0�mnH_0+7

(#oîp�¾�|6lh33t(�qV^rs"#�uvV§k�¨zT#$%0�Hv�7ªT#$

%"#����i�¯X4

tOl�\�"]^_�u�0�\��\v��v�c^(�Pwxy0�z{�|�}+�P�(

A~P5I���k34k���Q�y_����]�-�+¹�����±²�����Tc�(Î�

5I�-�Q�mr+�PI����V�7(�.P�01P4

0�´�.P¿h��; 1�©'.HWá#$"#�$]&'(mkl��Ä7+�.P5IHv8�

9:�#$%(mr.¿h01P4���9��)iØ�µ���%FÙ3�(mk�~�����-�h

&IX���x��C��+ ½klXPI����Ê�|6lXP��56��H�-�+Q�ÞP

601@��kv�y_���x��(­.P���¹t3��m�)+� .¿hH�01@��C�

�¡0´�mr.¿h�+FÇP¿hH�01P4

; 2�©'�.HWáu�H?@�éêI¢��&'(mkl��£­H���KL(tO�Q6¤6

�"#xc�(rÇ3Ô¥ò�;�¦Õ��§¨��jI©ª(�P��(W3P«±����I�¬�

�±���p%+.¿h01P4RST±���(�2l�­®3�0Á6��@u¯�±�+£­I

.P��H°+±kl�H-HX4[3�#$%(m.PéêI¢��3t�MN�j�£­01P4c

¡�²³¨x�´µ(m.P¶ H´0Ö·�|63²³¨H´¼¸ÁOHXTUx�Ô�¥<�HkX

TU�éêm�3�1[@(uXTU�c¶?0�efg�;�¹���^º.PTUH´(mr.Pé

궨��j�»(g­01P4¼�½¾�<�â¿�À2�éê��oÁIÂÃjÄ�<ÅÆ��j�

A%dÇ�¼�½IéêÈS�¢�¶¨��<ÅÆ%H´�Mt-6lh3��JÉ�MN�j�ÊM�

^hË01P4Q�3t�MN̬+ÊM.P��Hj]�6�²Í�no(©ª.¿h01P4MNO

3� PQR@STUVWX�Y(Z[ 5\]^_��`abc�2011

Page 3: 会計検査院 Board of Audit of Japan · 24 12 2 ˘ˇˆ˙˝˛˚ ˜ !" #$%&’() *+,-.ˇ/0123456+7 (8 9: #$%&’˛;0?@ab-6cde fg (h235i˙jklminop˛q6˛rsthuf(vw-hx5i+yz3x4

�� ����������

��d��

�HXÎ�0�hªHY�.0��/�ÏÐ�¯XÑ`mr�¢�+¤IklXl��MN�j�M[}�

3uv�8�9:����z�HkX45�¾Ò(�@�MNO�¯XÎ��¬�5#(Ó�klXP»

Ô+¾Òk����z`Õ0-TÖG+×ÇlMN�j�M�»Ô+j¦.¿h01P4ÉØ.P PPP

ØPublic Private PartnershipÙ�©ª�¸OH¶ç01@�ÙðT(j"|6lXP� �`Ú+Mt���

��¦»(U23�6%+no(j¦.¿h01P4

; 3�©'�.HWáMNO���ãA(ckl��AÛ; 2�©'��mrç�¸�01Ã�4tO

l��\�Üþ¦Ý��(ÌÍ.P5I�����MNO���ãA(�!.P5I�z{|6P¿h0

1P4]Þ�8�9:����z+ß�.P��~àá01@�[3âE�¹t3MNX�ã:��¯|

��������®H|(ÌÍklh35I(mk�� Täå�r¢(H|6P5I�g­01P4

; 4�©'�.HWáY|Hyq�MNX^ºIMNO^º(ckl����� æç�yq�M

NX�è�X3�®�]hHé+ýIklXP4-êë�MNX^º�\�"]^_��ì���í6(

ÆH�2lXP���9îTHc¶`ïF��xç�MNX�¸����ðB(H2lXP5I�ñ´(

1P���01P4MN`Õ�òó�¦¸ªO�Q�ôõI�Ði�-Á3��� æç�-êë�7

ª`ß+�ö{� ó�II�(é÷.¿h01P48�9:�1P¿hø+ùú(UF.P5IHv�

8�9:&'+�=������-�����ûü���IX239���0�â+ýh~.��H5I��

Q�"{�aþIU�klXHX5I�\�"]^_�±8�-�9:0�1P4

[3�efg��0�MNX��àT�à�$](�P¦T±8��®�&'½|6lh3���CX

(Q�a����01235I(��a.P£­�1Ã�4�áÃ�MNX����1@¶�Q����

1@¶�âEÎ�����1@¶H´+�.PÄS({lXP5I��OP¿h01P4��Å�

�S(3uv���âEMNX�yq(ä�klXPIX�¦»��Q��ã+�X½��-]a�v

µ�.P£­�1Ã�4

; 5�©'�.HWá�1_0I#$%I�cd(ckl��]�-0�uv���X+Ñ.hªi

�1@�c¶?0�¼¸y0(tO�×ô���(�@��Óý���(��+h3.5IIHP4\�

0�¬��v �� 20 õö�¾Í�E�HvE�.P5Ix!"�]¾³���xv#[P5I(H

PH´$O�|6lXP����[&[&��H½�>÷��3uv1P4[3� O�Y%&�&'�

à �|6��H@¾Ò|63��'F(�uv�qV^rsH5I�1[@)-6lXHX4*^¢�

+É~k(kl�c^�j4k3-'F�x�o�+5¨�-Ñ.��(IX���H���0mr.P

5I�ø�+I,9��r¢H-ZUW�INO���4û.�5ͨ�qV^rs"#�uX4qV^

rsHâE5ͨ�ÂÃ��ø/�+;òÜI��(~�|6P¿h01P41970�Å(�0ï�10+

zl(23�123ø/�+;òÜ�í�+�[}d4�y_»Ô�~5�-#t3��(�6Ó-7c

x897H´�*^iK��àx�5Í�!I*^i�~5H´�0hP5I�-#tP¿h0�H�Ã

��4

wxy0�Á�Á¼k)I�\�"]^_�9:��mr�.0(#[2lXP���C��I±�

T:;0�7<@|6HX5I+=X3X4

!(�c�±²��i%(ÆXlFÇP4

2��������� !"#$��%&���'()*

�µo>��T��±²�i%Ic�s?�Y�Î@F_�A�B��C��D%H´�â4�+E

Page 4: 会計検査院 Board of Audit of Japan · 24 12 2 ˘ˇˆ˙˝˛˚ ˜ !" #$%&’() *+,-.ˇ/0123456+7 (8 9: #$%&’˛;0?@ab-6cde fg (h235i˙jklminop˛q6˛rsthuf(vw-hx5i+yz3x4

������� No.472013.3

��e��

�(.P�µ+j¦.P5I01P4\�"]^_��F_i�%IB��C�&'��¬3Hmr(t

Ol�� �®� �Óý�1@¶�c¶?�FTy_��³TéG+ÎHk�J¶0deHÖG(|-

|6P±²�Iþ�·�%��mr�1@¶+��|�P��01234

JKL��M�NOP$o>Q{�JRklc�s?�{'+�µo>���TH�SIklh34¯

6��S�� !"��IâET!�·�0U�|63�01P4.HWá�¬0��-5#ÊM¨�F

���»`c���ÊM¨(#[P¬c0�F�c�V×cxW�F�c��jH´�X���I�

¯� ô�¬�ö�YZ�Z[\�×�ò�������I�][2l�c¶?��Î�^��M�&4

»(¯��×����ºHab0-T+�B�_/0��0¨�¯`tå}%�V×���c�µab�

$t��º�4�����c%+�3-k34âE�T!x'��d�+â]�NO�$t�-T+â]

|�PIX�¯6±²���efA+4ZÑk3�01234

�Ä�c�s?�Pg��c¶� 1!0��]�-� 2!�3!0�IX��0�²³�s?�(12

34c¶�� 2!0��Ê�I_���Ð%(�@�s?�Y(�hk3�01P4�Æl�"�¯6±

²����i�jkINW63��Q�Éo�H±²��+k3��uX456-���.¿l�Ä(c

�s?+â]|�lXP4þ(l.��( 1960�- 70�Å��"�¯6±²��Ic�Es?�Y+�

Ä(U�k3mJ��01P5I5Q�i�jkIN�(n|WkX4

; 2S�c�s?â]��80�Å�âE¤©�e´oI�pq�ÂÃH´r�s<0�I�t�z7ª

�s?��Q�"u01P4\�JÂÓ��MÊI�Ä(�c¶vþò��s?�â]�.HWáwxx

yz�{|H´c¶Ó��-�7ªÓ>�M�&ÄS0�1234

; 3S�c�s?â]}� 90�ÅÞ��-01P��þ(Á-6P��(¼�½0ÁP�@�; 1S�

2 S���Hâ]+lklXHX45�c�s?�â]k3IX�}~���®�¯°%�c�s?�I�

Î���\VÑx��c���ò½�7%���c����Q�H´(�P�ö{ÊY�c�s?�I�

N�¿h��01P4

�º�Å��µïv@�5���H»Ô��mr�st-6lXP�01P45�©'(mk�uv�

efg�3�E(W32lé÷k3)�Cæ��µ��o>Ikl[It-634�µ��o>�È�

g­H�����µ���²³�¾c01P42 É����I���6lXP���c¶�I��4��

��ä�01P4

�� 19� 11�(?@[It-63�µ�U o>? Ãi��[O�h�(����µ(st-6P

5IIkl�!� 4��+�BlXP4

�� � �®�� +abkHX�µ

�� \Ô¦Ô(èÞP¬c��ÑiIÖGO�j¦

�� ¬3H�~�+7�I.Pc�O�Ó� � � �

�� u�H�����-HP»ÔmrO1P�µ

550���®�¯°%��mr01P4���� �®¡0¬c���O+¸.P3t(�Ô¦Ô�

8�+?@��5I�£­01@�Q�3t(���0�HvÔ¦Ô(èÞPÑiIÖGO+¸.P5I

�£­01PIX�¤¥01P4����:�Å8Ô��&Þ0�Hv�c���i%�3t(�ôN�

�(�}�Î���â�c�O+Ó.¿hIX��@�Þ01P4����Æl�¤­-T01P�Ï

�-ÁPIY|H��0123�I�H@�¤3P-T01PÔ¦Ô�-ÁPI�cC%T(�HP��

x�óH´�¬c��Q6¤6���+�Æ¿h01@�Q6��"+�v.PIX�¤¥01P4

� �®¡0�4�r�s<�KL�����¼ .P©'01P4� �®(�@¡¢£{¤£9¥£

Page 5: 会計検査院 Board of Audit of Japan · 24 12 2 ˘ˇˆ˙˝˛˚ ˜ !" #$%&’() *+,-.ˇ/0123456+7 (8 9: #$%&’˛;0?@ab-6cde fg (h235i˙jklminop˛q6˛rsthuf(vw-hx5i+yz3x4

20

2

Page 6: 会計検査院 Board of Audit of Japan · 24 12 2 ˘ˇˆ˙˝˛˚ ˜ !" #$%&’() *+,-.ˇ/0123456+7 (8 9: #$%&’˛;0?@ab-6cde fg (h235i˙jklminop˛q6˛rsthuf(vw-hx5i+yz3x4

������� No.472013.3

��fg��

3�+,-.�/0

AØ�¦Iv�� !"�#$%�c��i%(mrkl~�T!�^hË01PJ¶���|P5I

H�-�c¶yq��C�Â�Âtl�§0�Q��¨KLHvkl� !"����HH»Ô(1P4

»(�¯°X3���Ð\�A©(�@¡¢£{¤c·��Cªß�$t�«Þ-6}��ÆlE�01

23]�-yq�¬3HT!¬O+HvkÆÆ1P4c¶��¨KLHvkl£­H� !"T!�0

hHX»Ô��¯°%x­³���\VÑ�®>¯àH´�°ã�-Ál��`àvI�OP¿h01Ã

�4'�±Ð�AB-6l�� !"���¨^º��§%�²à�«Þ-6HX4

z2l�âE!"�©ª+>ÂT(þP£­�1P4�\IÏ¿l����� PFIØPrivate Finance InitiativeÙ

���»�i����\0]Þ+³tP�×`Õ�Âtl´01P5I��~T!pIâE!p�-ZU

W����T0��<�ªß�âE(µ&¶P·�<�uX5I��»(�×`Õ0�iª��x¸¹j

](c.P±8�=>|6lXHX5I���¾ëì�¯x~�"#��zX(c.P�6�^_`H5

I\º�¾Ò.¿h5I�uX4

�\0���¨^ºx�����Ð%+stl�PFI���PPPØPublic Private PartnershipÙ�©ª�þ

-6lh34k�k�º­�d]�Á�Üþ¦Ý���Ë�»¼�Cæ�d]H�<�ªßH´�½�

�3uv���TaÁ��X5I+¼½.¿h01P4®HX~T!p0��Ï(Ï¿ls¾(�ÐTH

�-¿ +��klh3]�-�~��×Cç� PPP��h� 01P4 ô£Z[£YZH´�~�

��û� BOTØBuild Operate Transfer : PFI�JÀÙI���¿h��01@�jÊËA�(mk�"��

h� Ikl�l0hP�601P4�¿âÁ%IQ�É� JR(�PT!��hk3 PPP�JÀINO

��45��H�\�±8��hI&'�+Â[Ol����(rk3âE!p��¨+©ª.P¿hH

�01P4

pqT(�� ô0Ùð|6ÆÆ1P���¢��iª���̧ ¹Ã��®3�Ã��¾Ò�� O��

Ã�ÄxÃ�SEÄÅÄ�iªÆê���©ª�d4���¢�±��~5��<��`ßتw(�P

ûâ���`ßÙ�S��cÇÎ�I7�6�ÈÉÊ�QR�¾ËTÃ�SE��S%H´01P4[3�

^_�ì��� PPP(ÆXl��5#I���z�¥ò�j]�#o̪��X(î/`h0���z�

¹t3��(rwhªIkÖG+ÊM.P¶��j]X��HP®3��x�À���-ZUW���%�

µa"#x4�r�s<"#�A¡`Ͷ�H´+é÷k3X4

�£­H����½kHXE�H PPP¶�+Îs.P5I0�Hv�ÙðÏ�klûâ��@ÐX�6

(¾ÒklXv5I�g­01P4PPP ��C��¡0£­H~���+MtP3t(«Þl�×6HX

�01P�-�Q�ÑÀ+FÇP�0�Hv�[3Ò�6�¨¾�(ĺ.P�0�Hv��@ÐX�6

#o(�O+]G¿h01Ã�4

�\Üþ¦Ý��� PPP+L�I.P���uX��jÊËA���6�[&[&%E�01P4âE

(Ó+�Þ���X�Ó[PIÔÕ(�O���Üþ¦Ý����³T!-T(èÞPÖGO+bµT

(äåklXHXaÖS�X�uX4z2lr�H�6+��.P5I�£­01P4�"�AÛ���

H�i�.�IHP�ÐT0�ƯXr�s<+�×.P�6+4ZÑklh3±8+¸klXP4�\

Ø��7ðk3 PPP�-%@ÆÆ�Q6+A~P¶�+�"�lk�PPP(ÆXl�¬3H�òÜ:�÷

�(H@�PI�ûâ��OP5I5QÑj�01Ã�4�\ÙÑIkl5#Üþ¦Ý��+IP5IQ

\(��\�c¡¿Ú� �(�PøÛ8Õ�þIX�~TÎ�q�#�����(��6x-Üïv@

�Û�øÝ+ÙÑk�Q6+×ÇlÜþ¦Ý��+IPIX� Þ�é÷kHÞ6�H-HX4