154
UHVHDUFKIRU PDQDQGHQYLURQPHQW 5,-.6,167,7887922592/.6*(=21’+(,’(10,/,(8 1$7,21$/,167,787(2)38%/,&+($/7+$1’7+((19,5210(17 5,90UDSSRUW 3V\FKLVFKHRQJH]RQGKHLG ’HWHUPLQDQWHQHQGHHIIHFWHQYDQSUHYHQWLHYH LQWHUYHQWLHV ,$00DDV --DQVHQHLQGUHG VHSWHPEHU ’LWRQGHU]RHNZHUGYHUULFKWLQRSGUDFKWHQWHQODVWHYDQKHW0LQLVWHULHYDQ9RONVJH]RQGKHLG :HO]LMQHQ6SRUWLQKHWNDGHUYDQSURMHFW’HWHUPLQDQWHQHQ3UHYHQWLH PRPHQWHHOZHUN]DDPELM7123UHYHQWLHHQ*H]RQGKHLG 5,903RVWEXV%$%LOWKRYHQWHOHIRRQID[

RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

UHVHDUFK�IRUPDQ�DQG�HQYLURQPHQW5,-.6,167,7887�9225�92/.6*(=21'+(,'�(1�0,/,(81$7,21$/�,167,787(�2)�38%/,&�+($/7+�$1'�7+(�(19,5210(17

5,90�UDSSRUW����������3V\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG'HWHUPLQDQWHQ�HQ�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV,$0�0DDV� � -�-DQVHQ��HLQGUHG��

VHSWHPEHU�����

'LW�RQGHU]RHN�ZHUG�YHUULFKW�LQ�RSGUDFKW�HQ�WHQ�ODVWH�YDQ�KHW�0LQLVWHULH�YDQ�9RONVJH]RQGKHLG�:HO]LMQ�HQ�6SRUW��LQ�KHW�NDGHU�YDQ�SURMHFW���������'HWHUPLQDQWHQ�HQ�3UHYHQWLH� PRPHQWHHO�ZHUN]DDP�ELM�712�3UHYHQWLH�HQ�*H]RQGKHLG

5,90��3RVWEXV���������%$�%LOWKRYHQ��WHOHIRRQ�������������������ID[�����������������

Page 2: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

Page 3: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ����YDQ����

9RONVJH]RQGKHLG7RHNRPVW�9HUNHQQLQJ3V\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG��GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HQ�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV

(LQGUHGDFWLH��,�$�0��0DDV��-��-DQVHQ

Page 4: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

Page 5: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ����YDQ����

$EVWUDFW

0HQWDO� GLVRUGHUV� FRQVWLWXWH� DQ� LPSRUWDQW� VRFLHWDO� DQG� SXEOLF� KHDOWK� SUREOHP�� EHLQJUHVSRQVLEOH� IRU� RYHU� ����RI� �GLUHFW�� KHDOWK� FDUH� FRVWV�� 7KH� XVH� RI�PHQWDO� KHDOWK� FDUHVHUYLFHV� LV� VWLOO� JURZLQJ� DW� D� VXEVWDQWLDO� UDWH�� 7R� XQGHUSLQ� SUHYHQWLRQ� SROLF\� ZLWKLQPHQWDO KHDOWK� FDUH�� PRUH� NQRZOHGJH� LV� QHHGHG� RQ� ERWK� WKH� GHWHUPLQDQWV� RI� PHQWDOGLVRUGHUV� DQG� WKH� SRVVLELOLWLHV� RI� LQIOXHQFLQJ� WKHVH� GHWHUPLQDQWV�� 7KLV� UHYLHZ� DLPV� WRUHIOHFW�WKH�VWDWH�RI�WKH�DUW�RQ�WKHVH�WRSLFV�$OWKRXJK�WKHUH�LV�D�JURZLQJ�ERG\�RI�NQRZOHGJH�RQ�VSHFLILF�GHWHUPLQDQWV�LQ�WKHHWLRORJ\� RI� VHYHUDO�PHQWDO� GLVRUGHUV�� WKHUH� LV� OLWWOH� NQRZQ� DERXW� WKH� LQWHUUHODWLRQVKLSVEHWZHHQ� GHWHUPLQDQWV� LQ� WKH� FDXVDO� FKDLQ� OHDGLQJ� WR� GLVRUGHUV�� 3HUVRQDOLW\� WUDLWV�WUDXPDWLF�HYHQWV�LQ�FKLOGKRRG��D�ORZ�VRFLR�HFRQRPLF�VWDWXV��H[WHQVLYH�XUEDQL]DWLRQ�DQGUDSLG� VRFLDO� FKDQJHV� LQ� VRFLHW\� DUH� UHODWHG� WR� PRUH� WKDQ� RQH� PHQWDO� GLVRUGHU�,QWHUYHQWLRQV�LQIOXHQFLQJ�WKHVH�JHQHULF�GHWHUPLQDQWV��RU�WUDLQLQJ�WR�FRSH�ZLWK�WKHP��ZLOOKDYH�WKH�JUHDWHVW�SRWHQWLDO�KHDOWK�EHQHILWV�1R� GHILQLWH� FRQFOXVLRQV� FDQ� EH� GUDZQ� DERXW� WKH� HIIHFWV� RI� LQWHUYHQWLRQVLQIOXHQFLQJ� WKH� GHWHUPLQDQWV� RI� PHQWDO� GLVRUGHUV�� ,QWHUYHQWLRQV� WDUJHWLQJ� VHYHUDOGHWHUPLQDQWV�DW�WKH�VDPH�WLPH�DUH�DVVXPHG�WR�EH�WKH�PRVW�SURPLVLQJ��7KH�HIIHFWLYHQHVVRI VHFRQGDU\�SUHYHQWLRQ�RI�GHSUHVVLRQ�LQ�WKH�HOGHUO\�DQG�SUHYHQWLRQ�RI�VXEVWDQFH�DEXVHWKURXJK� SURJUDPV� DW� VFKRRO� KDV� SURYHQ� VXIILFLHQW� IRU� QDWLRQDO� LPSOHPHQWDWLRQ�,QWHUYHQWLRQV� WDUJHWHG� DW� IDPLO\� PHPEHUV� RI� SV\FKLDWULF� SDWLHQWV� KDV� EHHQ� VHHQ� WRSUHYHQW�WKH�RFFXUUHQFH�RI�GLVWUHVV�DQG�DQ[LHW\�GLVRUGHUV�,QYHVWLQJ� LQ� UHVHDUFK� RQ� GHWHUPLQDQWV� RI�PHQWDO� GLVRUGHUV� LV� D� SUHUHTXLVLWH� IRUPDNLQJ SURJUHVV� LQ� SUHYHQWLRQ�� 5HVHDUFK� RQ� WKH� HIIHFWV� RI� SUHYHQWLYH� LQWHUYHQWLRQ� LQWHUPV RI� LQFLGHQFH� RI� GLVHDVH� LV� VFDUFH�� (IIHFWLYH� SURJUDPPHV� VKRXOG� EH� QDWLRQDOO\LPSOHPHQWHG��$V� WKHUH� LV� SUDFWLFDOO\� QR� LQIRUPDWLRQ� RQ� VWUDWHJLHV� IRU� LPSOHPHQWDWLRQZLWKLQ�WKH�ILHOG�RI�PHQWDO�GLVRUGHU�SUHYHQWLRQ��LQYHVWPHQWV�LQ�WKLV�ILHOG�DUH�UHTXLUHG�

Page 6: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

Page 7: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ����YDQ����

9RRUZRRUG'H�DOJHPHQH�GRHOVWHOOLQJ�YDQ�GH�979� LV�� ³+HW�ELMHHQEUHQJHQ�� DQDO\VHUHQ�HQ� LQWHJUHUHQYDQ�NHQQLV�HQ�JHJHYHQV��GLH�YDQ�EHODQJ�]LMQ�YRRU�GH�EHOHLGVYRUPLQJ�RS�KHW�JHELHG�YDQYRONVJH]RQGKHLG�HQ�]RUJ��9DQ�2HUV���������,Q�KHW�WUDMHFW�QDDU�979������]XOOHQ�WKHPD�UDSSRUWHQ� YHUVFKLMQHQ�� GLH� DDQVOXLWHQ� ELM� EHOHLGVYUDJHQ� RS� GH� NRUWH� HQ� PLGGHOODQJHWHUPLMQ�� 5LFKWOLMQ� YRRU� GH� NHX]H� YDQ� RQGHUZHUSHQ� LV� RQGHU� PHHU� GH� LQ� 979�����JHVLJQDOHHUGH� SUREOHPDWLHN�� +HW� RQGHUZHUS� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� JH]RQGKHLGNZDP�LQ�979������QLHW�DDQ�GH�RUGH��,Q�979������NZDP�KHW�RQGHUZHUS�µGHWHUPLQDQWHQYDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� JH]RQGKHLG¶� DDQ� ERG� LQ� WZHH� DI]RQGHUOLMNH� ELMGUDJHQ�µ3HUVRRQVNHQPHUNHQ� HQ� SV\FKLVFKH� JH]RQGKHLG¶� HQ� µ6RFLDOH� RPJHYLQJ� HQ� SV\FKLVFKHJH]RQGKHLG¶��2PGDW�GH]H�VSOLWVLQJ�QLHW�LQ�RYHUHHQVWHPPLQJ�LV�PHW�KHW�JHGDFKWHJRHG�LQ�GHSV\FKLDWULH�� LV� LQ� GH� YRRUEHUHLGLQJ� QDDU� 979������ EHVORWHQ� GLW� RQGHUVFKHLG� WH� ODWHQYHUYDOOHQ� HQ� ppQ� ELMGUDJH� RS� WH� QHPHQ� RYHU� µ'HWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH�RQ�JH]RQGKHLG¶��+HW�FRPSOH[H�NDUDNWHU�YDQ�GLW�RQGHUZHUS�YURHJ�RP�HHQ�PHHU�JHGHJHQDDQSDN�GDQ�PRJHOLMN�ZDV�ELQQHQ�KHW�WLMGVSDG�HQ�DQGHUH�NDGHUV�YDQ�979�������'LW�JROGRRN�YRRU�GH�GRRU�RQV�ZHQVHOLMN�JHDFKWH�NRSSHOLQJ�YDQ�GH]H�UDSSRUWDJH�DDQ�KHW�RQGHUZHUSHIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�1D� KHW� SUHVHQWHUHQ� YDQ�979������ LV� GLUHFW� JHVWDUW�PHW� KHW� QDGHQNHQ� RYHU� HHQ]LQYROOH�LQYXOOLQJ�YDQ�KHW�RQGHUZHUS�ELQQHQ�KHW�FRQFHSW�YDQ�GH�979��1D�RYHUOHJURQGHVPHW�KHW�0LQLVWHULH�YDQ�9:6�HQ�EHWURNNHQ�SDUWLMHQ�LV�HHQ�RS]HW�JHNR]HQ�ZDDUYDQ�X�KLHUKHW� HLQGUHVXOWDDW� ]LHW�� +HW� UDSSRUW� LV� �� FRQIRUP� GH� WKHPD�UDSSRUWHQ� YDQ� 979������ �RSJHERXZG� LQ� GHOHQ�� HHQ� LQWHJUDWLHI� GHHO� $� RS� QDDP� YDQ� GH� HLQGUHGDNWHXUV�� HQ� HHQµDFKWHUJURQG¶�GHHO�%��HQ�%���ZDDULQ�GH�ELMGUDJHQ�YDQ�GH�5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW�*URQLQJHQ�HQKHW�7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW�LQWHJUDDO�]LMQ�RSJHQRPHQ��+HW�LQWHJUDWLHYH�GHHO�$�NHQW�HHQ�RS]HWGLH DDQVOXLW� RS� GH� JHNR]HQ� VWUXFWXXU� YDQ� GH� WKHPDUDSSRUWHQ� YRRU� 979������SUREOHHPVWHOOLQJ�� SUREOHHPDQDO\VH�� EHOHLGVDQDO\VH� HQ� EHWHNHQLV� YDQ� GH� EHYLQGLQJHQYRRU KHW�EHOHLG�2SQLHXZ�LV�JHEOHNHQ�GDW�GH�SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG�HHQ�ZHHUEDUVWLJ�HQ�FRPSOH[JHELHG�ELQQHQ�GH�YRONVJH]RQGKHLG�EHVODDW��'DQN]LM�GH�HQWKRXVLDVWH�LQ]HW�YDQ�GH�DXWHXUVELQQHQ�GH�5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW�*URQLQJHQ�HQ�KHW�7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW�LV�HFKWHU�HHQ�VWDWH�RI�WKH�DUW� UDSSRUW� WRW� VWDQG� JHEUDFKW� GDW� GH� NHQQLV� RS� KHW� WHUUHLQ� YDQ� GH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG�HQ�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�GH]H�IDFWRUHQ�RSHHQ�LQWHJUDWLHYH�ZLM]H�LQ�NDDUW�EUHQJW�979� KRRSW� PHW� GLW� WKHPD�UDSSRUW� HHQ� ELMGUDJH� WH� NXQQHQ� OHYHUHQ� DDQ� GHLQIRUPDWLHEHKRHIWH�ELM�KHW�YHUGHU�RQWZLNNHOHQ�YDQ�RQGHU]RHNV��HQ�SUHYHQWLHEHOHLG�ELQQHQGH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ�

'U��-�$�0��YDQ�2HUV��SURMHFWOHLGHU�979

Page 8: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

Page 9: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ����YDQ����

,QKRXG.HUQERRGVFKDS���

'HHO�$��3V\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG��HHQ�RYHU]LFKW�YDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HQ�SUHYHQWLH���

� 3UREOHHPGHILQLWLH������ 0DDWVFKDSSHOLMNH�HQ�ZHWHQVFKDSSHOLMNH�FRQWH[W������ 9UDDJVWHOOLQJ�HQ�ZHUNZLM]H������ *HEUXLNWH�EHJULSSHQ���

� 3UREOHHPDQDO\VH������ 'HWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG������� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS��GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ��SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG���

� %HOHLGVDQDO\VH���

� $DQNQRSLQJVSXQWHQ�YRRU�EHOHLG������ 2QGHU]RHN�QDDU�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ������ 2QGHU]RHN�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV������ $DQEHYHOLQJHQ�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQ�GH�LPSOHPHQWDWLH�YDQ�HIIHFWLHI�JHEOHNHQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV������ 9HUDQWZRRUGHOLMNKHGHQ�LQ�SUHYHQWLH������ 6ORWRSPHUNLQJ���

/LWHUDWXXU���

'HHO�%���$FKWHUJURQGVWXGLHV���

,QWURGXFWLH���

'HHO�%���'HWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG���

� ,QOHLGLQJ������ 3V\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG��GHILQLWLH�HQ�DIEDNHQLQJ������ +HW�'\QDPLVFKH�6WUHVV�.ZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO������� (HQ�LQGHOLQJ�YDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ������� :HUNZLM]H���

� 'HWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�RQJH]RQGKHLG������ 6WHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ���

Page 10: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

���� $QJVW��HQ�VRPDWRIRUPH�VWRRUQLVVHQ������� 6FKL]RIUHQLH�HQ�DDQYHUZDQWH�SV\FKRWLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�������� 6FKL]RIUHQLH��������� %LSRODLUH�VWRRUQLV������� 9HUVODYLQJHQ������ 3V\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�LQ�NLQGHUHQ�HQ�DGROHVFHQWHQ������ 6XwFLGH������ 3V\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG���

� &RQFOXVLHV������� (HQ�RYHU]LFKW�YDQ�GH�EHODQJULMNVWH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ������� 1RJPDDOV�KHW�G\QDPLVFKH�VWUHVV�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO������� %HWHNHQLV�YDQ�GH�EHYLQGLQJHQ�YRRU�KHW�**=�EHOHLG��������� +HW�RQGHU]RHNVEHOHLG�������� 0RJHOLMNKHGHQ�YRRU�SUHYHQWLH������� (QNHOH�WRHNRPVWYHUZDFKWLQJHQ���

/LWHUDWXXU���

'HHO�%���+HW�HIIHFW�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS��GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ��SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG���

� ,QOHLGLQJ���

� 3UREOHHPVWHOOLQJ�HQ�PHWKRGH������� 'HILQLWLH�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH������� .HX]H�YDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�������� 'H�YUDDJVWHOOLQJHQ�������� 'H�PHWD�DQDO\WLVFKH�PHWKRGH����

� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�GH�QHJDWLHYH�JHYROJHQ�YDQ�LQJULMSHQGHOHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�RI�VWUHVVRUHQ�������� 9HUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�EHODVWLQJ�YDQ�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�SDWLsQWHQ�������� 9HUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�JHYROJHQ�YRRU�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�YDQ�KHW�RYHUOLMGHQ�YDQ�GH�SDUWQHU�������� 9HUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�JHYROJHQ�YDQ�ZHUNHORRVKHLG�YRRU�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�������� +HW�YHUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�EHODVWLQJ�YDQ�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�YDQ�KXOSEHKRHYHQGH�RXGHUHQ����

� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�GH�HUYDUHQ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�HQ�VHOI�HIILFDF\�������� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�������� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�VHOI�HIILFDF\����

� %HVFKRXZLQJ�������� %HSHUNLQJHQ����

Page 11: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

���� %HDQWZRRUGLQJ�YDQ�GH�YUDDJVWHOOLQJHQ�������� 'LVFXVVLH����

� .DGHUWHNVWHQ�������� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ������� 6HFXQGDLUH�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�ELM�RXGHUHQ��KHW�DNWLHI�DDQELHGHQ�YDQ�EHKDQGHOLQJ�DDQRXGHUHQ�PHW�GHSUHVVLHYH�NODFKWHQ�������� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�YHUVODYLQJVSUHYHQWLH��HHQ�RYHU]LFKW�YDQ�PHWD�DQDO\VHV�������� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�ELM�NLQGHUHQ����

/LWHUDWXXU����

'DQNEHWXLJLQJ����

%LMODJH�� �9HU]HQGOLMVW����

%LMODJH�� �/LMVW�YDQ�DXWHXUV�HQ�UHIHUHQWHQ����

%LMODJH�� �$INRUWLQJHQ�HQ�GHILQLWLHV����

Page 12: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

Page 13: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

.HUQERRGVFKDS'H� DOJHPHQH� GRHOVWHOOLQJ� YDQ� GH� 9RONVJH]RQGKHLG� 7RHNRPVW� 9HUNHQQLQJHQ� LV�� ³+HWELMHHQEUHQJHQ�� DQDO\VHUHQ� HQ� LQWHJUHUHQ� YDQ� NHQQLV� HQ� JHJHYHQV� GLH� YDQ� EHODQJ� ]LMQYRRU�GH�EHOHLGVYRUPLQJ�RS�KHW�JHELHG�YDQ�YRONVJH]RQGKHLG�HQ�]RUJ´��'LW�UDSSRUW�JDDWVSHFLILHN� LQ� RS� GH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� �RQ�JH]RQGKHLG� HQ� GH� HIIHFWHQ� YDQLQWHUYHQWLHV�� +LHUPHH� ZRUGW� HHQ� UHJHOPDWLJ� RSJHPHUNWH� ODFXQH� LQ� YRRUJDDQGH� 979�HGLWLHV� QX� JHYXOG��'H� JHJHYHQV� XLW� GLW� UDSSRUW� ELHGHQ� RS� GLUHFWH�ZLM]H� RQGHUVWHXQLQJYRRU� KHW� RQWZLNNHOHQ� YDQ� QLHXZ� EHOHLG� DOV� KHW� JDDW� RP� KHW� RQGHU]RHNVEHOHLG� HQ� KHWSUHYHQWLHEHOHLG�RS�KHW�WHUUHLQ�YDQ�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ�

3UREOHHPGHILQLWLH3V\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� YRUPHQ� HHQ�RPYDQJULMN�PDDWVFKDSSHOLMN� HQ� YRONVJH]RQGKHLGV�SUREOHHP�� 3V\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� �LQFOXVLHI� ]RUJ� YRRU� YHUVWDQGHOLMNH� KDQGLFDS� HQ� GHPHQWLH�� ]LMQ

YHUDQWZRRUGHOLMN�YRRU�UXLP�����YDQ�GH��GLUHFWH��NRVWHQ�YDQ�GH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ�� (U� LV�QRJ�VWHHGV�VSUDNH�YDQ�HHQ� IRUVH�JURHL� LQ�KHW�JHEUXLN�YDQ�**=�YRRU]LHQLQJHQ��9RRUHHQ� DFWLHYH� SUHYHQWLH� ELQQHQ� KHW� JHHVWHOLMN� YRONVJH]RQGKHLGVEHOHLG� LV� HHQ� UHJHOPDWLJH� HQJHGHJHQ� DQDO\VH� YDQ� GH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� YDQ� EHODQJ� HQ� YDQ� GHPRJHOLMNKHGHQ�RP�GLH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�WH�EHwQYORHGHQ�

3UREOHHPDQDO\VH��GHWHUPLQDQWHQ3V\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�]LMQ�PXOWLIDFWRULsOH�DDQGRHQLQJHQ� 2YHU�GH�RQGHUOLQJH�YHUEDQGHQ� WXVVHQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� LQ�GH�FDXVDOH�NHWHQ�QDDU�KHW�RQWVWDDQ

YDQ� HHQ� VWRRUQLV� LV� QRJ� ZHLQLJ� EHNHQG�� :HO� LV� HU� LQPLGGHOV� GH� QRGLJH� EHZLMVODVW� YRRUVSHFLILHNH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�ELM�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�� 9HUVFKLOOHQGH� JHQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� EOLMNHQ� HHQ� DDQ]LHQOLMNH� ELMGUDJH� WH� KHEEHQ� ELM� KHWRQWVWDDQ�YDQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH�HQ�ELSRODLUH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�� ,Q�PLQGHUH�PDWH�VSHOHQ�]LM�RRN�HHQ�UROELM� DQJVW�� HQ� VRPDWRIRUPH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� GHSUHVVLH� HQ� PLVEUXLN� HQ� DIKDQNHOLMNKHLG� YDQYHUVODYHQGH�PLGGHOHQ�� 5HODWLHI�JRHG�RQGHUERXZG�LV�RRN�GH�LQYORHG�YDQ�GLYHUVH�SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVNHQPHUNHQ�ELM�KHWRQWVWDDQ�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH��DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�YHUVODYLQJ�� 9DQ�GH�IDFWRUHQ�GLH�GH�VRFLDOH�NZHWVEDDUKHLG�EHwQYORHGHQ��H[RJHQH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� EHVWDDWHU�DOOHHQ�UHGHOLMN�EHZLMV�YRRU�HHQ� UHODWLH�PHW�FRQIOLFWXHX]H�JH]LQVVLWXDWLHV��(HQ� ODJH�6(6�VRFLDOH�LVRODWLH��JHEUHN�DDQ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�HQ�HHQ�YHUVWHGHOLMNWH�OHHIRPJHYLQJ�YHUWRQHQ�YDDNHHQ� UHGHOLMN� VWHUN� YHUEDQG� PHW� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� +HW� LV� HFKWHU� QRJ� RQYROGRHQGHGXLGHOLMN�RI�KLHU�VSUDNH�LV�YDQ�RRU]DDN�RI�JHYROJ�� 6WUHVVYROOH� OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� VSHOHQ� ELM� DOOH� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� EHODQJULMNH� URO�7UDXPDWLVFKH� MHXJGHUYDULQJHQ� KHEEHQ� YRRUDO� HHQ� FKURQLVFK� �ODQJH� WHUPLMQ�� HIIHFW�� WHUZLMODOOHUOHL� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� �ELMY�� YHUOLHVHUYDULQJHQ�� HHQ� XLWORNNHQGH� URO� NXQQHQ� VSHOHQ� ELM� KHWRQWVWDDQ�YDQ�VWRRUQLVVHQ�� 9RRU� HHQ� DDQWDO� ]RJHQRHPGH� JHQHULHNH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� NRPW� XLW� GH� OLWHUDWXXUDQDO\VH� QDDUYRUHQ� GDW� ]LM� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� YDQ� PHHUGHUH� �YHHO� YRRUNRPHQGH�� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ

Page 14: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

EHwQYORHGHQ�� +HW� JDDW� HQHU]LMGV� RP� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVNHQPHUNHQ� DOV� �RYHUPDWLJH�JHUHPGKHLG�� QHXURWLFLVPH�� LPSXOVLYLWHLW� HQ� FRJQLWLHYH� HQ� VRFLDDO�FRPPXQLFDWLHYHEHSHUNLQJHQ�� $QGHU]LMGV� RP� WUDXPDWLVFKH� HUYDULQJHQ� LQ� GH� MHXJG�� HHQ� ODJH� 6(6�� VWHUNHYHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ� HQ� VQHOOH� VRFLDOH� YHUDQGHULQJHQ�� 7KHRUHWLVFK� JH]LHQ� YDOW� GH� PHHVWHJH]RQGKHLGVZLQVW�RS�KHW�WHUUHLQ�YDQ�GH�SV\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG�GDQ�RRN�WH�EHKDOHQ�GRRUEHwQYORHGLQJ�YDQ��KHW�OHUHQ�RPJDDQ�PHW��GH]H�JHQHULHNH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�

3UREOHHPDQDO\VH��SUHYHQWLH9HHO�VWXGLHV�ELQQHQ�GH�**=�]LMQ�NZDOLWDWLHI�RQYROGRHQGH�RP�KDUGH�XLWVSUDNHQ�WH�NXQQHQGRHQ�RYHU�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV� 7HQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQ�KHW�EHwQYORHGHQ�YDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�GH�SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG�]LMQ�QRJ

JHHQ� GHILQLWLHYH� FRQFOXVLHV� PRJHOLMN�� +HW� OLMNW� HFKWHU� DDQQHPHOLMN� GDW� PHW� QDPH� GLHLQWHUYHQWLHV�YHHOEHORYHQG�]LMQ�GLH�RS�PHHUGHUH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�WHJHOLMN�DDQJULMSHQ��'LW�VOXLWDDQ� ELM� KHW� JHJHYHQ� GDW� LQWHUDFWLHV� WXVVHQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� HHQ� EHODQJULMNH� URO� VSHOHQ� LQ� GHHWLRORJLH�YDQ�VWRRUQLVVHQ�� %LM� GH� RQWZLNNHOLQJ� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� HQ� ELM� LPSOHPHQWDWLH�RQGHU]RHN� LV� RRN� NZDOLWDWLHIHYDOXDWLH�RQGHU]RHN� ZDDUGHYRO�� RQGHU� DQGHUH� RP� LQ]LFKW� WH� JHYHQ� LQ� VXFFHVIDFWRUHQ� HQNQHOSXQWHQ�ELM�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�HQ�GDDUGRRU�GH�NDQV�RS�LPSOHPHQWDWLH�YDQ�HIIHFWLHYHSURJUDPPD¶V�WH�EHYRUGHUHQ�

'RHOWUHIIHQGKHLG�YDQ�HHQ�DDQWDO�LQWHUYHQWLHV�DDQJHWRRQG� 6HFXQGDLUH� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH� ELM� RXGHUHQ� HQ� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� GUXJJHEUXLN� YLDVFKRROSURJUDPPD¶V� EOLMNHQ� YROGRHQGH� GRHOWUHIIHQG� RP� RYHU� WH� JDDQ� WRW� ODQGHOLMNHLPSOHPHQWDWLH�� ,QWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�SDWLsQWHQ� OLMNHQ�GRHOWUHIIHQG� LQ�KHWYRRUNyPHQ�YDQ�RYHUEHODVWLQJ��VWUHVV�HQ�DQJVW�

%HOHLGVDQDO\VH6WHHGV�PHHU�**=�LQVWHOOLQJHQ�DFWLHI�LQ�SUHYHQWLH� =RZHO�GH�&$'¶V�DOV�GH�5,$**¶V�]LHQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�DOV�HHQ�EHODQJULMNH�WDDN�YDQ

KXQ� RUJDQLVDWLH�� 'DDUQDDVW� JHYHQ� GH� **'¶HQ� XLWYRHULQJ� DDQ� GH� 2SHQEDUH� *HHVWHOLMNH*H]RQGKHLGV]RUJ�� 2RN� GH� KXLVDUWV� NULMJW� HHQ� VWHHGV� EHODQJULMNHU� URO� RS� KHW� JHELHG� YDQSUHYHQWLH��(HQ�JHEUHN�DDQ��GLDJQRVWLVFKH��NHQQLV�HQ�HUYDULQJ�HQ�KHW�DFKWHUZHJH�EOLMYHQ�YDQHHQ� DGHTXDWH� YHUJRHGLQJ� YRRU� SUHYHQWLHYH� DFWLYLWHLWHQ� YRUPHQ� HFKWHU� ELQQHQ� GHKXLVDUWVHQSUDNWLMN� HHQ� EHOHPPHULQJ� YRRU� KHW� VXFFHVYRO� LQYRHUHQ� YDQ� SURJUDPPDWLVFKHSUHYHQWLH�RS�**=�JHELHG�� &DWHJRUDOH� RUJDQLVDWLHV� �SDWLsQWHQYHUHQLJLQJHQ�� SHGDJRJLVFKH� FHQWUD�� DUER�GLHQVWHQ� HWF��YHUYXOOHQ�HHQ�VWHHGV�DFWLHYHUH�URO�LQ�GH�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG��'LW�URHSW�GHEHKRHIWH�RS�DDQ�RQGHUOLQJH�DIVWHPPLQJ�YDQ�WDNHQ�HQ�VDPHQZHUNLQJ�

Page 15: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

$DQNQRSLQJVSXQWHQ�YRRU�EHOHLG2QGHU]RHN�QDDU�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG�QRRG]DNHOLMN� (HQ�LQWHQVLYHULQJ�YDQ�KHW�RQGHU]RHN�QDDU�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�WHYHQV�SULRULWHULQJ�YDQ

GH PLGGHOHQ�LV�HHQ�QRRG]DNHOLMNH�YRRUZDDUGH�RP�GH�NHQQLVDFKWHUVWDQG�WHQ�RS]LFKWH�YDQ�GHVRPDWLVFKH� DDQGRHQLQJHQ� HQLJV]LQV� RS� WH� KHIIHQ� HQ� GDDUPHH� HHQ� IOLQNH� VWDS� YRRUXLW� WHPDNHQ�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQ�GH�PRJHOLMNKHGHQ�YRRU�SUHYHQWLH�� +HW� JHEUXLN� YDQ� ORQJLWXGLQDOH� RQGHU]RHNVGHVLJQV� LV� YDQ� JURRW� EHODQJ� RP�PHHU� LQ]LFKW� WHNULMJHQ�LQ�GH�RRU]DDN�JHYROJ�UHODWLHV�WXVVHQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HQ�SV\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG�� )XQGDPHQWHHO�QHXURELRORJLVFK�RQGHU]RHN� LV�HYHQHHQV�YDQ�EHODQJ�� WHQHLQGH�GH�GLDJQRVWLHNYDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�WH�YHUEHWHUHQ�

3UHYHQWLH�RQGHU]RHN�PRHW�]LFK�PHW�QDPH�ULFKWHQ�RS�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV��HQ�RSLPSOHPHQWDWLHVWUDWHJLHsQ� +HW�QDJHQRHJ�RQWEUHNHQ�YDQ�RQGHU]RHN�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�GHLQFLGHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�YHUJW�HHQ�DDQ]LHQOLMNH�LQYHVWHULQJ�RS�GLW�WHUUHLQ�LQ�GHNRPHQGH�MDUHQ��(FKWHU��KHW�YHUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�SV\FKLVFKH�FRQVHTXHQWLHV�YDQ� LQJULMSHQGHJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�NDQ�RRN�RS�]LFK]HOI�DOV�ZDDUGHYRO�ZRUGHQ�EHVFKRXZG��]HOIV�ZDQQHHU��QRJ�QLHW� GXLGHOLMN� LV� RI� GH� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� GDDUPHH� JHUHGXFHHUG� NDQZRUGHQ�� (U�LV�QRJ�ZHLQLJ�EHNHQG�RYHU�ZHONH�LPSOHPHQWDWLHVWUDWHJLHsQ�ELQQHQ�KHW�SUHYHQWLHYHOG�KHWPHHVW�VXFFHVYRO�]LMQ��7RW�QX�WRH�ZRUGHQ�NHX]HV�YRRU�SUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V�VWHUN�UHJLRQDDOEHSDDOG��PHW�YHUVQLSSHULQJ�DOV�FRQVHTXHQWLH��,PSOHPHQWDWLH�RQGHU]RHN�ZRUGW�RS�KHW�WHUUHLQYDQ�GH�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�QRJ�QDXZHOLMNV�YHUULFKW��+HW�LV�YDQ�EHODQJVWUDWHJLHsQ�YRRU�ODQGHOLMNH�LPSOHPHQWDWLH�YDQ�GRHOWUHIIHQGH�SURJUDPPD¶V�WH�RQWZLNNHOHQ�HQRQGHU]RHN�RS�GLW�WHUUHLQ�WH�VWLPXOHUHQ�

(U�]LMQ�GLYHUVH�NDQVHQ�YRRU�KHW�SUHYHQWLHEHOHLG� %LM�KHW�RQWZLNNHOHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�LV�KHW�YDQ�JURRW�EHODQJ�WH�RQGHU]RHNHQ�RSZHONH��FRPELQDWLH�YDQ��GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�KHW�EHVWH�DDQJHJUHSHQ�NDQ�ZRUGHQ�� 9DQZHJH�GH�YHURQGHUVWHOGH�JURWH�ELMGUDJH�DDQ�GH�SV\FKLVFKH�]LHNWHODVW�LV�KHW�DDQ�WH�EHYHOHQKHW� HIIHFWRQGHU]RHN� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� VSHFLILHN� WH� ULFKWHQ� RS� �KHW� OHUHQ� RPJDDQ� PHW�� GHHHUGHU� JHQRHPGH� JHQHULHNH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� �SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVNHQPHUNHQ�� WUDXPDWLVFKHHUYDULQJHQ� LQ� GH� MHXJG�� HHQ� ODJH� 6(6�� VWHUNH� YHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ� HQ� VQHOOH� VRFLDOHYHUDQGHULQJHQ��� 9HHOEHORYHQG� OLMNHQ�GH�JHwQGLFHHUGH�SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�GLH�JHULFKW� ]LMQ�RS�SHUVRQHQGLH�UHHGV�HQLJH�V\PSWRPHQ�YDQ�HHQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV�YHUWRQHQ��0RJHOLMN�NXQQHQ�]R�RRNFKURQLVFKH� DDQGRHQLQJHQ� LQ� HHQ� YURHJ� VWDGLXP� DDQJHSDNW� ZRUGHQ� HQ� NDQ� FKURQLFLWHLWYRRUNyPHQ�ZRUGHQ�� 6SHFLILHNH�DDQGDFKW�ZRUGW�JHYUDDJG�YRRU�YURHJH�KHUNHQQLQJ�HQ�LQWHUYHQWLH�ELM�KRRJ�ULVLFRNLQGHUHQ�HQ�DGROHVFHQWHQ��JH]LHQ�GH�DDQ]LHQOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLGVZLQVW�GLH�KLHUPHH�LQ�SRWHQWLHEHKDDOG� NDQ� ZRUGHQ�� (HQ� EHODQJULMNH� URO� LV� GDDUELM� ZHJJHOHJG� YRRU� GH� HHUVWHOLMQV�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ�� /LPLWHULQJ�YDQ�GH�EHVFKLNEDDUKHLG�YDQ�JHQRWPLGGHOHQ�NDQ�HHQ�EHODQJULMNH�URO�VSHOHQ�LQ�GHSUHYHQWLH�YDQ�JHGUDJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�VXwFLGH�

Page 16: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

Page 17: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

'HHO�$��3V\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG��HHQ�RYHU]LFKWYDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HQ�SUHYHQWLH

,�$�0��0DDV��-��-DQVHQ

Page 18: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

� 3UREOHHPGHILQLWLH��� 0DDWVFKDSSHOLMNH�HQ�ZHWHQVFKDSSHOLMNH�FRQWH[W3V\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� YRUPHQ� HHQ� YRONVJH]RQGKHLGVSUREOHHP� PHW� RPYDQJULMNHPDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH�JHYROJHQ��8LW�KHW�1(0(6,6�RQGHU]RHN�NRPW�QDDU�YRUHQ�GDW�MDDUOLMNVHHQ�NZDUW�YDQ�GH�YROZDVVHQ�1HGHUODQGVH�EHYRONLQJ�PHW�HHQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV�ZRUGWJHFRQIURQWHHUG� HQ� ���� RRLW� LQ� ]LMQ� OHYHQ� �%LMO� HW� DO��� ������� 3V\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQEOLMNHQ� YHUDQWZRRUGHOLMN� YRRU� HHQ� EHODQJULMN� GHHO� YDQ� GH� WRWDOH� ]LHNWHODVW� LQ� GHEHYRONLQJ�LQ�1HGHUODQG��8LW� ILJXXU�����±�DINRPVWLJ�XLW�GH�9RONVJH]RQGKHLG�7RHNRPVW9HUNHQQLQJ��979��������5XZDDUG��.UDPHUV����������EOLMNW�GDW�ZDQQHHU�GH�]LHNWHODVWZRUGW XLWJHGUXNW� LQ� YHUORUHQ� OHYHQVMDUHQ�� GH� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� UHODWLHI� ZHLQLJELMGUDJHQ� WHQ� RS]LFKWH� YDQ� DQGHUH� GLDJQRVH�FDWHJRULHsQ�� 'H� ELMGUDJH� LV� YHHO� JURWHUZDQQHHU�GH�]LHNWHODVW�ZRUGW�XLWJHGUXNW�LQ�]LHNWHMDDU�HTXLYDOHQWHQ��KHW�DDQWDO�OHYHQVMDUHQPHW ]LHNWH�� JHZRJHQ�YRRU� GH� HUQVW� YDQ� GH� ]LHNWH�� RI� LQ�'$/<¶V� �'LVDELOLW\�$GMXVWHG/LIH� <HDUV�� PDDW� YRRU� GH� WRWDOH� KRHYHHOKHLG� JH]RQGKHLG� GLH� YHUORUHQ� JDDW� LQ� HHQEHYRONLQJ�GRRU�]LHNWH�RI� VWHUIWH���2YHULJHQV� LV�GH�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQDDQ�PRUWDOLWHLW� PRJHOLMN� JURWHU� GDQ� LQ� GH� 979������ LV� EHVFKUHYHQ�� =R� EOLMNW� GDW� ELMPHQVHQ PHW�HHQ�GHSUHVVLH�GH�PRUWDOLWHLW�DDQ]LHQOLMN�YHUKRRJG�LV��3HQQLQ[�HW�DO���������+HW�LV�JRHG�RP�WH�UHDOLVHUHQ�GDW�GH]H�FLMIHUV�ERYHQGLHQ�HHQ�EHSHUNW�LQ]LFKW�JHYHQLQ KHW�SHUVRRQOLMN�OHHG�YRRU�GH�SDWLsQW��YRRU�]LMQ�QDDVWH�RPJHYLQJ��HQ�LQ�GH�DDQ]LHQOLMNHPDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH� FRQVHTXHQWLHV� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ]RDOV� DUEHLGV�RQJHVFKLNWKHLG��EHSHUNLQJHQ�LQ�KHW�VRFLDOH�IXQFWLRQHUHQ��JHZHOG�HQ�RYHUODVW�

)LJXXU� ����� 9HUGHOLQJ� YDQ� GH� DDQWDOOHQ� YHUORUHQ� OHYHQVMDUHQ�� ]LHNWHMDDU�HTXLYDOHQWHQ� HQ'$/<¶V�YRRU�JURHSHQ�YDQ�]LHNWHQ�HQ�DDQGRHQLQJHQ��5XZDDUG��.UDPHUV��������

������������

YHUORUHQ�OHYHQVMDUHQ ]LHNWHMDDU�HTXLYDOHQWHQ

'$/<

LQIHFWLH]LHNWHQQLHXZYRUPLQJHQSV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��LQFO��VXwFLGH�HQGHPHQWLH��H[FO��YHUVWDQGHOLMNH�KDQGLFDS�KDUW��HQ�YDDW]LHNWHQRYHULJH�OLFKDPHOLMNH�DDQGRHQLQJHQSHULQDWDOH��DDQGRHQLQJHQ�HQ�DDQJHERUHQDIZLMNLQJHQRQJHYDOOHQ

SHUFHQWDJH

Page 19: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

,Q�979������ LV�EHUHNHQG�GDW� UXLP�����YDQ�GH� WRWDOH�NRVWHQ�YDQ�GH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJYRRU UHNHQLQJ� NRPW� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� LQFOXVLHI� ]RUJ� YRRU� YHUVWDQGHOLMNHKDQGLFDS� HQ� GHPHQWLH� �3ROGHU� HW� DO��� ������� ([FOXVLHI� GH� ]RUJ� YRRU� YHUVWDQGHOLMNHKDQGLFDS� HQ� GHPHQWLH� JDDW� KHP� RP� RQJHYHHU� ��� YDQ� GH� WRWDOH� NRVWHQ�� ,Q� GH]H]RJHQDDPGH� GLUHFWH� NRVWHQ� LV� QRJ� JHHQ� UHNHQLQJ� JHKRXGHQ� PHW� GH� PDDWVFKDSSHOLMNHNRVWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�DUEHLGVRQJHVFKLNWKHLG��9ROJHQV�VFKDWWLQJHQ�NRPW�FLUFD�����YDQGH NRVWHQ� YDQ� KHW� ZHUNJHERQGHQ� ]LHNWHYHU]XLP� HQ� YDQ� DUEHLGVRQJHVFKLNWKHLG� YRRUUHNHQLQJ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��6PXOGHUV��������,Q� GH� DIJHORSHQ� MDUHQ� LV� HU� ERYHQGLHQ� HHQ� IRUVH� JURHL� WH� ]LHQ� JHZHHVW� YDQ� KHWJHEUXLN��HQ�KHW�DDQERG��YDQ�GH�**=��=R�EHGURHJ�KHW�DDQWDO�PHQVHQ�GDW�FRQWDFW�KDG�PHWDPEXODQWH� **=�YRRU]LHQLQJHQ� �5,$**¶V�� &$'¶V�� SROLNOLQLHNHQ� YDQ� $3=�HQ� HQ3$$=�HQ��LQ���������������GLW�EHWHNHQW�HHQ�WRHQDPH�PHW�����VLQGV�������'RQNHU�'H�:LOGH�� ������� 'H� YHUZDFKWLQJ� YRRU� GH� WRHNRPVW� LV� GDW� GH]H� JURHL� ]LFK� YRRUW� ]DO]HWWHQ��59=��������'H� %HOHLGVYLVLH� *HHVWHOLMNH� *H]RQGKHLGV]RUJ�� GLH� LQ� GHFHPEHU� ����� LVDDQJHERGHQ�DDQ�GH�7ZHHGH�.DPHU��EHVFKULMIW�GH�ZLM]H�ZDDURS�KHW�0LQLVWHULH�YDQ�9:6ZLO RPJDDQ�PHW�GH]H�SUREOHPDWLHN��9:6���������9RRU�KHW�DIUHPPHQ�YDQ�GH�JURHLHQGH]RUJYUDDJ�HQ�EHSHUNHQ�YDQ�GH�µ]LHNWHODVW�WHQ�JHYROJH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG¶��LVSUHYHQWLH� �LQFOXVLHI�YURHJH�RSVSRULQJ�HQ�VLJQDOHULQJ��HHQ�EHODQJULMN�PLGGHO��3UHYHQWLHELQQHQ�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ��**=��ULFKW�]LFK�QLHW�DOOHHQ�RS�KHW�YRRUNyPHQYDQ�GH�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�]HOI��PDDU�RRN�RS�KHW�YRRUNyPHQ�RI�YHUPLQGHUHQ�YDQEHOHPPHULQJHQ�LQ�KHW�VRFLDDO�HQ�PDDWVFKDSSHOLMN�IXQFWLRQHUHQ�DOV�JHYROJ�YDQ�GHUJHOLMNHSUREOHPDWLHN��9RRU�HHQ�DFWLHYH�SUHYHQWLH�ELQQHQ�HHQ�JHHVWHOLMN�YRONVJH]RQGKHLGVEHOHLGLV HHQ�DQDO\VH�YDQ�GH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�YDQ�EHODQJ�HQ�YDQ�GHPRJHOLMNKHGHQ�RP�GLH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�WH�EHwQYORHGHQ�+HW�ZHWHQVFKDSSHOLMN�RQGHU]RHN�QDDU�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�GH�**=�LV�QRJEHWUHNNHOLMN�QLHXZ��(HQ�YHUJHOLMNLQJ�PHW�GH�NHQQLVEDVLV��]RDOV�GLH�HU�RS�GLW�PRPHQW�LVYRRU GH� VRPDWLVFKH� JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ�� ODDW� GXLGHOLMN� HHQ� JURWH� DFKWHUVWDQG� ]LHQ�� 'HLQWURGXFWLH� YDQ� HHQ� LQWHUQDWLRQDDO� JHDFFHSWHHUG� FODVVLILFDWLHV\VWHHP� �GH� '60�,,,� LQ������� WHFKQRORJLVFKH� RQWZLNNHOLQJHQ� HQ� GH� YHUEHWHULQJ� YDQ� YUDJHQOLMVW�� HQLQWHUYLHZWHFKQLHNHQ�� KHEEHQ� HUWRH� JHOHLG� GDW� KHW� RQGHU]RHN� QDDU� GH� HSLGHPLRORJLH� HQSDWKRJHQHVH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HHQ�VWRUPDFKWLJH�JURHL�KHHIW�GRRUJHPDDNW��'HYUDDJ� LV� QDWXXUOLMN� LQ� KRHYHUUH� KLHUXLW� LQ]LFKWHQ� QDDU� YRUHQ� ]LMQ� JHNRPHQ�� GLHDDQNQRSLQJVSXQWHQ� ELHGHQ� YRRU� GH� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ�RI�GH�VRFLDDO�PDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH�JHYROJHQ�YDQ�GH]H�VWRRUQLVVHQ�:HWHQVFKDSSHOLMN� RQGHU]RHN� QDDU�SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� WHU� YRRUNyPLQJ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�NHQW�HHQ��QRJ��PLQGHU�ODQJH�WUDGLWLH�HQ�NUHHJ�RRN�LQ�UHFHQWHMDUHQ QRJ�ZHLQLJ� DDQGDFKW��(U� LV� WRW� QX� WRH� UHODWLHI�ZHLQLJ� JHwQYHVWHHUG� LQ� GH� YHUGHUHRQWZLNNHOLQJ�YDQ�GH�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG��+RVPDQ��������QRHPW�DOVPRJHOLMNH�YHUNODULQJ�GH�JURWH�GUXN�RS�GH�FXUDWLHYH�]RUJ��DOV�JHYROJ�YDQ�GH�QRJ�VWHHGVWRHQHPHQGH�YUDDJ��=RODQJ�QRJ�QLHW� DDQWRRQEDDU�NDQ�ZRUGHQ� JHPDDNW�GDW� SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV� LQ� VWDDW� EOLMNHQ� GH� YUDDJ� QDDU� FXUDWLHYH� KXOS� WH� VWDELOLVHUHQ� RI� ]HOIV� WHUHGXFHUHQ�� LV� HU� ZHLQLJ� KRRS� RS� HHQ� VWHUNH� LQYHVWHULQJ� LQ� SUHYHQWLH�� (HQ� WZHHGHPRJHOLMNH� YHUNODULQJ� LV� YROJHQV� +RVPDQ� GH� ODJH� PDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH� HQ� HFRQRPLVFKHZDDUGH� GLH� DDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� �RQ�JH]RQGKHLG� LV� JHKHFKW�� +HW� WRHJHQRPHQ� LQ]LFKW� LQ� GHPDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH�FRQVHTXHQWLHV�YDQ�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLGVSUREOHPHQ�]DO�KHW�NOLPDDWYRRU SUHYHQWLH� PRJHOLMN� LQ� JXQVWLJH� ]LQ� EHwQYORHGHQ�� (HQ� GHUGH� EHODQJULMNH� EDUULqUHYRRU LQYHVWHULQJHQ�LQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�LV�GH�VFHSVLV�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ

Page 20: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

YDQ�GH�YHUZDFKWH�HIIHFWLYLWHLW�HQ�KHW�PDDWVFKDSSHOLMN�SURILMW�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH��GLH�PRHLOLMNZHHUOHJG� NDQ� ZRUGHQ� ]RODQJ� HU� JHHQ� JHGHJHQ� ZHWHQVFKDSSHOLMNH� NHQQLVEDVLV� ZRUGWJHJHQHUHHUG��+RVPDQ��������%LQQHQ�HQ�EXLWHQ�GH�**=�]LMQ�HU�HFKWHU�LQ�GH�DIJHORSHQ�MDUHQ�GH�QRGLJH�SUHYHQWLHYHSURJUDPPD¶V� RQWZLNNHOG� HQ� XLWJHYRHUG�� GLH� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� VWRRUQLVVHQ� RI� YDQIXQFWLRQHOH� EHSHUNLQJHQ� WRW� GRHO� KHEEHQ� HQ� GLH� WRW� JXQVWLJH� UHVXOWDWHQ� KHEEHQ� JHOHLG�+RVPDQ��*HHOHQ������������ 9UDDJVWHOOLQJ�HQ�ZHUNZLM]H�+HW�GRHO�YDQ�GH]H� UDSSRUWDJH� VOXLW� DDQ� ELM� GH� LQ� GH� HHUGHUJHQRHPGH�%HOHLGVYLVLH�**=DDQJHJHYHQ�EHKRHIWH�DDQ�LQIRUPDWLH�RYHU�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HQ�EHwQYORHGLQJVPRJHOLMNKHGHQYDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� +HW� GRHO� LV� HHQ� VWDWH�RI�WKH�DUW� RYHU]LFKW� WH� JHYHQ� YDQ� GHKXLGLJ�EHVFKLNEDUH�NHQQLV� LQ�ELQQHQ�� HQ�EXLWHQODQG�RYHU�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH�RQ�JH]RQGKHLG�HQ�GH�GDDUXLW�YRRUWYORHLHQGH�PRJHOLMNKHGHQ�YRRU�SUHYHQWLH��7HYHQV�PRHWLQ]LFKW� ZRUGHQ� JHJHYHQ� LQ� GH� HYHQWXHOH� ODFXQHV� LQ� GH� NHQQLV� KLHURYHU�� 'H� YROJHQGHYUDJHQ�VWDDQ�GDDUELM�FHQWUDDO�� :DW�LV�GH�KXLGLJH�NHQQLV�RYHU�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�GH�SV\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG"� :DW�LV�KHW�UHODWLHYH�EHODQJ�YDQ�GH�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ��P�D�Z��ZDW�LV�EHNHQGRYHU�GH��NZDQWLWDWLHYH��ELMGUDJH�YDQ��LQGLYLGXHOH�RI�JURHSHQ�YDQ��GH]H�GHWHUPLQDQWHQDDQ�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�YRONVJH]RQGKHLG"� :DW� ]LMQ� GH� KXLGLJH�PRJHOLMNKHGHQ� YRRU� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� �RQ�JH]RQGKHLG"�WKHRUHWLVFK�KDDOEDUH�JH]RQGKHLGVZLQVW�� :DW� LV� HU� EHNHQG� RYHU� GH� GRHOWUHIIHQGKHLG� HQ� GRHOPDWLJKHLG� YDQ� GH� KXLGLJHSUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV"'H]H�UDSSRUWDJH�YHUVFKLMQW� LQ�KHW�NDGHU�YDQ�GH�9RONVJH]RQGKHLG�7RHNRPVW�9HUNHQQLQJHQ� GLHQW� GXV� WHU� RQGHUVWHXQLQJ� YDQ� KHW� YRONJH]RQGKHLGVEHOHLG�� +HW� JHHIW� HHQ� EUHHG� HQYHUJHOLMNHQG� RYHU]LFKW� YDQ� GH� ELMGUDJH� YDQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� DDQ� GH� SV\FKLVFKH�RQ�JH]RQGKHLG�� ,Q� FRPELQDWLH�PHW� LQ]LFKWHQ� LQ�GH�GRHOWUHIIHQGKHLG�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�ELHGWKHW�DDQNQRSLQJVSXQWHQ�YRRU�GH�HYDOXDWLH�HQ�RQWZLNNHOLQJ�YDQ�KHW�SUHYHQWLHEHOHLG�RS�KHWWHUUHLQ YDQ�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�YRONVJH]RQGKHLG�9RRU� KHW� EHDQWZRRUGHQ� YDQ� ERYHQJHQRHPGH� YUDJHQ� ]LMQ� RQGHU]RHNVJURHSHQYDQXLW� GH� 9DNJURHS� 3V\FKLDWULH� YDQ� GH� 58*� �SURI�� GU�� 2UPHO� H�D��� HQ� KHW� 7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW� �GU��&XLMSHUV� H�D��� JHYUDDJG� RP�HHQ� VWDWH�RI�WKH�DUW� UDSSRUW� WH� VFKULMYHQ� RS� KHWWHUUHLQ�YDQ� UHVSHFWLHYHOLMN�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH� �RQ�JH]RQGKHLG� HQ�GH� HIIHFWHQYDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV��'H]H�UDSSRUWDJHV�]LMQ�LQWHJUDDO�RSJHQRPHQ�LQ�GHHO�%�YDQ�GLWUDSSRUW��&RQFHSWYHUVLHV�YDQ�GH�VWDWH�RI�WKH�DUW� UDSSRUWHQ�]LMQ�YRRUJHOHJG�DDQ�HHQ�DDQWDOUHIHUHQWHQ�XLW�GH�ZHWHQVFKDS�HQ�GH�SUDNWLMN��+XQ�FRPPHQWDDU�LV�YHUZHUNW�LQ�GH�ELMGUDJHQRI�LV�LQ�KRRIGVWXN���YDQ�GHHO�$�YDQ�GLW�UDSSRUW�PHHJHQRPHQ��,Q�%LMODJH���LV�HHQ�OLMVW�YDQDXWHXUV�HQ�UHIHUHQWHQ�RSJHQRPHQ�,Q�KHW�NDGHU�YDQ�KHW�VWHOOHQ�YDQ�SULRULWHLWHQ�YRRU�KHW�ZHWHQVFKDSSHOLMN�RQGHU]RHNRS� KHW� JHELHG� YDQ� SULPDLUH� HQ� VHFXQGDLUH� SUHYHQWLH� KHHIW� =RUJ2QGHU]RHN� 1HGHUODQG�=21�� LQ� ����� HHQ� DDQYXOOLQJ� JHSXEOLFHHUG� RS� KHW� 3URJUDPPD� 3UHYHQWLH� ����������'H]H� DDQYXOOLQJ� LV� VSHFLILHN� JHULFKW� RS� HHQ� QDGHUH� XLWZHUNLQJ� YDQ� GH� SURJUDPPHULQJµ2QGHU]RHN� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� HQ� JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ¶�� 1DDVW� KHW� EHQRHPHQ� YDQSULRULWHLWHQ� YRRU� GH� LQKRXG� YDQ� RQGHU]RHN� KHHIW� GH� SURJUDPPDFRPPLVVLH� ]LFK� RRN� GHYHUVWHUNLQJ�YDQ�GH�ZHWHQVFKDSSHOLMNH�NZDOLWHLW�YDQ�KHW�SUHYHQWLHRQGHU]RHN�RS�GLW�WHUUHLQ

Page 21: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

WHQ�GRHO�JHVWHOG��+LHUPHH�ZLO�]LM�NRPHQ�WRW�HHQ�JURWHUH�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�KHW�RQGHU]RHN�DDQ�GH1HGHUODQGVH� YRONVJH]RQGKHLG� HQ� JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ� �=21�� ������� 7HQ� EHKRHYH� YDQJHQRHPGH� DDQYXOOLQJ� LV�� LQ� RSGUDFKW� YDQ� =21�� HHQ� EHNQRSWH� OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH� GRRU� KHW7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW�YHUULFKW�QDDU�KHW�HIIHFW�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�QHJHQ�HUQVWLJHSV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� ,Q� GH� ELMGUDJH� GLH� KHW� 7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW� KHHIW� JHOHYHUG� DDQ� GLW979�UDSSRUW� LV�RQGHU�DQGHUH�JHEUXLN�JHPDDNW�YDQ�GH]H� OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH��'H� LQYDOVKRHNYDQ� GLW� UDSSRUW� ZDV� DQGHUV�� QDPHOLMN� GLH� YDQ� GH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� ]LMQGH� GH� SULPDLUHDDQJULMSLQJSXQWHQ� YRRU� SUHYHQWLH�� +RSHOLMN� NDQ� GH� XLWJHEUHLGH� EHVFKULMYLQJ� YDQGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HQ�SUHYHQWLH�LQ�GH]H�UDSSRUWDJH�ELMGUDJHQ�DDQ�GH�YHUGHUH�LQYXOOLQJ�YDQ�GHRQGHU]RHNVSULRULWHULQJ�YDQ�=21�

��� *HEUXLNWH�EHJULSSHQ(HQ� DDQWDO� LQ� GLW� UDSSRUW� YHHOYXOGLJ� JHEUXLNWH� EHJULSSHQ� YUDDJW� RP� HQLJH� WRHOLFKWLQJ�:DQQHHU� JHVSURNHQ� ZRUGW� RYHU� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� GDQ� ZRUGW� JHGRHOG� RSGLDJQRVHQ�GLH�YROGRHQ�DDQ�GH�FULWHULD�]RDOV�RPVFKUHYHQ�LQ�KHW�FODVVLILFDWLHV\VWHHP�YDQSV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� GH� '60�,,,�5� �'LDJQRVWLF� DQG� 6WDWLVWLFDO� PDQXDO� RI� 0HQWDOGLVRUGHUV���HQ�GH�KHU]LHQLQJ�GDDUYDQ�LQ�GH�YRUP�YDQ�GH�'60�,9�LQ�������$3$��������%LQQHQ�GH�'60�ZRUGW�HHQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV�JHGHILQLHHUG�DOV�HHQ�NOLQLVFK�EHODQJULMNSV\FKLVFK� V\QGURRP�RI� JHGUDJVSDWURRQ� GDW� ELM� LHPDQG�YRRUNRPW� HQ�ZDDUELM� VSUDNH� LVYDQ�]LFKWEDDU�OLMGHQ�RI�RQYHUPRJHQ��WHNRUWNRPLQJ�LQ�ppQ�RI�PHHU�EHODQJULMNH�JHELHGHQZDDULQ PHQ� NDQ� IXQFWLRQHUHQ�� RI� ZDDUELM� HHQ� YHUKRRJG� ULVLFR� RS� VWHUIWH�� SLMQ� HQEHSHUNLQJHQ�RSWUHHGW�GDQ�ZHO�HHQ�EHODQJULMN�YHUOLHV� LQ�DXWRQRPLH��7HQ�RYHUYORHGH�]LMYHUPHOG� GDW� VWRRUQLVVHQ� LQ� KHW� JHEUXLN� YDQ� YHUVODYHQGH�PLGGHOHQ� �PHW� QDPH� DOFRKRO�GUXJV�HQ�PHGLFLMQHQ��KLHU�RRN�WRH�EHKRUHQ��0HW�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�SDWLsQWHQ�ZRUGW�JHGRHOGRS SHUVRQHQ�PHW� HHQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLV�� GLH� JHGLDJQRVWLFHHUG� ]LMQ� LQ� GH� SV\FKLDWULH�WZHHGH OLMQ��'H� WHUP� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG� LV� HHQ� EUHGHU� EHJULS�� +LHURQGHU� YDOOHQ� QLHWDOOHHQ� GH� YRRUQRHPGH� GLDJQRVHQ�� PDDU� RRN� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG� JHPHWHQ� PHW]RJHQDDPGH� JHQHULHNH�� QLHW�VWRRUQLVVSHFLILHNH�� PDWHQ� ZDDUPHH� RRN� GH� PLOGHUHSV\FKLVFKH�NODFKWHQ�ZRUGHQ�RSJHVSRRUG��]LH�YHUGHU�GHHO�%���SDUDJUDDI������'DDUQDDVW� ZRUGW� GH� PHHU� EHOHLGVPDWLJH� WHUP� JHHVWHOLMNH� YRONJH]RQGKHLGJHEUXLNW��+HW�JDDW�KLHU�HLJHQOLMN�RP�KHW�FRPSOHPHQW�YDQ�GH�WRWDOH�]LHNWHODVW�WHQ�JHYROJHYDQ�VRPDWLVFKH�DDQGRHQLQJHQ�,Q�GLW�UDSSRUW�LV�GH�WHUP�SV\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG�JHEUXLNW�RP�DDQ�WH�JHYHQ�GDWGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� ]RZHO� ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ� DOV� EHVFKHUPHQGH� IDFWRUHQ� NXQQHQ� ]LMQ�� ,Q� KHWYHUYROJ� ZRUGW� LQ� KHW� NDGHU� YDQ� GH� OHHVEDDUKHLG� YHHODO� JHNR]HQ� YRRU� KHW� EHJULSSV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG��DDQJH]LHQ�GH�QDGUXN� LQ�GH]H� UDSSRUWDJH�YHHODO��KRHZHO�QLHWHHQ]LMGLJ��RS�GH�ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ�EHQDGHULQJ�EOHHN�WH�OLJJHQ�2QGHU�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�ZRUGHQ�LQ�GLW�UDSSRUW�YLHU�YRUPHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHRQGHUVFKHLGHQ��FRQIRUP�GH�FRQVHQVXV�RS�GLW�WHUUHLQ��1,0+���������� 8QLYHUVHOH� SUHYHQWLH�� JHULFKW� RS� DOJHPHQH� EHYRONLQJ�� RI� VXEJURHSHQ� GLH� QLHW� ]LMQJHwGHQWLILFHHUG�RS�EDVLV�YDQ�HHQ�VSHFLILHNH�ULVLFRIDFWRU��� 6HOHFWLHYH� SUHYHQWLH�� JHULFKW� RS� VXEJURHSHQ� YDQ� GH� SRSXODWLH� ZDDU� KHW� ULVLFR� RSSV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�JURWHU�GDQ�JHPLGGHOG�LV���� *HwQGLFHHUGH� SUHYHQWLH�� JHULFKW� RS� LQGLYLGLGXHQ� GLH� QLHW� YROGRHQ� DDQ� '60�,9FULWHULD�YRRU�HHQ�DDQGRHQLQJ��PDDU�GLH�ZHO�UHHGV�V\PSWRPHQ�KHEEHQ�GLH�YRRUDIJDDQ

Page 22: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

DDQ� GH� DDQGRHQLQJ�� RI� ZHO� ELRORJLVFKH� NHQPHUNHQ� KHEEHQ� GLH� GXLGHQ� RS� HHQµDDQOHJ¶�YRRU�HHQ�DDQGRHQLQJ���� =RUJJHULFKWH� SUHYHQWLH�� JHULFKW� RS� PHQVHQ� GLH� HHQ� DDQGRHQLQJ� KHEEHQ� YROJHQV'60�,9� FULWHULD�� +HW� JDDW� GDDUELM� RP� WHUXJYDOSUHYHQWLH�� KHW� YRRUNyPHQ� YDQFRPRUELGLWHLW� HQ� KHW� YHUPLQGHUHQ� YDQ� GH� FRQVHTXHQWLHV� YDQ� GH� SV\FKLVFKHDDQGRHQLQJHQ�YRRU�PHQVHQ�LQ�GH�GLUHFWH�RPJHYLQJ�,Q� YHUJHOLMNLQJ� PHW� GH� GRRU� 979� LQ� KHW� DOJHPHHQ� JHKDQWHHUGH� LQGHOLQJ� LQ� SULPDLUH�VHFXQGDLUH� HQ� WHUWLDLUH� SUHYHQWLH�� NRPHQ�GH� HHUVWH� WZHH� YRUPHQ� JURIZHJ� RYHUHHQ�PHWSULPDLUH�SUHYHQWLH��HQ�GH�GHUGH�PHW�VHFXQGDLUH�SUHYHQWLH��=RUJJHULFKWH�SUHYHQWLH�RPYDWRQGHUGHOHQ� GLH� GRRU� VRPPLJHQ� QLHW� DOV� SUHYHQWLH� �KRRJVWHQV� DOV� WHUWLDLUH� SUHYHQWLH�ZRUGHQ�DDQJHGXLG� �]RDOV�KHW�YHUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH� FRQVHTXHQWLHV� YDQ� GH� DDQGRHQLQJHQYRRU�GH�RPJHYLQJ��,Q�ELMODJH���LV HHQ�OLMVW�YDQ�DINRUWLQJHQ�HQ�GHILQLWLHV�RSJHQRPHQ�

Page 23: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

� 3UREOHHPDQDO\VH��� 'HWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG8LWJDQJVSXQWHQ�HQ�DIEDNHQLQJ3V\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�]LMQ�YRUPHQ�YDQ�DEQRUPDDO�JHGUDJ��+HW�JDDW�GDDUELM�QLHW�DOOHHQRP KHW� ZDDUQHHPEDUH� JHGUDJ� YDQ� PHQVHQ�� PDDU� RRN� GH� GRRU� KHQ� JHUDSSRUWHHUGHEHOHYLQJHQ�� JHYRHOHQV� HQ� JHGDFKWHQ� EHKRUHQ� HUWRH� �'H� -RQJ� HW� DO��� ������� 8LW� GH]HGHILQLWLH�EOLMNW�GDW�KHW�EHJULS� µSV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG¶�YHHORPYDWWHQG� LV��9RRU�GH]HUDSSRUWDJH�]LMQ�HHQ�DDQWDO�EHODQJULMNH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�JHVHOHFWHHUG�RS�EDVLV�YDQKXQ� SUHYDOHQWLH�� ]LHNWHODVW� HQ� NRVWHQ� YDQ� GH� ]RUJ�� +HW� EHWUHIW� VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�DQJVW�� HQ� VRPDWRIRUPH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� � VFKL]RIUHQLH� HQ� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLV�� YHUVODYLQJHQ�YHHO� YRRUNRPHQGH� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ELM� NLQGHUHQ� HQ� DGROHVFHQWHQ� HQ� VXwFLGH�%HKDOYH� GH� VWRRUQLVVSHFLILHNH� LQYDOVKRHN�� EHVWHHGW� GLW� UDSSRUW� RRN� DDQGDFKW� DDQSV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�JHPHWHQ�YROJHQV�JHQHULHNH�PDWHQ��HQ�KHW�GDDUPHH�YHUZDQWHRQGHUZHUS�YDQ�GH�FRPRUELGLWHLW�8LWJDQJVSXQW�ELM� GH� EHVFKULMYLQJ� YDQ� GH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YRUPW� KHW�'\QDPLVFKH6WUHVV�.ZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO� �'6.�PRGHO��� +HW� PRGHO� JHHIW� DDQ� µKRH¶� SHUVRRQ�RPJHYLQJ� HQ� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� HONDDU� HQ� KHW� ULVLFR� RS� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�EHwQYORHGHQ��]LH�ILJXXU������

JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�REMHFWLHYH�NHQPHUNHQ��EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJ

� SHUFHSWLH�YDQ�YHUOLHV�GUHLJLQJ�HWF�

FRSLQJ

)LJXXU������+HW�'\QDPLVFKH�6WUHVV�.ZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO�

(UYDULQJHQ�HQ�JHGUDJ

3V\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG

3V\FKRELRORJLVFKH.ZHWVEDDUKHLG�(QGRJHQHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� JHQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGV�NHQPHUNHQ� VRPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ� SHULQDWDOH�SUREOHPHQ�OLFKDPHOLMNH�]LHNWHQ

6RFLDOH�RI�I\VLHNH.ZHWVEDDUKHLG�([RJHQHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� �FRQIOLFWXHX]H�JH]LQVVLWXDWLH� VRFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKHVWDWXV� YHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ� VRFLDOH�VWHXQ� I\VLHNH�IDFWRUHQ

RPJHYLQJV�FRQWUROH KDQGHOLQJV�

UXLPWH

72(9$/

Page 24: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

1HW� DOV� ELM� YHHO� VRPDWLVFKH� YHUVFKLMQVHOHQ�� ]RDOV� EORHGGUXN� HQ� ORQJIXQFWLH�� EHVWDDW� HUHHQ� YRRU� GH� SHUVRRQ� NHQPHUNHQG� QLYHDX� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� JH]RQGKHLG�� JHW\SHHUG� GRRURQGHUPHHU� KHW� QLYHDX� YDQ� DQJVWLJKHLG� RI� GHSUHVVLYLWHLW�� 9HUVFKLOOHQ� LQ� GH]H� QLYHDXVWXVVHQ�SHUVRQHQ�]LMQ�WRH�WH�VFKULMYHQ�DDQ�YHUVFKLOOHQ�LQ�KXQ�SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH�HQ VRFLDOHNHQPHUNHQ�� DQGHUV� JH]HJG� LQ� KXQ� SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH� HQ� VRFLDOH� NZHWVEDDUKHLG�)OXFWXDWLHV� LQ� QLYHDXV� ELQQHQ� SHUVRQHQ� ]LMQ� KHW� JHYROJ� YDQ� QHJDWLHYH� HQ� SRVLWLHYHJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� HQ�VLWXDWLHV�HQ�GH� UHDFWLH�GDDURS� �KHW�SURFHV�YDQ�EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJ� HQFRSLQJ�� +HW�]LMQ�PHW�QDPH�GH�VWUHVVYROOH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�GLH�ELM�NZHWVEDUH�SHUVRQHQ�WRWSV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�NXQQHQ�OHLGHQ�:pONH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� LHPDQG� PHHPDDNW�� ZRUGW� QDDVW� WRHYDO� EHSDDOG� GRRUIDFWRUHQ�LQ�GH�VRFLDOH�RPJHYLQJ��GH�KDQGHOLQJVUXLPWH��HQ�KHW�YHUPRJHQ�YDQ�LHPDQG�RPELM HHQ� JHJHYHQ� KDQGHOLQJVUXLPWH� EHSDDOGH� RPVWDQGLJKHGHQ� WH� UHDOLVHUHQ� RI� WHYHUPLMGHQ��RPJHYLQJVFRQWUROH��8LWJDDQGH�YDQ�ERYHQJHVFKHWVWH�XLWJDQJVSXQWHQ�JHHIW�2UPHO�HW�DO��HHQ�RYHU]LFKWYDQ� GH� KXLGLJH� NHQQLV� RPWUHQW� GH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�JHEDVHHUG�RS� OLWHUDWXXU�XLW�GH�SHULRGH����������� � �]LH�GHHO�%��� 'H�YROJHQGH�JURHSHQYDQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� YHHODO� DINRPVWLJ� XLW� KHW� '6.�PRGHO� �]LH� ILJXXU� ����� ]LMQ� VWHHGVV\VWHPDWLVFK�EHVFKUHYHQ��� /HHIWLMG� HQ� JHVODFKW�� GH]H� GHPRJUDILVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� �GRRU� 979� PHHVWDO� QLHW� DOVGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� DDQJHPHUNW�� ZRUGHQ� DSDUW� EHVFKRXZG� RPGDW� ]LM� YHUZLM]HQ� QDDU]RZHO�VRPDWLVFKH��SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH�DOV�VRFLDOH�NHQPHUNHQ�YDQ�KHW�LQGLYLGX��� )DFWRUHQ� GLH� GH� SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH� NZHWVEDDUKHLG� EHSDOHQ�� KLHURQGHU� YDOOHQJHQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ��SHUVRRQVNHQPHUNHQ�� �JHUHPGKHLG��VRFLDOH�YDDUGLJKHLG��HWF�� HQVRPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ��]RDOV�OLFKDPHOLMNH�]LHNWHQ���� )DFWRUHQ�GLH�GH�VRFLDOH�HQ�I\VLHNH�NZHWVEDDUKHLG�EHSDOHQ��]RDOV�JH]LQVVLWXDWLH��6(6�HWQLFLWHLW��VRFLDOH�VWHXQ��YHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ�HQ��KRHYHHOKHLG�GDJOLFKW�SHU�HWPDDO���� 6WUHVVYROOH� OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�� 'H]H� ]LMQ� RQGHUYHUGHHOG� LQ� HUYDULQJHQ� PHW� HHQPHHU� FKURQLVFK� HIIHFW� �ELMYRRUEHHOG� MHXJGWUDXPD¶V�� HQ�PHW� HHQ�PHHU� DFXXW� HIIHFW�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�RS�KHW�ZHUN��JHERRUWH��YHUOLHVHUYDULQJHQ��%LQQHQ� KHW� 979�FRQFHSW� ZRUGHQ� GH� GHPRJUDILVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� QLHW� DOV� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�PDDU DOV� RUGHQLQJVFULWHULD� EHVFKRXZG�� 'H� WZHHGH� JURHS� YDOW� RQGHU� GH� HQGRJHQHIDFWRUHQ�HQ GH�WZHH�ODDWVWH�RQGHU�GH�H[RJHQH�IDFWRUHQ�%HWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJ� HQ� FRSLQJ�ZRUGHQ� LQ�GH]H� UDSSRUWDJH� YHHODO� QLHW� DOV� DSDUWHGLVWDOH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�EHVFKRXZG��PDDU�PHHU�DOV�SUR[LPDOH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ��YLD�ZHONH�GHERYHQJHQRHPGH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�KXQ�LQYORHG�XLWRHIHQHQ��(QNHOH NDQWWHNHQLQJHQ�YRRUDI�ELM�GH�EHYLQGLQJHQ'H�DIJHORSHQ���� MDDU� ]LMQ�YHHO�PRJHOLMNH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLGRQGHU]RFKW�� 'H� EHZLMVODVW� YRRU� GH� EHWURNNHQKHLG� ELM� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� YDQ� ppQ� RI� PHHUVWRRUQLVVHQ� LV� YRRU� YHHO� YDQ� GH]H� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� HFKWHU� QRJ� RQYROGRHQGH�� (HQ� DDQWDOYHUVFKLOOHQGH�]DNHQ�KHEEHQ�KLHUWRH�ELMJHGUDJHQ��HQ�]XOOHQ�GDW�VRPV�RRN�LQ�GH�WRHNRPVWQRJ GRHQ��7HQ� HHUVWH� KHW� UHHGV� HHUGHU� JHQRHPGH� IHLW� GDW� KHW� HSLGHPLRORJLVFK� RQGHU]RHN� QDDUSV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�QRJ�PDDU�HHQ�NRUWH�KLVWRULH�NHQW��2QGHU]RHNVUHVXOWDWHQ�PHW�YHHO� 'H�WHUPHQ�GLVWDDO�HQ�SUR[LPDDO�YHUZLM]HQ�QDDU�GH�OHQJWH�YDQ�KHW�LQWHUYDO�WXVVHQ�KHW�WLMGVWLS�ZDDURSEORRWVWHOOLQJ�DDQ�GH�GHWHUPLQDQW�SODDWVYLQGW�HQ�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�GH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV��UHVSHFWLHYHOLMNODQJ�ELM�HHQ�GLVWDOH�HQ�NRUWHU�ELM�HHQ�SUR[LPDOH�GHWHUPLQDQW��

Page 25: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

EHZLMVNUDFKW�� ELMYRRUEHHOG� XLW� SURVSHFWLHI� RQGHU]RHN�� ]LMQ� VFKDDUV��'DDUQDDVW� LV� HU� KHWSUREOHHP YDQ�GH�GLDJQRVWLHN�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��'H�EHSHUNWH�EHWURXZEDDUKHLGYDQ� GH� JHOGHQGH� GLDJQRVWLVFKH� FULWHULD� YRRU� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� GH� YHOHYHUDQGHULQJHQ� LQ� GH� DIJHORSHQ� GHFHQQLD� LQ� GH� FODVVLILFDWLH� GDDUYDQ�� EHPRHLOLMNHQ� GHRSERXZ�YDQ�HHQ��HHQGXLGLJH��µERG\�RI�HYLGHQFH¶�HUQVWLJ��7HQ�GHUGH�KHHIW�GLW�WH�PDNHQPHW GH�FRQWH[WDIKDQNHOLMNKHLG�YDQ�KHW�HIIHFW�YDQ�YHOH��SV\FKRVRFLDOH��GHWHUPLQDQWHQ��%LMGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� ]RDOV� ZHUNORRVKHLG�� HFKWVFKHLGLQJ� HQ� DUPRHGH� EHSDDOW� GH� GRRU� KHWLQGLYLGX�WRHJHNHQGH�EHWHNHQLV��HQ�KHW�GDDURSYROJHQGH�FRSLQJJHGUDJ��PHGH�KHW�HIIHFW�RSGH SV\FKLVFKH� JH]RQGKHLG�� 'HWHUPLQDQWHQ� KHEEHQ� KLHUGRRU� YDDN� ZHLQLJ� RS� ]LFK]HOIVWDDQGH EHWHNHQLV� YRRU� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�� PDDU� PRHWHQ� LQLQWHUDFWLH�PHW� DQGHUH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�ZRUGHQ� EHVFKRXZG��+HW� ]DO� GXLGHOLMN� ]LMQ� GDW� GLWSXQW�KHW�GRHQ�YDQ�HSLGHPLRORJLVFK�RQGHU]RHN�H[WUD�ODVWLJ�PDDNW�(HQ� ODDWVWH� NHQPHUN� YDQ� KHW� '\QDPLVFKH� 6WUHVV�.ZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO� LV� GHZLVVHOZHUNLQJ�LQ�GH�WLMG�GLH�EHVWDDW�WXVVHQ�GH IDFWRUHQ�LQ�KHW�PRGHO��3V\FKRELRORJLVFKHNHQPHUNHQ�HQ�VRFLDOH�RPJHYLQJ�EHwQYORHGHQ�]RDOV�JH]HJG�KHW�DO�GDQ�QLHW�RSWUHGHQ�YDQJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�� PDDU� RRN� KHW� GDDURSYROJHQGH� JHGUDJ� �PHW� QDPH� GH� SURFHVVHQ� YDQEHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJ�HQ�FRSLQJ���0DDU�KHW�PRGHO�ODDW�RRN�H[SOLFLHW�WRH�GDW�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQHQ� JHGUDJ� RS� KXQ� EHXUW� GH� NZHWVEDDUKHLG� EOLMYHQG� YHUDQGHUHQ�� (HQ� HHQPDOLJH�PHWLQJYDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�]RDOV� LQ�FURVV�VHFWLRQHHO��PDDU�RRN�LQ�ORQJLWXGLQDDO�RQGHU]RHN�YDDNJHEHXUW�� LV�GXV�YHHODO�YDQ�EHSHUNWH�ZDDUGH�]LMQ�YRRU�RSKHOGHULQJ�YDQ�GH� HWLRORJLH�YDQSV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�� RPGDW� KHW� JHHQ� LQ]LFKW� JHHIW� LQ� ERYHQJHQRHPGHZLVVHOZHUNLQJ�(HQ�RYHU]LFKW�YDQ�GH�EHODQJULMNVWH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HQ�KXQ�RQGHUOLQJH�YHUEDQGHQ:DW LV�HU��JHJHYHQ�GH]H�EHSHUNLQJHQ��RS�GLW�PRPHQW�EHNHQG�RYHU�GH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQSV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG"� +HW� OLWHUDWXXURYHU]LFKW� EHYHVWLJW� KHW� EHHOG� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ� DOV� PXOWLIDFWRULsOH� DDQGRHQLQJHQ�� ,Q� WDEHO� ���� ]LMQ� GH� UHVXOWDWHQ�� ]RDOVJHSUHVHQWHHUG� LQ� GH� ELMGUDJH� YDQ�2UPHO� HW� DO�� NRUW� VDPHQJHYDW� YRRU� GH� DI]RQGHUOLMNHGHWHUPLQDQW�JURHS�HQ�'H�UHVXOWDWHQ�YDQ�KHW�OLWHUDWXXURQGHU]RHN�EOLMNHQ�EHSHUNW�LQ]LFKW�WH�JHYHQ�LQ�GHRQGHUOLQJH� YHUEDQGHQ� WXVVHQ� GH� EHVSURNHQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� +HW� RQGHU]RHN� QDDU� GHFDXVDOH� NHWHQV� LQ� GH� HWLRORJLH� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� �YROJHQV� KHW� YRRUJHVWHOGH'6.�PRGHO�� EOLMNW� QRJ� LQ� GH� NLQGHUVFKRHQHQ� WH� VWDDQ�� 2S� EDVLV� YDQ� GH� EHVFKLNEDUHJHJHYHQV� FRQFOXGHHUW�2UPHO� GDW� YHHO� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�ZDDUVFKLMQOLMN� GHHO� XLWPDNHQ�YDQFDXVDOH� NHWHQV� PHW� JHQHWLVFKH� EHODVWLQJ�� HHQ� RQJXQVWLJ� WHPSHUDPHQW� HQ� WUDXPDWLVFKH�MHXJG�HUYDULQJHQ� YDDN� DOV� HHUVWH� VFKDNHOV�� 'DDUQD� YROJHQ� GH� µULVNDQWH¶SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVWUHNNHQ�� OHLGHQG� WRW� EUHXNHQ� LQ� GH� RSOHLGLQJ� HQ� UHODWLHYRUPLQJ�FKURQLVFKH� LQWHUSHUVRRQOLMNH� HQ� ZHUNJHUHODWHHUGH� PRHLOLMNKHGHQ� HQ� HHQ� ODJH� 6(6�7HQVORWWH� ]LMQ� GH� PHHU� DFXWH� VWUHVVYROOH� OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� GH� GHILQLWLHYH� GXZ� LQULFKWLQJ�YDQ�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�GH�VWRRUQLV��6RFLDOH�IDFWRUHQ�YRUPHQ�HHQ�ULVLFR��RI�ELHGHQMXLVW� EHVFKHUPLQJ�� GRRU� KXQ� LQYORHG� RS� LHPDQGV� µYHHUNUDFKW¶� HQ� RS� GHKDQGHOLQJVUXLPWH�

Page 26: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

7DEHO����� 6DPHQYDWWLQJ�YDQ�GH�EHYLQGLQJHQ�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQ�GH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKHRQJH]RQGKHLG�'HWHUPLQDQWJURHS 5HVXOWDDW'HPRJUDILVFKH�IDFWRUHQ 9HHO�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�RQWVWDDQ�RS�UHODWLHI�MRQJH�OHHIWLMG� YHHODO�YRRU�KHWGHUWLJVWH� OHYHQVMDDU��'DDUELM� ]LMQ� HU� GXLGHOLMNH� YHUVFKLOOHQ� WXVVHQ� PDQQHQ� HQYURXZHQ� LQ� KHW� W\SH� VWRRUQLV� GDW� ]LM� RQWZLNNHOHQ�� 'H� ]RJHQDDPGHµLQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH¶� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� ZDDURQGHU� VWHPPLQJV�� HQ� DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQNRPHQ�YDNHU�YRRU�ELM�YURXZHQ��GH�H[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��YHUVODYLQJHQHQ�LQ�PLQGHUH�PDWH�VXwFLGH��ELM�PDQQHQ�3V\FKRELRORJLVFKHNZHWVEDDUKHLGVIDFWRUHQ� *HQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ (U�LV�RYHUWXLJHQGH�EHZLMVODVW�YRRU�HHQ�GXLGHOLMNH�ELMGUDJH�ELM�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQELSRODLUH�VWRRUQLV�HQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH��+HW�YHUEDQG�LV�PLQGHU�VWHUN�HQ�GH�EHZLMVODVW]ZDNNHU� YRRU� DQJVW��� VWHPPLQJV�� HQ� VRPDWRIRUPH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� HQ� YRRUPLVEUXLN� HQ� DIKDQNHOLMNKHLG� YDQ� PLGGHOHQ�� 2QEHNHQG� LV� RRN� KRH� VWHUN� GHELMGUDJH�LV�DDQ�VXwFLGH��ZDQQHHU�JHFRUULJHHUG�]RX�ZRUGHQ�YRRU�GH�ELMGUDJH�YDQJHQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�DDQ�DQGHUH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�GLH�YDDN�DDQZH]LJ�]LMQELM�SHUVRQHQ�GLH�VXwFLGH�SOHJHQ�� 3HUVRRQVNHQPHUNHQ 5HODWLHI� JRHG� RQGHUERXZG� LV� GH� LQYORHG� YDQ� SHUVRRQVNHQPHUNHQ�� ]RDOV� HHQJHUHPGH�RI� QHXURWLVFKH�SHUVRRQOLMNKHLG�HQ� LPSXOVLYLWHLW� RI� K\SHUDFWLYLWHLW� RSKHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH��PDDU�RRN�RS�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�YHUVODYLQJ�HQ��LQPLQGHUH�PDWH��VRPDWRIRUPH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�� 6RPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ 5HGHOLMNH� EHZLMVODVW� YRRU� GH� URO� YDQ� FRPSOLFDWLHV� ELM� ]ZDQJHUVFKDS� HQJHERRUWH�DOV�PHGH�GH��GDDUDDQ�PHGH�JHUHODWHHUGH��RQWZLNNHOLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�LQGH� HWLRORJLH� YDQ� YRRUDO� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ELM� MHXJGLJHQ�� PDDU� RRNVFKL]RIUHQLH��YHUVODYLQJ�HQ�LQ�PLQGHUH�PDWH�RRN�VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�6RFLDOHNZHWVEDDUKHLGVIDFWRUHQ (QLJH�WRW�UHGHOLMNH�EHZLMVODVW�YRRU�GH�URO�YDQ�FRQIOLFWXHX]H�JH]LQVVLWXDWLHV� LQKHW� RQWVWDDQ� YDQ� DOOH� JHVHOHFWHHUGH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� H[FOXVLHI� VFKL]RIUHQLH� HQELSRODLUH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��%LM� ODJH�6(6��VRFLDOH�LVRODWLH��JHEUHN�DDQ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�HQ� JH�UEDQLVHHUGH� OHHIRPJHYLQJ� ]LMQ� HYHQHHQV� YHUEDQGHQ� DDQJHWRRQG� PHWGLYHUVH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��PDDU�LV�GH�ULFKWLQJ�YDQ�KHW�YHUEDQG�QRJ�RQGXLGHOLMN�6WUHVVYROOHOHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ 9HUKRJHQ� KHW� ULVLFR� RS� DOOH� �JHVHOHFWHHUGH�� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� JHJHYHQHHQ�]HNHUH�NZHWVEDDUKHLG��(U�]LMQ�HFKWHU�PDDU�EHSHUNWH�DDQZLM]LQJHQ�GDW�HHQVSHFLILHN�W\SH�VWUHVVYROOH�JHEHXUWHQLV�YHUEDQG�KRXGW�PHW�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�HHQEHSDDOGH� VWRRUQLV�� 'H� PHHVWH� EHZLMVODVW� LQ� GLW� YHUEDQG� LV� YRRUYHUOLHVHUYDULQJHQ�HQ�GHSUHVVLH�

'H�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�DDQ�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�YRONVJH]RQGKHLG:DW YDOW� HU� QX� WH� ]HJJHQ� RYHU� GH� ELMGUDJH� YDQ� �LQGLYLGXHOH� RI� JURHSHQ� YDQ�� GH]HGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� DDQ� GH� SV\FKLVFKH� �RQ�JH]RQGKHLG� LQ� GH� EHYRONLQJ�� DQGHUV� JH]HJG� GHJHHVWHOLMNH� YRONVJH]RQGKHLG� LQ� 1HGHUODQG"� 'H� ELMGUDJH� YDQ� HHQ� GHWHUPLQDQW� KDQJWEHKDOYH�YDQ�GH�VWHUNWH�YDQ�KHW�YHUEDQG�PHW HHQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV��GH�KRRJWH�YDQ�KHWUHODWLHI� ULVLFR��� RRN� VDPHQ�PHW�KHW�DDQWDO� VWRRUQLVVHQ�ZDDUELM� GLH�GHWHUPLQDQW� HHQ� UROVSHHOW ��(HQ�NZDQWLWDWLHYH�VFKDWWLQJ�YDQ�GH�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�VSHFLILHNH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�DDQ�GHJHHVWHOLMNH� YRONVJH]RQGKHLG� �HQ� GDDUPHH� YDQ� GH� SRWHQWLHHO� WH� EHKDOHQ� JH]RQGKHLGV�ZLQVW��LV�YRRUORSLJ�QRJ�QLHW�PRJHOLMN��'LW�KHHIW�DOOHV�WH�PDNHQ�PHW�GH�UHHGV�JHVFKHWVWHEHSHUNWH� EHVFKLNEDDUKHLG� YDQ� GH� EHQRGLJGH� RQGHU]RHNVJHJHYHQV�� (HQ� PHHU� 2RN�GH�SUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�HHQ�GHWHUPLQDQW�LQ�GH�SRSXODWLH�LV�HHQ�EHSDOHQGH�IDFWRU�YRRU�GH�ELMGUDJH�DDQ�GH]LHNWHODVW���'H]H�LV�KLHU�HFKWHU�EXLWHQ�EHVFKRXZLQJ�JHODWHQ�RPGDW�YRRU�HHQ�JURRW�DDQWDO�GHWHUPLQDQWHQKLHURYHU�RS�SRSXODWLHQLYHDX�]HOGHQ�RI�QRRLW�JHJHYHQV�YHU]DPHOG�]LMQ��DVSHFWHQ�YDQ�WHPSHUDPHQW�RIFRSLQJVWLMOHQ��RI�RPGDW�KHW�EHJULS�SUHYDOHQWLH�RQ]LQQLJ�LV��UDPSHQ��

Page 27: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

NZDOLWDWLHYH�GXLGLQJ�YDQ�GH�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�HHQ�DDQWDO�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�LV�ZpO�WH�JHYHQ��9RRUGH YROJHQGH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� NRPW� XLW� GH� OLWHUDWXXUDQDO\VH� QDDU� YRUHQ� GDW� ]LM� PHHUGHUH�EHODQJULMNH�� VWRRUQLVVHQ� EHwQYORHGHQ� DOV� PHGH� KHW� QLYHDX� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKHRQJH]RQGKHLG�� JHPHWHQ� YROJHQV� JHQHULHNH� PDWHQ�� HHQ� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLG� JHNHQPHUNWGRRU �H[FHVVLHYH��JHUHPGKHLG�HQ�QHXURWLFLVPH�� �GRRU� LPSXOVLYLWHLW��RI�GRRU� FRJQLWLHYHHQ VRFLDDO�FRPPXQLFDWLHYH� EHSHUNLQJHQ� �LQFOXVLHI� GH� KLHUYRRU�PHGHYHUDQWZRRUGHOLMNHJHQHQ��� WUDXPDWLVFKH� HUYDULQJHQ� LQ� GH� MHXJG�� HHQ� ODJH� 6(6�� HQ� GH� GDDUPHHVDPHQKDQJHQGH�JURWHUH�NDQV�RS�ILQDQFLsOH�SUREOHPHQ��JH]LQVFRQIOLFWHQ�HQ�EORRWVWHOOLQJDDQ�ULVLFRYROOH�VLWXDWLHV��]RDOV�JHZHOG��HQ�GUXJV��VWHUNH�YHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ��HQ�VQHOOH�VRFLDOHYHUDQGHULQJHQ�GRRU�RQGHUPHHU�PLJUDWLH�:DW�LV�QX�GH�EHWHNHQLV�YDQ�GH�EHYLQGLQJHQ�XLW�GH�OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH�LQ�GHHO�%��YRRUSUHYHQWLH"�'H� YHOH� ODFXQHV� LQ� GH� NHQQLV� GLH�2UPHO� HW� DO�� KHEEHQ� JHFRQVWDWHHUG� HQ� GHEHSHUNWH�KLVWRULH�YDQ�KHW�SV\FKLDWULVFK�HSLGHPLRORJLVFK�RQGHU]RHN��ZLM]HQ�DOOHUHHUVW�RSGH ZHQVHOLMNKHLG� YDQ� HHQ� LQWHQVLYHULQJ� YDQ� KHW� HSLGHPLRORJLVFK� RQGHU]RHN� RS� GLWWHUUHLQ��7RFK�EOLMNHQ�HU�RRN�QX�DO�FRQFUHWH�DDQNQRSLQJVSXQWHQ�YRRU�SUHYHQWLH�WH�JHYHQ�0HW�QDPH�GH�KLHUYRRU�JHQRHPGH�JHQHULHNH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�OLMNHQ�YDQ�EHODQJ�DOV�KHW�JDDWRP KHW�SULRULWHUHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�RQGHU]RHN�HQ��SUDNWLMN��+RRIGVWXN���JDDW�QDGHU� LQ�RSGH EHWHNHQLV� YDQ� GH� EHYLQGLQJHQ� LQ� GH� DFKWHUJURQGUDSSRUWHQ� YRRU� RQGHU]RHNV�� HQSUHYHQWLHEHOHLG��

���� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ��SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG,Q� GH� GRRU� KHW� 7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW� XLWJHYRHUGH� OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH� QDDU� GH� HIIHFWHQ� YDQSUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS��GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ��SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG��]LH�GHHO�%�� LVRQGHU]RFKW� RI� KHW� PRJHOLMN� LV� RP� PHW� EHKXOS� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� GHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HQ�SUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�NODFKWHQ�WH�EHwQYORHGHQ�'H� VWXGLH� KHHIW� ]LFK� EHSHUNW� WRW� YROZDVVHQHQ� RPGDW� KHW� JHKHOH� YHOG� �LQFOXVLHINLQGHUHQ� HQ� MHXJGLJHQ�� WH� RPYDQJULMN� HQ� WH� KHWHURJHHQ� LV�� 9HHO� RQGHU]RHN� QDDUGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�LV�XLWJHYRHUG�ELM�YROZDVVHQHQ�HQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV�ULFKWHQ�]LFK�YDDN�H[SOLFLHWRS GH]H�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� 2S�EDVLV�YDQ�UHHGV�XLWJHYRHUGH�OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLHV�QDDU�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�LVJHNR]HQ� RP� GH� RQGHUVWDDQGH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� QDGHU� WH� RQGHU]RHNHQ�� LQ� GH� YHUZDFKWLQJGDW YRRU�GH]H�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YROGRHQGH�RQGHU]RHN�YRRUKDQGHQ�]RX�]LMQ��� (QGRJHQH�IDFWRUHQ��SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ��� HLJHQ�HIIHFWLYLWHLW��VHOI�HIILFDF\���� VRFLDOH�YDDUGLJKHGHQ��� ([RJHQH�IDFWRUHQ��VRFLDOH�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVIDFWRUHQ��� VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�� LQJULMSHQGH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�RI�VWUHVVRUHQ�� KHW ]RUJHQ�YRRU�HHQ�IDPLOLHOLG�PHW�HHQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�DDQGRHQLQJ�� +LHU�ZRUGW�JHGRHOG�RS�GH�QLHW�VWRRUQLVVSHFLILHNH��GLPHQVLRQHOH��EHQDGHULQJ�ZDDUELM�DDQ�LHGHU�LQGLYLGXHHQ�VFRUH�YRRU�SV\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG�ZRUGW�WRHJHNHQG�RS�EDVLV�YDQ�V\PSWRRPYUDJHQOLMVWHQ�DOV�GH*+4��]LH�YHUGHU�GHHO�%���SDUDJUDDI������� 9HUWURXZHQ�GDW�HHQ�SHUVRRQ�KHHIW�LQ�]LMQ�KDDU�HLJHQ�NXQQHQ�DDQJDDQGH�KHW�XLWYRHUHQ�YDQ�HHQ�EHSDDOGJHGUDJ�

Page 28: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

� YHUOLHV�YDQ�HHQ�QDDVWH�GRRU�GH�GRRG�� ZHUNORRVKHLG�� KHW ]RUJHQ�YRRU�HHQ�KXOSEHKRHYHQGH�RXGHUH�LQ�GH�QDDVWH�RPJHYLQJ�'H�JHJHYHQV�RYHU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�ELQQHQ�GH�**=�]LMQ�PHHVWDO�DINRPVWLJ�XLWLQWHUYHQWLHV� GLH� ]LMQ� JHULFKW� RS� KHW� EHwQYORHGHQ� YDQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKHJH]RQGKHLG� �]RDOV� KHW� YHUPLQGHUHQ� YDQ� GH� JHYROJHQ� YDQ� LQJULMSHQGHOHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� YRRU� GH� JHHVWHOLMNH� JH]RQGKHLG�� HQ� KHW� YHUPLQGHUHQ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH� NODFKWHQ�� (U� ]LMQ� QDXZHOLMNV� JHJHYHQV� EHVFKLNEDDU� RYHU� HIIHFWHQ� YDQGHUJHOLMNH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�KHW�GDDGZHUNHOLMN�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�9DQZHJH� KHW� EHSHUNWH� DDQWDO� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� GDW� LV� RQGHU]RFKW� NDQ� JHHQDOJHPHHQ� JHOGHQGH� XLWVSUDDN� ZRUGHQ� JHGDDQ� RYHU� GH� EHwQYORHGEDDUKHLG� YDQGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� JH]RQGKHLG�� 'RRU� HQNHOH� NDGHUWHNVWHQ� RS� WH� QHPHQ�ZDDULQ RRN�DQGHUH�DVSHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�NODFKWHQ�DDQERG�NRPHQ��LV�JHwOOXVWUHHUG�GDW�KHW�SUHYHQWLHYHOG�HQ�KHW�SUHYHQWLH�RQGHU]RHN�EUHGHU�]LMQGDQ GH�EHQDGHULQJ�GLH�LQ�GH]H�VWXGLH�JHYROJG�LV�,Q� KHW� RYHU]LFKW� LV� JHEUXLN� JHPDDNW� YDQ� JHFRQWUROHHUGH� HQ� ]R� PRJHOLMNJHUDQGRPLVHHUGH�HIIHFWVWXGLHV��5&7¶V���'HUJHOLMNH�VWXGLHV�NDQ�PHQ�EHVFKRXZHQ�DOV�GHJRXGHQ� VWDQGDDUG� RP� HIIHFWHQ� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� WH� RQGHU]RHNHQ�� 'DW� ZLO� HFKWHU� QLHW]HJJHQ� GDW� DQGHUH� RQGHU]RHNVGHVLJQV� YRRU� KHW� YDVWVWHOOHQ� YDQ� HHQ� HIIHFW� YDQ� JHHQHQNHOH� ZDDUGH� ]LMQ�� %LM� GH� RQWZLNNHOLQJ� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� HQ� ELM� LPSOHPHQWDWLH�RQGHU]RHN� LV�PHW�QDPH�RRN�NZDOLWDWLHI� HYDOXDWLH�RQGHU]RHN�ZDDUGHYRO�� RQGHU� DQGHUHRP LQ]LFKW� WH� JHYHQ� LQ� VXFFHVIDFWRUHQ� HQ� NQHOSXQWHQ� ELM� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� HQGDDUPHH�GH�NDQV�RS�LPSOHPHQWDWLH�YDQ�HIIHFWLHYH�SURJUDPPD¶V�WH�EHYRUGHUHQ�(HQ� DOJHPHQH� FRQFOXVLH� YDQ� &XLMSHUV� HW� DO�� LV� GDW� LQ� KHW� RQGHU]RHNVYHOG� YHHOVWXGLHV�QLHW�JRHG�]LMQ�RSJH]HW�HQ�RQYROGRHQGH�GDWD�SUHVHQWHUHQ�RP�KDUGH�XLWVSUDNHQ�WHNXQQHQ�GRHQ�RYHU�HIIHFWHQ��2QGDQNV�GH�EHSHUNLQJHQ�JHHIW�KHW�GRRU�KHQ�JHSUHVHQWHHUGHVWDWH�RI�WKH�DUW�RYHU]LFKW�ZHO�DDQZLM]LQJHQ�YRRU�KHW�EHDQWZRRUGHQ�YDQ�GH�YDQ� WHYRUHQJHGHILQLHHUGH�YUDDJVWHOOLQJHQ��]LH�WDEHO������$O�PHW�DO�LV�KHW�YHOG�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�KHW�EHwQYORHGHQ�YDQGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG�QRJ�VOHFKWV�LQ�JHULQJH�PDWH�RQGHU]RFKW��9HHOEHODQJULMNH� YUDJHQ� ]LMQ� QRJ� QLHW� WH� EHDQWZRRUGHQ�� (U� ]LMQ� JHHQ� GHILQLWLHYH� FRQFOXVLHVPRJHOLMN�RYHU�GH�SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�GLH�KHW�PHHVW�YHHOEHORYHQG�]LMQ�� RI�RYHU�GHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� GLH� PHW� EHKXOS� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� KHW� EHVW� EHwQYORHGEDDU� ]LMQ�� +HW� OLMNWHFKWHU� DDQQHPHOLMN� GDW�PHW� QDPH� GtH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� YHHOEHORYHQG� ]LMQ� GLH� RS� PHHUGHUHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� WHJHOLMN� DDQJULMSHQ�� 'LW� VOXLW� WHYHQV� DDQ� ELM� KHW� PRGHO�� ]RDOVJHSUHVHQWHHUG�LQ�GHHO�%��YDQ GLW�UDSSRUW�HQ�GH�UHVXOWDWHQ�YDQ�GH�OLWHUDWXXUDQDO\VH�GLH�HURS ZLM]HQ�GDW�LQWHUDFWLHV�WXVVHQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HHQ�EHODQJULMNH�URO�VSHOHQ�LQ�GH�HWLRORJLHYDQ VWRRUQLVVHQ��=R�]LMQ�YHHO�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�]RZHO�JHULFKW�RS�HHQ�LQJULMSHQGHOHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLV�RI�FKURQLVFKH�VWUHVVRU�� DOV�RS� FRSLQJ�YDDUGLJKHGHQ�RI� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ�%LM� GH� YHUGHUH� RQWZLNNHOLQJ� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� LV� KHW� GDQ� RRN� YDQ� JURRWEHODQJ�WH�RQGHU]RHNHQ�RS�ZHONH��FRPELQDWLH�YDQ��GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�KHW�EHVWH�DDQJHJUHSHQNDQ ZRUGHQ�

Page 29: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

7DEHO�������6DPHQYDWWLQJ�YDQ�GH�EHYLQGLQJHQ�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ��GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG�9UDDJ %HYLQGLQJHQ.XQQHQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GHFRQVHTXHQWLHV�YDQ�LQJULMSHQGHOHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�RI�VWUHVVRUHQYRRU�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLGEHSHUNHQ"

9RRU� HQNHOH� OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� HQ� VWUHVVRUHQ� EOLMNHQ� SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV� LQ� VWDDW� RP� GH]H� FRQVHTXHQWLHV� WH� YHUPLQGHUHQ�� 'XLGHOLMNEHwQYORHGEDDU� ]LMQ�GH� FRQVHTXHQWLHV� YDQ� KHW� ]RUJHQ� YRRU� HHQ�SV\FKLDWULVFK]LHN� IDPLOLHOLG�� $DQZLM]LQJHQ� YRRU� EHwQYORHGEDDUKHLG� ]LMQ� JHYRQGHQ� YRRUURXZ� HQ� ZHUNORRVKHLG�� 'H� FRQVHTXHQWLHV� YDQ� KHW� ]RUJHQ� YRRU� HHQKXOSEHKRHYHQG� RXGHU� IDPLOLHOLG� OLMNHQ� RS� GLW� PRPHQW� QRJ� QLHW� JRHG� WHEHwQYORHGHQ�.XQQHQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GHHUYDUHQ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�YHUEHWHUHQ" 'H]H�YUDDJ�LV�PRHLOLMN�WH�EHDQWZRRUGHQ�YDQZHJH�KHW�NOHLQ�DDQWDO�VWXGLHV�GDWYROGHHG�DDQ�GH�LQFOXVLH�FULWHULD�.XQQHQ�SUHYHQWLH�LQWHUYHQWLHVSHUVRRQVNHQPHUNHQ��LQ�KHW�ELM]RQ�GHU�HLJHQ�HIIHFWLYLWHLW�EHwQYORHGHQ"

'H]H� YUDDJ� LV� YRRU]LFKWLJ� SRVLWLHI� EHDQWZRRUG�� (U� ZHUG� HHQ� NOHLQ� PDDUVLJQLILFDQW�HIIHFW�YDQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV�JHYRQGHQ�:DW�LV�KHW�HIIHFW�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�V\PSWRPHQ�YDQHUQVWLJH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ"�

2YHU�KHW�HIIHFW�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH��VRPDWLVHULQJ�HQ�VXwFLGH�EOHHNQLHWV� WH� YLQGHQ� WH� ]LMQ�� 3UHYHQWLH� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH� HQ� DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� LV� LQPHHUGHUH�VWXGLHV�RQGHU]RFKW��PDDU�GH�UHVXOWDWHQ�]LMQ�QRJ�QLHW�HHQGXLGLJ��:DWEHWUHIW� SRVWWUDXPDWLVFKH� VWUHVV�VWRRUQLVVHQ�ZHUG� JHHQ� HIIHFW� JHYRQGHQ��(HQDDQWDO�VSHFLILHNHUH�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�]LMQ�XLWYRHULJHU�EHVWXGHHUG�� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� GUXJJHEUXLN� YLD� VFKRROSURJUDPPD¶V� EOLMNW� YROGRHQGHHIIHFWLHI�RP�RYHU�WH�JDDQ�WRW�ODQGHOLMNH�LPSOHPHQWDWLH� GDW]HOIGH�JHOGW�YRRU�VHFXQGDLUH�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�ELM�RXGHUHQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS� IDPLOLHOHGHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�SDWLsQWHQ� OLMNHQHIIHFWLHI�LQ�KHW�YRRUNyPHQ�YDQ�RYHUEHODVWLQJ��VWUHVV�HQ�DQJVW�� YHHOEHORYHQG� OLMNHQ� JHwQGLFHHUGH� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�� JHULFKW� RSSHUVRQHQ� GLH� UHHGV� HQLJH� V\PSWRPHQ� YDQ� HHQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVYHUWRQHQ�� ,QGLHQ� GH]H� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHEDVHHUG� ]LMQ� RS� NHQQLV� RYHUGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� GH]H� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� YRRUWERXZHQ� RS� NHQQLV� RYHUEHKDQGHOLQJ� YDQ� GH]H� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� NXQQHQ� ]LM� RS� HIIHFWLHYH�ZLM]H� KHWRQWVWDDQ� YDQ� QLHXZH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� YRRUNyPHQ�� 6WRRUQLVVHQ� ZDDU� YHHONHQQLV�RYHU�GH�EHKDQGHOLQJ�EHVFKLNEDDU�LV��]RDOV�DQJVW��HQ�GHSUHVVLHYHVWRRUQLVVHQ� NXQQHQ� LQ� HHQ� YURHJ� VWDGLXP� DDQJHSDNW� ZRUGHQ�� ]RGDWFKURQLFLWHLW� YRRUNyPHQ� ZRUGW�� %LM� MRQJHUH� OHHIWLMGVJURHSHQ� ZHUGHQKLHUYRRU�DO�YHHOEHORYHQGH�YRRUEHHOGHQ�JHYRQGHQ�

� %HDQWZRRUG�PHW�EHKXOS�YDQ�HHUGHU�GRRU�KHW�7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW�XLWJHYRHUGH�OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLHV��]LHNDGHUWHNVWHQ�LQ�GHHO�%���

Page 30: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

� %HOHLGVDQDO\VH(HQ�RYHU]LFKW�YDQ�KHW�KXLGLJH� ODQGHOLMN� HQ� UHJLRQDDO�EHOHLG� WHQ� DDQ]LHQ� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG� ZRUGW� RQGHU� DQGHUH� JHJHYHQ� LQ� KHW� RQWZLNNHOLQJVSODQSUHYHQWLH� JHHVWHOLMNH� YRONVJH]RQGKHLG� HQ� YHUVODYLQJHQ� µ+LQN�6WDS�6SURQJ¶� �'HNNHU�������� ,Q� GH� DIJHORSHQ� ��� MDDU� ]LMQ� VWHHGV� PHHU� LQVWHOOLQJHQ� DFWLHI� JHZRUGHQ� RS� KHWWHUUHLQ YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� **=�� 9DQ� RXGVKHU� EHVFKLNNHQ� 5,$**¶V� HQ� &$'¶V� RYHUGHVNXQGLJHQ� GLH� JHVFKRROG� ]LMQ� LQ� SUHYHQWLH�� 'H� QDGUXN� OLJW� ELM� GH]H� LQVWHOOLQJHQ� RSDFWLYLWHLWHQ� RS� JHOHLGH� YDQ� HHQ� YULMZLOOLJH� LQGLYLGXHOH� KXOSYUDDJ�� 7HQ� DDQ]LHQ� YDQ� GHYHUVODYLQJVSUHYHQWLH�ZRUGW�JHVFKDW�GDW�GH�&$'¶V�PRPHQWHHO�FLUFD�����YDQ�KXQ�EXGJHWDDQ�SUHYHQWLH�DFWLYLWHLWHQ�EHVWHGHQ��'DDUELM�LV�HHQ�YHUVFKXLYLQJ�PHUNEDDU�YDQ�DOJHPHQHYRRUOLFKWLQJ�QDDU�DFWLYLWHLWHQ��JHULFKW�RS�ULVLFRJURHSHQ��**=�1HGHUODQG���������8LW�KHWHHUVWH� EUDQFKHUDSSRUW�*HHVWHOLMNH�*H]RQGKHLGV]RUJ� �**=�1HGHUODQG�� ������ EOLMNW� GDWGH 5,$**¶V��RQGDQNV�GH�WRHQHPHQGH�ZDFKWOLMVWHQ�YRRU�EHKDQGHOLQJ��KXQ�LQYHVWHULQJ�LQSUHYHQWLH�DFWLYLWHLWHQ�RS�HHQ]HOIGH�QLYHDX�ZHWHQ�WH�KRXGHQ��%OLMNEDDU�KHFKWHQ�5,$**¶VYHHO�ZDDUGH�DDQ�SUHYHQWLH�DFWLYLWHLWHQ�+HW�]ZDDUWHSXQW�YDQ�GH�SUHYHQWLH�RQWZLNNHOLQJ�KHHIW�WRW�KHW�EHJLQ�YDQ�GH�MDUHQ¶��� YRRUDO� LQ� GH� UHJLR¶V� JHOHJHQ�� 'H]H� SOXULIRUPLWHLW� KHHIW� GH� RQWZLNNHOLQJ� YDQSUHYHQWLH� EHYRUGHUG�� PDDU� HU� RRN� WRH� JHOHLG� GDW� GH� SUHYHQWLHSUDNWLMN� YHUVQLSSHUG� LVJHEOHYHQ�� 3UHYHQWLH� KHHIW� ]LFK� QRJ� RQYROGRHQGH� WRW� HHQ� NUDFKWLJ� EHOHLGVLQVWUXPHQWNXQQHQ�RQWZLNNHOHQ��**=�1HGHUODQG��������%LQQHQ�GH�**'¶HQ�YHUYXOW� GH� MHXJGJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ� YDQRXGVKHU� WDNHQ� RS� KHWWHUUHLQ YDQ�GH�SUHYHQWLH��6LQGV������]LMQ�GH�**'¶HQ�]LFK�RQGHU�LQYORHG�YDQ�GH�:HW�RSGH FROOHFWLHYH� SUHYHQWLH� QRJ� VSHFLILHNHU� PHW� GH� SV\FKRK\JLsQH� JDDQ� EH]LJKRXGHQ�YRRUDO YLD� VFKRROJHULFKWH� SURJUDPPD¶V� HQ� SURJUDPPD¶V� YRRU� RXGHUHQ�� =LM� JHYHQXLWYRHULQJ� DDQ� GH� 2SHQEDUH� *HHVWHOLMNH� *H]RQGKHLGV]RUJ� �DFWLYLWHLWHQ� JHULFKW� RS� KHWEHYRUGHUHQ� YDQ� GH� JHHVWHOLMNH� YRONVJH]RQGKHLG�� QLHW� RS� JHOHLGH� YDQ� HHQ� LQGLYLGXHOHKXOSYUDDJ��� GLH� WRW� KHW� SDNNHW� YDQ� YHUDQWZRRUGHOLMNKHGHQ� YRRU� GH� ORNDOH� RYHUKHGHQ�JHPHHQWHQ��EHKRRUW��9:6��������2RN�GH�KXLVDUWV�NULMJW�HHQ�VWHHGV�EHODQJULMNHU�URO�RS�KHW�JHELHG�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH��,QGH 9:6�QRWD� µ*H]RQG� HQ� ZHO¶� ������� ZHUG� GH� LQYRHULQJ� YDQ� SURJUDPPDWLVFKHSUHYHQWLH�LQ�GH�KXLVDUWVHQSUDNWLMN�DOV�ppQ�YDQ�GH�EHOHLGVSULRULWHLWHQ�JHQRHPG��1LHWWHPLQEOLMYHQ�LQ�GH�KXLVDUWVHQSUDNWLMN�DOFRKROPLVEUXLN�HQ�GHSUHVVLH�RQGHUJHGLDJQRVWLVHHUG�HQRQGHUEHKDQGHOG��0RJHOLMN�]LMQ�RYHUEHODVWLQJ��HHQ�JHEUHN�DDQ��GLDJQRVWLVFKH��NHQQLV�HQHUYDULQJ� HQ� KHW� DFKWHUZHJH� EOLMYHQ� YDQ� HHQ� DGHTXDWH� YHUJRHGLQJ� YRRU� GH� KXLVDUWVHQIDFWRUHQ� GLH� KLHUELM� HHQ� URO� VSHOHQ�� HYHQDOV� KHW� WHNRUW� DDQ� RQGHUVWHXQLQJ� YDQXLW� GHUHJLRQDOH�**=�HQ�YHUVODYLQJV]RUJ��'HNNHU��������&DWHJRUDOH� RUJDQLVDWLHV� �SDWLsQWHQYHUHQLJLQJHQ�� SHGDJRJLVFKH� FHQWUD�� DUER�GLHQVWHQ HWF���YHUYXOOHQ�HHQ�VWHHGV�DFWLHYHUH�URO�LQ�GH�SUHYHQWLH��'LW�URHSW�GH�EHKRHIWH�RSDDQ�RQGHUOLQJH�DIVWHPPLQJ�YDQ�WDNHQ�HQ�VDPHQZHUNLQJ�RP�HHQ�GRHOPDWLJ�JHEUXLN�YDQGH EHVFKLNEDUH� PLGGHOHQ� YHLOLJ� WH� VWHOOHQ� �+RVPDQ� � *HHOHQ�� ������� +HW� 7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW�HQ�KHW�1,*=�KHEEHQ�LQ�GH�SHULRGH�����������FDPSDJQHV�RSJH]HW�URQG�WKHPD¶VDOV�µ+DVM�HQ�:HHG¶�HQ�µ'UDQN�PDDNW�PHHU�NDSRW�GDQ�MH�OLHI�LV¶��,Q�HHQ�DDQWDO�JHYDOOHQ�LVRS UHJLRQDDO�QLYHDX�LQYXOOLQJ�YHUYROJ�JHJHYHQ�DDQ�GH]H�DFWLYLWHLWHQ�$OV�JHYROJ�YDQ�GH�WHUXJWUHGHQGH�RYHUKHLG�HQ�KHW�GRRU�9:6�µXLW�KXLV�SODDWVHQ¶YDQ� XLWYRHUHQGH� ZHUN]DDPKHGHQ� LV� LQ� KHW� YHOG� HHQ� JURWH� EHKRHIWH� RQWVWDDQ� DDQ

Page 31: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

FR|UGLQDWLH�� RYHUOHJ� RYHU� GH� XLWYRHULQJ� DOVPHGH� RQGHUVWHXQLQJ� YDQ� KHW� ZHUN�� +HW/DQGHOLMN�2QGHUVWHXQLQJVSXQW�3UHYHQWLH�**=��/23���KHW�/DQGHOLMN�3ODWIRUP�3UHYHQWLH*HHVWHOLMNH� 9RONVJH]RQGKHLG� �/33*9�� HQ� GH� /DQGHOLMNH� 6WHXQIXQFWLH� 3UHYHQWLHYHUVODYLQJ�HQ�PLGGHOHQJHEUXLN��/63��SUREHUHQ�DDQ�GH]H�EHKRHIWH�WH�YROGRHQ�,Q�KHW�HHUGHU�JHQRHPGH�RQWZLNNHOLQJVSODQ�YDQ�'HNNHU��������ZRUGW�JHVWHOG�GDWGH WLMG�ULMS�LV�YRRU�HHQ�DFWLHYHU�SUHYHQWLHEHOHLG�YDQ�KHW�0LQLVWHULH�YDQ�9:6��%HODQJULMNSXQW�GDDUELM�LV�KHW�YDVWVWHOOHQ�YDQ�ODQGHOLMN�JHOGHQGH�SULRULWHLWHQ�YRRU�SUHYHQWLH�RS�KHWJHELHG�YDQ�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�YRONVJH]RQGKHLG��$OV�FULWHULD�YRRU�GH�NHX]H�YDQ�SULRULWHLWHQ]RXGHQ�GH�RPYDQJ�HQ�GH�HUQVW�YDQ�KHW�JH]RQGKHLGVSUREOHHP�EHODQJULMN�NXQQHQ�]LMQ�,Q�GH�%HOHLGVYLVLH�*HHVWHOLMNH�*H]RQGKHLGV]RUJ�� GLH� LQ�GHFHPEHU������ LV� DDQJHERGHQDDQ� GH� 7ZHHGH� .DPHU� EHVFKULMIW� KHW� 0LQLVWHULH� YDQ� 9:6� KHW� **=�EHOHLG� YRRU� GHODQJHUH� WHUPLMQ�� 'H� LQ� GH� EHOHLGVYLVLH� EHVFKUHYHQ� PDDWUHJHOHQ� ]LMQ� HURS� JHULFKW� GHGRHOWUHIIHQGKHLG� HQ� GRHOPDWLJKHLG� YDQ� GH� **=�VHFWRU� WH� YHUJURWHQ�� HQ� GDDUPHH� GHYHUDQGHUHQGH� HQ� WRHQHPHQGH� YUDDJ� QDDU� **=�KXOS� WH� NXQQHQ� RSYDQJHQ�� (pQ� YDQ� GHYRRU GH]H� UDSSRUWDJH� PHHVW� UHOHYDQWH� PDDWUHJHOHQ� LV� GH� RQWZLNNHOLQJ� YDQ� HHQ� DFWLHISUHYHQWLH��HQ�]RUJEHOHLG��GDW�]LFK�JDDW�ULFKWHQ�RS�GH�UDDNYODNNHQ�WXVVHQ�GH�**=�VHFWRUHQ� DQGHUH� ]RUJVHFWRUHQ�� RUJDQLVDWLHV� YDQ� PDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH� GLHQVWYHUOHQLQJ� HQ� ORNDOHRYHUKHGHQ� HQ� RS� HHQ� QDGHUH� DQDO\VH� YDQ� GH� IDFWRUHQ� GLH� JHHVWHOLMNH� RQWVSRULQJHQYHURRU]DNHQ� HQ� YDQ� GH� PRJHOLMNKHGHQ� RP� GLH� WH� YRRUNyPHQ�� 'DDUELM� ZRUGHQ� GHYROJHQGH�VSHHUSXQWHQ�JHQRHPG�� ,QVWHOOLQJ� YDQ� HHQ� EUHGH� PDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH� FRPPLVVLH� �/DQGHOLMNH� &RPPLVVLH*HHVWHOLMNH�9RONVJH]RQGKHLG��GLH�HHQ�DQDO\VH�]DO�XLWYRHUHQ�YDQ�GH�RRU]DNHQ�YDQ�GHJURHLHQGH� KXOSYUDDJ� DOVPHGH� ]DO� DGYLVHUHQ� KRH� NDQ� ZRUGHQ� ELMJHGUDJHQ� DDQ� GHYHUEHWHULQJ�YDQ�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�YRONVJH]RQGKHLG�� 9HUVWHUNLQJ�YDQ�GH� UHJLHIXQFWLH�� HHQ�YHUVWHUNLQJ�YDQ�GH�DIVWHPPLQJ�HQ�SULRULWHULQJYDQ SUHYHQWLH�� 9HUVWHUNLQJ� YDQ� IDFHWEHOHLG�� HHQ� EUHHG� GUDDJYODN� HQ� LQWHJUDOH� DDQGDFKW� LV� HHQQRRG]DDN�YRRU�VXFFHVYROOH�SUHYHQWLH�� 2RUPHUNLQJ� SUHYHQWLH� LQ� EXGJHWWHQ�� EHWHUH� YHUDQNHULQJ� YDQ� SUHYHQWLH� LQRUJDQLVDWRULVFK�HQ�ILQDQFLHHO�RS]LFKW�� .HQQLVRQWZLNNHOLQJ��GLW�LV�HHQ�RQGHUGHHO�YDQ�KHW�DOJHPHQH�3UHYHQWLH�3URJUDPPD�ELM=21�� ,PSOHPHQWDWLH�YDQ�NHQQLV��RS]HWWHQ�YDQ�HHQ�LPSOHPHQWDWLH��HQ�HYDOXDWLHWUDMHFW�YRRUHIIHFWLHI�JHEOHNHQ�SURJUDPPD¶V�� 9HUVWHUNHQ�NLQGHU��HQ� MHXJGSV\FKLDWULH�� JRHGH�RQGHUNHQQLQJ� HQ� WLMGLJH�EHKDQGHOLQJYDQ VWRRUQLVVHQ�RS�MHXJGLJH�OHHIWLMG��9:6��������,Q�HHQ�EULHI�DDQ�GH�7ZHHGH�.DPHU�LV�WRHJH]HJG�GDW�GH�LQPLGGHOV�LQJHVWHOGH�/DQGHOLMNH&RPPLVVLH� *HHVWHOLMNH� 9RONVJH]RQGKHLG� LQ� ����� ]DO� UDSSRUWHUHQ� HQ� GDW� DDQVOXLWHQGGDDURS� ODQGHOLMNH� SULRULWHLWHQ� YRRU� SUHYHQWLH� HQ� RQGHU]RHN�ZRUGHQ� YDVWJHVWHOG� �9:6������� %RYHQJHQRHPGH� VSHHUSXQWHQ� ZRUGHQ� TXD� EHODQJ� RQGHUERXZG� GRRU� GHEHYLQGLQJHQ�� ]RDOV� RSJHQRPHQ� LQ� GH� VWDWH�RI�WKH�DUW� UDSSRUWDJHV� LQ� GHHO� %� YDQ� GLWUDSSRUW��'LW� JHOGW� ELMYRRUEHHOG� YRRU� GH� YUDDJ� RP�H[WUD� DDQGDFKW� YRRU� YURHJWLMGLJH� HQDGHTXDWH� EHKDQGHOLQJ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ELM� NLQGHUHQ� HQ� DGROHVFHQWHQ�� ]RGDWHHQ� KDOW� NDQ� ZRUGHQ� WRHJHURHSHQ� DDQ� GH� F\FOXV� ZDDULQ� JHYROJHQ� YDQ� HHQ� µHHUGHUHSV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLV¶� GH� RRU]DNHQ� �GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� ZRUGHQ� YDQ� QLHXZH� SUREOHPHQ�'DDUQDDVW� OHYHUHQ� GH]H� UDSSRUWDJHV� QRJ� HHQ� DDQWDO� DDQNQRSLQJVSXQWHQ� RS� YRRU� KHWEHOHLG��'H]H�ZRUGHQ�LQ�KHW�YROJHQGH�KRRIGVWXN�VDPHQJHYDW�

Page 32: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

� $DQNQRSLQJVSXQWHQ�YRRU�EHOHLG��� 2QGHU]RHN�QDDU�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ0RPHQWHHO�ZRUGW�QRJ�JHHQ����YDQ�KHW�RQGHU]RHNVEXGJHW�YDQ�GH�PHGLVFKH�IDFXOWHLWHQLQ 1HGHUODQG� EHVWHHG� DDQ� RQGHU]RHN� QDDU� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� �5*2�� ������� (HQLQWHQVLYHULQJ� HQ� WHYHQV� SULRULWHULQJ� YDQ� GH� PLGGHOHQ� LV� GDQ� RRN� HHQ� QRRG]DNHOLMNHYRRUZDDUGH� RP� HHQ� VWDS� YRRUXLW� WH�PDNHQ� LQ� KHW�**=�RQGHU]RHN��'DDUELM�PRHW�PHQ]LFK� UHDOLVHUHQ� GDW� KHW� KLHUELM� ]DO� JDDQ� RP� ODQJGXULJH� LQVSDQQLQJHQ� RP� GHNHQQLVDFKWHUVWDQG�WHQ�RS]LFKWH�YDQ�GH�VRPDWLVFKH�DDQGRHQLQJHQ�HQLJV]LQV�WH�GLFKWHQ�

�8LW� GH� OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH� YDQ� 2UPHO� NRPW� QDDU� YRUHQ� GDW� PHHU� VROLGH� HQJHNZDQWLILFHHUGH� LQIRUPDWLH� RYHU� GH� ELMGUDJH� YDQ� LQGLYLGXHOH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� DDQSV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG� QRGLJ� LV��*URWHU� LV� HFKWHU� QRJ� GH� EHKRHIWH� DDQ�PHHU� NHQQLVRYHU� GH� RQGHUOLQJH� UHODWLHV� WXVVHQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� LQ� GH� HWLRORJLH� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ��(HQ�EHODQJULMNH�DQGHUH�YUDDJ�LV�LQ�KRHYHUUH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�FOXVWHUHQ�RPGDW�]LMHONDDUV�YyyUNRPHQ�EHwQYORHGHQ��yIZHO�RPGDW�]LM�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�JHPHHQ�KHEEHQ��9DQ� JURRW� EHODQJ� YRRU� GH� WRHNRPVW� LV� GDQ� RRN� KHW� JHEUXLN� YDQ� ORQJLWXGLQDOHRQGHU]RHNVGHVLJQV��GLH�FDXVDOH�NHWHQV�NXQQHQ�LGHQWLILFHUHQ�HQ�ZDDULQ�RRN�GH�UHODWLHV�HQLQWHUDFWLH� WXVVHQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� LQ� YROGRHQGH� GHWDLO� WH� EHVWXGHUHQ� ]LMQ�� 'DDUQDDVW� LVIXQGDPHQWHHO�QHXURELRORJLVFK�RQGHU]RHN�YDQ�EHODQJ��]RGDW�PHHU�EHNHQG�ZRUGW�RYHU�GHDFKWHUJURQGHQ� YDQ� V\PSWRPHQ� DOV� GHSUHVVLHYH� VWHPPLQJ� HQ� SDQLVFKH� DQJVW�� RI� YDQWHPSHUDPHQWHQ�DOV�JHUHPGKHLG�HQ� LPSXOVLYLWHLW��0HHU� LQ]LFKW� LQ�GH]H�PDWHULH�NDQ�HHQEHODQJULMNH� ELMGUDJH� OHYHUHQ� DDQ� GH� YHUEHWHULQJ� YDQ� GH� GLDJQRVWLHN� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�ELHGW�QLHXZH�LQ]LFKWHQ�LQ�GH�PRJHOLMNKHGHQ�YRRU�SUHYHQWLH�

���� 2QGHU]RHN�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV9HHO�YDQ�GH�EHVSURNHQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�]LMQ�PRHLOLMN�WH�EHwQYORHGHQ��'LW�KHHIW�RQGHUPHHUWH PDNHQ�PHW�GH�EHSHUNWH�PDDNEDDUKHLG�YDQ�GH�PDDWVFKDSSLM�HQ�KHW�LQGLYLGXHOH�OHYHQ�GHQN�DDQ� DUPRHGH�� ODJH�6(6��XUEDQLVDWLHJUDDG�� FRPSOLFDWLHV� ELM� GH� JHERRUWH��� RI�PHWHWKLVFKH� RQWRHODDWEDDUKHLG� �ELMYRRUEHHOG� JHGZRQJHQ� VWHULOLVDWLH� YDQ� HUIHOLMN� ]ZDDUEHODVWH�SHUVRQHQ��9DQZHJH�KXQ�JURWH�YHURQGHUVWHOGH�ELMGUDJH� DDQ�GH�SV\FKLVFKH�]LHNWHODVW� LV�KHWDDQ�WH�EHYHOHQ�KHW�HIIHFWRQGHU]RHN�VSHFLILHN�WH�ULFKWHQ�RS�PRPHQWHHO�EHNHQGH�JHQHULHNHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� ]RDOV� JHUHPGKHLG�QHXURWLFLVPH�� LPSXOVLYLWHLW�� FRJQLWLHYH� HQ� VRFLDDO�FRPPXQLFDWLHYH�EHSHUNLQJHQ�HQ�WUDXPDWLVFKH�HUYDULQJHQ�LQ�GH�MHXJG��%LM�SUHYHQWLH�YDOWGDQ� YRRUDO� WH� GHQNHQ� DDQ� KHW� FRPSHQVHUHQ� YDQ� WHNRUWHQ� LQ� FRJQLWLHYH� HQFRPPXQLFDWLHYH�YDDUGLJKHGHQ�HQ�KHW�OHUHQ�RPJDDQ�PHW�VWUHVVYROOH�VLWXDWLHV��6SHFLILHNHDDQGDFKW�ZRUGW�JHYUDDJG�YRRU�SUHYHQWLH�ELM�NLQGHUHQ�HQ�DGROHVFHQWHQ�ZDDUELM�VSUDNH�LVYDQ� HHQ� FRPELQDWLH� YDQ� ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ� �RXGHUV� PHW� HHQ� SV\FKLDWULVFKH� FDUULqUH� HQ�RILQDGHTXDWH�RXGHUOLMNH�]RUJ��ODJH�6(6��OHYHQG�LQ�YHUVWHGHOLMNWH�RPJHYLQJ���=RDOV�HOGHUVLV EHVFKUHYHQ� NDQ� PHW� HIIHFWLHYH� SUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V� ELM� GH]H� GRHOJURHS� HHQDDQ]LHQOLMNH� JH]RQGKHLGVZLQVW� EHKDDOG� ZRUGHQ�� 7HQ� VORWWH� LV� DDQGDFKW� YRRU� YURHJHRSVSRULQJ�HQ�EHKDQGHOLQJ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�ELM�NLQGHUHQ�HQ�DGROHVFHQWHQ�YDQJURRW EHODQJ��+LHUPHH�NDQ�QDPHOLMN�GH�YLFLHX]H�FLUNHO�ZRUGHQ�GRRUEURNHQ�ZDDUELM�GH

Page 33: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

JHYROJHQ�YDQ� HHQ� µHHUGHUH� VWRRUQLV¶�ZHHU�RRU]DNHQ� �GHWHUPLQDQWHQ��YDQ� HHQ�YROJHQGHVWRRUQLV�ZRUGHQ�'H� UDSSRUWDJH� YDQ� KHW� 7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW� RYHU� HIIHFWHQ� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� PDDNWGXLGHOLMN�GDW� HU� HHQ� DDQ]LHQOLMN� WHNRUW� DDQ� LQIRUPDWLH� EHVWDDW� RYHU� GH� GRHOWUHIIHQGKHLGYDQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� ELM� KHW� GDDGZHUNHOLMN� YRRUNyPHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ�� *HGHJHQ� HYDOXDWLH�RQGHU]RHN� ]RX� GDQ� RRN� HHQ� KRJH� SULRULWHLW� PRHWHQNULMJHQ�� ,Q� KHW� =21� 3URJUDPPD� 3UHYHQWLH� ���������� ZRUGW� HIIHFWLYLWHLWV�� HQGRHOPDWLJKHLGVRQGHU]RHN� ELQQHQ� GH� **=� GDQ� RRN� DOV� ppQ� YDQ� GH� ]ZDDUWHSXQWHQDDQJHPHUNW��'DDUELM�ZRUGW�PHW�QDPH�DDQJHGURQJHQ�RS�KHW�JHEUXLN�YDQ�GHVLJQV�GLH�GHPHHVW YDOLGH� RQGHU]RHNV�XLWNRPVWHQ� RSOHYHUHQ�� GH� UDQGRPL]HG� FRQWUROOHG� WULDO� HQ� GHFRPPXQLW\� LQWHUYHQWLRQ� WULDO� �ZDDUQHPLQJHQ� RS� UHVSHFWLHYHOLMN� LQGLYLGXHHO� HQJURHSVQLYHDX���=21��������

��� $DQEHYHOLQJHQ�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQ�GH�LPSOHPHQWDWLH�YDQHIIHFWLHI�JHEOHNHQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV,Q� GH� GHHOUDSSRUWDJH� RYHU� HIIHFWHQ� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� YDQ� KHW� 7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW�ZRUGHQHQNHOH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHYRQGHQ�ZDDUYDQ�GH�GRHOWUHIIHQGKHLG�YROGRHQGH� OLMNW� DDQJHWRRQGRP RYHU� WH� JDDQ� WRW� ODQGHOLMNH� LPSOHPHQWDWLH�� 6FKRROJHULFKWH� YHUVODYLQJVSUHYHQWLH� LVGRHOWUHIIHQG�HQ�DO�HQLJH�MDUHQ�ZRUGW�YDQXLW�KHW�7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW�JHZHUNW�DDQ�ODQGHOLMNHLPSOHPHQWDWLH�YDQ�HHQ�JHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUG�SURJUDPPD��*H]RQGH�VFKRRO�HQ�JHQRWPLGGH�OHQ� GDW�QDDVW�YRRUOLFKWLQJ�RRN�UHJOHPHQWHULQJ�HQ�GHVNXQGLJKHLGV�EHYRUGHULQJ�RPYDW�2RN�VHFXQGDLUH�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�ELM�RXGHUHQ�LV�GRHOWUHIIHQG�HQ�HU�ZRUGWUHHGV JHZHUNW�DDQ� ODQGHOLMNH� LPSOHPHQWDWLH�YDQ�GH�FXUVXVVHQ�µ2PJDDQ�PHW�GHSUHVVLH¶YRRU RXGHUHQ�� 9HUGHU� OLMNW� KHW� GXLGHOLMN� GDW� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHULFKW� RS� IDPLOLHOHGHQ� YDQSV\FKLDWULVFKH� SDWLsQWHQ� HIIHFWLHI� ]LMQ�� 2RN� GH]H� LQWHUYHQWLHV� OLMNHQ� JHUHHG� YRRULPSOHPHQWDWLH�� YRRUDO� RRN� RPGDW� XLW� GLYHUVH� DQGHUH� RQGHU]RHNHQ� LV� JHEOHNHQ� GDWGHUJHOLMNH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�HYHQHHQV�WHUXJYDO�YDQ�GH�SDWLsQW�NXQQHQ�YRRUNyPHQ�� (U� LV� QRJ� ZHLQLJ� EHNHQG� � RYHU� ZHONH� LPSOHPHQWDWLHVWUDWHJLHsQ� ELQQHQ� KHWSUHYHQWLHYHOG� KHW� PHHVW� HIIHFWLHI� ]LMQ�� 7RW� RS� KHGHQ� ZRUGW� GH� NHX]H� YRRUSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V� VWHUN� UHJLRQDDO� EHSDDOG�� 'DDUGRRU� EHVWDDW� HU� HHQ� YHHOKHLG� DDQSURJUDPPD¶V�HQ�]LMQ�HU�JHHQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GLH�RYHUDO�ZRUGHQ�XLWJHYRHUG��+HW�LV�GDQ�RRNYDQ EHODQJ�RP�VWUDWHJLHsQ�YRRU�ODQGHOLMNH�LPSOHPHQWDWLH�YDQ�HIIHFWLHYH�SURJUDPPD¶V�WHRQWZLNNHOHQ�HQ�RQGHU]RHN�RS�GLW�WHUUHLQ�WH�VWLPXOHUHQ��=21�NDQ�KLHUELM�HHQ�EHODQJULMNHLQLWLsUHQGH� URO� YHUYXOOHQ�� 7RW� RS� KHGHQ� LV� HU� RS� KHW� WHUUHLQ� YDQ� GH� SUHYHQWLH� YDQSV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�QRJ�QDXZHOLMNV�LPSOHPHQWDWLH�RQGHU]RHN�YHUULFKW����� 9HUDQWZRRUGHOLMNKHGHQ�LQ�SUHYHQWLH�,Q�KHW�RQWZLNNHOLQJVSODQ�SUHYHQWLH�JHHVWHOLMNH�YRONVJH]RQGKHLG�HQ�YHUVODYLQJHQ�µ+LQN�6WDS�6SURQJ¶� �'HNNHU�� ������� GDW� LV� VDPHQJHVWHOG� RS� YHU]RHN� YDQ� KHW�0LQLVWHULH� YDQ9:6�]LMQ�HHQ�DDQWDO�DDQEHYHOLQJHQ�JHGDDQ�RYHU�YHUDQWZRRUGHOLMNKHGHQ�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQSUHYHQWLH� RS� KHW� JHELHG� YDQ� GH� JHHVWHOLMNH� YRONVJH]RQGKHLG��'H]H� DDQEHYHOLQJHQ� ]LMQ

Page 34: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

EHVSURNHQ�WLMGHQV�HHQ�,QYLWDWLRQDO�&RQIHUHQFH�� 'H�DOJHPHQH�RSYDWWLQJ�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQKHW SUHYHQWLHEHOHLG�LV�GDW�GH�ODQGHOLMNH�RYHUKHLG�WH�YHU�LV�GRRUJHVFKRWHQ�LQ�GH�GHOHJDWLHYDQ KDDU�YHUDQWZRRUGHOLMNKHLG��(U�]XOOHQ�ODQGHOLMN�JHOGHQGH�SULRULWHLWHQ�YRRU�SUHYHQWLHPRHWHQ� ZRUGHQ� YDVWJHVWHOG�� JHEUXLNPDNHQG� YDQ� FULWHULD� GLH� XLWJDDQ� YDQ� RPYDQJ� HQHUQVW�YDQ�KHW�JH]RQGKHLGVSUREOHHP��'H�ODQGHOLMN�XLWJHVWLSSHOGH�SUHYHQWLHVWUDWHJLH�PRHWRQGHUVWHXQHQG�]LMQ�HQ�UXLPWH�ELHGHQ�RP�RS�UHJLRQDDO�ORNDDO�QLYHDX���UHNHQLQJ�KRXGHQGPHW�GH�DDQZH]LJH�FXOWXXU��PDFKWVYHUKRXGLQJHQ��RSJHERXZGH�HUYDULQJ�HWF����]HOIVWDQGLJGRHOJURHSHQ��PHWKRGHQ�HQ�XLWYRHULQJ�WH�EHSDOHQ��'LW�DOOHV�ELQQHQ�ODQGHOLMN�YDVWJHVWHOGHNDGHUV HQ� ULFKWOLMQHQ�� :DDU� KHW� JDDW� RP� SULRULWHULQJ� RS� EDVLV� YDQ� HIIHFWLYLWHLW�WRHSDVEDDUKHLG� HQ� LPSOHPHQWDWLH� LV� HHQ� EHODQJULMNH� URO� ZHJJHOHJG� YRRU� =21�DDQJH]LHQ�GLW�QRJ�YHHO�RQGHU]RHN��HQ�RQWZLNNHOLQJVZHUN�YHUHLVW�� 9RRU�KHW�UHDOLVHUHQ�YDQ�GH�WH�EHKDOHQ�JH]RQGKHLGVZLQVW�LQ�GH�HHUVWHOLMQ�]XOOHQ�GHQRRG]DNHOLMNH�FRQGLWLHV��TXD�RQGHUVWHXQLQJ�HQ�ILQDQFLHULQJ��PRHWHQ�ZRUGHQ�JHVFKDSHQ�,Q�KHW�ERYHQJHQRHPGH�RQWZLNNHOLQJVSODQ�µ+LQN�6WDS�6SURQJ¶�LV�YRRUJHVWHOG�RP�HQNHOHH[SHULPHQWHQ�PHW�GH�LQYRHULQJ�YDQ�VHFXQGDLUH�SUHYHQWLH�LQ�GH�KXLVDUWVSUDNWLMN�WH�VWDUWHQPHW�EHWUHNNLQJ�WRW�GHSUHVVLHV��DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�DOFRKRODIKDQNHOLMNKHLG�� 7HQVORWWH� ZRUGW� KHW� EHODQJ� RQGHUVFKUHYHQ� YDQ� HHQ� YHUVWHUNLQJ� YDQ� KHWIDFHWEHOHLG� 2RN� GH� YRRUOLJJHQGH� UDSSRUWDJH� RQGHUVWUHHSW� GDW� YHHO� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG� EXLWHQ� KHW� GLUHFWH� WHUUHLQ� OLJJHQ� YDQ� GH� **=�� ELMYRRUEHHOGZHUNVWUHVV��PDWH�YDQ�YHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ��RQYHLOLJKHLG�RS�VWUDDW��JHEUHNNLJH�ZRRQRPJHYLQJ�NLQGHUPLVKDQGHOLQJ��ZHUNORRVKHLG��DUPRHGH�HQ�HHQ]DDPKHLG��9RRU�HHQ�JRHGH�LQYXOOLQJYDQ KDDU�PLVVLH�LV�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ�PHGH�DIKDQNHOLMN�YDQ�DQGHUH�VHFWRUHQ]RDOV� GH� YHUVODYLQJV]RUJ�� PDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH� RSYDQJ�� ]RUJ� YRRU� YHUVWDQGHOLMNHJHKDQGLFDSWHQ�� MHXJG]RUJ�� MXVWLWLsOH� ]RUJ�� HQ� YDQ� LQVWHOOLQJHQ� DOV� ZRQLQJ�ERXZFRUSRUWDWLHV�� VRFLDDO�FXOWXUHHO� ZHUN�� RQGHUZLMV�� DUEHLGVYRRU]LHQLQJHQ�PDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH� GLHQVWYHUOHQLQJ� HQ� JHPHHQWHQ� �2**=��� )DFHWEHOHLG� ZRUGW� KHW� EHVWRPVFKUHYHQ�DOV�µJH]RQGKHLGVEHYRUGHULQJ�GRRU�LQWHUVHFWRUDDO�EHOHLG¶��EHQDGUXNNHQG�GDWKHW QLHW�DOOHHQ�RP�RYHUKHLGVEHOHLG�JDDW��0HQ�VSUHHNW�LQ�GLW�NDGHU�RRN�ZHO�YDQ�µKHDOWK\SXEOLF� SROLF\¶��+HW�0LQLVWHULH� YDQ�9:6�]DO� KLHUELM� HHQ� DFWLHYH� URO�PRHWHQ� YHUYXOOHQ�'DW� JHOGW� ELMYRRUEHHOG� WHQ� DDQ]LHQ� YDQ� GH� YHUGHUH� RQWZLNNHOLQJ� YDQ� GH� JH]RQGKHLGV�HIIHFWVFUHHQLQJ� �*(6���PDDU� RRN� ELM� KHW� RS� GH� DJHQGD� NULMJHQ� YDQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�ELM�DQGHUH�PLQLVWHULHV����� 6ORWRSPHUNLQJ�'H� LQ�KRRIGVWXN� �� JHSUHVHQWHHUGH� JHJHYHQV� RYHU� GH� RPYDQJ� YDQ� KHW� SUREOHHP� HQ� GHLQ]LFKWHQ�LQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�ODWHQ�]LHQ�GDW�GH�SRWHQWLHHO�WHEHKDOHQ�JH]RQGKHLGVZLQVW�RS�KHW�WHUUHLQ�YDQ�GH�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�HQRUP�JURRWLV� 0DDU� WHJHOLMNHUWLMG�PDNHQ�GH� WZHH�VWDWH�RI�WKH�DUW� VWXGLHV�GXLGHOLMN�GDW� HU�QRJ�KHHOZDW RQGHU]RHN�YHUHLVW�LV�RP�GH�KXLGLJH�JURYH�DDQNQRSLQJVSXQWHQ�YRRU��SULRULWHLWHQ�LQ�SUHYHQWLH� WH� YHUILMQHQ�� YHUYROJHQV� HIIHFWLHYH� SURJUDPPD¶V� WH� RQWZLNNHOHQ� YRRUYHUVFKLOOHQGH�GRHOJURHSHQ�HQ�RI�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�WHQVORWWH�]RUJ�WH�GUDJHQ�YRRU�HHQ�JRHGHLPSOHPHQWDWLH� HQ� HYDOXDWLH�� 1DDVW� RQGHU]RHN� YHUHLVW� GLW� RRN� HHQ� JHFR|UGLQHHUGHSULRULWHLWHQVWHOOLQJ� HQ� HHQ� EUHGHUH� �ODQGHOLMNH�� DDQVWXULQJ� YDQ� GH� RQWZLNNHOLQJ� HQ

� *HRUJDQLVHHUG�GRRU�KHW�7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW�HQ�KHW�1HGHUODQGV�,QVWLWXXW�YRRU�*H]RQGKHLGVEHYRUGHULQJ�HQ=LHNWHSUHYHQWLH�RS���VHSWHPEHU������

Page 35: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�$ ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

XLWYRHULQJ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH��]RDOV�RRN�LQ�KHW�HHUVWH�EUDQFKHUDSSRUW�**=��**=�1HGHUODQG�������ZRUGW�JHFRQFOXGHHUG��.RUWRP�� HU� LV� QRJ� HHQ� ODQJH� ZHJ� WH� JDDQ� LQ� KHW� RQGHU]RHN� HQ� GH� SUHYHQWLH�� +HWRQWJLQQHQ�YDQ�GLW�WHUUHLQ�PDJ�RQV�LQ]LHQV�WRW�ppQ�YDQ�GH�EHODQJULMNVWH�XLWGDJLQJHQ�YDQKHW�YRONVJH]RQGKHLGVRQGHU]RHN�HQ��EHOHLG�YRRU�GH���H�HHXZ�ZRUGHQ�JHUHNHQG�

Page 36: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�$

/LWHUDWXXU$3$��'LDJQRVWLF�DQG�6WDWLVWLFDO�0DQXDO�RI�0HQWDO�'LVRUGHUV��)RXUWK�HGLWLRQ��:DVKLQJWRQ��'&��$PHULFDQ3V\FKLDWULF�$VVRFLDWLRQ�������'HNNHU�(��+LQN�VWDS�VSURQJ��2QWZLNNHOLQJVSODQ�SUHYHQWLH�JHHVWHOLMNH�YRONVJH]RQGKHLG�HQ�YHUVODYLQJHQ�'HQ�+DDJ�������%LMO�5��=HVVHQ�*�YDQ��5DYHOOL�$��3V\FKLDWULVFKH�PRUELGLWHLW�LQ�1HGHUODQG���KHW�1(0(6,6�RQGHU]RHN��,,�3UHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��1HG�7LMGVFKU�*HQHHVNG����������������������'RQNHU�0&+��:LOGH�*:00�GH��2UJDQLVDWLH��EHOHLG�HQ�NRVWHQ�YDQ�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ��,Q�-RQJ�$�GH��%ULQN�:�YDQ�GHQ��2UPHO�-��:LHUVPD�'��UHG����+DQGERHN�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�HSLGHPLRORJLH�0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�'H�7LMGVWURRP��������SS����������*DJHOGRQN�$�YDQ��5LJWHU�+��3UHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�HQ�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ��HHQ�EHNQRSW�RYHU]LFKW�YDQGH�VWDQG�YDQ�ZHWHQVFKDS��'HQ�+DDJ��=RUJ2QGHU]RHN�1HGHUODQG�������**=�1HGHUODQG��%UDQFKHUDSSRUW�*HHVWHOLMNH�*H]RQGKHLGV]RUJ������������1DDU�HHQ�WUDQVSDUDQWH�**=�8WUHFKW��**=�1HGHUODQG�������+RVPDQ�&0+��,QYHVWHUHQ�LQ�2**=�SUHYHQWLH��KDQGHO�LQ�HIIHFWHQ��7LMGVFKU�*H]RQGKHLGVEHYRUGHULQJ����������������+RVPDQ�&0+��*HHOHQ�.5-��3UHYHQWLHYH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ��KLVWRULH��RQWZLNNHOLQJHQ�HQHIIHFWLYLWHLW��,Q��+XWVFKHPDHDNHUV�*-0��+RVPDQ�&0+��/LHVKRXW�YDQ�3$+��UHG����*HHVWHOLMNHYRONVJH]RQGKHLG��JHVFKLHGHQLV�YDQ�KHW�GHQNHQ�HQ�VWDQG�YDQ�GLVFXVVLH��������SS����������-RQJ�$�GH��%ULQN�:�YDQ�GHQ��2UPHO�-��:LHUVPD�'��HGV����+DQGERHN�3V\FKLDWULVFKH�(SLGHPLRORJLH�0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�'H�7LMGVWURRP�������1,0+��1DWLRQDO�$GYLVRU\�0HQWDO�+HDOWK�&RXQFLO�:RUNJURXS�RQ�0HQWDO�'LVRUGHUV�3UHYHQWLRQ�5HVHDUFK�3ULRULWLHV�IRU�SUHYHQWLRQ�UHVHDUFK�DW�1,0+��%HWKHVGD��1DWLRQDO�,QVWLWXWH�RI�0HQWDO�+HDOWK�������2HUV�-$0�YDQ��UHG����'HILQLWLH�YRRU�GH�RS]HW�YDQ�GH�VWXGLH�9RONVJH]RQGKHLG�7RHNRPVW�9HUNHQQLQJ������5DSSRUWQR�������������%LOWKRYHQ��5,90�������3HQQLQ[�%:-+��*HHUOLQJV�6:��'HHJ�'-+��(LMN�-70�YDQ��7LOEXUJ�:�YDQ��%HHNPDQ�$7)��0LQRU�DQGPDMRU�GHSUHVVLRQ�DQG�WKH�ULVN�RI�GHDWK�LQ�ROGHU�SHUVRQV��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������3ROGHU�--��0HHUGLQJ�:-��.RRSPDQVFKDS�0$��%RQQHX[�/��6WRN[�/-��YDQ�GHU�0DDV�3-��.RVWHQ�YDQ�]LHNWHQELQQHQ�GH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ��,Q��3RVW�'��6WRN[�/-��HLQGUHG���9RONVJH]RQGKHLG�7RHNRPVW�9HUNHQQLQJ������9,��=RUJEHKRHIWH�HQ�]RUJJHEUXLN��0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�GH�7LMGVWURRP��������SS��������59=��*HHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ�LQ�GH���H�HHXZ��$FKWHUJURQGVWXGLHV��=RHWHUPHHU��5DDG�YRRU�GH9RONVJH]RQGKHLG��=RUJ�������5XZDDUG�'��.UDPHUV�3*1��HLQGUHG����9RONVJH]RQGKHLG�7RHNRPVW�9HUNHQQLQJ�������'H�VRP�GHU�GHOHQ�0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�GH�7LMGVWURRP�������6PXOGHUV�3*:��=LHNWHYHU]XLP�HQ�DUEHLGVRQJHVFKLNWKHLG����,Q��0DDV�,$0��*LMVHQ�5��/REEH]RR�,(��3RRV0--&���HLQGUHG���9RONVJH]RQGKHLG�7RHNRPVW�9HUNHQQLQJ�������,��=RUJEHKRHIWH�HQ�]RUJJHEUXLN�0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�GH�7LMGVWURRP��������SS����������9:6��1RWD�*H]RQG�HQ�:HO��7ZHHGH�.DPHU��YHUJDGHUMDDU�������������������QU����'HQ�+DDJ��6GX8LWJHYHULM�������9:6��%HOHLGVYLVLH�*HHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ��7ZHHGH�.DPHU��YHUJDGHUMDDU�������������������QU���'HQ�+DDJ��6GX�8LWJHYHULM�������9:6��2SHQEDUH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ��7ZHHGH�.DPHU��YHUJDGHUMDDU�������������������QU�����'HQ�+DDJ��6GX8LWJHYHULM�������9:6��*HHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ��7ZHHGH�.DPHU��YHUJDGHUMDDU�������������������QU������'HQ�+DDJ�6GX�8LWJHYHULM�������=21��3URJUDPPD�3UHYHQWLH������������2QGHU]RHN�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�HQ�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ��'HQ+DDJ��=RUJ�2QGHU]RHN�1HGHUODQG�������

Page 37: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�% ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

'HHO�%���$FKWHUJURQGVWXGLHV

Page 38: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%

,QWURGXFWLH,Q� GHHO� $� YDQ� GLW� UDSSRUW� LV� UHHGV� DDQJHJHYHQ� GDW� GH]H� UDSSRUWDJH� RYHU� SV\FKLVFKHJH]RQGKHLG�]LFK�PHW�QDPH�ULFKW�RS�GH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG�HQRS PRJHOLMNKHGHQ�YRRU�HQ�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQ�GH]H�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�'H]H�RQGHUZHUSHQ�]LMQ�XLWJHZHUNW�DDQ�GH�KDQG�YDQ�VWDWH�RI�WKH�DUW� UDSSRUWHQ��GLH�]LMQRSJHVWHOG�GRRU�H[SHUWV�RS�GH]H�JHELHGHQ�LQ�1HGHUODQG��]LH�ELMODJH���� ,Q�GHHO�%�� LV�GHELMGUDJH� RSJHQRPHQ� YDQ� 2UPHO� HW� DO�� RYHU� GH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKHRQJH]RQGKHLG�� 'HHO� %�� EHKDQGHOW� KHW� HIIHFW� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� RS�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ��SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG��HQ�LV�RSJHVWHOG�GRRU�&XLMSHUV�HW�DO�,HGHU� VWDWH�RI�WKH�DUW� UDSSRUW� LV� WHU� FRPPHQWDDU� YRRUJHOHJG� DDQ� HHQ� DDQWDOUHIHUHQWHQ�XLW�GH�ZHWHQVFKDS�HQ�GH�SUDNWLMN��]LH�ELMODJH���� +XQ�FRPPHQWDDU�LV�YHUZHUNWLQ GH�ELMGUDJHQ��RI�LV�LQ�GH�GLVFXVVLH�YDQ�GHHO�$�YDQ�GLW�UDSSRUW�PHHJHQRPHQ�9RRU� EHLGH� UDSSRUWHQ� JHOGW� GDW� HHQ� DIEDNHQLQJ� YDQ� KHW� WHUUHLQ� KHHIWSODDWVJHYRQGHQ�RP�ELQQHQ�GH�JHVWHOGH�WHUPLMQ�WRW�HHQ�DIJHURQGH�UDSSRUWDJH�WH�NXQQHQNRPHQ� 'LW� EHWHNHQW� GDW� HU� JHHQ� YROOHGLJ� RYHU]LFKW� LV� JHJHYHQ� YDQ� GH� EHVFKLNEDUHNHQQLV� YDQ� GH� �HIIHFWHQ� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� RS�� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� DOOH� SV\FKLVFKHDDQGRHQLQJHQ�� 7HQ� DDQ]LHQ� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� ]LMQ� DDQ� KHW� HLQG� YDQ� GHHO� %� HHQ� DDQWDONDGHUWHNVWHQ�RSJHQRPHQ�PHW�EHYLQGLQJHQ��DINRPVWLJ�XLW�UHFHQWH�UDSSRUWDJHV�RS�DQGHUHGHHOWHUUHLQHQ�

Page 39: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

'HHO�%���'HWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG

-��2UPHO��-��1HHOHPDQ��'��:LHUVPD'LVFLSOLQHJURHS�3V\FKLDWULH��5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW�*URQLQJHQ

Page 40: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

� ,QOHLGLQJ3V\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG� YRUPW� HHQ� EHODQJULMN� YRONVJH]RQGKHLGSUREOHHP�� 'HYHUVFKLOOHQGH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�WHVDPHQ�]LMQ�YHUDQWZRRUGHOLMN�YRRU�HHQ�IOLQN�GHHOYDQ�GH� ]LHNWHODVW� LQ�GH�1HGHUODQGVH�EHYRONLQJ� HQ�GH� JHUHODWHHUGH�NRVWHQ� �5XZDDUG�.UDPHUV�� ������� 3UHYHQWLH� LV� YDQXLW� GLW� RRJSXQW� GDQ� RRN� ]HHU� UHOHYDQW�� (HQ� HHUVWHDDQNQRSLQJVSXQW� YRRU� SUHYHQWLH� YRUPHQ� GH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH�RQ�JH]RQGKHLG��'H�NHQQLV�KLHURYHU�YHUWRRQW�HFKWHU�QRJ�YHOH�ODFXQHV�HQ�EOLMIW�QRJ�DOWLMGYHU�DFKWHU�ELM�GLH�RYHU� �HHQ�DDQWDO��EHODQJULMNH� VRPDWLVFKH� ]LHNWHQ��7RFK�]LMQ� HU� LQ�GHDIJHORSHQ� MDUHQ� GH� QRGLJH� QLHXZH� LQ]LFKWHQ� YHUZRUYHQ�� 'H]H� UDSSRUWDJH� EHRRJW� HHQRYHU]LFKW�WH�JHYHQ��ZDDULQ�UHFHQW�EHVFKLNEDDU�JHNRPHQ�NHQQLV�LQ�ELQQHQ��HQ�EXLWHQODQGRYHU GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� �RQ�JH]RQGKHLG� LV� YHUZHUNW�� $FKWHUOLJJHQGHGRHOVWHOOLQJ� YDQ� GH]H� DQDO\VH� LV� KHW� OHYHUHQ� YDQ� DDQNQRSLQJVSXQWHQ� YRRU� KHW�SUHYHQWLH�EHOHLG�RS�KHW�WHUUHLQ�YDQ�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�YRONVJH]RQGKHLG�$DQJH]LHQ� GH� EHJULSSHQ� µSV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG¶� DOVPHGH� µGHWHUPLQDQWHQ¶YHHO�RPYDWWHQ��YLQGW�KLHU�HHUVW�HHQ�DIEDNHQLQJ�SODDWV��$OOHUHHUVW�JHYHQ�ZLM�HHQ�GHILQLWLHYDQ� KHW� EHJULS� µSV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG¶� ]RDOV� GLW� LQ� GH]H� UDSSRUWDJH� ]DO� ZRUGHQJHEUXLNW� �SDUDJUDDI� ����� 9HUYROJHQV� EHVFKULMYHQ� ZLM� KHW� GHWHUPLQDQWPRGHO� GDW� DOVXLWJDQJVSXQW� LV� JHQRPHQ� LQ� GH]H� UDSSRUWDJH� �SDUDJUDDI� ���� HQ� GH� GDDUXLWYRRUWYORHLHQGH� VHOHFWLH� YDQ� GHWHUPLQDQW�JURHS�HQ� �SDUDJUDDI� ������ 7RW� VORW� YROJW� HHQNRUWH EHVFKULMYLQJ�YDQ�GH�ZHUNZLM]H�ELM�KHW�XLWYRHUHQ�YDQ�GH�OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH��SDUDJUDDI�����

��� 3V\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG��GHILQLWLH�HQ�DIEDNHQLQJ3V\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�]LMQ�YRUPHQ�YDQ�DEQRUPDDO�JHGUDJ��ZDDUELM�GH�WHUP�JHGUDJ�EUHHGPRHW ZRUGHQ�RSJHYDW��QLHW� DOOHHQ�KHW�ZDDUQHHPEDUH�JHGUDJ�YDQ�PHQVHQ��PDDU�RRN�GHGRRU KHQ�JHUDSSRUWHHUGH�EHOHYLQJHQ��JHYRHOHQV�HQ�JHGDFKWHQ�EHKRUHQ�HUWRH��'H�-RQJ�HWDO��� ������� +HW� DEQRUPDOH� JHGUDJ� LV� KHW� JHYROJ� YDQ� RQWUHJHOLQJHQ� LQ� LHPDQGVSV\FKRORJLVFKH� IXQFWLHV�� ]RDOV� LQ� KHW� GHQNHQ�� GH� FRQFHQWUDWLH�� KHW� JHYRHOVOHYHQ�� GHPRWLYDWLH��GH�DJUHVVLHUHJXODWLH��GH�ZDDUQHPLQJ�HQ�KHW�OHUHQ��=RZHO�GH�SV\FKLDWULH�DOV�GHNOLQLVFKH� SV\FKRORJLH� EHVWXGHUHQ� GHUJHOLMNH� RQWUHJHOLQJHQ�� 'H� HHUVWH� KRXGW� ]LFK�GRRUJDDQV�YDQXLW� HHQ�PHGLVFK�SHUVSHFWLHI�� EH]LJ�PHW�GXLGHOLMNH� DIZLMNLQJHQ�YDQ�GH� LQGLDJQRVWLVFKH� FODVVLILFDWLHV\VWHPHQ� YDVWJHVWHOGH� QRUPHQ� �SV\FKLVFKH� µ]LHNWHQ¶��� 'HNOLQLVFKH�SV\FKRORJLH�KDQWHHUW�HHQ�SV\FKRORJLVFK�SHUVSHFWLHI�HQ�EHPRHLW�]LFK�RRN�PHHUPHW IOXFWXDWLHV�ELQQHQ�GH�QRUP��SV\FKLVFKH�NODFKWHQ�RI�SUREOHPDWLHN��� �+HW�YDVWVWHOOHQYDQ� GH]H� µQRUPHQ¶� ZRUGW� LQ� GH� SV\FKLDWULH� HFKWHU� HUQVWLJ� EHPRHLOLMNW� GRRU� GHDIZH]LJKHLG� YDQ� �NHQQLV� RYHU�� REMHFWLHYH� I\VLVFK�FKHPLVFKH� FULWHULD��'H� GLDJQRVWLVFKHFDWHJRULHsQ�� ZDDULQ� GH� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG� LQ� GH� ,QWHUQDWLRQDO� &ODVVLILFDWLRQ� RI'LVHDVHV� �,&'�� HQ� 'LDJQRVWLF� DQG� 6WDWLVWLFDO� PDQXDO� RI� 0HQWDO� GLVRUGHUV� �'60�� LVRSJHGHHOG�� EHWUHIIHQ� YDDN� �NDUDNWHULVWLHNH�� FOXVWHUV� YDQ� V\PSWRPHQ�� =LM� ]LMQ� QLHW� RIQDXZHOLMNV�JHEDVHHUG�RS�HWLRORJLVFKH�RYHUZHJLQJHQ�RI�I\VLVFK�FKHPLVFKH�FULWHULD��+HW�LVDDQQHPHOLMN�GDW�HU�HHQ�RYHUODS�EHVWDDW� WXVVHQ�GH�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�FDWHJRULHsQ�DOV�KHW� JDDWRP HWLRORJLH��QHXURELRORJLH�HQ�EHORRS�+HW� RQGHUVFKHLG� WXVVHQ� QRUPDDO� JHGUDJ� HQ� VWRRUQLV� HQ� WXVVHQ� VWRRUQLVVHQRQGHUOLQJ� LV� YDDN� ODVWLJ� WH� PDNHQ� �GH� RYHUJDQJHQ� ]LMQ� GRRUJDDQV� JHOHLGHOLMN��

Page 41: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

9HUVFKHLGHQH� DXWHXUV� KHEEHQ� GDDURP� EHWRRJG� GDW� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG� RRN� LQWHUPHQ YDQ� ppQ� HQNHOH� GLPHQVLH� GLH� GH� YDQ� PDWH� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLGZHHUJHHIW� EHVFKUHYHQ� NDQ�ZRUGHQ�� GH� HUQVW� GLPHQVLH� �9DQ� GHQ� %ULQN� � YDQ�<SHUHQ�������1HHOHPDQ���������$QGHUHQ�]LMQ�KHW�HHQV�PHW�HHQ�GLPHQVLRQDOH�EHQDGHULQJ�PDDUSOHLWHQ�YRRU�PHHUGHUH�GLPHQVLHV��ELMYRRUEHHOG�DQJVW�HQ�GHSUHVVLH��*ROGEHUJ�HW�DO�������2UPHO�HW�DO���������'LW�ZRUGW�ZHO�GH�]RJHQDDPGH�GLPHQVLRQHOH�EHQDGHULQJ�JHQRHPG�'H]H� UDSSRUWDJH� KDQWHHUW� ]RZHO� KHW� FDWHJRULDOH� DOV� KHW� GLPHQVLRQHOHJH]LFKWVSXQW�� +RRIGVWXN� �� EHKDQGHOW� GH� YROJHQGH� FDWHJRULHsQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ�� VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�� DQJVW�� HQ� VRPDWRIRUPH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� SV\FKRWLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ� �VFKL]RIUHQLH� HQ� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLV��� YHUVODYLQJHQ�� � YHHO� YRRUNRPHQGHSV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�ELM�NLQGHUHQ� HQ�DGROHVFHQWHQ�� HQ�]HOIGRGLQJ��2YHUZHJLQJHQ� WHQDDQ]LHQ� YDQ� SUHYDOHQWLH�� ]LHNWHODVW� HQ� NRVWHQ� YDQ� GH� ]RUJ� JDYHQ� ELM� GH]H� NHX]H� GHGRRUVODJ �5XZDDUG� � .UDPHUV�� ������� 'HPHQWLH� ZRUGW� KLHU� QLHW� EHKDQGHOG�� RRN� DOVFRRUW GH]H� ]LHNWH� KRRJ� RS� DOOH� GULH� FULWHULD�� %HKDOYH� UXLPWHJHEUHN� LV� HHQ� EHODQJULMNHUHGHQ GDW�GHPHQWLH�HHQ�DDQGRHQLQJ� LV�ZDDUYDQ�KHW�VRPDWLVFK�VXEVWUDDW� �GH�SDWKRORJLH�EHNHQG� LV�� 'LW� LQ� WHJHQVWHOOLQJ� WRW� GH� GRRU� RQV� JHVHOHFWHHUGH�� PHHU� IXQFWLRQHOH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��=HOIGRGLQJ� LV�RSJHQRPHQ�RPGDW�KHW�HHQ� UHODWLHI� JURRW� DDQGHHOKHHIW� LQ� KHW� WRWDDO� DDQ� YHUORUHQ� OHYHQVMDUHQ� LQ� GH� 1HGHUODQGVH� EHYRONLQJ��'LW� KHHIW� WHPDNHQ PHW�KHW�IHLW�GDW�VXwFLGH�ppQ�YDQ�GH�PHHVW�YyyUNRPHQGH�GRRGVRRU]DNHQ�RS�MRQJHOHHIWLMG�LV�$DQ�KHW�HLQG�YDQ�KRRIGVWXN���EHVFKULMYHQ�ZLM�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�RRN�QRJDDQ�GH�KDQG�YDQ�HQNHOH�]RJHQDDPGH�JHQHULHNH��QLHW�VWRRUQLV�VSHFLILHNH��PDWHQ�]RDOV�GHµ*HQHUDO� +HDOWK� 4XHVWLRQQDLUH¶� �*+4�� HQ� GH� µ3UHVHQW� 6WDWH� ([DPLQDWLRQ¶� �36(�SDUDJUDDI������ 2RN�NRPW�LQ�SDUDJUDDI�����KHW�RQGHUZHUS�FRPRUELGLWHLW�DDQ�GH�RUGH��'HDDQGDFKW� YRRU� GLW� RQGHUZHUS� YORHLW� HQHU]LMGV� YRRUW� XLW� KHW� IHLW� GDW� FRPRUELGLWHLW� HHQVWHUNH LQGLFDWRU� LV� YDQ� GH� HUQVW� HQ� GXXU� YDQ� GH� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�� $QGHU]LMGVRPGDW�FRPRUELGLWHLW�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�]R¶Q�YHHOYRRUNRPHQG�IHQRPHHQ�LV��2SGH]H�SODDWV�ZRUGW�GXV�DDQGDFKW�EHVWHHG�DDQ�GH�GLPHQVLRQHOH�EHQDGHULQJ�

��� +HW�'\QDPLVFKH�6WUHVV�.ZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO'HWHUPLQDQWHQ�]LMQ�IDFWRUHQ�GLH��GLUHFW�RI� LQGLUHFW��GH�SUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�RQJH]RQGKHLG� LQGH EHYRONLQJ� EHwQYORHGHQ�� ,Q� WHJHQVWHOOLQJ� WRW� ELMYHUVFKLMQVHOHQ� HQ� JHYROJHQ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ]LMQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� QLHW� DOOHHQ� PHW� GH� JH]RQGKHLGVWRHVWDQGJHDVVRFLHHUG��]H�JDDQ�HU�RRN�DDQ�YRRUDI�9RRU� KHW� EHVWXGHUHQ� YDQ� GH� ZLM]H� ZDDURS� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�EHwQYORHGHQ�]LMQ�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�PRGHOOHQ�LQ�JHEUXLN��'H�-RQJHW� DO��� ������� (HQ� YHHO� JHEUXLNW� HQ� JHDFFHSWHHUG� PRGHO� LV� KHW� G\QDPLVFKH� VWUHVV�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO��'6.�PRGHO��%URZQ��+DUULV��������&RKHQ�HW�DO���������'XQFDQ�-RQHV� HW� DO��� ������ )RONPDQ�� /D]DUXV�� ������*ROGEHUJ��+X[OH\�� ������ /D]DUXV�)RONPDQ�� ������0HHKO�� ������ 2UPHO�� ������ 2UPHO� � 6FKDXIHOL�� ������ 2UPHO� HW� DO��������������7\UHU��6WHLQEHUJ���������+HW�PRGHO�JHHIW�DDQ�µKRH¶��SHUVRRQ��RPJHYLQJ�HQJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� HONDDU� HQ� KHW� ULVLFR� RS� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�� EHwQYORHGHQ� �]LHILJXXU������

Page 42: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�REMHFWLHYH�NHQPHUNHQ��EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJ

� SHUFHSWLH�YDQ�YHUOLHV�GUHLJLQJ�HWF�

FRSLQJ

)LJXXU������+HW�'\QDPLVFKH�6WUHVV�.ZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO�+HW�PRGHO�NDQ�DOV�YROJW�EHVFKUHYHQ�ZRUGHQ��2UPHO��������2UPHO�HW�DO����������1HW�DOVELM YHHO�VRPDWLVFKH�YHUVFKLMQVHOHQ��]RDOV�EORHGGUXN�HQ� ORQJIXQFWLH��EHVWDDW�HU�HHQ�YRRUGH SHUVRRQ�QRUPDDO�QLYHDX�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG��JHNHQPHUNW�GRRU�RQGHUPHHU�KHWQLYHDX YDQ�DQJVWLJKHLG�� GHSUHVVLYLWHLW�� DQWLVRFLDOLWHLW� RI�ELMYRRUEHHOG�K\SHUDFWLYLWHLW�� ,QGH WLMG� ]LMQ� HU� IOXFWXDWLHV� URQGRP� GLW� JHPLGGHOGH� V\PSWRRPQLYHDX�� DOV� UHDFWLH� RSVLWXDWLHV�HQ�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ��'XQFDQ�-RQHV�HW�DO���������2UPHO��6FKDXIHOL���������2YHUODQJHUH� WLMG� JH]LHQ� JHGUDDJW� SV\FKLVFKH� �RQ�JH]RQGKHLG� ]LFK� GXV� PHHVWDO� DOV� HHQG\QDPLVFK�HYHQZLFKW�3HUVRQHQ� YHUVFKLOOHQ� QLHW� DOOHHQ� LQ� KXQ� QRUPDOH� QLYHDX� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKHJH]RQGKHLG�� PDDU� RRN� LQ� GH� PDWH� ZDDULQ� KHW� QLYHDX� IOXFWXHHUW� DOV� UHDFWLH� RSJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ��9HUVFKLOOHQ� LQ� V\PSWRRPQLYHDXV� WXVVHQ� SHUVRQHQ� ]LMQ� WRH� WH� VFKULMYHQDDQ� YHUVFKLOOHQ� LQ� KXQ� SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH� HQ� VRFLDOH� NHQPHUNHQ�� $QGHUV� JH]HJG�LHPDQGV QRUPDOH�V\PSWRRPQLYHDX�ZHHUVSLHJHOW�]LMQ�KDDU�SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH�HQ�VRFLDOHNZHWVEDDUKHLG� )OXFWXDWLHV� LQ� V\PSWRRPQLYHDXV�ELQQHQ� SHUVRQHQ� GDDUHQWHJHQ� ]LMQ� KHWJHYROJ�YDQ�QHJDWLHYH�HQ�SRVLWLHYH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�HQ�VLWXDWLHV��YHUGHU�VDPHQ�DDQJHJHYHQDOV�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�� +HW�]LMQ�PHW�QDPH�GH�VWUHVVYROOH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�GLH�ELM�NZHWVEDUHSHUVRQHQ�WRW�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�NXQQHQ�OHLGHQ��2UPHO�HW�DO��������� �

(UYDULQJHQ�HQ�JHGUDJ

3V\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG

3V\FKRELRORJLVFKH.ZHWVEDDUKHLG�(QGRJHQHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� JHQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGV�NHQPHUNHQ� VRPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ� SHULQDWDOH�SUREOHPHQ�OLFKDPHOLMNH�]LHNWHQ

6RFLDOH�RI�I\VLHNH.ZHWVEDDUKHLG�([RJHQHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� �FRQIOLFWXHX]H�JH]LQVVLWXDWLH� VRFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKHVWDWXV� YHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ� VRFLDOH�VWHXQ� I\VLHNH�IDFWRUHQ

RPJHYLQJV�FRQWUROH KDQGHOLQJV�

UXLPWH

72(9$/

Page 43: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

:pONH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� LHPDQG� PHHPDDNW�� ZRUGW� EHSDDOG� GRRU� ]LMQKDQGHOLQJVUXLPWH��RPJHYLQJVFRQWUROH� HQ�KHW�WRHYDO� +DQGHOLQJVUXLPWH�YHUZLMVW�QDDU�GHJUHQ]HQ� GLH� GH� VRFLDOH� HQ� I\VLHNH� RPJHYLQJ� �H[RJHQH� IDFWRUHQ�� KHP� RSOHJJHQ�2PJHYLQJVFRQWUROH�QDDU�]LMQ�YHUPRJHQ�RP��JHJHYHQ�HHQ�EHSDDOGH�KDQGHOLQJVUXLPWH��GHGRRU� KHP� JHZHQVWH� RPVWDQGLJKHGHQ� WH� UHDOLVHUHQ� HQ� RQJHZHQVWH� WH� YHUPLMGHQ��+HW� LVYHHOHHU� JHUHODWHHUG� DDQ� SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH� �HQGRJHQH�� IDFWRUHQ�� +DQGHOLQJVUXLPWH� HQRPJHYLQJVFRQWUROH� EHSDOHQ� WHVDPHQ� GH� PDWH� ZDDULQ� LHPDQG� ]LMQ� RPJHYLQJ� NDQVHOHFWHUHQ�HQ�YHUDQGHUHQ��%LMYRRUEHHOG��DUPH�PHQVHQ�KHEEHQ� LQ�YHUJHOLMNLQJ�PHW� ULMNHPHQVHQ�PLQGHU�KDQGHOLQJVUXLPWH��HQ�VRFLDDO�YDDUGLJH�PHQVHQ�PHHU�RPJHYLQJVFRQWUROHGDQ VRFLDDO�PLQGHU�YDDUGLJH�SHUVRQHQ���(HQ� UHODWLHI� JURWH KDQGHOLQJVUXLPWH� HQ� RPJHYLQJVFRQWUROH� EHWHNHQW� RYHULJHQVQLHW�GDW�GDQ�XLWVOXLWHQG�µULVLFROR]H¶�RPJHYLQJHQ�ZRUGHQ�JHVHOHFWHHUG�� ,HPDQG�NDQ�HHQYRRUNHXU� KHEEHQ� YRRU� RPJHYLQJHQ� GLH� HHQ� YHUKRRJGH� NDQV� RS� VWUHVVYROOHJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� PHW� ]LFK� PHHEUHQJHQ�� ]RDOV� VWUHVVYROOH� EDQHQ�� FULPLQHOH� YULHQGHQ� RILQVWDELHOH�SDUWQHUV�2I�VWUHVVYROOH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�YHUYROJHQV�WRW�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�OHLGHQ�KDQJWDI YDQ�� +XQ�NHQPHUNHQ�]RDOV�GH�DDUG��GXXU�HQ�PDWH�YDQ�VWUHVV�LQGXFHUHQG�YHUPRJHQ�� 'H�EHWHNHQLV�GLH�GH�EHWURNNHQH�HUDDQ�WRHNHQW��SURFHV�YDQ�EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJ��� +RH�KLM�RI�]LM�PHW�HUPHH�RPJDDW��FRSLQJ� �&RKHQ�HW�DO���������)RONPDQ��/D]DUXV�������/D]DUXV��)RONPDQ��������%HWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJ� LV� KHW� SODDWVHQ� YDQ� HHQ� JHEHXUWHQLV� LQ� UHODWLH� WRW� SHUVRRQOLMNHZDDUGHQ� HQ� EHKRHIWHQ�� 'DDUELM� LV� GH� LQVFKDWWLQJ� RI� GH� JHEHXUWHQLV� KHW� �WRHNRPVWLJH�ZHO]LMQ� EHGUHLJW� FUXFLDDO�� ,QGLHQ� GH]H� DOV� EHGUHLJHQG� ZRUGW� JH]LHQ�� GDQ� ZRUGWJHOLMNWLMGLJ� KHW� YHUPRJHQ� LQJHVFKDW� RP� DGHTXDDW�PHW� GH� JHEHXUWHQLV� RP� WH� JDDQ��+HWFRSLQJSURFHV� UHIHUHHUW� QDDU� KRH� LHPDQG� GDDGZHUNHOLMN� RPJDDW�PHW� GH� JHEHXUWHQLV� HQKDDU JHYROJHQ��LQ�HPRWLRQHHO��FRJQLWLHI��YHUVWDQGHOLMN���HQ�JHGUDJVPDWLJ�RS]LFKW�&RSLQJ� NDQ� DGHTXDDW� ]LMQ� �GH� EHGUHLJLQJ� ZRUGW� JHQHXWUDOLVHHUG��� LQDGHTXDDW�SV\FKLVFKH�SUREOHPHQ�NXQQHQ�RQWVWDDQ���RI��KRHZHO�RJHQVFKLMQOLMN�DGHTXDDW���WRFK�PHWµELMZHUNLQJHQ¶�JHSDDUG�JDDQ�GLH�KHW�ULVLFR�RS�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�YHUJURWHQ��9DQGLW� ODDWVWH� LV� ELMYRRUEHHOG� VSUDNH� ELM� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� YHUPLMGLQJ� YDQ� �PLQ� RI� PHHUDOOHGDDJVH��DQJVWSURGXFHUHQGH�VLWXDWLHV��ZDDUGRRU�GH�JHOHJHQKHLG�RP�WH� OHUHQ�RPJDDQPHW� GLH� VLWXDWLHV� ZHJYDOW� HQ� ]LFK� HHQ� IRELH� NDQ� RQWZLNNHOHQ�� :DW� HHQ� HIIHFWLHYHFRSLQJVWUDWHJLH�LV�� LV�HFKWHU�XLWHLQGHOLMN�DIKDQNHOLMN�YDQ�GH�VLWXDWLH� �/D]DUXV��������'H5LGGHU� HW� DO��� ������� 3UREOHHPJHULFKWH� FRSLQJ� �DFWLHJHULFKW�� OLMNW� WH� SUHIHUHUHQ� DOV� GHPRJHOLMNKHLG�HU�LV�RP�HHQ�VLWXDWLH�WH�YHUDQGHUHQ��(PRWLHJHULFKWH�FRSLQJ��DIVWDQG�QHPHQ�QHJHUHQ�� OLMNW� HFKWHU�GH� DDQJHZH]HQ�PHWKRGH�ELM� HHQ� VLWXDWLH�ZDDUDDQ�QLHWV� YHUDQGHUGNDQ ZRUGHQ��2RN�GH�SURFHVVHQ�YDQ�EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJ�HQ�YRRUDO�YDQ�FRSLQJ�VWDDQ��HYHQDOV�GHKDQGHOLQJVUXLPWH�HQ�RPJHYLQJVFRQWUROH��RQGHU�LQYORHG�YDQ�SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH�IDFWRUHQHQ GH� VRFLDOH� RPJHYLQJ�� $UPRHGH�� HHQ]DDPKHLG�� EHSHUNWH� LQWHOOHFWXHOH� YHUPRJHQV�JHULQJH� VRFLDOH� YDDUGLJKHGHQ�� RYHUPDWLJH� LPSXOVLYLWHLW�� DJUHVVLH� HQ� QHXURWLFLVPHµZHUNHQ¶�YHUPRHGHOLMN�DOV�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVIDFWRUHQ��RPGDW�]LM�ppQ�RI�PHHUGHUH�YDQ�GH]HSURFHVVHQ�QHJDWLHI�EHwQYORHGHQ�.HQPHUNHQG�YRRU�KHW�G\QDPLVFKH� VWUHVV�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO� LV�QLHW�DOOHHQ�GHQRWLH�YDQ�HHQ�G\QDPLVFK�HYHQZLFKW��PDDU�RRN�GH�ZLVVHOZHUNLQJ�GLH EHVWDDW� WXVVHQ�GHIDFWRUHQ�LQ�KHW�PRGHO��3V\FKRELRORJLVFKH�NHQPHUNHQ�HQ�VRFLDOH�RPJHYLQJ�EHwQYORHGHQ]RDOV�JH]HJG�KHW�DO�GDQ�QLHW�RSWUHGHQ�YDQ�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ��PDDU�RRN�KHW�GDDURSYROJHQGH

Page 44: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

JHGUDJ��PHW�QDPH�GH�SURFHVVHQ�YDQ�EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJ�HQ�FRSLQJ���0DDU�KHW�PRGHO�ODDWRRN H[SOLFLHW� WRH� GDW� HUYDULQJHQ� HQ� JHGUDJ� RS� KXQ� EHXUW� GH� NZHWVEDDUKHLG� EOLMYHQGYHUDQGHUHQ��2RN�NXQQHQ�GH�SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH�HQ�VRFLDOH�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVIDFWRUHQ�HONDDUEHwQYORHGHQ�� PHW� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� HQ� JHGUDJ� DOV� LQWHUPHGLDUH� IDFWRUHQ�� %OLMYHQGHYHUDQGHULQJHQ�LQ�NZHWVEDDUKHLG�]XOOHQ�EOLMYHQGH�YHUDQGHULQJHQ�LQ�KHW�YRRU�GH�SHUVRRQNDUDNWHULVWLHNH�QLYHDX�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG�EHZHUNVWHOOLJHQ�(HQ� EHODQJULMN� DVSHFW� YDQ� GLW� PRGHO� LV� RRN� GH� FRQWH[WDIKDQNHOLMNKHLG� YDQ� KHWHIIHFW�YDQ�YHOH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ��%LM� �SV\FKRVRFLDOH��GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� ]RDOV�ZHUNORRVKHLG�HFKWVFKHLGLQJ�HQ�DUPRHGH��EHSDDOW�GH�GRRU�KHW�LQGLYLGX�WRHJHNHQGH�EHWHNHQLV�PHGH�KHWHIIHFW�RS�GH�SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG��1HHOHPDQ���������'LW�OLJW�KHHO�DQGHUV�ELM�I\VLVFK�FKHPLVFKH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ��]RDOV�89�VWUDOLQJ�HQ�WDEDNVURRN��'H]H�KHEEHQ�HIIHFWHQ�RS�GHOLFKDPHOLMNH� JH]RQGKHLG� RQJHDFKW� GH� EHWHNHQLV� GLH� EHWURNNHQH� HQ� RPJHYLQJ� DDQ]RQQHEDGHQ�HQ�URNHQ�WRHNHQW��(pQ�YDQ�GH�IDFWRUHQ�GLH�GH�EHWHNHQLV�YDQ�SV\FKRVRFLDOHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�EHwQYORHGW��LV�GH�SUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�GH�GHWHUPLQDQW�]HOI��1HHOHPDQ��������'RRU� HHQ� VFDOD� DDQ� PHFKDQLVPHQ� EUHQJHQ� UHODWLHI� ]HOG]DPH� SV\FKRVRFLDOHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� GRRUJDDQV� KRJHUH� UHODWLHYH� ULVLFR¶V� PHW� ]LFK� PHH� GDQ� GH� PHHUSUHYDOHQWH�� +HW� ]DO� GXLGHOLMN� ]LMQ� GDW� GLW� VSHFLILHNH� NHQPHUN� YDQ� SV\FKRVRFLDOHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� KHW� RQGHU]RHN� QDDU� GH� URO� YDQ� GH]H� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� ELM� SV\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ�EHPRHLOLMNW�

���� (HQ�LQGHOLQJ�YDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ,Q�GH]H�UDSSRUWDJH�RQGHUVFKHLGHQ�ZLM�YLHU�KRRIGJURHSHQ�YDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� JHRUGHQGYROJHQV� KHW� VWUHVV�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO�� GHPRJUDILVFKH� IDFWRUHQ�� IDFWRUHQ� GLH� GHSV\FKRELRORJLVFKH�� UHVSHFWLHYHOLMN� GH� VRFLDOH� NZHWVEDDUKHLG� EHSDOHQ� HQOHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ��'H]H�LQGHOLQJ�VOXLW�RS�HHQ�DDQWDO�SXQWHQ�DDQ�ELM�KHW�PRGHO�GDW�LQ979������ ZRUGW� JHEUXLNW�� +LHULQ� ZRUGHQ� HQGRJHQH� �HUIHOLMN�� YHUZRUYHQ�� IDFWRUHQ�H[RJHQH�IDFWRUHQ��I\VLHNH�HQ�VRFLDOH�RPJHYLQJ�� HQ�KHW� V\VWHHP�YDQ�]RUJ�HQ�SUHYHQWLHRQGHUVFKHLGHQ� �5XZDDUG� � .UDPHUV�� ������� *HGUDJ� LV� KLHU� XLWJHZHUNW� GRRUOHHIVWLMOIDFWRUHQ�DOV�URNHQ�HQ�GULQNHQ�HQ�LV�RQGHUJHEUDFKW�ELM�GH�H[RJHQH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�+HW� ]RUJV\VWHHP� �GH�**=�� EOLMIW� LQ� GH]H� UDSSRUWDJH� EXLWHQ� EHVFKRXZLQJ�� RPGDW� GH]HGHWHUPLQDQW�YRRU�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�VWRRUQLVVHQ�QLHW�HUJ�YDQ�EHODQJ�LV��RYHULJHQV�ZHO�YRRUGH GXXU�� KHW� UHFLGLHI� ULVLFR� HQ�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�QLHXZH� VWRRUQLVVHQ���+LHUQD� YROJW� HHQW\SHULQJ�YDQ�GH�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�FDWHJRULHsQ�YDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�

'HPRJUDILVFKH�IDFWRUHQ*HVODFKW�HQ�OHHIWLMG�ZRUGHQ�DSDUW�EHVFKRXZG�RPGDW�]LM�YHUZLM]HQ�QDDU�]RZHO�HQGRJHQHDOV� H[RJHQH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� %HLGH� ]LMQ� JHUHODWHHUG� DDQ� ]RZHO� VRPDWLVFKH�SV\FKRORJLVFKH�DOV� VRFLDOH�NHQPHUNHQ�YDQ�KHW� LQGLYLGX��(WQLVFKH�YHUVFKLOOHQ� ]XOOHQ� LQGH]H� UDSSRUWDJH� EXLWHQ� EHVFKRXZLQJ� EOLMYHQ�� 'LW� KHHIW� RQGHUPHHU� WH� PDNHQ� PHW� GHJHULQJH�KRHYHHOKHLG�RQGHU]RHN�GLH�EHVFKLNEDDU�ZDV�LQ�GH�OLWHUDWXXU�

� +LHU�EHVWDDW�HHQ�LQWHUHVVDQWH�RYHUHHQNRPVW�WXVVHQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�HSLGHPLRORJLH�HQ�GH�LQIHFWLH]LHNWHQHSLGHPLRORJLH��]LHNWHYHUZHNNHUV�GLH�SUHYDOHQWHU�]LMQ��JDDQ�GRRUJDDQV�JHSDDUG�PHW�KRJHUH�VSHFLILHNHLPPXQLWHLWVQLYHDXV�LQ�GH�EHYRONLQJ�HQ�GHUKDOYH�PHW�HHQ�ODJHUH�EHVPHWWHOLMNKHLG�

Page 45: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

(QGRJHQH�IDFWRUHQ2QGHU� GH� HQGRJHQH� IDFWRUHQ� YHUVWDDQ� ZLM� GH� IDFWRUHQ� GLH� GH� SV\FKRELRORJLVFKHNZHWVEDDUKHLG�� RI� LQ� SRVLWLHYH� ]LQ�� GH� ZHHUEDDUKHLG� HQ� YHHUNUDFKW� YDQ� HHQ� LQGLYLGXEHSDOHQ�� 9RRUEHHOGHQ� KLHUYDQ� ]LMQ� KHW� JHQRW\SH� �JHQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ��� WHPSHUDPHQW�GDW LQ� ZLVVHOZHUNLQJ� PHW� VRFLDOLVDWLH� HQ� LQJULMSHQGH� HUYDULQJHQ� LHPDQGVSHUVRRQOLMNKHLG� YRUP� JHHIW�� HQ� �VRFLDOH�� LQWHOOLJHQWLH� 0DDU� RRN� VRPDWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQYDOOHQ�KLHU�RQGHU��9RRUEHHOGHQ�GDDUYDQ�]LMQ�SHULQDWDOH�SUREOHPHQ��OLFKDPHOLMNH�]LHNWHQ��HHUGHUH� RI� DQGHUH�� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� PDDU� RRN� QHXURELRORJLVFKHUHVSRQVLHSDWURQHQ��GHQN�DDQ�GH�UHDFWLH�YDQ�KHW�V\VWHHP�YDQ�GH�K\SRWKDODPXV�K\SRI\VH�ELMQLHUVFKRUV� RS� EORRWVWHOOLQJ� DDQ� VWUHVV��� ,Q� GH� EHVFKULMYLQJ� LQ�KRRIGVWXN� �� JHEUXLNHQZLM VWHHGV�GH�YROJHQGH�FDWHJRULHsQ��JHQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ���SHUVRRQOLMNKHLG� HQ�VRPDWLVFKHIDFWRUHQ�([RJHQH�IDFWRUHQ2QGHU� GH� H[RJHQH� IDFWRUHQ� YHUVWDDQ� ZLM� GH� �VRFLDOH� RI� I\VLHNH�� RPJHYLQJVJHERQGHQNZHWVEDDUKHLG� RI� ZHHUEDDUKHLG�� %HODQJULMNH� YRRUEHHOGHQ� KLHUYDQ� ]LMQ� VRFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKH� VWDWXV� �RSOHLGLQJ�� LQNRPHQ�� EHURHS��� YHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ�� HWQLFLWHLW�JH]LQVVLWXDWLH� �EXUJHUOLMNH� VWDDW�� PDDU� RRN� RSYRHGLQJVVWLMO��� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ�DUEHLGVRPVWDQGLJKHGHQ�� VRFLDDO�FXOWXUHOH� IDFWRUHQ� �ZDDUGHQ� HQ� QRUPHQ��� PLJUDWLH� HQRRUORJVVLWXDWLHV��(HQ�W\SLVFKH�I\VLHNH�IDFWRU�LV�GH�KRHYHHOKHLG�OLFKW�SHU�HWPDDO�/HYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ'H� ODDWVWH� JURHS� RPYDW� GH� OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ��'LW� ]LMQ� VWUHVVRUHQ� ]RDOV� YHUOLHV� YDQSDUWQHU�� HHQ� HFKWVFKHLGLQJ�� HHQ� JHERRUWH�� HHQ� VWUHVVYROOH� EDDQ� RI� HHQ� FKURQLVFKHDDQGRHQLQJ�� /HYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� ]LMQ� RQGHUYHUGHHOG� LQ� WZHH� FDWHJRULHsQ�� 'HNZHWVEDDUKHLGYHUKRJHQGH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� GLH�LHPDQG¶V�NZHWVEDDUKHLG�YRRU�ODQJHUH�WLMGRI ]HOIV� EOLMYHQG� EHwQYORHGHQ� �WUDXPDWLVFKH� MHXJGHUYDULQJHQ��� HQ� GH� XLWORNNHQGHJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� GLH� ZpO� KHW� ULVLFR� RS� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG� YHUJURWHQ� PDDU� JHHQEOLMYHQGH� JHYROJHQ� YRRU� LHPDQGV� NZHWVEDDUKHLG� KHEEHQ�� =HHU� LQJULMSHQGHJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�NXQQHQ�RYHULJHQV�EHLGH�HIIHFWHQ�KHEEHQ�'H� WHUP� µOHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ¶� RPYDW� RRN� GH� PHHU� FKURQLVFKH� JHYROJHQ� YDQGH]H� HUYDULQJHQ�� ]RDOV� ZHUNORRVKHLG� QD� YHUOLHV� YDQ� EDDQ�� DOVPHGH� PHHU� JHOHLGHOLMNRQWVWDQH� VWUHVVYROOH� RPVWDQGLJKHGHQ� �ELMYRRUEHHOG� LQ� GH� DUEHLGVVLWXDWLH��� +HWRQGHUVFKHLG� PHW� GH� HQGRJHQH� HQ� H[RJHQH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� LV� KLHUGRRU� QLHW� DOWLMG� HYHQVFKHUS�

���� :HUNZLM]H+HW� GRHO� YDQ� GH]H� UDSSRUWDJH� LV�� ]RDOV� JH]HJG�� KHW� JHYHQ� YDQ� HHQ� RYHU]LFKW� YDQ� GHKXLGLJH�ZHWHQ��VFKDSSHOLMNH�NHQQLV�RPWUHQW�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG�'DDUWRH� LV� OLWHUDWXXURQGHU]RHN� XLWJHYRHUG� RS� GH� YROJHQGH� ZLM]H�� 3RWHQWLHHO� UHOHYDQWHVWXGLHV� �SURVSHFWLHI� RI� FDVH�FRQWURO�� ZHUGHQ� RS� GULH� PDQLHUHQ� RSJHVSRRUG�� HHQOLWHUDWXXUVHDUFK� LQ� 0('/,1(� HQ� 36<&+/,7� ������������ VFUHHQLQJ� YDQ� RQV� HLJHQOLWHUDWXXUEHVWDQG��SHULRGH�������������HQ�GH�VQHHXZEDO�PHWKRGH��ZDDULQ�GH�UHIHUHQWLHVYDQ� LQWHUHVVDQWH� SXEOLFDWLHV� ZHUGHQ� EHNHNHQ�� 'H� JHEUXLNWH� WUHIZRRUGHQ� ELM� GH� +LHU�EUHHG�RSJHYDW��GXV�LQFOXVLHI�WHPSHUDPHQW��EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJV��HQ�FRSLQJVWLMOHQ�HQ��VRFLDOH�LQWHOOLJHQWLH�

Page 46: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

0('/,1(� HQ� 36<&+/,7� VHDUFK� EHVWRQGHQ� XLW� µSV\FKRORJLFDO� LOOQHVV¶�� µPHQWDOLOOQHVV�GLVRUGHU�KHDOWK¶�HQ�GH�JHVHOHFWHHUGH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��VWHHGV�LQ�FRPELQDWLHPHW µFDVH�FRQWURO¶�RI��µSURVSHFWLYH¶��HQ�µULVN¶��µULVN�IDFWRU¶��µGHWHUPLQDQW¶�RI�µHWLRORJ\¶�'LW�DOOHV�OHYHUGH�UXLP�������DUWLNHOHQ�RS�ZDDUYDQ�GH�RYHUJURWH�PHHUGHUKHLG�RPPHWKRGRORJLVFKH� UHGHQHQ� QLHW� EUXLNEDDU� EOHHN��2PGDW� GLW� KRRIGVWXN� ]LFK� WRHVSLWVW� RSGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�� ]LMQ� VWXGLHV� QDDU� KHWEHORRS�QLHW�JHVHOHFWHHUG��2PGDW�HU�QRJ�ZHLQLJ�SURVSHFWLHYH�RI�FDVH�FRQWURO�VWXGLHV�]LMQXLWJHYRHUG��LV�RRN�JHEUXLN�JHPDDNW�YDQ�HQNHOH�GZDUVGRRUVQHGH�VWXGLHV�GLH�ZLM�UHOHYDQWDFKWHQ�� ]RDOV� GH� 1HGHUODQGVH� 1(0(6,6� VWXGLH� �%LMO� HW� DO��� ����D�� ����E�� HQ� GH$PHULNDDQVH�1DWLRQDO�&RPRUELGLW\�6WXG\��.HVVOHU�HW�DO���������'H�UHVXOWDWHQ�YDQ�GLW� OLWHUDWXXURQGHU]RHN�ZRUGHQ�JHSUHVHQWHHUG� LQ�KRRIGVWXN���+LHULQ� EHVSUHNHQ� ZLM� GH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YRRU� HON� YDQ� GH� JHVHOHFWHHUGH� JURHSHQ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� $DQ� KHW� HLQG� YDQ� GLW� KRRIGVWXN� ZRUGHQ� GH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQEHVSURNHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�� JHPHWHQ� LQ�JHQHULHNH� WHUPHQ� YDQ� KHW]LM� KHWDDQWDO�V\PSWRPHQ�GDQ�ZHO�KHW�DDQWDO�VWRRUQLVVHQ��FRPRUELGLWHLW���+HW�JDDW�KLHUELM�VWHHGVRP HHQ� FRPSDFWH�� GHHOV� WDEHOODULVFKH�� EHVFKULMYLQJ� YDQ� GH� EHODQJULMNVWH� UHVXOWDWHQ�9ROOHGLJKHLG�LV�LQ�KHW�NDGHU�YDQ�GH]H�UDSSRUWDJH�QLHW�QDJHVWUHHIG��GH�EHVFKLNEDUH�UXLPWHZDV GDDUYRRU� WH� EHSHUNW�� ,Q� � KRRIGVWXN� �� ]LMQ� HQNHOH� �RYHUNRHSHOHQGH�� FRQFOXVLHVJHWURNNHQ�RS�EDVLV�YDQ�GH�EHVFKLNEDUH�NHQQLV�HQ�ZRUGW�LQJHJDDQ�RS�GH�LPSOLFDWLHV�YDQGH EHYLQGLQJHQ�YRRU�KHW�RQGHU]RHNV��HQ�SUHYHQWLHEHOHLG��7RW�VORW�JHYHQ�ZLM�RQ]H�YLVLHRS HQNHOH�WRHNRPVWLJH�RQWZLNNHOLQJHQ�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQ�GH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKHRQJH]RQGKHLG�

Page 47: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

� 'HWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQRQJH]RQGKHLG,Q�GLW�KRRIGVWXN�ZRUGHQ�GH�JHVHOHFWHHUGH�KRRIGJURHSHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�DOVYROJW�EHVFKUHYHQ��(ONH�VWRRUQLV�ZRUGW�NRUW�JHNDUDNWHULVHHUG�GRRU�HHQ�EHVFKULMYLQJ�YDQGH DDUG�YDQ�GH�VWRRUQLV��V\PSWRPHQ���KHW�YyyUNRPHQ�LQ�GH�1HGHUODQGVH�EHYRONLQJ��DDQGH KDQG� YDQ� SUHYDOHQWLH�� HQ�RI� LQFLGHQWLHFLMIHUV�� HQ� UHFHQWH� RQWZLNNHOLQJHQ� KLHULQ�� HQLHWV RYHU�KHW�EHORRS�HQ�JHYROJHQ� 'DDUQD�YROJW�HHQ�V\VWHPDWLVFKH�EHVFKULMYLQJ�YDQ�GHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� LQJHGHHOG� LQ� GHPRJUDILVFKH�� HQGRJHQH� HQ� H[RJHQH� IDFWRUHQ�� HQOHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ��(ONH�SDUDJUDDI�HLQGLJW�PHW� HHQ� FRQFOXVLH��+LHULQ�ZRUGW� JHWUDFKWRP RS� EDVLV� YDQ� GH� JHSUHVHQWHHUGH� JHJHYHQV� GH� RQGHUOLQJH� VDPHQKDQJ� WXVVHQGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� HQ� KHW� UHODWLHYH� EHODQJ� YDQ� GH� YHUVFKLOOHQGH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� LQ� NDDUW� WHEUHQJHQ�

��� 6WHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ'H� EHODQJULMNVWH� GULH� VWHPPLQJVWRRUQLVVHQ�� PHW� KXQ� PDDQG�� HQ� OHYHQVSUHYDOHQWLHYROJHQV�1(0(6,6�� ]LMQ� GH� GHSUHVVLH� LQ� HQJHUH� ]LQ� ������� �������� G\VWK\PLH� �������������HQ�GH�ELSRODLUH�VWRRUQLV���������������%LMO�HW�DO�������E���.HQPHUNHQG�YRRU�GHGHSUHVVLH� LQ�HQJHUH�]LQ��L�H�]���]LMQ�HHQ�DOJHKHHO�JHYRHO�YDQ�VRPEHUKHLG�HQ�YHUOLHV�YDQLQWHUHVVH� LQ� GH� DFWLYLWHLWHQ� HQ� GLQJHQ�ZDDUDDQ�PHQ� QRUPDOLWHU� SOH]LHU� EHOHHIW�� 'LW� XLW]LFK GRRUJDDQV�LQ�HHQ�YHUODDJG�DFWLYLWHLWHQQLYHDX��PDDU�VRPV�RRN�LQ�JHDJLWHHUG�JHGUDJ�LQ YHUDQGHULQJ� �GRRUJDDQV�HHQ� DIQDPH��YDQ� HHWOXVW�� LQ� DIJHQRPHQ�]HOIZDDUGHULQJ�� HHQQHJDWLHYH� NLMN� RS� ]LFK]HOI� HQ� RS� GH� WRHNRPVW�� 2RN� ]LMQ� HU� YDDN� VFKXOGJHYRHOHQV�JHYRHOHQV�YDQ�KRSHORRVKHLG��HQ�JHGDFKWHQ� DDQ�GRRG� HQ�]HOIGRGLQJ��'HSUHVVLH� L�H�]�� LVHSLVRGLVFK� YDQ� DDUG�� PHW� HHQ� KRRJ� UHFLGLHI� ULVLFR�� 'H� GXXU� YDQ� HHQ� HSLVRGH� YDULHHUWVWHUN� HQ� OLJW� GRRUJDDQV� WXVVHQ� �� HQ� ���PDDQGHQ�� '\VWK\PLH� LV� HHQ� DQGHUH�� OLFKWHUH�YRUP YDQ��XQLSRODLUH��GHSUHVVLH��GLH�RYHU�HHQ�ODQJHUH�SHULRGH�YULMZHO�FRQWLQX�DDQKRXGW�'DDUQDDVW�RQGHUVFKHLGW�PHQ�YDDN�QRJ�GH�PLOGH�GHSUHVVLH��'LW�LV�HHQ�OLFKWHUH�YRUP�YDQGHSUHVVLH� L�H�]���GLH�PLQLPDDO� WZHH�ZHNHQ�GLHQW�DDQ� WH�KRXGHQ��0HW�GH� WHUP�GHSUHVVLHEHGRHOHQ� ZLM� LQ� KHW� YHUYROJ� ]RZHO� GH� GHSUHVVLH� L�H�]��� GH� G\VWK\PLH�� DOV� GH� PLOGHGHSUHVVLH�6WHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ� YRUPHQ� HHQ� KHWHURJHQH� JURHS� YDQ� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� =HOIVELQQHQ�GH�GHSUHVVLH�LQ�HQJHUH�]LQ�RQGHUVFKHLGW�PHQ�ZHHU�GLYHUVH�YRUPHQ��]RDOV�RRN�XLWKHW� YRRUDIJDDQGH� EOLMNW�� =H� KHEEHQ� GH� QHLJLQJ� WH� UHFLGLYHUHQ� �(DWRQ� HW� DO��� ������NXQQHQ�HUQVWLJH�JHYROJHQ�KHEEHQ� LQ� WHUPHQ�YDQ�PRUWDOLWHLW� HQ� VRFLDOH�EHSHUNLQJHQ� HQJDDQ� JHSDDUG� PHW� DDQ]LHQOLMN� SURGXFWLHYHUOLHV� �2UPHO� HW� DO��� ����D�� ������� 'HSUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� PHW� QDPH� GH� PLOGHUH� YRUPHQ� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH� OLMNW� GH� DIJHORSHQ� WZHHGHFHQQLD� WH�]LMQ� WRHJHQRPHQ��ZDDUELM�GH�HHUVWH�HSLVRGH�]LFK�RS�VWHHGV� MRQJHUH� OHHIWLMGPDQLIHVWHHUW� �+DJQHOO� � *UDVEHFN�� ������ 2UPHO� HW� DO��� ����D�� 3ULFH� HW� DO��� �����5XZDDUG��.UDPHUV����������'H�DDQZLM]LQJHQ�KLHUYRRU�]LMQ�HFKWHU�LQGLUHFW�HQ�PRJHOLMNVSHOHQ KLHUELM�RRN�PHWKRGRORJLVFKH�DVSHFWHQ�HHQ�URO��]RDOV�PHHU�DDQGDFKW�HQ�HHQ�EHWHUHKHUNHQQLQJ�YDQ�GH�VWRRUQLV��EHWHUH�GHILQLWLHV�HQ�GLDJQRVWLHN�+HW�DFFHQW�OLJW�LQ�GH]H�SDUDJUDDI�RS�GHSUHVVLH�L�H�]���RPGDW�RYHU�G\VWK\PLH�YHHOPLQGHU�EHNHQG�LV�HQ�GH�PLOGH�GHSUHVVLH�XLWHHQORSHQG�LV�JHGHILQLHHUG��9RRU�]RYHU�HU�ZHO

Page 48: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

ZDW�EHNHQG�LV�EOLMNHQ�GH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�G\VWK\PLH�HQ�PLOGH�GHSUHVVLH�VWHUN�RYHUHHQWH NRPHQ�PHW� GLH� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH� L�H�]�� 'H� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLV�ZRUGW� DSDUW� LQ�SDUDJUDDI������ EHVSURNHQ�� RPGDW� SV\FKRWLVFKH� YHUVFKLMQVHOHQ� GHHO� XLW� PDNHQ� YDQ� GH� ELSRODLUHVWRRUQLV�'HPRJUDILVFKH�IDFWRUHQ*HVODFKW'HSUHVVLHV�NRPHQ�YDNHU�ELM�YURXZHQ�YRRU� �%LMO� HW� DO�������E��2UPHO�HW� DO����������=LMKHEEHQ�HHQ�RQJHYHHU�WZHHPDDO�]R�JURWH�NDQV�RP�HHQ�GHSUHVVLH� WH�NULMJHQ�DOV�PDQQHQ�:DDURP�YURXZHQ�HHQ�YHUKRRJG�ULVLFR�NHQQHQ�LV�QRJ�QLHW�JHKHHO�GXLGHOLMN��(U�]LMQ�VWHUNHDDQZLM]LQJHQ�GDW�HHQ�FRPELQDWLH�YDQ�SV\FKRORJLVFKH�HQ�VRFLDOH�IDFWRUHQ�HHQ�URO�VSHOHQ�GH YHHOHLVHQGH�FRPELQDWLH�YDQ�PHHUGHUH�UROOHQ��SDUWQHU��PRHGHU��ZHUNQHPHU�HQ�GH�WDDNLQ GH� KXLVKRXGLQJ��� GH� DFKWHUJHVWHOGH� VRFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKH� SRVLWLH�� KHW� KHEEHQ� YDQVWHUNHUH� DIIHFWLHYH� ELQGLQJHQ� HQ� HHQ� µ]RUJHOLMNHU¶� FRJQLWLHI�HPRWLRQHOH� UHVSRQV� RSVWUHVV� 0DDU� RRN� VRPDWLVFKH�� DDQ� GH� ELRORJLVFKH� UHSURGXFWLH� JHUHODWHHUGH�� KRUPRQDOHIDFWRUHQ� GUDJHQ� ZHOOLFKW� DDQ� KHW� VH[H� YHUVFKLO� ELM� �%UHPV�� ������ 1ROHQ�+RHNVHPD�������3HUXJL�HW�DO���������:HLVVPDQ�HW�DO���������/HHIWLMG+RHZHO� GHSUHVVLHV� RS� HONH� OHHIWLMG� YRRU� KHW� HHUVW� NXQQHQ� RSWUHGHQ�� EHJLQW� GHPHHUGHUKHLG� YRRUDO� YDQ� GH� UHFLGLYHUHQGH� GHSUHVVLH� L�H�]��� LQ� GH� ODWH� DGROHVFHQWLH� HQYURHJH�YROZDVVHQKHLG��%XUYLOO��������2UPHO�HW�DO�����������+HW�YHUVFKLO�WXVVHQ�PDQQHQHQ� YURXZHQ� LV� KHW� JURRWVW� URQG� KHW� ��VWH� OHYHQVMDDU� �-RUP�� ������� 'H� KRRJVWHPDDQGSUHYDOHQWLH� ZRUGHQ� GRRUJDDQV� ELM� ������ MDULJHQ� DDQJHWURIIHQ�� QDGLHQ� QHHPW� GHSUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH� L�H�]�� HQ� G\VWK\PLH� ODQJ]DDP�PDDU� JHVWDDJ� DI� �%HHNPDQ�2UPHO��������2UPHO�HW�DO���������6KXOPDQ�HW�DO���������:DDURP�GH� SUHYDOHQWLH� ELM� RXGHUHQ� ODJHU� LV�� LV� QRJ� QLHW� JHKHHO� GXLGHOLMN��:pOVWDDW YDVW�GDW�HHQ�YHUKRRJGH�PRUWDOLWHLW� WHQ�JHYROJH�YDQ�PHW�QDPH�VXwFLGH�HQ�KDUW��HQYDDW]LHNWHQ�ELM�PHQVHQ�PHW�FKURQLVFK�UHFLGLYHUHQGH�GHSUHVVLHV�HHQ�URO�VSHHOW��3HQQLQ[HW�DO��������� 0DDU�HU�]LMQ�DDQZLM]LQJHQ�GDW�RRN�DQGHUH�IDFWRUHQ�GH�GDOLQJ�EHwQYORHGHQ�]RDOV�HHQ�JHULQJHUH�JHYRHOLJKHLG�YDQ�KHW�JDQJEDUH� LQVWUXPHQWDULXP�YRRU�GHSUHVVLH�ELMRXGHUHQ�� HHQ� JURWHUH� XLWYDO� YDQ� VRPDWLVFK� ]LHNH� GHSUHVVLHYH� RXGHUHQ� LQEHYRONLQJVRQGHU]RHN�� HQ� HHQ� RSERXZ� YDQ� ZHHUVWDQG� WHJHQ� GHSUHVVLH� GRRU� GHOHYHQVODQJH� EORRWVWHOOLQJ� DDQ� GHSUHVVRJHQH� HUYDULQJHQ� �6\WHPD� � .RRSPDQV�� ������7HQVORWWH�JDDW�KHW�KLHU�RP�HHQ�VHOHFWH�JURHS�SHUVRQHQ��µKHDOWK\�VXUYLYRUV¶���GLH�ZHOOLFKWHHQ� YHUKRRJGH� ZHHUVWDQG� KHEEHQ� �RSJHERXZG�� WHJHQ� DDQGRHQLQJHQ� YDQ� ]RZHOOLFKDPHOLMNH�DOV�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�DDUG��'H�EHODQJULMNVWH�UHGHQ�GDW�GH�SUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�PLOGHGHSUHVVLHV�ELM�RXGHUHQ�JHHQ�DIQDPH�PDDU�YHHOHHU�HHQ�WRHQDPH�ODDW�]LHQ��LV�YHUPRHGHOLMNKHW�YHUOLHV�YDQ� I\VLHNH� FDSDFLWHLWHQ� HQ� EHODQJULMNH� UHODWLHV� �%HHNPDQ��2UPHO�� �����2UPHO�HW�DO�������� 6\WHPD��.RRSPDQV��������(QGRJHQH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ*HQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ*HQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� VSHOHQ� HHQ� URO� LQ� GH� HWLRORJLH� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH�� +XQ� ELMGUDJH� OLMNWJURWHU�WH�ZRUGHQ�QDDUPDWH�GH�VWRRUQLV�HUQVWLJHU�LV�HQ�RS�MRQJHUH�OHHIWLMG�EHJLQW��9RRU�GHGHSUHVVLH� L�H�]�� EHGUDDJW� GH� FRQFRUGDQWLH� �SHUFHQWDJH� WZHHOLQJSDUHQ�ZDDUELM� GHSUHVVLH

Page 49: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

ELM�EHLGH�µOHGHQ¶�YDQ�HHQ�SDDU�YRRUNRPW�RI�LV�YRRUJHNRPHQ��GRRUJDDQV�URQG�GH�����ELMPRQR]\JRWH��0=��WZHHOLQJHQ�HQ�����ELM�GL]\JRWH��'=��WZHHOLQJHQ��0DLHU�HW�DO��������0F*XIILQ� HW� DO��� ������0HULNDQJDV��6ZHQGVHQ�� ������0HULNDQJDV��.XSIHU�� �����6XOOLYDQ� �.HQGOHU�� ������� (HQ� KRJHUH� FRQFRUGDQWLH� ELM�0=� WZHHOLQJHQ� GDQ� ELM� '=WZHHOLQJHQ� ZLMVW� RS� GH� LQYORHG� YDQ� JHQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ�� DDQJH]LHQ� 0=� WZHHOLQJHQJHQHWLVFK�PHHU�RS�HONDDU�OLMNHQ�GDQ�'=�WZHHOLQJHQ�'H� ZLM]H� YDQ� RYHUHUYLQJ� HQ� GH� JHQHWLVFKH� UHODWLHV� WXVVHQ� GH� VWHPPLQJV�VWRRUQLVVHQ�]LMQ�RQGXLGHOLMN��DO�VWDDW�YDVW�GDW�PHHUGHUH�JHQHQ�LQ�KHW�VSHO�EHWURNNHQ�]LMQ�2RN�KHW�FKURPRVRPDDO�RQGHU]RHN�KHHIW�QRJ�JHHQ�FRQVLVWHQWH�UHVXOWDWHQ�RSJHOHYHUG��'HDDQZLM]LQJHQ�ZRUGHQ�VWHUNHU�GDW�HHQ�GHHO�YDQ�GH� UHODWLH� WXVVHQ�JHQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ�HQGHSUHVVLH� YHUORRSW� YLD� GH� GHWHUPLQDQW� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLG�� GLH� RS� ]LMQ� EHXUW� �YLDRPJHYLQJVFRQWUROH�� HHQ� GHWHUPLQDQW� YDQ� KHW� DO� GDQ� QLHW� RSWUHGHQ� YDQ� VWUHVVYROOHHUYDULQJHQ� LV� �]LH� ILJXXU� �����.HQGOHU� � .DUNRZVN\�6KXPDQ�� ������ 2UPHO�� �����6DXGLQR�HW�DO���������3HUVRRQOLMNKHLG([FHVVLHYH� JHUHPGKHLG� JHULQJH� ]HOIZDDUGHULQJ�� QHXURWLFLVPH�� KRJH� LQWHUSHUVRRQOLMNHVHQVLWLYLWHLW�HQ�VRFLDDO�FRJQLWLHYH�EHSHUNLQJHQ�YHUJURWHQ�KHW�ULVLFR�RS�GHSUHVVLH��&R\QH 'RZQH\��������+DPPHQ��������.UXHJHU� HW� DO��� ������2UPHO�� ������9DQ�2V� HW� DO���������'H�EHZLMVODVW�YRRU�]HOIZDDUGHULQJ�HQ�QHXURWLFLVPH� LV� WDPHOLMN� VWHUN��'DDUQDDVW]LMQ HU� EHVFKHLGHQ� DDQZLM]LQJHQ� GDW� HHQ� QHLJLQJ� WRW� µLQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH¶� VWLMOHQ� YDQEHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJ�HQ�FRSLQJ��RYHUGULMYHQ��YHUPLMGLQJ��]HOIYHUZLMW�HQ�VFKXOGJHYRHOHQV��ELM EORRWVWHOOLQJ� YDQ� HHQ� LQGLYLGX� DDQ� WHJHQVODJ� HQ� NULWLHN�� HHQ� URO� VSHOHQ� �+DPPHQ�������2UPHO�� �������0LOGH� FRJQLWLHYH� EHSHUNLQJHQ� LQ� FRPELQDWLH�PHW� HHQ� JHEUHNNLJHPRWRULVFKH�FRQWUROH�RS�MRQJH�OHHIWLMG�������MDDU���YHUKRJHQ�KHW�ULVLFR�RS�ODWHUH�GHSUHVVLHPHW HHQ�IDFWRU�����i����+HOOJUHQ�HW�DO���������9DQ�2V�HW�DO���������6RPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�HQ�HHUGHUH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ'HSUHVVLHYH�V\PSWRPHQ�ELM�RXGHUHQ�]LMQ�YRRU�HHQ�EHODQJULMN�GHHO��PRJHOLMN�ZHO�����WRH� WH� VFKULMYHQ� DDQ� GH� IXQFWLRQHOH� JHYROJHQ� YDQ� VRPDWLVFKH� ]LHNWHQ�� LQFOXVLHIVHQVRULVFKH� EHSHUNLQJHQ� �2UPHO� HW� DO��� ������ 3HQQLQ[� HW� DO��� ������ 9DQ� 7LOEXUJ� %HHNPDQ�� ������� 'DDUQDDVW� ]LMQ� GHPHQWLH�� GH� ]LHNWH� YDQ� 3DUNLQVRQ�� HQ� &9$JHDVVRFLHHUG�PHW�GHSUHVVLH�L�H�]���9DQ�7LOEXUJ��%HHNPDQ���������+HW�LV�RQGXLGHOLMN�LQKRHYHUUH�GLW�YHUEDQG�YHURRU]DDNW�ZRUGW�GRRU�JHPHHQVFKDSSHOLMNH�ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ�GDQ�ZHOGDW GH]H� DDQGRHQLQJHQ� ]pOI� �GRRU� KXQ� QHXURSDWKRORJLVFKH� FRQVHTXHQWLHV�� HHQULVLFRIDFWRU�YRRU�GHSUHVVLH�]LMQ�(U�]LMQ�DDQZLM]LQJHQ�YRRU�GH�EHWURNNHQKHLG�YDQ�HHQ�DDQWDO�ELRORJLVFKH�PHFKDQLVPHQ�ELMGHSUHVVLH�LQ�HQJHUH�]LQ�� +\SHUDFWLYLWHLW�YDQ�GH�K\SRWKDODPXV�K\SRI\VH�ELMQLHU��+3$��DV�� '\VIXQFWLHV� LQ� GH� WXUQRYHU� YDQ� VHURWRQLQH� ���K\GUR[\WU\SWDPLQH�� ��+7�� � HQFDWHFKRODPLQHQ�� $FWLYHULQJ� YDQ� KHW� LQIODPPDWRLUH� UHVSRQV� V\VWHHP� �,56�� GRRU� H[WHUQH� HQ� LQWHUQHVWUHVVIDFWRUHQ��9HUKRHYHQ��7XLQLHU��������9DQ�:HVW��0DHV��������2PGDW� HU� FRPSOH[H� LQWHUDFWLHV� EHVWDDQ� WXVVHQ� GH� +3$�DV�� KHW� ,56�� HQ� GHQHXURWUDQVPLWWHUV\VWHPHQ�� LV� RQGXLGHOLMN� LQ�KRHYHUUH�KHW�RP�RQDIKDQNHOLMNH� SURFHVVHQJDDW���2RN�LV�QRJ�QLHW�RSJHKHOGHUG�RI�KHW�KLHU�JDDW�RP�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ��ELMYHUVFKLMQVHOHQRI JHYROJHQ�YDQ�GH�GHSUHVVLH��:pO�LV�GXLGHOLMN�GDW�HON�YDQ�GH�GULH�V\VWHPHQ�EHWURNNHQ�LV

Page 50: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

ELM�KHW�RPJDDQ�PHW�VWUHVV��+HW�LV�GHUKDOYH�YRRUVWHOEDDU�GDW�ppQ�RI�PHHUGHUH�VRPDWLVFKHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH� JHOHJHQ� ]RXGHQ� NXQQHQ� ]LMQ� LQ� NZHWVEDDUKHLG� YDQ� GH]HV\VWHPHQ�� ELMYRRUEHHOG� ELM� EORRWVWHOOLQJ� DDQ� UHVSHFWLHYHOLMN� H[WHUQH� �ELMY�OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�� RI� � LQWHUQH� VWUHVVIDFWRUHQ� �ELMY�� YLUDOH� LQIHFWLHV�� �9HUKRHYHQ� 7XLQLHU��������9DQ�:HVW��0DHV��������([RJHQH�'HWHUPLQDQWHQ9HUVFKLOOHQ� LQ� GH� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH� WXVVHQ� SRSXODWLHV�� HQ� RYHU� WLMG� ELQQHQSRSXODWLHV��VXJJHUHUHQ�HHQ�YHUEDQG�PHW�H[RJHQH�IDFWRUHQ��%URZQ��������6RFLDOH�VWHXQ*HEUHN� DDQ� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ�� JHEUHNNLJH� VRFLDOH� LQWHJUDWLH� HQ� HHQ]DDPKHLG� ]LMQJHDVVRFLHHUG� PHW� GHSUHVVLH� �+HQGHUVRQ�� ������� 0HW� QDPH� KHW� RQWEUHNHQ� YDQ� HHQYHUWURXZHQVSHUVRRQ� HQ� LQVWDELHOH�� FRQIOLFWYROOH� UHODWLHV� PHW� SDUWQHU� RI� WKXLVZRQHQGHNLQGHUHQ�YRUPHQ�HHQ�ULVLFRIDFWRU�YRRU�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH��%LIXOFR�HW�DO���������0DDU� RRN� JHEUHN� DDQ� ZDDUGHULQJ� HQ� VWHXQ� RS� KHW� ZHUN� LV� LQ� YHUEDQG� JHEUDFKW� PHWGHSUHVVLHYH�V\PSWRPHQ�6(6�HQ�OHHIYRUP'H�SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH� LV� KRJHU� ELM� SHUVRQHQ�PHW� HHQ� UHODWLHI� ODJH� RSOHLGLQJ� HQLQNRPHQ�HQ�]LM�GLH�DINRPVWLJ�]LMQ�XLW�ppQRXGHU�JH]LQQHQ��%LMO�HW�DO�������E��6\WHPD�.RRSPDQV�� ������� $UPRHGH� YHUGXEEHOW� KHW� ULVLVR� RS� GHSUHVVLHV�� 'LW� LQGLUHFWH� HIIHFWYHUORRSW�GHHOV�YLD�HHQ�YHUPLQGHUGH�HLJHQZDDUGH��%URZQ��0RUDQ��������%UXFH�HW�DO��������HQ�GHHOV�YLD�HHQ�NOHLQHUH�KDQGHOLQJVUXLPWH��ZHONH�HHQ�QDGHOLJ�HIIHFW�NDQ�KHEEHQRS GH�EORRWVWHOOLQJ�DDQ�VWUHVVHUHQGH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ��]LH�RRN�SDUDJUDDI������9HUVWHGHOLMNLQJ'H�PHHVWH� VWXGLHV� YLQGHQ� HHQ� KRJHUH� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH� L�H�]� HQ� G\VWK\PLH� LQJH�UEDQLVHHUGH�JHELHGHQ��%LMO�HW�DO�������E��6\WHPD��.RRSPDQV���������+HW�OLMNW�QLHWZDDUVFKLMQOLMN� GDW� KHW� JHYRQGHQ� YHUEDQG� WRHJHVFKUHYHQ� NDQ�ZRUGHQ� DDQ�PLJUDWLH� YDQGHSUHVVLHYH�SHUVRQHQ�QDDU� JH�UEDQLVHHUGH� JHELHGHQ� �VHOHFWLH�HIIHFW���:HON� RRU]DNHOLMNPHFKDQLVPH�HU�ZpO�DFKWHU�KHW�JHYRQGHQ�YHUEDQG�]LW��LV�HFKWHU�QRJ�RQGXLGHOLMN�6HL]RHQVLQYORHGHQ'H�LQFLGHQWLH�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�LV��HYHQDOV�GLH�YDQ�VXwFLGH��YHUKRRJG�LQ�KHW�YRRU��HQ�QDMDDU�0HUVFK� HW� DO��� ������� =RZHO� GH� KRHYHHOKHLG� OLFKW� SHU� HWPDDO�� DOV� GH� PDWH� YDQYHUDQGHULQJ�LQ�GH�YHUKRXGLQJ�WXVVHQ�OLFKW�HQ�GRQNHU��PD[LPDDO�LQ�PDDUW�HQ�VHSWHPEHU�VSHOHQ� GRRU�YHUVWRULQJ�YDQ�FLUFDGLDQH�KRUPRQDOH�HQ�JHGUDJVULWPHQ��PRJHOLMN�HHQ�URO�/HYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ.ZHWVEDDUKHLGYHUKRJHQGH�HUYDULQJHQ/LFKDPHOLMN� PLVEUXLN� HQ� HPRWLRQHOH� YHUZDDUOR]LQJ� WLMGHQV� GH� NLQGHUMDUHQ� ]LMQJHDVVRFLHHUG�PHW�HHQ�FLUFD� WZHHPDDO�YHUKRRJG� ULVLFR�RS� �ODWHUH��GHSUHVVLH� �%LIXOFR� HWDO���������+DUULV�HW�DO����������+RH�GHUJHOLMNH�WUDXPDWLVFKH�MHXJGHUYDULQJHQ�]RYHHO�MDUHQODWHU QRJ� YDQ� LQYORHG� NXQQHQ� ]LMQ�� LV� QLHW� GXLGHOLMN�� 'LYHUVH� YHUNODULQJHQ� ]LMQYRRUJHVWHOG��YDULsUHQG�YDQ�HHQ�SHUPDQHQWH�EHVFKDGLJLQJ�YDQ�GH� HLJHQZDDUGH�PHW�DOOH

Page 51: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

JHYROJHQ�YDQ�GLHQ� WRW�HHQ�EOLMYHQGH�RYHUJHYRHOLJKHLG�YDQ�QHXURELRORJLVFKH�V\VWHPHQ�ZDDURQGHU�GH�+3$�DV��1DDU�KHW�ODQJH�WHUPLMQ�HIIHFW�YDQ�DQGHUH�SRWHQWLHHO�WUDXPDWLVFKHHUYDULQJHQ� LV� ZHLQLJ� JRHG� RQGHU]RHN� JHGDDQ�� 9HUOLHV� YDQ� HHQ� RXGHU�� GRRU� GRRG� RIVFKHLGLQJ� RS� MRQJH� OHHIWLMG�� LV� YRRUDO� HHQ� ULVLFRIDFWRU� LQGLHQ� KHW� ZRUGW� JHYROJG� GRRUYHUZDDUOR]LQJ�RI�JH]LQVSUREOHPHQ��+DUULV�HW�DO���������5XWWHU��6PLWK���������(U�LV�HUQRJ ZHLQLJ�EHNHQG�RYHU�GH�DDUG�YDQ�HUYDULQJHQ�LQ�GH�YROZDVVHQ�MDUHQ�GLH�HHQ�EOLMYHQGHYHUDQGHULQJ�LQ�NZHWVEDDUKHLG�RI�ZHHUEDDUKHLG�NXQQHQ�YHURRU]DNHQ��2UPHO��5LMVGLMN������� (HQ� VWDELHOH� UHODWLH� HQ� HHQ� YDVWH� EDDQ� OLMNHQ� GH� NZHWVEDDUKHLG� WH� YHUPLQGHUHQ�2UPHO��GH� -RQJ��������5XWWHU�� ������� HQ� µJHFRQWUROHHUGH¶� VWUHVVYROOH� HUYDULQJHQ� GHZHHUEDDUKHLG�WH�YHUJURWHQ��$QGUHZV�HW�DO���������8LWORNNHQGH�HUYDULQJHQ6WUHVVYROOH� OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� YHUKRJHQ� KHW� ULVLFR� RS� GHSUHVVLH� �%URZQ� � +DUULV������� -HQDZD\� � 3D\NHUO�� ������ 2UPHO�� ������� %LM� YURXZHQ� JDDW� KHW� YRRUDO� RPJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�RS�KHW�LQWHUSHUVRRQOLMNH�YODN��%URZQ�HW�DO����������ELM�RXGHUHQ�]LMQ�GH]HYDDN�DDQ�GH� JH]RQGKHLG�JHUHODWHHUG� �%ULOPDQ��2UPHO�� �������*HEHXUWHQLVVHQ�GLH�GHHUQVW� �KRSHORRVKHLG�� YDQ� HHQ� DO� ODQJHU� EHVWDDQGH� PRHLOLMNKHLG� EHQDGUXNNHQ� RIYHUHUJHUHQ� HQ� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� GLH� LHPDQGV� KRRIGEURQ� YDQ� HLJHQZDDUGH� DDQWDVWHQ�YHUKRJHQ�KHW�ULVLFR�RS�GHSUHVVLH�L�H�]��PHW�HHQ�IDFWRU�WZHH�WRW�GULH��%URZQ�HW�DO���������9RRUEHHOGHQ�YDQ�GH�HHUVWH�FDWHJRULH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�]LMQ�� 8LWKXLV]HWWLQJ�YDQ�HHQ�ELMVWDQGVPRHGHU�GLH�GRRU�FKURQLVFKH�ILQDQFLsOH�SUREOHPHQ�GHKXXU�QLHW�PHHU�NDQ�EHWDOHQ�� 9URXZ� GLH� KRRUW� GDW� KDDU� DDQ� DOFRKRO� YHUVODDIGH� HFKWJHQRRW� HHQ� HUQVWLJYHUNHHUVRQJHOXN�KHHIW�YHURRU]DDNW�9RRUEHHOGHQ�YDQ�GH�WZHHGH�FDWHJRULH�]LMQ�� +HW�RQWVODJ�YDQ�HHQ�RQJHWURXZGH��NLQGHUOR]H�DGYRFDDW�YRRU�ZLH�]LMQ�ZHUN�]LMQ�OXVWHQ OHYHQ�LV�� (HQ�QLHW�EXLWHQVKXLV�ZHUNHQGH�YURXZ�PHW�WZHH�MRQJH�NLQGHUHQ��GLH�RQWGHNW�GDW�ppQYDQ KDDU�NLQGHUHQ�DDQ�GUXJV�YHUVODDIG�LV��+DDU�PDQ�YHUZLMW�KDDU�JHIDDOG�WH�KHEEHQDOV PRHGHU�+HW�HIIHFW�YDQ�GHUJHOLMNH��YDDN�PHW�YHUOLHV�YDQ�HLJHQZDDUGH�RI�VWDWXV�JHSDDUG�JDDQGH�QHJDWLHYH�HUYDULQJHQ�OLMNW�HFKWHU�QLHW�EHSHUNW�WH�EOLMYHQ�WRW�GHSUHVVLH��9DQ�GH�:LOOLJH�HWDO����������2RN�SHUVRQHQ�PHW�HHQ�DQJVWVWRRUQLV�RI�SV\FKRWLVFKH�HSLVRGH�HUYDUHQ�YDNHUGDQ� FRQWUROHV� GHUJHOLMNH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� LQ� GH� PDDQGHQ� YRRU� KHW� XLWEUHNHQ� YDQ� GHHSLVRGH��-HQDZD\��3D\NHO���������'H�LQ�GH�OLWHUDWXXU�JHUDSSRUWHHUGH�UHODWLHYH�ULVLFR¶V�55�� YRRU� KHW� YHUEDQG� WXVVHQ� KHW� PHHPDNHQ� YDQ� HHQ� ]HHU� QHJDWLHYH� JHEHXUWHQLV� HQGHSUHVVLH�L�H�]��YDULsUHQ�YDQ�������&RRNH��������2UPHO���������+HW�55�OLMNW�ELM�YURXZHQKRJHU�HQ�ELM�UHFLGLHYHQ�ODJHU� WH�]LMQ��9DQZHJH�GH�KRJHUH�SUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�ELMYURXZHQ��KHHIW�KHW�RQGHU]RHN�QDDU�GHSUHVVRJHQH�HUYDULQJHQ�]LFK�YRRUDO�JHFRQFHQWUHHUGRS YURXZHQ��'H�DDUG�YDQ�GHSUHVVRJHQH�HUYDULQJHQ�ELM�PDQQHQ� VWDDW� QRJ�RQYROGRHQGHYDVW��PDDU�EHWUHIW�PRJHOLMN�YRRUDO�YHUOLHV�YDQ�VWDWXV�&RQFOXVLHV'H� HWLRORJLH� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH� LV�PXOWLIDFWRULHHO� HQ� FRPSOH[��9HOH� HQGRJHQH� HQ� H[RJHQHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� VSHOHQ�� LQ� LQWHUDFWLH� PHW� OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�� HHQ� URO�� 'H� XQLHNHELMGUDJH� YDQ� YHHO� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� LV� GRRU� GH� EHSHUNWH� NHQQLV� RYHU� KXQ� RQGHUOLQJHDIKDQNHOLMNKHLG�WKDQV�QRJ�QLHW�WH�NZDQWLILFHUHQ�

Page 52: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

2S� GLW� PRPHQW� OLMNHQ� JHQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ�� �VRFLDDO�� FRJQLWLHYH� EHSHUNLQJHQ�QHXURWLFLVPH�HQ�HHQ�ODJH�HLJHQZDDUGH�GH�EHODQJULMNVWH�SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH�ULVLFRIDFWRUHQYRRU� GHSUHVVLH�� (HQ� FRQIOLFWXHX]H� JH]LQVVLWXDWLH� HQ� DUPRHGH� ]LMQ� ZDDUVFKLMQOLMN� GHEHODQJULMNVWH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YRRU� HHQ� VRFLDOH� NZHWVEDDUKHLG�� WHUZLMOOHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� GLH� HHQ� �� DO� JHULQJH� �� HLJHQZDDUGH� RI� VRFLDOH� VWDWXV� YHUGHUDDQWDVWHQ�PRJHOLMN�GH�EHODQJULMNVWH�XLWORNNHQGH�IDFWRUHQ�YRUPHQ�

���� $QJVW��HQ�VRPDWRIRUPH�VWRRUQLVVHQ$QJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� NHQPHUNHQ� ]LFK� GRRU� H[FHVVLHYH� FRJQLWLHYH� �YUHHV��� JHGUDJVPDWLJH�YHUPLMGLQJ�� HQ�VRPDWLVFKH� �IULJKW�IOLJKW�ILJKW� UHDFWLH��YHUVFKLMQVHOHQ�RS�YHUPHHQGH�RIUHsOH�GUHLJHQGH�VLWXDWLHV���%LM�VRPDWRIRUPH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�LV�HU�VSUDNH�YDQ�RQYHUNODDUEDUHOLFKDPHOLMNH� NODFKWHQ� RI� DEQRUPDDO� ]LHNWHJHGUDJ� �µ$ WHQGHQF\� WR� H[SHULHQFH� DQGFRPPXQLFDWH�VRPDWLF�GLVWUHVV�DQG�V\PSWRPV�XQDFFRXQWHG�IRU�E\�SDWKRORJLFDO�ILQGLQJV�WR� DWWULEXWH� WKHP� WR� SK\VLFDO� LOOQHVV�� DQG� WR� VHHN�PHGLFDO� KHOS� IRU� WKHP¶� �/LSRZVNL�������� 'LW� KRRIGVWXN� EHKDQGHOW� GH� DQJVW�� HQ� VRPDWRIRUPH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� JH]DPHQOLMN�'H]H�NHX]H�KHHIW�HHQ�EDVLV�LQ�GH�JHVFKLHGHQLV��$DQ�KHW�HLQGH�YDQ�GH�YRULJH�HHXZ�ZHUGYRRU KHW� HHUVW�� ELQQHQ� GH� GLDJQRVWLVFKH� YHUJDDUEDN� GHU� QHXUDVWKHQLH� HHQ� RQGHUVFKHLGDDQJHEUDFKW� WXVVHQ� ZDW� ZLM� QX� JURIZHJ� NHQQHQ� DOV� UHVSHFWLHYHOLMN� GH� DQJVW�� HQ� GHVRPDWRIRUPH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� �%HUULRV� � 3RUWHU�� ������� � 5HFHQW� RQGHU]RHN� VXJJHUHHUWERYHQGLHQ� GDW�� RQGDQNV� GH� YHUVFKHLGHQKHLG� LQ� V\PSWRPHQ�� DQJVW�� HQ� VRPDWRIRUPHVWRRUQLVVHQ� HHQ� JHPHHQVFKDSSHOLMNH� JHQHWLVFKH� EDVLV� KHEEHQ� �.HQGOHU� HW� DO��� ����D��'H� � PDDQG�� HQ� MDDUSUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� LQ� 1HGHUODQG� �DOOH� '60�,,,�5GLDJQRVHV��H[FOXVLHI�SRVWWUDXPDWLVFKH�VWUHVVVWRRUQLV��]LMQ�UHVSHFWLHYHOLMN������HQ�������%LMO�HW�DO�������E���'H�1HGHUODQGVH�JHJHYHQV�VXJJHUHUHQ�GDW�GH�HQNHOYRXGLJH�IRELH�KHWPHHVW� HQ� GH� REVHVVLHI�FRPSXOVLHYH� VWRRUQLV� �2&6�� KHW� PLQVW� SUHYDOHQW� LV� $QGHUHDQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� ]LMQ� GH� DJRUDIRELH� �DQJVW� YRRU� RSHQ� UXLPWHV� RI� PHQLJWHV��� GHSDQLHNVWRRUQLV�� GH� VRFLDOH� IRELH� HQ� GH� JHJHQHUDOLVHHUGH� DQJVWVWRRUQLV� �RQJHULFKWHFRQWLQXH� DQJVW� HQ� SLHNHUHQ��� 9RRU� GH� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� KHW� SRVWWUDXPDWLVFK� VWUHVVV\QGURRP��3766���HHQ�V\QGURRP�YDQ�DQJVWV\PSWRPHQ��YHUPLMGLQJ�HQ�JHJHQHUDOLVHHUGHK\SHUDOHUWKHLG�� GDW� DDQVOXLWHQG� RS� HHQ� H[FHVVLHI� VWUHVVYROOH� JHEHXUWHQLV� RQWVWDDW� ]LMQDOOHHQ�EXLWHQODQGVH�JHJHYHQV�EHVFKLNEDDU��'H���PDDQGV�SUHYDOHQWLH�ZDV�LQ�$PHULNDDQVRQGHU]RHN������YRRU�YURXZHQ�HQ������YRRU�PDQQHQ��6WHLQ�HW�DO���������7UHQGJHJHYHQV� RYHU� DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� ]LMQ� VFKDDUV�� ,Q� JHJHYHQV� DINRPVWLJ� XLWKXLVDUWVSUDNWLMNHQ�ZRUGW�HHQ�VWLMJLQJ�JH]LHQ�LQ�GH�DIJHORSHQ�MDUHQ��5XZDDUG��.UDPHUV��������'H]H�LV�PRJHOLMN�WH�ZLMWHQ�DDQ�HHQ�EHWHUH�KHUNHQQLQJ�GRRU�GH�KXLVDUWV�2YHU� GH� FODVVLILFDWLH�� HQ� GHUKDOYH� RRN� GH� HSLGHPLRORJLH� YDQ� GH� VRPDWRIRUPHVWRRUQLVVHQ�� EHVWDDW� YHHO� RQGXLGHOLMNKHLG�� %RYHQGLHQ� LV� VRPDWLVDWLH� ELM� XLWVWHN� HHQFXOWXXUDIKDQNHOLMN� IHQRPHHQ� �/LSRZVNL�� ������� ]RGDW� JHJHYHQV� XLW� EXLWHQODQGVRQGHU]RHN�QLHW�EUXLNEDDU�]LMQ�RP�HHQ�LQGUXN�WH�NULMJHQ�YDQ�GH�SUHYDOHQWLH�LQ�1HGHUODQG� �'HPRJUDILVFKH�IDFWRUHQ'H�SLHNLQFLGHQWLH�YDQ�2&6�HQ�SDQLHNVWRRUQLV�OLJW�URQG�KHW���VWH�OHYHQVMDDU��:LWWFKHQ������� HQ� YDQ� GH� VRFLDOH� IRELH� LQ� GH� DGROHVFHQWLH� �.DVSHU�� �������2YHULJHQV� JHOGW� GDWYHHO� DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� UHHGV�KXQ�YRRUERGHQ� LQ�GH� NLQGHUMDUHQ� KHEEHQ� �'RXJODVV� HW� DO��

Page 53: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

�������9URXZHQ�KHEEHQ��PHW�XLW]RQGHULQJ�YDQ�VRFLDOH�IRELH�HQ�2&6��HHQ�WZHH�NHHU�]RKRRJ ULVLFR� RS� HHQ� DQJVWVWRRUQLV� GDQ� PDQQHQ�� ,Q� YHUJHOLMNLQJ� WRW� GHSUHVVLH� KHEEHQDQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�HHQ�FKURQLVFKHU�EHORRS��.DVSHU��������1HHOHPDQ�HW�DO���������6NRRJ�6NRRJ�� �������'H�'60�,,,� GLDJQRVH� VRPDWLVDWLHVWRRUQLV� NRPW� SUDNWLVFK� JH]LHQ� DOOHHQELM YURXZHQ�YRRU� HQ�RSHQEDDUW� ]LFK�SHU�GHILQLWLH�YRRU� KHW� ��H� OHYHQVMDDU� �ppQ� YDQ� GHGLDJQRVWLVFKH�FULWHULD�EHWUHIW�GH]H�OHHIWLMGVJUHQV��(QGRJHQH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ*HQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ*HQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� VSHOHQ� HHQ� URO� LQ� GH� HWLRORJLH� YDQ� DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�� PDDU� GHPHFKDQLVPHQ�YDQ�RYHUHUYLQJ�]LMQ�RQGXLGHOLMN��7ZHHOLQJVWXGLHV�VXJJHUHUHQ�GDW�������YDQ� GH� YDWEDDUKHLG� YRRU� DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� JHQHWLVFK� EHSDDOG� LV� �&OLIIRUG� HW� DO��� �����7RUJHUVHQ���������'LW�JHOGW�RRN�YRRU�GH�3766��'DYLGVRQ�HW�DO����������'H�FRQFRUGDQWLHYRRU GH� SDQLHNVWRRUQLV� LV� ����RQGHU�PRQR]\JRWH� HQ� ����RQGHU� GL]\JRWH� WZHHOLQJHQ�0F*XIILQ� HW� DO��� ������ 0HULNDQJDV� � 6ZHQGVHQ�� ������� 2QGHU]RHNVUHVXOWDWHQVXJJHUHUHQ� GDW� JHJHQHUDOLVHHUGH� DQJVWVWRRUQLV� HQ� GHSUHVVLH� JH]DPHQOLMN� RYHUHUYHQ�.HQGOHU�HW�DO����������+HW]HOIGH�OLMNW� WH�JHOGHQ�YRRU�GH�SDQLHN��HQ�VRPDWLVDWLHVWRRUQLV�.HQGOHU�HW�DO�������D������E��3HUVRRQOLMNKHLG%LM�GH�PHHUGHUKHLG�YDQ�GH�SDWLsQWHQ�PHW�HHQ�DQJVWVWRRUQLV�LV�HU�YyyU�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�GHVWRRUQLV� VSUDNH� YDQ� GH� DDQZH]LJKHLG� YDQ� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVWUHNNHQ� ]RDOV� H[FHVVLHYHJHUHPGKHLG�� YHUPLMGLQJ�� QHXURWLFLVPH�� HQ� HHQ� WHQGHQV� H[FHVVLHI� WH� UHDJHUHQ� RSVWUHVVYROOH� VLWXDWLHV� �&ORQLQJHU�� ������� 3URVSHFWLHI� RQGHU]RHN� VXJJHUHHUW� GDW� KHW� KLHUJDDW� RP� HHQ� EHODQJULMNH� GHWHUPLQDQW�� PDDU� GDW� GH]H� QLHW� VSHFLILHN� LV� YRRUDQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ��2RN�KHW�ULVLFR�RS�GHSUHVVLH�LV�YHUKRRJG��(U�]LMQ�DDQZLM]LQJHQ�GDW�GH]HSHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVWUHNNHQ�� JHFRPELQHHUG� PHW� LPSXOVLYLWHLW� HQ� DJUHVVLH�� KHW� ULVLFRYHUKRJHQ�GDW�GH�DQJVW�GHSUHVVLH�]DO�OHLGHQ�WRW�VRPDWLVDWLH�ELM�YURXZHQ�HQ�WRW�DQWLVRFLDDOJHGUDJ� �HHQ� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGV�� VWRRUQLV�� HQ�PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN� ELM�PDQQHQ� �%DWWDJOLD� HWDO��� ������� +HW� ]RJHQDDPGH� W\SH� $�KRVWLOLWHLWVFRPSOH[� �LQJHKRXGHQ� DJUHVVLH�RQYHUPRJHQ�WRW�KHW�XLWHQ�YDQ�HPRWLHV��YHUWRRQW�TXD�XLWLQJVYRUP��HHQ�JHOLMNHQLV�PHW�GHSHUVRRQOLMNKHLGWUHNNHQ�GLH�KHW�ULVLFR�RS�VRPDWLVDWLH�YHUKRJHQ�6RPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�HQ�HHUGHUH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ(U� LV� HHQ� VWHUN� YHUEDQG� WXVVHQ� SDQLHNVWRRUQLV� HQ� DVWPD� �&DUU�� ������� PDDU� RRNELMYRRUEHHOG�KDUWNOHSDIZLMNLQJHQ�JHYRQGHQ��.DWHUQGDKO���������%LM�GH�DVVRFLDWLH�WXVVHQDVWPD� HQ� SDQLHNVWRRUQLV� JDDW� KHW� RP� HHQ� ZHGHU]LMGVH� EHwQYORHGLQJ�� HHQ� DDQYDO� YDQNRUWDGHPLJKHLG�NDQ�HHQ�SDQLHNDDQYDO�XLWORNNHQ�HQ�RPJHNHHUG�(U� LV� YHHO� JHVSHFXOHHUG� RYHU� GH� URO� YDQ� KHUVHQEHVFKDGLJLQJHQ� �PRJHOLMNWHQJHYROJH�YDQ�SHULQDWDOH�FRPSOLFDWLHV�]RDOV�]XXUVWRIWHNRUW��ELM�GH�2&6��$DQZLM]LQJHQYRRU HHQ�GHUJHOLMN�YHUEDQG�EOLMYHQ�HFKWHU�NDULJ��ZRUGHQ�DOOHHQ�JHUDSSRUWHHUG�ELM�PDQQHQ�/HQVL�HW� DO��������� HQ�QLHW� JHVWDDIG�GRRU� UHFHQW�EHYRONLQJVRQGHU]RHN� �'RXJODV� HW� DO���������2QGHU]RHN�QDDU�GH�QHXURELRORJLVFKH�DFKWHUJURQGHQ�YDQ�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�ZRUGWJHSODDJG� GRRU� KHW� PRHLOLMNH� RQGHUVFKHLG� WXVVHQ� GH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� GH� GLDJQRVH�DQJVWVWRRUQLV��HQ�GH�ELMYHUVFKLMQVHOHQ�YDQ�GH�VWRRUQLV��0HW�EHWUHNNLQJ�WRW�GH�2&6�YDOWRRN WH� YHUPHOGHQ� GDW� GHSUHVVLH� RS� GH� NLQGHUOHHIWLMG� HQ� YURHJ� PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLNVSHFLILHNH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�]LMQ��'RXJODV�HW�DO���������

Page 54: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

([RJHQH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ6(6��YHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ�HQ�OHHIYRUP(HQ�ODDJ�RSOHLGLQJV��HQ�LQNRPHQVQLYHDX�LV�JHDVVRFLHHUG�PHW�HHQ�KRJHUH�SUHYDOHQWLH�YDQDQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� �%LMO� HW� DO��� ����E��� $QJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� NRPHQ� YDNHU� YRRU� ELMDOOHHQVWDDQGHQ��YRRUDO�JHVFKHLGHQHQ���+HW�EOLMIW�HFKWHU�RQGXLGHOLMN�ZDW�KLHU�RRU]DDN�HQJHYROJ�LV��2RN�]RX�KHW�NXQQHQ�]LMQ�GDW�GH]H�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�QLHW�]R]HHU�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�DOVZHO KHW�EHORRS��GH�GXXU�HQ�HUQVW��YDQ�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�EHwQYORHGHQ��,Q�WHJHQVWHOOLQJ�WRWGH DIIHFWLHYH� HQ� GH� PLGGHOHQVWRRUQLVVHQ�� EHVWDDW� HU� JHHQ� VLJQLILFDQW� YHUEDQG� WXVVHQYHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ�HQ�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�&XOWXUHOH�IDFWRUHQ+RHZHO� HU� JHHQ� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� YHUVFKLOOHQ� ]LMQ� LQ� SUHYDOHQWLH� HQ� LQFLGHQWLH� YDQDQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� LQ� YHUVFKLOOHQGH� FXOWXUHQ�� LV� ZpO� GXLGHOLMN� GDW� ELQQHQ� QLHW�ZHVWHUVHFXOWXUHQ�HPRWLRQHOH�SUREOHPHQ�YDNHU�JHVRPDWLVHHUG�ZRUGHQ��)DURRT��������5DPSHQ'H� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� DQJVW�� LQ� KHW� ELM]RQGHU� 3766�� KDQJW� XLWHUDDUG� VDPHQ� PHW� GHIUHTXHQWLH� ZDDUPHH� JURRWVFKDOLJH� GUDPDWLVFKH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� ]LFK� YRRUGRHQ� �RRUORJ�QDWXXUUDPSHQ��� ,Q� KHW� DOJHPHHQ� JHOGW� GDW� QDDUPDWH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� DOV� RQYHUZDFKWHU�RQFRQWUROHHUEDDUGHU�HQ�EHGUHLJHQGHU�ZRUGHQ�HUYDUHQ��GH�NDQV�GDW�]LFK�3766�RQWZLNNHOWKRJHU�LV�/HYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ.ZHWVEDDUKHLGYHUKRJHQGH�HUYDULQJHQ.LQGHUHQ� YDQ� ZLH� GH� PRHGHU� YURHJWLMGLJ� VWHUIW� RI� GLH� WH� PDNHQ� NULMJHQ� PHWHFKWVFKHLGLQJHQ�� KHEEHQ� HHQ� VWHUN� YHUKRRJGH� NDQV� ODWHU� HHQ� SDQLHNVWRRUQLV� WHRQWZLNNHOHQ� �/LQGVH\� HW� DO��� ������� 'H]H� YHUEDQGHQ� OLMNHQ� VSHFLILHN� WH� ]LMQ� YRRUSDQLHNVWRRUQLV� HQ� QLHW� YRRU� DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� LQ� KHW� DOJHPHHQ� WH� JHOGHQ�� 6HNVXHHOPLVEUXLN� LV�ZDDUVFKLMQOLMN� HHQ� VSHFLILHNH� GHWHUPLQDQW� YDQ� DEQRUPDDO� ]LHNWHJHGUDJ� HQVRPDWLVDWLH�RS�ODWHUH�OHHIWLMG��6DOPRQ��&DOGHUEDQN���������(U�LV�HFKWHU�RRN�RQGHU]RHNGDW� VXJJHUHHUW� GDW� KHW� KLHU� HHQ� GHWHUPLQDQW� YDQ� SV\FKLDWULVFKH� SUREOHPDWLHN� LQ� KHWDOJHPHHQ�EHWUHIW��0F&DXOH\�HW�DO����������]LH�RRN�SDUDJUDIHQ�������HQ ����� ,QDGHTXDWHRXGHUOLMNH� ]RUJ� �ELMYRRUEHHOG� GRRU� ]LHNWH�� HQ� ]LHNWH� YDQ� KHW� NLQG� ]HOI�� ]LMQGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YRRU�ODWHU�DEQRUPDDO�]LHNWHJHGUDJ��&UDLJ�HW�DO���������(pQ� YDQ� GH� PHHVW� VSHFLILHNH� YRRUVSHOOHUV� �RI� YURHJH� XLWLQJHQ�� YDQSDQLHNVWRRUQLV�LV�VFKRROIRELH��'HOWLWR��+DKQ���������6FKRROIRELVFKH�NLQGHUHQ�NRPHQYDNHU� XLW� IDPLOLHV� ZDDU� YHHO� OLFKDPHOLMNH� pQ� SV\FKLDWULVFKH� ]LHNWHQ� YRRUNRPHQ�&KULVWHQVHQ��0RUWHQVHQ���������=LM�NXQQHQ�RQGHUVFKHLGHQ�ZRUGHQ�YDQ�NLQGHUHQ�PHWDOOHHQ� OLFKDPHOLMNH� NODFKWHQ�� GLH� HHQ� YHUKRRJG� ULVLFR� KHEEHQ� RS� SV\FKLDWULVFKHSUREOHPDWLHN�LQ�KHW�DOJHPHHQ��+RWRSI�HW�DO���������8LWORNNHQGH�HUYDULQJHQ(U� ]LMQ� EHSHUNWH� DDQZLM]LQJHQ� GDW� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�� GRRU� KXQ� VSHFLILHNH� EHWHNHQLV�YHUEDQG�KRXGHQ�PHW�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ� ppQ�EHSDDOG� W\SH� DQJVWVWRRUQLV� �)LQOD\�-RQHV�%URZQ��������� �'H�KHOIW�YDQ�GH�SDWLsQWHQ�PHW�VRFLDOH� IRELH�JHHIW�DDQ�GDW�]H�YODN�YyyUKHW� XLWEUHNHQ� YDQ� GH� NODFKWHQ� HHQ� VRFLDDO� EHVFKDPHQGH� VLWXDWLH� HUYRHUHQ� �.DVSHU�

Page 55: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

�������6WUHVVYROOH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�]LMQ�RRN�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�VRPDWLVDWLH��%DVV�������HQ� NXQQHQ� DIKDQNHOLMN� YDQ� KXQ� DDUG� RI� EHWHNHQLV�� RRN� VSHFLILHN� ]LMQ� YRRU� KHW� W\SHV\PSWRRP� GDW� ]LFK� RQWZLNNHOW� �$QGUHZV� � +RXVH�� ������� (HQ� SDQLHNDDQYDO� NDQ�GRRUGDW ]LM�JHSDDUG�JDDW�PHW�KDUWNODFKWHQ��RS�]LFK]HOI�DDQOHLGLQJ�JHYHQ�WRW�VRPDWRIRUPHVWRRUQLVVHQ�ZDDULQ�YHUPHHQGH�KDUWNODFKWHQ�FHQWUDDO�VWDDQ�&RQFOXVLHV+HW�YDOW�RS��GDW�LQ�YHUJHOLMNLQJ�PHW�GHSUHVVLH��GH�HWLRORJLH�YDQ�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�PLQGHUJRHG�LQ�NDDUW�JHEUDFKW�LV��,Q�:HVWHUVH�FXOWXUHQ�LV�WXVVHQ�GH��������YDQ�KHW�YyyUNRPHQYDQ� DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� EHSDDOG� GRRU� JHQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ�� (U� ]LMQ� DDQZLM]LQJHQ� YRRUJHQHWLVFKH�FRPSRQHQWHQ�GLH�DOOH�HPRWLRQHOH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��GXV�LQFOXVLHI�3766��GHSUHVVLHHQ� G\VWK\PLH�� JHPHHQ� KHEEHQ�� 'DDUQDDVW� ]LMQ� HU� LQGLFDWLHV� YRRU� VWRRUQLVVSHFLILHNHJHQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� YRRU� RQGHUPHHU� GH� JHJHQHUDOLVHHUGH� DQJVW� LQ� FRPELQDWLH� PHWGHSUHVVLH��YRRU�SDQLHNVWRRUQLV�HQ�YRRU�VRPDWLVDWLH�9RRUDOVQRJ�]LMQ�HU�JHHQ�DDQZLM]LQJHQ�GDW�SHUVRQHQ�PHW�HHQ�YHUKRRJG�ULVLFR�RSHHQ�DQJVWVWRRUQLV�RS�EDVLV�YDQ�UHHGV�DDQZH]LJH�SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVWUHNNHQ�RQGHUVFKHLGHQNXQQHQ� ZRUGHQ�� :pO� OLMNW� GH� FRPELQDWLH� LPSXOVLYLWHLW� HQ� YHUPLMGLQJ� HHQ� UHODWLHIVSHFLILHNH�GHWHUPLQDQW�WH�]LMQ�YDQ�VRPDWLVDWLH�1RJ�DIJH]LHQ�YDQ�HYHQWXHOH�JHQHWLVFKH�HIIHFWHQ�OLMNW�DEQRUPDDO�]LHNWHJHGUDJ�LQIDPLOLHV WH�FOXVWHUHQ��6HNVXHHO�PLVEUXLN�LV�ZDDUVFKLMQOLMN�HHQ�JHQHULHNH�GHWHUPLQDQW�YDQSV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�PDDU�PRJHOLMN�PHW�HHQ�UHODWLHI�VSHFLILHN�HIIHFW�RS�VRPDWLVDWLH�6WUHVVYROOH�HUYDULQJHQ�YHUKRJHQ�GH�NDQV�RS�ZHONH�HPRWLRQHOH�VWRRUQLV�GDQ�RRN��(U�]LMQHFKWHU�ZHO�HQLJH�DDQZLM]LQJHQ�GDW�KHW�W\SH�JHEHXUWHQLV��WHVDPHQ�PHW�GH�GDDURSYROJHQGHZLM]H YDQ�EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJ�HQ�FRSLQJ��GH�DDUG�YDQ�GH�VWRRUQLV�PHGH�NDQ�EHSDOHQ��+HWLV EHNHQG��GDW� HUYDULQJHQ� GLH� HHQ� EHGUHLJLQJ� LQKRXGHQ�PHHU� VSHFLILHNH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ]LMQ YRRU�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�GDQ�ELMYRRUEHHOG�YHUOLHVHUYDULQJHQ�

���� 6FKL]RIUHQLH�HQ�DDQYHUZDQWH�SV\FKRWLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ'H�EHODQJULMNVWH�YRUP�YDQ�SV\FKRWLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�EHWUHIW�VFKL]RIUHQLH��(U�LV�KLHU�YRRUJHNR]HQ�RP�RRN�GH�ELSRODLUH�VWRRUQLV��HHQ�VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLV�YROJHQV�GH�'60�,,,�5��LQGH]H�SDUDJUDDI�WH�EHKDQGHOHQ��YDQZHJH�HHQ�]HNHUH�V\PSWRPDWRORJLVFKH�HQ�HWLRORJLVFKHYHUZDQWVFKDS� WXVVHQ� GH]H� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� %LM� EHLGH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� JDDW� KHW� RP� FKURQLVFKHDDQGRHQLQJHQ�� GLH� JHNHQPHUNW� ZRUGHQ� GRRU� LQJULMSHQGH� HQ� YDDN� YRRUWGXUHQGHYHUDQGHULQJHQ� LQ� KHW� HPRWLRQHOH�� YHUVWDQGHOLMNH� HQ� VRFLDOH� IXQFWLRQHUHQ� YDQ� PHQVHQ�+HW�RQGHUVFKHLG� WXVVHQ�EHLGH�EHWUHIW�YRRUDO�GH�YHUDQGHULQJ� LQ� VWHPPLQJ� �GHSUHVVLH� HQPDQLH� GLH� ELM� GH� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLV� RSWUHHGW�� LQ� WHJHQVWHOOLQJ� WRW� GH� JHEUHNNLJHHPRWLRQHOH� EHWURNNHQKHLG�� GLH� QRJDO� HHQV� ELM� VFKL]RIUHQLH� YRRUNRPW�� 3V\FKRWLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ� GRRU� HHQ� OLFKDPHOLMNH� ]LHNWH� RI� PLGGHOHQJHEUXLN� EOLMYHQ� KLHUEXLWHQEHVFKRXZLQJ�

����� 6FKL]RIUHQLH6FKL]RIUHQLH�� LQFOXVLHI� YHUZDQWH� QLHW�DIIHFWLHYH� SV\FKRWLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ]RDOV� GHNRUWGXUHQGH� VFKL]RIUHQLIRUPH� SV\FKRVH� HQ� GH� ZDDQVWRRUQLV�� NHQPHUNW� ]LFK� GRRU

Page 56: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

VWRRUQLVVHQ�LQ�KHW�GHQNHQ��KDOOXFLQDWLHV�HQ�ZDQHQ���HQ�LQ�PHHU�RI�PLQGHUH�PDWH�RRN�LQKHW�YRHOHQ�HQ�LQ�GH�VRFLDOH�EHWURNNHQKHLG��0DDQG��HQ�OHYHQVSUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�VFKL]RIUHQLHOLJJHQ� URQG� GH� ����� HQ� ����� LQ� 1HGHUODQGV� RQGHU]RHN� �LQ� EXLWHQODQG� WRW� ����� 'HMDDUOLMNVH�LQFLGHQWLH�LV�RQJHYHHU���i���SHU���������%LMO�HW�DO�������E��%URPHW�HW�DO��������(DWRQ�HW�DO���������:LHUVPD��'H�-RQJ���������6RPPLJH�EXLWHQODQGVH�VWXGLHV�ZLM]HQ�RSHHQ� GDOLQJ� LQ� KHW� DDQWDO� VFKL]RIUHQLH� SDWLsQWHQ� PHW� HHQ� HHUVWH� RSQDPH� RI� DPEXODQWHEHKDQGHOLQJ�LQ�GH�SHULRGH�YDQ�RQJHYHHU������WRW�������'HU�HW�DO����������'H]H�WHQGHQVZRUGW QLHW�LQ�1HGHUODQG�HQ�(QJHODQG�WHUXJJHYRQGHQ��%UHZLQ�HW�DO���������2OGHKLQNHO�*LHO��������'HPRJUDILVFKH�IDFWRUHQ,Q� UHSUHVHQWDWLHYH� EXLWHQODQGVH� FRKRUWVWXGLHV� LV� HU� YRRU� VFKL]RIUHQLH� HQ� YHUZDQWHSV\FKRWLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�JHHQ�YHUVFKLO�LQ�GH�LQFLGHQWLH�WXVVHQ�PDQQHQ�HQ�YURXZHQ��'LWJHOGW�RRN�YRRU�FRKRUW��HQ�VXUYH\�RQGHU]RHN�LQ�1HGHUODQG��*LHO�HW�DO���������*RRGZLQ�-DPLVRQ���������6FKL]RIUHQLH�RQWVWDDW�LQ�YHHO�JHYDOOHQ�LQ�GH�ODWH�DGROHVFHQWLH�HQ�YURHJHYROZDVVHQKHLG�� DO� ZRUGW� GH� SUHFLH]H� KHUNHQQLQJ� HUYDQ� YDDN� ODWHU� GXLGHOLMN�� 'HPDQQHOLMNH�SDWLsQW� LV� LQ�GH�UHJHO�JHPLGGHOG���� MDDU�RXG�HQ�GH�YURXZHOLMNH�SDWLsQW����MDDU RXGHU� DOV� KHW� HHUVWH� FRQWDFW� YDQZHJH� GH� SV\FKRVH� PHW� GH� JHHVWHOLMNHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ�WRW�VWDQG�NRPW��+lIQHU�HW�DO���������������:LHUVPD�HW�DO����������'LWOHHIWLMGVYHUVFKLO�KHHIW�QLHW�]R]HHU�PHW�ELRORJLVFKH�YHUVFKLOOHQ�WH�PDNHQ��DOV�ZHO�PHW�HHQDQGHUH�NOLQLVFKH�SUHVHQWDWLH�RI�PHW�HHQ�YHUWUDDJG�KXOS]RHNJHGUDJ��%HLVHU�HW�DO���������(QGRJHQH�IDFWRUHQ*HQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ+HW�ULVLFR�RS�VFKL]RIUHQLH�LV�ELM�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�DDQPHUNHOLMN�YHUKRRJG�YHUJHOHNHQ�PHW�GDWLQ GH� DOJHPHQH� EHYRONLQJ�� ELM� RXGHUV� YDQ� HHQ� SDWLsQW� PHW� HHQ� VFKL]RIUHQLH� ���� ELMEURHUV HQ�]XVWHUV������ELM�HLJHQ�NLQGHUHQ�����HQ�ELM�WZHHGH��HQ�GHUGHJUDDGV�YHUZDQWHQWXVVHQ�GH����HQ�����$OV�EHLGH�RXGHUV�DDQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH�OLMGHQ�LV�GH�NDQV�GDDURS�ELM�KXQNLQGHUHQ� ���� �*RWWHVPDQ� � 6KLHOG�� ������� 'H� JHPLGGHOGH� FRQFRUGDQWLH� LQWZHHOLQJVWXGLHV�LV�����YRRU�PRQR]\JRWH�HQ�����YRRU�GL]\JRWH�WZHHOLQJHQ��*HQHWLVFKHIDFWRUHQ� OLMNHQ� YRRU� WHQPLQVWH� ���� YHUDQWZRRUGHOLMN� WH� ]LMQ� YRRU� KHW� XLWHLQGHOLMNRQWVWDDQ�YDQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH� �9RQN�HW�DO����������2YHU�GH�ZLM]H�YDQ�RYHUHUYLQJ� LV� HFKWHUQRJ ZHLQLJ� GXLGHOLMNKHLG�� %LM� GH� PHHUGHUKHLG� YDQ� GH� SDWLsQWHQ� ��������� EOLMNWVFKL]RIUHQLH�RYHULJHQV�QLHW�LQ�GH�QDDVWH�IDPLOLH�YRRU�WH�NRPHQ�3HUVRRQOLMNKHLG6RPPLJH�JHGUDJV�� HQ�SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVNHQPHUNHQ�]LMQ�YRRUVSHOOHQG�YRRU�KHW�RSWUHGHQYDQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH��7HUXJJHWURNNHQKHLG��KHW�KHEEHQ�YDQ�RQJHZRQH�IDQWDVLHsQ�RI�VSHFLDOHLQWHUHVVHV�� KHW� RSWUHGHQ� YDQ� �WDDO�DFKWHUVWDQG�� GLVIXQFWLRQHUHQ� LQ� VRFLDDO� RS]LFKW� HQ� LQVFKRROSUHVWDWLHV� RI� HHQ� VFKL]RW\SLVFKH� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLG� �JHEUHNNLJH� VRFLDOH� HQHPRWLRQHOH� EHWURNNHQKHLG� HQ� LQWHUHVVH�� KHEEHQ� HHQ� ]ZDN� YHUEDQG� PHW� KHW� ODWHUHRSWUHGHQ YDQ�HHQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH��0DOPEHUJ�HW�DO���������6RPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�HQ�HHUGHUH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ6FKL]RIUHQLH� ZRUGW� WKDQV� EHVFKRXZG� DOV� HHQ� QHXURELRORJLVFKH� RQWZLNNHOLQJVVWRRUQLVZDDUELM QDDVW� JHQHWLVFKH� RRN� DQGHUH� IDFWRUHQ� PHH� EHSDOHQG� ]LMQ�� &RPSOLFDWLHV� URQG

Page 57: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

]ZDQJHUVFKDS�HQ�JHERRUWH�]LMQ�UHJHOPDWLJ�DOV�ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ�YRRU�VFKL]RIUHQLH�JHQRHPG�9HUGRX[� HW� DO��� ������ HQ� VSHOHQ� QDDU� VFKDWWLQJ� HHQ� URO� LQ� ���� YDQ� GH� JHYDOOHQ�9HUPRHGHOLMN�LV�HU�LQ�GH]H�JHYDOOHQ�VSUDNH�YDQ�HHQ�]XXUVWRIJHEUHN��ZDDUGRRU�VFKDGH�LVWRHJHEUDFKW� DDQ� GH� KHUVHQHQ�� *HERRUWH� LQ� GH� ZLQWHUPDDQGHQ�� YLUDOH� LQIHFWLHV� LQ� GHYLHUGH PDDQG�YDQ� GH� ]ZDQJHUVFKDS� HQ� EORRWVWHOOLQJ� DDQ� HUQVWLJH� RQGHUYRHGLQJ� �]RDOVWLMGHQV GH�KRQJHUZLQWHU��RI�JURWH�VSDQQLQJ� WLMGHQV�GH�]ZDQJHUVFKDS�YHUKRJHQ�GH�NDQVRS VFKL]RIUHQLH� �%URPHW� HW� DO��� ������(DWRQ� HW� DO��� ������:LHUVPD��'H� -RQJ��������2RN� QHXUR�DQDWRPLVFKH� DIZLMNLQJHQ� LQ� GH� KHUVHQHQ� ZRUGHQ� JH]LHQ� DOV� PRJHOLMNHULVLFRIDFWRUHQ�� HHQ� UHODWLHYH� �NOHLQH�� RPYDQJ� YDQ� GH� KHUVHQHQ� HQ� GH� WKDODPXV�� HQ� GHYHUJURWLQJ�YDQ�GH�GHUGH�YHQWULNHO��%XFKDQDQ�HW�DO����������+HW�RSWUHGHQ�YDQ�UHXPDWRwGHDUWULWLV�OLMNW�HHQ�EHVFKHUPHQGH�IDFWRU�WHJHQ�KHW�RSWUHGHQ�YDQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH��(DWRQ�HW�DO�������� 2QJHYHHU�����YDQ�PHQVHQ�PHW�HHQ�SV\FKRWLVFKH�VWRRUQLV�KHHIW�RRLW�LQ�]LMQ�OHYHQHHQ� GLDJQRVH� YDQ� PLGGHOHQDIKDQNHOLMNKHLG� �DOFRKRO�� GUXJV�� JHKDG�� 2RN� ]LMQ� HUFRQVLVWHQWH� EHYLQGLQJHQ� WHQ� DDQ]LHQ� YDQ� PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN� DOV� GHWHUPLQDQW� YDQ� KHWEHJLQ�RI�YDQ�GH�HUQVW�YDQ�GH�SV\FKRVH��5DELQRZLW]�HW�DO����������,Q�=ZHHGV�RQGHU]RHNZDV KHW�UHODWLHYH�ULVLFR�YDQ�HHQ�FDQQDELV�JHEUXLNHU�WHQ�RS]LFKWH�YDQ�HHQ�QLHW�JHEUXLNHU���� �$QGUHDVVRQ� HW� DO��� ������� ,Q� HLJHQ� ODQG� LV� DDQJHWRRQG� GDW� FDQQDELVJHEUXLN� LQ� GHUHJHO� YRRUDI� JDDW� DDQ� GH� VFKL]RIUHQH� SV\FKRVH� HQ� GDW� KHW� HHQ� WHUXJYDO� YHUYURHJW�/LQV]HQ�HW�DO����������+HW� LV�QRJ�QLHW�GXLGHOLMN�DDQJHWRRQG�GDW�JHEUXLN�YDQ�GUXJV�KHWRQWVWDDQ� YDQ� VFKL]RIUHQLH� YHURRU]DDNW�� (HQ� VFKL]RW\SLVFKH� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLG� NDQELMYRRUEHHOG�RRN�PHW�KHW�JHEUXLN�VDPHQKDQJHQ�([RJHQH�IDFWRUHQ6(6�HQ�OHHIYRUP'H� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� VFKL]RIUHQLH� LQ� GH� ODJHUH� VRFLDOH� VWUDWD� LV� YHHO� KRJHU� GDQ� LQ� GHKRJHUH��'LW�OLMNW�JURWHQGHHOV�KHW�JHYROJ�YDQ�GH�]LHNWH�WH�]LMQ��'RRU�GH�VRFLDOH��FRJQLWLHYHHQ�HPRWLRQHOH�EHSHUNLQJHQ�GLH�GH�VWRRUQLV�PHW�]LFK�PHH�EUHQJW��HQ�GLH�GHHOV�RRN�DO�DDQGH VWRRUQLV� YRRUDIJDDQ�� YHUVOHFKWHUW� KHW� VRFLDDO� HQ� EHURHSVPDWLJ� IXQFWLRQHUHQ�� ,Q� KHWDOJHPHHQ�EOLMNHQ�GH�SDWLsQWHQ�ZHO�LQ�VWDDW�HHQ�KRJH�RSOHLGLQJ�WH�YROJHQ��YDDN�EHWHU�GDQGLH YDQ�KXQ�RXGHUV���PDDU�QLHW�RP�YHUYROJHQV�LQ�HHQ�SDVVHQG�EHURHS�HU�PHH�DDQ�GH�VODJWH JDDQ� �:LHUVPD� HW� DO��� �������9RRUDO� GH�PDQQHOLMNH� VFKL]RIUHQLH� SDWLsQW� EOLMIW� YDDNRQJHKXZG� �PHHU�GDQ�������9URXZHQ�PHW� VFKL]RIUHQLH� ]LMQ�ZDW�EHWHU� LQ� VWDDW� RP�HHQKXZHOLMNVSDUWQHU�WH�YLQGHQ�HQ�YHUYROJHQV�WH�KRXGHQ�9HUVWHGHOLMNLQJ(U�LV�HHQ�YHUVFKLO�WXVVHQ�VWHGHOLMNH�HQ�UXUDOH�JHELHGHQ��'LW�EOLMNW�XLW�=ZHHGV��'HHQV�HQ1HGHUODQGV� RQGHU]RHN�� 2SJURHLHQ� LQ� VWHGHOLMNH� JHELHGHQ� YHUKRRJW� KHW� ULVLFR� RSVFKL]RIUHQLH� HQ� RYHULJH� SV\FKRVHQ� �55� YRRU� GH� KRRJVWH� XUEDQLVDWLHJUDDG� LV�����0DUFHOLV���������(HQ�GXLGHOLMNH�YHUNODULQJ�RQWEUHHNW�RYHULJHQV�0LJUDWLH(PLJUDWLH�XLW�KHW�&DUDwELVFKH�JHELHG�QDDU�:HVW�(XURSD��(QJHODQG�PDDU�RRN�1HGHUODQG�YRUPW HHQ� ULVLFRIDFWRU� YRRU� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� YDQ� VFKL]RIUHQLH�� 'H� LQFLGHQWLHFLMIHUV� YRRUHHUVWH�HQ�WZHHGH�JHQHUDWLHPLJUDQWHQ�XLW�$IUR�&DUDwELVFKH�HLODQGHQ�LQ�/RQGHQ�HQ�XLW�GH1HGHUODQGVH�$QWLOOHQ�HQ�6XULQDPH�LQ�1HGHUODQG�]LMQ�DDQPHUNHOLMN������NHHU��YHUKRRJG�+DUULVRQ�HW�DO���������.LQJ�HW�DO���������6HOWHQ�HW�DO����������'H�UHGHQHQ�GDDUYRRU�]LMQ

Page 58: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

QRJ�RQGXLGHOLMN��DO�OLJJHQ�]H�QLHW�LQ�GH�VIHHU�YDQ�PRHLOLMNKHGHQ�PHW�GH�GLDJQRVHVWHOOLQJRI UHJLVWUDWLHDUWHIDFWHQ�� 9HUPRHGHOLMN� LV� KHW� HHQ� FRPELQDWLH� YDQ� FXOWXUHOH� IDFWRUHQ�FRQVLVWHQWH� HQ� YHLOLJH� RSYRHGLQJVLWXDWLHV�� HQ� HFRQRPLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� �DUPRHGH�KXLVYHVWLQJ�� ZHUN�� GLH� KHW� ULVLFR� RS� HHQ� SV\FKRWLVFKH� VWRRUQLV� YHUJURWHQ�� :HOOLFKWKHEEHQ� ZH� WH� PDNHQ� PHW� HHQ� FRPELQDWLH� YDQ� YRRUWGXUHQGH� VWUHVVYROOHRPJHYLQJVIDFWRUHQ��GLH�EXLWHQJHZRRQ�NUDFKWLJ�LV�ELM�KHW�XLWORNNHQ�YDQ�HHQ�SV\FKRVH�ELMNZHWVEDUH�PHQVHQ�/HYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ+HW�XLWEUHNHQ�YDQ�HHQ�VFKL]RIUHQH�SV\FKRVH�JDDW�VLJQLILFDQW�YDNHU�JHSDDUG�PHW�HHQ�KRJHIUHTXHQWLH� DDQ� LQJULMSHQGH� OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� JHGXUHQGH� GH� GULH� YRRUDIJDDQGHPDDQGHQ� �%HEELQJWRQ� HW� DO��� ������� PDDU� HU� NXQQHQ� QDXZHOLMNV� YHUEDQGHQ� PHWVSHFLILHNH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�ZRUGHQ� DDQJHWRRQG�� ,Q� DOJHPHQH� ]LQ� OLMNHQ� ]H� KHW�PRPHQWYDQ�RQWVWDDQ�HQ�UHFLGLHI�WH�YHUYURHJHQ�&RQFOXVLHV'H�FRQFOXVLHV�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQ�GH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH�ZRUGHQ�LQ�SDUDJUDDI������EHVSURNHQ��WH]DPHQ�PHW�GLH�YRRU�GH�ELSRODLUH�VWRRUQLV�

������ %LSRODLUH�VWRRUQLV%LM� ELSRODLUH� VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ� JDDW� KHW� LQ� GH�PDQLVFKH� IDVH� RP� HHQ� DDQKRXGHQGHXIRULVFKH��RYHUPDWLJ�GUXNNH�RI�SULNNHOEDUH�VWHPPLQJ��%LMNRPHQGH�V\PSWRPHQ�NXQQHQHHQ� RSJHEOD]HQ� JHYRHO� YDQ� HLJHQZDDUGH� ]LMQ�� HHQ� DIJHQRPHQ� EHKRHIWH� DDQ� VODDS�FRQFHQWUDWLHVWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� DJLWDWLH� RI� RYHUGUHYHQ� EHZHHJOLMNKHLG� 3V\FKRWLVFKHV\PSWRPHQ��ELMYRRUEHHOG�HHQ�JURRWKHLGVZDDQ��KRHYHQ�QLHW�DOWLMG�DDQZH]LJ�WH�]LMQ��+HWWLMGLJ KHUNHQQHQ�YDQ�GH]H� VWRRUQLV�ZRUGW�RQGHUPHHU� EHPRHLOLMNW� GRRUGDW� KHW� ELSRODLUHNDUDNWHU�YDDN�SDV�ODDW�LQ�KHW�EHORRS�GXLGHOLMN�ZRUGW�� ,Q�HHQ�DDQ]LHQOLMN�DDQWDO�JHYDOOHQ�! �����JDDW�KHW�ELM�GH�HHUVWH�HSLVRGH�RP�HHQ�GHSUHVVLH�HQ�LV�GH�GLDJQRVH�DDQYDQNHOLMNHHQ� XQLSRODLUH� GHSUHVVLH��'H�PDDQG�� HQ� OLIHWLPH� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLVVHQOLJJHQ�URQG�GH������HQ�������%LMO�HW�DO�������E��.XSND��1ROHQ���������'H�MDDUOLMNVHLQFLGHQWLH�YDQ�QLHXZH�JHYDOOHQ�NRPW�XLW�RS���j���SHU���������%HEELQJWRQ��5DPDQD�������7RKHQ��*RRGZLQ���������(U� OLMNW� LQ�GH�WZHHGH�KHOIW�YDQ�GH���VWH�HHXZ�VSUDNHYDQ�HHQ�WRHQDPH�LQ�KHW�YRRUNRPHQ�YDQ�ELSRODLUH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�LQ�(XURSD��%HEELQJWRQ�5DPDQD�� ������ 5RELQV� � 5HJLHU�� ������� 'H]H� WRHQDPH� LV� LQ� YHUEDQG� JHEUDFKW� PHWLPPLJUDWLH��YRRUDO�YDQ�SHUVRQHQ�XLW�KHW�&DULELVFKH�JHELHG��9DQ�2V�HW�DO����������]LH�RRNKLHUQD��'HPRJUDILVFKH�IDFWRUHQ%LM� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ZRUGHQ�� HYHQDOV� ELM� VFKL]RIUHQLH�� JHHQ� RI� VOHFKWV� NOHLQHJHVODFKWVYHUVFKLOOHQ� DDQJHWURIIHQ� �%LMO� HW� DO��� ����E��� 'H� JHPLGGHOGH� OHHIWLMG� ELM� KHWRQWVWDDQ� YDQ� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� LV� RQJHYHHU� ��� MDDU� �*RRGZLQ� � -DPLVRQ�� ������PDDU VRPPLJH�JHYDOOHQ�EHJLQQHQ�]HOIV�QD�KHW���VWH�OHYHQVMDDU�

Page 59: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

(QGRJHQH�IDFWRUHQ*HQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ*HQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� VSHOHQ� HHQ� JURWH� URO� ELM� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� YDQ� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�9RQN�HW�DO����������'H�NDQV�RS�HHQ�ELSRODLUH�VWRRUQLV�LV�ELM�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�PHHU�GDQ�WLHQPDDO KRJHU�GDQ�LQ�GH�DOJHPHQH�EHYRONLQJ��.LQGHUHQ�YDQ�RXGHUV�YDQ�ZLH�WHQPLQVWH�ppQHHQ� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLV� KHHIW� HQ� GH� DQGHU� HYHQWXHHO� HHQ� DQGHUH� VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLV�KHEEHQ� ������� NDQV� RP� RRN� HHQ� VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLV� WH� NULMJHQ�� 9RRU� GH� ELSRODLUHVWRRUQLV� YDULsUHQ� GH� FRQFRUGDQWLHV� YDQ� ������� ELM�0=�WZHHOLQJHQ� HQ� YDQ� ������ ELM'=�WZHHOLQJHQ��0DLHU�HW�DO���������0F*XIILQ�HW�DO���������0HULNDQJDV��.XSIHU��������(YHQDOV�ELM�VFKL]RIUHQLH�LV�GH�ZLM]H�YDQ�RYHUHUYLQJ�RQGXLGHOLMN�3HUVRRQOLMNKHLG'XLGHOLMNH� JHGUDJV�� HQ� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVNHQPHUNHQ� GLH� YRRUVSHOOHQG� ]LMQ� YRRU� KHWRSWUHGHQ YDQ�HHQ�ELSRODLUH�VWRRUQLV�RQWEUHNHQ��'H�'60�PHOGW�LQ�]LMQ�YLHUGH�YHUVLH��GDWHHQ�DDQPHUNHOLMNH�PLQGHUKHLG�YDQ�DGROHVFHQWHQ�HHQ�SUHPRUELGH�JHVFKLHGHQLV�KHHIW�YDQODQJGXULJH�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ��VFKRROYHU]XLP�HQ�DIEUHNHQ�YDQ�GH�RSOHLGLQJ��DQWLVRFLDDOJHGUDJ�� HQ� PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN� �$3$�� ������� ,Q� KHW� DOJHPHHQ� WUHHGW� ELM� GH� ELSRODLUHVWRRUQLV��YHUJHOHNHQ�ELM�GH� VFKL]RIUHQH�VWRRUQLV��KHW�G\VIXQFWLRQHUHQ� ODWHU�RS�HQ� LV�KHWUHODWLHI�PLQGHU�HUQVWLJ�6RPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�HQ�HHUGHUH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ,Q� GH� WZHH� JURWH� $PHULNDDQVH� VWXGLHV� �GH� (&$�VWXGLH� HQ� GH� 1DWLRQDO� &RPRUELGLW\6WXGLH��EOHHN�GDW�LQ�PHHU�GDQ�����YDQ�GH�SDWLsQWHQ�PHW�ELSRODLUH�VWRRUQLV�RRN�RRLW�HHQGLDJQRVH YDQ�PLGGHOHQDIKDQNHOLMNKHLG��PHHVWDO�YDQ�DOFRKRO��ZDV�JHVWHOG��.HVVOHU�HW�DO��������:HLVVPDQ� HW� DO��� ������� 'H� EHYLQGLQJHQ� ]LMQ� LQFRQVLVWHQW� WHQ� DDQ]LHQ� YDQ� GLWPLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN� DOV� GHWHUPLQDQW� YDQ� KHW� EHJLQ� �YHUYURHJHQ�� RI� GH� HUQVW� YDQ� GHSV\FKRVH� �7RKHQ� � *RRGZLQ�� ������� ,Q� 1HGHUODQGV� RQGHU]RHN� LV� HU� VSUDNH� YDQ� HHQVWHUNH PDWH� YDQ� FR�PRUELGLWHLW� WXVVHQ� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLV� HQ� GUXJVDIKDQNHOLMNKHLG�25 ������5DYHOOL�HW�DO���������([RJHQH�IDFWRUHQ6(6�HQ�/HHIYRUP,Q� NOLQLVFKH� VWXGLHV� YLQGW�PHQ� HHQ� KRJHUH� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� GH� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLV� LQ� GHKRJHUH� VRFLDOH� NODVVHQ�� PDDU� QLHW� LQ� EHYRONLQJVWXGLHV�� 'LW� YHUVFKLO� ]RX� YHURRU]DDNWNXQQHQ� ZRUGHQ� GRRU�� DDQ� GH� VRFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKH� VWDWXV� JHUHODWHHUGH�� YHUVFKLOOHQ� LQKXOS]RHN�� HQ� RSQDPHJHGUDJ�� ,Q� GH�(&$�VWXGLH� EOHHN� GDW�PHQVHQ�PHW�PLQGHU� GDQ� ��MDDU RSOHLGLQJ� MXLVW� HHQ� KRJHUH� SUHYDOHQWLH� KDGGHQ� GDQ� PHQVHQ� PHW� HHQ� ODQJHUHRSOHLGLQJ� �25 �����:HLVVPDQ� HW� DO��� ������� 0HQVHQ� PHW� HHQ� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLV� ]LMQYDNHU�DOOHHQVWDDQG�RI�RQJHKXZG� �VDPHQZRQHQG��GDQ�JHKXZG��5HGHQ� LV�ZDDUVFKLMQOLMNKHW�YHUPLQGHUGH�YHUPRJHQ�RP�HHQ�KXZHOLMN�DDQ�WH�JDDQ�HQ�LQ�VWDQG�WH�KRXGHQ�9HUVWHGHOLMNLQJ�HQ�PLJUDWLH(U� LV�HHQ�YHUVFKLO� WXVVHQ�VWHGHOLMNH�HQ�UXUDOH�JHELHGHQ��+HW�ZRQHQ� LQ�HHQ�YHUVWHGHOLMNWJHELHG� LV� JHDVVRFLHHUG�PHW� HHQ� KRJHUH� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLV�� ,Q� GH� UHHGVHHUGHU� JHQRHPGH� (&$�VWXGLH� YDULHHUGH� GH� 25� WXVVHQ� ���� HQ� ���� �:HLVVPDQ� HW� DO�������� �

Page 60: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

(PLJUDWLH� OLMNW� HHQ� ULVLFRIDFWRU� YRRU� HHQ� ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLV�� PDDU� KHW� LV� QLHWGXLGHOLMN� RI� LQGLYLGXHQ� GLH� HHQ� DDQOHJ� YRRU� GH]H� VWRRUQLV� KHEEHQ� HPLJUHUHQ� RI� GDWIDFWRUHQ� GLH� YHUEDQG� KRXGHQ�PHW� KHW� HPLJUHUHQ� GH� ]LHNWH� ELM�PHQVHQ�PHW� HHQ� ]HNHUHNZHWVEDDUKHLG�GRHW�RQWVWDDQ��3RSH�HW�DO���������/HYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ+HW� XLWEUHNHQ� YDQ� HHQ� PDQLVFKH� SV\FKRVH� JDDW� VLJQLILFDQW� YDNHU� JHSDDUG� PHW� KHWRYHUPDWLJ� YRRUNRPHQ� YDQ� LQJULMSHQGH� OHYHQVHUYDULQJHQ� JHGXUHQGH� GH� GULHYRRUDIJDDQGH�PDDQGHQ��%HEELQJWRQ�HW�DO����������PDDU�HU�NXQQHQ�QDXZHOLMNV�YHUEDQGHQPHW� VSHFLILHNH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� ZRUGHQ� DDQJHWRRQG�� ,Q� KHW� DOJHPHHQ� OLMNHQ� VWUHVVYROOHJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� KHW� PRPHQW� YDQ� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� HQ� UHFLGLHI� WH� YHUYURHJHQ�� 'H� URO� YDQJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� LQ�GH�HWLRORJLH�YDQ�ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� LV�PLQGHU�GXLGHOLMN�GDQ�ELM�GHGHSUHVVLH��PDDU�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�HQ�VLWXDWLHV�GLH�YHUDQGHULQJHQ� LQ�FLUFDGLDQH�KRUPRQDOHULWPHQ�YHURRU]DNHQ�OLMNHQ�KHW�ULVLFR�RS�HHQ�GHSUHVVLHYH�HSLVRGH�WH�YHUJURWHQ�&RQFOXVLHV+HW� LV� DOJHPHHQ� DDQYDDUG� GDW� HU� LQ� GH� HWLRORJLH� YDQ� VFKL]RIUHQLH� LQ�PHHU� RI�PLQGHUHPDWH� VSUDNH� LV� YDQ� HHQ� JHQHWLVFKH� NZHWVEDDUKHLG�� GLH� RQGHU� EHSDDOGH� FRQGLWLHV� YDQELQQHQ�HQ�EXLWHQ�GH�SHUVRRQ�JHOHJHQ�LQYORHGHQ�HQ�RQWZLNNHOLQJHQ�WRW�HHQ�SV\FKRVH�YDQVFKL]RIUHQH�DDUG�DDQOHLGLQJ�JHHIW��'LW]HOIGH�JHOGW�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQ�GH�ELSRODLUH�VWRRUQLV�'H� HWLRORJLH� LV� YRRUDOVQRJ� RQEHJUHSHQ� HQ� GH� YRRUVSHOOHQGH� ZDDUGH� YDQ� VSHFLILHNHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�LV�NOHLQ�HQ�YROVWUHNW�RQYROGRHQGH�RP�WLMGLJ�HQ�QDXZNHXULJ�SHUVRQHQ�GLHLQ GH� WRHNRPVW� HHQ� VFKL]RIUHQH� SV\FKRVH� ]XOOHQ� RQWZLNNHOHQ� WH� KHUNHQQHQ�*H]RQGKHLGVUDDG���������+HW�YRRUNyPHQ�YDQ�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�SV\FKRVHQ�LV�WKDQV�QLHWPRJHOLMN�HQ�RRN�QLHW�ELQQHQ�KHW�HHUVWYROJHQGH�GHFHQQLXP�WH�YHUZDFKWHQ��%HwQYORHGLQJYDQ JHQRHPGH� ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ� HQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� LV� QDXZHOLMNV�PRJHOLMN� RPGDW�ZH� QLHWZHWHQ�ZDQQHHU�ZDW�ELM�ZLH�YDQ�GRRUVODJJHYHQGH�EHWHNHQLV�LV�YRRU�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�HHQHHUVWH�SV\FKRVH�

���� 9HUVODYLQJHQ9HUVODYLQJ�ZRUGW� KLHU� RSJHYDW� DOV�PLVEUXLN� HQ� DIKDQNHOLMNKHLG� YDQ� DOFRKRO� HQ� GUXJV�YROJHQV� GH� GLDJQRVWLVFKH� FULWHULD� ]RDOV� RPVFKUHYHQ� LQ� ,&'� HQ�'60�� (HQ� HHQGXLGLJHJHYDOVGHILQLWLH�LV�KHODDV�QLHW�YRRUKDQGHQ�HQ�HHQ�XLWYRHULJH�EHVSUHNLQJ�HUYDQ�YDOW�EXLWHQGH FRQWH[W�YDQ�GLW�VWXN��:H�EHSHUNHQ�RQV�WRW�DOFRKRO�HQ��LOOHJDOH��GUXJV�HQ�ODWHQ�DQGHUHYRUPHQ YDQ�YHUVODYLQJ��JRNNHQ��EHQ]RGLD]HSLQHV��RPZLOOH�YDQ�GH�RYHU]LFKWHOLMNKHLG�HQUHOHYDQWLH�LQ�KHW�NDGHU�YDQ�GH�GRHOVWHOOLQJ�YDQ�GH]H�UDSSRUWDJH�EXLWHQ�EHVFKRXZLQJ�9HUVODYLQJ� LV� HHQ� YHHOYRRUNRPHQGH�� FKURQLVFK�SV\FKLDWULVFKH� DDQGRHQLQJ� PHWHHQ�JULOOLJ�HQ�PRHLOLMN�YRRUVSHOEDDU�EHORRS��$QWKRQ\��+HO]HU��������9DQ�GHQ�%ULQN�������'D\��������6\WHPD��.RRSPDQV���������0LGGHOHQPLVEUXLN� LV� JHGHILQLHHUG� DDQGH KDQG�YDQ�GH�QHJDWLHYH�PDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH�� OLFKDPHOLMNH� HQ�SV\FKLVFKH� FRQVHTXHQWLHVHQ� LV� GHUKDOYH� ELM� XLWVWHN� HHQ� FXOWXXUDIKDQNHOLMNH� GLDJQRVH� �1RUWVWURP�� ������� %LMPLGGHOHQDIKDQNHOLMNKHLG� LV� VSUDNH� YDQ� HHQ� DDQWDO� VSHFLILHNH� V\PSWRPHQ� �(GZDUGV�������PHW�FUDYLQJ��HHQ�EHZXVW�HUYDUHQ�GUDQJ�RP�WH�JHEUXLNHQ��DOV�FHQWUDOH�FRPSRQHQW�

Page 61: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

%LM� HHQ� JURRW� GHHO� YDQ� GH� YHUVODDIGHQ� LV� VSUDNH� YDQ� SROLGUXJJHEUXLN� YDQ� KHURwQH�FRFDwQH��DOFRKRO�HQ�NDOPHUHQGH�PLGGHOHQ��6SUXLW��'H�=ZDUW��������$IKDQNHOLMNKHLG�JDDW�YHUGHU�GDQ�PLVEUXLN��9RRU]RYHU�GLW�RQGHUVFKHLG�UHOHYDQW�LV]XOOHQ� ZH� KHW� JHEUXLNHQ�� $QGHUV� VSUHNHQ� YRRU� KHW� JHPDN� RYHU� YHUVODYLQJ� DOVRYHUNRHSHOHQGH�WHUP� �'H� PDDQGSUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� YHUVODYLQJ� DDQ� DOFRKRO� LV� FLUFD� ���� ,Q� 1HGHUODQGVEHYRONLQJV�RQGHU]RHN� LV� YRRU� PLVEUXLN� HHQ� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� ����� HQ� YRRUDIKDQNHOLMNKHLG� YDQ� ����� JHYRQGHQ�� 'H� PDDQGSUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� YHUVODYLQJ� DDQ� GUXJV�FDQQDELV�� RSLXP�� KHURwQH�� FRFDwQH�� LV� ���� 9RRU� PLVEUXLN� OLJW� GLW� RS� ������ YRRUDIKDQNHOLMNKHLG�RS�������%LMO�HW�DO�������E���2S�MDDUEDVLV�JDDW�KHW�RP�ELMQD����YDQ�GHYROZDVVHQ�EHYRONLQJ�GLH�HHQ�YHUVODYLQJ�UDSSRUWHUHQ��%LMO�HW�DO�������D������E��'H�ODDWVWH���� MDDU� LV�GH�DOFRKROFRQVXPSWLH�XLWJHGUXNW� LQ� OLWHUV�SXUH�DOFRKRO�SHUKRRIG YDQ�GH�EHYRONLQJ�YDQ����MDDU�HQ�RXGHU��OLFKW��GDOHQGH��9DQDI�FLUFD������OLMNW�HHQVWDELOLVHULQJ�RS�WH�WUHGHQ��+HW�DDQWDO�SUREOHHPGULQNHUV�LV�LQ�GH�DOJHPHQH�EHYRONLQJ�RYHUGH SHULRGH�������������WDPHOLMN�VWDELHO�JHEOHYHQ��9DQ�GHQ�%ULQN���������+HW��H[FHVVLHI�GUDQNJHEUXLN� YDQ� MRQJHUHQ� EOLMNW� LQ� GH� DIJHORSHQ� ��� MDDU� HFKWHU� VWHUN� WRHJHQRPHQ�0HQVLQN��6SUXLW��������+HW�JHEUXLN�YDQ�VRIWGUXJV�OLMNW�QD�HHQ�VWDELOLVDWLH�LQ�GH�MDUHQ�WDFKWLJ�YDQDI�����ZHHU WH� VWLMJHQ�� WHUZLMO�KHW�JHEUXLN�YDQ�KDUGGUXJV� �PHW�XLW]RQGHULQJ�YDQ�PLGGHOHQ� DOV;7&�� WDPHOLMN� VWDELHO� OLMNW�� (U� ]LMQ� ZHO� YHUVFKLOOHQ� SHU� VWRI�� KHW� JHEUXLN� YDQ� KHURwQHQHHPW�DI�HQ�YDQ�FRFDwQH�WRH��+HW�DDQWDO�LQVFKULMYLQJHQ�YDQ�GUXJFOLsQWHQ�LQ�GH�DPEXODQWHYHUVODYLQJV]RUJ� LV� LQ� GH� DIJHORSHQ� ��� MDDU� PHHU� GDQ� YHUGXEEHOG� WRW� URQG� GH� ������FOLsQWHQ�SHU�MDDU��JHOGW�QLHW�YRRU�DOFRKROFOLsQWHQ��JHVWDELOLVHHUG�URQG��������FOLsQWHQ�LQ�������0HQVLQN��6SUXLW��������'HPRJUDILVFKH�IDFWRUHQ*HVODFKW0DQQHQ�KHEEHQ�RQJHYHHU�YLHU�PDDO�]R�KRJH�OLIH�WLPH�HQ�MDDUSUHYDOHQWLH�DOV�YURXZHQ�ELMVWRRUQLVVHQ�VDPHQKDQJHQG�PHW�PLGGHOHQJHEUXLN��'LW�JHOGW�ZDW�VWHUNHU�YRRU�PLVEUXLN�HQZDW PLQGHU�VWHUN�YRRU�DIKDQNHOLMNKHLG��'H]H�JHVODFKWVYHUVFKLOOHQ�]LMQ�YHHO�JURWHU�YRRUDOFRKRO��55 ���GDQ�YRRU�GUXJV��55 ����%LMO�HW�DO�������E��/HHIWLMG9HUVODYLQJHQ� DDQ� DOFRKRO� HQ� GUXJV� EHJLQQHQ� RS� MRQJH� OHHIWLMG�� YDDN� ������ YRRU� KHWWZLQWLJVWH� HQ� PHHVWDO� ������ YRRU� KHW� GHUWLJVWH� OHYHQVMDDU�� 'H� MDDUSUHYDOHQWLH� YDQVWRRUQLVVHQ�LQ�KHW�DOFRKROJHEUXLN�LV�YRRUDO�ELM�MRQJHUHQ�RQGHU�GH����MDDU�]HHU�KRRJ��ppQRS GH� GULH��� KHWJHHQ�PHGH� YHURRU]DDNW� ZRUGW� GRRU� GH� WH� PLOGH� GLDJQRVHFULWHULD� YRRUµDOFRKROPLVEUXLN¶�0HW�KHW�VWLMJHQ�YDQ�GH�OHHIWLMG�GDDOW�GH�SUHYDOHQWLH�VWHUN�'UXJVYHUVODYLQJ�EHJLQW�PHHVWDO�RQGHU�GH�WZLQWLJ�HQ�QD�KHW�GHUWLJVWH�OHYHQVMDDU�LVGH NDQV�HURS�KHHO�NOHLQ�JHZRUGHQ��1D�KHW�YHHUWLJVWH�OHYHQVMDDU�EOLMNHQ�YHHO�YHUVODDIGHQµVSRQWDDQ¶�WH�VWRSSHQ�PHW�JHEUXLNHQ��9RRU�GH�OHHIWLMGVFDWHJRULH�������MDDU�LV�KHW�ULVLFR�LQ HHQ� MDDU� WLMG�� RS� HHQ� PLGGHOHQVWRRUQLV� ELMQD� ��� NHHU� ]R� JURRW� DOV� YRRU� GHOHHIWLMGVFDWHJRULH����MDDU�RI�RXGHU��%LMO�HW�DO�������E��

Page 62: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

(QGRJHQH�IDFWRUHQ*HQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ9HUVODYLQJ�EOLMNW�HHQ�IDPLOLDLUH�DDQGRHQLQJ��%LM�EHKDQGHOGH�DOFRKROLVWHQ�KHHIW�����WRW����WHQPLQVWH�ppQ�DOFRKRODIKDQNHOLMNH�RXGHU������WRW�����WHQPLQVWH�ppQ�HHUVWHJUDDGVIDPLOLHOLG� HQ� ���� WRW� ���� WHQPLQVWH� ppQ� HHUVWH�� RI� WZHHGHJUDDGV� IDPLOLHOLG� PHWDOFRKROSUREOHPHQ��6FKXFNLW���������%LM��HHQ��DOFRKROYHUVODDIGH�RXGHU�V��ORRSW�KHW�ULVLFRRP YHUVODDIG�WH� UDNHQ�YRRU�]RRQV�RS�WRW�����HQ�YRRU�GRFKWHUV� WRW������7ZHHOLQJ��HQDGRSWLHVWXGLHV� PDNHQ� DDQQHPHOLMN� GDW� HHQ� GHHO� YDQ� GH� IDPLOLDLUH� EHODVWLQJ� DDQJHQHWLVFKH� LQYORHGHQ� NDQ� ZRUGHQ� WRHJHVFKUHYHQ�� 0DQQHQ� EOLMNHQ� NZHWVEDDUGHU� YRRUDOFRKRODIKDQNHOLMNKHLG� �*RRGZLQ�� �������� GDQ� YURXZHQ�� 'LW� JHOGW� RRN� �PDDU� LQ� LHWVPLQGHUH� PDWH�� YRRU� GUXJVYHUVODYLQJ�� GH� FRQFRUGDQWLH� ELM� PDQQHOLMNH� PRQR]\JRWHWZHHOLQJHQ�LV�����HQ�ELM�GL]\JRWH�WZHHOLQJHQ������9RRU�YURXZHQ�OLJW�GH�FRQFRUGDQWLHZDW ODJHU��7VXDQJ�HW�DO���������3HUVRRQOLMNKHLG%HKRHIWH� DDQ� QLHXZH� HUYDULQJHQ� �VHQVDWLH]XFKW�� HQ� I\VLHNH� EHORQLQJ� �µUHZDUGGHSHQGHQFH¶�� DOVPHGH� LPSXOVLYLWHLW� HQ� UHODWLHYH� RQJHYRHOLJKHLG� YRRU� VWUDI� �JHULQJHµKDUP DYRLGDQFH¶��VSHOHQ�HHQ�URO�LQ�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�HHQ�FDUULqUH�LQ�GHYLDQW�JHGUDJ�GLHQRJDO�HHQV�JHSDDUG�JDDW�PHW�YHUVODYLQJ��*HGUDJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�LQ�GH�NLQGHUWLMG�HQ�YURHJHDGROHVFHQWLH�YRUPHQ�HHQ�GXLGHOLMNH�ULVLFRIDFWRU�YRRU�ODWHUH�YHUVODYLQJ��%DHU�HW�DO��������=XFNHU�HW�DO����������9HUGHU�LV�KHW�K\SHUDFWLYLWHLWVV\QGURRP�LQ�GH�NLQGHUWLMG��JHW\SHHUGGRRU DDQGDFKWVVWRRUQLVVHQ��LPSXOVLYLWHLW�HQ�K\SHUDFWLHI�JHGUDJ��ELM�MRQJHQV�YRRUVSHOOHQGYRRU GUXJVYHUVODYLQJ��%DHU�HW�DO���������6RPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�HQ�HHUGHUH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ+HW� URNHQ� �PHHU� GDQ� �� SDNMH� SHU� GDJ�� YDQ� GH� PRHGHU� WLMGHQV� GH� ]ZDQJHUVFKDSEHwQYORHGW� GH� RQWZLNNHOLQJ� YDQ� GH� IRHWXV�� KHW� XLWHLQGHOLMNH� JHERRUWHJHZLFKW� HQ� GHFRJQLWLHYH� RQWZLNNHOLQJ�� 'DDUPHH� LV� KHW� HHQ� GXLGHOLMNH� ULVLFRIDFWRU� YRRU� JHGUDJV�� HQDDQGDFKWVVWRRUQLVVHQ�ELM�NLQGHUHQ��=RDOV�]RMXLVW�DO�YHUPHOG�]LMQ�GH]H�RS�KXQ�EHXUW�ZHHUHHQ� GHWHUPLQDQW� YDQ� JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ� LQ� GH� DGROHVFHQWLH�� GHOLQTXHQWLH� HQPLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN��25 ������.DQGHO��������9HUVODYLQJ�JDDW�GLNZLMOV�JHSDDUG�PHW�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�HQ�VRPDWLVFKH�FRPRUELGLWHLW�0HULNDQJDV�HW�DO����������&LUFD�����YDQ�SHUVRQHQ�PHW�DOFRKRODIKDQNHOLMNKHLG�HQ����YDQ SHUVRQHQ�PHW�GUXJVDIKDQNHOLMNKHLG�KHEEHQ��RRLW��HHQ�DQGHUH�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�VWRRUQLV�JHKDG���%LM�GUXJVYHUVODYLQJ�OLMNHQ�GH�PHHVWH�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�HQ�VRPDWLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQLQ KHW� EHORRS� YDQ� GH� YHUVODYLQJ� RS� WH� WUHGHQ�� WHUZLMO� �YRRUDO� ELM� YURXZHQ�� GHSUHVVLH��VRFLDDO�IRELVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� VFKL]RIUHQH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� QRJDO� HHQV� YRRUDI� JDDQ� DDQDOFRKROYHUVODYLQJ��$DQZLM]LQJHQ�QHPHQ�WRH�GDW�KHW�WRFK�PHW�QDPH�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�]LMQGLH DDQ�PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN� HQ� �DIKDQNHOLMNKHLG� YRRUDI� JDDQ��'LW� JHOGW� LQ� YHHO�PLQGHUHPDWH� YRRU� GH� VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ� �0HULNDQJDV� HW� DO��� ������� 8LW� UHFHQW� 1HGHUODQGVEHYRONLQJVRQGHU]RHN� EOLMNW� GDW� DOFRKRODIKDQNHOLMNKHLG� �QLHW� PLVEUXLN�� HHQ� ]ZDNYHUEDQG NHQW� PHW� WDO� YDQ� DQGHUH� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� �25� YDULHHUW� YDQ� ���� YRRUVSHFLILHNH� IRELH� WRW� ���� YRRU� REVHVVLHI�FRPSXOVLHYH� VWRRUQLV��� WHUZLMO� KHW� YHUEDQG�PHWGUXJVDIKDQNHOLMNKHLG��QLHW�PLVEUXLN��YHHO�VWHUNHU�LV��YRRUDO�DOV�KHW�JDDW�RP�GH�ELSRODLUHVWRRUQLV��25 ������HQ�GH�G\VWK\PH�VWRRUQLV��25 ������5DYHOOL�HW�DO���������

Page 63: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

([RJHQH�IDFWRUHQ%HVFKLNEDDUKHLG�YDQ�KHW�PLGGHO,Q� KHW� DOJHPHHQ� JHOGW�� GDW� GH� EHVFKLNEDDUKHLG� YDQ� KHW� PLGGHO� HHQ� EHODQJULMNHGHWHUPLQDQW�LV�YDQ�GH�YHUVODYLQJ��'H�EHWUHNNHOLMNKHLG�YDQ�GH]H�GHWHUPLQDQW�NDQ�EOLMNHQXLW� GH� RPVWDQGLJKHLG� GDW� LQ� RQV� ODQG� HHQ� UHODWLHI� JURWH� EHVFKLNEDDUKHLG� YDQ� FDQQDELVJHSDDUG� JDDW� PHW� HHQ� UHODWLHI� ODJH� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� JHEUXLN� LQ� FDVX� PLVEUXLN�� ,Q� KHW9HUHQLJG�.RQLQNULMN� OLMNW�KHW�RPJHNHHUGH�KHW� JHYDO� OLMNW� WH� ]LMQ��:HOOLFKW�KHHIW� GDW� WHPDNHQ PHW�IDFWRUHQ�YDQ�FXOWXUHOH�DDUG�HQ�GH�PDWH�YDQ�WROHUDQWLH��]LH�KLHUQD��&XOWXUHOH�ZDDUGHULQJ�HQ�WROHUDQWLH6RFLDDO�FXOWXUHOH� ZDDUGHQ� HQ� QRUPHQ� UHJXOHUHQ� LQ� EHODQJULMNH� PDWH� KHW� JHEUXLN� HQPLVEUXLN��'H� YULMH� WRHJDQJ� WRW� DOFRKRO� HQ� GH� JURWH�PDWH� YDQ� WROHUDQWLH� LQ� KHW� JHEUXLNHUYDQ�� RRN� YDQ� RYHUKHLGVZHJH�� YRUPHQ� QDXZHOLMNV� HHQ� EDUULqUH� RS� KHW� SDG� QDDU� GHYHUVODYLQJ� LQ� 1HGHUODQG�� 'LW� OLJW� YRRU� GUXJV� DQGHUV� RPGDW� GDDUYRRU� HHQ� YHHOUHVWULFWLHYHU� EHOHLG� JHOGW�� +HW� 1HGHUODQGVH� RYHUKHLGVEHOHLG� YDQ� UHODWLHYH� UHSUHVVLHYHWROHUDQWLH� PHW� HHQ� MXVWLWLsOH� QDDVW� HHQ� SULPDLUH� YRONVJH]RQGKHLGVDDQSDN� VFRRUW� LQ� GHLQWHUQDWLRQDOH�YHUJHOLMNLQJ�JXQVWLJ�DOV�KHW�JDDW�RP�GH�RPYDQJ��HUQVW�HQ�VWDELOLWHLW�YDQ�GHGUXJVSUREOHPDWLHN�� PHW� QDPH� DOV� KHW� JDDW� RP� GH� JHYROJHQ� YRRU� JH]RQGKHLG� HQFULPLQDOLWHLW�� 2YHULJHQV� OLMNW� KHW� RS� JURQG� YDQ� HHQ� LQWHUQDWLRQDOH� YHUJHOLMNLQJ� WXVVHQODQGHQ DOV�1HGHUODQG��'HQHPDUNHQ��GH�9HUHQLJGH�6WDWHQ�� KHW�9HUHQLJG�.RQLQNULMN� HQ=ZHGHQ�]R�WH�]LMQ�GDW�KHW�QDWLRQDOH�GUXJVEHOHLG�PDDU�HHQ�EHSHUNWH�LQYORHG�KHHIW�RS�KHWGDDGZHUNHOLMN�JHEUXLN��9DQ�GHQ�%ULQN��������6RFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKH�VWDWXV�HQ�OHHIYRUPHQ,Q� HHQ� UHFHQWH� 1HGHUODQGVH� EHYRONLQJVVWXGLH� �%LMO� HW� DO��� ����E�� LV� JHHQ� YHUEDQGJHYRQGHQ� WXVVHQ� YHUVODYLQJHQ� HQ� VRFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKH� YDULDEHOHQ� DOV� LQNRPHQ� HQRSOHLGLQJ��ZpO�PHW�ZHUNORRVKHLG� HQ� DUEHLGVRQJHVFKLNWKHLG� �25 ������ ,Q� EXLWHQODQGVHVWXGLHV� LV� YDDN� ZHO� VSUDNH� LV� YDQ� HHQ� KRJH� FRUUHODWLH� PHW� 6(6�� (pQ� HQ� DQGHU� KHHIWPRJHOLMN� WH� PDNHQ�PHW� GH� RSHUDWLRQDOLVDWLH� YDQ� GH� GLDJQRVH�PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN� LQ� GH1HGHUODQGVH�VWXGLH��$OV�HFKWHU�DOOHHQ�QDDU�DIKDQNHOLMNKHLG��GXV�QLHW�QDDU�KHW�PLVEUXLN�ZRUGW JHNHNHQ�LV�HU�VSUDNH�YDQ�HHQ�YHUKRRJG�ULVLFR�ELM�PHQVHQ�PHW�HHQ�ODJH�RSOHLGLQJ�ELM ZHUNORRVKHLG�HQ�DUEHLGVRQJHVFKLNWKHLG�$OFRKROYHUVODYLQJ� ZRUGW� VLJQLILFDQW� YDNHU� DDQJHWURIIHQ� RQGHU� RQJHKXZGHQ�QRRLW JHKXZG�� HQ� JHVFKHLGHQ� PHQVHQ�� DOVPHGH� RQGHU� DOOHHQVWDDQGHQ�� %LM� GUXJ�YHUVODYLQJ�JDDW�GLW�YHUEDQG�RRN�RS��PHW�GH�WRHYRHJLQJ�GDW�LQ�HHQ�$PHULNDDQVH�VWXGLH�GHKRRJVWH� SUHYDOHQWLH� ZHUG� JHYRQGHQ� RQGHU� VDPHQZRQHQGH� VWHOOHQ� �5RELQV� � 5HJLHU�������� ,Q�1HGHUODQG� KHEEHQ� SHUVRQHQ�PHW� HHQ� OHHIYRUP� DQGHUV� GDQ� VDPHQOHYLQJ�PHWHHQ�SDUWQHU��HHQ�JURWHU�ULVLFR�RS�HHQ�YHUVODYLQJ��25 ���������%LMO�HW�DO�������E��9HUVWHGHOLMNLQJ:RQHQ LQ� VWHGHOLMNH� JHELHGHQ� YHUJURRW� KHW� ULVLFR� RS� HHQ�PLGGHOHQVWRRUQLV� �25 �����(HQ� UXLPHUH�EHVFKLNEDDUKHLG�YDQ�EHSDDOGH�PLGGHOHQ��GH�JHULQJHUH� VRFLDOH�FRQWUROH� HQGH VWHUNHUH� WUHN� QDDU� VWHGHQ� YDQ� MRQJHUHQ� PHW� HHUGHUJHQRHPGH� ULVNDQWHSHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVWUHNNHQ��VSHOHQ�KLHUELM�PRJHOLMN�HHQ�URO�

Page 64: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

/HYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ.ZHWVEDDUKHLGYHUKRJHQGH�HUYDULQJHQ7HNRUWHQ� LQ� RXGHUOLMN� WRH]LFKW�� LQFRQVLVWHQWLH� LQ� RSYRHGLQJVSDWURQHQ� HQ� JHEUHN� DDQSRVLWLHYH� EHWURNNHQKHLG� NXQQHQ� OHLGHQ� WRW� JHGUDJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�� VFKRROYHU]XLP�� VOHFKWHVFKRROSUHVWDWLHV�HQ�YRRUWLMGLJH�VFKRROYHUODWLQJ�GLH�RS�KXQ�EHXUW�ZHHU�HHQ�ULVLFR�YRUPHQYRRU ODWHU�YHUVODYLQJVJHGUDJ��$OV�KHW�JDDW�RP�HPRWLRQHOH�YHUZDDUOR]LQJ��SV\FKLVFKH�RIOLFKDPHOLMNH� PLVKDQGHOLQJ� LQ� GH� MHXJG� �YRRU� KHW� ��H� OHYHQVMDDU�� GDQ� LV� GH� NDQV� LHWVJURWHU� RS� HHQ� PLGGHOHQVWRRUQLV� �25 ����� �/DQJHODQG� � +DUWJHUV�� ������� 8LWSURVSHFWLHYH� VWXGLHV� EOLMNW� YRRUDOVQRJ� YRRU�PDQQHQ� JHHQ� YHUEDQG� WXVVHQ� VHNVXHHO� HQI\VLHNH�PLVKDQGHOLQJ� LQ�GH�NLQGHUWLMG� HQ� ODWHU� DOFRKROLVPH�� HU� LV� ELM� YURXZHQ�ZHO� HHQKRJHU� ULVLFR� RS� DOFRKROSUREOHPHQ�� .LQGHUHQ� YDQ� YHUVODDIGH� RXGHUV� GRHQ� WLMGHQV� KXQMHXJG�PHHU�WUDXPDWLVFKH�HUYDULQJHQ�RS�HQ�VWDDQ�DDQ�PHHU�VWUHVV�EORRW�GDQ�NLQGHUHQ�YDQQLHW�YHUVODDIGH� RXGHUV�� 'LW� NDQ� OHLGHQ� WRW� DQJVW� HQ� GHSUHVVLYLWHLW�� WRW� HHQ� ODJH]HOIZDDUGHULQJ� HQ� WRW� DQGHUH� YHUZDFKWLQJHQ� RYHU� KHW� JHEUXLN� HQ� GH� JHYROJHQ� YDQ� KHWPLGGHO�8LWORNNHQGH�HUYDULQJHQ9DQ�JURRW�EHODQJ�]LMQ�GH�HUYDULQJHQ�GLH�PHQ�LQ�]LMQ�YULHQGHQ��HQ�NHQQLVVHQNULQJ�RSGRHW�'HHO� XLWPDNHQ� YDQ� HHQ� JURHS� ZDDULQ� GUXJV� ZRUGW� JHEUXLNW� YHUKRRJW� KHW� ULVLFR�+RIIPDQQ�� 6X�� ������� (U� LV� QLHW� ppQ� GXLGHOLMNH� JHEHXUWHQLV� RI� VWUHVVRU� EHNHQG� XLWRQGHU]RHN�GLH�DOV�XLWORNNHQGH�GHWHUPLQDQW�YDQ�YHUVODYLQJ�NDQ�ZRUGHQ�EHVFKRXZG��+HWJDDW�YHUPRHGHOLMN�RP�HHQ�UHHNV�YDQ�HUYDULQJHQ�LQ�HHQ�QHJDWLHYH�FRQWH[W�GLH�GH�GRRUVODJJHYHQ�ELM�HHQ�EHSDDOGH�LQGLYLGXHOH�NZHWVEDDUKHLG�&RQFOXVLHV9HUVODYLQJ� LV� HHQ� FRPSOH[� IHQRPHHQ� ZDDUYDQ� RQWVWDDQ� HQ� DIORRS� PRHLOLMN� WHYRRUVSHOOHQ�]LMQ��2YHU�KHW�UHODWLHYH�EHODQJ�YDQ�GH�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�LV�VOHFKWVWH VSHFXOHUHQ�� 1DDVW� JHQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� VSHOHQ� ZHOOLFKW� YRRUDO� NZHWVEDDUKHLGV�YHUKRJHQGH�HQ�XLWORNNHQGH�HUYDULQJHQ�JHGXUHQGH�GH�MHXJG�HQ�DGROHVFHQWLH�WHVDPHQ�PHWGH FXOWXUHOH�ZDDUGHULQJ�HQ�WROHUDQWLH�GH�EHODQJULMNVWH�URO�LQ�GH�XLWHLQGHOLMNH�RQWVSRULQJQDDU� PLVEUXLN� HQ� DIKDQNHOLMNKHLG� YDQ� DOFRKRO� HQ� GUXJV�� 6RPPLJH� DXWHXUV� �9DQ� GHQ%ULQN��������SUREHUHQ�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�W\SHQ�DOFRKROLVWHQ�WH�RQGHUVFKHLGHQ��(pQ�YDQ�GH]HW\SHV�NHQPHUNW�]LFK�GRRU�HHQ�FRPELQDWLH� �YDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�]RDOV�HUIHOLMNH�EHODVWLQJ�HHQ� JHGUDJVVWRRUQLV� LQ� GH� NLQGHUWLMG�� RS� MRQJH� OHHIWLMG� RQWVWDDQ� YDQ� GUDQNSUREOHPHQ�SULPDLUH� VWRRUQLV� LQ� DOFRKROJHEUXLN�� DJUHVVLHI� HQ� GHOLQTXHQW� JHGUDJ�� YHHO� µQRYHOW\VHHNLQJ¶� LQ� FRPELQDWLH� PHW� ZHLQLJ� µKDUP� DYRLGDQFH¶HQ� µUHZDUG� GHSHQGHQF\¶�� (URQWEUHHNW�HFKWHU�YRRUORSLJ�YROGRHQGH�HPSLULVFKH�VWHXQ�YRRU�HHQ�GHUJHOLMNH�W\SRORJLH�

��� 3V\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�LQ�NLQGHUHQ�HQ�DGROHVFHQWHQ:H� EHSHUNHQ� RQV� WRW� GH� UHODWLHI� SUHYDOHQWH� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ELM� NLQGHUHQ� HQDGROHVFHQWHQ�� $XWLVPH�� YHUVWDQGHOLMNH� KDQGLFDS�� VSUDDN�� HQ� OHHUVWRRUQLVVHQ� NRPHQ� LQGH]H�SDUDJUDDI�QLHW�DDQ�GH�RUGH��,Q�GH�OLWHUDWXXU�RYHU�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�ELM�NLQGHUHQVSUHHNW PHQ� YDDN� YDQ� LQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH� HQ� H[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� DO� QHHPW� KHW

Page 65: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

JHEUXLN� YDQ� GH� VWDQGDDUG� '60� GLDJQRVHQ� VWHUN� WRH�� ,QWHUQDOLVHUHQGH� VWRRUQLVVHQRPYDWWHQ� DQJVW�� HQ� VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� VRPDWLVHULQJ�� 0HW� H[WHUQDOLVHUHQGHVWRRUQLVVHQ� GRHOW� PHQ� RS� DDQGDFKWVWHNRUWVWRRUQLV�� K\SHUDFWLYLWHLW�� JHGUDJVVWRRUQLV�DQWLVRFLDDO�JHGUDJ��HQ�PLVEUXLN�YDQ�PLGGHOHQ��%LM�GH�LQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�OLMNWKHW� LQGLYLGX�]LFK�YRRUDO� WHJHQ�]LFK]HOI� WH� NHUHQ�� HU� LV� GDQ� VSUDNH� YDQ� HHQ� µYHUVWRRUGHUHODWLH�PHW�]LFK]HOI¶��%LM�GH�H[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�ULFKW�KHW�LQGLYLGX�]LFK�WHJHQ�GHZHUHOG� ZDW� WRW� XLWGUXNNLQJ� NRPW� LQ� HHQ� YHUVWRRUGH� UHODWLH�PHW� GH� VRFLDOH� RPJHYLQJ�5HGHQHQ�YRRU�GH�XLWHHQORSHQGH�WHUPLQRORJLH�]LMQ�GH�YROJHQGH�� µ9ROZDVVHQ¶� VWRRUQLVVHQ�PDQLIHVWHUHQ� ]LFK� ELM� NLQGHUHQ� HQ� DGROHVFHQWHQ� YDDN� LHWVDQGHUV��GHSUHVVLH��� µ.LQGHU¶VWRRUQLVVHQ�ZRUGHQ� SDV� VLQGV� NRUW� ELM� YROZDVVHQHQ� JHGLDJQRVWLVHHUG�� ELMY�DDQGDFKWVWHNRUWVWRRUQLV�PHW�K\SHUDFWLYLWHLW��$WWHQWLRQ�'HILFLW�+\SHUDFWLYH�'LVRUGHU $'+'��� 'LPHQVLRQHOH� EHQDGHULQJHQ� �]RDOV� ELM� KHW� RQGHUVFKHLG� LQWHUQDOLVHUHQG�H[WHUQDOLVHUHQG�� ]LMQ� DOWLMG� SRSXODLU� JHZHHVW� LQ� GH� RQWZLNNHOLQJVSV\FKRORJLH� HQNLQGHU��HQ�MHXJGSV\FKLDWULH�'H� JHUDSSRUWHHUGH�SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ELM� NLQGHUHQ� LV� HUJ� DIKDQNHOLMN� YDQ� GHJHEUXLNWH� LQIRUPDWLHEURQ� �RXGHU�� NLQG�DGROHVFHQW� ]HOI�� RI� OHHUNUDFKW��� ,Q� 1HGHUODQGEHGUDDJW�GH���PDDQGVSUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�'60�,,,�5�GLDJQRVHQ�ELM�DGROHVFHQWHQ��������DOVRRN VWRRUQLVVHQ�ZRUGHQ�PHHJHWHOG�GLH�PDDU�GRRU�ppQ�RI�WZHH�YDQ�GH�GULH�EURQQHQ�ZRUGWYHUPHOG� �9HUKXOVW�� ������� 'H� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� VWRRUQLVVHQ� GLH� PHW� IXQFWLRQHOHEHSHUNLQJHQ�JHSDDUG�JDDQ�OLJJHQ�HFKWHU�YHHO�HQ�YHHO�ODJHU��QDPHOLMN�RS������������RI�����YROJHQV�UHVSHFWLHYHOLMN�GH�RXGHU��GH�DGROHVFHQW�]HOI�RI�GH�RXGHU�pQ�DGROHVFHQW��'HEHODQJULMNVWH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� LQ�NLQGHUHQ� HQ� DGROHVFHQWHQ�]LMQ� DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� �PHW�QDPHVSHFLILHNH� RI� VRFLDOH� IRELH��� GHSUHVVLH�� JHGUDJVVWRRUQLV�� PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN�� HQDDQGDFKWVWHNRUWVWRRUQLV� PHW� K\SHUDFWLYLWHLW� �$'+'��� 'H]H� KHEEHQ� HON� HHQ� ��PDDQGVSUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�WHQPLQVWH������YROJHQV�RXGHU�pQ�DGROHVFHQW��PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLNZRUGW RYHULJHQV�YULMZHO�DOOHHQ�GRRU�GH�MRQJHUH�JHUDSSRUWHHUG��'LYHUVH�EXLWHQODQGVH�VWXGLHV� UDSSRUWHUHQ�HHQ� WRHQDPH�LQ�GH�DIJHORSHQ���� MDUHQYDQ� GHSUHVVLHI� HQ� DQWLVRFLDDO� JHGUDJ� HQ�PLVEUXLN� YDQ�PLGGHOHQ� �3URVVHU� �0F$UGOH�������5XWWHU��6PLWK���������'LW�ZRUGW�HFKWHU�QLHW�RI�QDXZHOLMNV�LQ�1HGHUODQGVH�VWXGLHVWHUXJJHYRQGHQ��9HUKXOVW�HW�DO���������9HHO� VWRRUQLVVHQ� GLH� ]LFK� WLMGHQV� GH� DGROHVFHQWLH� RQWZLNNHOHQ� ]LMQ� QLHXZ�1HZPDQ� HW� DO��� �������0DDU� HHQ� GHUGH��PRJHOLMN� ]HOIV� YHHO�PHHU�� LV� HHQ� YHUYROJ� RSJHGUDJVVWRRUQLVVHQ� LQ� GH� NLQGHUMDUHQ� ZDDURQGHU� DDQGDFKWVWRRUQLVVHQ�� K\SHUDFWLYLWHLW�LPSXOVLYLWHLW�� FRQWDFWDUPRHGH� RI� DQWLVRFLDDO� JHGUDJ�� 'H� DGROHVFHQWLH�JHERQGHQSUREOHPDWLHN�YHUGZLMQW�YRRU�HHQ�GHHO�ELM�KHW�RXGHU�ZRUGHQ��PDDU�HHQ�QLHW�RQDDQ]LHQOLMNGHHO�EOLMIW�EHVWDDQ��'LW�JHEHXUW�PHW�QDPH�LQ�DGROHVFHQWHQ�GLH�RRN�DO�DOV�NLQG�SUREOHPHQKDGGHQ��0RIILW�HW�DO���������9HUKXOVW��������'HPRJUDILVFKH�IDFWRUHQ2YHU�KHW�DOJHPHHQ� LV�GH�SUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ� LQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH�SUREOHPHQ�KRJHU�ELM�PHLVMHV�VSHFLILHNH� HQ� VRFLDOH� IRELH��� WHUZLMO� H[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� �JHGUDJVVWRRUQLV�DDQGDFKWVVWRRUQLV��ZDW� YDNHU� ELM� MRQJHQV� ZRUGHQ� DDQJHWURIIHQ�� 'H� YHUVFKLOOHQ� QHPHQWRH JHGXUHQGH� GH� DGROHVFHQWLH� �9HUKXOVW� �.RRW�� ������� 'H� JHVODFKWVYHUVFKLOOHQ� ]LMQJURWHU�ZDQQHHU�QDDU�VSHFLILHNH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�ZRUGW�JHNHNHQ��$'+'�NRPW�ELMYRRUEHHOG���� NHHU�]RYHHO�YRRU�ELM�MRQJHQV�DOV�ELM�PHLVMHV�

Page 66: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

9ROJHQV�PHWLQJHQ�ELM�KHW�NLQG�GH�DGROHVFHQW�]HOI�VWLMJW�GH�SUHYDOHQWLH�JHGXUHQGHGH DGROHVFHQWLH�VWHUN��'LW� JHOGW�YRRUDO�YRRU� LQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH�VWRRUQLVVHQ� �YHUGXEEHOLQJHQ KHW�VWHUNVW�ELM�PHLVMHV��HQ�PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN��YDQ�YULMZHO�QXO� WRW�PHHU�GDQ�����HQKHW VWHUNVW�ELM�MRQJHQV���0F*HH��1HZFRPE��������1HZPDQ�HW�DO���������9HUKXOVW�.RRW��������(QGRJHQH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ*HQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ(YHQDOV� ELM� YROZDVVHQHQ� LV� GH� HWLRORJLH� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ELM� MRQJHUHQFRPSOH[� HQ� VSHOHQ� YHUPRHGHOLMN� WDO� YDQ� JHQHQ� �ZDDUVFKLMQOLMN� LQ� LQWHUDFWLH� PHWRPJHYLQJVGHWHUPLQDQWHQ��HHQ�URO��(DYHV�HW�DO���������5XWWHU�HW�DO����������'H�ELMGUDJHYDQ JHQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� OLMNW� JURWHU� WH�ZRUGHQ� QDDUPDWH� GH� VWRRUQLV� HUQVWLJHU� LV� HQ� RSMRQJHUH� OHHIWLMG� EHJLQW�� %LM� SUREOHPDWLHN� GLH� ODDW� LQ� GH� DGROHVFHQWLH� RQWVWDDW� LV� GHELMGUDJH�YDQ�JHQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�JHULQJHU��,Q�GLW�JHYDO�VSHOHQ�]RJHQDDPGH�QLHW�JHGHHOGHHUYDULQJHQ��GDW�ZLO�]HJJHQ�HUYDULQJHQ�GLH�GH�DGROHVFHQW�QLHW�PHW�]LMQ�RI�KDDU��WZHHOLQJ�EURHU� RI� ]XV� GHHOW�� HHQ� JURWHUH� URO�� 'H� UHVXOWDWHQ� YDQ� RQGHU]RHN� ELM� 1HGHUODQGVHWZHHOLQJHQ�]LMQ�KLHUPHH�LQ�RYHUHHQVWHPPLQJ��2RUG�HW�DO�����������������2QJHYHHU����WRW�����YDQ�GH�VSUHLGLQJ�LQ�GH�VFRUHV�RS�GH�VFKDOHQ�YDQ�GH�&KLOG�%HKDYLRU�&KHFN�/LVW�&%&/�� NDQ�ZRUGHQ�WRHJHVFKUHYHQ�DDQ�JHQHWLVFKH�YHUVFKLOOHQ��LQFOXVLHI�JHQ�RPJHYLQJLQWHUDFWLHV�� �9HUKXOVW�� ������� 2YHU� GH� ZLM]H� YDQ� RYHUHUYLQJ� HQ� GH� UHODWLHV� WXVVHQ� GHVWRRUQLVVHQ�RQGHUOLQJ�LV�QRJ�ZHLQLJ�EHNHQG�3HUVRRQOLMNKHLG*HGUDJVJHQHWLFL� JDDQ� HU� LQ� WRHQHPHQGH� PDWH� YDQ� XLW�� GDW� JHQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� KXQLQYORHG� RS� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� JURWHQGHHOV� XLWRHIHQHQ� YLD� KXQEHWURNNHQKHLG� ELM� LQGLYLGXHOH� YHUVFKLOOHQ� LQ� WHPSHUDPHQW� HQ� �VRFLDDO�� FRJQLWLHYHYDDUGLJKHGHQ� �3ORPLQ�� ������� � �'H]H� YHUVFKLOOHQ� WXVVHQ� NLQGHUHQ� EHwQYORHGHQ� RS� KXQEHXUW�ZHHU�GH��VRFLDOH��RPJHYLQJ�ZDDULQ�]LM�RSJURHLHQ��RQGHU�DQGHUH�YLD�YHUVFKLOOHQ�LQRPJHYLQJVFRQWUROH�HQ�LQ�GH�UHDFWLHV�GLH�KHW�JHGUDJ�YDQ�NLQGHUHQ�ELM�RXGHUV�HQ�DQGHUHQRSURHSHQ� �]RJHQDDPGH� DFWLHYH� HQ�SDVVLHYH�SHUVRRQ�RPJHYLQJ� FRUUHODWLHV�� �9DQ�2V�0DUFHOLV�� ������3ORPLQ��������5XWWHU� HW� DO��� �������2JHQVFKLMQOLMN� JHKHHO� RPJHYLQJV�JHERQGHQ�IDFWRUHQ���]RDOV�GH�RXGHUOLMNH�UHJHOKDQGKDYLQJ�HQ�DIIHFWLHYH�EHQDGHULQJ��VWDDQKLHUGRRU�GHHOV�RQGHU�LQYORHG�YDQ�JHQHWLVFKH�NHQPHUNHQ�YDQ�KHW�NLQG��3ORPLQ��������%HODQJULMNH�YRRUVSHOOHUV�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�LQ�GH�DGROHVFHQWLH�]LMQ�� *HUHPGKHLG� �VFKXZKHLG�� WHUXJJHWURNNHQKHLG�� YRRU� PHW� QDPH� LQWHUQDOLVHUHQGHVWRRUQLVVHQ�ELM�PHLVMHV�� $IZH]LJKHLG� YDQ� VFKXOGJHYRHO�� K\SHUDFWLYLWHLW� HQ� RQJHUHPGKHLG� YRRU� PHW� QDPHH[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�� 6RFLDDO�FRJQLWLHYH� WHNRUWHQ� �DDQGDFKW�� FRPPXQLFDWLHYH� YDDUGLJKHGHQ��� YRRU� ]RZHOLQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH� DOV� H[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH� SUREOHPHQ� �&DVSL� HW� DO��� ������ 0DJQXVVRQ�������5XWWHU�HW�DO��������� �6RPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ2I� SUH�� HQ� SHULQDWDOH� SUREOHPHQ� ]RDOV� JURHLVWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� FRPSOLFDWLHV� WLMGHQV� GHEHYDOOLQJ��YHUKRRJGH�VWUHVV� WHQ� WLMGH�YDQ�GH�]ZDQJHUVFKDS�HQ�VSHFLILHNH�NLQGHU]LHNWHQ� (HQ�VFUHHQLQJVOLMVW�YRRU�HPRWLRQHOH�HQ�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�ELM�NLQGHUHQ�

Page 67: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

KHW�ULVLFR�RS�SV\FKRSDWKRORJLH�ELM�NLQGHUHQ�YHUJURWHQ�LV�RQGXLGHOLMN��=LM�OLMNHQ�KHW�ULVLFRRS JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�� LQ�KHW�ELM]RQGHU�DDQGDFKWVWHNRUWVWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�K\SHUDFWLYLWHLW� WHYHUKRJHQ��DOV�]LM� OHLGHQ� WRW� �PLOGH��QHXURORJLVFKH�RI�QHXURSV\FKRORJLVFKH� DIZLMNLQJHQRI LQ�FRPELQDWLH�PHW�HHQ�SV\FKRVRFLDDO�RQJXQVWLJH�JH]LQVVLWXDWLH�YRRUNRPHQ��9HUKXOVW�������� (HQ� GHHO� YDQ� GH]H� HIIHFWHQ� HEW� RRN� ZHHU� ZHJ� PHW� KHW� RXGHU� ZRUGHQ�� DO� LVRQGXLGHOLMN� KRHYHHO�� 2RN� GH� EHWUHNNHOLMN� JHULQJH� JHGUDJVHIIHFWHQ� YDQ� FKURQLVFKHEORRWVWHOOLQJ�DDQ�ORRG��DOFRKRO�HQ�GUXJV�WLMGHQV�GH�]ZDQJHUVFKDS�OLMNHQ�JURWHQGHHOV�PHWKHW� RSJURHLHQ� DI� WH� QHPHQ� �9HUKXOVW�� ������� � (HQ� YHUPLQGHUGH� UHVSRQVLYLWHLW� YDQ� KHWDXWRQRPH� ]HQXZVWHOVHO� �%UHQQDQ� HW� DO��� ������ HQ� URNHQ� �9HUVOXLV�GHQ� %LHPDQ�� �����WLMGHQV GH�]ZDQJHUVFKDS�]LMQ�LQ�YHUEDQG�JHEUDFKW�PHW�DQWLVRFLDOH�JHGUDJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�([RJHQH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ6(6�HQ�YHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ'H�PHHVWH�VWXGLHV�YLQGHQ�HHQ�LHWV�ODJHUH�SUHYDOHQWLH�LQ�GH�KRJHUH�VRFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKHVWUDWD HQ�RS�KHW�SODWWHODQG��9HUKXOVW��.RRW��������9HUKXOVW���������'H�YHUVFKLOOHQ�]LMQNOHLQ� PHW�QDPH�WXVVHQ�VWHUN�HQ�PDWLJ�JH�UEDQLVHHUGH�JHELHGHQ��&KURQLVFKH�ILQDQFLsOHSUREOHPHQ�YDQ�RXGHUV�YHUKRJHQ�KHW�ULVLFR�RS�VWRRUQLVVHQ��ZDQQHHU�]LM�JHSDDUG�JDDQ�PHWSHUVLVWHUHQGH�RSYRHGLQJVSUREOHPHQ�RI�FRQIOLFWHQ�LQ�KHW�JH]LQ��&KHUOLQ�HW�DO���������/HHIYRUP�HQ�DQGHUH�JH]LQVLQYORHGHQ3V\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� YDQ� RXGHUV�� PLVKDQGHOLQJ� HQ� PLVEUXLN�� FULPLQHHO� RXGHUOLMNJHGUDJ��FKURQLVFKH�FRQIOLFWHQ� LQ�KHW�JH]LQ��H[WUHPH�RSYRHGLQJVWLMOHQ��HFKWVFKHLGLQJ�HQRSJURHLHQ�LQ�HHQ�ppQRXGHUJH]LQ�]LMQ�YRRUEHHOGHQ�YDQ�JH]LQVIDFWRUHQ�GLH�KHUKDDOGHOLMN�LQYHUEDQG�]LMQ�JHEUDFKW�PHW�SV\FKRSDWKRORJLH�ELM�MRQJHUHQ��+XQ�XQLHNH�ELMGUDJH�LV�HFKWHURQGXLGHOLMN��RQGHU�DQGHUH�GRRU�GH�VWHUNH�RQGHUOLQJH�DIKDQNHOLMNKHLG�YDQ�GH]H�IDFWRUHQHQ� KXQ� PRJHOLMNH�� GHHOV� JHPHHQVFKDSSHOLMNH�� JHQHWLVFKH� DFKWHUJURQG�� +RHZHO� �GHVWHUNWH YDQ��KHW�YHUEDQG�DIKDQJW�YDQ�GH�EHVWXGHHUGH�VWRRUQLV��ZLM]HQ�GH�PHHVWH�VWXGLHVHFKWHU�ZHO� LQ� GH� ULFKWLQJ� YDQ� HHQ� ELMGUDJH� YDQ� WZHH� IDFWRUHQ�� HUQVWLJH� HQ� FKURQLVFKHFRQIOLFWHQ� LQ� KHW� JH]LQ� �PHW� YDDN� DOV� JHYROJ� ZLVVHOHQGH� YHU]RUJHUV�� HQ LQDGHTXDWHRSYRHGLQJVSDWURQHQ� �H[WUHHP�� LQVWDELHO�� LQFRQVLVWHQW�� �-HVVRU�� ������ 9HUKXOVW�� ������$QGHUH� SRWHQWLHHO� QHJDWLHYH� JH]LQVIDFWRUHQ� OLMNHQ� DOOHHQ� YDQ� EHODQJ� DOV� ]LM� GH]H� WZHHEHwQYORHGHQ� �/HYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ.ZHWVEDDUKHLGYHUKRJHQGH�HUYDULQJHQ.LQGHUHQ�GLH� LQ�KXQ�HHUVWH� OHYHQVMDUHQ�]LMQ�YHUZDDUORRVG�RI�PLVKDQGHOG�RI�GLH� LQ� HHQWHKXLV�RSJURHLGHQ�]LMQ�JHPLGGHOG�NZHWVEDDUGHU�YRRU�XLWHHQORSHQGH� LQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH�HQH[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� LQ� GH� DGROHVFHQWLH� �9HUVOXLV�GHQ� %LHPDQ�� ������� :HONHIDFWRUHQ� KLHUYRRU� SUHFLHV� YHUDQWZRRUGHOLMN� ]LMQ� LV� QLHW� GXLGHOLMN� �9HUKXOVW�� ������2SYDOOHQG�LV�GH�LQGLYLGXHOH�YDULDWLH�LQ�ODWHU�IXQFWLRQHUHQ�ELM�NLQGHUHQ�GLH�DOOHQ�DDQ�JURWHVRFLDOH WHJHQVSRHG�KHEEHQ�EORRWJHVWDDQ��.LQGHUHQ�HQ�DGROHVFHQWHQ�YHUVFKLOOHQ�NHQQHOLMNVWHUN LQ�NZHWVEDDUKHLG�HQ�YHHUNUDFKW�

Page 68: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

8LWORNNHQGH�HUYDULQJHQ2QGHU]RHN� QDDU� GH� URO� YDQ� VWUHVVYROOH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� DOV� XLWORNNHQGH� IDFWRUHQ� YRRUSV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ELM� NLQGHUHQ� HQ� DGROHVFHQWHQ� LV� VFKDDUV�� 'H� PHWKRGRORJLVFKHYRRUXLWJDQJ� GLH� GH� DIJHORSHQ� WZHH� GHFHQQLD� LV� JHERHNW� ELM� YROZDVVHQHQ� EHJLQW� SDVODQJ]DDP LQJDQJ�WH�YLQGHQ�LQ�GH�NLQGHU��HQ�MHXJGSV\FKLDWULH��+HW�ZHLQLJH�RQGHU]RHN�GDWHU� LV�� ZLMVW� RS� HHQ� EHVFKHLGHQ� ELMGUDJH� YDQ� QHJDWLHYH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� �9HUVOXLV�GHQ%LHPDQ���������2I�GLW�KHW�JHYROJ�LV�YDQ�PHWKRGRORJLVFKH�SUREOHPHQ�RI�GDW�FKURQLVFKHVWUHVVRUHQ�EHODQJULMNHU�]LMQ��LV�RQGXLGHOLMN�&RQFOXVLHV(HQ� EHODQJULMNH� FRPELQDWLH� YDQ� ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ� YRRU� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� HQ� YRRUWEHVWDDQ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�ELM� MHXJGLJHQ� LV�KHW� VDPHQJDDQ�YDQ� HHQ�PRHLOLMN� WHPSHUDPHQW�VRFLDDO�FRJQLWLHYH� EHSHUNLQJHQ�� SUREOHPDWLVFKH� JH]LQVRPVWDQGLJKHGHQ�� HQ� HHQ� ODJHVRFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKH� VWDWXV� YDQ� KHW� JH]LQ��(HQ� JURRW�PDDWVFKDSSHOLMN� SUREOHHP� YRUPWPHW QDPH�GH� JURHS� YDQ� MRQJHUHQ�PHW� SHUVLVWHUHQGH�PXOWLSUREOHPDWLHN��'H� RRU]DDN� LVYDDN�GH�FXPXODWLH�YDQ�]RZHO�HQGRJHQH�ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ��JHQHWLVFKH�EHODVWLQJ��DDQGDFKWV�SUREOHPHQ�� K\SHUDFWLYLWHLW�� FRPPXQLFDWLHYH� EHSHUNLQJHQ�� VOHFKWH� VFKRROUHVXOWDWHQ�� DOVH[RJHQH� ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ� �JH]LQVFRQIOLFWHQ�� LQDGHTXDWH� RSYRHGLQJVSUDNWLMNHQ�� FULPLQHOHRPJHYLQJ�� �)HUGLQDQG� � 9HUKXOVW�� ������ )HUJXVVRQ� HW� DO��� ������ )HUJXVVRQ� +RUZRRG��������/RHEHU�HW�DO���������5XWWHU�HW�DO���������

��� 6XwFLGH,Q� 1HGHUODQG� YLQGHQ� RS� MDDUEDVLV� FLUFD� ������ VWHUIJHYDOOHQ� SODDWV� GLH� WRHJHVFKUHYHQZRUGHQ DDQ�VXwFLGH��:+2���������'LW�EHWHNHQW�HHQ�UHJLVWUHHUGH�MDDULQFLGHQWLH�YDQ�����SHU����������'H� LQFLGHQWLH�YDQ� VXwFLGHSRJLQJHQ� OLJW� WXVVHQ�GH���� HQ�����SHU� ��������$UQHQVPDQ��������1,9(/��������3ODWW�HW�DO����������'LW�]LMQ�RQGHUVFKDWWLQJHQ�YDQ�GHZHUNHOLMNH� LQFLGHQWLHV�� 9HOH� IDFWRUHQ� GUDJHQ� HU� WRH� ELM� GDW� LQ� WZLMIHOJHYDOOHQ� DQGHUH�PLQGHU�VWLJPDWLVHUHQGH��VWHUIWHRRU]DNHQ�GDQ�VXwFLGH�RS�RYHUOLMGHQVYHUNODULQJHQ�ZRUGHQDDQJHJHYHQ� �1HHOHPDQ� � :HVVHO\�� ������� 'H� ZHUNHOLMNH� LQFLGHQWLH� YDQVXwFLGHSRJLQJHQ� OLJW� PRJHOLMN� YLHU� PDDO� KRJHU� GDQ� GH� JHUHJLVWUHHUGH� �.HQQHG\� .UHLWPDQ�� ������� ,Q� DEVROXWH� ]LQ� YRUPW� VWHUIWH� GRRU� ]HOIGRGLQJ� HHQ� NOHLQ� GHHO� YDQ� GHWRWDOH�VWHUIWH�������LQ��������'RRU�GH�UHODWLHI�MRQJH�OHHIWLMG�ZDDURS�VXwFLGH�SODDWVYLQGW�LQ YHUJHOLMNLQJ�PHW�DQGHUH�VWHUIWHRRU]DNHQ��LV�KHW�HFKWHU�WRFK�YHUDQWZRRUGHOLMN�YRRU�HHQDDQ]LHQOLMN� GHHO� ����� YDQ� KHW� WRWDDO� DDQ� YHUORUHQ� OHYHQVMDUHQ� LQ� GH� EHYRONLQJ� YDQ1HGHUODQG��5XZDDUG��.UDPHUV��������'HPRJUDILVFKH�IDFWRUHQ6XwFLGH�NRPW�WZHH�PDDO�]R�YDDN�YRRU�ELM�PDQQHQ�DOV�ELM�YURXZHQ��2XGHUHQ�KHEEHQ�HHQKRJHU� ULVLFR� GDQ� MRQJHUHQ�� KHW� ULVLFR� YDQ� ��� SOXVVHUV� OLJW� ����PDDO� KRJHU� GDQ� GDW� YDQ³MRQJHUHQ´������MDDU���:+2��������

Page 69: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

(QGRJHQH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ*HQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�HQ�SHUVRRQOLMNKHLG*HQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� VSHOHQ� ZHOLVZDDU� HHQ� URO� ELM� VXwFLGH� �5R\� HW� DO��� ������ PDDU� GLWZHHUVSLHJHOW�ZDDUVFKLMQOLMN�GH�HUIHOLMNH�LQYORHGHQ�RS�KHW�YyyUNRPHQ�YDQ�GH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�]RDOV� GHSUHVVLH�� VFKL]RIUHQLH� HQ� PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN� GLH� PHW� HHQ� KRRJ� VXwFLGHULVLFRJHSDDUG�JDDQ�+HW� JDDW� KLHU� RYHULJHQV� ZDDUVFKLMQOLMN� QLHW� DOOHHQ� RP� HUIHOLMNH� HIIHFWHQ� RSSV\FKLDWULVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� PDDU� RRN� RS� EHSDDOGH� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVWUHNNHQ� ]RDOVQHXURWLFLVPH�HQ�LPSXOVLYLWHLW�ZDDUYDQ�EHNHQG�LV�GDW�]H��RS�ODQJH�WHUPLMQ��KHW�ULVLFR�RSJHVODDJGH� VXwFLGH�YHUKRJHQ� �UHODWLHYH� ULVLFR¶V� UHVSHFWLHYHOLMN����� HQ������ �&DSVL� HW� DO��������*DUULVRQ�HW�DO���������1HHOHPDQ�HW�DO���������6RPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�HQ�DQGHUH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ9DQ�GH�YROJHQGH�VRPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�]LMQ�YHUEDQGHQ�PHW�]HOIGRGLQJ�DDQJHWRRQG�� ODDJJHERRUWHJHZLFKW� HQ� FRPSOLFDWLHV� ELM� ]ZDQJHUVFKDS� HQ� EHYDOOLQJ� �YRRUDO� ELM� PDQQHQ55 ����������%DUNHU�HW�DO���������-DFREVRQ��%\JGHPDQ��������1HHOHPDQ���������+,9�LQIHFWLHV��QLHXZYRUPLQJHQ��QHXURORJLVFKH�DDQGRHQLQJHQ��]ZHUHQ�YDQ�GH�WZDDOIYLQJHULJHGDUP� HQ� PRJHOLMN� HHQ� YHUODDJG� FKROHVWHUROJHKDOWH� �'HOYD� HW� DO��� ������ +DUULV� %DUUDFORXJK��������9ULMZHO� DOOH� SV\FKLDWULVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� JDDQ� PHW� HHQ� YHUKRRJG� VXwFLGHULVLFRJHSDDUG��'LW�JHOGW��PHW�QDPH�YRRU�VFKL]RIUHQLH��55 �������YHUVODYLQJHQ��55 ���������HQ� VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ� �55 ������ �)DUUHOO� HW� DO��� ������ 1HHOHPDQ�� )DUUHOO�� �����1HHOHPDQ���������0HHU�LQ�KHW�DOJHPHHQ�LV�RQWVODJ�XLW�HHQ�SV\FKLDWULVFK�]LHNHQKXLV�LQ�GHYRRUJDDQGH� GULH�PDDQGHQ�� HHQ� ]HHU� VWHUNH� ULVLFRIDFWRU� YRRU� VXLFLGH� �55 ����� JHKHOH]LHNHQKXLVSRSXODWLH�W�R�Y��DOJHPHQH�EHYRONLQJ���*XQQHO��)UDQNHO��������/HZLV�HW�DO��������� $OV� PHHVW� GLUHFWH� GHWHUPLQDQW� YDQ� JHVODDJGH� VXwFLGH� JHOGW� GH� QLHW� IDWDOHVXwFLGHSRJLQJ��55 �������1HHOHPDQ��������([RJHQH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ7UDGLWLRQHHO� LV� HU� YHHO� EHODQJVWHOOLQJ� YRRU� VRFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ]HOIGRGLQJ� �'XUNKHLP�� ������ 1HHOHPDQ�� ������� (HQ� ODJH� VRFLDOH� NODVVH� YDQ� GHEHWURNNHQH�SHUVRRQOLMN�RI�]LMQ�RXGHUV��1HHOHPDQ�HW�DO��������� �55 ������ZHUNORRVKHLG�55 ����� �0RVHU�HW�DO��������HQ�GHWHQWLH�RI�GUHLJLQJ�GDDUPHH� �55 ��� �%ODDXZ�HW�DO��������EOLMNHQ�UHODWLHI�UREXXVWH�H[RJHQH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�VXwFLGH�/HYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ*H]LHQ� GH� UHODWLHI� ODJH� IUHTXHQWLH� YDQ� ]HOIGRGLQJ� LV� HU� ZHLQLJ� SURVSHFWLHI� RQGHU]RHNRYHU GH�URO�YDQ�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVYHUKRJHQGH�RI�XLWORNNHQGH�VWUHVVYROOH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�DOVGHWHUPLQDQW�YDQ�VXwFLGH��/DQJGXULJH�IROORZ�XS�VWXGLHV�VXJJHUHUHQ�GDW�VH[XHHO�PLVEUXLN�PLVKDQGHOLQJ� GRRU� RXGHUV� HQ� RYHUPDWLJ� GUDQNJHEUXLN� YDQ� RXGHUV� NZHWVEDDUKHLGV�YHUKRJHQG� NXQQHQ� ZHUNHQ� �$OOHEHFN� HW� DO��� ������� 8LW� UHWURVSHFWLHYH� SV\FKRORJLVFKHDXWRSVLH�VWXGLHV��GLH�YLD�PLGGHOV�LQIRUPDQWHQLQWHUYLHZV�GH�SHULRGH�YRRUDIJDDQG�DDQ�GH]HOIGRGLQJ�LQ�NDDUW�EUHQJHQ��NRPHQ�FRQIOLFWHQ�HQ�PHW�QDPH�YHUOLHVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�LQ�GHSHULRGH�GLUHFW�YRRUDIJDDQG�DDQ�GH�VXwFLGH�DOV�GHWHUPLQDQW�QDDU�YRUHQ��5LFK�HW�DO���������

Page 70: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

0HW� QDPH� RQGHU� DOFRKROJHEUXLNHUV� NXQQHQ� YHUOLHVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� NUDFKWLJ� DOVXLWORNNHQGH� GHWHUPLQDQW� ZHUNHQ� �0XUSK\�� ������� 6WUHVVYROOH� OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�]RDOV� PLVKDQGHOLQJ� GRRU� GH� RXGHUV�� YHUNUDFKWLQJ� HQ� FRQIOLFWHQ� PHW� SDUWQHUV�� ZRUGHQYDNHU� JHUDSSRUWHHUG� GRRU� SDUDVXwFLGDQWHQ� GDQ� GH� DOJHPHQH� EHYRONLQJ�� 0DDU� LQWHJHQVWHOOLQJ� WRW� GH� JHVODDJGH� VXwFLGH� JDDW� KHW� KLHUELM� PLQGHU� YDDN� RP� W\SLVFKHYHUOLHVHUYDULQJHQ��PDDU� YRRUDO� RP� LQWHUSHUVRRQOLMNH� FRQIOLFWHQ� �$UHQVPDQ�� ������� 'HPHHVWH YDQ� GH]H� HUYDULQJHQ� OLMNHQ� RYHULJHQV� JHQHULHNH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YRRUSV\FKLDWULVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ� WH�]LMQ��]RQGHU�GXLGHOLMNH� VSHFLILFLWHLW�YRRU� VXwFLGDDO� JHGUDJ�1HHOHPDQ�� ������� 'HVDOQLHWWHPLQ� OLMNHQ� WZHH� W\SHQ� YDQ� HUYDULQJHQ� HHQ� VSHFLILHNHYRRUVSHOOHQGH�ZDDUGH�WH�KHEEHQ�YRRU�]HOIGRGLQJ��URXZ�RP�KHW�YHUOLHV�YDQ�HHQ�JHOLHIGH�1HHOHPDQ�� ������ HQ� EORRWVWHOOLQJ� DDQ� YRRUEHHOGJHGUDJ�� ]RDOV� VXwFLGHV� LQ� GH� PHGLD�3KLOOLSV��������6FKPLGWNH��+DHIQHU���������'H�URO�YDQ�DOFRKRO��HQ�PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLNDOV NUDFKWLJH� XLWORNNHQGH� IDFWRUHQ� GLHQW� DSDUW� JHPHPRUHHUG� WH� ZRUGHQ�� 'LW� VWHUNHYHUEDQG UHIOHFWHHUW� ZDDUVFKLMQOLMN� WZHH� VHSDUDWH� PHFKDQLVPHQ�� 7HQ� HHUVWH� LV� HU� HHQYHUEDQG WXVVHQ�PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN�HQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�V\PSWRPDWRORJLH� LQ�KHW�DOJHPHHQ�7HQ�WZHHGH�KHHIW�PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN�HHQ�RQWUHPPHQG�HIIHFW��GDW�HU�ELMYRRUEHHOG�WRH�NDQOHLGHQ�GDW�PHQ�LQ�SODDWV�YDQ�HHQ�KDQGMHYRO��HHQ�KHHO�IOHVMH�PHGLFLMQHQ�LQ�RYHUGRVHULQJQHHPW��'LW�KHHIW�WRW�JHYROJ�GDW�VXwFLGDDO�JHGUDJ�YDNHU�RRN�GDDGZHUNHOLMN�OHWKDDO�]DO�]LMQ�)DUUHOO�HW�DO���������1HHOHPDQ��)DUUHOO��������&RQFOXVLHV%LM� ]HOIGRGLQJ� JDDW� KHW� LQ� YHUJHOLMNLQJ� WRW� GH� DQGHUH� LQ� GLW� KRRIGVWXN� EHVSURNHQVWRRUQLVVHQ� RP� UHODWLHI� NOHLQH� DDQWDOOHQ�� +HW� XLWYRHUHQ� YDQ� SURVSHFWLHI� HWLRORJLVFKRQGHU]RHN�LV�GDDURP�QLHW�KDDOEDDU��(HQ�DQGHU�SUREOHHP�PHW�GLW�W\SH�RQGHU]RHN�LV�GDW�GHVODFKWRIIHUV�QLHW�PHHU�RQGHU]RFKW�NXQQHQ�ZRUGHQ��+LHUGRRU� LV�GH�EHZLMVODVW�YRRU�YHOHYDQ GH� EHVSURNHQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� UHODWLHI� ODDJ�� (HQ� EHYLQGLQJ� ZDDU� SUDNWLVFK� DOOHRQGHU]RHNLQJHQ� HHQVOXLGHQG� RYHU� ]LMQ�� EHWUHIW� KHW� ]HHU� VWHUNH� YHUEDQG� WXVVHQSV\FKLDWULVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� VXwFLGH�� *HVFKDW� ZRUGW� GDW� ���� �� ����� YDQ� DOOHVXwFLGHVODFKWRIIHUV�DDQ�HHQ�VWRRUQLV�OLMGHQ�

��� 3V\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG,Q�GH]H�SDUDJUDDI�ZRUGW� LQJHJDDQ�RS�GH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�=RDOV�UHHGV�XLWHHQJH]HW�LQ�SDUDJUDDI�����NHQW�GH�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�HSLGHPLRORJLH�QDDVW�GHFDWHJRULDOH�� VWRRUQLVJHERQGHQ�� EHQDGHULQJ� RRN� HHQ� GLPHQVLRQHOH� LQYDOVKRHN�� +LHULQZRUGW DDQ� LHGHU� LQGLYLGX� HHQ� VFRUH� YRRU� SV\FKLVFKH� �RQ�JH]RQGKHLG� WRHJHNHQG�ELMYRRUEHHOG� JHPHWHQ� PHW� EHKXOS� YDQ� GH� *HQHUDO� +HDOWK� 4XHVWLRQQDLUH� �*+4��*ROGEHUJ�� ������ RI� GH� 3UHVHQW� 6WDWH� ([DPLQDWLRQ�� +HW� VWUHVV�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO�ILJXXU� ����SDUDJUDDI� ������ YHURQGHUVWHOW� GDW� LHGHU� LQGLYLGX� ]LMQ� KDELWXHOH� QLYHDX� YDQSV\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG�KHHIW��3HUVRQHQ�]RQGHU�VWRRUQLV�RQGHUVFKHLGHQ�]LFK�YDQ�KHQGLH GLDJQRVWLFHHUEDUH� VWRRUQLV� KHEEHQ� GRRU� KHW� IHLW� GDW� KXQ� V\PSWRRPQLYHDX� HHQEHSDDOGH �LQ�GH�'60�FODVVLILFDWLH�YDVWJHOHJGH��JUHQV�QLHW�RYHUVFKULMGW��'LW�KRXGW�HFKWHUQLHW LQ�GDW�]LM�GDiURP�HHQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLGVVFRUH�YDQ�QXO�KHEEHQ�

Page 71: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

+HW� LV� JHEOHNHQ� GDW� LQGLYLGXHQ�PHW� GH� KRRJVWH� VFRUHV� YRRU� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLGQLHW DOOHHQ�HUQVWLJHU�HQ�ODQJGXULJHU��PDDU�RRN�PpHU�VWRRUQLVVHQ�KHEEHQ�GDQ�JHPLGGHOG�3V\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�KHEEHQ�HHQ�VWHUNH�QHLJLQJ�RP�WH�FOXVWHUHQ��$QGUHZV��+RXVH��������� 8LW�UHFHQW�1HGHUODQGV�RQGHU]RHN�EOLMNW�GDW�����YDQ�DOOH�SHUVRQHQ�GLH�RRLW�HHQSV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLV� LQ� KXQ� OHYHQ� KHEEHQ� PHHJHPDDNW�� PHHU� GDQ� ppQ� VWRRUQLV� KHHIWJHKDG� �KRHZHO� QLHW� QRRG]DNHOLMNHUZLMV� WHJHOLMNHUWLMG�� �%LMO� HW� DO��� ����E��� 9DQ� DOOHJHUDSSRUWHHUGH� ���PDDQGVWRRUQLVVHQ� FRQFHQWUHHUW� HHQ� GHUGH� ]LFK� LQ� ��� YDQ� GH1HGHUODQGVH�EHYRONLQJ��%LMO�HW�DO�������E���'H]H�PLQGHUKHLG�KHHIW�QLHW�DOOHHQ�GH�PHHVWH�PDDU�RRN�GH�PHHVW�HUQVWLJVWH�HQ�PHHVW�FKURQLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��HQ�LV�GXV�SV\FKLVFK�KHWRQJH]RQGVW�� 3V\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG� NDQ� GDQ� RRN� ZRUGHQ� EHVFKRXZG� YDQXLW� HHQGULHWDO�LQYDOVKRHNHQ��GLH�YDQ�GH�FKURQLFLWHLW��GH�HUQVW�HQ�GH�GLYHUVLWHLW�YDQ�VWRRUQLVVHQ�'HPRJUDILVFKH�IDFWRUHQ+HW� LV� RQGXLGHOLMN� RI�� HQ� ]R� MD�� LQ� KRHYHUUH� LQWHQVLWHLW�� FKURQLFLWHLW� RI� GLYHUVLWHLW� YDQSV\FKLDWULVFKH� V\PSWRPHQ� RQGHU� VWHUNH� JHVODFKWVLQYORHG� VWDDQ�� 9URXZHQ� VFRUHQ� ZHOKRJHU�GDQ�PDQQHQ�RS�GLUHFWH�PDWHQ�YRRU�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG� ]RDOV�GH�*+4�HQKHEEHQ� RRN� PHHU� FRPRUELGH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� �%LMO� HW� DO��� ����E�� PDDU� GLW� ZRUGW� ZHOWRHJHVFKUHYHQ� DDQ� HHQ� KRJHUH�PDWH� YDQ� RQWNHQQLQJ� ELM�PDQQHQ� �&RUQH\�� �������:pOEHVWDDW� HU� HHQ� VWHUN� QHJDWLHI� YHUEDQG� WXVVHQ� OHHIWLMG� HQ� LQGLFHV� YRRU� SV\FKLVFKHRQJH]RQGKHLG� �/HZLV�HW� DO���������0HOW]HU� HW� DO��� �������'H� UHGHQHQ�YRRU�GLW� YHUEDQG]LMQ� QLHW� JHKHHO� GXLGHOLMN�� 6WRRUQLVVHQ� ELM� RXGHUHQ� ]LMQ� YDDN� FKURQLVFKHU�PDDU�PLQGHUHUQVWLJ�GDQ�ELM�MRQJHUHQ��(U�]RX�RRN�VSUDNH�NXQQHQ�]LMQ�YDQ�HHQ�KHDOWK\�VXUYLYRU�HIIHFW�GH ODQJVW�OHYHQGHQ�]LMQ�RRN�GH�PHHVW�UREXXVWHQ�(QGRJHQH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ*HQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ=RDOV� HOGHUV� UHHGV� WHU� VSUDNH� NZDP� ]LMQ� HU� DDQZLM]LQJHQ� YRRU� JHPHHQVFKDSSHOLMNHJHQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� GLH� WHQ� JURQGVODJ� OLJJHQ� DDQ� VRPPLJH� SV\FKLDWULVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�.HQGOHU� HW� DO��� ������ ������ 0HULNDQJDV� HW� DO��� �������9RRUEHHOGHQ� KLHUYDQ� ]LMQ� GHJHPHHQVFKDSSHOLMNH�RYHUHUYLQJ�YDQ�JHJHQHUDOLVHHUGH�DQJVWVWRRUQLV�HQ�GHSUHVVLH��RI�YDQHUQVWLJH� DOFRKROSUREOHPDWLHN� HQ� DQWLVRFLDOH� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVVWRRUQLV�� 'LW� EHWHNHQWDXWRPDWLVFK� GDW� RRN� FRPRUELGLWHLW� HQ� GHUKDOYH� RRN� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�� WHQPLQVWH�WHQ�GHOH��JHQHWLVFK�EHSDDOG�]LMQ�3HUVRRQOLMNKHLG�HQ�VRPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ1HXURWLFLVPH�HQ�DQGHUH�YRUPHQ�YDQ�LQWHUQDOLVHUHQG�JHGUDJ�]LMQ�VWHUN�JHDVVRFLHHUG�PHWSV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�� 'H]H� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVNHQPHUNHQ� EOLMNHQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� WH]LMQ�YDQ�FKURQLFLWHLW��HUQVW�HQ�GLYHUVLWHLW�YDQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��'XJJDQ�HW�DO��)DURRT�HW�DO���������)HUGLQDQG��9HUKXOVW��������1HHOHPDQ�HW�DO�������������� 6FRWW���������'LW�JHOGW�RRN�YRRU�RQWZLNNHOLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�]RDOV�LQWUD�XWHULHQH�HQ�SRVW�QDWDOHJURHLYHUWUDJLQJ�� SHULQDWDOH� FRPSOLFDWLHV� HQ� YURHJ� RSWUHGHQGH� KHFKWLQJV�� HQJHGUDJVPRHLOLMNKHGHQ��-RQHV�HW�DO���������9DQ�2V�HW�DO���������1HHOHPDQ�HW�DO��������5RGJHUV��������

���9DQ�FOXVWHULQJ�ZRUGW�JHVSURNHQ�ZDQQHHU�VWRRUQLVVHQ�YDNHU�JHFRPELQHHUG��FRPRUELGH��YRRUNRPHQ�GDQWH�YHUZDFKWHQ�]RX�]LMQ�RS�JURQG�YDQ�KXQ�DI]RQGHUOLMNH�SUHYDOHQWLHV�

Page 72: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

([RJHQH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ6RFLDOH�VWHXQ3HUVRQHQ� PHW� HHQ� UHODWLHI� XLWJHEUHLG� HQ� KRRJZDDUGLJ� VRFLDDO� QHWZHUN� ]LMQ� SV\FKLVFKJH]RQGHU� GDQ� ]LM� GLH� GHUJHOLMNH� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ� RQWEHUHQ� �%UXJKD� HW� DO��� ������ &UDPHU�������*HRUJH�HW�DO���������+HQGHUVRQ��������.HQGOHU�HW�DO���������.HVVOHU��.HQGOHU��������+HW�LV�HFKWHU�QLHW�GXLGHOLMN�RI�ZH�KLHU�PHW�RRU]DDN�RI�JHYROJ�WH�PDNHQ�KHEEHQ�3V\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�NDQ�OHLGHQ�WRW�HHQ�XLWKROOLQJ�YDQ�KHW�VRFLDOH�QHWZHUN�PDDU�RRNRPJHNHHUG� �+HQGHUVRQ� HW� DO��� ������� (U� LV� RS� GLW� SXQW� HHQ� JHEUHN� DDQ� SURVSHFWLHIRQGHU]RHN�GDW�GLW�YUDDJVWXN�NDQ�RSORVVHQ�6(6��YHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ�HQ�OHHIYRUP(HQ�ODJH�VRFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKH�SRVLWLH��RQJHKXZG�]LMQ�HQ�ZRQHQ�LQ�GH�VWDG�YRUPHQ�HHQGXLGHOLMNH� ULVLFRIDFWRU� YRRU� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�� 'H� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� GLHYRRUNRPHQ� LQ� PDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH� JURHSHQ� GLH� JHNHQPHUNW� ZRUGHQ� GRRU� GH]HULVLFRIDFWRUHQ��]LMQ�FKURQLVFKHU�HQ�PHHU�YHUVFKHLGHQ��%LMO�HW�DO�������E���'DW�KHW�KLHUELMJDDW� RP� HHQ� YHUEDQG� WXVVHQ� GH]H� PDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH� IDFWRUHQ� DOV� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�HQ�QLHW�RPJHNHHUG�LV�LQPLGGHOV�GRRU�GH�PHHVWH��'RKUHQZHQG 'RKUHQZHQG��������/HZLV�HW�DO���������1HHOHPDQ�HW�DO���������PDDU�QLHW�DOOH��7RUUH\HW�DO���������SURVSHFWLHYH�RQGHU]RHNHQ�EHYHVWLJG�/HYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ.ZHWVEDDUKHLGVYHUKRJHQGH�� YURHJ� RSJHGDQH� HUYDULQJHQ� NXQQHQ� GH� ODWHUH� SV\FKLVFKHJH]RQGKHLG� QHJDWLHI� EHwQYORHGHQ�� ELMYRRUEHHOG� GRRU� HHQ� YHUKRJLQJ� LQ� GH� PDWH� YDQQHXURWLVFK�UHDJHUHQ�WRW�VWDQG�WH�EUHQJHQ��9URHJNLQGHUOLMNH�QHJDWLHYH�HUYDULQJHQ�EOLMNHQPDWLJ� VWHUNH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ� WRWDOH�36(�HQ�*+4�VFRUHV�RS� MRQJ�YROZDVVHQ� OHHIWLMG�*ROGEHUJ��+X[OH\��������.HQGOHU��.DUNRZVN\�6KXPDQ��������+HW� RPJHNHHUGH� JHOGW� YRRU� XLWORNNHQGH� IDFWRUHQ�� 6WRRUQLVVHQ� GLH� YRRUDI� ]LMQJHJDDQ� GRRU� GXLGHOLMNH� VWUHVVIDFWRUHQ� ]LMQ� RYHU� KHW� DOJHPHHQ� PLQGHU� FKURQLVFK� RIHUQVWLJ�GDQ�VSRQWDQH��]LFK�ODQJ]DDP�RSHQEDUHQGH�YRUPHQ�YDQ�RQJH]RQGKHLG��+HW� OLMNWHU� RS� GDW� KRH� KRJHU� GH� NZHWVEDDUKHLG� LV�� KRH� PLQGHU� VWUHVV� HU� QRGLJ� LV� RP� KHWG\QDPLVFKH�HYHQZLFKW�XLW�EDODQV�WH�GRHQ�JHUDNHQ�&RQFOXVLHV3V\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�HQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�FRPRUELGLWHLW�]LMQ�WZHH�]LMGHQ�YDQ�ppQPHGDLOOH��+HW�EHHOG�GDW�RSULMVW�XLW�RQGHU]RHN�GDW�]RZHO�GH�FDWHJRULDOH�DOV�GHGLPHQVLRQDOH�EHQDGHULQJ�KDQWHHUW��LV�GDW�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLGHQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�DI]RQGHUOLMNH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�LQ�VWHUNH�PDWH�RYHUODSSHQ��+HW�YHUEDQGYDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�PHW�GH�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�ZRUGW�VWHUNHU�QDDUPDWH�]LM�DDQPHHU VWRRUQLVVHQ�]LMQ�JHUHODWHHUG��0HW�QDPH�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVYHUKRJHQGH�HUYDULQJHQ�HQHQGRJHQH�IDFWRUHQ�GLH�UHHGV�YURHJ�LQ�GH�LQGLYLGXHOH�RQWZLNNHOLQJ�DDQZH]LJ�]LMQ�OLMNHQLQ GLW�JHYDO�EHODQJULMNH�ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ

Page 73: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

� &RQFOXVLHV'H� DIJHORSHQ� GHFHQQLD� ]LMQ� YHHO� PRJHOLMNH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH�RQ�JH]RQGKHLG� RQGHU]RFKW�� 6RPPLJH� ]LMQ� LQPLGGHOV� RQWPDVNHUG� DOV� RQ]LQ�ELMYHUVFKLMQVHO� RI� JHYROJ�� 'HQN� PDDU� DDQ� GH� GH[DPHWKDVRQ� VXSSUHVVLHWHVW� YRRUGHSUHVVLH��GH�NLOOH�PRHGHU�YRRU�VFKL]RIUHQLH�HQ�GH�UHSUHVVLHYH�PDDWVFKDSSHOLMNH�RUGH�DOVGHWHUPLQDQW�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�LQ�KHW�DOJHPHHQ��$QGHUH�IDFWRUHQ�EOLMNHQ�ZpOGLUHFW� RI� LQGLUHFW� EHWURNNHQ� ELM� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� 'H� EHZLMVODVW� YRRU� YHHO� YDQ� GH]HGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�LV�HYHQZHO�QRJ�GXQ�'LW� KHHIW� DOOHUHHUVW� WH�PDNHQ�PHW� KHW� IHLW� GDW� GH� SV\FKLDWULVFKH� HSLGHPLRORJLHQRJ HHQ� UHODWLHI� MRQJH� ZHWHQVFKDS� LV�� ZDDUGRRU� SURVSHFWLHI� ORQJLWXGLQDDO� RQGHU]RHNVFKDDUV LV�� 'DDUQDDVW� KHHIW� KHW� WRW� QX� WRH� XLWJHYRHUGH� RQGHU]RHN� YDDN� QLHW� GXLGHOLMNNXQQHQ� PDNHQ� KRH� GH� UHODWLH� WXVVHQ� GHWHUPLQDQW� HQ� VWRRUQLV� QX� SUHFLHV� OLJW�� (HQLQDGHTXDWH� GDWHULQJ� YDQ� KHW� RSWUHGHQ� YDQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� HQ� �]LHNWH�HSLVRGHQ� HQ� HHQJHEUHN�DDQ�DDQGDFKW�YRRU�PHFKDQLVPHQ�HQ�PHGLsUHQGH�SURFHVVHQ�YRUPHQ�KLHUYRRU�GHEHODQJULMNVWH�UHGHQHQ��(HQ�EHODQJULMN�SUREOHHP�EOLMIW�RRN�GH�LGHQWLILFDWLH�HQ�FODVVLILFDWLHYDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�GRRU�GH� DIZH]LJKHLG�YDQ� �NHQQLV�RYHU��REMHFWLHYH� I\VLVFK�FKHPLVFKH�FULWHULD�LQ�GH�GLDJQRVWLHN��'H�EHSHUNWH�EHWURXZEDDUKHLG�YDQ�GH�GLDJQRVWLVFKHFULWHULD� HQ� GH� YHOH� YHUDQGHULQJHQ� LQ� GH� DIJHORSHQ� GHFHQQLD� LQ� GH� FODVVLILFDWLH� YDQSV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�EHSHUNHQ�GH�RQGHUOLQJH�YHUJHOLMNEDDUKHLG�YDQ���KHW� WRFK�DO�QLHWRPYDQJULMNH� DDQWDO�� VWXGLHV�� HQ� EHPRHLOLMNHQ� KHW� GRHQ� YDQ� XLWVSUDNHQ� RYHU� GHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�8LWJDDQGH�YDQ�GH]H�EHSHUNLQJHQ�HQ� JHEDVHHUG�RS�GH� JHJHYHQV�XLW�KRRIGVWXN��ZRUGW KLHU� DDQJHJHYHQ� ZDW� RS� GLW� PRPHQW� GH� EHODQJULMNVWH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG�OLMNHQ�WH�]LMQ��ZDW�GDDUYRRU�GH�EHZLMVODVW�LV�HQ�ZHONH�UHODWLHVHU� WXVVHQ�GH]H�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�]LMQ��*HWUDFKW�ZRUGW� RP� HHQ� HQ� DQGHU� WH� SODDWVHQ� LQ� KHWG\QDPLVFKH� VWUHVV�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO� �'6.�PRGHO��� 7HQVORWWH� ZRUGW� GH� EHWHNHQLVYDQ�GH�EHYLQGLQJHQ� JHVFKHWVW� YRRU�RQGHU]RHN�HQ� �SUHYHQWLH�EHOHLG�� HQ� HHQ� EOLN� RS� GHWRHNRPVW�JHZRUSHQ�

Page 74: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

���� (HQ�RYHU]LFKW�YDQ�GH�EHODQJULMNVWH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ7DEHO� ���� JHHIW� HHQ� RYHU]LFKW� YDQ� GH� EHODQJULMNVWH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�� 'DDUELM� LV� JHSRRJG� RP� GH� VWHUNWH� YDQ� KHWYHUEDQG� HQ� GH� ELMEHKRUHQGH�EHZLMVODVW� HQLJV]LQV� WH� NZDQWLILFHUHQ��'H� VWHUNWH� YDQ� KHWYHUEDQG� LV� JHVFKDW�XLW� GH� UHODWLHYH� ULVLFR¶V� ]RDOV�GH]H�XLW� KHW� OLWHUDWXXURQGHU]RHN� QDDUYRUHQ NZDPHQ��'H�EHZLMVODVW�LV�JHEDVHHUG�RS�KHW�DDQWDO�VWXGLHV��GH�FRQVLVWHQWLH�YDQ�GHEHYLQGLQJHQ�� KXQ� PHWKRGRORJLVFKH� NZDOLWHLW� �SURVSHFWLHI�� FDVH�FRQWURO�� GZDUVGRRU�VQHGH�� HQ�GH�ELRORJLVFKH�SODXVLELOLWHLW�YDQ�KHW�YHUEDQG��'H�WDEHO�EHYHVWLJW�KHW�EHHOG�YDQSV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� DOV� PXOWLIDFWRULsOH� DDQGRHQLQJHQ�� 'H� YHOH� YUDDJWHNHQV� HQ� GHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� ZDDUYRRU� GH� EHZLMVODVW� QRJ� JHULQJ� LV� DFFHQWXHUHQ� HFKWHU� RRN� RQ]HRQZHWHQGKHLG�

Page 75: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

7DEHO�������2YHU]LFKW�YDQ�GH�VWHUNWH�YDQ�GH�YHUEDQG�WXVVHQ�GHWHUPLQDQW�HQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV�F�T��SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�HQ�GH�EHZLMVODVW�KLHUYRRU�

'HWHUPLQDQW 6WHPPLQJV�VWRRUQLVVHQ55E %/F

$QJVW��HQVRPDWRIRUPHVWRRUQLVVHQ55��������� %/

6FKL]RIUHQLH

55�������� %/

%LSRODLUH6WRRUQLV55��������� %/

$OFRKRO�GUXJVYHUVODYLQJ55�������� %/

=HOIGRGLQJ

55�������� %/

3V\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ�ELMMHXJGLJHQ55��������� ���%/

3V\FKLVFKHRQJH]RQGKHLG�D55����������������%/

'HPRJUDILVFKH�IDFWRUHQ� JHVODFKW�G �� ��� �� ��� � ��� � ��� ���� ��� ��� ��� ��� ��� " "� OHHIWLMG�������MU�ELM�RQWVWDDQ� MD �� MD �� MD ��� MD �� MD ��� QHH ��� MD S�G� MD ��(QGRJHQH�IDFWRUHQ� JHQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�H� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLG� JHUHPG���LQWHUQDOLVHUHQGILQWHUSHUVRRQOLMNH�VHQVLWLYLWHLW� LPSXOVLYLWHLW���K\SHUDFWLYLWHLWJ� VRPDWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ� FRPSOLFDWLHV�ELM�]ZDQJHUVFKDS�JHERRUWH� RQWZLNNHOLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�KQHXUR�DQDWRPLVFK�L� QHXUR�HQGRFULQRORJLVFK�M� OLFKDPHOLMNH�]LHNWHQ���JHYROJHQN� HHUGHUH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV� GURS�RXW�VFKRRO���ZHUN

������������"����"

��������"����"

���������""""��"

������""""��"

��������������

�������������������

���������������

�����������������

���"����������

����"������������

"�"����"""������

"��"���"""������

�����"����"""��

����"������"""���

��������"����

�������"����

([RJHQH�IDFWRUHQ� ODJH�6(6� VWUHVVYRO�ZHUN� FRQIOLFWXHX]H�JH]LQVVLWXDWLHO� YHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ� VRFLDDO�FXOWXUHOH�IDFWRUHQP� VRFLDOH�LVRODWLH���JHHQ�VWHXQ� VRFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKH�FULVLV�RRUORJ�UDPSHQ

��������

����������

������"��

���������"�

�����"�

�������"�

������"�

������"�

������"�

��������"�

��"�������"�

���"�����"

�����"""�

�����"""

��������

�������

Page 76: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

7DEHO������YHUYROJ����2YHU]LFKW�YDQ�GH�VWHUNWH�YDQ�GH�YHUEDQG�WXVVHQ�GHWHUPLQDQW�HQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV�F�T��SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�HQ�GH�EHZLMVODVWKLHUYRRU�

'HWHUPLQDQW 6WHPPLQJV�VWRRUQLVVHQ55E %/F

$QJVW��HQVRPDWRIRUPHVWRRUQLVVHQ55��������� %/

6FKL]RIUHQLH

55�������� %/

%LSRODLUH6WRRUQLV55��������� %/

$OFRKRO�GUXJVYHUVODYLQJ55�������� %/

=HOIGRGLQJ

55�������� %/

3V\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ�ELMMHXJGLJHQ55��������� ���%/

3V\FKLVFKHRQJH]RQGKHLG�D55����������������%/

/HYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� NZHWVEDDUKHLGYHUKRJHQG��WUDXPD¶V�� XLWORNNHQG��JHSDDUG�JDDQGH�PHW«� ��YHUOLHV�HLJHQZDDUGH�VWDWXV�Q� �VRFLDOH"��RQWZRUWHOLQJ� ��DDQSDVVLQJ�YHUJHQG

�����"

�����"

�����

����

����

������

����

�����

����

������"

�����"

����

����

����

����

����

D�� 3V\FKLVFKH��RQ�JH]RQGKHLG�EHWUHIW�HHQ�GLPHQVLRQHOH�EHQDGHULQJ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��+HW�JHHIW�ZHHU�GH�PDWH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�LQ�WHUPHQ�YDQ��LQWHQVLWHLW�FKURQLFLWHLW��HQ�GLYHUVLWHLW�YDQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�V\PSWRPHQ�E�� 5HODWLHI�5LVLFR��55��RI�2GGV�5DWLR��25���PDDW�YRRU�GH�VWHUNWH�YDQ�KHW�YHUEDQG�WXVVHQ�GH�GHWHUPLQDQW�HQ�GH�VWRRUQLV��'H�KRRJWH�YDQ�KHW�55�LV�JHVFKDW�DDQ�GH�KDQG�YDQ�GHEHVFKLNEDUH�OLWHUDWXXU��DOV�YROJW�ZHHUJHJHYHQ����� �FLUFD����JHHQ�YHUEDQG������ ���������� ������������ �!���VWHUN�YHUEDQG���"� �RQGXLGHOLMN��YDQZHJH�JHEUHN�DDQ�RQGHU]RHN�RILQFRQVLVWHQWH�UHVXOWDWHQ����'LW�DOOHV�RQJHFRUULJHHUG�YRRU�RQGHUOLQJH�UHODWLHV�WXVVHQ�GH�DQGHUH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�F�� %HZLMVODVW��%/����� �ZHLQLJ�EHZLMVODVW������� �HQLJH�EHZLMVODVW������� �DDQ]LHQOLMNH�EHZLMVODVW���"� �JHHQ�WRW�QDXZHOLMNV�RQGHU]RHN�QDDU��JHGDDQ�G�� *HVFRRUG�LV�HHQ�KRJHU�UHODWLHI�ULVLFR�YRRU�YURXZHQ��WHQ]LM�DQGHUV�DDQJHJHYHQ�LQ�GH�WDEHO�H�� :DDUGH�UHIHUHHUW�DDQ�FRQFRUGDQWLH�UDWLR�YDQ�0=�WRY�'=��WZHHOLQJHQ����� ���� ������� �������� !���I�� 2PYDW�WHYHQV�QHXURWLFLVPH�HQ�µLQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH¶�EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJV��HQ�FRSLQJVWLMOHQ��VFKXOG��VFKDDPWH��HPRWLH�JHULFKW��YHUPLMGLQJ��J�� 2PYDW�WHYHQV�µH[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH¶�EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJV��HQ�FRSLQJVWLMOHQ��SHUFHSWLH�YDQ�YLMDQGLJKHLG��DJUHVVLH��K�� 2QWZLNNHOLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�EHWUHIIHQ�DEQRUPDOLWHLWHQ�LQ�PRWRULVFKH��FRJQLWLHYH�HQ�RI��VRFLDOH�RQWZLNNHOLQJ�JHGXUHQGH�GH�NLQGHUMDUHQ�L� 1HXUR�DQDWRPLVFKH�µDIZLMNLQJHQ¶�]RDOV�UHODWLHI�NOHLQH�KHUVHQHQ�HQ�YHUJURWH�YHQWULNHOV�M� 1HXUR�HQGRFULQRORJLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�EHWUHIIHQ�R�D��K\SHUDFWLYLWHLW�YDQ�GH�K\SRWKDODPXV�K\SRI\VH�ELMQLHU��+3$��DV�N�� %LM�OLFKDPHOLMNH�]LHNWHQ�HQ�JHYROJHQ�JDDW�KHW�HQHU]LMGV�RP�GLUHFWH��µLQWHUQ�VRPDWLVFKH¶�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�EHSDDOGH�]LHNWHQ�RS�SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG��EY��&9$�HQ�GHPHQWLH�RS�GHSUHVVLHULVLFR���HQ�DQGHU]LMGV�RP�PHHU�VWUHVV�JHUHODWHHUGH�HIIHFWHQ�GLH�VDPHQKDQJHQ�PHW�GH�JHSHUFLSLHHUGH�OHYHQVYHUZDFKWLQJ�HQ�PHW�GH�JHYROJHQ�YDQ�]LHNWH�YRRU�KHW�GDJHOLMNVHIXQFWLRQHUHQ�O�� &RQIOLFWXHX]H�JH]LQVVLWXDWLH�RPYDW�QDDVW�FKURQLVFKH�FRQIOLFWHQ�RRN�GLVFRQWLQXLWHLW�YDQ�]RUJ�HQ�YHUZDDUOR]LQJ�P�� 6RFLDDO�FXOWXUHOH�RQWKHHPGLQJ�HQ�LGHQWLWHLWVYHUOLHV��YRRUDO��W�J�Y���PLJUDWLH��PDDU�RRN�FXOWXXU�JHERQGHQ�YHUVFKLOOHQ�LQ�PDQLIHVWDWLH�HQ�SUHVHQWDWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�G\VIXQFWLRQHUHQ�Q�� 'H]H�GHWHUPLQDQW�RYHUODSW��YRRUDO�ELM�RXGHUHQ���PHW�GH�IXQFWLRQHOH�JHYROJHQ�YDQ�HUQVWLJH�FKURQLVFKH�]LHNWHQ���� 5LVLFR�ELM�PDQQHQ�YHUKRRJG���� 5LVLFR�YRRU�H[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�LV�ELM�MRQJHQV�YHUKRRJG��ULVLFR�YRRU�LQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�ELM�PHLVMHV���� 'XLGHOLMNH�EHZLMVODVW�RQWEUHHNW��DO�LV�KHW�DDQQHPHOLMN�RP�HHQ�HIIHFW�WH�YHUZDFKWHQ�JH]LHQ�GH�UHODWLH�PHW�VWUHVVYROOH�OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�

Page 77: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

'H�EHZLMVODVW�YRRU�HHQ�GXLGHOLMNH�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�JHQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�ELM�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQVWRRUQLVVHQ� XLW� KHW� SV\FKRWLVFKH� VSHFWUXP� �ELSRODLUH� VWRRUQLV�� VFKL]RIUHQLH�� LVRYHUWXLJHQG� �0HULNDQJDV�� 6ZHQGVHQ�� ������ 5XWWHU� � 3ORPLQ�� ������� 'LW� JHOGW� RRNYRRU� HQNHOH� DQGHUH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� � ]RDOV� DXWLVPH� �QLHW� EHVSURNHQ� LQ� GH]H� UDSSRUWDJH��$'+'�HQ�SHUVLVWHUHQG�DQWL�VRFLDDO�JHGUDJ��+HW�YHUEDQG�LV�PLQGHU�VWHUN�HQ�GH�EHZLMVODVW]ZDNNHU� YRRU� DQJVW��� VWHPPLQJV�� HQ� VRPDWRIRUPH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� PHW� QDPH� KXQ� PLOGHYDULDQWHQ�� HQ� YRRU� PLVEUXLN� HQ� DIKDQNHOLMNKHLG� YDQ� PLGGHOHQ�� 2QEHNHQG� LV� RRN� KRHVWHUN� GH� JHQHWLVFKH� ELMGUDJH� LV� DDQ� VXwFLGH�� ZDQQHHU� GH]H� JHFRUULJHHUG� LV� YRRU� GHELMGUDJH�YDQ�JHQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�DDQ�GH�YDDN�FRPRUELGH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV��2RN�ELM�GHKLHU�QLHW�EHVSURNHQ�SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVVWRRUQLVVHQ� LV�RQGXLGHOLMN�KRH�JURRW�GH�JHQHWLVFKHELMGUDJH�LV��DO�LV�GXLGHOLMN�GDW�GH]H�EHVWDDW��/LYHVOH\�HW�DO���������+HW� IHLW� GDW� JHQHWLVFKH� LQYORHGHQ� ELM� GH� PHHVWH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HHQ� URO� VSHOHQ�LPSOLFHHUW�QLHW�GDW�KHW�RP�GH]HOIGH� JHQHQ�JDDW��$OOHHQ� WXVVHQ�GH�DQJVW� HQ�GHSUHVVLHYHVWRRUQLVVHQ� EHVWDDW� HHQ� VWHUNH� JHQHWLVFKH� FRUUHODWLH�� ZDW� LQKRXGW� GDW� GHHOV� GH]HOIGHJHQHQ� ELM� GH]H� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ]LMQ� EHWURNNHQ�� 'H� JHQHWLVFKH� FRUUHODWLH� WXVVHQ� GH� DQGHUHJURHSHQ� VWRRUQLVVHQ� LV� HFKWHU� YHHO� NOHLQHU�� =HOIV� ELQQHQ� GH� JURHSHQ� ]LMQ� HU� YDDNYHUVFKLOOHQ� LQ� GH� EHWURNNHQ� JHQHQ�� 'LW� JHOGW� ELMYRRUEHHOG� YRRU� $'+'� HQ� DXWLVPH�DFKWLJH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��7HQVORWWH�GLHQW�PHQ�ELM�GLW�DOOHV�WH�EHVHIIHQ�GDW�QRJ�JHHQ�JHQHQ�]LMQJHwGHQWLILFHHUG��HU�LV�KRRJXLW�VSUDNH�NDQGLGDDWJHQHQ�5HODWLHI� JRHG� RQGHUERXZG� LV� RRN� GH� LQYORHG� YDQ� GH� RYHULJH� HQGRJHQHULVLFRIDFWRUHQ� PHW� QDPH� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVNHQPHUNHQ� HQ� LQ� PLQGHUH� PDWHEHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJV�� HQ� FRSLQJVWLMOHQ�� HQ� YDQ� LQJULMSHQGH� VWUHVVYROOH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�+HW�JDDW�KLHUELM�YRRUDO�RP�KHW�RQVWDDQ�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH��PDDU�RRN�RP�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�HQYHUVODYLQJ� HQ� LQ� PLQGHUH� PDWH�� VRPDWRIRUPH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� 6WUHVVYROOH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQYHUKRJHQ�RYHULJHQV�KHW�ULVLFR�RS�GH�PHHVWH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��JHJHYHQ�HHQ�]HNHUHNZHWVEDDUKHLG�� (U� ]LMQ� HFKWHU� PDDU� EHSHUNWH� DDQZLM]LQJHQ� GDW� HHQ� EHSDDOG� W\SHVWUHVVYROOH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�� GRRU� KXQ� VSHFLILHNH� EHWHNHQLV�� YHUEDQG� KRXGHQ� PHW� KHWRQWVWDDQ� YDQ� HHQ� EHSDDOGH� VWRRUQLV�� 'H� PHHVWH� VWHXQ� LQ� GLW� YHUEDQG� LV� YRRUYHUOLHVHUYDULQJHQ�HQ�GHSUHVVLH�9DQ� GH� H[RJHQH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� EHVWDDW� HU� DOOHHQ� HQLJH� WRW� UHGHOLMNH� EHZLMVODVWYRRU�FRQIOLFWXHX]H�JH]LQVVLWXDWLHV��HHQ�ODJH�6(6�HQ�DUPRHGH��HHQ�VWHUN�JH�UEDQLVHHUGHOHHIRPJHYLQJ��VRFLDOH�LVRODWLH�HQ�JHEUHN�DDQ�VWHXQ��RRUORJ�HQ�DQGHUH�UDPSHQ��%LM�VRFLDOHLVRODWLH��JHEUHN�DDQ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ��HQ�JH�UEDQLVHHUGH�OHHIRPJHYLQJ�LV�GH�ULFKWLQJ�YDQ�KHWYHUEDQG�HFKWHU�RQGXLGHOLMN��'H]H�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�NXQQHQ�]RZHO�JHYROJ�DOV�RRU]DDN ]LMQYDQ�HHQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV�8LW WDEHO� ���� HQ� KHW� YRRUDIJDDQGH� NRPW� QDDU� YRUHQ� GDW� ]RZHO� JHQHWLVFKH� DOVRPJHYLQJVIDFWRUHQ� ELM� YULMZHO� DOOH� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HHQ� URO� VSHOHQ�� %LM� GHLQWHUSUHWDWLH� YDQ� JHJHYHQV� RYHU� GH� ELMGUDJH� YDQ� JHQHWLVFKH� YHUVXV� RPJHYLQJVIDFWRUHQ]LMQ HHQ� DDQWDO� ]DNHQ�YDQ� JURRW� EHODQJ� �5XWWHU��3ORPLQ�� ������� GLH� LQ� RQGHUVWDDQGHWHNVWER[�ZRUGHQ�WRHJHOLFKW��]LH�WHNVWER[����

Page 78: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

7HNVWER[����2YHU�GH�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�JHQHWLVFKH�YHUVXV�RPJHYLQJVIDFWRUHQ�DDQ�SV\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ

��� 6FKDWWLQJHQ�YDQ�GH�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�JHQHWLVFKH�HQ�QLHW�JHQHWLVFKH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�DDQ�GHSV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�]LMQ�SRSXODWLH��HQ�WLMGVSHFLILHN��%URZQ��������5RWKPDQ�*UHHQODQG���������(UIHOLMNKHLGVVFKDWWLQJHQ�JHYHQ�HQNHO�ZHHU�ELM�ZHON�GHHO�YDQ�GH�YDULDQWLHLQ�RQJH]RQGKHLG�LQ�HHQ�SRSXODWLH�JHQHWLVFKH�LQYORHGHQ�]LMQ�EHWURNNHQ��%LM�ZHLQLJJHQHWLVFKH�YDULDWLH�]DO�KHW�EHODQJ�YDQ�DQGHUH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�ZRUGHQ�µRYHUVFKDW¶��5RWKPDQ *UHHQODQG���������'LW�JHOGW�WURXZHQV�YRRU�DOOH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ���� *HQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�]LMQ��RRN�ELM�WUHNNHQ�GLH�HHQ�KRJH�HUIHOLMNKHLG�KHEEHQ�]RDOVQHXURWLFLVPH�HQ�LPSXOVLYLWHLW��GRRUJDDQV��PDDU�QLHW�DOWLMG��EHWUHNNHOLMN�LUUHOHYDQW�ZDQQHHUKHW�JDDW�RP�GH�YHUNODULQJ�YDQ�YHUVFKLOOHQ�LQ�SUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�WXVVHQSRSXODWLHV�HQ�YDQ�YHUVFKLOOHQ�LQ�GH�WLMG�ELQQHQ�ppQ�HQ�GH]HOIGH�SRSXODWLH��=XONHSRSXODWLHYHUVFKLOOHQ�ZRUGHQ�PHHVWDO�YHURRU]DDNW�GRRU�YHUVFKLOOHQ�LQ�RPJHYLQJVIDFWRUHQ�(HQ�JRHG�YRRUEHHOG�LV�GHSUHVVLH��ZDDUYDQ�JURWH�YHUVFKLOOHQ�WXVVHQ�SRSXODWLHV�]LMQDDQJHWRRQG��WHUZLMO�GHSUHVVLH�WRFK�GHHOV�GRRU�JHQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�ZRUGW�EHSDDOG��%URZQ�������%XUYLOO��������:HLVVPDQ�HW�DO����������2RN�OLMNW�GH�LQFLGHQWLH�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�LQ�GH:HVWHUVH�ODQGHQ�WRH�WH�QHPHQ��+DJQHOO��*UDVEHFN��������%HEELQJWRQ��5DPDQD����������� =HOIV�ELM�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�PHW�HHQ�UHODWLHI�KRJH�HUIHOLMNKHLG�NXQQHQ�QLHW�JHQHWLVFKHIDFWRUHQ�YDQ�JURRW�EHODQJ�]LMQ�LQ�KHW�RQWVWDDQ��'H�JHVFKDWWH�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�JHQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQLQ�RQGHU]RHN�RPYDW�QDPHOLMN�QDDVW�XQLHNH�JHQHWLVFKH�YDULDWLH�RRN�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�JHQ�RPJHYLQJ�LQWHUDFWLHV�HQ���FRUUHODWLHV��QDWXUH�YLD�QXUWXUH����� +HW�IHLW�GDW�GH�FRQFRUGDQWLH�YDQ�GH�PHHVW�µJHQHWLVFKH¶�VWRRUQLVVHQ�ELM�LGHQWLHNH�WZHHOLQJHQELM�ODQJH�QD�JHHQ������LV��LPSOLFHHUW�QLHW�]RQGHUPHHU�GDW�RPJHYLQJVIDFWRUHQ�HHQEHODQJULMNH�URO�VSHOHQ��+HW�LV�PRJHOLMN�GDW�GH�LPSHUIHFWH�FRQFRUGDQWLH�KHW�JHYROJ�LV�YDQPHHWIRXW�HQ�WRHYDOVSURFHVVHQ��'H�DDQZLM]LQJHQ�JURHLHQ�GDW�GH�RQWZLNNHOLQJ�YDQ�KHW�EUHLQGHHOV�RS�WRHYDOVSURFHVVHQ�EHUXVW�HQ�DOOHHQ�LQ�µJURWH�OLMQHQ¶�GRRU�KHW�JHQRRP�ZRUGW�JHVWXXUG�(GHOPDQ��7RQRQL��������0DJQXVVRQ���������2RN�PRHW�PHQ�EHGHQNHQ�GDW�QLHW�JHQHWLVFKHLQYORHGHQ��DOOH�LQYORHGHQ�EHKDOYH�GLH�YDQ�KHW�JHQRW\SH�RPYDWWHQ��2PJHYLQJ�RPYDW�GXV�RRNGH�EDDUPRHGHU�'H�URO�YDQ�JHQHWLVFKH�HQ�RPJHYLQJVIDFWRUHQ�LQ�GH�HWLRORJLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�NDQZHOOLFKW�KHW�EHVWH�DOV�YROJW�ZRUGHQ�XLWJHGUXNW��'H�SURSRUWLH�SHUVRQHQ�LQ�HHQ�EHSDDOGH�SRSXODWLHGDW�DDQ�HHQ�QLHW�SV\FKRWLVFKH�VWRRUQLV�OLMGW��LV�YRRUDO�DIKDQNHOLMN�LV�YDQ�VRFLDOH��FXOWXUHOH��HQHFRQRPLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ��WHUZLMO�HQGRJHQH��PHW�QDPH�JHQHWLVFKH�HQ�IDPLOLDLUH�IDFWRUHQ��DOVPHGHSHFK� YRRUDO�EHSDOHQ�ZLH�LQ�GLH�SRSXODWLH�GDW�GDQ�]XOOHQ�]LMQ��9RRU�GH�SV\FKRWLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQJHOGW�GLW�ZDDUVFKLMQOLMN�LQ�PLQGHUH�PDWH��'H�SUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�VFKHUS�JHGHILQLHHUGH�SV\FKRWLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ�YHUWRRQW�PLQGHU�JURWH�YHUVFKLOOHQ�WXVVHQ�SRSXODWLHV�HQ�LQ�GH�WLMG��ZDW�VXJJHUHHUW�GDWVRFLDOH��FXOWXUHOH�HQ�HFRQRPLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ�YHUPRHGHOLMN�PLQGHU�EHODQJULMN�]LMQ�

+HW�EHODQJ�YDQ�HHQ�GHWHUPLQDQW�YRRU�GH�SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG�YDQ�GH� �1HGHUODQGVH�EHYRONLQJ�KDQJW�EHKDOYH�YDQ�GH�VWHUNWH�YDQ�KHW�YHUEDQG� �KRRJWH�YDQ�55���RRN�QRJ�DIYDQ� GH SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� GLH� GHWHUPLQDQW� LQ� GH� SRSXODWLH� HQ� WHQVORWWH� YDQ� KHW� DDQWDOVWRRUQLVVHQ� ZDDUELM� GLH� GHWHUPLQDQW� HHQ� URO� VSHHOW�� =RJHQDDPGH� JHQHULHNHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� EHwQYORHGHQ� PHHUGHUH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� ]LMQ� GHUKDOYH� JHUHODWHHUG� DDQFRPRUELGLWHLW� HQ� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�� 2S� EDVLV� YDQ� KRRIGVWXN� �� JOREDDOZHHUJHJHYHQ� LQ� WDEHO� ����� OLMNHQ� GH� YROJHQGH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� JHQHULHNH� DVSHFWHQ� WH

Page 79: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

EH]LWWHQ�� QHXURWLFLVPH�� LPSXOVLYLWHLW�� HQ� FRJQLWLHYH� HQ� VRFLDDO�FRPPXQLFDWLHYHEHSHUNLQJHQ� �LQFOXVLHI� GH� KLHUYRRU� PHGHYHUDQWZRRUGHOLMNH� JHQHQ��� WUDXPDWLVFKHHUYDULQJHQ� LQ�GH� MHXJG��HHQ� ODJH�6(6��PHW�]LMQ�JURWHUH�NDQV�RS� ILQDQFLsOH�SUREOHPHQ�JH]LQVFRQIOLFWHQ�� EORRWVWHOOLQJ� DDQ� SDWKRJHQH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� HQ� GUXJV��� VWHUNHYHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ�HQ�VQHOOH�VRFLDOH�YHUDQGHULQJHQ��GRRU�RQGHUPHHU�PLJUDWLH���+XQ�LQYORHGLV LQ�HON�JHYDO�QLHW�WRW�ppQ�VWRRUQLV�EHSHUNW��%RYHQGLHQ�EHwQYORHGHQ�]LM�GH�HUQVW�JHPHWHQYROJHQV�GLPHQVLRQHOH�PDWHQ�]RDOV�GH�*+4�2S�EDVLV�YDQ�GH�RYHUHHQNRPVWHQ�LQ�KXQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ��µGHWHUPLQDQWHQSURILHO¶�ZRUGHQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�RRN�ZHO�JHNDUDNWHULVHHUG�DDQ�GH�KDQG�YDQ�HHQ� WZHHWDO�GHHOV�RYHUODSSHQGH��LQGHOLQJHQ���� ,QWHUQDOLVHUHQGH� YHUVXV� H[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� �UHVSHFWLHYHOLMN� GHSUHVVLH�DQJVW��� HQ� VRPDWRIRUPH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� YHUVXV� $'+'�� DQWLVRFLDDO� JHGUDJ� HQYHUVODYLQJHQ����� 3V\FKRVHQ�YHUVXV�DQJVW��HQ�VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�YHUVXV�YHUVODYLQJHQ�'H� LQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH� HQ� H[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� KHEEHQ� HON�� WRW� RS� ]HNHUHKRRJWH�� KXQ� HLJHQ� SURILHO� YDQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� 9URXZ� ]LMQ�� VWHUNH� JHUHPGKHLG�� KRRJQHXURWLFLVPH�� RYHUJHYRHOLJKHLG� YRRU� DINHXULQJ� HQ� NULWLHN�� HHQ� YHUPLMGHQGH� �HPRWLH�JHULFKWH�� FRSLQJVWLMO�� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� GLH� JHSDDUG� JDDQ� PHW� YHUOLHV� HQ� VRFLDOHRQWZRUWHOLQJ�� HQ� G\VIXQFWLHV� LQ� GH� +3$�DV� YHUKRJHQ� YRRUDO� KHW� ULVLFR� RSLQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� ([WHUQDOLVHUHQGH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� OLMNHQ� PHHU� JHUHODWHHUG� DDQKHW� PDQQHOLMN� JHVODFKW�� H[WUHPH� RQJHUHPGKHLG�� µVHQVDWLH]XFKW¶�� HHQ� UHODWLHI� ODJHUHVSRQVLYLWHLW� YDQ�KHW� DXWRQRPH� ]HQXZVWHOVHO� HQ� HHQ� JHGHSULYHHUGH� �HQ�GDDUPHH�YDDNULVNDQWHUH��VRFLDOH�RPJHYLQJ��+RHZHO�VRPPLJH�ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ�YRRU�HHQ�LQWHUQDOLVHUHQGHVWRRUQLV� HQLJH� EHVFKHUPLQJ� ELHGHQ� WHJHQ� HHQ� H[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH� VWRRUQLV� �GHQN� DDQJHUHPGKHLG��� PRHW� KHW� SDWKRJHQH� HIIHFW� YDQ� ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ� XLW� EHLGH� GRPHLQHQ� �ELMY�QHXURWLFLVPH�HQ�LPSXOVLYLWHLW��QLHW�ZRUGHQ�RQGHUVFKDW��3HUVLVWHUHQGH�FRPRUELGLWHLW�YDQLQWHUQDWLOLVHUHQGH�HQ�H[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�NDQ�YHUPRHGHOLMN�GHHOV�DDQ�GHUJHOLMNHFRPELQDWLHV�YDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�ZRUGHQ�WRHJHVFKUHYHQ�'H� WZHHGH� LQGHOLQJ� OHJW� KHW� DFFHQW� VWHUN� RS� GH� ELMGUDJH� HQ� DDUG� YDQ� GH�QLHW�JHQHWLVFKH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� 'H� SV\FKRWLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� �HQ� DXWLVPH�� HQ� ZHOOLFKW� RRN$'+'��ZRUGHQ� WRFK�YRRUDO� JH]LHQ�DOV�QHXURELRORJLVFKH�RQWZLNNHOLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ� WHQJHYROJH� YDQ� HHQ� EHSDDOGH� JHQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ�� RQJXQVWLJH� RPVWDQGLJKHGHQ� HQJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� WHQ� WLMGH� YDQ� GH� RQWZLNNHOLQJ� YDQ� GH� KHUVHQHQ� HQNZHWVEDDUKHLGVYHUKRJHQGH� HUYDULQJHQ�� ,Q� GH� DQGHUH� WZHH� JURHSHQ� VSHOHQ� JHQHWLVFKHIDFWRUHQ� PLQGHU� HHQ� URO� HQ� VWUHVVHUHQGH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� MXLVW� PHHU�� +HW� EHODQJULMNVWHRQGHUVFKHLG� WXVVHQ� GH� HPRWLRQHOH� HQ� VRPDWRIRUPH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQHU]LMGV� HQ� GHYHUVODYLQJHQ� DQGHU]LMGV� OLJW� LQ� GH� DDUG� YDQ� GH� RPJHYLQJVGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� 7HUZLMO� GHHHUVWH� FDWHJRULH� YRRUDO� YHURRU]DDNW� ZRUGHQ� GRRU� VWUHVV� LQGXFHUHQGH� VLWXDWLHV� HQJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� HQ� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVIDFWRUHQ� �LQFOXVLHI� EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJV�� HQFRSLQJVWLMOHQ��� ]LMQ� YHUVODYLQJHQ� yyN� QRJ� VWHUN� JHUHODWHHUG� DDQ� H[RJHQH� VRFLDOH� HQFXOWXUHOH�IDFWRUHQ�

Page 80: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

���� 1RJPDDOV�KHW�G\QDPLVFKH�VWUHVV�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO'H� YRRUDIJDDQGH� SDUDJUDDI� JLQJ� LQ� RS� RQ]H� KXLGLJH� NHQQLV� RYHU� ZHONH� QX� GH�EHODQJULMNVWH��GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�]LMQ��0DDU�LQ�ZHONH�PDWH�LVHU� VSUDNH� YDQ� LQWHUDFWLHV�� YDQ� IDFWRUHQ� GLH� KHW� HIIHFW� YDQ� DQGHUH� IDFWRUHQ� YHUVWHUNHQ":DW� ZHWHQ� ZH� QX� RYHU� GH� UHODWLHV� WXVVHQ� GH� GULH� KRRIGJURHSHQ� XLW� KHW� G\QDPLVFKHVWUHVV�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO��KRH�]LHQ�GH�FDXVDOH�NHWHQV�YDQDI�HHQ�LQGLYLGXHOH�H[RJHQHRI�HQGRJHQH�ULVLFRIDFWRU�WRW�KHW�RQVWDDQ�YDQ�HHQ�EHSDDOGH�VWRRUQLV�HU�XLW"'LYHUVH�FDXVDOH�NHWHQV�]LMQ�GHQNEDDU��ZDDUELM�JHQHWLVFKH� IDFWRUHQ� �ZDQQHHU�]LMHHQ�URO�YDQ�EHWHNHQLV�VSHOHQ��LQ�HON�JHYDO�DOWLMG�DDQ�KHW�EHJLQ�VWDDQ��'H�QLHW�JHQHWLVFKHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� ]RXGHQ� KHW� JHQHWLVFK� EHSDDOGH� ULVLFR� NXQQHQ� PHGLsUHQ� �QDWXUH� YLDQXUWXUH�� �3ORPLQ��0F&OHDUQ���������PRGLILFHUHQ� �LQWHUDFWLH�� �5XWWHU� HW� DO��� �������RIRQDIKDQNHOLMN� HUYDQ� RSHUHUHQ� �2WWPDQ�� ������� *HQHWLVFKH� EHODVWLQJ� ]RX� ELM� GLW� DOOHVYHUDQWZRRUGHOLMN� NXQQHQ� ]LMQ� YRRU� HHQ� EHODQJULMN� GHHO� YDQ� GH� RQGHUOLQJH� YHUEDQGHQWXVVHQ� GH� QLHW�JHQHWLVFKH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� �WXVVHQ� RQGHUPHHU� QHXURWLFLVPH� HQLQWHUSHUVRRQOLMNH� VWUHVV�� HQ� KXQ� DVVRFLDWLHV� PHW� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG�� (HQYRRUEHHOG� YDQ� ]R¶Q� FDXVDOH� NHWHQ� LV� KHW� YROJHQGH�� +HW� LV� EHNHQG� GDW� ]RZHOSV\FKRSDWKRORJLH� ELM� RXGHUV� DOV� YRRUWGXUHQGH� JH]LQVFRQIOLFWHQ� JHDVVRFLHHUG� ]LMQ� PHWSV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�ELM�DGROHVFHQWHQ� �5XWWHU� HW� DO��� �������������6WRRUQLVVHQ�ELM�GHRXGHUV�]LMQ� HFKWHU�RRN�HHQ� ULVLFRIDFWRU�YRRU� JH]LQVFRQIOLFWHQ��+HW� LV�PRJHOLMN�GDW� DOOHYHUEDQGHQ�WXVVHQ�SV\FKRSDWKRORJLH�ELM�GH�RXGHU��GLH�ELM�KHW�NLQG��HQ�GH�JH]LQVFRQIOLFWHQKHW�JHYROJ�]LMQ�YDQ�GH]HOIGH�JHQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ��0DDU�HU�]LMQ�RRN�DQGHUH�YHUNODULQJHQPRJHOLMN�YDQ�GH�JHYRQGHQ�YHUEDQGHQ��=R�]RX�SV\FKRSDWKRORJLH�ELM�GH�RXGHU�KHW�ULVLFRYDQ� JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ� ELM� GH� DGROHVFHQW� DOOHHQ� NXQQHQ� YHUJURWHQ� DOV� KHW� OHLGW� WRWHUQVWLJH�JH]LQVFRQIOLFWHQ�(HQ� DQGHU� YRRUEHHOG� EHWUHIW� GHSUHVVLH�� (HQ� GHHO� YDQ� KHW� HIIHFW� YDQ� JHQHWLVFKHIDFWRUHQ� RS� GHSUHVVLH� YHUORRSW� YLD� HHQ� JHUHPG� WHPSHUDPHQW� HQ� µLQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH¶SHUVRRQOLMNKHLG��GLH�RS�KXQ�EHXUW�KHW� ULVLFR�RS�GHSUHVVRJHQH�HUYDULQJHQ�YHUKRJHQ��'HHIIHFWHQ� YDQ� GH]H� HUYDULQJHQ� ZRUGHQ� ZHHU� YHUVWHUNW� GRRU� HHQ� LQWHUQDOLVHUHQGHSHUVRRQOLMNKHLG� �2UPHO�� ������ 2UPHO� � 'H� -RQJ�� ������� 2RN� GH� DVVRFLDWLH� YDQFRQIOLFWXHX]H� JH]LQVVLWXDWLH� �FRQIOLFWHQ�� PLVKDQGHOLQJ�� DIIHFWLHYH� YHUZDDUOR]LQJ�� PHWODWHUH� GHSUHVVLH� YHUORRSW� ZHOOLFKW� YLD� EOLMYHQGH� YHUDQGHULQJHQ� LQ� GH� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGHQ�RI� GH� QHXURELRORJLH� �+3$�DV��� GLH� RS� KXQ� EHXUW� ZHHU� GH� RPJHYLQJVFRQWUROH�EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJ� HQ� FRSLQJ� EHwQYORHGHQ�� $O� HHUGHU� LV� RSJHPHUNW� GDW� HHQ� JHULQJHUHRPJHYLQJVFRQWUROH� JHSDDUG� JDDW� PHW� HHQ� KRJHU� LQFLGHQWLH� YDQ� VWUHVVYROOHJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�HQ�RPVWDQGLJKHGHQ�9HHO� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� PDNHQ� ZDDUVFKLMQOLMN� GHHO� XLW� YDQ� FDXVDOH� NHWHQV� PHWJHQHWLVFKH�EHODVWLQJ��HHQ�RQJXQVWLJ�WHPSHUDPHQW�HQ�WUDXPDWLVFKH��MHXJG�HUYDULQJHQ�DOVHHUVWH� VFKDNHOV�� 'DDUQD� YROJHQ� GH� µULVNDQWH¶� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVWUHNNHQ�� OHLGHQG� WRWEUHXNHQ� LQ� RSOHLGLQJ� HQ� UHODWLHYRUPLQJ�� FKURQLVFKH� LQWHUSHUVRRQOLMNH� HQZHUNJHUHODWHHUGH� PRHLOLMNKHGHQ� HQ� HHQ� ODJH� 6(6�� 7HQVORWWH� ]LMQ� GH� PHHU� DFXWHVWUHVVYROOH�OHYHQVJHEHXU�WHQLVVHQ�GH�GHILQLWLHYH�GXZ�LQ�ULFKWLQJ�YDQ�KHW�RQVWDDQ�YDQ�GHVWRRUQLV��6RFLDOH� IDFWRUHQ�YRUPHQ� HHQ� ULVLFR�� RI� ELHGHQ�EHVFKHUPLQJ�� YRRUDO� GRRU� KXQLQYORHG�RS� LHPDQGV�SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH�NZHWVEDDUKHLG�RI�YHHUNUDFKW�HQ�RS�]LMQ�RI�KDDUKDQGHOLQJVUXLPWH�� +HODDV� VWDDW� KHW� RQGHU]RHN� QDDU� FDXVDOH� NHWHQV� QRJ� LQ� ]LMQNLQGHUVFKRHQHQ��HQ�EHWUHIW�KHW�YRRUDO�GHSUHVVLH�HQ�DQWLVRFLDDO�JHGUDJ�

Page 81: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

���� %HWHNHQLV�YDQ�GH�EHYLQGLQJHQ�YRRU�KHW�**=�EHOHLG������ +HW�RQGHU]RHNVEHOHLG1DDVW� PHHU� VROLGH� HQ� JHNZDQWLILFHHUGH� LQIRUPDWLH� RYHU� GH� ELMGUDJH� YDQ� LQGLYLGXHOHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�DDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG��LV�HU�JURWH�EHKRHIWH�DDQ�PHHU�NHQQLV�RYHUKXQ RQGHUOLQJH�UHODWLHV�LQ�GH�HWLRORJLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��'H�UHODWLHV�WXVVHQ�GHGULH� KRRIGJURHSHQ� XLW� KHW� G\QDPLVFKH� VWUHVV�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO� ]LMQ� QRJ� YHUUH� YDQGXLGHOLMN� �]LH� ILJXXU ����� +RH� NRPW� KHW� JHQHWLVFKH� ULVLFR� WRW� H[SUHVVLH� HQ� KRHEHwQYORHGHQ�H[RJHQH�ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ�]RDOV�6(6��YHUVWHGHOLMNLQJ�HQ�PLJUDWLH�KHW�ULVLFR�RSSV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG"�(Q�ZHONH�HUYDULQJHQ�ELQQHQ�� HQ�EXLWHQVKXLV� VSHOHQ�GDDUELMHHQ�URO"��2UPHO��'H�-RQJ��������9DQ�2V�HW�DO���������2RN�LV�PHHU�NHQQLV�QRGLJ�RYHU�KHW�PHFKDQLVPH�ZDDUPHH�HQGRJHQH�HQ�H[RJHQHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YLD� KDQGHOLQJVUXLPWH� HQ� RPJHYLQJVFRQWUROH� GH� EORRWVWHOOLQJ� DDQULVLFRYROOH� VLWXDWLHV� EHwQYORHGHQ� HQ� YLD� EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJ� HQ� FRSLQJ�KHW� JHGUDJ��9DQJURRW� EHODQJ� LV� RRN� LQ]LFKW� LQ� ZHONH� HUYDULQJHQ� GH� NZHWVEDDUKHLG� HQEHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJV�� HQ� FRSLQJVWLMOHQ� EOLMYHQG� NXQQHQ� YHUDQGHUHQ�� KRH� ]LM� GDW� NODDUVSHOHQ��HQ�PHW�ZHONH�YHUDQGHULQJHQ�LQ�KHW�SODVWLVFKH�EUHLQ�GDW�JHSDDUG�JDDW��(GHOPDQ�7RQRQL��������0DJQXVVRQ��������2UPHO��5LMVGLMN��������2UPHO��'H�-RQJ��������(HQ� EHODQJULMNH� DQGHUH� YUDDJ� LV� LQ� KRHYHUUH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� FOXVWHUHQ� RPGDW� ]LMHONDDUV� YyyUNRPHQ� EHwQYORHGHQ�� yIZHO� RPGDW� ]LM� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� JHPHHQ� KHEEHQ�%HDQWZRRUGLQJ� YDQ� GH]H� YUDDJ� LV� QLHW� DOOHHQ� YDQ� WKHRUHWLVFK� EHODQJ�� ,QGHOLQJ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG� DDQ� GH� KDQG� YDQ� JHQHULHNH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� ]RX� RUGH� NXQQHQVFKHSSHQ� LQ� GH� ZLOGJURHL� DDQ� SV\FKLDWULVFKH� GLDJQRVHQ� HQ� KHW� �� ZHOOLFKW� JURWHQGHHOVNXQVWPDWLJH� �� SUREOHHP� YDQ� GH� FRPRUELGLWHLW� NXQQHQ� YHUOLFKWHQ� �*LHO�� ������� 0HHULQ]LFKW� LQ� KHW� EHVWDDQ�YDQ�JHQHULHNH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� ]RX� WHYHQV�EHODQJULMNH� LPSOLFDWLHVKHEEHQ�YRRU�KHW�SUHYHQWLHEHOHLG��(IIHFWLHYH�SUHYHQWLH� OLMNW�JHEDDW�ELM�HHQ�RULsQWDWLH�RSJHQHULHNH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� DDQJH]LHQ� KLHUPHH� HHQ� GLYHUVLWHLW� DDQ� VWRRUQLVVHQ� DOVPHGHHUQVW�HQ�FKURQLFLWHLW�ZRUGHQ�EHwQYORHG�9DQ�JURRW�EHODQJ�YRRU�GH�WRHNRPVW�LV�KHW�JHEUXLN�YDQ�RQGHU]RHNVPHWKRGHQ�GLHRQGHUVFKHLG�NXQQHQ�PDNHQ�WXVVHQ�RPJHYLQJVHIIHFWHQ�RS�PHQVHQ��HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�PHQVHQRS� KXQ� RPJHYLQJ�� HQ� JHQHWLVFKH� HIIHFWHQ� RS� SV\FKRSDWKRORJLH�� HQ� GLH� FDXVDOH� NHWHQVNXQQHQ� LGHQWLILFHUHQ�� /RQJLWXGLQDDO� RQGHU]RHN� LV� LQ� VWDDW� HHQ� GHUJHOLMNHRQWZLNNHOLQJVSHUVSHFWLHI� WH� UHDOLVHUHQ� �(LVHQEHUJ�� ������ 2UPHO�� ������ 5XWWHU� HW� DO�������� ������� (HQ� JRHG� YRRUEHHOG� LV� GH� 'XQHGLQ� VWXGLH� ZDDULQ� HHQ� JHERRUWHFRKRUW�Q ������� PHW� WZHHMDDUOLMNVH� PHWLQJHQ� LQPLGGHOV� RQJHYHHU� ��� MDDU� LV� JHYROJG�� 'H'XQHGLQ�VWXGLH�KHHIW�KHW� LQ]LFKW� LQ�URXWHV�HQ�NHWHQ��YRRUDO� WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQ�DQWLVRFLDDOJHGUDJ�� DDQ]LHQOLMN� YHUJURRW� �0RIILW� HW� DO��� ������� ,Q� KHW� DOJHPHHQ� JURHLHQ� GHDDQZLM]LQJHQ�GDW�VRPPLJH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ��JHQHWLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ��MHXJGWUDXPD��FKURQLVFKHFRQIOLFWHQ� LQ�RXGHUOLMN�JH]LQ��JHYROJHQ�NXQQHQ�KHEEHQ� �ODJH� HLJHQZDDUGH�� DIJHEURNHQRSOHLGLQJ��RQJHKXZG�PRHGHUVFKDS���GLH�RS�KXQ�EHXUW�ZHHU�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�ZRUGHQ��'H]HKHEEHQ�GDQ�HHQ�HLJHQ�ELMGUDJH�DDQ�KHW�ULVLFR��RQDIKDQNHOLMN�YDQ�GH�HHUVWH�GHWHUPLQDQW�+HW]HOIGH� JHOGW� YRRU� GH� JHYROJHQ� YDQ� HHQ� HHUGHUH� VWRRUQLV�� GLH� RRN� ZHHUULVLFRYHUKRJHQG�NXQQHQ�ZHUNHQ�YRRU�KHW�RSWUHGHQ�YDQ�HHQ�QLHXZH�VWRRUQLV�$O� PHW� DO� PHQHQ� ZLM� GDW� YDQXLW� KHW� JH]LFKWVSXQW� YDQ� GH� JHHVWHOLMNHYRONVJH]RQGKHLG�GH�YROJHQGH�YLHU�W\SHQ�RQGHU]RHN�KRJH�SULRULWHLW�KHEEHQ�

Page 82: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

�� /RQJLWXGLQDOH� VWXGLHV� YDQ� KRPRJHQH� SRSXODWLHV�� ]RDOV� HHQ� JHERRUWHFRKRUW�� FRKRUWYDQ����MDULJHQ�RI�YDQ�SDWLsQWHQ�PHW�HHQ�HHUVWH�HSLVRGH�YDQ�HHQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV�'H]H�SRSXODWLHV�GLHQHQ�JHGXUHQGH�ODQJH�WLMG�WH�ZRUGHQ�JHYROJG��ZDDULQ�DDQGDFKW�LVYRRU�PHHUGHUH�H[RJHQH�HQ�HQGRJHQH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HQ�PHHUGHUH�XLWNRPVWPDWHQ��GLHKHUKDDOGHOLMN�ZRUGHQ� JHPHWHQ��2RN�GLHQW� HU� DDQGDFKW� WH� ]LMQ� YRRU� FDXVDOH� NHWHQV�=RGUD� XLW� KHW� JHQHWLVFK�HSLGHPLRORJLVFK� HQ� PROHFXODLU�JHQHWLVFK� RQGHU]RHNNDQGLGDDWJHQHQ� YRRU� ppQ� RI�PHHUGHUH� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ]LMQ� JHwGHQWLILFHHUG�OHQHQ�GHUJHOLMNH�VWXGLHV�]LFK�RRN�XLWVWHNHQG�YRRU�KHW�EHVWXGHUHQ�YDQ�JHQ�RPJHYLQJLQWHUDFWLHV� HQ� FRUUHODWLHV�� =RODQJ� GLW� QRJ� RQYROGRHQGH� KHW� JHYDO� LV�� YHUGLHQW� KHWDDQEHYHOLQJ�RQGHU]RHNVSRSXODWLHV�WH�NLH]HQ�PHW�YROGRHQGH�YHUVFKLOOHQ�LQ�JHQHWLVFKHYHUZDQWVFKDS�� 'LW NDQ� WDPHOLMN� HHQYRXGLJ� ZRUGHQ� JHUHDOLVHHUG� GRRU� GHRQGHU]RHNVJURHS� XLW� WH� EUHLGHQ� PHW� HHUVWH� HQ� WZHHGHJUDDGVYHUZDQWHQ�� 'HILQDQFLHULQJVPRJHOLMNKHGHQ�YRRU� ORQJLWXGLQDDO� RQGHU]RHN�GLHQHQ� VWHUN� YHUJURRW� WHZRUGHQ�� 6DPHQZHUNLQJ� WXVVHQ� NLQGHU��� MHXJG�� HQ� YROZDVVHQHQSV\FKLDWULH�RQWZLNNHOLQJV��HQ�NOLQLVFKH�SV\FKRORJLH�LV�RQRQWEHHUOLMN�LQ�GHUJHOLMNH�VWXGLHV��� *HFRQWUROHHUGH� LQWHUYHQWLH� VWXGLHV� YDQ� YURHJWLMGLJH� HQ� SUR�DFWLHYHEHKDQGHOLQJVVWUDWHJLHsQ� LQ� HHUVWH�� � WZHHGH�� HQ� GHUGHOLMQ� PHW� HHQ� UDQJH� YDQXLWNRPVWPDWHQ� HQ� YURHJH� HQ� ODWH� IROORZ�XSV�� (VVHQWLHHO� LV� GDW� RRN� GH� HIIHFWHQ� RSNZHWVEDDUKHLG�YHHUNUDFKW��GHWHUPLQDQWHQ���HQ�UHFLGLHI�ULVLFR�ZRUGHQ�JHPHWHQ� ��� 6WXGLHV� GLH� RQWUDIHOHQ� ZDDURP� EHSDDOGH� SHUVRRQOLMNKHLGVWUHNNHQ� KHW� ULVLFR� RSVWRRUQLVVHQ� YHUKRJHQ�� +RH� YHUKRRJW� ELMYRRUEHHOG� QHXURWLFLVPH� HQ� VRFLDOHRQKDQGLJKHLG� KHW� ULVLFR� RS� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG"�:HONH� EHWHNHQLVYHUOHQLQJV�HQ� FRSLQJVWLMOHQ�� QHXUR�HQGRFULQRORJLVFKH� UHVSRQVLHSDWURQHQ�� HQ� QHXURSV\FKROR�JLVFKH�SURFHVVHQ�]LMQ�KLHUELM�EHWURNNHQ"�� µ&RUUHVSRQGHQWLH¶� VWXGLHV� ZDDULQ� GH� UHODWLHV� WXVVHQ� SV\FKRORJLVFKH� HQQHXURELRORJLVFKH�YDULDEHOHQ�HQ�IXQFWLHV�ZRUGHQ�EHVWXGHHUG��'H]H�NXQQHQ�DQWZRRUGJHYHQ� RS� GH� YUDDJ� ZDW� GH� QHXURELRORJLVFKH� DFKWHUJURQGHQ� YDQ� V\PSWRPHQ� DOVGHSUHVVLHYH�VWHPPLQJ�HQ�SDQLVFKH�DQJVW�]LMQ��RI�YDQ�WHPSHUDPHQWHQ�DOV�JHUHPGKHLGHQ�LPSXOVLYLWHLW��0HHU�LQ]LFKW�LQ�GH]H�PDWHULH�NDQ�HHQ�EHODQJULMNH�ELMGUDJH�OHYHUHQDDQ�GH�YHUEHWHULQJ�YDQ�GH�GLDJQRVWLHN�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�

����� 0RJHOLMNKHGHQ�YRRU�SUHYHQWLH9HHO�YDQ�GH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�XLW�SDUDJUDDI�����HQ�WDEHO ����]LMQ�PRHLOLMN�WH�EHwQYORHGHQ�'LW KHHIW� WH� PDNHQ� PHW� GH� EHSHUNWH� PDDNEDDUKHLG� YDQ� GH� PDDWVFKDSSLM� HQ� KHWLQGLYLGXHOH� OHYHQ� �GHQN� DDQ� DUPRHGH�� ODJH� 6(6�� XUEDQLVDWLHJUDDG�� FRPSOLFDWLHV� ELM� GHJHERRUWH��� PHW� HWKLVFKH� RQWRHODDWEDDUKHLG� �ELMY�� JHGZRQJHQ� VWHULOLVDWLH� YDQ� HUIHOLMN]ZDDU� EHODVWH� SHUVRQHQ�� HQ�PHW� GH� EHSHUNLQJ� YDQ� KHW� UHFKW� YDQ� KHW� OHYHQ� QDDU� HLJHQNHX]H�LQ�WH�ULFKWHQ�GLH�RQYHUPLMGHOLMN�PHW�EHwQYORHGLQJ�YDQ�EHODQJULMNH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQJHSDDUG�JDDW��]RDOV�ELM�LQJULMSHQ�LQ�LQDGHTXDWH�RSYRHGLQJVSDWURQHQ�HQ�ELM�GURRJOHJJLQJ��2UPHO��������7HQ�GHOH�YRUPHQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��PDDU�GLW�JDDW�RRN�RS�YRRU�VRPDWLVFKHDDQGRHQLQJHQ��GH�UHNHQLQJ�GLH�GH�PDDWVFKDSSLM�JHSUHVHQWHHUG�NULMJW�YRRU�GH�GRRU�KDDUJHNR]HQ� LQULFKWLQJ�� HQ� KDDU� EXUJHUV� YRRU� GH� GRRU� KXQ� YHUNR]HQ� OHHIZLM]H�� 'HHFRQRPLVFKH� RUGH�PHW� RS�ZLQVW�PD[LPDOLVDWLH� JHEDVHHUGH� RQGHUQHPLQJHQ� KHHIW� QDDVWWDO� YDQ� YRRUGHOHQ�� RRN� QDGHOHQ�� ]RDOV� ZHUNORRVKHLG�� PHQWDOH� RYHUEHODVWLQJ�� HQ� JURWHLQNRPHQVYHUVFKLOOHQ��0DDU�GDDURP�ZLO�PHQ�QRJ�QLHW�HHQ�DQGHU�HFRQRPLVFK�V\VWHHP��'HKLHUPHH� VDPHQKDQJHQGH� � WRHJHQRPHQ�PRELOLWHLW�� XUEDQLVDWLH�� HQ� SHUVRRQOLMN� XWRSLVPH

Page 83: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

KHEEHQ�YHUPRHGHOLMN�JHOHLG�WRW�KHW�ORVVHU�ZRUGHQ�YDQ�VRFLDOH�YHUEDQGHQ�HQ�WRHQDPH�YDQVFKHLGLQJHQ�8LWJDDQGH�YDQ�GH�KXLGLJH�NHQQLV�YDQ�GH�HWLRORJLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQERYHQVWDDQGH� FRQVWDWHULQJHQ� RPWUHQW� GH� EHwQYORHGEDDUKHLG� YDQ� HHQ� DDQWDOGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YHUGLHQHQ� RQV� LQ]LHQV� GH� YROJHQGH� YLHU� µSUHYHQWLHYH¶� VWUDWHJLHsQ� GHYRRUNHXU��RRN�YDQZHJH�KXQ�YHUPRHGHOLMN�UHODWLHI�JXQVWLJH�NRVWHQ�EDWHQ�UDWLR���� (HQ� IRFXV� RS� PRPHQWHHO� EHNHQGH� JHQHULHNH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� +LHUELM� GHQNHQ� ZLMYRRUDO� DDQ� KHW� FRPSHQVHUHQ� YDQ� WHNRUWHQ� LQ� FRJQLWLHYH� HQ� FRPPXQLFDWLHYHYDDUGLJKHGHQ�HQ�KHW�OHUHQ�RPJDDQ�PHW�VWUHVVYROOH�VLWXDWLHV��3UHYHQWLH�DFWLYLWHLWHQ�DOVGH]H�]XOOHQ�HIIHFW�KHEEHQ�RS�PHHUGHUH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�SV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG� LQKHW� DOJHPHHQ�� 2RN� EHWUHIW� KHW� UHODWLHI� JHPDNNHOLMN� WH� EHwQYORHGHQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�'H]H�YDDUGLJKHGHQ�]LMQ�PLQVWHQV�]R�EHODQJULMN�YRRU�KHW�ODWHUH�ZHO]LMQ�DOV�OH]HQ�HQVFKULMYHQ���� $DQGDFKW�YRRU�SUHYHQWLH�ELM�KRRJ�ULVLFR�NLQGHUHQ��%HGRHOG�ZRUGHQ�NLQGHUHQ�GLH�DDQHHQ� YHHOKHLG� YDQ� ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ� EORRWVWDDQ�� ]RDOV� RXGHUV� PHW� HHQ� SV\FKLDWULVFKHFDUULqUH�� LQDGHTXDWH� RXGHUOLMNH� ]RUJ� LQ� FRPELQDWLH� PHW� HHQ� JHGHSULYHHUGHOHHIRPJHYLQJ�� 'H]H� NLQGHUHQ� ORSHQ� HHQ� UHODWLHI� JURRW� ULVLFR� RS� HUQVWLJH� HQFKURQLVFKH� LQWHUQDOLVHUHQGH� pQ� H[WHUQDOLVHUHQGH� SUREOHPHQ� LQ� GH� DGROHVFHQWLH� HQYROZDVVHQKHLG�� (IIHFWLHYH� SUHYHQWLH� RS� GLW� WHUUHLQ� ]RX� YRRU� HHQ� DDQ]LHQOLMNHEHVSDULQJ�NXQQHQ�]RUJHQ�LQ�GH�VRFLDOH�NRVWHQ��,Q�KHW�DOJHPHHQ�]RX�HU�WURXZHQV�PHHUDDQGDFKW� YRRU� SUHYHQWLH� ELM� NLQGHUHQ� HQ� DGROHVFHQWHQ� PRHWHQ� ]LMQ� GDQ� WKDQV� KHWJHYDO�LV��� $DQGDFKW�YRRU�YURHJWLMGLJH�HQ�DGHTXDWH�EHKDQGHOLQJ�ELM�NLQGHUHQ�HQ�DGROHVFHQWHQ�PDDU�RRN�ELM�YROZDVVHQHQ��+LHUPHH�NDQ�HHQ�KDOW�ZRUGHQ�WRHJHURHSHQ�DDQ�GH�F\FOXVZDDULQ�JHYROJHQ�YDQ�HHQ�µHHUGHUH�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV¶�GH�RRU]DNHQ��GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�ZRUGHQ�YDQ�QLHXZH�SUREOHPHQ��*RHGH�YRRUEHHOGHQ� ]LMQ� VFKRROIRELH� HQ� GHSUHVVLH�7ZHH� SUREOHPHQ� ZDDUYRRU� ERYHQGLHQ� ZHORPVFKUHYHQ� HQ� UHGHOLMN� VXFFHVYROOHLQWHUYHQWLHV� YRRUKDQGHQ� ]LMQ� �]LH� RRN� GHHO� %�� YDQ� GLW� UDSSRUW��� 9URHJWLMGLJHKHUNHQQLQJ�HQ� DGHNZDWH�EHKDQGHOLQJ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� LQ� GH� VRPDWLVFKHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ� NDQ� VFKDGH� GRRU� YHHOYXOGLJ� VSHFLDOLVWLVFK� RQGHU]RHN� ELMVRPDWLVHUHQGH� SDWLsQWHQ� YRRUNyPHQ�� 'H]H� SDWLsQWHQ� ZRUGHQ� YRRUDO� JHYRQGHQZRUGHQ�LQ�GH�ODJHUH�6(6�JURHSHQ�HQ�ELM�HWQLVFKH�PLQGHUKHGHQ���� +HW� YHUGLHQW� YHUGHU� DDQEHYHOLQJ�� PHW� QDPH� ZDDU� KHW� JDDW� RP� GH� SUHYHQWLH� YDQJHGUDJVVWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� VXwFLGH�� HHQ� EHOHLG� WH� RYHUZHJHQ� YDQ� OLPLWHULQJ� YDQ� GHEHVFKLNEDDUKHLG� YDQ� JHQRWPLGGHOHQ�� (HQ� HHQYRXGLJH� PRJHOLMNKHLG� KLHUWRH� LVELMYRRUEHHOG�GH�DFFLMQVYHUKRJLQJ�RS�DOFRKRO��.HQGHOO��������.UHLWPDQ��������PDDURRN� GH� YHHO� ODVWLJHU� PRJHOLMNKHLG� YDQ� EHwQYORHGLQJ� YDQ� QRUPHQ� HQ� ZDDUGHQ� WHQDDQ]LHQ�YDQ�KHW�JHEUXLN�YDQ�SRWHQWLHHO�YHUVODYHQGH�JHQRWPLGGHOHQ�

���� (QNHOH�WRHNRPVWYHUZDFKWLQJHQ7RW� VORW� YDQ� GH]H� UDSSRUWDJH� ZLOOHQ� ZLM� QRJ� HHQ� EOLN� RS� GH� WRHNRPVW� ZHUSHQ�$DQQHPHQGH�GDW�HU�GH�DDQNRPHQGH�WLHQ�MDUHQ�JHHQ�LQJULMSHQGH�VRFLDOH�RPZHQWHOLQJHQ]XOOHQ� SODDWVYLQGHQ� LQ� 1HGHUODQG�� ]LMQ� HU� YLHU� RQWZLNNHOLQJHQ� WH� VFKHWVHQ� ZDDUYDQPRJHOLMN� HQLJH� LQYORHG� LV� WH� YHUZDFKWHQ� GH� RS� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�RQJH]RQGKHLG�

Page 84: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

��� 'H KXLGLJH�GHPRJUDILVFKH� WUHQGV� YDQ� RQWJURHQLQJ� HQ� YHUJULM]LQJ�]XOOHQ� OHLGHQ� WRWHHQ�WRHQDPH�YDQ�KHW�DDQWDO�FKURQLVFK�]LHNHQ��+RHZHO�GH�SUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ� DIQHHPW� PHW� GH� OHHIWLMG�� YHUZDFKWHQ� ZLM� HHQ� WRHQDPH� � YDQ� �PLOGH�GHSUHVVLHYH� NODFKWHQ�� DOV� JHYROJ� YDQ� KHW� YHUOLHV� YDQ� FDSDFLWHLWHQ� HQ� UHODWLHV� RSRXGHUH�OHHIWLMG�HQ�PRJHOLMN�RRN�HHQ�WRHQDPH�YDQ�JHGUDJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�DOV�JHYROJ�YDQFHUHEUDOH�]LHNWHQ�ELM�RXGHUHQ��'H�WRHQHPHQGH�OHHIWLMG�ZDDURS�PHQ�]LMQ�HHUVWH�NLQGNULMJW�� JHFRPELQHHUG� PHW� GH� PHGLVFK� WHFKQRORJLVFKH� RQWZLNNHOLQJHQ� URQGRPYUXFKWEDDUKHLGVEHYRUGHUHQGH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�HQ�GH�QHRQDWDOH�]RUJ��OHLGHQ��QX�UHHGV��WRWVWHHGV� PHHU� RYHUOHYHQGH� WH� YURHJJHERUHQ� NLQGHUHQ�� 'LW� JDDW� JHSDDUG� PHW� PHHUSRVWQDWDOH�FRPSOLFDWLHV��GLH�RRN�JHYROJHQ�NXQQHQ�KHEEHQ�YRRU�GH�ODWHUH�SV\FKLVFKHJH]RQGKHLG��.RN�HW�DO���������'HQ�2XGHQ�HW�DO������������ 'H YRRUWVFKULMGHQGH� VRFLDDO�FXOWXUHOH� WUHQGV� YDQ� LQGLYLGXDOLVHULQJ�� HPDQFLSDWLH�SHUVRRQOLMN� XWRSLVPH� HQ� GH� DIQDPH� YDQ� WUDGLWLRQHOH� VWHXQYHUEDQGHQ� HQ� VRFLDOHFRQWUROH� OHLGHQ� QDDU� RQ]H� YHUZDFKWLQJ� WRW� HHQ� JHULQJH� WRHQDPH� YDQ� DQWLVRFLDDOJHGUDJ�� PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN� HQ� DDQ� VWUHVV� JHUHODWHHUGH� DQJVW��� GHSUHVVLHYH� HQVRPDWRIRUPH� NODFKWHQ�� 'DDUQDDVW� NXQQHQ� GH]H� WUHQGV�� LQ� VDPHQKDQJ� PHW� GHH[WUDPXUDOLVHULQJ� YDQ� FKURQLVFK� SV\FKLDWULVFKH� SDWLsQWHQ�� PRJHOLMN� OHLGHQ� WRWYHUZDDUOR]LQJ�ELM�GH]H�JURHS��PHW�PHHU�RYHUODVW�WKXLV�HQ�RS�VWUDDW�DOV�JHYROJ��2RNNDQ� GH� YRRUWVFKULMGHQGH� GH�LQVWLWXWLRQDOLVHULQJ� YDQ� SV\FKLDWULVFKH� SDWLsQWHQ�� LQVDPHQKDQJ�PHW�GH�WRHQHPHQGH�EHVFKLNEDDUKHLG�YDQ�DOFRKRO��.HQGHOO���������GUXJV�)DUUHOO� HW� DO��� ������ HQ� DQGHUH�PLGGHOHQ� �0DU]XN� HW� DO��� ������ ELMGUDJHQ� DDQ� HHQWRHQHPHQG�EHODQJ�YDQ�VXwFLGH�DOV�RRU]DDN�YDQ�YRRUWLMGLJH�VWHUIWH��7RW� VORW�NDQ�KHW]LMQ GDW�GRRU�µSHUVRRQOLMNH�XWRSLVPH¶�HQ�RYHUWURNNHQ�YHUZDFKWLQJHQ�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQ�HQ�YDQXLW��GH��JHHVWHOLMNH��JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ�VWHHGV�PHHU�SV\FKLVFK�RQZHOEHYLQGHQDOV�RQJHZHQVW�HQ�YHUPLMGEDDU�ZRUGW�JH]LHQ��ZDDUGRRU�KHW� LQ� WRHQHPHQGH�PDWH�DOVSV\FKLVFKH�RQJH]RQGKHLG�EHOHHIG�JDDW�ZRUGHQ��+HW�LV�HFKWHU�ELM]RQGHU�PRHLOLMN�RPGH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�GH]H�VRFLDDO�FXOWXUHOH�WUHQGV�JRHG�LQ�WH�VFKDWWHQ��� 9HUDQGHULQJHQ� LQ� GH� RUJDQLVDWLH� HQ� ZHUNZLM]H� YDQ� GH� **=� �HIIHFWLHYHU� HQ� PHHUHYLGHQFH� EDVHG�� ]XOOHQ� QLHW� DOOHHQ� OHLGHQ� WRW� HQLJH� UHGXFWLH� YDQ� GH� GXXU� YDQHSLVRGHQ��PDDU�ZHOOLFKW� RRN� WRW� HHQ� DIQDPH� YDQ� GH� SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH� HQ� VRFLDOHNZHWVEDDUKHLG� HQ� GDDUPHH� YDQ� GH� UHFLGLHINDQV� HQ� GH� NDQV� RS� DQGHUH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� DOV� GHWHUPLQDQW��� $OV� YHUEHWHUGH� EHKDQGHOLQJVSURWRFROOHQRRN� LQ� GH� HHUVWHOLMQ� �KXLVDUWVHQ�� HHUVWHOLMQVSV\FKRORJHQ�� YHUSOHHJNXQGLJHQ�PDDWVFKDSSHOLMN� ZHUN�� HQ� LQ� GH� VRPDWLVFKH� �SROL�NOLQLHN� KXQ� WRHSDVVLQJ� ]XOOHQYLQGHQ��]LMQ�HYHQHHQV�SRVLWLHYH�HIIHFWHQ�RS�HSLVRGHGXXU�HQ�FXPXODWLH�YDQ� ULVLFR¶V�HQ� GXV� RS� GH� SUHYDOHQWLH� WH� YHUZDFKWHQ� �2UPHO� HW� DO��� ����E�� 6SHFNHQV�� �����7LHPHQV����������� 0HGLVFK�WHFKQRORJLVFKH� RQWZLNNHOLQJHQ� WHQ� DDQ]LHQ� YDQ� GH� PROHFXODLUH� JHQHWLFD�'1$�WHFKQRORJLH��]XOOHQ�HU�WRH�OHLGHQ��GDW�GH�ELM�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�EHWURNNHQJHELHGHQ�YDQ�KHW�JHQRRP�]XOOHQ�ZRUGHQ�JHORNDOLVHHUG��+HW�LV�HFKWHU�RQGXLGHOLMN�KRHODQJ�GLW�QRJ�]DO�GXUHQ�HQ�KRH�VQHO�GDQ�YHUYROJHQV�GH�YROJHQGH�KLQGHUQLVVHQ�YDQ�JHQLGHQWLILFDWLH� HQ� RSKHOGHULQJ� YDQ� GH� EHWURNNHQ� LQWUDFHOOXODLUH� SURFHVVHQ� ]XOOHQZRUGHQ� JHQRPHQ�� +HW� NDQ� GHUKDOYH� QRJ� ZHO� HQNHOH� GHFHQQLD� GXUHQ� YRRUGDW� GHJHYROJHQ� YRRU� SUHYHQWLH� HQ� EHKDQGHOLQJ� ]LFKWEDDU� ZRUGHQ�� (HQ� JURRW� SUREOHHPKLHUELM�]RX�QRJ�ZHO�HHQV�NXQQHQ�]LMQ��GDW�GH�XQLHNH RQDIKDQNHOLMNH�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�GHEHWURNNHQ�JHQHQ�DDQ�KHW�ULVLFR�]HHU�NOHLQ�LV�HQ�GDW�]LM�YRRUDO�LQ�FRPSOH[H��ODVWLJ�WHLGHQWLILFHUHQ�� LQWHUDFWLHV� PHW� HONDDU� HQ� PHW� RPJHYLQJVIDFWRUHQ� YDQ� LQYORHG� ]LMQ�9RRUDO� JHQHQ�GLH� HHQ� URO� VSHOHQ�ELM� GH� QLHW�SV\FKRWLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� NXQQHQ� ]HHU

Page 85: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

ZHO� DOOHHQ� EHWURNNHQ� ]LMQ� ELM� WDPHOLMN� LQGLUHFWH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� ]RDOV� JHUHPGKHLG�LPSXOVLYLWHLW�� � QHXURWLFLVPH�� EHKRHIWH� DDQ� QLHXZH� HUYDULQJHQ� �QRYHOW\� VHHNLQJ��LQWHUSHUVRRQOLMNH�VHQVLWLYLWHLW��FRJQLWLHYH�YDDUGLJKHGHQ�HQ�VRFLDOH�RQKDQGLJKHLG��'LW]LMQ� WHQ� GHOH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� GLH� YRRU� VRPPLJH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HHQ� NZHWVEDDUKHLGYRUPHQ�PDDU�EHVFKHUPLQJ�ELHGHQ�WHJHQ�DQGHUH�RQJHZHQVWH�XLWNRPVWHQ�$OOHV� RYHUZHJHQGH�PHQHQ�ZLM� GDW� HU� QHWWR� GH� HHUVWH� YLMI� WRW� WLHQ� MDDU� QLHW� YHHO� LQ� GHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG� ]DO� YHUDQGHUHQ�� 9RRUVSHOOLQJHQ� GRHQ� RSEDVLV�YDQ�KHW�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�SODDWMH�RS�GH�ZDW�ODQJHUH�WHUPLMQ�LV�NRIILHGLN�NLMNHQ��YRRUDOGRRU� GH� EHSHUNWH� KXLGLJH� NHQQLV� RYHU� GH� HWLRORJLH� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� GHRQYRRUVSHOEDDUKHLG�YDQ�VRFLDDO�FXOWXUHOH��PHGLVFK�WHFKQRORJLVFKH�HQ�HSLGHPLRORJLVFKHRQWZLNNHOLQJHQ�

Page 86: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

/LWHUDWXXU$OOHEHFN�3��$OOJXODQGHU�&��)LVKHU�/'��3UHGLFWRUV�RI�FRPSOHWHG�VXLFLGH�LQ�D�FRKRUW�RI��������\RXQJ�PHQ�UROH�RI�SHUVRQDOLW\�DQG�GHYLDQW�EHKDYLRXU���%U�0HG�-��������������������$3$�'LDJQRVWLF�DQG�6WDWLVWLFDO�0DQXDO�RI�0HQWDO�'LVRUGHUV��)RXUWK�(GLWLRQ��:DVKLQJWRQ�'&��$PHULFDQ3V\FKLDWULF�$VVRFLDWLRQ�������$QGUHDVVRQ�6��$OOHEHFN�3��(QJVWU|P��5\GEHUJ�8��&DQQDELV�DQG�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��$�ORQJLWXGLQDO�VWXG\�RI6ZHGLVK�FRQVFULSWV��/DQFHW�������LL�������������$QGUHZV�+��+RXVH�$��)XQFWLRQDO�G\VSKRQLD��,Q��%URZQ�*:��+DUULV�72��HGV����/LIH�HYHQWV�DQG�SK\VLFDOLOOQHVV��1HZ�<RUN��*XLOIRUG�3UHVV����������������$QGUHZV�*��3DJH�$&��1HLOVRQ�0'��6HQGLQJ�\RXU�WHHQDJHUV�DZD\��FRQWUROOHG�VWUHVV�GHFUHDVHV�QHXURWLFYXOQHUDELOLW\��$UFKLYHV�RI�*HQHUDO�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������$QWKRQ\�-&��+HO]HU�-(��(SLGHPLRORJ\�RI�GUXJ�GHSHQGHQFH��,Q��7VXDQJ�07��7RKHQ�0��=DKQHU�*(3��HGV���7H[WERRN�LQ�SV\FKLDWULF�HSLGHPLRORJ\��1HZ�<RUN���-�:LOH\��6RQV��������SS����������$UHQVPDQ�(��$WWHPSWHG�VXLFLGH��HSLGHPLRORJ\�DQG�FODVVLILFDWLRQ��>$FDGHPLVFK�3URHIVFKULIW@��/HLGHQ�8QLYHUVLWHLW�/HLGHQ�������%DHU�-6��0DF/HDQ�0*��0DUODWW�*$��/LQNLQJ�HWLRORJ\�DQG�WUHDWPHQW�RI�DGROHVFHQW�VXEVWDQFH�DEXVH�7RZDUG�D�EHWWHU�PDWFK��,Q��-HVVRU�5��HG����1HZ�SHUVSHFWLYHV�RQ�DGROHVFHQW�ULVN�EHKDYLRU��&DPEULGJH�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV���������SS����������%DUNHU�'-��2VPRQG�&��5RGLQ�,��)DOO�&+'��:LQWHU�3'��/RZ�ZHLJKW�JDLQ�LQ�LQIDQF\�DQG�VXLFLGH�LQ�DGXOWOLIH���%U�0HG�-�����������������%DVV�&0��6RPDWL]DWLRQ��SK\VLFDO�V\PSWRPV�DQG�SV\FKRORJLFDO�LOOQHVV��/RQGRQ��%ODFNZHOO�6FLHQWLILF3XEOLFDWLRQV�������%DWWDJOLD�0��%HUWHOOD�6��%DMR�6��3ROLWL�(��%HOORGL�/��$Q�LQYHVWLJDWLRQ�RI�WKH�FR�RFFXUUHQFH�RI�SDQLF�DQGVRPDWL]DWLRQ�GLVRUGHUV�WKURXJK�WHPSHUDPHQWDO�YDULDEOHV��3V\FKRVRPDWLF�0HGLFLQH������������������%HEELQJWRQ�3��5DPDQD�5���7KH�HSLGHPLRORJ\�RI�ELSRODU�DIIHFWLYH�GLVRUGHU��6RFLDO�3V\FKLDWU\�DQG3V\FKLDWULF�(SLGHPLRORJ\�������������������%HEELQJWRQ�3��:LONLQV�6��-RQHV�3��)RHUVWHU�$��0XUUD\�5��7RRQH�%��/HZLV�6��/LIH�HYHQWV�DQG�SV\FKRVLV�,QLWLDO�UHVXOWV�IURP�WKH�&DPEHUZHOO�&ROODERUDWLYH�3V\FKRVLV�VWXG\��%ULWLVK�-RXUQDO�RI�3V\FKLDWU\�����������������%HHNPDQ�$7)��2UPHO�-��'HSUHVVLH��,Q��-RQJ�$�GH��%ULQN�:�YDQ�GHQ��2UPHO�-��:LHUVPD�'��HGV���+DQGERHN�3V\FKLDWULVFKH�(SLGHPLRORJLH��0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�'H�7LMGVWURRP��������SS����������%HLVHU�0��(ULFNVRQ�'��)OHPLQJ�-��,DFRQR�:��(VWDEOLVKLQJ�WKH�RQVHW�RI�SV\FKRWLF�LOOQHVV��$PHULFDQ�-RXUQDORI�3V\FKLDWU\����������������������%HUULRV�*(��3RUWHU�5��HGV���$�KLVWRU\�RI�FOLQLFDO�SV\FKLDWU\��/RQGRQ��$WKORQH�������%LIXOFR�$��%URZQ�*:��+DUULV�72��&KLOGKRRG�H[SHULHQFH�RI�FDUH�DQG�DEXVH��&(&$���D�UHWURVSHFWLYHLQWHUYLHZ�PHDVXUH��&KLOG�3V\FKRORJ\�DQG�3V\FKLDWU\����������������������%LIXOFR�$��%URZQ�*:��0RUDQ�3��%DOO�&��&DPSEHOO�&��3UHGLFWLQJ�GHSUHVVLRQ�LQ�ZRPHQ��WKH�UROH�RI�SDVWDQG�SUHVHQW�YXOQHUDELOLW\��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�����������������%LMO�59��=HVVHQ�*�YDQ��5DYHOOL�$��5LMN�&�GH��/DQJHQGRHQ�<��3V\FKLDWULVFKH�PRUELGLWHLW�RQGHUYROZDVVHQHQ�LQ�1HGHUODQG��KHW�1(0(6,6�RQGHU]RHN��,��GRHOVWHOOLQJHQ��RS]HW�HQ�PHWKRGHQ�1HGHUODQGV�7LMGVFKULIW�YRRU�*HQHHVNXQGH�����D�����������������%LMO�59��=HVVHQ�*�YDQ��5DYHOOL�$��3V\FKLDWULVFKH�PRUELGLWHLW�RQGHU�YROZDVVHQHQ�LQ�1HGHUODQG��KHW1(0(6,6�RQGHU]RHN��OO��3UHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��1HGHUODQGV�7LMGVFKULIW�YRRU*HQHHVNXQGH�����E�����������������%ODDXZ�(��.HUNKRI�$��9HUPXQW�5��6XwFLGHV�DQG�RWKHU�GHDWKV�SROLFH�FXVWRG\��6XwFLGH�DQG�/LIH�WKUHDWHQLQJ%HKDYLRXU�������������������%UHPV�&��:RPHQ�DQG�GHSUHVVLRQ��D�FRPSUHKHQVLYH�DQDO\VLV��,Q��%HFNKDP�((��/HEHU�:5��HGV���+DQGERRN�RI�GHSUHVVLRQ��1HZ�<RUN��*XLOIRUG��������SS����������%UHQQDQ�3$��*UHNLQ�(5��0HGQLFN�6$��0DWHUQDO�VPRNLQJ�GXULQJ�SUHJQDQF\�DQG�DGXOW�PDOH�FULPLQDORXWFRPHV��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������%UHZLQ�-��&DQWZHOO�5��'DONLQ�7�HW�DO��,QFLGHQFH�RI�VFKL]RSKUHQLD�LQ�1RWWLQJKDP��$�FRPSDULVRQ�RI�WZRFRKRUWV����������DQG����������%ULWLVK�-RXUQDO�RI�3V\FKLDWU\��������������������%ULOPDQ�(,��2UPHO�-��/LIH�&KDQJH�DQG�GHSUHVVLRQ�LQ�ROGHU�SHRSOH��D�SRSXODWLRQ�EDVHG�FDVH�FRQWURO�VWXG\�3V\FKRO�0HG��VXEPLWWHG�

Page 87: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

%ULQN�:�YDQ�GHQ��'HFULPLQDOLVHULQJ�YDQ�FDQQDELV�HQ�KHW�JHEUXLN�YDQ�GUXJV�LQ�1HGHUODQG��HHQHSLGHPLRORJLVFKH�HYDOXDWLH�YDQ�KHW�JHGRRJEHOHLG���,Q��0LFKRQ�-$��HG����6WUDIUHFKW�WHJHQGUXJJHEUXLN"�:HQVHOLMNKHLG�HQ�RQZHQVHOLMNKHLG�YDQ�EHVWULMGLQJ�YDQ�GUXJJHEUXLN�GRRU�PLGGHO�YDQ�KHWVWUDIUHFKW��$PVWHUGDP��.1$:�������%ULQN�:�YDQ�GHQ��<SHUHQ�7$�YDQ��&ODVVLILFDWLH�LQ�GH�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�HSLGHPLRORJLH��,Q��-RQJ�$�GH��%ULQN: YDQ�GHQ��2UPHO�-��:LHUVPD�'��HGV����+DQGERHN�3V\FKLDWULVFKH�(SLGHPLRORJLH��0DDUVVHQ�(OVHYLHU�'H�7LMGVWURRP���������SS�������%ULQN�:�YDQ�GHQ��9HUVODYLQJHQ���,Q��-RQJ�$�GH��%ULQN�:�YDQ�GHQ��2UPHO�-��:LHUVPD�'��HGV����+DQGERHN3V\FKLDWULVFKH�(SLGHPLRORJLH��0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�'H�7LMGVWURRP��������SS����������%URPHW�(-��'HZ�0$��(DWRQ�:��(SLGHPLRORJ\�RI�3V\FKRVLV�ZLWK�VSHFLDO�UHIHUHQFH�WR�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��,Q�7VXDQJ�07��7RKHQ�0��=DKQHU�*(3��HGV����7H[WERRN�LQ�SV\FKLDWULF�HSLGHPLRORJ\��1HZ�<RUN�-�:LOH\�DQG�6RQV�LQF���������S����������%URZQ�*:��*HQHWLFV�RI�GHSUHVVLRQ��$�VRFLDO�VFLHQFH�SHUVSHFWLYH��,QW�5HY�3V\FKLDWU\������������������%URZQ�*:��0RUDQ�3��6LQJOH�PRWKHUV��SRYHUW\�DQG�GHSUHVVLRQ��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�����������������%URZQ�*:��+DUULV�72��+HSZRUWK�&��/RVV��KXPLOLDWLRQ�DQG�HQWUDSPHQW�DPRQJ�ZRPHQ�GHYHORSLQJGHSUHVVLRQ��D�SDWLHQW�DQG�QRQ�SDWLHQW�FRPSDULVRQ��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH����������������%URZQ�*:��+DUULV�72��/LIH�HYHQWV�DQG�HQGRJHQRXV�GHSUHVVLRQ��D�SX]]OH�UHH[DPLQHG��$UFK�*HQ3V\FKLDWU\�������������������%URZQ�*:��+DUULV�72��6RFLDO�2ULJLQV�RI�'HSUHVVLRQ��/RQGRQ��7DYLVWRFN�������%UXFH�0/��7DNHXFKL�'7��/HDI�3-��3RYHUW\�DQG�SV\FKLDWULF�VWDWXV��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������%UXJKD�76��%HEELQJWRQ�3(��6WUHWFK�''��0DF&DUWK\�%��:\NHV�7��3UHGLFWLQJ�WKH�VKRUW�WHUP�RXWFRPH�RIILUVW�HSLVRGHV�DQG�UHFXUUHQFHV�RI�FOLQLFDO�GHSUHVVLRQ��D�SURVSHFWLYH�VWXG\�RI�OLIH�HYHQWV��GLIILFXOWLHV�DQG�VRFLDO�VXSSRUW�QHWZRUNV��-�&OLQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������%XFKDQDQ�5:��6WHYHQV�-5��&DUSHQWHU�:7��7KH�QHXURDQDWRP\�RI�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��6FKL]�%XOOHWLQ������������������%XUYLOO�3:��5HFHQW�SURJUHVV�LQ�WKH�HSLGHPLRORJ\�RI�PDMRU�GHSUHVVLRQ��(SLGHPLRO�5HY�����������������&DUU�5(��3DQLF�GLVRUGHU�DQG�DVWKPD��FDXVHV��HIIHFWV�DQG�UHVHDUFK�LPSOLFDWLRQV��-RXUQDO�RI�3V\FKRVRPDWLF5HVHDUFK�����������������&DVSL�$��0RIILWW�7(��1HZPDQ�'/��6LOYD�3$��%HKDYLRUDO�REVHUYDWLRQV�DW�DJH���\HDUV�SUHGLFW�DGXOWSV\FKLDWULF�GLVRUGHUV��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\���������������������&KHUOLQ�$-��)XUVWHQEHUJ�))��&KDVH�/DQVGDOH�3/��HW�DO��/RQJLWXGLQDO�VWXGLHV�RI�HIIHFWV�RI�GLYRUFH�RQFKLOGUHQ�LQ�*UHDW�%ULWDLQ�DQG�WKH�8QLWHG�6WDWHV��6FLHQFH����������������������&KULVWHQVHQ�0)��0RUWHQVHQ�2��/RQJ�WHUP�SURJQRVLV�LQ�FKLOGUHQ�ZLWK�UHFXUUHQW�DEGRPLQDO�SDLQ��$UFKLYHVRI�'LVHDVH�LQ�&KLOGKRRG�������������������&OLIIRUG�&$��0XUUD\�50��)XONHU�':��*HQHWLF�DQG�HQYLURQPHQWDO�LQIOXHQFHV�RQ�REVHVVLRQDO�WUDLWV�DQGV\PSWRPV��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�������������������&ORQLQJHU�&5��$�XQLILHG�ELRVRFLDO�WKHRU\�RI�SHUVRQDOLW\�DQG�LWV�UROH�LQ�WKH�GHYHORSPHQW�RI�DQ[LHW\�VWDWHV�3V\FKLDWULF�'HYHORSPHQWV������������������&RKHQ�6��.HVVOHU�5&��*RUGRQ�/8��0HDVXULQJ�6WUHVV��$�JXLGH�IRU�KHDOWK�DQG�VRFLDO�VFLHQWLVWV��2[IRUG�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV�������&RRNH�'-��7KH�VLJQLILFDQFH�RI�OLIH�HYHQWV�DV�D�FDXVH�RI�SV\FKRORJLFDO�DQG�SK\VLFDO�GLVRUGHU��,Q��&RRSHU�%�HG����3V\FKLDWULF�HSLGHPLRORJ\��3URJUHVV�DQG�SURVSHFWV��/RQGRQ��&URRP�+HOP�������&RUQH\�5+��6H[�GLIIHUHQFHV�LQ�JHQHUDO�SUDFWLFH�DWWHQGDQFH�DQG�KHOS�VHHNLQJ�IRU�PLQRU�LOOQHVV��-RXUQDO�RI3V\FKRVRPDWLF�5HVHDUFK�������������������&R\QH�-&��'RZQH\�*��6RFLDO�IDFWRUV�DQG�SV\FKRSDWKRORJ\��VWUHVV��VRFLDO�VXSSRUW��DQG�FRSLQJ�SURFHVVHV�$QQXDO�5HYLHZ�RI�3V\FKRORJ\�������������������&UDLJ�7.-��%RDUGPDQ�$3��0LOOV�.��'DO\�-RQHV�2��'UDNH�+��7KH�6RXWK�/RQGRQ�VRPDWLVDWLRQ�VWXG\�ORQJLWXGLQDO�FRXUVH�DQG�WKH�LQIOXHQFH�RI��HDUO\�OLIH�H[SHULHQFHV��%U�-�3V\FKLDWU\���������������&UDPHU�'��6RFLDO�VXSSRUW�DQG�SV\FKRORJLFDO�GLVWUHVV�LQ�ZRPHQ�DQG�PHQ��%U�-�0HG�3V\FKRO������������������'DYLGVRQ�-5��7XSOHU�/$��:LOVRQ�:+��&RQQRU�.0��$�IDPLO\�VWXG\�RI�FKURQLF�376'�IROORZLQJ�UDSHWUDXPD��-RXUQDO�RI�3V\FKLDWULF�5HVHDUFK�������������������'D\�1/��(SLGHPLRORJ\�RI�DOFRKRO�XVH��DEXVH��DQG�GHSHQGHQFH��,Q��7VXDQJ�07��7RKHQ�0��=DKQHU�*(3�HGV����7H[WERRN�LQ�SV\FKLDWULF�HSLGHPLRORJ\��1HZ�<RUN��-�:LOH\��6RQV��������SS����������'HOWLWR�-$��+DKQ�5��$�WKUHH�JHQHUDWLRQDO�SUHVHQWDWLRQ�RI�VHSDUDWLRQ�DQ[LHW\�LQ�FKLOGKRRG�ZLWKDJRUDSKRELD�LQ�DGXOWKRRG��3V\FKRSKDUPDFRORJ\�%XOOHWLQ�������������������

Page 88: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

'HOYD�1-��0DWWKHZV�'5��&RZHQ�3-��%UDLQ�VHURWRQLQ���+7��QHXURHQGRFULQH�IXQFWLRQ�LQ�SDWLHQWV�WDNLQJFKROHVWHURO�ORZHULQJ�GUXJV��%LRORJLFDO�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������'HU�*��*XSWD�6��0XUUD\�50��,V�VFKL]RSKUHQLD�GLVDSSHDULQJ"�/DQFHW��������������������'RKUHQZHQG�%3��'RKUHQZHQG�%6��6RFLR�HQYLURQPHQWDO�IDFWRUV��VWUHVV��DQG�SV\FKRSDWKRORJ\���3DUW�,4XDVL�H[SHULPHQWDO�HYLGHQFH�RQ�WKH�VRFLDO�FDXVDWLRQ���VRFLDO�VHOHFWLRQ�LVVXH�SRVHG�E\�FODVVGLIIHUHQFHV��$PHULFDQ�-RXUQDO�RI�&RPPXQLW\�3V\FKRORJ\������������������'RXJODVV�+0��0RIILWW�7(��'DU�5��0F*HH�5��6LOYD�3��2EVHVVLYH�FRPSXOVLYH�GLVRUGHU�LQ�D�ELUWK�FRKRUW�RI���\HDU�ROGV��SUHYDOHQFH�DQG�SUHGLFWRUV��-RXUQDO�RI�WKH�$PHULFDQ�$FDGHP\�RI�&KLOG�DQG�$GROHVFHQW3V\FKLDWU\���������������������'XJJDQ�&)��/HH�$6��0XUUD\�50��'RHV�SHUVRQDOLW\�SUHGLFW�ORQJ�WHUP�RXWFRPH�LQ�GHSUHVVLRQ"�%U�-3V\FKLDWU\������������������'XQFDQ�-RQHV�3��)HUJXVVRQ�'0��2UPHO�-��+RUZRRG�/-��$�PRGHO�RI�VWDELOLW\�DQG�FKDQJH�LQ�PLQRU�SV\�FKLDWULF�V\PSWRPV��UHVXOWV�IURP�WKUHH�ORQJLWXGLQDO�VWXGLHV��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH��0RQRJUDSK6XSSOHPHQW����������������'XUNKHLP�(��6XwFLGH��$�6WXG\�LQ�6RFLRORJ\��WUDQVODWHG�E\�-�$�6SDXOGLQJ��*��6LPSVRQ���,OOLQRLV��)UHH3UHVV�������(DWRQ�::��7LHQ�$<��3RHVFKOD�%'��(SLGHPLRORJ\�RI�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��,Q��%RHU�-$�GHQ��:HVWHQEHUJ�+*0�HGV����$GYDQFHV�LQ�WKH�QHXURELRORJ\�RI�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��:LOH\�VHULHV�RQ�FOLQLFDO�DQG�QHXURELRORJLFDODGYDQFHV�LQ�SV\FKLDWU\�YRO��,��&KLFKHVWHU��-�:LOH\��VRQV��������SS�������(DWRQ�::��$QWKRQ\�-&��*DOOR�-�HW�DO��1DWXUDO�KLVWRU\�RI�',6�'60�,9�0DMRU�'HSUHVVLRQ��$UFK�*HQ3V\FKLDWU\��������������������(DWRQ�::��+D\ZDUG�&��5DP�5��6FKL]RSKUHQLD�DQG�UKHXPDWLF�DUWKULWLV��D�UHYLHZ���6FKL]��5HVHDUFK�����������������(DYHV�/-��6LOEHUJ�-/��0H\HU�-0�HW�DO��*HQHWLFV�DQG�GHYHORSPHQWDO�SV\FKRSDWKRORJ\��-�&KLOG�3V\FKRO3V\FKLDWU\�������������������(GHOPDQ�*0��7RQRQL�*��6HOHFWLRQ�DQG�GHYHORSPHQW��WKH�EUDLQ�DV�D�FRPSOH[�V\VWHP��,Q��0DJQXVVRQ�$�HG����7KH�OLIHVSDQ�GHYHORSPHQW�RI�LQGLYLGXDOV�±�%HKDYLRUDO��QHXURELRORJLFDO�DQG�SV\FKRVRFLDOSHUVSHFWLYHV��&DPEULGJH��8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV��������SS����������(GZDUGV�*��7KH�DOFRKRO�GHSHQGHQFH�V\QGURPH��D�FRQFHSW�DV�WLPXOXV�WR�HQTXLU\��%U�-�$GGLFW�����������������(LVHQEHUJ�/��'HYHORSPHQW�DV�D�XQLI\LQJ�FRQFHSW�LQ�SV\FKLDWU\��%U�-�3V\FKLDWU\��������������������)DURRT�6��2N\HUH�(��*DKLQ�06��6KHLNK�$-��2\HERGH�)��6RPDWL]DWLRQ��D�WUDQVFXOWXUDO�VWXG\��-RXUQDO�RI3V\FKRVRPDWLF�5HVHDUFK�������������������)DUUHOO�0��1HHOHPDQ�-��*ULIILWKV�3��6WUDQJ�-��6XwFLGH�DQG�RYHUGRVH�DPRQJ�RSLDWH�DGGLFWV��$GGLFWLRQ������������������)DUUHOO�0��6WUDQJ�-��1HHOHPDQ�-��5HXWHU�3��3ROLF\�RQ�GUXJ�PLVXVH�LQ�(XURSH��%U�0HG�-��������������������)HUGLQDQG�5)��9HUKXOVW�)&��3V\FKRSDWKRORJ\�IURP�DGROHVFHQFH�LQWR�\RXQJ�DGXOWKRRG��DQ���\HDU�IROORZ�XS�VWXG\��$PHULFDQ�-RXUQDO�RI�3V\FKLDWU\�����������������������)HUJXVVRQ�'0��/\QVNH\�07��+RUZRRG�/-��2ULJLQV�RI�FRPRUELGLW\�EHWZHHQ�FRQGXFW�DQG�DIIHFWLYHGLVRUGHUV��-RXUQDO�RI�WKH�$PHULFDQ�$FDGHP\�RI�FKLOG�DQG�$GROHVFHQW�3V\FKLDWU\��������������������)HUJXVVRQ�'0��+RUZRRG�/-��(DUO\�FRQGXFW�SUREOHPV�DQG�ODWHU�OLIH�RSSRUWXQLWLHV��-RXUQDO�RI�&KLOG3V\FKRORJ\�DQG�3V\FKLDWU\���������������������)LQOD\�-RQHV�5��%URZQ�*:��7\SHV�RI�VWUHVVIXO�OLIH�HYHQW�DQG�WKH�RQVHW�RI�DQ[LHW\�DQG�GHSUHVVLYHGLVRUGHUV��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�������������������)RONPDQ�6��/D]DUXV�56��&RSLQJ�DV�D�PHGLDWRU�RI�HPRWLRQ��-RXUQDO�RI�3HUVRQDOLW\�DQG�6RFLDO�3V\FKRORJ\������������������)RPERQQH�(��'HSUHVVLYH�GLVRUGHUV��WLPH�WUHQGV�DQG�WKHLU�FDXVHV��,Q��5XWWHU�0��6PLWK�'-��HGV���3V\FKRVRFLDO�'LVRUGHUV�LQ�<RXQJ�SHRSOH��7LPH�7UHQGV�DQG�7KHLU�&DXVHV��&KLFKHVWHU��:LOH\��6RQV������*DUULVRQ�&=��0F.HRZQ�5(��9DORLV�5)��9LQFHQW�0/��$JJUHVVLRQ��VXEVWDQFH�XVH�DQG�VXLFLGDO�EHKDYLRUV�LQKLJK�VFKRRO�VWXGHQWV��$P�-�3XEOLF�+HDOWK�������������������*HRUJH�/.��%OD]HU�'*��+XJKHV�'&��)RZOHU�1��6RFLDO�VXSSRUW�DQG�WKH�RXWFRPH�RI�PDMRU�GHSUHVVLRQ��%U�-3V\FKLDWU\��������������������*H]RQGKHLGVUDDG��2SVSRULQJ�HQ�EHKDQGHOLQJ�YDQ�DGROHVFHQWHQ�PHW�VFKL]RIUHQLH��'HQ�+DDJ�*H]RQGKHLGVUDDG��SXEOLFDWLHQU����������������*LHO�5��&RPRUELGLWHLW��HHQ�GRRG�VSRRU"�7LMGVFKULIW�YRRU�3V\FKLDWULH�������������������

Page 89: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

*LHO�5��6DXHU�+&��6ORRII�&-��:LHUVPD�'��2YHU�HSLGHPLRORJLH�YDQ�IXQNWLRQHOH�SV\FKRVHQ�HQ�LQYDOLGLWHLW�7LMGVFKULIW�YRRU�3V\FKLDWULH�������������������*ROGEHUJ�'��7KH�'HWHFWLRQ�RI�3V\FKLDWULF�,OOQHVV�E\�4XHVWLRQQDLUH��/RQGRQ��2[IRUG�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV������*ROGEHUJ�'��+X[OH\�3��&RPPRQ�PHQWDO�GLVRUGHUV��$�ELR�VRFLDO�PRGHO��/RQGRQ��7DYLVWRFN�5RXWOHGJH������*ROGEHUJ�'3��%ULGJHV�.��'XQFDQ�-RQHV�3��*UD\VRQ�'��'LPHQVLRQV�RI�QHXURVHV�VHHQ�LQ�SULPDU\�FDUHVHWWLQJV��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�������������������*RRGZLQ�).��-DPLVRQ�.5��0DQLF�GHSUHVVLYH�LOOQHVV��1HZ�<RUN��2[IRUG�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV�������*RRGZLQ�':��*HQHWLFV�RI�DOFRKROLVP��,Q��+VX�/.*��+HUVHQ�0��HGV����5HVHDUFK�LQ�SV\FKLDWU\��LVVXHV�VWUDWHJLHV�DQG�PHWKRGV��1HZ�<RUN��3OHQXP�3UHVV�������*RWWHVPDQ�,,��6KLHOG�-���6FKL]RSKUHQLD��WKH�HSLJHQHWLF�SX]]OH��1HZ�<RUN��)UHHPDQ�������*XQQHOO�'��)UDQNHO�6��3UHYHQWLRQ�RI�VXLFLGH��DVSLUDWLRQV�DQG�HYLGHQFH��%U�0HG�-����������������������*X]H�%+��&ORQLQJHU�&5��0DUWLQ�5/��&OD\WRQ�3-��$�IROORZ�XS�DQG�IDPLO\�VWXG\�RI�%ULTXHWV�V\QGURPH��%U- 3V\FKLDWU\��������������+lIQHU�+��0DXUHU�.��/|IIOHU�:��5LHFKHU�5|VVOHU�$��7KH�LQIOXHQFH�RI�DJH�DQG�VH[�RQ�WKH�RQVHW�DQG�FRXUVHRI�HDUO\�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��%U�-�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������+lIQHU�+��DQ�GHU�+HLGHQ�:��%HKUHQV�6W��*DWWD]�:I�HW�DO��&DXVHV�DQG�FRQVHTXHQFHV�RI�WKH�JHQGHUGLIIHUHQFH�LQ�DJH�RI�RQVHW�RI�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��$�UHYLHZ�RI�UHVXOWV�IURP�EUDQFK����JHQGHU��RI�WKH�$%&�DJH��EHJLQQLQJ��FRXUVH��VFKL]RSKUHQLD�VWXG\��6FKL]RSKUHQLD�%XOOHWLQ�������������������+DJQHOO�2��*UDVEHFN�$��&RPRUELGLW\�RI�DQ[LHW\�DQG�GHSUHVVLRQ�LQ�WKH�/XQGE\����\HDU�SURVSHFWLYH�VWXG\�WKH�SDWWHUQV�RI�VXEVHTXHQW�HSLVRGHV��,Q��0DVHU�-'��&ORQLQJHU�&5��HGV����&RPRUELGLW\�RI�PRRG�DQGDQ[LHW\�GLVRUGHUV��:DVKLQJWRQ�'&��$33��������SS����������+DPPHQ�&��&RJQLWLYH��OLIH�VWUHVV��DQG�LQWHUSHUVRQDO�DSSURDFKHV�WR�D�GHYHORSPHQWDO�SV\FKRSDWKRORJ\PRGHO�RI�GHSUHVVLRQ��'HYHORSPHQW�DQG�3V\FKRSDWKRORJ\������������������+DUULV�72��%URZQ�*:��%LIXOFR�$��/RVV�RI�SDUHQW�LQ�FKLOGKRRG�DQG�DGXOW�SV\FKLDWULF�GLVRUGHU��D�WHQWDWLYHRYHUDOO�PRGHO��'HYHORSPHQW�DQG�3V\FKRSDWKRORJ\������������������+DUULV�(&��%DUUDFORXJK�%0��6XwFLGH�DV�DQ�RXWFRPH�IRU�PHGLFDO�GLVRUGHUV��0HGLFLQH�%DOWLPRUH�������������������+DUULVRQ�*��2ZHQV�'��+ROWRQ�$��1HLOVRQ�'��%RRW�'��3URVSHFWLYH�VWXG\�RI�VHYHUH�PHQWDO�GLVRUGHU�LQ�$IUR�&DULEEHDQ�SDWLHQWV��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�������������������+DZWRQ�.��:DUH�&��0LVWU\�+�HW�DO��:K\�SDWLHQWV�FKRRVH�SDUDFHWDPRO�IRU�VHOI�SRLVRQLQJ�DQG�WKHLUNQRZOHGJH�RI�LWV�GDQJHUV��%U�0HG�-����������������+HOOJUHQ�/��*LOOEHUJ�,&��%DJHQKROP�$��*LOOEHUJ�&��&KLOGUHQ�ZLWK�GHILFLWV�LQ�DWWHQWLRQ��PRWRU�FRQWURO�DQGSHUFHSWLRQ�DOPRVW�JURZQ�XS��SV\FKLDWULF�DQG�SHUVRQDOLW\�GLVRUGHUV�DW�DJH����\HDUV��-RXUQDO�RI�&KLOG3V\FKRORJ\�DQG�3V\FKLDWU\���������������������+HQGHUVRQ�$6��6RFLDO�VXSSRUW��,WV�SUHVHQW�VLJQLILFDQFH�IRU�SV\FKLDWULF�HSLGHPLRORJ\��,Q��'RKUHQZHQG�%3�HG����$GYHUVLW\��VWUHVV��DQG�SV\FKRSDWKRORJ\��1HZ�<RUN��2[IRUG�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV��������SS����������+HQGHUVRQ�$6��%\UQH�'*��'XQFDQ�-RQHV�3��1HXURVLV�DQG�WKH�6RFLDO�(QYLURQPHQW��6\GQH\��$FDGHPLF3UHVV�������+HQGHUVRQ�6��6RFLDO�UHODWLRQVKLSV��DGYHUVLW\�DQG�QHXURVLV��DQ�DQDO\VLV�RI�SURVSHFWLYH�REVHUYDWLRQV��%U�-3V\FKLDWU\��������������������+RIIPDQQ�-3��6X�66��3DUHQWDO�VXEVWDQFH�XVH�GLVRUGHU��PHGLDWLQJ�YDULDEOHV�DQG�DGROHVFHQW�GUXJ�XVH��DQRQ�UHFXUVLYH�PRGHO��$GGLFWLRQ���������������������+RWRSI�0��&DUU�6��0D\RX�5��:DGVZRUWK�0��:HVVHO\�6��:K\�GR�FKLOGUHQ�KDYH�FKURQLF�DEGRPLQDO�SDLQDQG�ZKDW�KDSSHQV�WR�WKHP�ZKHQ�WKH\�JURZ�XS"�3RSXODWLRQ�EDVHG�FRKRUW�VWXG\��%U�0HG�-���������������������-DFREVRQ�%��%\JGHPDQ�0��2EVWHWULF�FDUH�DQG�SURQHQHVV�RI�RIIVSULQJ�WR�VXLFLGH�DV�DGXOWV��FDVH�FRQWUROVWXG\���%U�0HG�-����������������������-HQDZD\�$��3D\NHO�(6��/LIH�HYHQWV�DQG�GHSUHVVLRQ��,Q��+RQLJ�$��3UDDJ�+0�YDQ��HGV����'HSUHVVLRQ�QHXURELRORJLFDO��SV\FKRSDWKRORJLFDO�DQG�WKHUDSHXWLF�DGYDQFHV��1HZ�<RUN��-�:LOH\�DQG�6RQV�������-HVVRU�5��1HZ�SHUVSHFWLYHV�RQ�DGROHVFHQW�ULVN�EHKDYLRU��&DPEULGJH��8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV�������-RQHV�3��5RGJHUV�%��0XUUD\�5��0DUPRW�0��&KLOG�GHYHORSPHQWDO�ULVN�IDFWRUV�IRU�DGXOW�VFKL]RSKUHQLD�LQWKH�%ULWLVK������ELUWK�FRKRUW��/DQFHW����������������������-RQJ�$�GH��%ULQN�:�YDQ�GHQ��2UPHO�-��:LHUVPD�'��HGV����+DQGERHN�3V\FKLDWULVFKH�(SLGHPLRORJLH�0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�'H�7LMGVWURRP�������

Page 90: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

-RUP�$)��6H[�GLIIHUHQFHV�LQ�QHXURWLFLVP��D�TXDQWLWDWLYH�V\QWKHVLV�RI�SXEOLVKHG�UHVHDUFK��$XVWUDOLDQ�DQG1HZ�=HDODQG�-RXUQDO�RI�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������.DQGHO�'%��3HUVLVWHQW�WKHPHV�DQG�QHZ�SHUVSHFWLYHV�RQ�DGROHVFHQW�VXEVWDQFH�DEXVH��$�OLIHVSDQSHUVSHFWLYH��,Q��-HVVRU�5��HG����1HZ�SHUVSHFWLYHV�RQ�DGROHVFHQW�ULVN�EHKDYLRU��&DPEULGJH��8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV��������SS�������.DVSHU�6��6RFLDO�SKRELD��WKH�QDWXUH�RI�WKH�GLVRUGHU��-�$IIHFW�'LVRUG�����������V��V��.DWHUQGDKO�'$��3DQLF�DQG�SURODSVH��PHWD�DQDO\VLV��-RXUQDO�RI�1HUYRXV�DQG�0HQWDO�'LVHDVH�������������������.HQGHOO�5(��7KH�EHQHILFLDO�FRQVHTXHQFHV�RI�WKH�8QLWHG�.LQJGRPV�GHFOLQLQJ�SHU�FDSLWD�DOFRKROFRQVXPSWLRQ�LQ������������$OFRKRO�DQG�$OFRKROLVP�������������������.HQGOHU�.6��.DUNRZVN\�6KXPDQ�/��6WUHVVIXO�OLIH�HYHQWV�DQG�JHQHWLF�OLDELOLW\�WR�PDMRU�GHSUHVVLRQ��JHQHWLFFRQWURO�RI�H[SRVXUH�WR�WKH�HQYLURQPHQW��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�������������������.HQGOHU�.6��:DOWHUV�((��1HDOH�0&��.HVVOHU�5&��+HDWK�$&��(DYHV�/-��7KH�VWUXFWXUH�RI�JHQHWLF�DQGHQYLURQPHQWDO�ULVN�IDFWRUV�IRU�VL[�PDMRU�SV\FKLDWULF�GLVRUGHUV�LQ�ZRPHQ��SKRELD��JHQHUDOL]HG�DQ[LHW\GLVRUGHU��SDQLF�GLVRUGHU��EXOLPLD��PDMRU�GHSUHVVLRQ�DQG�DOFRKROLVP��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\������������������.HQGOHU�.6��1HDOH�0&��.HVVOHU�5&��+HDWK�$&��(DYHV�/-��0DMRU�GHSUHVVLRQ�DQG�JHQHUDOL]HG�DQ[LHW\GLVRUGHU��VDPH�JHQHV��SDUWO\�GLIIHUHQW�HQYLURQPHQWV"�$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������.HQGOHU�.6��:DOWHUV�((��7UXHWW�.5��HW�DO��$�WZLQ�IDPLO\�VWXG\�RI�VHOI�UHSRUWHG�V\PSWRPV�RI�SDQLF�SKRELDDQG�VRPDWL]DWLRQ��%HKDYLRU�*HQHWLFV�������������������.HQGOHU�.6��:DOWHUV�((��.HVVOHU�5&��7KH�SUHGLFWLRQ�RI�OHQJWK�RI�PDMRU�GHSUHVVLYH�HSLVRGHV��UHVXOWV�IURPDQ�HSLGHPLRORJLFDO�VDPSOH�RI�IHPDOH�WZLQV��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�������������������.HQGOHU�.6��+HDWK�$��0DUWLQ�1*��(DYHV�/-��6\PSWRPV�RI�DQ[LHW\�DQG�GHSUHVVLRQ�LQ�D�YROXQWHHU�WZLQSRSXODWLRQ��7KH�HWLRORJLF�UROH�RI�JHQHWLF�DQG�HQYLURQPHQWDO�IDFWRUV��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\������������������.HQQHG\�3)��.UHLWPDQ�1��$Q�HSLGHPLRORJLFDO�VXUYH\�RI�SDUDVXLFLGH���DWWHPSWHG�VXLFLGH���LQ�JHQHUDOSUDFWLFH��%U�-�3V\FKLDWU\������������������.HVVOHU�5&��0F*RQDJOH�.$��=KDR�6�HW�DO��/LIHWLPH�DQG����PRQWK�SUHYDOHQFH�RI�'60����U��SV\FKLDWULFGLVRUGHUV�DPRQJ�SHUVRQV�DJHG�������LQ�WKH�8QLWHG�6WDWHV��5HVXOWV�IURP�WKH�1DWLRQDO�&RPRUELGLW\6XUYH\��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\����������������.HVVOHU�5&��.HQGOHU�.6��6RFLDO�VXSSRUW��GHSUHVVHG�PRRG�DQG�DGMXVWPHQW�WR�VWUHVV��D�JHQHWLFHSLGHPLRORJLFDO�LQYHVWLJDWLRQ��-RXUQDO�RI�3HUVRQDOLW\�DQG�6RFLDO�3V\FKRORJ\������������������.LQJ�0��&RNHU�(��/HDYH\�*��+RDUH�$��-RKQVRQ�6DELQH�(��,QFLGHQFH�RI�SV\FKRWLF�LOOQHVV��FRPSDULVRQ�RIHWKQLF�JURXSV��%U�0HG�-RXUQDO����������������������.OHUPDQ�*/��/DYRUL�3:��5LFH�-�HW�DO��%LUWK�FRKRUW�WUHQGV�LQ�UDWHV�RI�PDMRU�GHSUHVVLYH�GLVRUGHU�DPRQJUHODWLYHV�RI�SDWLHQWV�ZLWK�DIIHFWLYH�GLVRUGHU��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������.RN�-+���2XGHQ�$/��9HUORRYH�9DQKRULFN�63��%UDQG�5��2XWFRPH�RI�YHU\�SUHWHUP�VPDOO�IRU�JHVWDWLRQDODJH�LQIDQWV��%U�-�2EVWHW�*\QDHFRO��������������������.UHLWPDQ�1��7KH�FRDO�JDV�VWRU\��8.�VXLFLGH�UDWHV�������������%U�-�3UHYHQWLYH�6RF�0HG�����������������.UXHJHU�5)��&DVSL�$��0RIILWW�7(�3HUVRQDOLW\�WUDLWV�DUH�GLIIHUHQWLDOO\�OLQNHG�WR�PHQWDO�GLVRUGHUV��DPXOWLWUDLW�PXOWLGLDJQRVLV�VWXG\�RI�DQ�DGROHVFHQW�ELUWK�FRKRUW��-RXUQDO�RI�$EQRUPDO�3V\FKRORJ\�����������������.XSND�5:��1ROHQ�:$��%LSRODLUH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��,Q��-RQJ�$�GH��%ULQN�:�YDQ�GHQ��2UPHO�-��:LHUVPD�'�HGV����+DQGERHN�3V\FKLDWULVFKH�(SLGHPLRORJLH��0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�'H�7LMGVWURRP��������SS����������/DQJHODQG�:��+DUWJHUV�&��&KLOG�VH[XDO�DQG�SK\VLFDO�DEXVH�DQG�DOFRKROLVP��$�UHYLHZ��-RXUQDO�RI�6WXGLHVRQ�DOFRKRO�������������������/D]DUXV�56��&RSLQJ�WKHRU\�DQG�UHVHDUFK��SDVW��SUHVHQW��DQG�IXWXUH��3V\FKRVRP�0HG�������������������/D]DUXV�56��)RONPDQ�6��6WUHVV��DSSUDLVDO�DQG�FRSLQJ��1HZ�<RUN��6SULQJHU�������/HQVL�3��&RUUHGX�*��.XQRYDF�-/��&DVVDQR�*%��5DYDJOL�6��2EVHVVLYH�FRPSXOVLYH�GLVRUGHU��)DPLO\GHYHORSPHQWDO�KLVWRU\��V\PSWRPDWRORJ\��FRPRUELGLW\�DQG�FRXUVH�ZLWK�VSHFLDO�UHIHUHQFH�WRJHQGHU�UHODWHG�GLIIHUHQFHV��%U�-�3V\FKLDWU\��������������������/HZLV�*��$VVHVVLQJ�SV\FKLDWULF�GLVRUGHU�ZLWK�D�KXPDQ�LQWHUYLHZHU�RU�D�FRPSXWHU��-RXUQDO�RI(SLGHPLRORJ\�&RPPXQLW\�+HDOWK�������������������/HZLV�*��+DZWRQ�.��-RQHV�3��6WUDWHJLHV�IRU�SUHYHQWLQJ�VXLFLGH��%U�-�3V\FKLDWU\��������������������/HZLV�*��'DYLG�$��$QGUHDVVRQ�6��$OOHEHFN�3��6FKL]RSKUHQLD�DQG�FLW\�OLIH��/DQFHW��������������������/LQGVH\�7ZHHG�-��6FKRHQEDFK�9-��*HRUJH�/.��%OD]HU�'*��7KH�HIIHFWV�RI�FKLOGKRRG�SDUHQWDO�GHDWK�DQGGLYRUFH�RQ���PRQWK�KLVWRU\�RI�DQ[LHW\�GLVRUGHUV��%U�-�3V\FKLDWU\��������������������

Page 91: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

/LQV]HQ�'+��'LQJHPDQV�30��/HQLRU�0(��&DQQDELV�DEXVH�DQG�WKH�FRXUVH�RI�UHFHQW�RQVHW�VFKL]RSKUHQLFGLVRUGHUV��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������/LSRZVNL�=-��6RPDWL]DWLRQ��WKH�FRQFHSW�DQG�LWV�FOLQLFDO�DSSOLFDWLRQ��$P�-�3V\FKLDWU\���������������������/LYHVOH\�:-��-DQJ�./�9HUQRQ�3$��3KHQRW\SLF�DQG�JHQHWLF�VWUXFWXUH�RI�WUDLWV�GHOLQHDWLQJ�SHUVRQDOLW\GLVRUGHU��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������/RHEHU�5��)DUULQJWRQ�'3��6WRXWKDPPHU�/RHEHU��9DQ�.DPPHQ�:%��0XOWLSOH�ULVN�IDFWRUV�IRUPXOWLSUREOHP�ER\V��,Q��-HVVRU�5��(G����1HZ�SHUVSHFWLYHV�LQ�DGROHVFHQW�ULVN�EHKDYLRU��&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\�������0DJQXVVRQ�'��7KH�OLIHVSDQ�GHYHORSPHQW�RI�LQGLYLGXDOV��%HKDYLRUDO��QHXURELRORJLFDO�DQG�SV\FKRVRFLDOSHUVSHFWLYHV��$�V\QWKHVLV��&DPEULGJH��&DPEULGJH�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV�������0DLHU�:��/LFKWHUPDQQ�'��0LQJHV�-�HW�DO��&RQWLQXLW\�DQG�GLVFRQWLQXLW\�RI�DIIHFWLYH�GLVRUGHUV�DQGVFKL]RSKUHQLD��UHVXOWV�RI�D�FRQWUROOHG�IDPLO\�VWXG\��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������0DOPEHUJ�$��/HZLV�*��'DYLG�$��$OOHEHFN�3��3UHPRUELG�DGMXVWPHQW�DQG�SHUVRQDOLW\�LQ�SHRSOH�ZLWKVFKL]RSKUHQLD���%U�-�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������0DUFHOLV�0��1DYDUUR�0DWHX�)��0XUUD\�5��6HOWHQ�-�3��2V�-�YDQ��8UEDQL]DWLRQ�DQG�SV\FKRVLV��D�VWXG\�RI����������ELUWK�FRKRUWV�LQ�WKH�1HWKHUODQGV��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�������������������0DU]XN�30��/HRQ�$&��7DUGLII�.��0RUJDQ�(%��6WDMLF�0��0DQQ�--��7KH�HIIHFW�RI�DFFHVV�WR�OHWKDO�PHWKRGVRI�LQMXU\�RQ�VXLFLGH�UDWHV��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������0F&DXOH\�-��.HUQ�'(��.RORGQHU�.�HW�DO��&OLQLFDO�FKDUDFWHULVWLFV�RI�ZRPHQ�ZLWK�D�KLVWRU\�RI�FKLOGKRRGDEXVH��XQKHDOHG�ZRXQGV��-$0$����������������������0F*HH�/��1HZFRPE�0'��*HQHUDO�GHYLDQFH�V\QGURPH��H[SDQGHG�KLHUDUFKLFDO�HYDOXDWLRQV�DW�IRXU�DJHVIURP�HDUO\�DGROHVFHQFH�WR�DGXOWKRRG��-RXUQDO�RI�&RQVXOWLQJ�DQG�&OLQLFDO�3V\FKRORJ\�������������������0F*XIILQ�3��2ZHQ�0-��2¶'RQRYDQ�0&��6HPLQDUV�LQ�3V\FKLDWULF�*HQHWLFV��/RQGRQ��7KH�5R\DO�&ROOHJHRI�3V\FKLDWULVWV�������0HHKO�3(��7RZDUG�DQ�LQWHJUDWHG�WKHRU\�RI�VFKL]RWD[LD��VFKL]RW\S\�DQG�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��-�3HUV�'LVRUG��������������0HOW]HU�+��*LOO�%��3HWWLFUHZ�0��+LQGV�.��23&6�6XUYH\�RI�SV\FKLDWULF�PRUELGLW\�LQ�*UHDW�%ULWDLQ��5HSRUW,��7KH�SUHYDOHQFH�RI�SV\FKLDWULF�PRUELGLW\�DPRQJ�DGXOWV�OLYLQJ�LQ�SULYDWH�KRXVHKROGV��/RQGRQ�23&6�������0HQVLQN�&��6SUXLW�,3���UHG����-DDUERHN�YHUVODYLQJ������RYHU�JHEUXLN�HQ�]RUJ��+RXWHQ�'LHJHP��%RKQ6WDIOHX�9DQ�/RJKXP�������0HULNDQJDV�.5��6ZHQGVHQ�-'��*HQHWLF�HSLGHPLRORJ\�RI�SV\FKLDWULF�GLVRUGHUV��(SLGHPLRO�5HY������������������0HULNDQJDV�.5��0HKWD�5/��0ROQDU�%(�HW�DO��&RPRUELGLW\�RI�VXEVWDQFH�XVH�GLVRUGHUV�ZLWK�PRRG�DQGDQ[LHW\�GLVRUGHUV��5HVXOWV�RI�WKH�,QWHUQDWLRQDO�&RQVRUWLXP�LQ�3V\FKLDWULF�(SLGHPLRORJ\��$GGLFWLYH%HKDYLRUV�������������������0HULNDQJDV�.5��.XSIHU�'-��0RRG�GLVRUGHUV��JHQHWLF�DVSHFWV��,Q��.DSODQ�+,��6DGRFN�%-��HGV���&RPSUHKHQVLYH�WH[WERRN�RI�SV\FKLDWU\���WK�HG��%DOWLPRUH��0'��:LOOLDPV�DQG�:LONLQV��������SS�����������0HULNDQJDV�.5��5LVFK�1-��:HLVVPDQ�00��&R�PRUELGLW\�DQG�FR�WUDQVPLVVLRQ�RI�DOFRKROLVP��DQ[LHW\�DQGGHSUHVVLRQ��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�����������������0HUVFK�33$��0HHVWHUV�<��%HHUVPD�'*0��:LQWHUGHSUHVVLH��,Q��%RHU�-$�GHQ��2UPHO�-��3UDDJ�+0�YDQ�:HVWHQEHUJ�+*0��'¶KDHQHQ�+��HGV����+DQGERHN�VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ��0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�'H7LMGVWURRP��������SS����������0LHFK�5$��&DVSL�$��0RIILWW�7(��:ULJKW�%5(��6LOYD�3$��/RZ�VRFLRHFRQRPLF�VWDWXV�DQG�PHQWDO�GLVRUGHUV�$ ORQJLWXGLQDO�VWXG\�RI�VHOHFWLRQ�DQG�FDXVDWLRQ�GXULQJ�\RXQJ�DGXOWKRRG��$P�-�6RFLRORJ\���������������������0RIILWW�7(��&DVSL�$��'LFNVRQ�1��6LOYD�3��6WDQWRQ�:��&KLOGKRRG�RQVHW�YHUVXV�DGROHVFHQW�RQVHW�DQWLVRFLDOFRQGXFW�LQ�PDOHV��1DWXUDO�KLVWRU\�IURP�DJH���WR�����'HYHORSPHQW�DQG�3V\FKRSDWKRORJ\������������������0RVHU�.$��)R[�$-��-RQHV�'5��8QHPSOR\PHQW�DQG�PRUWDOLW\�LQ�WKH�23&6�ORQJLWXGLQDO�VWXG\��/DQFHW������L������������0XUSK\�*(��6XwFLGH�LQ�DOFRKROLVP��1HZ�<RUN��2[IRUG�8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV�������1HHOHPDQ�-��2OGHKLQNHO�$-��2UPHO�-��3RVLWLYH�OLIH�FKDQJH�DQG�UHPLVVLRQ�RI�FRPPRQ�PHQWDO�LOOQHVV��DFRPSHWLQJ�HQGSRLQWV�DSSURDFK��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\��VXEPLWWHG�

Page 92: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

1HHOHPDQ�-��:DW�DOOH�VSHFLDOLVPHQ�ELQGW��YDQ�FRPRUELGLWHLW�QDDU�JHQHULHNH�NZHWVEDDUKHLG��1HGHUODQGV7LMGVFKULIW�YRRU�*HQHHVNXQGH��VXEPLWWHG�1HHOHPDQ�-��5HJLRQDO�VXLFLGH�UDWHV�LQ�WKH�1HWKHUODQGV��GRHV�UHOLJLRQ�VWLOO�SOD\�D�UROH"�,QW�-�(SLGHPLRORJ\������������������1HHOHPDQ�-��:HVVHO\�6��&KDQJHV�LQ�FODVVLILFDWLRQ�RI�VXLFLGH�LQ�(QJODQG��:DOHV��WLPH�WUHQGV�DQGDVVRFLDWLRQV�ZLWK�FRURQHUV�SURIHVVLRQDO�EDFNJURXQG��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�������������������1HHOHPDQ�-��)DUUHOO�0��6XwFLGH�DQG�VXEVWDQFH�DEXVH��%U�-�3V\FKLDWU\��������������������1HHOHPDQ�-��7KH�VRFLDO�DQG�HSLGHPLRORJLFDO�FRQWH[W�RI�VXLFLGDO�EHKDYLRXU��3URHIVFKULIW��5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW*URQLQJHQ�������1HHOHPDQ�-��$�FRQWLQXXP�RI�SUHPDWXUH�GHDWK��PHWD�DQDO\VLV�RI�FRPSHWLQJ�PRUWDOLW\�LQ�WKH�SV\FKRVRFLDOO\YXOQHUDEOH��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\��VXEPLWWHG�1HHOHPDQ�-��:HVVHO\�6��:DGVZRUWK�0��3UHGLFWRUV�RI�VXLFLGH��DFFLGHQWDO�GHDWK�DQG�SUHPDWXUH�QDWXUDOGHDWK�LQ�D�JHQHUDO�SRSXODWLRQ�ELUWK�FRKRUW��/DQFHW������������������1HZPDQ�'/��0RIILW�7(��&DVSL�$��0DJGRO�/��6WDQWRQ�:5��6LOYD�3$��3V\FKLDWULF�GLVRUGHU�LQ�D�ELUWKFRKRUW�RI�\RXQJ�DGXOWV��SUHYDOHQFH��FRPRUELGLW\��FOLQLFDO�VLJQLILFDQFH�DQG�QHZ�FDVH�LQFLGHQFH�IURPDJHV����WR�����-RXUQDO�RI�&RQVXOWLQJ�DQG�&OLQLFDO�3V\FKRORJ\�������������������1,9(/��&RQWLQXH�0RUELGLWHLWV�UHJLVWUDWLH��8WUHFKW��1,9(/�������1ROHQ�+RHNVHPD�6��6H[�GLIIHUHQFHV�LQ�XQLSRODU�GHSUHVVLRQ��HYLGHQFH�DQG�WKHRU\��3V\FKRORJLFDO�%XOOHWLQ�������������������1RUWVWURP�7��$OFRKRO�DQG�VXLFLGH��D�FRPSDUDWLYH�DQDO\VLV�RI�)UDQFH�DQG�6ZHGHQ��$GGLFWLRQ��������������������2OGHKLQNHO�$-��2UPHO�-��1HHOHPDQ�-��7KH�HIIHFW�RI�SRVLWLYH�OLIH�FKDQJH�RQ�WLPH�WR�UHFRYHU\�IURPGHSUHVVLRQ��VRPH�SHRSOH�EHQHILW�PRUH�WKDQ�RWKHUV��-�$EQRUPDO�3V\FKRORJ\��VXEPLWWHG�2OGHKLQNHO�$-��*LHO�5��7LPH�WUHQGV�LQ�WKH�FDUH�EDVHG�LQFLGHQFH�RI�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��%U�-�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������2RUG�(-&*�YDQ�GHQ��9HUKXOVW�)&��%RRPVPD�',��$�JHQHWLF�VWXG\�RI�PDWHUQDO�DQG�SDWHUQDO�UDWLQJV�RISUREOHP�EHKDYLRUV�LQ�WKUHH�\HDU�ROG�WZLQV��-RXUQDO�RI�$EQRUPDO�3V\FKRORJ\��������������������2RUG�(-&*�YDQ�GHQ��9HUKXOVW�)&��%RRPVPD�',��$�VWXG\�RI�SUREOHP�EHKDYLRUV�LQ�����WR����\HDU�ROGELRORJLFDOO\�UHODWHG�DQG�XQUHODWHG�LQWHUQDWLRQDO�DGRSWHHV��%HKDYLRU�*HQHWLFV�������������������2UPHO�-��'HSUHVVLH��'H�URO�YDQ�OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ��SHUVRRQOLMNKHLG�HQ�HUIHOLMNKHLG��,Q��%RHU�-$�GHQ�2UPHO�-��3UDDJ�+0�YDQ��:HVWHQEHUJ�+*0��'¶KDHQHQ�+��HGV����+DQGERHN�VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ�0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�'H�7LMGVWURRP��������SS���������2UPHO�-��6XOOLYDQ�0��.HPSHQ�*,-0��5LMVGLMN�)9��6RQGHUHQ�(�YDQ��,PPHGLDWH�DQG�GHOD\HG�UHODWLRQVKLSVEHWZHHQ�$'/�GLVDELOLW\�DQG�GHSUHVVLYH�V\PSWRPV�LQ�ODWHU�OLIH��VXEPLWWHG�2UPHO�-��3ULPDLUH�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�YHHO�YRRUNRPHQGH��SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��KRH�PRJHOLMN�LV�KHWRQPRJHOLMNH"�(HQ�HSLGHPLRORJLVFKH�YHUNHQQLQJ��0DDQGEODG�*HHVWHOLMNH�9RONVJH]RQGKHLG���������������������2UPHO�-��6FKDXIHOL�:��6WDELOLW\�DQG�FKDQJH�RI�SV\FKRORJLFDO�GLVWUHVV�DQG�WKHLU�UHODWLRQVKLS�ZLWK�VHOI�HVWHHP�DQG�ORFXV�RI�FRQWURO��-RXUQDO�RI�3HUVRQDOLW\�DQG�6RFLDO�3V\FKRORJ\�������������������2UPHO�-��.HPSHQ�*,-0��'HHJ�'-+��%ULOPDQ�(,��6RQGHUHQ�(�YDQ��5HO\YHOG�-��)XQFWLRQLQJ��ZHOO�EHLQJDQG�KHDOWK�SHUFHSWLRQ�LQ�ODWH�PLGGOH�DJHG�DQG�ROGHU�SHRSOH��&RPSDULQJ�WKH�HIIHFWV�RI�GHSUHVVLYHV\PSWRPV�DQG�FKURQLF�PHGLFDO�FRQGLWLRQV���-RXUQDO�RI�WKH�$PHULFDQ�*HULDWULFV�6RFLHW\�����D������������2UPHO�-��9RQ.RUII�0��8VWXQ�7%��3LQL�6��.RUWHQ�$��2OGHKLQNHO�$-��&RPPRQ�PHQWDO�GLVRUGHUV�DQGGLVDELOLW\�DFURVV�FXOWXUHV��5HVXOWV�IURP�WKH�:+2�&ROODERUDWLYH�3ULPDU\�&DUH�6WXG\��-$0$���������������������2UPHO�-��6\WHPD�6��2OGHKLQNHO�$-��(SLGHPLRORJLVFKH�DVSHFWHQ�YDQ�DQJVW��,Q��%RHU�-$�GHQ��:HVWHQEHUJ+*0��HGV����/HHUERHN�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ��8WUHFKW��'H�7LMGVWURRP��������SS���������2UPHO�-��5LMVGLMN�)9��&RQWLQXLQJ�FKDQJH�LQ�QHXURWLFLVP�GXULQJ�DGXOWKRRG��6WUXFWXUDO�PRGHOOLQJ�RI�D����\HDU����ZDYH�FRPPXQLW\�VWXG\��3HUVRQDOLW\�DQG�,QGLYLGXDO�'LIIHUHQFHV��������������������2UPHO�-��-RQJ�$�GH��2Q�YXOQHUDELOLW\�WR�FRPPRQ�PHQWDO�GLVRUGHUV��$Q�HYLGHQFH�EDVHG�SOHD�IRU�DGHYHORSPHQWDO�SHUVSHFWLYH��,Q��7DQVHOOD�0��7KRUQLFURIW�*���HGV���&RPPRQ�PHQWDO�GLVRUGHUV�LQSULPDU\�FDUH��/RQGRQ��5RXWOHGJH��������������2UPHO�-��:RKOIDUWK�7'��+RZ�QHXURWLFLVP��ORQJ�WHUP�GLIILFXOWLHV��DQG�FKDQJHV�LQ�TXDOLW\�RI�OLIH�DIIHFWSV\FKRORJLFDO�GLVWUHVV��$�ORQJLWXGLQDO�DSSURDFK��-�3HUVRQDOLW\�6RFLDO�3V\FKRORJ\�������������������2UPHO��-��7LHPHQV�%*��2V�7:'3�YDQ��0HHU�.�YDQ�GHU��-HQQHU�-$��%ULQN��5+6�YDQ�GHQ��%HWHUHKHUNHQQLQJ�HQ�EHKDQGHOLQJ�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�HQ�VRPV�VQHOOHU�KHUVWHO�QD�QDVFKROLQJ�YDQ�KXLVDUWVHQ��1HG7LMGVFKU�*HQHHVNG�����E�����������������

Page 93: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

2UPHO�-��2OGHKLQNHO�$-��*ROGEHUJ�'3��+RGLDPRQW�33*��:LOPLQN�):��%ULGJHV�.��7KH�VWUXFWXUH�RIFRPPRQ�SV\FKLDWULF�V\PSWRPV��+RZ�PDQ\�GLPHQVLRQV�RI�QHXURVLV��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH������������������2V�-�YDQ��-RQHV�3��/HZLV�*��:DGVZRUWK�0��0XUUD\�5��'HYHORSPHQWDO�SUHFXUVRUV�RI�DIIHFWLYH�LOOQHVV�LQ�DJHQHUDO�SRSXODWLRQ�ELUWK�FRKRUW��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������2V�-�YDQ��&DVWOH�'��7DNHL�1��'HU�*��0XUUD\�5��6FKL]RSKUHQLD�LQ�HWKQLF�PLQRULWLHV��FODULILFDWLRQ�IURP�WKH�����FHQVXV��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�������������������2V�--�YDQ��0DUFHOLV�0��1DWXUH�HQ�QXUWXUH�LQ�GH�SV\FKLDWULH��JHQHWLVFKH�HSLGHPLRORJLH��,Q��-RQJ�$�GH�%ULQN�:�YDQ�GHQ��2UPHO�-��:LHUVPD�'��HGV����+DQGERHN�3V\FKLDWULVFKH�(SLGHPLRORJLH��0DDUVVHQ�(OVHYLHU�'H�7LMGVWURRP��������SS���������2WWPDQ�5��$Q�HSLGHPLRORJLFDO�DSSURDFK�WR�JHQH�HQYLURQPHQW�LQWHUDFWLRQ��*HQHWLF�(SLGHPLRO�����������������2XGHQ�$/�GHQ��'ULMNRQLQJHQ�&(��6SHH�YDQ�GHU�:HNNH�-��6LJPRQG�GH�%UXLQ�(0��9HUORRYH�9DQKRULFN63��>6HTXHODH�RI�SUHPDWXUH�ELUWK��VXEVWDQWLDO�PHGLFDO�FRQVXPSWLRQ�DQG�SK\VLFDO�OLPLWDWLRQ��VXUYH\DPRQJ�SDUHQWV�RI����\HDU�ROGV�@�1HG�7LMGVFKU�*HQHHVNG��������������������3HQQLQ[�%:-+��*HHUOLQJV�6:��'HHJ�'-��(LMN�-WK0�YDQ��7LOEXUJ�:�YDQ��%HHNPDQ�$7)��0LQRU�DQGPDMRU�GHSUHVVLRQ�DQG�WKH�ULVN�RI�GHDWK�LQ�ROGHU�SHUVRQV��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������3HUXJL�*��0XVHWWL�/��6LPRULQL�(��3LDJHQWLQL�)��&DVVDQR�*%��$NLVNDO�+6��*HQGHU�PHGLDWHG�FOLQLFDOIHDWXUHV�RI�GHSUHVVLYH�LOOQHVV��WKH�LPSRUWDQFH�RI�WHPSHUDPHQWDO�GLIIHUHQFHV��%U�-�3V\FKLDWU\���������������3KLOOLSV�'3��0RWRU�YHKLFOH�IDWDOLWLHV�LQFUHDVH�MXVW�DIWHU�SXEOLFL]HG�VXLFLGH�VWRULHV��6FLHQFH����������������3ODWW�6��%LOOH�%UDKH�8��.HUNKRI�$-)0��3DUDVXLFLGH�LQ�(XURSH��7KH�:+2�(852�PXOWLFHQWUH�VWXG\�RQSDUDVXLFLGH��,��,QWURGXFWLRQ�DQG�SUHOLPLQDU\�DQDO\VLV�IRU�������$FWD�3V\FKLDWU�6FDQG�����������������3ORPLQ�5��0F&OHDUQ��HGV����1DWXUH��QXUWXUH�DQG�SV\FKRSDWKRORJ\��:DVKLQJWRQ��'&��$PHULFDQ3V\FKRORJLFDO�$VVRFLDWLRQ�������3ORPLQ�5��*HQHWLF�LQIOXHQFH�DQG�FRJQLWLYH�DELOLWLHV��%HKDYLRUDO�DQG�%UDLQ�6FLHQFHV���������������3RSH�+*��,RQHVFX�3LRJJLD�0��<XUJHOXQ�7RGG�'��0LJUDWLRQ�DQG�PDQLF�GHSUHVVLYH�LOOQHVV��&RPS3V\FKLDWU\�������������������3ULFH�5$��.LGG�..��3DXOV�'/��*HUVKRQ�(6��3UXVRII�%$��:HLVVPDQ�00��*ROGLQ�/5��0XOWLSOH�WKUHVKROGPRGHOV�IRU�DIIHFWLYH�GLVRUGHUV��WKH�<DOH�1,0+�FROODERUDWLYH�IDPLO\�VWXG\��-RXUQDO�RI�3V\FKLDWULF5HVHDUFK�������������������3ULWFKDUG�&��6XwFLGH��XQHPSOR\PHQW�DQG�JHQGHU�YDULDWLRQV�LQ�WKH�:HVWHUQ�:RUOG�������������6RF3V\FKLDWU\�3V\FKLDWU�(SLGHPLRO�����������������3URVVHU�-��0F$UGOH�3��7KH�FKDQJLQJ�PHQWDO�KHDOWK�RI�FKLOGUHQ�DQG�DGROHVFHQWV��HYLGHQFH�IRU�DGHWHULRUDWLRQ"�3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH������������������5DELQRZLW]�-��%URPHW�(-��/DYHOOH�-��&DUOVRQ�*��.RYDV]QD\�%��6FKZDUW]�-(��3UHYDOHQFH�DQG�VHYHULW\�RIVXEVWDQFH�XVH�GLVRUGHUV�DQG�RQVHW�RI�SV\FKRVLV�LQ�ILUVW�DGPLVVLRQ�SV\FKRWLF�SDWLHQWV��3V\FKRORJLFDO0HGLFLQH���������������������5DLQH�$��%UHQQDQ�3��0HGQLFN�6$��%LUWK�FRPSOLFDWLRQV�FRPELQHG�ZLWK�HDUO\�PDWHUQDO�UHMHFWLRQ�DW�DJH��\HDU�SUHGLVSRVH�WR�YLROHQW�FULPH�DW�DJH����\HDUV��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������5DLQH�$��%UHQQDQ�3��0HGQLFN�6$��,QWHUDFWLRQ�EHWZHHQ�ELUWK�FRPSOLFDWLRQV�DQG�HDUO\�PDWHUQDO�UHMHFWLRQ�LQSUHGLVSRVLQJ�LQGLYLGXDOV�WR�DGXOW�YLROHQFH��VSHFLILFLW\�WR�VHULRXV��HDUO\�RQVHW�YLROHQFH��$P�-3V\FKLDWU\����������������������5DYHOOL�$��%LMO�59��=HVVHQ�*�YDQ��&RPRUELGLWHLW�YDQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�LQ�GH�1HGHUODQGVHEHYRONLQJ��UHVXOWDWHQ�YDQ�GH�1HWKHUODQGV�0HQWDO�KHDOWK�6XUYH\�DQG�,QFLGHQFH��6WXG\��1(0(6,6��7LMGVFKU�3V\FKLDWULH�������������������5LFK�&/��)RZOHU�5&��)RJDUW\�/$��<RXQJ�'��6DQ�'LHJR�6XwFLGH�6WXG\��,,,��5HODWLRQVKLSV�EHWZHHQGLDJQRVHV�DQG�VWUHVVRUV��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������5LGGHU�'�GH��'HSOD�0��6HYHUHQV�3��0DOVFK�0��%HOLHIV�RQ�FRSLQJ�ZLWK�LOOQHVV��D�FRQVXPHUV�SHUVSHFWLYH�6RF�6FL�0HG�������������������5XZDDUG�'��.UDPHUV�3*1��HLQGUHG����9RONVJH]RQGKHLG�7RHNRPVW�9HUNHQQLQJ�������'H�VRP�GHU�GHOHQ�0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�GH�7LMGVWURRP�������5RELQV�/1��5HJLHU�'$��HGV����3V\FKLDWULF�GLVRUGHUV�LQ�$PHULFD��7KH�(SLGHPLRORJLFDO�&DWFKPHQW�$UHD6WXG\��1HZ�<RUN��7KH�)UHH�3UHVV�������5RGJHUV�%��%HKDYLRXU�DQG�SHUVRQDOLW\�LQ�FKLOGKRRG�DV�SUHGLFWRUV�RI�DGXOW�SV\FKLDWULF�GLVRUGHU��-RXUQDO�RI&KLOG�3V\FKRORJ\�DQG�3V\FKLDWU\�������������������

Page 94: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

5RWKPDQ�.-��*UHHQODQG�6��0RGHUQ�HSLGHPLRORJ\���3KLOLGHOSKLD��/LSSLQFRWW�5DYHQ�������5R\�$��6HJDO�1/��6DUFKLDSRQH�0��$WWHPSWHG�VXLFLGH�DPRQJ�OLYLQJ�FR�WZLQV�RI�WZLQ�VXLFLGH�YLFWLPV���$P- 3V\FKLDWU\����������������������5XWWHU�0��'XQQ�-��3ORPLQ�5�HW�DO��,QWHJUDWLQJ�QDWXUH�DQG�QXUWXUH��,PSOLFDWLRQV�RI�SHUVRQ�HQYLURQPHQWFRUUHODWLRQV�DQG�LQWHUDFWLRQV�IRU�GHYHORSPHQWDO�SV\FKRSDWKRORJ\��'HYHORSPHQW�DQG�3V\FKRSDWKRORJ\�����������������5XWWHU�0��0DFGRQDOG�+��/H�&RXWHXU�$�HW�DO��*HQHWLF�IDFWRUV�LQ�FKLOG�SV\FKLDWULF�GLVRUGHUV�,,��HPSLULFDOILQGLQJV��-�&KLOG�3V\FKRO�3V\FKLDWU\�����������������5XWWHU�0��7UDQVLWLRQV�DQG�WXUQLQJ�SRLQWV�LQ�GHYHORSPHQWDO�SV\FKRSDWKRORJ\��DV�DSSOLHG�WR�WKH�DJH�VSDQEHWZHHQ�FKLOGKRRG�DQG�PLG�DGXOWKRRG��,QWHUQDWLRQDO�-RXUQDO�RI�%HKDYLRU�'HYHORSPHQW������������������5XWWHU�0��*LOOHU�+��+DJHOO�$��$QWLVRFLDO�EHKDYLRU�E\�\RXQJ�SHRSOH��&DPEULGJH��8QLYHUVLW\�3UHVV�������5XWWHU�0��6PLWK�'-��3V\FKRVRFLDO�GLVRUGHUV�LQ�\RXQJ�SHRSOH��WLPH�WUHQGV�DQG�WKHLU�FDXVHV��.ULHJHU��1HZ<RUN�������5XWWHU�0��3ORPLQ�5��2SSRUWXQLWLHV�IRU�SV\FKLDWU\�IURP�JHQHWLF�ILQGLQJV��%U�-�3V\FKLDWU\��������������������6DOPRQ�3��&DOGHUEDQN�6��7KH�UHODWLRQVKLS�RI�FKLOGKRRG�SK\VLFDO�DQG�VH[XDO�DEXVH�WR�DGXOW�LOOQHVVEHKDYLRXU��-RXUQDO�RI�3V\FKRVRPDWLF�5HVHDUFK�������������������6DXGLQR�.-��0F&OHDUQ�*(��3HGHUVHQ�1/��&DQ�SHUVRQDOLW\�H[SODLQ�JHQHWLF�LQIOXHQFHV�RQ�OLIH�HYHQWV�-RXUQDO�RI�3HUVRQDOLW\�DQG�6RFLDO�3V\FKRORJ\�������������������6FKPLGWNH�$��+DHIQHU�+��7KH�:HUWKHU�HIIHFW�DIWHU�WHOHYLVLRQ�ILOPV��QHZ�HYLGHQFH�IRU�DQ�ROG�K\SRWKHVLV�3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�������������������6FKXFNLW�0$��)DPLOLDO�DOFRKROLVP��,Q��:LGLJHU�7$��)UDQFLV�$-��3LQFXV�+$��HGV����'60�,9�VRXUFHERRNYROXPH�,��:DVKLQJWRQ�'&��$PHULFDQ�3V\FKLDWULF�$VVRFLDWLRQ�������6FRWW�-��&KURQLF�GHSUHVVLRQ��%U�-�3V\FKLDWU\��������������������6HOWHQ�-�3��6ODHWV�-3-��.DKQ�56��6FKL]RSKUHQLD�LQ�6XULQDPHVH�DQG�'XWFK�$QWLOOHDQ�LPPLJUDQWV�WR�WKH1HWKHUODQGV��HYLGHQFH�RI�DQ�LQFUHDVHG�LQFLGHQFH��3V\FKRORJLFDO�0HGLFLQH�������������������6KXOPDQ�.,��7RKHQ�0��.XWFKHU�63��0RRG�GLVRUGHUV�DFURVV�WKH�OLIH�VSDQ��1HZ�<RUN��:LOH\�������6LOEHUHLVHQ�5.��5RELQV�/��5XWWHU�0��6HFXODU�WUHQGV�LQ�VXEVWDQFH�DEXVH��FRQFHSWV�DQG�GDWD�RQ�WKH�LPSDFWRI�VRFLDO�FKDQJH�RQ�DOFRKRO�DQG�GUXJ�DEXVH��,Q��5XWWHU�0��6PLWK�'��HGV����3V\FKRVRFLDO�GLVRUGHUV�LQ\RXQJ�SHRSOH��WLPH�WUHQGV�DQG�WKHLU�FDXVHV��&KLFKHVWHU��:LOH\��6RQV��������SS����������6NRRJ�*��6NRRJ�,��$����\HDU�IROORZ�XS�RI�SDWLHQWV�ZLWK�REVHVVLYH�FRPSXOVLYH�GLVRUGHU��$UFK�*HQ3V\FKLDWU\�������������������6SHFNHQV�$(0��&RJQLWLYH�EHKDYLRXUDO�WKHUDS\�IRU�XQH[SODLQHG�SK\VLFDO�V\PSWRPV��3URHIVFKULIW5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW�/HLGHQ�������6SUXLW�,3��=ZDUW�:0�GH���(SLGHPLRORJLH�YDQ�DOFRKRO��GUXJVJHEUXLN�HQ�JRNNHQ��,Q��6SUXLW�,3��HG���-DDUERHN�9HUVODYLQJ�������RYHU�JHEUXLN�HQ�]RUJ��+RXWHQ��%RKQ�6WDIOHX�9DQ�/RFKXP�������6WHLQ�0%��:DONHU�-5��+RUQ�$/��)DUGH�5��)XOO�DQG�SDUWLDO�376'��ILQGLQJV�IURP�D�FRPPXQLW\�VXUYH\��$P- 3V\FKLDWU\����������������������6XOOLYDQ�3)��.HQGOHU�.6��*HQHWLF�HSLGHPLRORJ\�RI�QHXURWLF�GLVRUGHUV��&XUUHQW�2SLQLRQ�LQ�3V\FKLDWU\������������������6\WHPD�6���.RRSPDQV�3&��3V\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�LQ�GH�YROZDVVHQ�EHYRONLQJ��HHQ�YHUNHQQLQJ�YDQRPYDQJ��JHYROJHQ�HQ�NRVWHQ��'HQ�+DDJ���6GX�XLWJHYHULM�������7LHPHQV�%*��0DQDJHPHQW�RI�PHQWDO�KHDOWK�SUREOHPV�LQ�SULPDU\�FDUH��7KH�GRFWRU��WKH�SDWLHQW��DQG�WKHPHGLFDO�PRGHO��3URHIVFKULIW�5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW�*URQLQJHQ�������7LOEXUJ�:�YDQ��%HHNPDQ�$7)��$IIHFWLHYH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�ELM�RXGHUHQ��,Q��%RHU�-$�GHQ��2UPHO�-��3UDDJ�+0YDQ��:HVWHQEHUJ�+*0��'¶KDHQHQ�+��HGV����+DQGERHN�VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ��0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�'H7LMGVWURRP��������SS��������7RKHQ�0��*RRGZLQ�).��(SLGHPLRORJ\�RI�ELSRODU�GLVRUGHU��,Q��7VXDQJ��0�7���7RKHQ��0���=DKQHU��*(3�HGV����7H[WERRN�LQ�SV\FKLDWULF�HSLGHPLRORJ\��1HZ�<RUN��-�:LOH\�DQG�6RQV�LQF���������SS����������7RUJHUVHQ�6��*HQHWLF�IDFWRUV�LQ�DQ[LHW\�GLVRUGHUV��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDWU\���������������������7RUUH\�()��%RZOHU�$(��&ODUN�5��8UEDQ�ELUWK�DQG�UHVLGHQFH�DV�ULVN�IDFWRUV�IRU�SV\FKRVHV��DQ�DQDO\VLV�RQ�����GDWD��6FKL]RSKUHQLD�5HVHDUFK�������������������7VXDQJ�07��/\RQV�0-��(LVHQ�6$�HW�DO��*HQHWLF�LQIOXHQFHV�RQ�'60�,,,�5�GUXJ�DEXVH�DQG�GHSHQGHQF\��DVWXG\�RI������WZLQ�SDLUV��$P�-RXUQDO�RI�0HGLFDO�*HQHWLFV�������������������7\UHU�3��6WHLQEHUJ�'��0RGHOV�IRU�PHQWDO�GLVRUGHU��&RQFHSWXDO�PRGHOV�LQ�SV\FKLDWU\���QG�HGLWLRQ�&KLFKHVWHU��-�:LOH\��6RQV�������

Page 95: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� �����SDJ�����YDQ����

9HUGRX[�+��*HGGHV�-5��3V\FK�05&��2EVWHWULF�FRPSOLFDWLRQV�DQG�DJH�DW�RQVHW�LQ�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��DQLQWHUQDWLRQDO�FROODERUDWLYH�PHWD�DQDO\VLV�RI�LQGLYLGXDO�SDWLHQW�GDWD��$PHULFDQ�-RXUQDO�RI�3V\FKLDWU\���������������������9HUKRHYHQ�:0$��7XLQLHU�6��1HXURWUDQVPLWWHUV��KRUPRQHQ�HQ�GHSUHVVLH��,Q��%RHU�-$�GHQ��2UPHO�-��3UDDJ+0�YDQ��:HVWHQEHUJ�+*0��'¶KDHQHQ�+��HGV����+DQGERHN�VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ��0DDUVVHQ�(OVHYLHU�'H�7LMGVWURRP��������SS����������9HUKXOVW�)&��.RRW�+0��&KLOG�SV\FKLDWULF�HSLGHPLRORJ\��&RQFHSWV��PHWKRGV�DQG�ILQGLQJV��1HZEXU\�3DUN�6DJH�3XEOLFDWLRQV�������9HUKXOVW�)&��(QGH�-�YDQ�GHU��5LHWEHUJHQ�$�7HQ�\HDU�WLPH�WUHQGV�RI�SV\FKRSDWKRORJ\�LQ�'XWFK�FKLOGUHQDQG�DGROHVFHQWV��QR�HYLGHQFH�IRU�VWURQJ�WUHQGV��$FWD�3V\FKLDWULFD�6FDQGLQDYLFD����������������9HUKXOVW�)&��.LQGHU��HQ�MHXJGSV\FKLDWULH��,Q��-RQJ�$�GH��%ULQN�:�YDQ�GHQ��2UPHO�-��:LHUVPD�'����HGV���+DQGERHN�3V\FKLDWULVFKH�(SLGHPLRORJLH��0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�'H�7LMGVWURRP��������SS����������9HUVOXLV�GHQ�%LHPDQ�+-0��,QWHUODQGHOLMN�JHDGRSWHHUGHQ�LQ�GH�DGROHVFHQWLH��9HUYROJRQGHU]RHN�QDDUJHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�HQ�YDDUGLJKHGHQ��3URHIVFKULIW��(UDVPXV�8QLYHUVLWHLW�5RWWHUGDP�������9RQN�5��:HWHULQJ�%-0�YDQ�GH��1LHUPHLMHU�0)��6WDWH�RI�WKH�DUW��'H�HUIHOLMNKHLG�YDQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKHDDQGRHQLQJHQ��5HFHQWH�RQWZLNNHOLQJHQ�GHHO�,,��EHYLQGLQJHQ�ELM�VFKL]RIUHQLH��VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQHQ�GH�]LHNWH�YDQ�$O]KHLPHU��7LMGVFKULIW�YRRU�3V\FKLDWULH�����������������:HLVVPDQ�00��%UXFH�0/��/HDI�3-��)ORULR�/3��+RO]HU�&��$IIHFWLYH�GLVRUGHUV��,Q��5RELQV�/��5HJLHU�'�HGV����3V\FKLDWULF�GLVRUGHUV�LQ�$PHULFD��1HZ�<RUN��)UHH�3UHVV��������SS��������:HLVVPDQ�00��%ODQG�5��-R\FH�35��1HZPDQ�6��:HOOV�-(��:LWWFKHQ�+8��6H[�GLIIHUHQFHV�LQ�UDWHV�RIGHSUHVVLRQ��FURVV�QDWLRQDO�SHUVSHFWLYHV��-�$IIHFW�'LVRUG�����������������:HVW�'�YDQ��0DHV�0��3V\FKR�LPPXQRORJLH�YDQ�DIIHFWLHYH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��,Q��%RHU�-$�GHQ��2UPHO�-��3UDDJ+0�YDQ��:HVWHQEHUJ�+*0��'¶KDHQHQ�+��HGV����+DQGERHN�VWHPPLQJVVWRRUQLVVHQ��0DDUVVHQ�(OVHYLHU�'H�7LMGVWURRP��������SS����������:LHUVPD�'��*LHO�5��-RQJ�$�GH��6DXHU�+&��6ORRII�&-��+HW�VRFLDOH�SURILHO�HQ�KHW�YHUORRS�YDQ�IXQFWLRQHOHSV\FKRVHQ��7LMGVFKULIW�YRRU�3V\FKLDWULH�������������������:LHUVPD�'��-RQJ�$�GH��6FKL]RIUHQLH�HQ�DDQYHUZDQWH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��,Q��'H�-RQJ�$��%ULQN�:�YDQ�GHQ��2UPHO-��:LHUVPD�'��HGV����+DQGERHN�3V\FKLDWULVFKH�(SLGHPLRORJLH��0DDUVVHQ��(OVHYLHU�GH�7LMGVWURRP�������SS����������:LHUVPD�'��*LHO�5���-RQJ�$�GH��6ORRII�&-���6RFLDO�FODVV�DQG�VFKL]RSKUHQLD�LQ�D�'XWFK�FRKRUW���3V\FKRO0HGLFLQH������������������:LOOLJH�*�YDQ�GH��2UPHO�-��*LHO�5��(WLRORJLVFKH�EHWHNHQLV�YDQ�LQJULMSHQGH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�HQ�ODQJGXULJHPRHLOLMNKHGHQ�YRRU�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�HQ�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ��HHQ�QDGHUH�XLWZHUNLQJ��7LMGVFKULIWYRRU�3V\FKLDWULH�������������������:LWWFKHQ�+8��1DWXUDO�FRXUVH�DQG�VSRQWDQHRXV�UHPLVVLRQV�RI�XQWUHDWHG�DQ[LHW\�GLVRUGHUV��UHVXOWV�RI�WKH0XQLFK�)ROORZ�XS�VWXG\��0)6���,Q��+DQG�,��:LWWFKHQ�+8��HGV���3DQLF�DQG�SKRELDV�����WUHDWPHQW�DQGYDULDEOHV�DIIHFWLQJ�FRXUVH�DQG�RXWFRPH��1HZ�<RUN��6SULQJHU�9HUODJ��������SS�������:+2��+HDOWK�6WDWLVWLFDO�'DWD�&ROOHFWLRQV��*HQHYD��:RUOG�+HDOWK�2UJDQL]DWLRQ�������=XFNHU�5$��)LW]JHUDOG�+(��0RVHV�+'��(PHUJHQFH�RI�DOFRKRO�SUREOHPV�DQG�WKH�VHYHUDO�DOFRKROLVPV��$GHYHORSPHQWDO�SHUVSHFWLYH�RQ�HWLRORJ\�WKHRU\�DQG�OLIH�FRXUVH�WUDMHFWRU\��,Q��&LFFKHWWL�'��&RKHQ�'-��HGV����'HYHORSPHQWDO�SV\FKRSDWKRORJ\��YRO����1HZ�<RUN��-�:LOH\��6RQV��������SS����������

Page 96: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

Page 97: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ�����YDQ����

'HHO�%���+HW�HIIHFW�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ��SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG

3��&XLMSHUV��$��YDQ�*DJHOGRQN��&�&�(��2YHUWRRP7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW

Page 98: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ�����YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

� ,QOHLGLQJ,V� KHW� PRJHOLMN� RP� PHW� EHKXOS� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� HQSUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�NODFKWHQ�WH�EHwQYORHGHQ"�'H]H�YUDDJ�VWDDW�LQGH]H� ELMGUDJH� FHQWUDDO�� 9RRU� HHQ� VHOHFWLH� YDQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� �ZDDU� YROGRHQGH� HIIHFW�RQGHU]RHN�YRRU�EHVFKLNEDDU�LV��]DO�PHW�EHKXOS�YDQ�HHQ�PHWD�DQDO\VH�ZRUGHQ�QDJHJDDQRI�GH�SV\FKLVFKH�FRQVHTXHQWLHV�PHW�EHKXOS�YDQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV�EHwQYORHG�NXQQHQ�ZRUGHQ�'H]H�EHQDGHULQJ�KHHIW�YDQZHJH�KHW�EHSHUNWH�DDQWDO�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�GDW�ZH�RQGHU]RHNHQHHQ� H[SORUDWLHI� NDUDNWHU�� +HW� LV� RRN� QLHW� GH� EHGRHOLQJ� RP� KHW� JHKHOH� YHOG� YDQ� GHSUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�NODFKWHQ�WH�EHVWULMNHQ��9RRU�HHQ�GHHO�QHPHQ�GHSUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YRRU� SV\FKLVFKH� JH]RQGKHLG� DOV� XLWJDQJVSXQW�YRRU� HHQ� DQGHU� GHHO� ]LMQ� ]H� JHULFKW� RS� �VHFXQGDLUH� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ�� GH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQNODFKWHQ� ]HOI�� 2RN� EHSHUNHQ� ZH� RQV� WRW� JHUDQGRPLVHHUG� HQ� JHFRQWUROHHUGHIIHFWRQGHU]RHN��HQ�WRW�LQWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS�YROZDVVHQHQ�,Q�KRRIGVWXN���ZRUGW� HHQ�GHILQLWLH�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH� JHSUHVHQWHHUG� HQ�ZRUGW� DDQJHYHQZHONH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� RQGHU]RFKW� ZRUGHQ�� 9HUGHU� ZRUGW� GH� YUDDJVWHOOLQJ� QDGHUXLWJHZHUNW� HQ� ZRUGW� GH� JHEUXLNWH� PHWKRGH�� HHQ� VWDWLVWLVFKH� PHWD�DQDO\VH�� QDGHUXLWHHQJH]HW��,Q�GH�KRRIGVWXNNHQ���HQ���ZRUGW�LQJHJDDQ�RS�GH�UHVXOWDWHQ�YDQ�GH�DQDO\VHV�,Q�KRRIGVWXN���WHQVORWWH�ZRUGHQ�FRQFOXVLHV�JHWURNNHQ�HQ�YLQGW�GLVFXVVLH�SODDWV�RYHU�GHUHVXOWDWHQ�9DQZHJH�GLW�H[SORUDWLHYH�NDUDNWHU�HQ�GH�EHSHUNLQJHQ�LQ�GH�RS]HW�]XOOHQ�ZH�GH�YUDDJQDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�NODFKWHQ�RRNSUREHUHQ� WH� EHDQWZRRUGHQ� GRRU� HHUGHUH� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� RYHU]LFKWVVWXGLHV� HQ� PHWD�DQDO\VHV�VDPHQ�WH�YDWWHQ�LQ�HHQ�DDQWDO�NDGHUWHNVWHQ��]LH KRRIGVWXN ��� +HW�JDDW�GDDUELMRP�HHQ�V\VWHPDWLVFKH�RYHU]LFKWVVWXGLH�QDDU�GH�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�LQKHW� DOJHPHHQ� �9DQ� *DJHOGRQN� � 5LJWHU�� ������� HHQ� PHWD�DQDO\VH� YDQ� VHFXQGDLUHSUHYHQWLH� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH� ELM� RXGHUHQ� �&XLMSHUV�� ������� � HHQ� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� RYHU]LFKWV�VWXGLH�YDQ�YHUVODYLQJVSUHYHQWLH��9DQ�*DJHOGRQN��&XLMSHUV��������HQ�HHQ�PHWD�DQDO\VHYDQ� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ� ELM� NLQGHUHQ� HQ� MHXJGLJHQ� �&XLMSHUV�� 6WDP�� LQYRRUEHUHLGLQJ��2P UXLPWH� WH� VSDUHQ� ]LMQ� ELM� GH� WDEHOOHQ� QLHW� DOOH� DINRUWLQJHQ� YDQ� GH� JHQRHPGHPHHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ� XLWJHVFKUHYHQ�� GH� JHwQWHUHVVHHUGH� OH]HU� ZRUGW� YHUZH]HQ� QDDU� GHRULJLQHOH�DUWLNHOHQ�

Page 99: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ�����YDQ����

� 3UREOHHPVWHOOLQJ�HQ�PHWKRGH���� 'HILQLWLH�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH9RRU�KHW�EHDQWZRRUGHQ�YDQ�RQ]H�RQGHU]RHNVYUDJHQ�LV�KHW�DOOHUHHUVW�YDQ�EHODQJ�RP�HHQDIEDNHQLQJ� WH� JHYHQ� YDQ� ZDW� ZH� RQGHU� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� YHUVWDDQ�� (U� EHVWDDQYHUVFKLOOHQGH� GHILQLWLHV� YDQ� SUHYHQWLH�� ,Q� 1HGHUODQG� LV� KHW� JHEUXLNHOLMN� RP� HHQRQGHUVFKHLG� WH� PDNHQ� WXVVHQ� SULPDLUH� SUHYHQWLH� �KHW� YRRUNRPHQ� YDQ� ]LHNWH� GRRU� KHWZHJQHPHQ� YDQ� GH� RRU]DNHQ�� HQ� VHFXQGDLUH� SUHYHQWLH� �YURHJWLMGLJH� RSVSRULQJ� HQEHKDQGHOLQJ�� �5XZDDUG��.UDPHUV�� ������� %LM� SULPDLUH� SUHYHQWLH� ULFKW� PHQ� ]LFK� RSSRSXODWLHV�GLH�QRJ�JHHQ�DDQGRHQLQJ�KHEEHQ��ELM�VHFXQGDLUH�SUHYHQWLH�RS�SRSXODWLHV�GLHDO�ZHO�HHQ�DDQGRHQLQJ�KHEEHQ��PDDU�ZDDUELM�GH�GLDJQRVH�QRJ�QLHW�LV�YDVWJHVWHOG�9RRU� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHULFKW� RS� SV\FKLVFKH� SUREOHPHQ� LV� UHFHQW� HHQDDQJHVFKHUSWH� GHILQLWLH� RQWZLNNHOG�� GLH�ZLM� LQ� GLW� UDSSRUW� ]XOOHQ� KDQWHUHQ� �0UD]HN�+DJJHUW\�� ������ 1,0+�� ������� ,Q� KHW� QLHXZ� RQWZLNNHOGH� FODVVLILFDWLHV\VWHHP� YDQLQWHUYHQWLHV�ZRUGHQ�YLHU�YRUPHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�RQGHUVFKHLGHQ��� 8QLYHUVHOH�SUHYHQWLH� LV JHULFKW� RS�GH� DOJHPHQH�EHYRONLQJ�RI� HHQ�GHHOSRSXODWLH� GLHQLHW� JHwGHQWLILFHHUG� LV� RS� EDVLV� YDQ� HHQ� LQGLYLGXHOH� ULVLFRIDFWRU� �ELMYRRUEHHOGPDVVDPHGLDOH� FDPSDJQHV� JHULFKW� RS� GH� JHKHOH� EHYRONLQJ� RI� VFKRROJHULFKWHLQWHUYHQWLHV��ZDDUELM�DOOH�OHHUOLQJHQ��RQJHDFKW�KXQ�ULVLFRVWDWXV�EHQDGHUG�ZRUGHQ���� 6HOHFWLHYH� SUHYHQWLH� LV� JHULFKW� RS� LQGLYLGXHQ� RI� HHQ� VXEJURHS� YDQ� GH� SRSXODWLHZDDUELM�KHW� ULVLFR�RS�KHW�RQWZLNNHOHQ�YDQ�HHQ�**=�SUREOHPDWLHN�VLJQLILFDQW�JURWHUGDQ�JHPLGGHOG�LV��ELMYRRUEHHOG�PHQVHQ�GLH�UHFHQW�HHQ�LQJULMSHQGH�OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVKHEEHQ�PHHJHPDDNW�RI�EORRW�VWDDQ�DDQ�HHQ�FKURQLVFKH�VWUHVVRU�]RDOV�HFKWVFKHLGLQJ�URXZ��]RUJHQ�YRRU�HHQ�]LHN�IDPLOLHOLG��ZHUNHORRVKHLG���� *HwQGLFHHUGH� SUHYHQWLH� LV� JHULFKW� RS� LQGLYLGXHQ� GLH� QLHW� YROGRHQ� DDQ� GH� '60�,9FULWHULD� YRRU� HHQ� DDQGRHQLQJ��PDDU� GLH�ZHO� UHHGV� EHSHUNWH� V\PSWRPHQ� KHEEHQ� GLHYRRUDIJDDQ�DDQ�GH�DDQGRHQLQJ��RI�ZHO�ELRORJLVFKH�NHQPHUNHQ�KHEEHQ�GLH�GXLGHQ�RSHHQ�SUHGLVSRVLWLH�YRRU�HHQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�DDQGRHQLQJ��:DDU�ELM�VHOHFWLHYH�SUHYHQWLHQRJ�JHHQ�SUREOHPHQ�DDQZH]LJ�KRHYHQ� WH�]LMQ�� LV�GDW�ELM�JHwQGLFHHUGH�SUHYHQWLH�ZHOKHW�JHYDO����=RUJJHULFKWH� SUHYHQWLH� LV� JHULFKW� RS� PHQVHQ� GLH� HHQ� DDQGRHQLQJ� KHEEHQ� YROJHQV'60�,9�FULWHULD��3UHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHULFKW� RS�GH]H� JURHSHQ� ]LMQ� JHULFKW� RSWHUXJYDOSUHYHQWLH�� KHW� YRRUNyPHQ� YDQ� FRPRUELGLWHLW� HQ� KHW� YHUPLQGHUHQ� YDQ� GHFRQVHTXHQWLHV� YDQ� GH� SV\FKLVFKH� DDQGRHQLQJHQ� YRRU� PHQVHQ� LQ� GH� GLUHFWHRPJHYLQJ�,Q� 1HGHUODQG� ZRUGHQ� RRN� YHHO� DFWLYLWHLWHQ� GLH� LQ� KHW� QLHXZH� FODVVLILFDWLHV\VWHHPJHNHQPHUNW�]LMQ�DOV�FDVH�ILQGLQJ�HQ�GLH�JHULFKW�]LMQ�RS�YURHJVLJQDOHULQJ�HQ��LQWHUYHQWLHDOV� SUHYHQWLHI� EHVWHPSHOG�� *URIZHJ� NDQ� PHQ� VWHOOHQ� GDW� GH� HHUVWH� WZHH� YRUPHQ� YDQSUHYHQWLH� RYHUHHQNRPHQ� PHW� SULPDLUH� SUHYHQWLH� HQ� GH� ODDWVWH� WZHH� PHW� VHFXQGDLUHSUHYHQWLH��KRHZHO�]RUJJHULFKWH�SUHYHQWLH�RRN�RQGHUGHOHQ�RPYDW�GLH�GRRU�VRPPLJHQ�QLHWDOV� SUHYHQWLH� �KRRJVWHQV� DOV� WHUWLDLUH� SUHYHQWLH�� ZRUGHQ� DDQJHGXLG� �]RDOV� KHWYHUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�FRQVHTXHQWLHV�YDQ�DDQGRHQLQJHQ�YRRU�GH�RPJHYLQJ��'H]H� GHILQLWLH� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� LV� VWHUN� JHULFKW� RS� KHW� YRRUNyPHQ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� 'H� PHHVWH� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� ZDDU� RQGHU]RHN� QDDU� LVYHUULFKW� ]LMQ� JHULFKW� RS� KHW� EHwQYORHGHQ� YDQ� SUHGLFWRUHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� JH]RQGKHLG

Page 100: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

�]RDOV�KHW�YHUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�JHYROJHQ�YDQ� LQJULMSHQGH� OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�YRRU�GHJHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG��HQ�KHW�YHUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�NODFKWHQ��(U� LV�QDXZHOLMNVRQGHU]RHN�EHVFKLNEDDU�GDW�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQSV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� RQGHU]RHNW�� ,Q� GH]H� ELMGUDJH� ]XOOHQ� ZH� RQV� GDDURP� YRRUDOFRQFHQWUHUHQ�RS�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�SUHGLFWRUHQ�HQ�RS�SV\FKLVFKH�NODFKWHQ�+HW�EHwQYORHGHQ�YDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HQ�HIIHFWHQ�RS�SV\FKLVFKH�NODFKWHQ�EHVFKRXZHQ�ZHDOV�LQWHUPHGLDLUH�GRHOHQ�ELM�KHW�UHDOLVHUHQ�YDQ�HIIHFWHQ�RS�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�

���� .HX]H�YDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ2P� QD� WH� NXQQHQ� JDDQ� RI�PHW� EHKXOS� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� HQSUHYDOHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�NODFKWHQ�EHwQYORHG�NXQQHQ�ZRUGHQ��]XOOHQ�ZHHHQ�NHX]H�PRHWHQ�PDNHQ�ZHONH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�QDGHU�RQGHU�GH�ORHS�ZRUGHQ�JHQRPHQ�:H� EHSHUNHQ� RQV� LQ� GH]H� VWXGLH� WRW� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� JH]RQGKHLG� ELMYROZDVVHQHQ��:H�KHEEHQ�GDDUYRRU�JHNR]HQ�RPGDW�KHW�JHKHOH�YHOG� �LQFOXVLHI�NLQGHUHQHQ�MHXJGLJHQ��WH�RPYDQJULMN�HQ�WH�KHWHURJHHQ�LV��:H�KHEEHQ�YHUGHU�YRRU�KHW�YHOG�YDQ�GHSUHYHQWLHYH� YROZDVVHQHQ]RUJ� JHNR]HQ� RPGDW� YHHO� RQGHU]RHN� QDDU� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� ELMYROZDVVHQHQ� LV� XLWJHYRHUG� HQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� ]LFK� YDDN� H[SOLFLHW� RS� GHUJHOLMNHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�ULFKWHQ�(U ]LMQ� YHUVFKLOOHQGH� PRGHOOHQ�� GHILQLWLHV� HQ� LQGHOLQJHQ� YDQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG�EHVFKLNEDDU�� ,Q�GH]H�ELMGUDJH�]XOOHQ�ZH�RQV� ULFKWHQ�RS� HQNHOHEHODQJULMNH�FDWHJRULHsQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ��:H�JDDQ�GDDUELM�XLW�YDQ�KHW�G\QDPLVFKH�VWUHVV�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO��]RDOV�JHKDQWHHUG� LQ�GH�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�2UPHO� HW� DO�� LQ�GLW� UDSSRUW�'LW LV�HHQ�XLWEUHLGLQJ�YDQ�KHW�VWUHVVWKHRUHWLVFKH�PRGHO��]RDOV�EHVFKUHYHQ�GRRU�GH�5LGGHU��������=RDOV� LQ�GH�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�2UPHO�HW�DO��QDDU�YRUHQ� LV�JHNRPHQ�� LV�KHW� VFDOD�DDQGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�]HHU�XLWJHEUHLG��9DQZHJH�GH�EHSHUNWH�RS]HW�YDQ�GH]H� VWXGLH� LV�KHW�QLHWPRJHOLMN�RS�DOOH�JHQRHPGH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�LQ�WH�JDDQ�,Q� KHW� VWUHVV�NZHWVEDDUKHLGVPRGHO�ZRUGW� HUYDQ� XLW� JHJDDQ� GDW� LHPDQG� YRRUWGXUHQGEH]LJ� LV� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� LQ� RI� RP� KHP� KHHQ� WH� WD[HUHQ� RS� JHYROJHQ� YRRU� KHW� HLJHQZHOEHYLQGHQ�� %LM� HHQ� EHGUHLJHQGH� JHEHXUWHQLV� RQGHUQHHPW� GH� SHUVRRQ� HHQ� µFRSLQJ¶�DFWLH�RP�GH�EHGUHLJLQJ�DI�WH�ZHQGHQ��$OV�GH]H�SRJLQJ�QLHW�VXFFHVYRO�LV�NDQ�JHHVWHOLMNHRQJH]RQGKHLG� RQWVWDDQ�� 3V\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� PRHWHQ� ZRUGHQ� JH]LHQ� DOVPXOWLIDFWRULsOH� DDQGRHQLQJHQ�� ZDDUELM� ]RZHO� JHQHWLVFKH� DOV� RPJHYLQJVIDFWRUHQ� HQYURHJH� HUYDULQJHQ� KHW� ULVLFR� RS� SV\FKLVFKH� RQJH]RQGKHLG� EHSDOHQ�� ,Q� KHW� PRGHO� NDQPHQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� RPVFKULMYHQ� DOV� IDFWRUHQ� GLH� HHQ� FDXVDOH� UHODWLH� KHEEHQ� PHW� KHWRQWVWDDQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�SUREOHPHQ��9DDN�JDDW�KHW�ELM�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HFKWHU�RP�IDFWRUHQGLH�ZHO� HHQ� DDQWRRQEDUH� UHODWLH� KHEEHQ�PHW� SV\FKLVFKH� SUREOHPHQ��PDDU�ZDDUYDQ� GHFDXVDOLWHLW�QLHW�YDVW�VWDDW��:H�]XOOHQ�GH]H�EUHGH�RPVFKULMYLQJ�LQ�GLW�VWXN�JHEUXLNHQ�0HQ� NDQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� JH]RQGKHLG� RQGHUVFKHLGHQ� LQ� GH� YROJHQGHJURHSHQ��2UPHO�HW�DO���������'H�5LGGHU����������� ,QJULMSHQGH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�RI�VWUHVVRUHQ����([RJHQH� IDFWRUHQ� �ELMYRRUEHHOG� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ�� VRFLDOH� ZDDUGHQ� HQ� QRUPHQ�RSYRHGLQJVVWLMO��DUEHLGVRPVWDQGLJKHGHQ���� (QGRJHQH� IDFWRUHQ�� SV\FKRELRORJLVFKH� NHQPHUNHQ� �ELMYRRUEHHOG� HUIHOLMNH� IDFWRUHQ�SHUVRRQOLMNKHLG��FRSLQJVWLMOHQ��QHXURELRORJLVFKH�IDFWRUHQ��,Q� GH]H� ELMGUDJH� RQGHU]RHNHQ� ZH� XLW� HON� YDQ� GH]H� FDWHJRULHsQ� ppQ� RI� PHHUGHUHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ��:H� FRQFHQWUHUHQ� RQV� GDDUELM� RS� GLH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� GLH� LQ� GH� KXLGLJH

Page 101: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�FHQWUDDO�VWDDQ�HQ�ZDDU�GH�EHwQYORHGEDDUKHLG�YDQ�LV�RQGHU]RFKW�2YHULJHQV�VOXLWHQ�GH]H�GULH�FDWHJRULHsQ�HONDDU�QLHW�ZHGHU]LMGV�XLW��PDDU�ZRUGHQ�YDDN�LQHHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH�JHFRPELQHHUG�,Q�HHQ�HHUGHUH�OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH�VHOHFWHHUGHQ�ZLM����VWXGLHV��ZDDUYDQ�HU����JHULFKW�]LMQRS� YROZDVVHQHQ�� QDDU� GH� HIIHFWHQ� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHULFKW� RS� SV\FKLVFKHNODFKWHQ�HQ�VWRRUQLVVHQ��9DQ�*DJHOGRQN��5LJWHU���������:H�EHNHNHQ�LQ�GH]H�VHW�YDQVWXGLHV� HQ� LQ� HQNHOH� DQGHUH� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� RYHU]LFKWHQ� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�%RVPD��+RVPDQ��������0UD]HN��+DJJHUW\��������ZHONH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�LQ�GH]H�GULHFDWHJRULHsQ�KHW�PHHVW�RQGHU]RFKW�ZDUHQ��2S�EDVLV�GDDUYDQ�NR]HQ�ZLM�YRRU�GH�YROJHQGHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�RP�QDGHU�WH�RQGHU]RHNHQ���� ,QJULMSHQGH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�RI�VWUHVVRUHQ�� +HW�]RUJHQ�YRRU�HHQ�IDPLOLHOLG�PHW�HHQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�DDQGRHQLQJ�� 9HUOLHV�YDQ�HHQ�QDDVWH�GRRU�GH�GRRG�� :HUNHORRVKHLG�� +HW�]RUJHQ�YRRU�HHQ�KXOSEHKRHYHQGH�RXGHUH�LQ�GH�QDDVWH�RPJHYLQJ����([RJHQH�IDFWRUHQ�� 6RFLDOH�VWHXQ��� (QGRJHQH�IDFWRUHQ�� VHOI�HIILFDF\���� VRFLDOH�YDDUGLJKHGHQ�%LM�HQGRJHQH�IDFWRUHQ�]LMQ�WZHH�NHQPHUNHQ�JHNR]HQ�GLH�EHVFKRXZG�NXQQHQ�ZRUGHQ�DOVFRSLQJ�YDDUGLJKHGHQ�� 'HUJHOLMNH� FRSLQJ�YDDUGLJKHGHQ� VWDDQ� LQ� YHHO� SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV� FHQWUDDO�� 3HUVRRQVNHQPHUNHQ� GLH� PHHU� WH� PDNHQ� KHEEHQ� PHW� µWUDLWV¶� RINDUDNWHUHLJHQVFKDSSHQ� ]LMQ� QLHW� YHUGHU� RQGHU]RFKW�� RPGDW� GLH� LQ� SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV�QDXZHOLMNV�DDQ�ERG�NRPHQ�9RRU� VRFLDOH� YDDUGLJKHGHQ� ]LMQ� RQYROGRHQGH� VWXGLHV� JHYRQGHQ� GLH� YROGHGHQ� DDQ� GHLQFOXVLHFULWHULD�'H�HQLJH�HQGRJHQH�IDFWRU�GLH�DDQ�ERG�NRPW�LV�GXV�VHOI�HIILFDF\�

���� 'H�YUDDJVWHOOLQJHQ'H�NHUQYUDDJ�YDQ�GH]H�ELMGUDJH� LV�RI�KHW�PRJHOLMN� LV�RP�PHW�EHKXOS�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� HQ� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� NODFKWHQ� WHEHwQYORHGHQ��'H]H�NHUQYUDDJ�NXQQHQ�ZH�LQGHOHQ�LQ�YLHU�GHHOYUDJHQ����.XQQHQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� GH� QHJDWLHYH� JHYROJHQ� YDQ� LQJULMSHQGHOHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� RI� VWUHVVRUHQ� YRRU� GH� JHHVWHOLMNH� JH]RQGKHLG� EHSHUNHQ"� :HJDDQ�HUYDQ�XLW�GDW�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�LQ�KHW�DOJHPHHQ�YRRUDO�JHULFKW�]LMQ�RS�KHWYHUPLQGHUHQ� YDQ� GH� JHYROJHQ� YDQ� LQJULMSHQGH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� YRRU� GH� JHHVWHOLMNHJH]RQGKHLG� HQ� QLHW� RS� KHW� EHwQYORHGHQ� YDQ� LQJULMSHQGH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� ]HOI�� :H]XOOHQ� GDDUELM� LQJDDQ� RS� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHULFKW� RS� GH� JHYROJHQ� YDQ� KHW]RUJHQ� YRRU� HHQ� IDPLOLHOLG�PHW� HHQ� SV\FKLDWULVFKH� DDQGRHQLQJ�� ZHUNHORRVKHLG�� KHWYHUOLHV�YDQ�GH�SDUWQHU�GRRU�GH�GRRG�HQ�KHW�]RUJHQ�YRRU�HHQ�KXOSEHKRHYHQGH�RXGHUHLQ GH�QDDVWH�RPJHYLQJ����.XQQHQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GH�HUYDUHQ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�YHUEHWHUHQ"���9HUWURXZHQ�GDW�HHQ�SHUVRRQ�KHHIW�LQ�]LMQ�KDDU�HLJHQ�NXQQHQ�DDQJDDQGH�KHW�XLWYRHUHQ�YDQ�HHQ�EHSDDOGJHGUDJ�

Page 102: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

���.XQQHQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� SHUVRRQVNHQPHUNHQ�� LQ� KHW� ELM]RQGHU� VHOI�HIILFDF\EHwQYORHGHQ"���:DW�LV�KHW�HIIHFW�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�V\PSWRPHQ�YDQ�HUQVWLJH�SV\FKLVFKHSUREOHPHQ"+HW�ZDV�RRUVSURQNHOLMN�RRN�GH�EHGRHOLQJ�RP�WH�RQGHU]RHNHQ�RI�HU�HHQ�UHODWLH�JHYRQGHQNRQ� ZRUGHQ� WXVVHQ� HIIHFWHQ� RS� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ� HQ� VHOI�HIILFDF\� HQHU]LMGV� HQ� DQGHU]LMGVHIIHFWHQ� RS� SV\FKLVFKH� NODFKWHQ�� +HW� DDQWDO� VWXGLHV� GDW� EHVFKLNEDDU� ZDV� RP� GH]HYUDDJVWHOOLQJ�WH�RQGHU]RHNHQ�EOHHN�HFKWHU�WH�NOHLQ�WH�]LMQ�RP�GH]H�WH�RQGHU]RHNHQ�'H HHUVWH�GULH�YUDDJVWHOOLQJHQ�]XOOHQ�ZH�EHDQWZRRUGHQ�GRRU� OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLHV�HQ�PHWD�DQDO\VHV�XLW�WH�YRHUHQ��GLH�YRRU�GH]H�VWXGLH�]LMQ�XLWJHYRHUG��9RRU�GH�YLHUGH�YUDDJVWHOOLQJ]XOOHQ�ZH�JHEUXLN�PDNHQ�YDQ�HHUGHU�GRRU�RQV�XLWJHYRHUGH�OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLHV��2PGDW�GH]HOLWHUDWXXUVWXGLHV� DQGHUV� YDQ� RS]HW� ]LMQ� GDQ� GH� DQGHUH� RQGHUGHOHQ� YDQ� GH]H� ELMGUDJH]XOOHQ�ZH�VDPHQYDWWLQJHQ�KLHUYDQ�LQ�GH�YRUP�YDQ�NDGHUWHNVWHQ�JHYHQ��]LH�KRRIGVWXN����+HW�JDDW�KLHU�RP�GH�YROJHQGH�NDGHUWHNVWHQ���� (HQ�V\VWHPDWLVFKH�OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH�QDDU�KHW�HIIHFW�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKHHQ� JHGUDJVSUREOHPDWLHN�� GLH� UHFHQW� YDQXLW� KHW� 7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW� LV� YHUULFKW�9DQ� *DJHOGRQN� � 5LJWHU�� ������� ,Q� GH]H� NDGHUWHNVW� SUHVHQWHUHQ� ZLM� HHQVDPHQYDWWLQJ� YDQ� GH]H� OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH�� ZDDUELM� ZH� RQV� EHSHUNHQ� WRW� KHWGRPHLQ�YDQ�KHW�YRRUOLJJHQGH�UDSSRUW��QDPHOLMN�SUHYHQWLH�ELM�YROZDVVHQHQ���� (HQ�PHWD�DQDO\VH�YDQ�YURHJWLMGLJH�RSVSRULQJ�HQ�EHKDQGHOLQJ�YDQ�GHSUHVVLHV�ELMRXGHUHQ��&XLMSHUV���������� (HQ� V\VWHPDWLVFK� RYHU]LFKW� YDQ� PHWD�DQDO\VHV� RS� KHW� JHELHG� YDQ� GHYHUVODYLQJVSUHYHQWLH��9DQ�*DJHOGRQN��&XLMSHUV������������ (HQ�PHWD�DQDO\VH�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�ELM�NLQGHUHQ� �&XLMSHUV 6WDP��LQ�YRRUEHUHLGLQJ���'H]H�VWXGLH�YDOW�HLJHQOLMN�EXLWHQ�KHW�NDGHU�YDQ�GH]HVWXGLH�� RPGDW� GH]H� ]LFK� DOOHHQ� RS� YROZDVVHQHQ� ULFKW��2P� WRFK� HHQ� LQGUXN� WHJHYHQ� YDQ� GH� HIIHFWLYLWHLW� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� ELM� NLQGHUHQ� HQMHXJGLJHQ�KHEEHQ�ZH�GH]H�PHWD�DQDO\VH�RSJHQRPHQ�

���� 'H�PHWD�DQDO\WLVFKH�PHWKRGH$OV�PHWKRGH�ZRUGW�GH�VWDWLVWLVFKH�PHWD�DQDO\VH�JHEUXLNW��,Q�HHQ�PHWD�DQDO\VH�ZRUGW�HHQJHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�G EHUHNHQG�YROJHQV�GH�IRUPXOH�� 0H � 0FG � 6'HFZDDUELM� GH� JHPLGGHOGH� VFRUH� YDQ� GH� FRQWUROHJURHS� ZRUGW� DIJHWURNNHQ� YDQ� GHJHPLGGHOGH�VFRUH�YDQ�GH�H[SHULPHQWHOH�JURHS��GRRUJDDQV�QD�DIORRS�YDQ�GH�LQWHUYHQWLH�HQ�KHW� UHVXOWDDW�ZRUGW� JHGHHOG�GRRU� KHW� JHPLGGHOGH� YDQ�GH� VWDQGDDUGGHYLDWLHV� YDQ� GHFRQWUROHJURHS� HQ� H[SHULPHQWHOH� JURHS�� 2S� GH]H� ZLM]H� RQWVWDDW� HHQ� PDDW� GLHRQDIKDQNHOLMN�LV�YDQ�KHW�JHEUXLNWH�PHHWLQVWUXPHQW�HQ�GDDUGRRU�YHUJHOLMNEDDU�PHW�DQGHUHHIIHFWJURRWWHV� �+HGJHV� � 2ONLQ�� ������� (HQ� HIIHFWJURRWWH� YDQ� ���� JHHIW� DDQ� GDW� KHWJHPLGGHOGH�YDQ�GH�H[SHULPHQWHOH�JURHS�HHQ�KDOYH�VWDQGDDUGGHYLDWLH�KRJHU�OLJW�GDQ�KHWJHPLGGHOGH�YDQ�GH�FRQWUROHJURHS��(HQ�HIIHFWJURRWWH�YDQ������HQ�JURWHU�EHVFKRXZHQ�ZHDOV�JURRW��HHQ�HIIHFWJURRWWH�WXVVHQ�GH������HQ������DOV�PLGGHOJURRW�HQ�NOHLQHU�GDQ�����DOV�NOHLQ�

Page 103: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

,Q� RQ]H� EHUHNHQLQJHQ� ZHUGHQ� DOOH� JHYRQGHQ� HIIHFWJURRWWHQ� JHFRUULJHHUG� GRRU� GHµVPDOO�VDPSOH�ELDV¶�GLH�GRRU�+HGJHV�HQ�2ONLQ��������ZRUGW�JHUDSSRUWHHUG��,Q�PHHUGHUHVWXGLHV�ZHUGHQ�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�PHHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ�YRRU�GH]HOIGH�YDULDEHOH�JHEUXLNW��,Q�GLHJHYDOOHQ� ZHUG� SHU� H[SHULPHQWHOH� FRQGLWLH� ppQ� HIIHFWJURRWWH� EHUHNHQG�� GRRU� KHWJHPLGGHOGH�YDQ�GH�HIIHFWJURRWWHV�YRRU�GH�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�PHHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ�WH�JHEUXLNHQ�,Q� PHHUGHUH� VWXGLHV� ZHUGHQ� RQYROGRHQGH� GDWD� JHUDSSRUWHHUG� RP� GH� HIIHFWJURRWWHQ� WHEHUHNHQHQ��,Q�GLH�JHYDOOHQ�ZHUGHQ�GH�IRUPXOHV�]RDOV�GLH�GRRU�:ROI��������EHVFKUHYHQ]LMQ�JHEUXLNW�RP�HHQ�VFKDWWLQJ�WH�PDNHQ�YDQ�GH�HIIHFWJURRWWHQ��$OV�HHQ�QLHW�VLJQLILFDQWYHUVFKLO�ZHUG�JHUDSSRUWHHUG��ZHUG�GH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�JHVFKDW�RS�QXO�7HU� RQGHUVWHXQLQJ� YDQ� GH� PHWD�DQDO\VHV� ZHUG� KHW� FRPSXWHUSURJUDPPD�0HWD� ���JHEUXLNW� �6FKZDU]HU�� ������� 'H� VWDWLVWLVFKH� SURFHGXUHV� LQ� GLW� SURJUDPPD� ]LMQYRRUQDPHOLMN�JHEDVHHUG�RS�KHW�ZHUN�YDQ�+HGJHV�HQ�2ONLQ���������(U�]LMQ�YHUVFKLOOHQGHPRJHOLMNKHGHQ�RP�KHW�JHPLGGHOGH�YDQ�HIIHFWJURRWWHQ�XLW�PHHUGHUH�VWXGLHV�WH�EHUHNHQHQ�,Q�RQ]H�DQDO\VHV�JHEUXLNWHQ�ZH�KHW�]RJHKHWHQ�µUDQGRP�HIIHFWV¶�PRGHO��'LW�PRGHO�ZHUGJHNR]HQ� RPGDW� KLHUPHH� RQGHU]RFKW� NDQ� ZRUGHQ� RI� GH� VHW� YDQ� RQGHU]RFKWH� VWXGLHVKRPRJHHQ� LV�� ,Q� GLW�PRGHO�ZRUGW� GH� SURSRUWLH� YDULDQWLH� EHUHNHQG�GLH� YHUNODDUG�ZRUGWGRRU�IOXFWXDWLHV�LQ�GH�YHU]DPHOLQJ�VWXGLHV��$OV�����RI�PHHU�YDQ�GH�YDULDQWLH�YHUNODDUGZRUGW�GRRU�IOXFWXDWLHV� LQ�GH�YHU]DPHOLQJ�VWXGLHV��NDQ�PHQ�GDW�]LHQ�DOV�DDQZLM]LQJ�GDWV\VWHPDWLVFKH�YHUVFKLOOHQ�WXVVHQ�VWXGLHV�NOHLQ�RI�DIZH]LJ�]LMQ��6FKZDU]HU��������

Page 104: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�GHQHJDWLHYH�JHYROJHQ�YDQ�LQJULMSHQGHOHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�RI�VWUHVVRUHQ,Q�GH]H�SDUDJUDDI�ZRUGW�LQJHJDDQ�RS�GH�YUDDJ�RI�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GH�QHJDWLHYHJHYROJHQ�YDQ� LQJULMSHQGH�JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�RI� VWUHVVRUHQ�YRRU�GH� JHHVWHOLMNH� JH]RQGKHLGNXQQHQ� YHUPLQGHUHQ��:H� JDDQ� GDDUELM� LQ� RS� GH� YROJHQGH� YLHU� VWUHVVRUHQ�� KHW� ]RUJHQYRRU� HHQ� IDPLOLHOLG�PHW� HHQ� SV\FKLDWULVFKH� DDQGRHQLQJ��ZHUNHORRVKHLG�� KHW� RYHUOLMGHQYDQ�GH�SDUWQHU�HQ�KHW�]RUJHQ�YRRU�HHQ�KXOSEHKRHYHQGH�RXGHUH�LQ�GH�QDDVWH�RPJHYLQJ�

���� 9HUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�EHODVWLQJ�YDQ�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�YDQSV\FKLDWULVFKH�SDWLsQWHQ��

3UREOHHPVWHOOLQJ'H EHODVWLQJ�YDQ�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�GLH�ELMGUDJHQ�DDQ�GH�]RUJ�YRRU�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�SDWLsQWHQNDQ�DDQ]LHQOLMN�]LMQ� HQ�KHW�RQGHU]RHN�RS�GLW� WHUUHLQ�GDW� LQ�GH� MDUHQ�YLMIWLJ�YDQ� VWDUW� LVJHJDDQ��&ODXVHQ��<DUURZ���������KHHIW�DDQJHWRRQG�GDW�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�YDQGH]H�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�HUQVWLJ�NDQ�ZRUGHQ�DDQJHWDVW�GRRU�GH�]RUJ��0DXULQ��%R\G��������ZDDUGRRU�KHW�ULVLFR�RS�RYHUEHODVWLQJ��DQJVW�HQ�GHSUHVVLH�VWHUN�YHUKRRJG�LV��6RORPRQ�'UDLQH�� ������� 'LW� YHUKRRJG� ULVLFR� NDQ� KHW� EHVW� EHJUHSHQ� ZRUGHQ� YDQXLW� HHQ� VWUHVV�WKHRUHWLVFK� NDGHU�� ZDDUELM� RYHUEHODVWLQJ� OHLGW� WRW� JH]RQGKHLGVNODFKWHQ� HQ� SV\FKLVFKHSUREOHPHQ��/D]DUXV��)RONPDQ��������(U ]LMQ�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�SV\FKRVRFLDOH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RQWZLNNHOG�RP�GH]H�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�WHRQGHUVWHXQHQ�� 2RN� LQ� YHHO� 1HGHUODQGVH� **=�LQVWHOOLQJHQ� ZRUGHQ� SV\FKR�HGXFDWLHYHRQGHUVWHXQLQJVJURHSHQ� YRRU� IDPLOLHOHGHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLDWULVFKH� SDWLsQWHQ� JHRUJDQLVHHUG�9HHO�SV\FKRVRFLDOH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�KHEEHQ�WRW�GRHO�WHUXJYDO�ELM�GHSV\FKLDWULVFKH� SDWLsQW� WH� YRRUNRPHQ�� $QGHUH� SV\FKRVRFLDOH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� ]LMQ� HU� RSJHULFKW�GH�NZDOLWHLW�YDQ�OHYHQ�YDQ�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�SDWLsQWHQ�WH�YHUKRJHQHQ�RYHUEHODVWLQJ�ELM�KHQ�WH�YRRUNRPHQ��6RORPRQ���������9RRUDO�GH]H� LQWHUYHQWLHV�]LMQYDQXLW� SUHYHQWLHI� RRJSXQW� YDQ� EHODQJ� RPGDW� ]LM� JHULFKW� ]LMQ� RS� KHW� UHGXFHUHQ� YDQ� GHFRQVHTXHQWLHV�YDQ�HHQ�QHJDWLHYH�VWUHVVRU��'HUJHOLMNH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�ZRUGHQ�LQ�1HGHUODQGRS�JURWH�VFKDDO�XLWJHYRHUG��+LHURQGHU�ZRUGW�HHQ�PHWD�DQDO\VH�JHSUHVHQWHHUG�YDQ�VWXGLHVZDDULQ� GH� HIIHFWHQ� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� RS� GH� PDWH� YDQ� GLVWUHVV� YDQIDPLOLHOHGHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�SDWLsQWHQ�ZRUGHQ�RQGHU]RFKW�9UDDJVWHOOLQJ.XQQHQ�RQGHUVWHXQHQGH�SV\FKRVRFLDOH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GH�JHYROJHQ�YDQ�KHW�]RUJHQ�YRRU�HHQIDPLOLHOLG�PHW�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�SUREOHPHQ�UHGXFHUHQ"

���'H]H�SDUDJUDDI�LV�HHQ�VDPHQYDWWLQJ�YDQ�KHW�DUWLNHO�7KH�(IIHFWV�RI�)DPLO\�,QWHUYHQWLRQV�RQ�5HODWLYHV¶%XUGHQ��$�0HWD�DQDO\VLV��3��&XLMSHUV��-RXUQDO�RI�0HQWDO�+HDOWK������������

Page 105: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

0HWKRGH6HOHFWLH� YDQ� VWXGLHV� 9LD� UHYLHZV� RS� GLW� WHUUHLQ� �6RORPRQ�� ������ /DP�� ������ 7DUULHU�������.D]DULDQ��9DQGHUKH\GHQ���������ZDDURQGHU�HHQ� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLHURQG�GLW�RQGHUZHUS��'L[RQ�HQ�/HKPDQ���������9RRU�GH� MDUHQ������ WRW������ZHUG�HHQDDQYXOOHQGH�OLWHUDWXXUVHDUFK�LQ�3V\FKOLW�HQ�0HGOLQH�XLWJHYRHUG�,QFOXVLHFULWHULD� 6WXGLHV�ZHUGHQ�LQ�GH�PHWD�DQDO\VH�RSJHQRPHQ�DOV�]LM�����JHULFKW�ZDUHQRS�RQGHUVWHXQLQJ�YDQ�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�PHW�HHQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�VWRRUQLV������HHQ�JHVWDQGDDU�GLVHHUGH�PDDW�YRRU�EHODVWLQJ�YDQ�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�DOV�XLWNRPVWPDDW�KDGGHQ��HQ�����JHEUXLNPDDNWHQ� YDQ� HHQ� FRQWUROHJURHS� HQ� SUH�� HQ� SRVWWHVW� GDWD� UDSSRUWHHUGHQ� �HQ� YROGRHQGHUHVXOWDWHQ�SUHVHQWHHUGHQ�RP�GH�JHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�WH�EHUHNHQHQ��5HVXOWHUHQGH�VHW�YDQ�VWXGLHV� =LH�WDEHO����� ,Q���YDQ�GH����VWXGLHV�ZHUGHQ�UHVSRQGHQWHQZLOOHNHXULJ�DDQ�FRQGLWLHV�WRHJHZH]HQ��'H�FRQWUROHJURHSHQ�ZDUHQ�YRRUDO�ZDFKWOLMVWHQ���VWXGLHV�� RI� WUHDWPHQW� DV� XVXDO� �]HV� PDDO��� ,Q� ]HV� VWXGLHV� ZHUGHQ� EHKDOYH� SRVWWHVW�PHWLQJHQ�RRN�IROORZ�XS�PHWLQJHQ�XLWJHYRHUG��WRW����PDDQGHQ���'H� LQWHUYHQWLHV�ZDUHQLQGLYLGXHHO����VWXGLHV��RI�JURHSVJHZLMV����VWXGLHV���+HW�JURV�YDQ�GH�GHHOQHPHUV�ZDUHQRXGHUV�YDQ�SDWLsQWHQ�HQ�GRRUJDDQV�JDDW�KHW�RP�VFKL]RIUHQLH�SDWLsQWHQ�0HWKRGH� 0HWD�DQDO\VH�YDQ�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�GH�EHODVWLQJ�YDQ� IDPLOLHOHGHQYDQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�SDWLsQWHQ�RS�EDVLV�YDQ�KHW�UDQGRP�HIIHFWV�PRGHO�5HVXOWDWHQ2PGDW� LQ� HQNHOH� VWXGLHV� PHHUGHUH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� PHW� HHQ� FRQWUROHJURHS� ZHUGHQYHUJHOHNHQ�� NRQGHQ� HU� LQ� WRWDDO� ��� FRQWUDVWJURHSHQ� ZRUGHQ� VDPHQJHVWHOG� ZDDULQ� GHH[SHULPHQWHOH� JURHS� ZHUG� YHUJHOHNHQ� PHW� GH� FRQWUROHJURHS� ELM� GH� QDPHWLQJ�� 'HJHPLGGHOGH� HIIHFWJURRWWH� ZDV� ����� ����� EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDO�� ����� ±� ������ =� ������S����������'LW�GXLGW�RS�HHQ�PLGGHOJURRW�HIIHFW��/LSVH\��������%LM� GH� IROORZ�XS�PHWLQJHQ� NRQGHQ� DFKW� FRQWUDVWJURHSHQ� VDPHQJHVWHOG�ZRUGHQ�PHW� LQWRWDDO�����UHVSRQGHQWHQ��'H�JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�YDQ�GH]H�VWXGLHV�ZDV����������EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDO���������������=� �������S��������2PGDW�GH�KRPRJHQLWHLW�YDQ�GH�VHW�YDQ�RQGHU]RFKWH�VWXGLHV�QLHW�RSWLPDDO�ZDV��ZHUGHQFOXVWHU�DQDO\VHV�XLWJHYRHUG�ZDDUELM�HHQ�VXEVHW�YDQ�VWXGLHV�ZHUG�JHYRQGHQ�PHW�JURWHUHHIIHFWHQ� ELM� GH� QDPHWLQJ� �G� � ������ ���� EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDO�� ����� �� ������ =� �������S����������HQ�HHQ�VXEVHW�PHW�JHULQJHUH�HIIHFWHQ�ELM�GH�QDPHWLQJ��G� ����������EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDO���������������=� �������S����������(U�NRQGHQ�JHHQ�NHQPHUNHQJHYRQGHQ�ZRUGHQ� YDQ� VWXGLHV� GLH� GXLGHOLMN� JHUHODWHHUG�ZDUHQ� DDQ� JURWHUH� RI� NOHLQHUHHIIHFWLYLWHLW�� :HO� ZDV� GXLGHOLMN� GDW� NRUWHUH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� �PLQGHU� GDQ� WLHQ� VHVVLHV�DOOHPDDO�NOHLQHUH�HIIHFWJURRWWHV�KDGGHQ�&RQFOXVLHV%HODQJULMNVWH�EHSHUNLQJHQ� ����5HODWLHI�NOHLQH�DDQWDOOHQ� UHVSRQGHQWHQ�HQ� ���� HHQ�JURWHGLYHUVLWHLW�DDQ�PHHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ�RP�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG��RYHUEHODVWLQJ��WH�PHWHQ�8LWNRPVWHQ� 3V\FKRVRFLDOH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHULFKW� RS� IDPLOLHOHGHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLDWULVFKHSDWLsQWHQ�NXQQHQ�RS�HIIHFWLHYH�ZLM]H�GH�RYHUEHODVWLQJ�YDQ�GH]H�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�UHGXFHUHQ�'H HIIHFWHQ�]LMQ�PLGGHOJURRW�HQ�QHLJHQ�ELM�IROORZ�XS�PHWLQJHQ�QDDU�HHQ�NOHLQ�HIIHFW��,QSRWHQWLH� KHEEHQ� GH]H� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JURWH� HIIHFWHQ� �PHW� G�ZDDUGHQ� YDQ� ����� RI� JURWHU��PDDU�KHW� LV�QRJ�QLHW�GXLGHOLMN� DDQ�ZHONH� NHQPHUNHQ�GH�SURJUDPPDV�PRHWHQ�YROGRHQRP�GHUJHOLMNH�HIIHFWHQ�WH�UHDOLVHUHQ�

Page 106: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

7DEHO�������6WXGLHV�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ��RS�GH�EHODVWLQJ��YDQ�SV\FKRVRFLDOH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLDWULVFKH�SDWLsQWHQ�6WXGLH &RQGLWLHV�D 1 5&7E � VFKL]RIU�F � RXGHUV GFWU

G GIXH

$EUDPRZLW]�&RXUVH\������ ��� ,QWHUYHQWLH��LQIRUPDWLH���FRSLQJ���VWUHVVPDQ�����GLVFXVVLH��JURHS����VHVVLHV���� :DFKWOLMVW

���� ± ��� �� ���� -&DUSHQWLHU�HW�DO������ ��� ,QWHUYHQWLH��LQIRUPDWLH���FRSLQJ���FRXQVHOLQJ��LQG��

��� µ7UHDWPHQW�DV�XVXDO¶���� ± ��� �� ���� -

&R]ROLQR�HW�DO������� ��� ,QWHUYHQWLH��LQIRUPDWLH���GLVFXVVLH��JURHS����VHVVLH���� :DFKWOLMVW

���� � ��� �� ���� -+DDV�HW�DO������� ��� ,QWHUYHQWLH��LQIRUPDWLH���FRSLQJ���VWUHVVPDQ���LQG������VHVVLHV�

��� µ7UHDWPHQW�DV�XVXDO¶���� � �� ± ���� -

+RJDUW\�HW�DO������� ��� ,QWHUYHQWLH��LQIRUPDWLH��FRSLQJ��VRFLDOH�YDDUGLJKHGHQ���VWUHVV�PDQ���LQG���!����VHVVLHV���� ,QWHUYHQWLH��VRFLDOH�YDDUGLJKHGHQ��!����VHVVLHV���� ,QWHUYHQWLH��VRFLDOH�YDDUGLJKHGHQ���LQIRUPDWLH�FRSLQJ��!����VHVVLHV���� µ7UHDWPHQW�DV�XVXDO¶

��������

� ��� ± ��� ������� ������� ����

��� ������� ������� ����

0DF�&DUWK\�HW�DO����� ��� ,QWHUYHQWLH��LQIRUPDWLH���GLVFXVVLH���XLWZLVVHOLQJ���FRSLQJ��LQG������VHVVLHV���� *HHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH

���� ± �� �� - ����3RVQHU�HW�DO������� ��� ,QWHUYHQWLH��LQIRUPDWLH���GLVFXVVLH���FRSLQJ��JURHS����VHVVLHV�

��� :DFKWOLMVW���� � ��� �� ���� ����

6PLWK��%LUFKZRRG����� ��� ,QWHUYHQWLH��LQIRUPDWLH���GLVFXVVLH��JURHS����VHVVLHV���� ,QIRUPDWLH�SHU�SRVW

���� � ��� �� ���� ����6RORPRQ�HW�DO������� ��� ,QGLYLGXHOH�LQWHUYHQWLH��LQIRUPDWLH���FRSLQJ���FRXQVHOLQJ���SUREOHHP�RSO������VHVVLHV�

��� *URHSVLQWHUYHQWLH��LGHP���� :DFKWOLMVW

������� �� �� ��� ����

��� ����-

;LRQJ�HW�DO������� ��� ,QWHUYHQWLH��LQIRUPDWLH��VWHXQ���SUREOHHP�RSO���FRXQVHOLQJ��LQG��HQ�JURHS��!���VHVVLHV���� µ7UHDWPHQW�DV�XVXDO¶

���� � ��� ± ���� ����=KDQJ�HW�DO������� ��� ,QWHUYHQWLH��LQIRUPDWLH���GLVFXVVLH��JURHS�����VHVVLHV�

��� µ7UHDWPHQW�DV�XVXDO¶�������� ± ��� �� ���� -

D��VWUHVVPDQ��VWUHVVPDQDJHPHQW�YDDUGLJKHGHQ��LQG��LQGLYLGXHOH�LQWHUYHQWLH�� G��GFWU� JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�YDQ�H[SHULPHQWHOH�YHUVXV�FRQWUROHFRQGLWLH�ELM�SRVW�WHVW�E��5&7��µUDQGRPL]HG�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO¶��ZHO�JHHQ�UDQGRP�WRHZLM]LQJ�DDQ�FRQGLWLHV��� H��GIX��JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�ELM�IROORZ�XS�PHWLQJ�F� ��VFKL]RIU����IDPLOLHOHGHQ�YDQ�VFKL]RIUHQH�SDWLsQWHQ�

Page 107: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

���� 9HUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�JHYROJHQ�YRRU�JHHVWHOLMNHJH]RQGKHLG�YDQ�KHW�RYHUOLMGHQ�YDQ�GH�SDUWQHU3UREOHHPVWHOOLQJ+HW�RYHUOLMGHQ�YDQ�GH�SDUWQHU�KHHIW�HUQVWLJH�JHYROJHQ�YRRU�GH� JHHVWHOLMNH� JH]RQGKHLG�+HW�PHHVW�RQGHU]RFKW�]LMQ�GH�JHYROJHQ�RS�GHSUHVVLHV�HQ�GHSUHVVLHYH�NODFKWHQ��2QJHYHHUGH� KHOIW� YDQ� DOOH� ZHGXZHQ� HQ� ZHGXZQDDUV� YROGRHW� JHGXUHQGH� KHW� HHUVWH� MDDU� QD� KHWYHUOLHV� DDQ� GH� FULWHULD� YRRU� HHQ� GHSUHVVLHYH� VWRRUQLV� YROJHQV� GH� '60�,9� �1XVV� =XEHQNR���������'HSUHVVLHYH�NODFKWHQ�NXQQHQ�GDQ�RRN�DOV�QRUPDDO�EHVFKRXZG�ZRUGHQLQ SHULRGHQ�YDQ�URXZ��,Q�KHW�PHUHQGHHO�YDQ�GH�JHYDOOHQ�JDDQ�GH]H�GHSUHVVLHV�VSRQWDDQRYHU��$OV�GH�GHSUHVVLHYH�NODFKWHQ� HFKWHU� JHGXUHQGH� ODQJHUH� WLMG�EOLMYHQ�EHVWDDQ�ZRUGWYHURQGHUVWHOG�GDW�GH�QRUPDOH�URXZ�JHFRPSOLFHHUG�ZRUGW�GRRU�GH�RQWZLNNHOLQJ�YDQ�HHQGHSUHVVLHYH�VWRRUQLV��,Q�HHQ�VWXGLH�ZHUG�JHYRQGHQ�GDW�HHQ�MDDU�QD�KHW�YHUOLHV�QRJ�]R¶Q���SURFHQW�YDQ�GH�ZHGXZHQ�HQ�ZHGXZQDDUV�YROGHHG�DDQ�GH�FULWHULD�YDQ�HHQ�GHSUHVVLHYHVWRRUQLV�� WHJHQRYHU� �� SURFHQW� ELM� YHUJHOLMNEDUH� RXGHUHQ� GLH� KXQ� SDUWQHU� QLHW� UHFHQWKHEEHQ�YHUORUHQ��=LVRRN��6KXFKWHU���������:HGXZHQ�HQ�ZHGXZQDDUV�YRUPHQ�GDQ�RRNHHQ�GXLGHOLMNH�ULVLFRJURHS�YRRU�GHSUHVVLHYH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�(U ]LMQ� YHUVFKLOOHQGH� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� RQWZLNNHOG� RP� GH� JHYROJHQ� YDQ� KHWYHUOLHV�YDQ�GH�SDUWQHU�YRRU�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�WH�UHGXFHUHQ�HQ�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQSV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� WH� YRRUNRPHQ�� :H� YRQGHQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHULFKW� RSFULVLVLQWHUYHQWLH��ZDDUELM�]R�VQHO�PRJHOLMN�QD�KHW�RYHUOLMGHQ�SV\FKRVRFLDOH�KXOS�JHJHYHQZRUGW� �&RQVWDQWLQR�� ������ ������� ]HOIKXOSJURHSHQ� GLH� GRRU� ORWJHQRWHQ� JHRUJDQLVHHUGZRUGHQ� HQ� ZDDULQ� XLWZLVVHOLQJ� YDQ� HUYDULQJHQ� HQ� ZHGHU]LMGVH� VWHXQ� FHQWUDDO� VWDDW�7XGLYHU� HW� DO��� ������� FRXQVHOLQJ� �6FKXW� HW� DO��� ������ HQ� YDDUGLJKHLGVWUDLQLQJ� �9DQ/DPPHUHQ��*HHOHQ��������9UDDJVWHOOLQJ.XQQHQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GH�JHYROJHQ�YDQ�KHW�RYHUOLMGHQ�YDQ�GH�SDUWQHU�YRRU�GHJHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�UHGXFHUHQ"0HWKRGH6HOHFWLH�YDQ�VWXGLHV� 9LD� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� OLWHUDWXXUVHDUFK� LQ�3V\FKOLW� HQ�0HGOLQH� ������������,QFOXVLHFULWHULD� 6WXGLHV�ZHUGHQ�LQ�GH�PHWD�DQDO\VH�RSJHQRPHQ�DOV�]LM�����JHULFKW�ZDUHQPHQVHQ� GLH� KXQ� SDUWQHU� GRRU� GH� GRRG� KDGGHQ� YHUORUHQ�� ���� XLWNRPVWHQ� YDQ� HHQLQWHUYHQWLH�YRRU�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�UDSSRUWHHUGHQ��HQ�����JHEUXLN�PDDNWHQ�YDQ�HHQFRQWUROHJURHS� HQ� SUH�� HQ� SRVWWHVW� GDWD� UDSSRUWHHUGHQ� �HQ� YROGRHQGH� UHVXOWDWHQSUHVHQWHHUGHQ�RP�GH�JHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�WH�EHUHNHQHQ��5HVXOWHUHQGH� VHW� YDQ� VWXGLHV� (U�ZHUGHQ� LQ� WRWDDO� �� VWXGLHV� JHYRQGHQ� �]LH� WDEHO� �����0HHUGHUH�VWXGLHV��RQGHU�DQGHUH�&DVHUWD��/XQG��������/LHEHUPDQ��9LGHND�6KHUPDQ������� NRQGHQ� QLHW� LQ� GH� DQDO\VHV� RSJHQRPHQ� ZRUGHQ� RPGDW� RQYROGRHQGH� GDWDJHSUHVHQWHHUG�ZHUGHQ�RP�GH�JHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�WH�EHUHNHQHQ�

Page 108: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

7DEHO������6WXGLHV�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKRVRFLDOH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS�KHW�YHUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�JHYROJHQ�YRRU�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�YDQ�KHWYHUOLHV�YDQ�GH�SDUWQHU�GRRU�GH�GRRG�6WXGLH &RQGLWLHV 1 'RHOJURHS 5&7D 0HHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ GFWU�E GIX

�F

&RQVWDQWLQR����� ��� &ULVLV�LQWHUYHQWLH����ZHNHOLMNVH�JURHSVVHVVLHV���� $OOHHQ�VRFLDOH�DFWLYLWHLWHQ����ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV���� *HHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH�����

$OOHHQ�ZHGXZHQ - 'HSUHVVLRQ�$GMHFWLYH&KHFNOLVW G ����� -

&RQVWDQWLQR����� ��� &ULVLVLQWHUYHQWLH����ZHNHOLMNVH�JURHSVVHVVLHV���� $OOHHQ�VRFLDOH�DFWLYLWHLWHQ��� *HHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH������

$OOHHQ�ZHGXZHQ � %', G� ����� ��PQG��G� ������ PQG��G� ��������PQG��G� �����/HY\�HW�DO������� ��� 2QGHUVWHXQLQJVJURHS��JHPLGGHOG���JURHSVVHVVLHV���� 9HUJHOLMNLQJVJURHS ���� :HGXZHQ��ZHGXZQDDUV - &(6�'��3206�'��3206�7 G� ����� -5HLFK��=DXWUD����� ��� 7UDLQLQJ�LQ�FRJQLWLHYH�FRQWUROH����VHVVLHV���� *HHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH ���� 2XGHUH�ZHGXZHQ��ZHGXZQDDUV � 3V\FKRORJLVFKH�GLVWUHVV�VDPHQJHVWHOG�XLW�PHHUGHUHLQVWUXPHQWHQ�

G ������ -

6FKXW�HW�DO������� ��� &RXQVHOLQJ��SUREOHP�IRFXVHG����ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV���� &RXQVHOLQJ��HPRWLRQ�IRFXVHG����ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV���� *HHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH������

:HGXZHQ��ZHGXZQDDUV � *+4 ���G� ��������G� ����� � PQG���� G �������� G �����7XGLYHU�HW�DO������ ��� =HOIKXOSJURHS����JURHSVVHVVLHV���� :DFKWOLMVW ���� $OOHHQ�YHUZHGXZGHPDQQHQ � *+4��%',��67$, G� ����� ��PQG��G� ��������PQG��G� �����9DQ�/DPPHUHQ *HHOHQ������ ��� 9DDUGLJKHLGVWUDLQLQJ�����ZHNHOLMNVH�JURHSVVHVVLHV���� 9HUJHOLMNLQJVJURHS ���� $OOHHQ�ZHGXZHQ - =XQJ��� G� ������ ��PQG��G� ������

D��5&7��µUDQGRPL]HG�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO¶��ZHO�JHHQ�UDQGRP�WRHZLM]LQJ�DDQ�FRQGLWLHV��E��GFWU� JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�YDQ�H[SHULPHQWHOH�YHUVXV�FRQWUROHFRQGLWLH�ELM�SRVW�WHVW�F� GIX��JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�ELM�IROORZ�XS�PHWLQJ�

Page 109: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

'H� RQGHU]RFKWH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� YDULHHUGHQ� VWHUN� �FULVLVLQWHUYHQWLH�� ]HOIKXOSJURHSHQ�FRXQVHOLQJ�� YDDUGLJKHLGVWUDLQLQJ��� 6RPPLJH� VWXGLHV� ZDUHQ� XLWVOXLWHQG� JHULFKW� RSZHGXZHQ��ppQ�VWXGLH�RQGHU]RFKW�DOOHHQ�ZHGXZQDDUV��6RPV�ZHUGHQ�DOOHHQ�RXGHUHQ�LQ�GHVWXGLH� EHWURNNHQ�� VRPV� YHUZHGXZGHQ� YDQ� DOOH� OHHIWLMGHQ�� ,Q� �� VWXGLHV� ZHUG� HHQJHUDQGRPLVHHUG� GHVLJQ� JHEUXLNW�� 'H� TXDVL�H[SHULPHQWHOH� VWXGLHV� JHEUXLNWHQ� JHHQJHPDWFKWH�YHUJHOLMNLQJVJURHSHQ�ZDDUGRRU�GH�UHVXOWDWHQ�PRHLOLMN�LQWHUSUHWHHUEDDU�]LMQ�0HWKRGH� 0HWD�DQDO\VH�YDQ�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�GH� JHHVWHOLMNH� JH]RQGKHLG�RSEDVLV�YDQ�KHW�µUDQGRP�HIIHFWV¶�PRGHO�5HVXOWDWHQ(U�NRQGHQ� LQ� WRWDDO� �� FRQWUDVWJURHSHQ� VDPHQJHVWHOG�ZRUGHQ��PHW� HHQ� WRWDOH� SRSXODWLHYDQ������'H�JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�ZDV�������PHW�HHQ�����EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDOYDQ� ±����� WRW� ����� �=� � ������ Q�V���� 'LW� LV� HHQ� PLGGHOJURRW� HIIHFW�� GDW� HFKWHU� QLHWVLJQLILFDQW�LV�+HW�SHUFHQWDJH�YDULDQWLH�GDW�YHUNODDUG�ZHUG�GRRU�VWHHNSURHIIOXFWXDWLHV�EHGURHJ�VOHFKWV����� ZDW� GXLGW� RS� HHQ� ]HHU� KHWHURJHQH� VHW� YDQ� VWXGLHV�� (U� ZHUG� HHQ� FOXVWHU�DQDO\VHXLWJHYRHUG�RP�WH�]RHNHQ�QDDU�KRPRJHQH�FOXVWHUV�YDQ�VWXGLHV��'H�FOXVWHU�DQDO\VH�OHLGGHWRW�YLHU�FOXVWHUV�YDQ�VWXGLHV��GLH�PRHLOLMN�LQKRXGHOLMN�LQWHUSUHWHHUEDDU�ZDUHQ�2S GH� ODQJHUH� WHUPLMQ� YRQGHQ� ZH� GH� PHHVWH� XLWNRPVWHQ� LQ� GH� SHULRGH� YDQ� �� WRW� �PDDQGHQ� QD� DIORRS� YDQ� GH� LQWHUYHQWLH� ��� FRQWUDVWJURHSHQ�� 1� � �����:H� YRQGHQ� HHQJHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�G�YDQ�����������EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDO�±�����WRW�������=� ������Q�V���SHUFHQWDJH�GRRU�VWHHNSURHIIOXFWXDWLHV�YHUNODDUGH�YDULDQWLH����������:DQQHHUZH�GH]H�VHW�YDQ�VWXGLHV�EHSHUNWHQ�WRW�JHUDQGRPLVHHUGH�WULDOV��DDQWDO�FRQWUDVWJURHSHQ� ��� 1� � ����� ZHUG� ZHO� HHQ� VLJQLILFDQW� JHPLGGHOG� HIIHFW� JHYRQGHQ� �G� � ������ ���EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDO�� ����� WRW� ������ =� � ������ S� �� ������ SHUFHQWDJH� GRRUVWHHNSURHIIOXFWXDWLHV�YHUNODDUGH�YDULDQWLH���������&RQFOXVLHV%HODQJULMNVWH�EHSHUNLQJHQ� ����.OHLQ�DDQWDO�VWXGLHV��GLH�VWHUN�YHUVFKLOOHQ�ZDW�EHWUHIW����GH�RQGHU]RFKWH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�� ����GH�GRHOJURHSHQ��HQ� ����RQGHU]RHNVGHVLJQV��'RRU�GH]HEHSHUNLQJHQ� PRHWHQ� GH� UHVXOWDWHQ� YDQ� GH� PHWD�DQDO\VHV� PHW� GH� DOOHUJURRWVWHYRRU]LFKWLJKHLG�EHVFKRXZG�ZRUGHQ��(U�LV�RQYROGRHQGH�JRHG�RQGHU]RHN�XLWJHYRHUG�RPKDUGH�FRQFOXVLHV�WH�WUHNNHQ�8LWNRPVWHQ� 'H� RQGHU]RFKWH� VWXGLHV� EOHNHQ� ]HHU� KHWHURJHHQ�ZDW� EHWUHIW� GHVLJQ�� ,Q� GHXLWJHYRHUGH� PHWD�DQDO\VH� YRQGHQ� ZH� GDW� GH� JHPLGGHOGH� HIIHFWJURRWWH� YDQ� GHRQGHU]RFKWH� VWXGLHV� PLGGHOJURRW� ZDV�� PDDU� QLHW� VLJQLILFDQW� YHUVFKLOGH� YDQ� ��� ,Q� GHJHUDQGRPLVHHUGH�VWXGLHV�ZHUG�RS�ODQJHUH�WHUPLMQ����WRW���PDDQGHQ�QD�DIORRS��ZHO�HHQVLJQLILFDQW��]LM�KHW�NOHLQ��HIIHFW�JHYRQGHQ�'LW OLMNW� HU� RS� WH� GXLGHQ� GDW� HU� LQWHUYHQWLHV� EHVWDDQ� GLH� GH� FRQVHTXHQWLHV� YRRU� GHJHHVWHOLMNH� JH]RQGKHLG� YDQ� KHW� RYHUOLMGHQ� YDQ� GH� SDUWQHU� NXQQHQ� UHGXFHUHQ�� DQGHUHLQWHUYHQWLHV�]LMQ�GDDU�QLHW�WRH�LQ�VWDDW��2S�EDVLV�YDQ�GH�XLWJHYRHUGH�PHWD�DQDO\VH�LV�KHWHFKWHU� QLHW� PRJHOLMN� RP� DDQ� WH� JHYHQ� ZHONH� NHQPHUNHQ� YDQ� GH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� WRW� HHQKRJHUH�HIIHFWLYLWHLW�OHLGHQ�

Page 110: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

���� 9HUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�JHYROJHQ�YDQ�ZHUNHORRVKHLGYRRU�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG3UREOHHPVWHOOLQJ8LW HSLGHPLRORJLVFK� RQGHU]RHN� NRPW� QDDU� YRUHQ� GDW� ZHUNHORRVKHLG� EHODQJULMNHQHJDWLHYH�JHYROJHQ�KHHIW�YRRU�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�HQ�KHW�ZHOEHYLQGHQ��9LQRNXUHW�DO����������9HUGHU�EOLMNW�GDW�ZDQQHHU�HHQ�ZHUNHORRV�LHPDQG�RSQLHXZ�ZHUN�YLQGW��GHQHJDWLHYH�FRQVHTXHQWLHV�YRRU�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�RSJHKHYHQ�ZRUGHQ�HQ�GDW�KXQHHUGHUH�QLYHDX�YDQ�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�KHUVWHOG�ZRUGW��3UHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�]LMQHU�GDDURP�VRPV�RS�JHULFKW�RP�YDDUGLJKHGHQ�WH�RQWZLNNHOHQ�GLH�ZHUNHOR]HQ�KHOSHQ�RP�RSQLHXZ��ZHUN�WH�YLQGHQ��(HQ�VXFFHVYRO�YRRUEHHOG�YDQ�HHQ�GHUJHOLMNH�LQWHUYHQWLH�LV�GHµ-RE� )LQGLQJ� &OXE¶�� ZDDULQ� GHHOQHPHUV� YDDUGLJKHGHQ� OHUHQ� HQ� GDDUQDDVW� RRN� OHUHQJHEUXLN� WH� PDNHQ� YDQ� GH� PRJHOLMNKHGHQ� YDQ� VRFLDOH� RQGHUVWHXQLQJ� LQ� KXQ� GLUHFWHRPJHYLQJ� �$]ULQ�HW� DO��� �������������'H]H� VWXGLHV� ODWHQ�SRVLWLHYH�HIIHFWHQ�]LHQ�RS�GHNDQV�RP�QLHXZ�ZHUN�WH�YLQGHQ��'H�YHURQGHUVWHOOLQJ�GDW�KHW�YLQGHQ�YDQ�QLHXZ�ZHUN�GRRUGH� LQWHUYHQWLH� RRN� OHLGW� WRW� EHWHUH� JHHVWHOLMNH� JH]RQGKHLG�� LV� VOHFKWV� LQ� ppQ� VWXGLHRQGHU]RFKW� �5LIH� � %HOFKHU�� ������� (HQ� DQGHU� YRRUEHHOG� LV� KHW� -2%6�SURJUDPPD�RQWZLNNHOG� YDQXLW� KHW� 0LFKLJDQ� 3UHYHQWLRQ� 5HVHDUFK� &HQWHU�� ZDDULQ� HYHQHHQVYDDUGLJKHLGVWUDLQLQJ�� VRFLDOH� RQGHUVWHXQLQJ�� PDDU� RRN� YHUEHWHULQJ� YDQ� GH]HOIZDDUGHULQJ�FHQWUDDO�VWDDQ�9UDDJVWHOOLQJ.XQQHQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� GH� JHYROJHQ� YDQ� ZHUNHORRVKHLG� YRRU� GH� JHHVWHOLMNHJH]RQGKHLG�UHGXFHUHQ"0HWKRGH6HOHFWLH�YDQ�VWXGLHV� 9LD� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� OLWHUDWXXUVHDUFK� LQ�3V\FKOLW� HQ�0HGOLQH� ������������,QFOXVLHFULWHULD� 6WXGLHV�ZHUGHQ�LQ�GH�PHWD�DQDO\VH�RSJHQRPHQ�DOV�]LM�����JHULFKW�ZDUHQRS�PHQVHQ� GLH�ZHUNHORRV�ZDUHQ�� ���� XLWNRPVWHQ� YDQ� HHQ� LQWHUYHQWLH� YRRU� JHHVWHOLMNHJH]RQGKHLG� UDSSRUWHHUGHQ�� HQ� ���� JHEUXLN�PDDNWHQ� YDQ� HHQ� FRQWUROHJURHS� HQ� SUH�� HQSRVWWHVW� GDWD� UDSSRUWHHUGHQ� �HQ� YROGRHQGH� UHVXOWDWHQ� SUHVHQWHHUGHQ� RP� GHJHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�WH�EHUHNHQHQ��5HVXOWHUHQGH� VHW� YDQ� VWXGLHV� 7HJHQ� GH� YHUZDFKWLQJ� LQ� ZHUGHQ� VOHFKWV� �� VWXGLHVJHYRQGHQ�GLH�YROGHGHQ�DDQ�DOOH�LQFOXVLHFULWHULD��]LH�WDEHO�������(U�ZHUGHQ�ZHO�PHHUGHUHVWXGLHV�JHYRQGHQ�QDDU�LQWHUYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V�YRRU�ZHUNHOR]HQ��RQGHU�DQGHUH�$]ULQ�HWDO���������������*UD\���������PDDU�LQ�GH]H�VWXGLHV�ZHUGHQ�GH�HIIHFWHQ�RS�GH�JHHVWHOLMNHJH]RQGKHLG�QLHW�RQGHU]RFKW��7ZHH�YDQ�GH�GULH�JHVHOHFWHHUGH�VWXGLHV�EHWUHIIHQ�KHW�-2%6�SURJUDPPD�� 2PGDW� GH]H� VWXGLHV� UHGHOLMN� JURWH� SRSXODWLHV� RPYDWWHQ�� GHJHOLMN� ]LMQRSJH]HW�HQ�XLWJHYRHUG�HQ�EHODQJULMNH�YRRUEHHOGHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V�YRUPHQ�SUHVHQWHUHQ�ZLM�RRN�GH�EHYLQGLQJHQ�YDQ�GH]H�JURHS�YDQ�GULH�VWXGLHV�0HWKRGH� 0HWD�DQDO\VH�YDQ�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG��RSEDVLV�YDQ�KHW�UDQGRP�HIIHFWV�PRGHO�

Page 111: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

7DEHO�������6WXGLHV�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKRVRFLDOH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS�KHW�YHUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�JHYROJHQ�YDQ�ZHUNHORRVKHLG�YRRU�GH�JHHVWHOLMNHJH]RQGKHLG�6WXGLH &RQGLWLHV 1 'RHOJURHS 5&7D 0HHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ GFWU�E GIX

�F

&DSODQ�HW�DO������ ��� -2%6�SURJUDPPD����VHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� $OOHHQ�LQIRUPDWLH ����� KRRJ�ULVLFRZHUNHOR]HQ � +RSNLQV�6\PSWRP&KHFNOLVW G ����� ��PQG��G� ��������PQG��G� �����5LIH���%HOFKHU����� ��� µ-RE�ILQGLQJ¶�FOXE��� &RQWUROHJURHS ���� DOOH�ZHUNHOR]HQ � *'6 G� ����� -9LQRNXU�HW�DO������ ��� -2%6�SURJUDPPD����VHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� $OOHHQ�LQIRUPDWLH ������ KRRJ�ULVLFRZHUNHOR]HQ � +RSNLQV�6\PSWRP&KHFNOLVW G ����� -

D��5&7��µUDQGRPL]HG�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO¶��ZHO�JHHQ�UDQGRP�WRHZLM]LQJ�DDQ�FRQGLWLHV��E��GFWU� JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�YDQ�H[SHULPHQWHOH�YHUVXV�FRQWUROHFRQGLWLH�ELM�SRVW�WHVW�F� GIX��JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�ELM�IROORZ�XS�PHWLQJ�

Page 112: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

5HVXOWDWHQ(U�NRQGHQ�GULH�FRQWUDVWJURHSHQ�VDPHQJHVWHOG�ZRUGHQ�PHW�HHQ�WRWDOH�SRSXODWLH�YDQ�����'H JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�ZDV������PHW�HHQ�����EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDO�YDQ�±����WRW�������=� �������S��������SHUFHQWDJH�GRRU�VWHHNSURHIIOXFWXDWLHV�YHUNODDUGH�YDULDQWLH�������� 9DQZHJH� KHW� NOHLQH� SHUFHQWDJH� YHUNODDUGH� YDULDQWLH� ZHUG� HHQ� DDQYXOOHQGHDQDO\VH�XLWJHYRHUG�PHW�DOOHHQ�GH�WZHH�VWXGLHV�QDDU�KHW�-2%6�SURJUDPPD��'DDUELM�ZHUGHHQ�VWHUN�VLJQLILFDQWH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�G�YDQ������JHYRQGHQ� ����EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDOYDQ������WRW�������=� �������S����������SHUFHQWDJH�GRRU�VWHHNSURHIIOXFWXDWLHV�YHUNODDUGHYDULDQWLH���������*H]LHQ�KHW�NOHLQH�DDQWDO�VWXGLHV�PRHWHQ�GH]H�UHVXOWDWHQ�HFKWHU�PHW�GHQRGLJH�YRRU]LFKWLJKHLG�EHVFKRXZG�ZRUGHQ�&RQFOXVLHV%HODQJULMNVWH� EHSHUNLQJHQ� ���� =HHU� NOHLQ� DDQWDO� VWXGLHV�� ���� PHW� YHUVFKLOOHQGHRQGHU]RFKWH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�HQ�����PHW�VOHFKWV�ppQ�VWXGLH�GLH�GH�HIIHFWHQ�RS�ODQJHUH�WHUPLMQRQGHU]RFKW�8LWNRPVWHQ� 'H�LQWHUYHQWLHV�]LMQ�HU�YRRUDO�RS�JHULFKW�RP�ZHUNHOR]HQ�WH�RQGHUVWHXQHQ�ELMKHW�YLQGHQ�YDQ�QLHXZ�ZHUN��+RHZHO�HU�PHHUGHUH�VWXGLHV�YHUULFKW�]LMQ�GLH�DDQWRQHQ�GDWRQGHUVWHXQLQJ�YDQ�ZHUNHOR]HQ�HUWRH� OHLGW�GDW�GHHOQHPHUV�VQHOOHU�ZHUN�YLQGHQ��YRQGHQZH�VOHFKWV�GULH� VWXGLHV�ZDDULQ�RRN�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�GH]H� LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�GH�JHHVWHOLMNHJH]RQGKHLG�GLUHFW�ZHUGHQ�RQGHU]RFKW��'H]H�GULH�VWXGLHV�KDGGHQ�VDPHQ�HHQ�PLGGHOJURRWHIIHFW�� 'H� WZHH� VWXGLHV� GLH� KHW� -2%6� SURJUDPPD� RQGHU]RFKWHQ�� UHVXOWHHUGHQ� LQ� HHQVLJQLILFDQW�PLGGHOJURRW� HIIHFW�� 'H]H� UHVXOWDWHQ� OLMNHQ� HU� RS� WH� GXLGHQ� GDW� SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV� LQ�VWDDW�]LMQ�GH�QHJDWLHYH�JHYROJHQ�YDQ�ZHUNHORRVKHLG�YRRU�GH�JHHVWHOLMNHJH]RQGKHLG�WH�UHGXFHUHQ�

���� +HW�YHUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�EHODVWLQJ�YDQ�IDPLOLHOHGHQYDQ�KXOSEHKRHYHQGH�RXGHUHQ3UREOHHPVWHOOLQJ+HW� ]RUJHQ� YRRU� HHQ� KXOSEHKRHYHQGH� RXGHU� IDPLOLHOLG� LV� YRRU� YHHO� EHWURNNHQHQ� HHQ]ZDUH�EHODVWLQJ��&XLMSHUV�HW�DO����������'RRUJDDQV�LV�HU�ppQ�SHUVRRQ�GLH�GH]H�]RUJ�YRRU]LMQ�RI�KDDU�UHNHQLQJ�QHHPW��'H]H�URO�YDQ�FHQWUDOH�RI�SULPDLUH�YHU]RUJHU�ZRUGW�PHHVWDOYHUYXOG�GRRU�GH�SDUWQHU�HQ�DOV�GH]H�QLHW�EHVFKLNEDDU� LV�GRRU�HHQ�GRFKWHU�RI�HHQ�DQGHUIDPLOLHOLG��1DDVW�GH�WLMG�HQ�PRHLWH�GLH�GH�GDDGZHUNHOLMNH�]RUJ�NRVW��NXQQHQ�EHWURNNHQHQRRN�WH�PDNHQ�KHEEHQ�PHW�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�YDQ�GH�RXGHUH��ELMYRRUEHHOG� LQ�KHW�JHYDOYDQ�GHPHQWLH���9HUGHU�JHEHXUW�KHW�QRJDO�HHQV�GDW�GH�YHU]RUJHUV�LQ�HHQ�LVROHPHQW�WHUHFKWNRPHQ�HQ�GDW�KHW�DDQWDO�VRFLDOH�FRQWDFWHQ�VWHUN�YHUPLQGHUW��(PRWLRQHHO�HUYDUHQ�]LM�YDDNHHQ� URXZSURFHV� GDW� VDPHQKDQJW�PHW� GH� DFKWHUXLWJDQJ� YDQ� GH� RXGHUH��'LYHUVH� VWXGLHVKHEEHQ�GXLGHOLMN�JHPDDNW�GDW�GH]H�YHU]RUJHUV�HHQ�YHUKRRJG�ULVLFR�KHEEHQ�RS�GHSUHVVLH�YHUVOHFKWHUGH�JH]RQGKHLG�HQ�FKURQLVFKH�YHUPRHLGKHLG��'XLMQVWHH��������(U�]LMQ�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�SV\FKRVRFLDOH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RQWZLNNHOG�JHULFKW�RS�RQGHUVWHXQLQJYDQ� GH]H� IDPLOLHOHGHQ�� 'DDUELM� NDQ� KHW� JDDQ� RP� YRRUOLFKWLQJ� RYHU� KHW� ]LHNWHEHHOG�RQGHUVWHXQLQJ�GRRU�PLGGHO� YDQ� ]HOIKXOS�� HQ� RQGHUVWHXQLQJVJURHSHQ� HQ� SV\FKR�HGXFD�WLHYH�FXUVXVVHQ�ZDDULQ�EHWURNNHQHQ�YDDUGLJKHGHQ�OHUHQ�KRH�PHW�GH�VLWXDWLH�RP�WH�JDDQ�

Page 113: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

9UDDJVWHOOLQJ.XQQHQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� GH� QHJDWLHYH� JHYROJHQ� YDQ� KHW� ]RUJHQ� YRRU� HHQKXOSEHKRHYHQG�RXGHU�IDPLOLHOLG�EHSHUNHQ"0HWKRGH6HOHFWLH�YDQ�VWXGLHV� 9LD� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� OLWHUDWXXUVHDUFK� LQ�3V\FKOLW� HQ�0HGOLQH� �������������ELEOLRWKHHN�7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW��UHIHUHQWLHV�XLW�YHU]DPHOGH�OLWHUDWXXU�,QFOXVLHFULWHULD� ���� KHW� PRHW� JDDQ� RP� RQGHU]RHN� QDDU� GH� HIIHFWHQ� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV�����ZDDULQ�HHQ�FRQWUROHJURHS�LV�JHEUXLNW������PHW�HHQ�VWHHNSURHIJURRWWH�YDQWHQPLQVWH�����HQ�����ZDDULQ�GH�HIIHFWHQ�RS�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�ZRUGHQ�JHPHWHQ��HQYROGRHQGH�UHVXOWDWHQ�SUHVHQWHUHQ�RP�GH�JHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�WH�EHUHNHQHQ��1LHW�JHVHOHFWHHUG�ZHUG�RQGHU]RHN�QDDU�EHKDQGHOLQJ��WHUXJYDOSUHYHQWLH�HQ�QDDU�SUHYHQWLHYDQ�VRPDWLVFKH�DDQGRHQLQJHQ�5HVXOWHUHQGH�VHW�YDQ�VWXGLHV� :H�VHOHFWHHUGHQ�]HV�HIIHFWRQGHU]RHNHQ�RYHU�SUHYHQWLH�YDQSV\FKLVFKH�SUREOHPHQ�ELM�YHU]RUJHUV�YDQ�RXGHUHQ�ZDDURQGHU� ��5&7¶V� �]LH�WDEHO �����%LM�GH�RQGHU]RFKWH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�JDDW�KHW�RP�GLYHUVH�FRPELQDWLHV�YDQ�QLHW�LQ�DOOH�JHYDOOHQGXLGHOLMN� RPVFKUHYHQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV�� 9RRUEHHOGHQ� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHRQGHUGHOHQ� ]LMQ�YRRUOLFKWLQJ� JHYHQ�� LQGLYLGXHOH� HQ� JURHSVJHVSUHNNHQ�� OHUHQ� SUREOHPHQ� RS� WH� ORVVHQ�HPRWLRQHOH�VWHXQ�ELHGHQ��RQWVSDQQLQJVRHIHQLQJHQ�HQ�DVVHUWLYLWHLWVWUDLQLQJ�0HWKRGH� PHWD�DQDO\VH�RS�EDVLV�YDQ�KHW�UDQGRP�HIIHFWV�PRGHO�5HVXOWDWHQ'H JHPLGGHOGH� HIIHFWJURRWWH� YDQ� YLHU� VWXGLHV� YRRU� GHSUHVVLHV\PSWRPHQ� �%URGDW\� *UHVKDP��������0F&XUU\�HW�DO���������0RKLGH�HW�DO���������.DKDQ�HW�DO���������RS�GHODDWVWH�PHWLQJ�������RI���PDDQGHQ��LV�NOHLQ�HQ�QLHW�VLJQLILFDQW��G ������= �������S ���������EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDO� LV�±�����±��������'H�DI]RQGHUOLMNH�G�ZDDUGHQ�]LMQ�NOHLQ������HQ�������HQ�ELM�WZHH�RQGHU]RHNHQ�]HOIV�QHJDWLHI��������UHVS��±�������0RKLGH�HW�DO�UDSSRUWHUHQ� HYHQHHQV� JHHQ� HIIHFW� RS� DQJVWV\PSWRPHQ� �G ������� 'H� YLHU� SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV�YHUVFKLOOHQ�RQGHUOLQJ��*HULQJH�SRVLWLHYH�HIIHFWHQ�ZHUGHQ�EHKDDOG�PHW� HHQFRPELQDWLH� YDQ� RQGHUVWHXQHQGH� DFWLYLWHLWHQ� LQ� JURHSVYHUEDQG� YHUVXV� HHQ� PHHU� RS� GHGHPHQWHUHQGH� SDWLsQW� JHULFKWH� SUHYHQWLH� HQ� LQ� KHW� WZHHGH� ELM� HHQ� FRPELQDWLH� YDQDQGHUVRRUWLJH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�LQFOXVLHI�HHQ�FRJQLWLHYH�JHGUDJVWKHUDSHXWLVFKH�(HQ�YLMIGH�VWXGLH��=DULW�HW�DO���������JHHIW�XLWVOXLWHQG��JHULQJH��XLWNRPVWHQ�YRRU�WZHHSUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV��RS�DFWLYHUHQGH�PDQLHU�VWHXQ�ELHGHQ�LQ�JURHSVYHUEDQG�YHUVXV�LQJH]LQVYHUEDQG�� DI]RQGHUOLMN� �ppQ� JHULQJ� HQ� HHQ� QHJDWLHI� HIIHFW��� $OOHHQ� ELM� GH� ]HVGHVWXGLH� �7RVHODQG� � 6PLWK�� ����E�� EOLMNW� KHW� HIIHFW� YDQ� � FRXQVHOLQJJHVSUHNNHQ� GRRUSURIHVVLRQHOH� NUDFKWHQ� pQ� GRRU� OHHIWLMGVJHQRWHQ� JURRW� WH� ]LMQ� �G ����� UHVSHFWLHYHOLMN������� (HUGHUH� RQGHU]RHNHQ� YDQ� 7RVHODQG� HW� DO�� �����D�� ����E�� ����D�� EHVFKULMYHQHFKWHU� LQ� NZDOLWDWLHYH� WHUPHQ� HHQ� YHHO� EHVFKHLGHQHU� HQ� QLHW� VLJQLILFDQW� UHVXOWDDW� YDQGH]HOIGH�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLH�YRRU�GH]HOIGH�GRHOJURHS�

Page 114: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

7DEHO������6WXGLHV�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKRVRFLDOH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS�KHW�YHUPLQGHUHQ�YDQ�GH�JHYROJHQ�YDQ�KHW�]RUJHQ�YRRU�HHQ�KXOSEHKRHYHQGRXGHU�IDPLOLHOLG�YRRU�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�2QGHU]RHN 'RHOJURHS &RQGLWLHV 1 5&7D 8LWYDO 3UREOHPHQ�LQVWUXP� 8LWNRPVWHQ%URGDW\�*UHVKDP������ 9HU]RUJHUV�GHPHQWHUHQGHRXGHUH 9RRUOLFKWLQJ��FRSLQJ��VWUHVVPDQDJHPHQW��JURHSVVHVVLHV�JH]LQVWKHUDSLH��UROOHQVSHO��JHGUDJVWKHUDSLH,QWHUYHQWLH:DFKWOLMVW����PDDQGHQ�

������

� " +56'��GHSUHVVLH��*+4��=XQJ¶V�6'6�GHSUHVVLH�G ����������PQG�

0RKLGH�HW�DO������ 9HU]RUJHUV�GHPHQWHUHQGHRXGHUHQ ��� &DUHJLYHU�VXSSRUW�SURJUDP����PDDQGHOLMNVH�VHVVLHVYDQ���XXU���� 1RUPDOH�ZLMNYHUSOHJLQJ����

� �������PQG� &(6�'��GHSUHVVLH��67$,��DQJVW� &(6�'�G ���������PQG���G ��������PQG�67$,�G ���������PQG�0F&XUU\�HW�DO������ 9HU]RUJHUV�GHPHQWHUHQGHRXGHUHQ ��� *URHSVEHKDQGHOLQJ����ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV���� ,QGLYLGXHOH�EHKDQGHOLQJ����ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV���� *HHQ�EHKDQGHOLQJ

������ �������PQG� &(6�'��GHSUHVVLH� &(6�'��(����(���G ����������PQG�

=DULW�HW�DO������ 9HU]RUJHUV�GHPHQWHUHQGHRXGHUHQ ��� 6XSSRUW�JURXS��� ,QGLYLGXHOH�JH]LQV�FRXQVHOLQJ��� :DFKWOLMVW����ZHNHQ�������

- �������PQG� %6,�����$QJVW�HQGHSUHVVLH� %6,����PQG����� G �������� G �����7RVHODQG�6PLWK������E �6FKRRQ�GRFKWHU��YHU�]RUJHUV�PHW�YHHO�VWUHVVGRRU�YHU]RUJLQJKXOSEHKRHYHQGH�RXGHU

��� 3URIHVVLRQHOH�LQGLYLGXHOH�FRXQVHOLQJ����ZHNHOLMNVHVHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� 3HHU�FRXQVHOLQJ����ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� *HHQ�FRXQVHOLQJ

������

- �������PQG� %6,�����$QJVW�HQGHSUHVVLH� %6,��DQJVW�����G� ��������G� �����%6,��GHSUHVVLH�����G�� ��������G� �����.DKDQ�HW�DO������ 9HU]RUJHUV�GHPHQWHUHQGHRXGHUHQ ��� 6XSSRUW�JURXS��YRRUOLFKWLQJ��SUREOHHPRSORVVHQ�FRJQLWLHI�JHGUDJVWK�����ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� *HHQ�VXSSRUW�JURXS

����

- " =XQJ¶V�6'6�GHSUHVVLH� G ���������PQG�

D��5&7��µUDQGRPL]HG�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO¶��ZHO�JHHQ�UDQGRP�WRHZLM]LQJ�DDQ�FRQGLWLHV��

Page 115: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

&RQFOXVLHV%HODQJULMNVWH� EHSHUNLQJHQ� ���� 0HHUGHUH� VWXGLHV� NRQGHQ� QLHW� LQ� GH� DQDO\VHVPHHJHQRPHQ�ZRUGHQ�RPGDW�KHW�QLHW�PRJHOLMN�ZDV�RP�HIIHFWJURRWWHV�WH�EHUHNHQHQ�����KHW�DDQWDO�JHVHOHFWHHUGH�VWXGLHV�LV�UHODWLHI�NOHLQ�8LWNRPVWHQ� ,Q� RQ]H�PHWD�DQDO\VH� YLQGHQ� ZH� JHHQ� VLJQLILFDQW� HIIHFW� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHVJHULFKW� RS� RQGHUVWHXQLQJ� YDQ� IDPLOLHOHGHQ� YDQ� KXOSEHKRHYHQGH� RXGHUHQ�� ,Q� HHQ�5&7PHW�JURWH�VWHHNSURHI��0LWWHOPDQ�HW�DO���������������GLH�ZH�QLHW�LQ�RQ]H�VHOHFWLH�NRQGHQRSQHPHQ� ZHUG� JHYRQGHQ� GDW� HHQ� FRPELQDWLH� YDQ� LQGLYLGXHOH� JHVSUHNNHQ� PHWJH]LQVJHVSUHNNHQ�QD�HHQ�MDDU�QRJ�WRW�VLJQLILFDQW�PLQGHU�GHSUHVVLHYH�V\PSWRPHQ�OHLGGH�S� �� �������� 0RJHOLMN� GDW� GH]H� FRPELQDWLH� JURWHUH� HIIHFWHQ� RSOHYHUW�� PDDU� RS� GLWPRPHQW�LV�GH�ZHWHQVFKDSSHOLMNH�HYLGHQWLH�GDDUYRRU�QRJ�RQYROGRHQGH�

Page 116: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�GHHUYDUHQ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�HQ�VHOI�HIILFDF\���� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ3UREOHHPVWHOOLQJ6RFLDOH� VWHXQ� NDQ� PHQ� RPVFKULMYHQ� DOV� �SRVLWLHYH�� HIIHFWHQ� YDQ� LQWHUDFWLHV� RS� HHQEHSDDOG� LQGLYLGX� �6FKUDPHLHU���������9HUVFKLOOHQGH�DXWHXUV� ]LHQ� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ�QLHW� DOVppQ�FRQFHSW��PDDU�YHHOPHHU�DOV�HHQ�FRQWDLQHUEHJULS�RI�PHWD�FRQVWUXFW�YDQ�YHUVFKLOOHQGHFRQFHSWXHHO� YDQ� HONDDU� WH� RQGHUVFKHLGHQ� FRPSRQHQWHQ� �'H� 5LGGHU�� ������ 9DQ6RQGHUHQ���������9DDN�ZRUGW�GDDUELM�HHQ�RQGHUVFKHLG�JHPDDNW�WXVVHQ�HPRWLRQHOH�VWHXQ�KHW� JHYHQ� YDQ� HPSDWKLH�� YHUWURXZHQ� HQ� ZDDUGHULQJ��� LQVWUXPHQWHOH� VWHXQ� �FRQFUHWH�SUDNWLVFKH�KXOS���LQIRUPDWLHYH�KXOS��DGYLVHULQJ�HQ�UHOHYDQWH�LQIRUPDWLH��HQ�HYDOXDWLHYHVWHXQ��KHW�JHYHQ�YDQ�IHHGEDFN�RYHU�KHW�IXQFWLRQHUHQ��9HHO�SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�GLH� LQ�GH�SUDNWLMN�ZRUGHQ�XLWJHYRHUG�]LMQ�JHULFKW�RS�KHWEHYRUGHUHQ�YDQ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�DDQ�SHUVRQHQ�GLH�HHQ�YHUKRRJG�ULVLFR�ORSHQ�RS�SV\FKLVFKHSUREOHPHQ� RI� PLQGHU� NXQQHQ� EHVFKLNNHQ� RYHU� EURQQHQ� YDQ� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ�� +HWEHYRUGHUHQ� YDQ� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ� NDQ� RS� YHUVFKLOOHQGH� PDQLHUHQ� JHEHXUHQ�� (HQ� YHHOWRHJHSDVWH�PHWKRGH� LV� GLH� YDQ� GH� RQGHUVWHXQLQJV�� RI� ORWJHQRWHQJURHS��$DQ� GHUJHOLMNHJURHSHQ� QHPHQ� SHUVRQHQ� GHHO� GLH� HHQ� YHUJHOLMNEDUH� LQJULMSHQGH� JHEHXUWHQLV� KHEEHQPHHJHPDDNW��'H�GHHOQHPHUV�ZLVVHOHQ�HUYDULQJHQ�HQ�HPRWLHV�XLW�HQ�ELHGHQ�HONDDU�VRFLDOHVWHXQ��(HQ�DQGHUH�PDQLHU� LV�RP�SHUVRQHQ�XLW� ULVLFRJURHSHQ� WH� WUDLQHQ� LQ�YDDUGLJKHGHQRP�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�WH�YHUZHUYHQ��VRFLDOH�HQ�FRJQLWLHYH�YDDUGLJKHGHQ��9UDDJVWHOOLQJ.DQ� KHW� ELHGHQ� YDQ� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ� GH� QHJDWLHYH� JHYROJHQ� YDQ� LQJULMSHQGHOHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� RI� FKURQLVFKH� VWUHVVRUHQ� �]RDOV� ]ZDQJHUVFKDS� RQGHU� RQJXQVWLJHRPVWDQGLJKHGHQ�RI�]RUJ�YRRU�HHQ�FKURQLVFK�]LHNH�SDUWQHU��EHSHUNHQ":HONH�LQYORHG�KHEEHQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�HQ�ZHONH�RS�SV\FKLVFKHSUREOHPHQ"0HWKRGH6HOHFWLH� YDQ� VWXGLHV� 9LD� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� OLWHUDWXXUVHDUFK� LQ� 3V\FKOLW� HQ� 0HGOLQH�ELEOLRWKHHN�7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW��UHIHUHQWLHV�XLW�YHU]DPHOGH�OLWHUDWXXU��3HULRGH������������,QFOXVLHFULWHULD� ���� KHW� PRHW� JDDQ� RP� RQGHU]RHN� QDDU� GH� HIIHFWHQ� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV�����ZDDULQ�HHQ�FRQWUROHJURHS�LV�JHEUXLNW������PHW�HHQ�VWHHNSURHIJURRWWH�YDQWHQPLQVWH�����HQ�����ZDDULQ�GH�HIIHFWHQ�RS�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�ZRUGHQ�JHPHWHQ��1LHWJHVHOHFWHHUG�ZHUG�RQGHU]RHN�QDDU�EHKDQGHOLQJ��WHUXJYDOSUHYHQWLH�HQ�QDDU�SUHYHQWLH�YDQVRPDWLVFKH� DDQGRHQLQJHQ�� 1LHW� JHVHOHFWHHUG� ZHUG� RQGHU]RHN� QDDU� EHKDQGHOLQJ�WHUXJYDOSUHYHQWLH� HQ� QDDU� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� VRPDWLVFKH� DDQGRHQLQJHQ�� 2QGHU]RHN�ZDDULQVRFLDOH�VWHXQ�QLHW�DOV�XLWNRPVW�PDDU�XLWVOXLWHQG�DOV�VHOHFWLHFULWHULXP�ZHUG�JHEUXLNW��WZHHRQGHU]RHNVJURHSHQ��PHW�]RQGHU�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ���ZHUG�HYHQPLQ�PHHJHQRPHQ�5HVXOWHUHQGH�VHW�YDQ�VWXGLHV� 9RRU�YLMI�YDQ�GH� WLHQ�HIIHFWRQGHU]RHNHQ��ZDDURQGHU�YLHU

Page 117: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

YDQ� GH� LQ� WRWDDO� ]HV�5&7¶V�� NRQGHQ�ZLM� GH� JURRWWH� YDQ� KHW� HIIHFW� RS� �HHQ� YRUP�YDQ�VRFLDOH� VWHXQ� EHUHNHQHQ� �/DQJHU� HW� DO��� ������+HOOHU� HW� DO��� ������'DGGV��0F+XJK������� $EUDPRZLW]� � &RXUVH\�� ������0LWWHOPDQ� HW� DO��� ������ ������� 'H� YLHU� DQGHUHVWXGLHV� UDSSRUWHHUGHQ� RQYROGRHQGH� JHJHYHQV� RP� GH� G�ZDDUGH� YRRU� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ� WHEHUHNHQHQ�� ,Q� GH]H� VWXGLHV� JDDW� KHW� RP� ]HHU� GLYHUVH� GRHOJURHSHQ�� LQWHUYHQWLHV� HQRSHUDWLRQDOLVDWLHV� YDQ� KHW� EHJULS� µVRFLDOH� VWHXQ¶�� 9RRUEHHOGHQ� YDQ� GRHOJURHSHQ� ]LMQ�]ZDQJHUH�/DWLMQV�DPHULNDDQVH�YURXZHQ�PHW�HHQ�YHUKRRJG�ULVLFR�RS�HHQ�NLQG�PHW�HHQ�WHOLFKW�JHERRUWHJHZLFKW��RXGHUH�YURXZHQ�LQ�VOHFKWH�VRFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKH�RPVWDQGLJKHGHQ�DOOHHQVWDDQGH�PRHGHUV�YDQ�NLQGHUHQ�PHW�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ��HHQ�YHU]RUJHQGH�QDDVWH�YDQHHQ�VFKL]RIUHHQ�JH]LQVOLG�HQ�YHU]RUJHUV�YDQ�HHQ�GHPHQWHUHQGH�YDGHU�RI�HFKWJHQRRW��'HVWXGLHV�EHVFKULMYHQ�GLYHUVH� FRPELQDWLHV�YDQ�YDDN�RQGXLGHOLMN�RPVFKUHYHQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV�WDEHO ���� JHHIW� VOHFKWV� HHQ� VDPHQYDWWHQGH� EHVFKULMYLQJ��� 9RRUEHHOGHQ� YDQLQWHUYHQWLHFRPSRQHQWHQ� ]LMQ�� YRRUOLFKWLQJ� JHYHQ�� LQGLYLGXHOH� HQ� JURHSVJHVSUHNNHQ�OHUHQ� SUREOHPHQ� RS� WH� ORVVHQ�� HPRWLRQHOH� VWHXQ� ELHGHQ�� DFWLYHUHQGH� JHVSUHNNHQ�DVVHUWLYLWHLWVWUDLQLQJ�RI�RQWVSDQQLQJVRHIHQLQJHQ��6RPV�JDDW�KHW�RP�GRRU� SURIHVVLRQHOHNUDFKWHQ�XLWJHYRHUGH�LQWHUYHQWLHV��LQ�DQGHUH�JHYDOOHQ�GRHQ�RQJHWUDLQGH�OHHIWLMGVJHQRWHQGLW��6RPV�YLQGW�SUHYHQWLH�LQ�JURHSVYHUEDQG�SODDWV��VRPV�LQGLYLGXHHO�RI�EHLGH�YRUPHQ�LQFRPELQDWLH�'H XLWNRPVWHQ�KHEEHQ�EHWUHNNLQJ�RS�KHW�DDQWDO�RQGHUVWHXQHQGH�SHUVRQHQ��RS�KHW�DDQWDOWDNHQ�GDW�GRRU�DQGHUH�SHUVRQHQ�ZRUGW�RYHUJHQRPHQ��RS�VXEMHFWLHYH�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�RI�RSGH� WHYUHGHQKHLG�KLHURYHU� HQ�RS�KHW� JHEUXLN� YDQ�YRRU]LHQLQJHQ�GLH� GH]H� VWHXQ�NXQQHQELHGHQ��,Q�GULH�YDQ�GH�YLMI�RQGHU]RHNHQ�]LMQ�G�ZDDUGHQ�EHNHQG�YDQ�PHHU�GDQ�ppQ�YRUPYDQ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ��'DDURP�KHEEHQ�ZLM�DIJH]LHQ�YDQ�EHUHNHQLQJ�YDQ�HHQ�JHPLGGHOGH�G�ZDDUGH�RYHU�GH]H�RQGHU]RHNHQ5HVXOWDWHQ(HQ� PHWD�DQDO\VH� YDQ� GH� YLMI� VWXGLHV� PHW� NZDQWLWDWLHYH� XLWNRPVWHQ� RS� VRFLDOH� VWHXQOHYHUGHQ� HHQ� JHPLGGHOGH� HIIHFWJURRWWH� RS� YDQ� ����� ����� EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDO�� ������±�������=� � ������ Q�V��� SHUFHQWDJH� YDULDQWLH� YHUNODDUG� GRRU� VWHHNSURHIIOXFWXDWLHV��������� 9DQZHJH� KHW� QLHW�VLJQLILFDQWH� UHVXOWDDW� HQ� YDQZHJH� GH� JURWH� KHWHURJHQLWHLWEHVSUHNHQ�ZH�GH�WLHQ�JHVHOHFWHHUGH�VWXGLHV�DSDUW�'H� YLMI� VWXGLHV� PHW� NZDQWLWDWLHYH� XLWNRPVWHQ� YDQ� SUHYHQWLH� RS� SV\FKLVFKHSUREOHPHQ� KHEEHQ�� ]RDOV� DDQJHJHYHQ�� HHQ� XLWHHQORSHQG� UHVXOWDDW�� +HW� HIIHFW� YDQRQGHUVWHXQHQGH�EH]RHNHQ�DDQ�KXLV�RQGHU�HHQ�VWHHNSURHI�YDQ�PHHU�GDQ������YURXZHQ�XLWGLYHUVH� /DWLMQV�DPHULNDDQVH� YURXZHQ� �PHW� YHUKRRJG� ULVLFR� YRRU� HHQ� WH� OLFKWJHERRUWHJHZLFKW�� RS� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ� HQ� RS� DQJVW� EOLMNW� QD� GULHNZDUW� MDDU� QLKLO� WH� ]LMQ�/DQJHU�HW�DO����������1D�HHQ��QLHW�JHUDSSRUWHHUG��DDQWDO� LQIRUPHOH�WHOHIRRQJHVSUHNNHQPHW� RXGHUH� HQ� YHHODO� DOOHHQVWDDQGH� YURXZHQ� GLH�PLQGHU� GDQ� JHPLGGHOG� VRFLDOH� VWHXQHUYDUHQ��EOLMNHQ�]LM�UXLP�HHQ�KDOI�MDDU�QD�DDQYDQJ�YDQ�GH]H�JHVSUHNNHQ�JHHQ�WRHQDPH�LQVRFLDOH�VWHXQ�WH�HUYDUHQ�HQ�HU�LV�HYHQPLQ�HHQ�HIIHFW�RS�GHSUHVVLHYH�V\PSWRPHQ��+HOOHUHW�DO����������9HUGHU�EOLMNW�GDW�HHQ�FRPELQDWLH�YDQ�&KLOG�0DQDJHPHQW�7UDLQLQJ��&07�PHW�SDUWQHUYRRUOLFKWLQJ�HQ��RQGHUVWHXQLQJ�LQ�YHUJHOLMNLQJ�PHW�XLWVOXLWHQG�&07��YRRU�HOIDOOHHQVWDDQGH� PRHGHUV� PHW� HHQ� NLQG� PHW� JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ� HHQ� DYHUHFKWV� HIIHFW� WHKHEEHQ� RS� HUYDUHQ� VWHXQ� XLW� GH� YULHQGHQNULQJ� HQ� RS� GHSUHVVLH� �'DGGV� � 0F+XJK�������� 'H� VWHXQ� YDQ� GH� SDUWQHU� RI� YDQ� DQGHUH� IDPLOLHOHGHQ� LV� HFKWHU� ZHO� VLJQLILFDQWWRHJHQRPHQ��G� �������

Page 118: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

7DEHO�������6WXGLHV�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�VRFLDO�VXSSRUW�HQ�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�

2QGHU]RHN &RQGLWLHV 1 5&7D 'RHOJURHS 0HHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ� 8LWNRPVWHQ��ODDWVWH�PHWLQJ��E�F/DQJHU�HW�DO������ ��� 7KXLVEH]RHN��9HUVWHUNLQJ�YDQ�VRFLDDOQHWZHUN��YRRUOLFKWLQJ��� *HHQ�WKXLVEH]RHN

��������

� =ZDQJHUH�/DWLMQV�DPHULNDDQVH�YURXZHQ�ULVLNRJURHS�YRRU�HHQ�WHODDJ�JHERRUWHJHZLFKW

6RFLDO�VXSSRUW��]HOIJHFRQVWUXHHUGH�YUDJHQOLMVW�6WDWH�7UDLW�$Q[LHW\,QYHQWRU\��67$,�

1 RQGHUVWHXQHQGH�PHQVHQ��G� �����1 WDNHQ�GLH�SDUWQHU�RYHUQHHPW��G� ������1 WDNHQ�GLH�DQGHUHQ�RYHUQHPHQ��G� ������*HHQ�VLJQLILFDQWH�YHUDQGHULQJ�LQ�DQJVW�HQ�LQ�HUYDUHQVRFLDOH�VWHXQ��S��������67$,��G� �������FD����PQG�+HOOHU�HW�DO������ ��� ,QIRUPHOH�WHOHIRQLVFKH�JHVSUHNNHQ����ZN��HHUVWH���ZN��DOOHHQ�VWDII��;�S�ZN�ODDWVWH����ZN��;�S�ZN�VWDII���SHHUV���� *HHQ�JHVSUHNNHQ

��

���

� 2XGHUH�YURXZHQ�ZHLQLJ�VWHXQ��ODDJLQNRPHQ3HUFHLYHG�6RFLDO�6XSSRUW6FDOH��JH]LQ�RIIDPLOLH�YULHQGHQ�'HSUHVVLH��&(6�'�

366�JH]LQ�IDPLOLH��G� ������366�YULHQGHQ��G� ������*HHQ�VLJQLILFDQWH�YHUDQGHULQJHQ�LQ�VWHXQ�HQSUREOHPHQ&(6�'��G� �������QDPHWLQJ���ò�PQG�'DGGV�0F+XJK�������� &KLOG�0DQDJHPHQW�7UDLQLQJ��&07���YRRUOLFKWLQJ�HQ�VWHXQ�DDQ�SDUWQHU���ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV���� $OOHHQ�&07����ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV�

��

��

� $OOHHQVWDDQGH�RXGHUPHW�NLQG�PHWJHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ3HUFHLYHG�6RFLDO�6XSSRUW6FDOH��JH]LQ�RIIDPLOLH�YULHQGHQ�'HSUHVVLH��%ULHI�6\PSWRP,QYHQWRU\��%',�

366�JH]LQ�IDPLOLH��G� �����366�YULHQGHQ��G� ������%',��G� ����������PQG�

$EUDPRZLW] &RXUVH\�������� (GXFDWLRQ�VXSSRUW�JURXS����ZHNHOLMNVHVHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� *HHQ�VXSSRUW�JURXS

����

- 9HU]RUJHUV�YDQ�HHQVFKL]RIUHHQ�JH]LQVOLG *HEUXLN�YDQ�YRRU]LHQLQJHQ�]HOI�JHFRQVWU��0HHWLQVWU���$QJVW��67$,�WUDLW�LWHPV�*HEUXLN�EXXUWYRRU]LHQLQJHQ��G� �����67$,��WUDLW���G� ��������QDPHWLQJ���ò�PQG�

0LWWHOPDQ�HWDO��������������� ,QGLYLGXHOH�HQ�JH]LQV�FRXQVHOLQJ���LQGLY������JH]LQVVHVVLHV�LQ���PQG���� 6WDQGDDUG�DVVLVWHQWLH���FRXQVHOLQJ�RSYHU]RHN��ZHO�LQWHUYHQWLH�RS�LQLWLDWLHIYDQ�SDUWQHU�

������

� 9HU]RUJHQGH�SDUWQHUVYDQ�$O]KHLPHUSDWLsQWHQ6WRNHV�6RFLDO�1HWZRUN6FDOH��*HULDWULF'HSUHVVLRQ�6FDOH

6RFLDOH�VWHXQ���G� ��������WXVVHQPHWLQJ����PQG�1 ���6LJQLILFDQW�PLQGHU�WHYUHGHQ�RYHU�VRFLDDO�QHWZHUN�S��������������������PQG�6LJQLILFDQWH�9HUPLQGHULQJ�GHSUHVVLH��S�������������������PQG�+DOH\�HW�DO������������ ��� 6XSSRUW�JURXS��LQIRUPDWLH��HPRWLRQHOHVWHXQ��RSORVVHQ�YDQ�SUREOHPHQ����VHVVLHV�YDQ��ò�XXU���� 6XSSRUW�JURXS��LGHP�PDDU�PHWRQWVSDQQLQJ���FRJQLWLHYH�YDDU�GLJKHGHQ�����VHVVLHV�YDQ��ò�XXU���� :DFKWOLMVW

��

��

� 9HU]RUJHUV�YDQGHPHQWHUHQGH�RXGHUHQ +HDOWK�DQG�'DLO\�/LYLQJ)RUP��+'/)���VRFLDODFWLYLW\�LWHPV��VRFLDOQHWZRUN�VDWLVIDFWLRQ%HFN¶V�'HSUHVVLRQ,QYHQWRU\��%',�

*HHQ�VLJQLILFDQW�YHUVFKLO�WXVVHQ�(���(���HQ�&�LQSV\FKRVRFLDDO�IXQFWLRQHUHQ(YHQPLQ�LQ�GHSUHVVLHYH�V\PSWRPHQ����PQG�

Page 119: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

7DEHO������YHUYROJ����6WXGLHV�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�VRFLDO�VXSSRUW�HQ�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�2QGHU]RHN &RQGLWLHV 1 5&7D 'RHOJURHS 0HHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ� 8LWNRPVWHQ��ODDWVWH�PHWLQJ��E�F%RJDW�-DVRQ������ ��� 9HUEHWHUHQ�VRFLDDO�QHWZHUN����ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� $OOHHQ�KXLVEH]RHN�����ZHNHOLMNVHVHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� *HHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH

������

� 2XGHUH�EHZRQHUV�EXXUW��VWDGVGHHO� %HVWDDQG�HQ�JHZHQVWVRFLDDO�QHWZHUN��JHHQLQVWU��'HSUHVVLRQ�$GMHFWLYH&KHFNOLVW

*HHQ�VLJQLILFDQW�YHUVFKLO�(���(��HQ�&�LQ�VRFLDOHVWHXQ��QDPHWLQJ��FD����PQG�8LWVOXLWHQG�FRUUHODWLHV� 'HSUHVVLH�YHUVXV�JHZHQVWVRFLDDO�QHWZHUN��SRVLWLHI�VLJQLILFDQW��0LOGH�GHSUHVVLH�YV�EHVWDDQG�VRFLDDO�QHWZHUN�JHPLGGHOG�SRVLWLHYH�FRUUHODWLH���FD����PQG�%DUQDUG�HWDO������� ��� &RSLQJ�SUREOHPHQ�RSORVVHQ��VRFLDOHYDDUGLJKHGHQ��� 7UDGLWLRQHOH�LQIRUPDWLH�HQLQIRUPDWLHEURQQHQ�DDQELHGHQ

����

- =ZDQJHUVFKDSV�FRPSOLFDWLHVJHFRPELQHHUG�PHWZHLQLJ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ

6WHXQ��3HUVRQDO�5HVRXUFHV4XHVWLRQQDLUH'HSUHVVLH��%ULHI�6\PSWRP,QYHQWRU\��%',�

,Q���PHHU�HUYDUHQ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�GDQ�LQ���� PLQGHU�GHSUHVVLH�GDQ����QD������MU�

7RVHODQG�6PLWK������E ��� 3URIHVVLRQHOH���LQGLYLGXHOH�FRXQVHOLQJ���ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� 3HHU�FRXQVHOLQJ����ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHVYDQ���XXU���� *HHQ�FRXQVHOLQJ

������- �VFKRRQ�GRFKWHU�YHU]RUJHUV�PHW�YHHOVWUHVV�GRRU�YHU]RUJLQJKXOSEHKRHYHQGH�RXGHU

66��=HOI�JHFRQVWUXHHUGLQVWUXPHQW��&RPPXQLW\5HVRXUFH�6FDOH���$QJVW��GHSUHVVLH��%ULHI�6\PSWRP,QYHQWRU\��%6,�

*HHQ�VLJQLILFDQW�YHUVFKLO�WXVVHQ������HQ���RS�VRFLDOHVWHXQ'HSUHVVLH��G�SURI� ��������G�SHHU� �����$QJVW��G�SURI� ��������G�SHHU� ��������QDPHWLQJ���PQG�7RVHODQG�5RVVLWHU�HWDO�������D

��� 3URIHVVLRQHHO��FRXQVHOLQJ��YRRUOLFKWLQJ�SUREOHPHQ�RSORVVHQ����ZHNHOLMNVHVHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� 3HHUV��DOOHHQ�FRXQVHOLQJ����ZHNHOLMNVHVHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� :DFKWOLMVW

��

����

� �VFKRRQ�GRFKWHU�YHU]RUJHUV�PHW�YHHOVWUHVV�GRRU�YHU]RUJLQJKXOSEHKRHYHQGH�RXGHU

66� =HOI�JHFRQVWUXHHUGLQVWUXPHQW��&RPPXQLW\5HVRXUFH�6FDOH�'LYHUVH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��%ULHI6\PSWRP�,QYHQWRU\��%6,�

6LJQLILFDQWH�YHUPHHUGHULQJ�YDQ��(���(��YV�&�LQRPYDQJ�VRFLDOH�QHWZHUN��P�Q��ELM�GRRUOHHIWLMGVJHQRWHQ�JHOHLGH�JURHSHQ�*HHQ�VLJQLILFDQW�YHUVFKLO�LQ�DQJVW��HQ�GHSUHVVLHYHV\PSWRPHQ��ZHO�RS�HQNHOH�DQGHUH��ELMY��REVHVVLHI�FRPSXOVLHYH���QDPHWLQJ����PQG�7RVHODQG�HWDO�������E ��� 3URIHVVLRQHHO��FRXQVHOLQJ��YRRUOLFKWLQJ�SUREOHPHQ�RSORVVHQ����ZHNHOLMNVHVHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� 3HHUV��DOOHHQ�FRXQVHOLQJ����ZHNHOLMNVHVHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� 3URIHVVLRQHHO��VWUHVV�WUDLQLQJ��� :DFKWOLMVW

��

������

� �VFKRRQ�GRFKWHU�YHU]RUJHUV�PHW�YHHOVWUHVV�GRRU�YHU]RUJLQJKXOSEHKRHYHQGH�RXGHU

66� =HOI�JHFRQVWUXHHUGLQVWUXPHQW��&RPPXQLW\5HVRXUFH�6FDOH�'LYHUVH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��%ULHI6\PSWRP�,QYHQWRU\��%6,�

(���(��HQ�(��HHQ�VLJQLILFDQW�JURWHU�VRFLDDO�QHWZHUNGDQ�&��S����������%LM���ZDW�PLQGHU�JURWHU�GDQ�ELM��HQ���*HHQ�VLJQLILFDQW�YHUVFKLO�LQ�DQJVW��HQ�GHSUHVVLHYHV\PSWRPHQ��QDPHWLQJ����PQG�

7RVHODQG�HWDO�������D ��� 3URIHVVLRQHHO��FRXQVHOLQJ��YRRUOLFKWLQJ�SUREO�RSORVVHQ����ZNO�VHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� 3HHUV��RSYDQJJHVSUHNNHQ����ZHNHOLMNVHVHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� :DFKWOLMVW

������

� �VFKRRQ�GRFKWHU�YHU]RUJHUV�PHW�YHHOVWUHVV�GRRU�YHU]RUJLQJKXOSEHKRHYHQGH�RXGHU

66� =HOI�JHFRQVWUXHHUGLQVWUXPHQW��&RPPXQLW\5HVRXUFH�6FDOH�'LYHUVH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��%ULHI6\PSWRP�,QYHQWRU\��%6,�

� HQ���KHEEHQ�HHQ�VLJQLILFDQW�JURWHU�VRFLDDO�QHWZHUNGDQ���*HHQ�VLJQLILFDQW�YHUVFKLO�LQ�SV\FKLVFKH�SUREOHPHQ�S������������PQG�����PQG�D��5&7���� �µUDQGRPL]HG�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO¶���� �JHFRQWUROHHUG�QLHW�JHUDQGRPLVHHUG�E��(��«L�� �H[SHULPHQWHOH�FRQGLWLH�V���&� �FRQWUROHFRQGLWLH�F��GH�PHHVW�JHVSHFLILFHHUGH�JHNZDQWLILFHHUGH�XLWNRPVWHQ�

Page 120: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

$EUDPRZLW]��&RXUVH\��������ODWHQ�]LHQ�GDW�YRRUOLFKWLQJ�HQ�DGYLHV�RYHU�VFKL]RIUHQLHHQ� KRH� HUPHH� RP� WH� JDDQ�� KHW� JHEUXLN� YDQ� GLHQVWYHUOHQHQGH� YRRU]LHQLQJHQ� GRRU� HHQYHU]RUJHQGH� QDDVWH� YDQ� ]R¶Q� SDWLsQW� DDQ]LHQOLMN� GRHW� WRHQHPHQ� �G� � ������� +XQDQJVWSUREOHPHQ�EOLMNHQ�HFKWHU�WRH��LQ�SODDWV�YDQ�DIJHQRPHQ��G� ���������0LWWHOPDQ�HW�DO��������������WHQVORWWH��UDSSRUWHUHQ�GDW�YHU]RUJHUV�YDQ�HHQ�GHPHQWHUHQG�JH]LQVOLG�QD�HHQFRPELQDWLH� YDQ� LQGLYLGXHOH� HQ� JH]LQVJHVSUHNNHQ� MXLVW� EHODQJULMN�PLQGHU� WHYUHGHQ� ]LMQPHW�KXQ�VRFLDOH�QHWZHUN��PDDU�WHJHOLMNHUWLMG�EHODQJULMN�PLQGHU�GHSUHVVLHYH�V\PSWRPHQKHEEHQ�'H XLWNRPVWHQ� YDQ� GH� YLHU� RYHULJH� VWXGLHV� GLH� RQYROGRHQGH� JHJHYHQVUDSSRUWHHUGHQ� YRRU� EHUHNHQLQJ� YDQ� GH� HIIHFWJURRWWH� JHYHQ� HYHQHHQV� HHQ� ZLVVHOHQGEHHOG�� $OOHHQ� GLH� YDQ� %DUQDUG� HW� DO�� ������� RQGHU� YURXZHQ� PHW� ]ZDQJHUVFKDSV�FRPSOLFDWLHV�ODDW�HHQ�YHUEHWHULQJ�]LHQ�YDQ�GH�HUYDUHQ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�HQ�HHQ�YHUPLQGHULQJYDQ� GHSUHVVLHYH� YHUVFKLMQVHOHQ�� 'H� XLWYDO� LQ� GLW� RQGHU]RHN� LV� QD� WZHH� MDDU� ����� +HWHIIHFW�RS�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�LV�LQ�GH�DQGHUH�RQGHU]RHNHQ�QLHW�VLJQLILFDQW��+LHUELM�JDDW�KHW�RPYHUVFKLOOHQGH� PHWLQJHQ� YDQ� VWHXQ�� JHEUXLN� YDQ� GLHQVWYHUOHQHQGH� YRRU]LHQLQJHQ�7RVHODQG�� 6PLWK�� ����E��� VRFLDOH� DFWLYLWHLWHQ� HQ� WHYUHGHQKHLG�PHW� VRFLDDO� QHWZHUN�+DOH\�HW�DO���������������HQ� WHQVORWWH�EHVWDDQG�HQ�JHZHQVW� VRFLDDO�QHWZHUN� �%RJDW�-DVRQ���������'H�DQGHUH�RQGHU]RHNHQ�YDQ�7RVHODQG�HQ�FROOHJD¶V������D������E������D�JHYHQ�ZHO�YHUEHWHULQJHQ�LQ�KHW�VRFLDOH�QHWZHUN�&RQFOXVLHV%HODQJULMNVWH�EHSHUNLQJHQ� ����HHQ�]HHU�KHWHURJHQH�VHW�YDQ�VWXGLHV� �GLW�NRPW�XLWHUDDUGRRN�GRRU�GH�EUHGH�YUDDJVWHOOLQJ�������ZDDUELM�KHW�ELM�YHHO�VWXGLHV�QLHW�PRJHOLMN�ZDV�RPHIIHFWJURRWWHV�WH�EHUHNHQHQ������YHHO�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�PHHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ�8LWNRPVWHQ� 9RRUDO� YRRU� GH� PHHVW� UHFHQWH� VWXGLHV� NRQGHQ� ZLM� GH� HIIHFWJURRWWHEHUHNHQHQ�� 'H� JHVHOHFWHHUGH� VWXGLHV� YHUVFKLOOHQ� RS� GLYHUVH� NHQPHUNHQ� �GRHOJURHS�NHQPHUNHQ�YDQ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ��LQWHUYHQWLHV���2RN�LV�WH�ZHLQLJ�RQGHU]RHNVSXEOLFDWLHV�YRRUDI]RQGHUOLMNH�YDULDQWHQ�YDQ�GH]H�NHQPHUNHQ�EHVFKLNEDDU��'H�PHHVWH�XLWNRPVWHQ�GXLGHQRS�JHHQ�VLJQLILFDQW�HIIHFW�RS�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ��'DDURP�LV�KHW�QLHW�]LQYRO�RP�YRRU�PHHUGHUHVWXGLHV� HHQ� JH]DPHQOLMNH� FRQFOXVLH� WH� WUHNNHQ� RI� HHQ� JHPLGGHOGH� HIIHFWJURRWWH� WHEHUHNHQHQ�� +HW� RQGHU]RHN� QDDU� KHW� HIIHFW� YDQ� SUHYHQWLH� RS� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ� LV� KLHUYRRULQKRXGHOLMN� WH� YHUVQLSSHUG�� 2P� YDVW� WH� VWHOOHQ� ZHONH� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� HHQJHZHQVW� HIIHFW� KHEEHQ� YRRU� ZHONH� GRHOJURHS� LV� PHHU� HIIHFWRQGHU]RHN� QRGLJ� QDDURYHUHHQNRPVWLJH�GRHOJURHSHQ��YRUPHQ�YDQ� �VRFLDOH�� VWHXQ�HQ�SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�7RW�QRJ�WRH�VFKLHW�GH�HYLGHQWLH�YRRU�HHQ�HIIHFW�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�RS�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�WH�NRUW�

���� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�VHOI�HIILFDF\3UREOHHPVWHOOLQJ6HOI�HIILFDF\�NDQ�PHQ�RPVFKULMYHQ�DOV�KHW�JHORRI�HQ�YHUWURXZHQ�LQ�GH�HLJHQ�FDSDFLWHLWHQRP�HHQ�JHYUDDJG�JHGUDJ�XLW�WH�YRHUHQ��%DQGXUD���������$QGHUV�JH]HJG��+HW�JDDW�RP�GHWD[DWLH� YDQ� HHQ� LQGLYLGX� KRH� GH� DFWLHV� GLH� YHUHLVW� ]LMQ� RP� DGHTXDDW� RP� WH� JDDQ� PHWWRHNRPVWLJH�HQ�RQYRRUVSHOEDUH�VLWXDWLHV��JHRUJDQLVHHUG�HQ�XLWJHYRHUG�NXQQHQ�ZRUGHQ�'H]H�WD[DWLHV�EHSDOHQ�KHW�JHGUDJ�GDW�JHNR]HQ�ZRUGW�HQ�EHwQYORHGHQ�KRHYHHO�PRHLWH�HUDDQ� HHQ� EHSDDOGH� WDDN� EHVWHHG� ZRUGW�� HYHQDOV� KHW� YROKRXGHQ� HUYDQ� DOV� KLHUELM

Page 121: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

PRHLOLMNKHGHQ�RQWVWDDQ�6HOI�HIILFDF\� EHwQYORHGW� GH� NHX]H� YDQ� DFWLYLWHLWHQ�� =R� ]DO� LHPDQG� HHQ� VLWXDWLHYHUPLMGHQ� DOV� KLM� GHQNW� GDDU� QLHW� PHH� RP� WH� NXQQHQ� JDDQ�� ,HPDQG� ]DO� VLWXDWLHV� RIDFWLYLWHLWHQ�RS]RHNHQ�ZDDUYDQ�KLM�KHW�JHYRHO�KHHIW�HU�JULS�RS�WH�KHEEHQ��'HV�WH�VWHUNHUPHQ�KHW�JHYRHO�KHHIW�LHWV�DDQ�WH�NXQQHQ��GHV�WH�PHHU�PRHLWH�HU�DDQ�GH�DFWLYLWHLW�EHVWHHG]DO�ZRUGHQ��'H�EHOHYLQJ�YDQ�HLJHQ�NXQQHQ�RP�EHSDDOGH�VSHFLILHNH�JHGUDJLQJHQ�XLW� WHYRHUHQ��VHOI�HIILFDF\��LV�GDQ�RRN�HHQ�VWHUNH�SUHGLFWRU�YRRU�WRHNRPVWLJ�JHGUDJ��%DQGXUD�������(U�]LMQ�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�YRRU�XLWHHQORSHQGH�GRHOJURHSHQ�RQWZLNNHOG�RP�GHVHOI�HIILFDF\� WH� YHUJURWHQ��9RRUEHHOGHQ� ]LMQ� WUDLQLQJHQ� YRRU� RXGHUV�PHW� NLQGHUHQ�PHWJHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�� RQGHUVWHXQLQJVJURHSHQ� YRRU� IDPLOLHOHGHQ� GLH� YRRU� HHQ� KXOSEHKRH�YHQGH�RXGHUH�]RUJHQ��JHKHXJHQWUDLQLQJHQ�ELM�RXGHUHQ�HQ�RQGHUVWHXQLQJ�YDQ�YHWHUDQHQ�9UDDJVWHOOLQJ.XQQHQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�VHOI�HIILFDF\�YHUEHWHUHQ��,Q�HHUVWH�LQVWDQWLH�ZDV�KHW�GHEHGRHOLQJ�RP�RRN�GH�UHODWLH�WXVVHQ�HIIHFWHQ�RS�VHOI�HIILFDF\�HQ�HIIHFWHQ�RS�JHHVWHOLMNHJH]RQGKHLG� WH� RQGHU]RHNHQ�� +HW� DDQWDO� VWXGLHV� EOHHN� GDDUYRRU� HFKWHU� RQYROGRHQGH�'HVRQGDQNV� ]XOOHQ� ZH� GH� HIIHFWHQ� RS� JHHVWHOLMNH� JH]RQGKHLG� XLW� GH� JHVHOHFWHHUGHVWXGLHV�KLHURQGHU�SUHVHQWHUHQ�0HWKRGH6HOHFWLH�YDQ�VWXGLHV��9LD�OLWHUDWXXUVHDUFKHV�LQ�3V\FKOLW�HQ�0HGOLQH�YDQDI������W�P������,QFOXVLHFULWHULD��6WXGLHV�ZHUGHQ�LQ�GH�PHWD�DQDO\VH�RSJHQRPHQ�DOV�]LM�����JHULFKW�ZDUHQRS�YHUEHWHULQJ�YDQ�GH�VHOI�HIILFDF\�HQ�����RS�YHUEHWHULQJ�YDQ�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�HQ�����JHEUXLN�PDDNWHQ�YDQ�HHQ�FRQWUROHJURHS�HQ�SUH��HQ�SRVWWHVW�GDWD�UDSSRUWHHUGHQ��HQYROGRHQGH� UHVXOWDWHQ� SUHVHQWHHUGHQ� RP� GH� JHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGH� HIIHFWJURRWWH� WHEHUHNHQHQ��� 6WXGLHV� RYHU� VRPDWLVFKH� DDQGRHQLQJHQ� ZHUGHQ� XLJHVORWHQ� HYHQDOVEHKDQGHOLQJHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�WHUXJYDO�5HVXOWHUHQGH� VHW� YDQ� VWXGLHV�� ,Q� WRWDDO� ZHUGHQ� �� VWXGLHV� JHVHOHFWHHUG�� ZDDULQ� �LQWHUYHQWLHV�RQGHU]RFKW�]LMQ��]LH�WDEHO�������9LHU�VWXGLHV�ZDUHQ�JHUDQGRPLVHHUGH� WULDOV�'H RQGHU]RFKWH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�HQ�GH�GRHOJURHSHQ� OLHSHQ�]HHU� VWHUN�XLWHHQ��YDULsUHQG�YDQRQGHUVWHXQLQJ� YDQ� KXOSEHKRHYHQGH� RXGHUHQ� WRW� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ� ELMNLQGHUHQ��9HUGHU�ZHUG�LQ�HONH�VWXGLH�HHQ�DQGHU�LQVWUXPHQW�JHEUXLNW�RP�GH�VHOI�HIILFDF\WH�PHWHQ�0HWKRGH� 0HWD�DQDO\VH�RS�EDVLV�YDQ�KHW�UDQGRP�HIIHFWV�PRGHO�5HVXOWDWHQ'H RQGHU]RFKWH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�EOHNHQ�HHQ�NOHLQ�PDDU�VLJQLILFDQW�HIIHFW�WH�KHEEHQ�RS�VHOI�HIILFDF\��JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�����������EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDO�������±�������= ������S���������'H�SURSRUWLH�YDULDQWLH�GLH�YHUNODDUG�ZRUGW�GRRU�VWHHNSURHIIOXFWXDWLHV�LV�����ZDW�DDQJHHIW�GDW�HU�ZHLQLJ�V\VWHPDWLVFKH�YHUVFKLOOHQ�WXVVHQ�GH�VWXGLHV�]LMQ�

Page 122: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

7DEHO�������6WXGLHV�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�VHOI�HIILFDF\�6WXGLH 'RHOVWHOOLQJ�GRHOJURHS &RQGLWLHV �1 5&7D 0HHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ 6HOI�HIILFDF\XLWNRPVW **=�XLWNRPVWHQELM�SRVWPHWLQJ/RYHWW�&DOODJKHU������ 2QGHUVWHXQLQJ�YDQ�YHU]RUJHUVYDQ�KXOSEHKRHYHQGH�RXGHUHQ ��� WUDLQLQJ��LQ�YHUJURWLQJ�YDQ�QLYHDX�YDQ�SOH]LHULJHJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ�����ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU���� WUDLQLQJ�LQ�YHUJURWHQ�YDQ��YDDUGLJKHGHQ�LQ�RSORVVHQYDQ�VRFLDOH�SUREOHPHQ����ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV�YDQ��XXU���� :DFKWOLMVW

��

����

� 'HSUHVVLH��%',��6$'6� 3RVWWHVW���� G ������� G �������� G �������� G �����

'HOOHILHOG��0F'RXJKDOO�����9HUJURWHQ�YDQ�µPHPRU\�VHOI�HIILFDF\¶�ELM�RXGHUHQ ��� ,QWHUYHQWLH�PHW�RXGHUHQ�EHGRHOG�RP�VHOI�HIILFDF\JHKHXJHQ�HQ�JHKHXJHQ�JHGUDJ�WH�YHUJURWHQ����VHVVLHVYDQ��ò�XXU��LQ���ZHNHQ���� :DFKWOLMVW

��

��

- $QJVW��DQJVWVFKDDO0HWDPHPRU\�LQ$GXOWKRRG�4XHVWLRQQDLUH'HSUHVVLRQ�6FDOH�

3RVWWHVW�G �����)ROORZ�XS���ZHNHQ��G �����

3RVW�WHVW�G �����)ROORZ�XS���ZHNHQ��G �������*URVV�HW�DO������� 9HUEHWHUHQ�RXGHU�NLQG�UHODWLH�VHOI�HIILFDF\��GHSUHVVLH�HQVWUHVV�RXGHU��JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQNLQG��RXGHUV�YDQ���±MDULJHQ�

��� 2XGHU�WUDLQLQJ�RYHU�R�D��KRH�WH�VSHOHQ�PHW�NLQG�FRPSOLPHQWHUHQ�HQ�EHORQHQ��JUHQ]HQ�VWHOOHQ��RPJDDQPHW�VOHFKW�JHGUDJ���� &RQWUROHJURHS

��

��

� 'HSUHVVLH��&(6�'���VWUHVV�3DUHQWLQJ�6WUHVV�,QGH[� 3RVWWHVW�G �����)ROORZ�XS���PDDQGHQ��G �����

3RVWPHWLQJ��G ����)ROORZ�XS���PDDQGHQ��G �����/LWW�HW�DO������� 9HUPLQGHUHQ�GLVWUHVV�ELM��HNLHV�H[WUDFWLH�SDWLsQWHQ ��� 5HOD[DWLH�HQ�VHOI�HIILFDF\�YHUKRJLQJ��LQFOXVLHIELRIHHGEDFN�G�P�Y��LQIRUPDWLH�RYHU�QLYHDX�YDQKXLGJHOHLGLQJ��LQWHUYHQWLH�YDQ����PLQXWHQ�WLMGHQVRSHUDWLH���� 6HOI�HIILFDF\�YHUKRJLQJ�HQ�LQWUDYHQXH]H�QDDOGGHVHQVLWLVDWLH��LGHP�DOV����DOOHHQ�RRN�QDDOG�GHVHQVLWLVDWLH��LQWHUYHQWLH�WLMGHQV�RSHUDWLH���� 6WDQGDDUG�EHKDQGHOLQJ

��

��

��

� GLVWUHVV�WLMGHQV�RSHUDWLH�3DWLHQW�6WUHVV�5HVSRQVH,QGH[��YLVXHOH�DQDORJHVFKDOHQ�

3RVWWHVW���G� ��������G� �����3RVWWHVW���� G �������� G �����

$EUDPRZLW]�&RXUVH\������ 2QGHUVWHXQLQJ�HQ�HGXFDWLH�YDQIDPLOLHOHGHQ�YDQ�VFKL]RIUHQHSDWLsQWHQ��� (GXFDWLH��VXSSRUW�JURHS��ZHNHOLMNVH�VHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU�� ZHNHQ���� :DFKWOLMVW

����

- $QJVW��6WDWH�7UDLW�$Q[LHW\,QYHQWRU\����GLVWUHVV�5HODWLYHV¶�6WUHVV�6FDOH�3RVWWHVW�G ������ 3RVWWHVW�G �����

7ROOHWW�7KRPDV������ 3RVLWLHYH�EHwQYORHGLQJ�YDQKRRS��VHOI�HIILFDF\�HQ�GHSUHVVLHLQ�WKXLVOR]H�YHWHUDQHQ��� 2QGHUVWHXQHQGH�LQWHUYHQWLH�GRRU�YHUSOHHJNXQGLJH���VHVVLHV�YDQ���XXU�SHU�ZHHN����ZHNHQ���� :DFKWOLMVW

����

� 'HSUHVVLH��%',� 3RVWWHVW�G �� 3RVWWHVW�G ��D��5&7��µUDQGRPL]HG�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO¶��ZHO�JHHQ�UDQGRP�WRHZLM]LQJ�DDQ�FRQGLWLHV��

Page 123: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

'H�HIIHFWHQ�RS�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�YDQ�GH]H�VHW�YDQ�VWXGLHV�EOHNHQ�PLGGHOJURRW� WH]LMQ��'H�JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�ZDV�����������EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDO�������±������= � ������ S�� �������� 'H� SURSRUWLH� YDULDQWLH� GLH� YHUNODDUG� ZRUGW� GRRUVWHHNSURHIIOXFWXDWLHV� LV� ������ GLW� EHWHNHQW� GDW� HU� JHHQ� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� YHUVFKLOOHQ�KRPRJHQLWHLW��WXVVHQ�GH�VWXGLHV�]LMQ�(U� ]LMQ�PDDU� WZHH� VWXGLHV�ZDDULQ� KHW� HIIHFW� YDQ�GH� LQWHUYHQWLH� RS�GH� ODQJH� WHUPLMQ�IROORZ�XS�� RQGHU]RFKW� LV�� (pQ� VWXGLH� JDI� HHQ� DDQKRXGHQG� HIIHFW� YDQ� GH� EHKDQGHOLQJWHUZLMO� GH� DQGHUH� VWXGLH� JHHQ� HIIHFW� VRUWHHUGH�� RRN� QLHW� GLUHFW� QD� GH� EHKDQGHOLQJ�$DQJH]LHQ�HU�PDDU�WZHH�VWXGLHV�IROORZ�XS�PHWLQJHQ�UDSSRUWHHUGHQ�ZDV�KHW�QLHW�]LQYRORP�GDDU�HHQ�PHWD�DQDO\VH�RYHU�XLW�WH�YRHUHQ�&RQFOXVLHV%HODQJULMNVWH� EHSHUNLQJHQ� ���� %HSHUNW� DDQWDO� EUXLNEDUH� VWXGLHV�� ���� NOHLQH� DDQWDOOHQSURHISHUVRQHQ������]HHU�YHHO�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�PHHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ�RP�VHOI�HIILFDF\�WH�PHWHQ�LHGHUH� VWXGLH� JHEUXLNWH� HHQ� DQGHUH��� ���� GH� RQGHU]RFKWH� GRHOJURHSHQ� HQ� LQWHUYHQWLHVYDULsUHQ�VWHUN��'H�JURWH�YDULDWLH�LQ�JHEUXLNWH�PHHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ�YRRU�VHOI�HIILFDF\�JHHIWGH�LQGUXN�GDW�KHW�FRQFHSW�QRJ�RQYROGRHQGH�RSHUDWLRQHHO�LV�XLWJHZHUNW�8LWNRPVWHQ� 2Q]H�DQDO\VHV� ODWHQ�]LHQ�GDW� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHULFKW� RS�KHW� YHUKRJHQ�YDQ�GHVHOI�HIILFDF\�HHQ�NOHLQ��PDDU�VLJQLILFDQW�HIIHFW�KHEEHQ�RS�GH�VHOI�HIILFDF\��'H�HIIHFWHQRS�SV\FKLVFKH�NODFKWHQ�]LMQ�PLGGHOJURRW��2I�HU�HHQ�YHUEDQG�LV�WXVVHQ�HIIHFWHQ�RS�VHOI�HIILFDF\�HQ�HIIHFWHQ�RS�SV\FKLVFKH�NODFKWHQ�NRQGHQ�ZH�QLHW�RQGHU]RHNHQ��2I�GH�HIIHFWHQRS� VHOI�HIILFDF\� HQ� RS� SV\FKLVFKH� NODFKWHQ� RS� GH� ODQJHUH� WHUPLMQ� EHKRXGHQ� EOLMYHQ�NRQGHQ�ZH�HYHQPLQ�RQGHU]RHNHQ�

Page 124: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

� %HVFKRXZLQJ���� %HSHUNLQJHQ'H]H� OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH� LV� H[SORUDWLHI� YDQ� NDUDNWHU� HQ� KHHIW� HHQ� DDQWDO� EHODQJULMNHEHSHUNLQJHQ��7HQ�HHUVWH�YRQGHQ�ZLM�YRRU�GH�PHHVWH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�GLH�ZH�RQGHU]RFKWHQVOHFKWV�HHQ�EHSHUNW�DDQWDO�VWXGLHV�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GLH�DDQRQ]H�LQFOXVLHFULWHULD�YROGHGHQ��:H�PRHWHQ�GDDURP�GH�UHVXOWDWHQ�YDQ�GH]H�VWXGLH�PHW�GHXLWHUVWH�YRRU]LFKWLJKHLG�EHWUDFKWHQ�7HQ� WZHHGH� VHOHFWHHUGHQ� ZLM� VOHFKWV� HQNHOH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� JHHVWHOLMNHJH]RQGKHLG� ZDDUYDQ� ZLM� YRRUDI� YHUPRHGGHQ� �RS� EDVLV� YDQ� JOREDOH� VFUHHQLQJ� YDQ� GHOLWHUDWXXU�� GDW� HU� YROGRHQGH� RQGHU]RHN� YRRUKDQGHQ� ]RX� ]LMQ��'H]H� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� ]LMQQLHW�YDQ]HOIVSUHNHQG�GH�PHHVW�EHODQJULMNH��QRFK�JHYHQ�]LM�HHQ�UHSUHVHQWDWLHI�EHHOG�YDQDOOH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ��:H�NXQQHQ�GXV�RS�EDVLV�YDQ�GH]H�VWXGLH�JHHQ�DOJHPHHQ�JHOGHQGHXLWVSUDDN� GRHQ� RYHU� GH� EHwQYORHGEDDUKHLG� YDQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKHJH]RQGKHLG�LQ�KHW�DOJHPHHQ�7HQ� GHUGH� KHEEHQ� ZH� YDQZHJH� SUDJPDWLVFKH� UHGHQHQ� HHQ� LQGHOLQJ� LQ� FDWHJRULHsQYDQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� DOV� XLWJDQJVSXQW� JHQRPHQ�� 'DDUGRRU� NULMJHQ� ZH� ZHO� HHQ� JOREDOHLQGUXN�YDQ�HQNHOH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ��PDDU�KHW�LV�QLHW�PRJHOLMN�RP�RS�WKHRUHWLVFKH�JURQGHQDDQ� WH�JHYHQ�ZHONH�HIIHFWHQ�PHQ�]RX�NXQQHQ�YHUZDFKWHQ�YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV��7HQ�YLHUGHKHEEHQ� ZLM� ELM� GH� OLWHUDWXXUVHDUFKHV� PRHWHQ� YROVWDDQ� PHW� VQHOOH�� DIJHEDNHQGH]RHNPHWKRGHQ�� 'DDUGRRU� KHEEHQ� ZLM� RQJHWZLMIHOG� VWXGLHV� JHPLVW� GLH� ZHO� DDQ� GHLQFOXVLHFULWHULD� YROGRHQ��2RN� GDDURP�PRHWHQ�ZH� YRRU]LFKWLJ� ]LMQ�PHW� GH� LQWHUSUHWDWLHYDQ�GH�UHVXOWDWHQ�9HUGHU� KHHIW� GH]H� VWXGLH� QLHW� GH� SUHWHQWLH� HHQ� RRUGHHO� WH� NXQQHQ� JHYHQ� RYHU� KHWSUDNWLMNYHOG� YDQ� **=�SUHYHQWLH�� 7HQ� HHUVWH� LV� HHQ� DDQ]LHQOLMN� GHHO� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV�LQ�GH�SUDNWLMN�GLUHFW�JHULFKW�RS�VWRRUQLVVHQ��VHFXQGDLUH�SUHYHQWLH��HQ�QLHW�RSGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�� 7HQ� WZHHGH� KHEEHQ� ZH� RQV� LQ� GLW� RYHU]LFKW� JHFRQFHQWUHHUG� RS� GHSV\FKLVFKH�FRQVHTXHQWLHV�YDQ�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HQ�QLHW�RS�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�]HOI��WHUZLMO�LQ�GHSUDNWLMN�ZHO�LQWHUYHQWLHV�XLWJHYRHUG�ZRUGHQ�GLH�GDDURS�JHULFKW�]LMQ��]RDOV�ELMYRRUEHHOGSUHYHQWLH� YDQ� NLQGHUPLVKDQGHOLQJ� HQ� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� SHVWJHGUDJ� RS� VFKRRO�� 'HQDYROJHQGH�FRQFOXVLHV�PRHWHQ�LQ�GLW�OLFKW�EHVFKRXZG�ZRUGHQ�(HQ� DQGHU� SXQW� EHWUHIW� RQ]H� EHSHUNLQJ� WRW� JHFRQWUROHHUGH� HQ� ]R� PRJHOLMNJHUDQGRPLVHHUGH�HIIHFWVWXGLHV��'HUJHOLMNH�VWXGLHV�NDQ�PHQ�EHVFKRXZHQ�DOV�GH�JRXGHQVWDQGDDUG�RP�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� WH�RQGHU]RHNHQ��'DW�ZLO�HFKWHU�QLHW�]HJJHQ�GDWDQGHUH�RQGHU]RHNVGHVLJQV�YRRU�KHW�YDVWVWHOOHQ�YDQ�HHQ�HIIHFW�YDQ�JHHQ� HQNHOH�ZDDUGH]LMQ��2RN�QLHW�JHUDQGRPLVHHUG�H[SHULPHQWHHO�RQGHU]RHN�PHW�JURWHUH�VWHHNSURHYHQ��FDVH�FRQWURO�VWXGLHV�HQ�ORQJLWXGLQDDO�FRKRUW�RQGHU]RHN�NDQ�LQGLFDWLHV�JHYHQ�YRRU�HHQ�HIIHFW�%LM�GH�RQWZLNNHOLQJ�YDQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV�HQ�ELM�LPSOHPHQWDWLH�RQGHU]RHN�LV�RRN�NZDOLWDWLHIHQ� RQJHFRQWUROHHUG� HYDOXDWLH� RQGHU]RHN� YDQ� JURRW� EHODQJ�� 'HUJHOLMN� RQGHU]RHN� NDQLQ]LFKW� JHYHQ� LQ� VXFFHVIDFWRUHQ� HQ� NQHOSXQWHQ� ELM� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� HQ� NDQGDDUGRRU�GH�NDQV�RS�LPSOHPHQWDWLH�YDQ�HIIHFWLHYH�SURJUDPPD¶V�EHYRUGHUHQ�(HQ� ODDWVWH� EHSHUNLQJ�GLH�ZH�QRHPHQ� LV� GDW�ZH� LQ� RQ]H� H[SORUDWLHYH� VWXGLH� HQNHOHGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� RQGHU]RFKW� KHEEHQ�� ZDDUELM� YHURQGHUVWHOG� ZHUG� GDW� GH]H� RS� PRQR�FDXVDOH�ZLM]H�JHUHODWHHUG�]LMQ�DDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��8LW�GH�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�2UPHO�HQFROOHJD¶V� LV� HFKWHU� GXLGHOLMN� QDDU� YRUHQ� JHNRPHQ� GDW� MXLVW� LQWHUDFWLH� YDQ� PHHUGHUH

Page 125: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�HHQ�JURWH�URO�VSHHOW�ELM�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�0HGH� YDQZHJH� GH� EHSHUNLQJHQ� YDQ� GH]H� VWXGLH� KHEEHQ� ZH� HQNHOH� NDGHUWHNVWHQRSJHQRPHQ�� ZDDULQ� RRN� DQGHUH� DVSHFWHQ� GLH� EHWUHNNLQJ� KHEEHQ� RS� GH� HIIHFWHQ� YDQSUHYHQWLH� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� NODFKWHQ� DDQ� ERG� NRPHQ�� 'H]H� NDGHUWHNVWHQLOOXVWUHUHQ� RRN� GDW� KHW� SUHYHQWLHYHOG� HQ� KHW� SUHYHQWLH±RQGHU]RHN� EUHGHU� ]LMQ� GDQ� GHEHQDGHULQJ�GLH�ZLM�LQ�GH]H�VWXGLH�JHYROJG�KHEEHQ�(HQ� DOJHPHQH� FRQFOXVLH� LV� GDW� LQ� KHW� RQGHU]RHNVYHOG� QRJ� UHODWLHI� ZHLQLJ� JRHGXLWJHYRHUG� RQGHU]RHN� LV� YHUULFKW�� 'HHOV� NDQ� GLW� WH� PDNHQ� KHEEHQ� PHW� RQ]H]RHNPHWKRGHQ� ZDDUGRRU� ZLM� VWXGLHV� JHPLVW� KHEEHQ�� 0DDU� EHODQJULMNHU� OLMNW� GDW� YHHOVWXGLHV� RS� GH]H� WHUUHLQHQ� QLHW� JRHG� ]LMQ� RSJH]HW� RI� RQYROGRHQGH� GDWD� SUHVHQWHUHQ� RPJHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGH� HIIHFWJURRWWHV� WH� EHUHNHQHQ�� 'DDUQDDVW� LV� HU� PRJHOLMN� QRJRQYROGRHQGH� LQWHUHVVH� YDQXLW� KHW� RQGHU]RHNVYHOG� YRRU� KHW� XLWYRHUHQ� YDQHIIHFWRQGHU]RHN��9HUGHU� LV� KHW� DDQWDO� VWXGLHV� WH� NOHLQ� RP� KDUGH� XLWVSUDNHQ� WH� NXQQHQGRHQ�RYHU�HIIHFWHQ��:H�YHUPRHGHQ�GDW�DOV�ZH�DQGHUH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�JHNR]HQ�KDGGHQ�RPWH�RQGHU]RHNHQ��ZH�QRJ�PLQGHU�RQGHU]RHN�JHYRQGHQ�]RXGHQ�KHEEHQ�'RRU� GH]H� EHSHUNLQJHQ� EOHNHQ�ZH� QLHW� LQ� VWDDW� RP� DQWZRRUG� WH� JHYHQ� RS� HHQ� YDQRQ]H�YUDJHQ�� LV� HU� HHQ� UHODWLH� WXVVHQ�HIIHFWHQ�RS�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� �]RDOV� VHOI�HIILFDF\� HQVRFLDOH�VWHXQ��HQ�HIIHFWHQ�RS�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG"�(U�ZRUGW�YDDN�YHURQGHUVWHOG�GDWEHwQYORHGLQJ� YDQ� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� OHLGW� WRW� HHQ� EHWHUH� JHHVWHOLMNH� JH]RQGKHLG�� PDDUHPSLULVFKH�RQGHUVWHXQLQJ�GDDUYRRU�NRQGHQ�ZLM�QLHW�YLQGHQ�(U�LV�QDXZHOLMNV�RQGHU]RHN�YHUULFKW�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RSKHW� GDDGZHUNHOLMN� YRRUNyPHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� YROJHQV� GH� FULWHULD� YDQ� GH'60�,9��,Q�GH�LQ�KRRIGVWXN���VDPHQJHYDWWH�OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH�ZHUGHQ�VOHFKWV�WZHH�VWXGLHVJHYRQGHQ� GLH� GH� HIIHFWHQ� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� RS� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� YDQ� QLHXZH� JHYDOOHQ� YDQSV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�RQGHU]RFKWHQ��'DGGV�HW�DO���������&ODUNH�HW�DO����������,Q�EHLGHZHUG�HHQ�SRVLWLHI�HQ�VLJQLILFDQW�HIIHFW�JHYRQGHQ��0DDU��EHLGH�ZDUHQ�JHULFKW�RS�NLQGHUHQHQ� MHXJGLJHQ� HQ� YLHOHQ� GDDURP� EXLWHQ� GH� KXLGLJH� VWXGLH�� 'DW� EHWHNHQW� GDW� ELMYROZDVVHQHQ� YRRUDOVQRJ� DOOHHQ� HIIHFWHQ� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� RS� SV\FKLVFKH� NODFKWHQ� HQV\PSWRPHQ�RQGHU]RFKW�]LMQ�HQ�QLHW�RS�GH�LQFLGHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�]LHNWHQ�

���� %HDQWZRRUGLQJ�YDQ�GH�YUDDJVWHOOLQJHQ2QGDQNV� GH� EHVSURNHQ� EHSHUNLQJHQ� JHHIW� GH]H� VWXGLH� ZHO� LQGLFDWLHV� RYHU� GHYUDDJVWHOOLQJHQ�GLH�ZLM�RQGHU]RFKWHQ�'H�HHUVWH� YUDDJ�ZDV�RI� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� LQ� VWDDW� ]LMQ� RP�GH� FRQVHTXHQWLHVYDQ� LQJULMSHQGH� OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� HQ� VWUHVVRUHQ� YRRU� GH� JHHVWHOLMNH� JH]RQGKHLG� WHYHUPLQGHUHQ�� 9RRU� HQNHOH� OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� HQ� VWUHVVRUHQ� YRQGHQ� ZH� GDW� GLWLQGHUGDDG�PRJHOLMN� LV�� 'XLGHOLMN� EHwQYORHGEDDU� ]LMQ� GH� FRQVHTXHQWLHV� YDQ� KHW� ]RUJHQYRRU� HHQ� SV\FKLDWULVFK� ]LHN� IDPLOLHOLG�� $DQZLM]LQJHQ� YRRU� EHwQYORHGEDDUKHLG� YRQGHQZH� YRRU� URXZ� HQ� ZHUNHORRVKHLG�� 'H� FRQVHTXHQWLHV� YDQ� KHW� ]RUJHQ� YRRU� HHQKXOSEHKRHYHQG�RXGHU�IDPLOLHOLG�OLMNHQ�RS�GLW�PRPHQW�QRJ�QLHW�JRHG�WH�EHwQYORHGHQ�'H� WZHHGH� YUDDJ�ZDV� RI� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� GH� HUYDUHQ� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ� NXQQHQEHwQYORHGHQ�� 'LW� OLMNW� RS� EDVLV� YDQ� GH� GRRU� RQV� JHVHOHFWHHUGH� VWXGLHV� QLHW� KHW� JHYDO�(FKWHU��ZH�VHOHFWHHUGHQ�DOOHHQ�VWXGLHV�GLH�]RZHO�HIIHFWHQ�RS�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ�DOV�HIIHFWHQ�RSJHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLG�UDSSRUWHHUGHQ��'LW�UHVXOWHHUGH�LQ�HHQ�NOHLQ�DDQWDO�VWXGLHV�

Page 126: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

'H�GHUGH�YUDDJ��NXQQHQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�VHOI�HIILFDF\�EHwQYORHGHQ"��NXQQHQZH�YRRU]LFKWLJ�SRVLWLHI�EHDQWZRRUGHQ��:H�YRQGHQ�HHQ�NOHLQ�PDDU�VLJQLILFDQW�HIIHFW�YDQSUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�'H YLHUGH� YUDDJ�EHWURI�GH�HIIHFWLYLWHLW� YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�ZDW� EHWUHIW� KHWEHwQYORHGHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�SUREOHPHQ��:H�KHEEHQ�GH]H�YUDDJ�QLHW�GLUHFW�LQ�GH]H�VWXGLHRQGHU]RFKW��PDDU�KHEEHQ�YRRU�GH�EHDQWZRRUGLQJ�JHEUXLN�JHPDDNW�YDQ�GH�HHUGHU�GRRURQV� XLWJHYRHUGH� OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLHV� GLH� LQ� GH� NDGHUWHNVWHQ� �]LH� KRRIGVWXN �� VWDDQVDPHQJHYDW�� 2YHU� KHW� HIIHFW� YDQ� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� VFKL]RIUHQLH�� VRPDWLVHULQJ� HQ� VXwFLGHEOHHN� QLHWV� WH� YLQGHQ� WH� ]LMQ�� 3UHYHQWLH� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH� HQ� DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� LV� ZHO� LQPHHUGHUH� VWXGLHV� RQGHU]RFKW��PDDU� GH� UHVXOWDWHQ� ]LMQ� QRJ� QLHW� HHQGXLGLJ��:DW� EHWUHIWSRVWWUDXPDWLVFKH�VWUHVV�VWRRUQLVVHQ�ZHUG�JHHQ�HIIHFW�JHYRQGHQ��(HQ�DDQWDO�VSHFLILHNHUHSUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� ZHUGHQ� XLWYRHULJHU� EHVWXGHHUG�� 'DDUELM� EOHHN� GDW� VHFXQGDLUHSUHYHQWLH�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�ELM�RXGHUHQ�JURWH�HIIHFWHQ�KHHIW��SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�GUXJJHEUXLN�YLDVFKRROSURJUDPPD¶V�EOHHN�RRN�HIIHFWLHI�WH�]LMQ��KRHZHO�GH]H�HIIHFWHQ�NOHLQ�]LMQ��+RHZHOSUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� ELM� NLQGHUHQ� HQ� MHXJGLJHQ� QLHW� WRW� KHW� RQGHUZHUS� YDQ� GH]HVWXGLH� EHKRRUGHQ�� JLQJHQ� ZH� WHU� LOOXVWUDWLH� QD� ZDW� GH� HIIHFWHQ� YDQ� SUHYHQWLH� YDQJHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�]LMQ��'H]H�HIIHFWHQ�EOHNHQ�PLGGHOJURRW�WH�]LMQ�$O�PHW�DO�LV�KHW�YHOG�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�NODFKWHQ�HQ�KHW�EHwQYORHGHQ�YDQGHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� JH]RQGKHLG� QRJ� RQYROGRHQGH� RQGHU]RFKW�� 9HHOEHODQJULMNH�YUDJHQ�]LMQ�QRJ�QLHW�WH�EHDQWZRRUGHQ�

���� 'LVFXVVLH+HW� YHUGLHQW� DDQEHYHOLQJ� RP� PHHU� RQGHU]RHN� WH� GRHQ� ZDDULQ� RQGHU]RFKW� ZRUGW� RISUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GDDGZHUNHOLMN�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�NXQQHQYRRUNRPHQ��'DW�JHOGW�]RZHO�YRRU�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GLH�JHULFKW�]LMQ�RS�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�DOV�RSLQWHUYHQWLHV�GLH�]LFK�GLUHFW�ULFKWHQ�RS�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�NODFKWHQ��+HW�QDJHQRHJRQWEUHNHQ�YDQ�RQGHU]RHN�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�RS�GH�LQFLGHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�LVGHV� WH�RSPHUNHOLMNHU�RPGDW�GLW� WRFK� DOV� HHQ�YDQ�GH�EHODQJULMNVWH� HLQGGRHOHQ�YDQ�GH]HLQWHUYHQWLHV�JH]LHQ�NDQ�ZRUGHQ�$DQ� GH� DQGHUH� NDQW� LV� KHW� ZHOOLFKW� QLHW� DOWLMG� QRRG]DNHOLMN� GDW� SUHYHQWLHYHLQWHUYHQWLHV� HHQ� HIIHFW� KHEEHQ� RS� GH� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� +HWYHUPLQGHUHQ� YDQ� GH� SV\FKLVFKH� FRQVHTXHQWLHV� YDQ� LQJULMSHQGH� JHEHXUWHQLVVHQ� RIVWUHVVRUHQ�NDQ�RRN�RS�]LFK]HOI�DOV�ZDDUGHYRO�EHVFKRXZG�ZRUGHQ��=R�NDQ�ELMYRRUEHHOGKHW� YHUPLQGHUHQ� YDQ� KHW� SV\FKLVFK� OHHG� YDQ� IDPLOLHOHGHQ� GLH� GH� ]RUJ� YRRU� HHQSV\FKLDWULVFKH�SDWLsQW� GUDJHQ�� RRN� HHQ� OHJLWLHP�GRHO� YDQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� ]LMQZDQQHHU� �QRJ�� QLHW� GXLGHOLMN� LV� RI� GH� SUHYDOHQWLH� YDQ� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� GDDUPHHJHUHGXFHHUG�NDQ�ZRUGHQ�2S EDVLV� YDQ� GH]H� VWXGLH� NXQQHQ� ZH� JHHQ� GHILQLWLHYH� FRQFOXVLHV� WUHNNHQ� RYHU� GHSUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GLH�KHW�PHHVW�YHHOEHORYHQG�]LMQ��RI�RYHU�GH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�GLHPHW�EHKXOS�YDQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV�KHW�EHVW�EHwQYORHGEDDU�]LMQ��+HW�OLMNW�HFKWHU�DDQQHPHOLMN�GDWPHW� QDPH� GLH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� YHHOEHORYHQG� ]LMQ� GLH� RS� PHHUGHUH� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� WHJHOLMNDDQJULMSHQ��'LW� VOXLW� WHYHQV� DDQ�ELM� KHW�PRGHO�� ]RDOV� JHSUHVHQWHHUG� LQ� GH� ELMGUDJH� YDQ2UPHO�HW�DO�� LQ�GLW� UDSSRUW��=R�]LMQ�YHHO�SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�]RZHO�JHULFKW�RS�HHQLQJULMSHQGH� OHYHQVJHEHXUWHQLV� RI� FKURQLVFKH� VWUHVVRU�� DOV� RS� FRSLQJ�YDDUGLJKHGHQ� RIVRFLDOH�VWHXQ��%LM�GH�RQWZLNNHOLQJ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�LV�KHW�GDQ�RRN�YDQ�JURRWEHODQJ�WH�RQGHU]RHNHQ�RS�ZHONH�GHWHUPLQDQWHQ�KHW�EHVWH�DDQJHJUHSHQ�NDQ�ZRUGHQ�

Page 127: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

9HHOEHORYHQG� OLMNHQ� GH� JHwQGLFHHUGH� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� GLH� JHULFKW� ]LMQ� RSSHUVRQHQ�GLH�UHHGV�HQLJH�V\PSWRPHQ�YDQ�HHQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV�YHUWRQHQ��,QGLHQ�GH]HLQWHUYHQWLHV� JHEDVHHUG� ]LMQ� RS� NHQQLV� RYHU� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YRRU� GH]H� VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQYRRUWERXZHQ�RS�NHQQLV�RYHU�EHKDQGHOLQJ�YDQ�GH]H�VWRRUQLVVHQ��NXQQHQ�]LM�RS�HIIHFWLHYHZLM]H�KHW�RQWVWDDQ�YDQ�QLHXZH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�YRRUNRPHQ��'LW� LV�PHW�QDPH�LQWHUHVVDQW�ELMVWRRUQLVVHQ�ZDDUYDQ� YHHO� NHQQLV� RYHU� GH� EHKDQGHOLQJ� EHVFKLNEDDU� LV�� ]RDOV� DQJVW�� HQGHSUHVVLHYH�VWRRUQLVVHQ��%LM�MRQJHUH�OHHIWLMGVJURHSHQ�ZHUGHQ�KLHUYRRU�DO�YHHOEHORYHQGHYRRUEHHOGHQ� JHYRQGHQ� �&ODUNH� HW� DO��� ������ 'DGGV�� ������� 0RJHOLMN� NXQQHQ� ]R� RRNFKURQLVFKH� DDQGRHQLQJHQ� LQ� HHQ� YURHJ� VWDGLXP� DDQJHSDNW�ZRUGHQ� HQ� NDQ� FKURQLFLWHLWYRRUNRPHQ�ZRUGHQ�:H� YRQGHQ� JHHQ� HYLGHQWLH� GDW� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� HIIHFWHQ� KHEEHQ� RS� VRFLDOHVWHXQ�� 9HHO� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� GLH� LQ� GH� SUDNWLMN� ZRUGHQ� XLWJHYRHUG�� PHW� QDPH]HOIKXOS�� HQ� RQGHUVWHXQLQJVJURHSHQ�� ]LMQ� JHULFKW� RS� YHUEHWHULQJ� YDQ� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ�0RJHOLMN� KHHIW� KHW� QLHW� YLQGHQ� YDQ� HIIHFWHQ� WH� PDNHQ� PHW� GH� EHSHUNLQJHQ� YDQ� RQVRQGHU]RHN��PDDU�PRJHOLMN�YHUGLHQW�KHW�RRN�DDQEHYHOLQJ�RP�LQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHVPHHU�DDQ�WH�VOXLWHQ�RS�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GLH�RRN�LQ�GH�EHKDQGHOLQJ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQHIIHFWLHI� ]LMQ� JHEOHNHQ�� ]RDOV� FRJQLWLHYH� JHGUDJVWKHUDSLH� HQ� VRFLDOHYDDUGLJKHLGVWUDLQLQJHQ�� 'HUJHOLMNH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� ]LMQ� YHHO� PHHU� JHULFKW� RS� FRSLQJ�YDDUGLJKHGHQ�� 'H� UHODWLHYH� HIIHFWLYLWHLW� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHULFKW� RS� VRFLDOH� VWHXQ� HQLQWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS�FRSLQJ�YDDUGLJKHGHQ�]RX�QDGHU�RQGHU]RFKW�PRHWHQ�ZRUGHQ�:H�YRQGHQ�HQNHOH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�ZDDUYDQ�GH�HIIHFWLYLWHLW� YROGRHQGH� OLMNW� DDQJHWRRQGRP� RYHU� WH� JDDQ� WRW� ODQGHOLMNH� LPSOHPHQWDWLH�� 6FKRROJHULFKWH� YHUVODYLQJVSUHYHQWLH� LVHIIHFWLHI� HQ� DO� HQLJH� MDUHQ� ZRUGW� YDQXLW� KHW� 7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW� JHZHUNW� DDQ� ODQGHOLMNHLPSOHPHQWDWLH� YDQ� HHQ� JHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUG� SURJUDPPD� �'H� JH]RQGH� VFKRRO� HQJHQRWPLGGHOHQ���2RN�VHFXQGDLUH�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�ELM�RXGHUHQ� LV� HIIHFWLHI� HQ�HUZRUGW� UHHGV� JHZHUNW� DDQ� ODQGHOLMNH� LPSOHPHQWDWLH� YDQ� GH� FXUVXVVHQ� µ2PJDDQ� PHWGHSUHVVLH¶� YRRU� RXGHUHQ�� 9HUGHU� OLMNW� KHW� GXLGHOLMN� GDW� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHULFKW� RSIDPLOLHOHGHQ� YDQ� SV\FKLDWULVFKH� SDWLsQWHQ� HIIHFWLHI� ]LMQ�� 2RN� GH]H� LQWHUYHQWLHV� OLMNHQJHUHHG� YRRU� LPSOHPHQWDWLH�� YRRUDO� RRN� RPGDW� XLW� GLYHUVH� DQGHUH� RQGHU]RHNHQ� LVJHEOHNHQ� GDW� GHUJHOLMNH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� HYHQHHQV� WHUXJYDO� YDQ� GH� SDWLsQW� NXQQHQYRRUNRPHQ��/DP���������1DWXXUOLMN� LV�KHW�PRJHOLMN�GDW�HU�QDDVW�GH]H�GULH� LQWHUYHQWLHVQRJ�DQGHUH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�]LMQ�GLH�JHwPSOHPHQWHHUG�NXQQHQ�ZRUGHQ�(U� LV� QRJ� ZHLQLJ� EHNHQG� � RYHU� ZHONH� LPSOHPHQWDWLHVWUDWHJLHsQ� ELQQHQ� KHWSUHYHQWLHYHOG� KHW� PHHVW� HIIHFWLHI� ]LMQ�� 7RW� RS� KHGHQ� ZRUGW� GH� NHX]H� YRRUSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V� VWHUN� UHJLRQDDO� EHSDDOG�� 'DDUGRRU� EHVWDDW� HU� HHQ� YHHOKHLG� DDQSURJUDPPD¶V�HQ�]LMQ�HU�JHHQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GLH�RYHUDO�ZRUGHQ�XLWJHYRHUG��+HW�LV�GDQ�RRNYDQ�EHODQJ�RP�VWUDWHJLHsQ�YRRU�ODQGHOLMNH�LPSOHPHQWDWLH�YDQ�HIIHFWLHYH�SURJUDPPD¶V�WHRQWZLNNHOHQ�HQ�RQGHU]RHN�RS�GLW�WHUUHLQ�WH�VWLPXOHUHQ��7RW�RS�KHGHQ�LV�HU�RS�KHW�WHUUHLQYDQ�GH�**=�SUHYHQWLH�QRJ�QDXZHOLMNV�LPSOHPHQWDWLH�RQGHU]RHN�YHUULFKW�

Page 128: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

� .DGHUWHNVWHQ���� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�SV\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ,Q� GH]H� SDUDJUDDI� YDWWHQ� ZLM� GH� OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH� VDPHQ� GLH� UHFHQW� GRRU� KHW� 7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW� LQ� RSGUDFKW� YDQ� =RUJ2QGHU]RHN� 1HGHUODQG� LV� YHUULFKW� QDDU� KHW� HIIHFW� YDQSUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�HQ�JHGUDJVSUREOHPDWLHN��9DQ�*DJHOGRQN��5LJWHU���������:HEHSHUNHQ�RQV�WRW�GH�UHVXOWDWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�ELM�YROZDVVHQHQ�$FKWHUJURQG�HQ�SUREOHHPVWHOOLQJ+HW�HIIHFW�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�LQ�GH�JHHVWHOLMNH�JH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ�LV�WRW�QRJ�WRH�QLHW�HPSLULVFKYDVWJHVWHOG�� 'H]H� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� RYHU]LFKWVVWXGLH� JHHIW� HHQ� RYHU]LFKW� YDQ� GHZHWHQVFKDSSHOLMNH� HYLGHQWLH� YRRU� KHW� HIIHFW� YDQ� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� HUQVWLJH� SV\FKLVFKHSUREOHPHQ� ELM� YROZDVVHQHQ�� :LM� VHOHFWHHUGHQ� JHHQ� RQGHU]RHN� QDDU� KHW� HIIHFW� RSWHYUHGHQKHLG�RI�DQGHUH�PRJHOLMN�LQWHUPHGLDLUH�HIIHFWHQ�9RRU� HHQ� GHHO� QHPHQ� GH� RQGHU]RFKWH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� GHWHUPLQDQWHQ� YRRU� SV\FKLVFKHJH]RQGKHLG� DOV� XLWJDQJVSXQW�� YRRU� HHQ� DQGHU� GHHO� SUREHUHQ� ]LM� GLUHFW� �LQ� HHQ� YURHJVWDGLXP��DDQ�WH�JULMSHQ�RS�SV\FKLVFKH�SUREOHPDWLHN�,Q� KHW� KLHUQD� YROJHQGH� JDDQ� ZLM� QLHW� LQ� RS� FRQFUHWH� SUHYHQWLHYH� DFWLYLWHLWHQ� �GH]HZRUGHQ� RYHULJHQV� ODQJ� QLHW� DOWLMG� GXLGHOLMN� JHUDSSRUWHHUG��� PDDU� RSLQWHUYHQWLHFDWHJRULHsQ�9UDDJVWHOOLQJ:DW� LV� RS� JURQG� YDQ� JRHG� XLWJHYRHUG� HIIHFWRQGHU]RHN� WH� ]HJJHQ� RYHU� KHW� HIIHFW� YDQSUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� RS� V\PSWRPHQ� YDQ� HUQVWLJH� SV\FKLVFKH� SUREOHPHQ� ELMYROZDVVHQHQ"0HWKRGH'H YROJHQGH�EURQQHQ� OHYHUGHQ�GH�HHUVWH�YHU]DPHOLQJ�SXEOLFDWLHV��0HGOLQH�HQ�3V\FKOLW�EHLGH� YDQDI� ������ HQ� VXJJHVWLHV� YDQ�GHVNXQGLJHQ��0HW� EHKXOS� YDQ� GH� UHIHUHQWLHV� XLW�RYHU]LFKWV�VWXGLHV� HQ� SURHIVFKULIWHQ� VSRRUGHQ� ZLM� YHUYROJHQV� DQGHUH� SXEOLFDWLHV� YDQHIIHFWRQGHU]RHN� RS� �RRN� JRHG� XLWJHYRHUGH� VWXGLHV� YDQ� YRRU� ������� 'HSUREOHHPFDWHJRULHsQ� ]LMQ�� VFKL]RIUHQLH� HQ� VRPDWLVHULQJ�� GHSUHVVLH�� DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�VXwFLGH�HQ�SRVWWUDXPDWLVFKH�VWUHVV�VWRRUQLVVHQ�8LW GH]H� YHU]DPHOLQJ� VHOHFWHHUGHQ� ZLM� YHUYROJHQV� 5DQGRPL]HG� &OLQLFDO� 7ULDOV�5&7¶V�� PDDU� RRN� QLHW�JHUDQGRPLVHHUG�� JHFRQWUROHHUG� RQGHU]RHN� PHW� HHQ� VWHHNSURHIJURWHU�GDQ�����9RRUWV�GLHQGH�GH�XLWNRPVW��SV\FKLVFKH�SUREOHPDWLHN��WH�]LMQ�JHPHWHQ�PHWHHQ� JHYDOLGHHUG� LQVWUXPHQW�� 1LHW� JHVHOHFWHHUG� ZHUGHQ� SXEOLFDWLHV� RYHU� WHUWLDLUHSUHYHQWLH�� :LM� VHOHFWHHUGHQ� HYHQPLQ� VWXGLHV� RYHU� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� JHEUXLN� YDQJHQRWPLGGHOHQ��]LH�GHHO�%���SDUDJUDDI����� 9DQ�*DJHOGRQN��&XLMSHUV��������7HQVORWWH�]LMQ�LQGLFDWLHV�JHJHYHQ�YDQ�YHUVFKLOOHQ�LQ�PHWKRGRORJLVFKH�NZDOLWHLW�RS�JURQGYDQ� VRPVFRUHV� RS� YLMI� FULWHULD�� ZHO�QLHW� JHUDQGRPLVHHUG�� ZHO�QLHW� �HQNHO�JHEOLQGHHUG�

Page 129: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

ZHO�QLHW� YHUJHOLMNEDUH� RQGHU]RHNVJURHSHQ� RS� GH� YRRUPHWLQJ�� XLWYDOSHUFHQWDJH� RS� GHODDWVWH�PHWLQJ�HQ�ZHO�QLHW�VSHFLILFDWLH�YDQ�LQFOXVLHFULWHULD�:LM� ]XOOHQ� LQ� GH]H� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� RYHU]LFKWVVWXGLH� RQJHWZLMIHOG� HQNHOH� SXEOLFDWLHVJHPLVW�KHEEHQ��PDDU�GH�FRQFOXVLHV�RS�JURQG�YDQ�HHQ�LQWHQVLHYHUH�]RHNWRFKW�]RXGHQ�HUYHUPRHGHOLMN�QLHW�YHHO�DQGHUV�XLW�KHEEHQ�JH]LHQ�6WXGLHV��DDQWDO�HQ�NZDOLWHLW*HHQ� YDQ� GH� DDQYDQNHOLMN� YHU]DPHOGH� VWXGLHV� QDDU� KHW� HIIHFW� YDQ� SUHYHQWLH� ELMVFKL]RIUHQLH� HQ� VRPDWLVHULQJ� ]LMQ� JHVHOHFWHHUG� �]LH� KLHURQGHU��� 2RN� GH� VWXGLHV� QDDUSUHYHQWLH� YDQ� VXwFLGH� YROGHGHQ� QLHW� DDQ� RQ]H� VHOHFWLHFULWHULD�� 9RRU� GH� RYHULJHSUREOHHPFDWHJRULHsQ� VHOHFWHHUGHQ�ZLM� LQ� WRWDDO� ��� VWXGLHV�ZDDURQGHU� ���5&7¶V��9RRUGHSUHVVLH�HQ�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�JDDW�KHW�RP����RQGHU]RHNHQ�ZDDURQGHU����5&7¶V�HQ�YRRUSRVWWUDXPDWLVFKH� VWUHVV�VWRRUQLVVHQ� ]HV� �GULH� 5&7¶V��� ZDDUYDQ� YLHU� YDQ� 1HGHUODQGVHRQGHU]RHNHUV����5&7¶V���'H�PHWKRGRORJLVFKH�NZDOLWHLW�SHU�GRHOJURHS�YDULHHUW�YDQ����WRW�������UDQJH��±������,Q�WDEHO ����LV�DDQJHJHYHQ�KRHYHHO�VWXGLHV�SHU�FDWHJRULH�ZHUGHQJHVHOHFWHHUG��ZDW�GH�PHWKRGRORJLVFKH�NZDOLWHLW�ELM�EHQDGHULQJ�LV�HQ�ZDW�GH�XLWNRPVWHQ�7DEHO�����$DQWDO�RQGHU]RHNHQ�SHU�FDWHJRULH�YDQ�RQGHUZHUSHQ�QDDU�RQGHU]RHNVRS]HW�

JHPLGGHOGH�NZDOLWHLWVVFRUH�HQ�XLWNRPVWHQ�&DWHJRULH $DQWDO�RQGHU]RHNVRS]HW�D *HPLGGHOGH

NZDOLWHLWVVFRUH�E$DQWDO�XLWNRPVWHQ�F

'HSUHVVLH�HQ�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� MRQJHUH�ZHGXZHQ ��5&7¶V ��� ��� EHYDOOLQJ�PRHGHUVFKDS ��5&7¶V ��� ��� YHU]RUJHUV�YDQ�HHQ�VFKL]RIUHHQ

JH]LQVOLG� 5&7¶V� JHFRQWUROHHUG

��� ���� YHU]RUJHUV�YDQ�FKURQLVFK�]LHNH

RXGHUHQ� 5&7¶V� JHFRQWUROHHUG

��� �������������� ZHUNORRVKHLG ��5&7 ��� �� SROLNOLQLVFKH�SDWLsQWHQ��ODJH�6(6� ��JHFRQWUROHHUG ��� �� RXGHUH�ZHGXZHQ�HQ�ZHGXZQDDUV ��5&7¶V

� JHFRQWUROHHUG��� �����

� RXGHUHQ�DOJHPHHQ ��5&7¶V ��� ��3RVWWUDXPDWLVFKH�VWUHVV�VWRRUQLVVHQ� QD�RQJHYDO�RI�QDWXXUUDPS ��5&7¶V

� JHFRQWUROHHUG��� �������

� QD�PLVNUDDP ��5&7¶V ��� ��D��5&7� �JHUDQGRPLVHHUG�HQ�JHFRQWUROHHUG��JHFRQWUROHHUG� �QLHW�JHUDQGRPLVHHUG�RQGHU]RHN��E��5DQJH�NZDOLWHLWVVFRUHV��5&7¶V�������JHFRQWUROHHUG�RQGHU]RHN�������F���� �SRVLWLHI��JHZHQVW��HIIHFW���� �JHHQ�HIIHFW���� �QHJDWLHI��RQJHZHQVW��HIIHFW��:LM�YHURQGHUVWHOOHQ�JHPDNVKDOYHGDW�GH�NZDOLWHLWVVFRUHV�YDQ�5&7¶V�HQ�QLHW�JHUDQGRPLVHHUG�RQGHU]RHN�YHUJHOLMNEDDU�]LMQ�

5HVXOWDWHQ��LQWHUYHQWLHV�HQ�HIIHFW6FKL]RIUHQLH+HW� QXW� YDQ� HHQ� VFUHHQLQJVSURJUDPPD� �EHYRONLQJVRQGHU]RHN�� ZRUGW� DOJHPHHQEHRRUGHHOG� RS� JURQG� YDQ� GH� YROJHQGH� YUDJHQ��:DW� LV� GH� VHQVLWLYLWHLW�� VSHFLILFLWHLW� HQYRRUVSHOOHQGH�ZDDUGH�YDQ�GH�VFUHHQLQJVPHWKRGH"�,V�HU�HHQ�HIIHFWLHYH�EHKDQGHOLQJ�RP

Page 130: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

WRH�WH�SDVVHQ�ELM�RQWGHNWH� JHYDOOHQ"�9ROGRHW�KHW�EHYRONLQJVRQGHU]RHN�DDQ�HWKLVFKH�HQMXULGLVFKH�EHJLQVHOHQ"2QGHU]RHN�QDDU�RQGHUNHQQLQJ�YDQ�YRRUWHNHQHQ�YDQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH�RQGHU�YROZDVVHQHQPHW� DOV� GRHO� HHQ� SV\FKRVH� WH� YRRUNRPHQ� LV� QRJ� LQ� XLWYRHULQJ�� 6HFXQGDLUH� SUHYHQWLH�YURHJH�RSVSRULQJ��YDQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH�RQGHU�YROZDVVHQHQ�LV�QRJ�QLHW�UHDOLVWLVFK��9DJOXP��������'H�YRRUVSHOOHQGH�ZDDUGH�KDQJW�DI�YDQ�VHQVLWLYLWHLW��VSHFLILFLWHLW�HQ�LQFLGHQWLH�YDQGH�YHUVFKLMQVHOHQ�GLH�]RXGHQ�ZLM]HQ�RS�QDGHUHQGH� VFKL]RIUHQLH��'LH� LQFLGHQWLH� LV� ODDJRQGHU� GH� DOJHPHQH� EHYRONLQJ� HQ� GDDURP� OLJW� EHYRONLQJVRQGHU]RHN� RS� GLH� VFKDDO� QLHWYRRU�GH�KDQG��9DQ�2V���������'H�V\PSWRPHQ�ZDDURS� JHVFUHHQG�]RX�NXQQHQ�ZRUGHQ�]RDOV� WHUXJJHWURNNHQKHLG�� DJUHVVLYLWHLW�� ZHLQLJ� YULHQGHQ�� IDPLOLHEHODVWLQJ�� HQ]RYRRUW�]LMQ PHHVWDO�YDDJ�HQ�GH�YRRUVSHOOHQGH�ZDDUGH�HUYDQ��HYHQDOV�GLH�YDQ�FRPELQDWLHV�YDQGH]H� IDFWRUHQ�� LV� YRRUDOVQRJ� ODDJ� �)DOORRQ� HW� DO��� ������ 0F*ODVKDQ� � -RKDQQHVVHQ�������9DQ�(QJHODQG��������9DQ�2V��������(HQ� DOWHUQDWLHI� LV� VFUHHQLQJ� RQGHU� ]RJHQRHPGH� µKRRJ�ULVLFR¶� SHUVRQHQ�� LQ� KHWELM]RQGHU�PHQVHQ�GLH�]LFK�PHW�µSUH�VFKL]RIUHQH¶�NODFKWHQ� WRW�GH�KXOSYHUOHQLQJ�KHEEHQJHZHQG��'H�PRJHOLMNH�RSEUHQJVW�YDQ�GH]H�DDQSDN�LQ�WHUPHQ�YDQ�VHQVLWLYLWHLW��VSHFLILFL�WHLW� HQ� YRRUVSHOOHQGH� ZDDUGH� VWDDW� QRJ� RQYROGRHQGH� YDVW�� (YHQPLQ� LV� EHNHQG� RI� HUHIIHFWLHYH� EHKDQGHOLQJ� NDQ� ZRUGHQ� JHERGHQ� DDQ� SUH�VFKL]RIUHQH� SDWLsQWHQ�� (U� ]LMQYRUPHQ�YDQ�YURHJEHKDQGHOLQJ�GLH�PHW�HQLJ�VXFFHV�ZRUGHQ�WRHJHSDVW�]RGUD�HU�GDDGZHU�NHOLMN�VSUDNH�LV�YDQ�SV\FKRVH��PDDU�RI�GLH�EHKDQGHOLQJHQ�RRN�JXQVWLJ�XLWZHUNHQ�ELM�SUH�VFKL]RIUHQLH�PRHW�QRJ�ZRUGHQ�YDVWJHVWHOG��/LQV]HQ��������0F*RUU\�HW�DO���������<XQJHW� DO��� ������ /LQV]HQ�� ������ �������.RUWRP�� KHW� QXW� YDQ� VFUHHQLQJ� RS� YRRUVWDGLD� YDQVFKL]RIUHQLH�LV�QRJ�QLHW�DDQJHWRRQG�6RPDWLVHULQJ6RPDWLVHULQJ� LV� HHQ� YDDJ� EHJULS�� 0HQ� NDQ� RQGHUVFKHLG� PDNHQ� WXVVHQ� VRPDWLVD�WLHV\PSWRPHQ�� RQYROOHGLJH� VRPDWLVDWLHVWRRUQLV� HQ� YROOHGLJH� VRPDWLVDWLHVWRRUQLV�� 0HWRQYROOHGLJH�VRPDWLVDWLH� LV�EHGRHOG�HHQ�VDPHQVWHO�YDQ�V\PSWRPHQ�GDW� LQ�DDQWDO�RQGHUGH� GUHPSHO� EOLMIW� GLH� LQ� FODVVLILFDWLHV\VWHPHQ� DOV� GH� '60�,9� LV� JHVWHOG� RP� YDQ� HHQ�YROOHGLJH��VRPDWLVDWLHVWRRUQLV�WH�NXQQHQ�VSUHNHQ��+HW�LV�QLHW�JH]HJG�GDW�VRPDWLVDWLH�ELMSDWLsQWHQ�SURJUHVVLHI�YHUORRSW�YDQ�V\PSWRRP�QDDU�HUQVWLJH�VWRRUQLV��'DDURP�LV�RQGXLGH�OLMN� RI� SUHYHQWLH� ELM� V\PSWRPHQ� RI� ELM� HHQ� PLQGHU� HUQVWLJH� VRPDWLVDWLHVWRRUQLV� KHWRQWVWDDQ� YDQ� HHQ� HUQVWLJH� VRPDWLVDWLHVWRRUQLV� NDQ� YRRUNRPHQ� �6SHFNHQV� HW� DO��� �����$YLD�HW�DO���������5LJWHU�HW�DO���������:DUZLFN�HW�DO���������/LGEHFN���������9RRU�]RYHUZLM RQGHU]RHN�WHJHQNZDPHQ�ZDV�GLW�JHULFKW�RS�WHUWLDLUH�SUHYHQWLH�RI�EHKDQGHOLQJ��:LMZHWHQ�PRPHQWHHO�QLHWV�RYHU�KHW�HIIHFW�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�VRPDWLVHULQJ�'HSUHVVLH��DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�HQ�VXwFLGH9HHO�RQGHU]RHN�GDW�ZLM�RQGHU�GH]H�SUREOHHPFDWHJRULH�UDQJVFKLNWH��YLHO�ELM�WRHWVLQJ�DDQRQ]H�VHOHFWLHFULWHULD�DI��ZDDURQGHU�DOOH�GRRU�RQV�YHU]DPHOGH�VWXGLHV�RYHU�SUHYHQWLH�YDQVXwFLGH��,Q�GH�VWXGLHV�GLH�ZHO�YROGHGHQ�DDQ�RQ]H�VHOHFWLHFULWHULD�ZRUGW�]RZHO�LQGLYLGXHOHDOV� JURHSVJHULFKWH� SUHYHQWLH� RQGHU]RFKW�� +HW� JDDW� GDDUELM� YRRUDO� RP� YRRUOLFKWLQJ�PRQGHOLQJ�HQ� VFKULIWHOLMN� ELMYRRUEHHOG� LQ� GH� YRUP�YDQ�ELEOLRWKHUDSLH���ZRUNVKRSV� HQSV\FKRHGXFDWLHYH�FXUVXVVHQ��FRUUHFWLH�YDQ�JHGDFKWHQ��FRJQLWLHV��RI�YDQ��JHGUDJ��RI��RPYHUVWHUNLQJ� YDQ� KHW� VRFLDDO� QHWZHUN�� $DQ� YHU]RUJHQGH� OHGHQ� YDQ� HHQ� JH]LQ� ZDDULQVFKL]RIUHQLH�YRRUNRPW��ZRUGW�VRPV�YRRUOLFKWLQJ�HQ�RHIHQLQJHQ�DDQJHERGHQ��6WHXQ�DDQ�PHHVWDO� RXGHUH�� YHU]RUJHQGHQ� YDQ� GHPHQWHUHQGH� RXGHUHQ� �YDDN� GH� SDUWQHU� RI� HHQIDPLOLHOLG�� LV�EHGRHOG�RP� WH�YRRUNRPHQ�GDW� ]LM�SUREOHPHQ�NULMJHQ��'RHO� LV� ERYHQGLHQ

Page 131: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

RP�RSQDPH�YDQ�GH�GHPHQWHUHQGH�LQ�HHQ�YHU]RUJLQJVWHKXLV�XLW�WH�VWHOOHQ��&XLMSHUV�HW�DO��������� 2RN� NDQ� VSUDNH� ]LMQ� YDQ� RQGHUVWHXQLQJVJURHSHQ� ZDDULQ� HUYDULQJHQ� ZRUGHQXLWJHZLVVHOG��YRRUOLFKWLQJ�ZRUGW�JHJHYHQ�RYHU�GHPHQWLH�HQ�RYHU�KRH�PHQ�EHWHU�PHW�GHGHPHQWHUHQGH�RXGHUH�NDQ�RPJDDQ��2P�GHSUHVVLH�HQ�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ�WH�YRRUNRPHQ�ELMRXGHUHQ�GLH�QLHW�FKURQLVFK�]LHN�]LMQ��ZRUGW�PHHVWDO�WKXLV�DGYLVHUHQGH�JHVSUHNNHQ�JHKRX�GHQ�RI�KHP�RI�KDDU�ELEOLRWKHUDSLH��HHQ�YRUP�YDQ�]HOIKXOS��JHERGHQ��+HW�GRHO�YDQ�YLMIDQGHUH�RQGHU]RHNHQ�ZDV�YRRUNRPLQJ�RI�YHUPLQGHULQJ�YDQ� URXZYHUVFKLMQVHOHQ� �GHSUH�VVLH��DQJVW��HHQ]DDPKHLG��ELM�RXGHUH�ZHGXZHQ�HQ�ZHGXZQDDUV�7ZHH�VWXGLHV�YDQ�JRHGH�NZDOLWHLW� WRQHQ�DDQ�GDW�MRQJH�YURXZHQ�YDQ�ZLH�RQODQJV�GHSDUWQHU� LV� RYHUOHGHQ�� QD� SUHYHQWLH�PLQGHU� ODVW� KHEEHQ� YDQ� GHSUHVVLHYH� YHUVFKLMQVHOHQGDQ�SHUVRQHQ�LQ�GH�FRQWUROHJURHS��(pQ�5&7�WRRQGH�GDW�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�HQ�DQJVWLQ YHUEDQG�PHW�GH�HHUVWH�EHYDOOLQJ�HIIHFWLHI�ZDV��PDDU�HHQ�DQGHUH� OLHW�YRRU�SRVWQDWDOHGHSUHVVLH� JHHQ� HIIHFW� ]LHQ�� (HQ� GXLGHOLMN� HIIHFW� YDQ� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� GHSUHVVLH� HQ� DQJVWRQGHU�YHU]RUJHQGHQ�YDQ�HHQ�VFKL]RIUHHQ�JH]LQVOLG�LV�QRJ�QLHW�DDQJHWRRQG��GULH�VWXGLHVYDQ� JHPLGGHO� ODJH� NZDOLWHLW�PHW� DDQZLM]LQJHQ� YRRU� HHQ� HIIHFW��� 'HUWLHQ� RQGHU]RHNHQ�ZDDURQGHU� DFKW� 5&7V�� YDQ� UHGHOLMNH� NZDOLWHLW� JHYHQ� ZLVVHOHQGH� XLWNRPVWHQ� YRRUSUHYHQWLH�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH� HQ�DQJVW�RQGHU�YHU]RUJHQGHQ�YDQ�]LHNH� �GHPHQWHUHQGH��RXGH�UHQ��2RN�NDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�VXFFHV�KHEEHQ�ELM�SROLNOLQLVFKH�SDWLsQWHQ�PHW�HHQODJH�VRFLDDO�HFRQRPLVFKH�VWDWXV��6(6��RI�WLMGHQV�ODQJHU�GXUHQGH�ZHUNORRVKHLG��6OHFKWVppQ�YDQ�GH�YLMI�RQGHU]RHNHQ�YDQ�JHPLGGHOG�UHGHOLMNH�NZDOLWHLW�QDDU�KHW�YRRUNRPHQ�RIYHUZHUNHQ�YDQ�URXZYHUVFKLMQVHOHQ�KDG�KHW�YHUZDFKWH�UHVXOWDDW��GH�RYHULJH�YLHU�NRQGHQJHHQ�HIIHFW�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�DDQWRQHQ��7HQVORWWH� ODWHQ� WZHH�JRHG�XLWJHYRHUGH�5&7V�RYHUKHW� HIIHFW� ELM� GHSUHVVLH� ELM� RXGHUHQ� �ELEOLRWKHUDSLH� HQ� WKXLVJHVSUHNNHQ�� ]LHQ� GDWWKXLVJHVSUHNNHQ�QLHW�KLHOSHQ��PDDU�ELEOLRWKHUDSLH�ELM�OLFKW�GHSUHVVLHYH�RXGHUHQ�ZHO��'HODDWVWH�PHWLQJHQ�YDULHHUGHQ�LQ�DO�GH]H�VWXGLHV�YDQ�WZHH�ZHNHQ�WRW�GULH�MDDU�,Q�KHW�GRRU�RQV�JHDQDO\VHHUGH�RQGHU]RHN�QDDU�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SRVWWUDXPDWLVFKH�VWUHVV�VWRRUQLVVHQ�JDDW�KHW�PHHVWDO�RP�KHW�DDQELHGHQ�YDQ�RSYDQJJHVSUHNNHQ��LQGLYLGXHHO�RI�LQJURHSV�� RI� EHGULMIVYHUEDQG� �GHEULHILQJ��� � %HKDQGHOLQJ� YDQ� UHHGV� RQWVWDQH� V\PSWRPHQYDQ� GHUJHOLMNH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� KHEEHQ� ZLM� QLHW� PHHJHQRPHQ�� 7LMGHQV� RSYDQJJHVSUHNNHQZRUGW�LQ�HHQ�YHUWURXZGH�RPJHYLQJ�HPRWLRQHOH�VWHXQ�JHJHYHQ��GH�JHOHJHQKHLG�JHERGHQJHYRHOHQV� WH� XLWHQ� HQ� ZRUGW� VRPV� GH� WUDXPDWLVHUHQGH� JHEHXUWHQLV� JHUHFRQVWUXHHUG�9HURQGHUVWHOG�ZRUGW�GDW�GLW�KHW�YHUZHUNLQJVSURFHV�EHYRUGHUW��&DUOLHU��*HUVRQV��������,Q�]HYHQ�YDQ�GH�QHJHQ�VWXGLHV�ZDUHQ�GH�SURHISHUVRQHQ�VODFKWRIIHUV�YDQ�RQJHYDOOHQ�RIQDWXXUUDPSHQ� RI� UHGGLQJVZHUNHUV� HQ� SROLWLHDJHQWHQ� GLH� KLHUELM� ZHUGHQ� LQJH]HW�� ,Q� GHWZHH�RYHULJH�RQGHU]RHNHQ�JLQJ�KHW�RP�KXOS�QD�HHQ�PLVNUDDP��*HHQ�YDQ�EHLGH�OHYHUGHEHZLMV� WHQ� JXQVWH� YDQ� GHEULHILQJ�� 8LW� GH� ]HYHQ� DQGHUH� VWXGLHV� NDQ� JHFRQFOXGHHUGZRUGHQ�GDW�GHEULHILQJ��]RDOV� WRW�QRJ� WRH� LQ� HIIHFWRQGHU]RHN�JHSUDNWL]HHUG��JHHQ�HIIHFWEOLMNW� WH� KHEEHQ� RS� KHW� RQWVWDDQ� YDQ� HUQVWLJH� SV\FKLVFKH� VWRRUQLVVHQ�� 'H]H� QHJDWLHYHFRQFOXVLH� VWHPW� RYHUHHQ� PHW� GLH� YDQ� HHQ� GRRU� KHW� &RFKUDQH�QHWZHUN� JHSXEOLFHHUGHVWXGLH��:HVVHO\�HW�DO����������'H�ODDWVWH�PHWLQJHQ�YDULHHUGHQ�YDQ�GULH�WRW����PDDQGHQ�QDKHW�RQJHYDO�RI�GH�UDPS�&RQFOXVLHV2YHU�KHW�HIIHFW�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH��VRPDWLVHULQJ�HQ�VXwFLGH�ZHWHQ�ZLM�QRJQLHWV��3UHYHQWLH�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�HQ�DQJVWVWRRUQLVVHQ� LV�ZHOLVZDDU� LQ�PHHU�SXEOLNDWLHV�RSHIIHFW� RQGHU]RFKW��PDDU� GH]H� YHU]DPHOLQJ� VWXGLHV� YHUWRRQW� QRJ� YHHO� EHSHUNLQJHQ�� 'HVWXGLHV�]LMQ�JHPLGGHOG�ZHOLVZDDU�YDQ�UHGHOLMNH� WRW�JRHGH�NZDOLWHLW�PDDU�GRRU�GH�JURWH

Page 132: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

YDULDWLH� DDQ� GRHOJURHSHQ� HQ� �PRJHOLMNH�� RRU]DNHQ� YDQ� GH]H� VWRRUQLVVHQ� LV� KHW� DDQWDOVWXGLHV� SHU� GRHOJURHS� YDDN� JHULQJ�� 9RRU� HHQ� GRHOJURHS� �YHUZHGXZGHQ�� LV� RRN� GHNZDOLWHLW� EHQHGHQ� GH� PDDW� HQ� YHUVFKLOOHQ� GH� XLWNRPVWHQ�� (U� EOLMNW� YRRUWV� RS� GLWRQGHU]RHNVWHUUHLQ�QRJ�JHHQ�WUDGLWLH�WH�EHVWDDQ�RP�GH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�WH�UDSSRUWHUHQ��'RRUGH�RQGHU]RHNHUV�ZRUGW� WRW�QRJ� WRH�]HOGHQ�GH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�EHUHNHQG��2S�JURQG�YDQ�GHJHUDSSRUWHHUGH�JHJHYHQV�NRQGHQ�ZLM�]HOI�GH]H�PDDW�LQ�PLQGHU�GDQ�GH�KHOIW�YDQ�KHW�WRWDOHDDQWDO�RQGHU]RHNHQ��YHHODO�GH�UHFHQWHUH��YDVWVWHOOHQ��8LW�KHW�ERYHQVWDDQGH�EOLMNW�GDW�GHIROORZ�XS� SHULRGHQ� DDQ]LHQOLMN� YHUVFKLOOHQ�� 9RRUWV� LV� LQ� GH]H� RQGHU]RHNHQ� JHEUXLNJHPDDNW� YDQ� UXLP� WLHQ� PHHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ� YRRU� GHSUHVVLH�� YLMI� YRRU� DQJVWV\PSWRPHQ�HYHQHHQV� YLMI� YRRU� SRVWWUDXPDWLVFKH� VWUHVV�VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� QRJ� HHQV� YLMI� YRRU� GLYHUVHVWRRUQLVVHQ��*+4��%6,�HQ�+6&���'LW�DOOHV�EHPRHLOLMNW�KHW�WUHNNHQ�YDQ�ZHWHQVFKDSSHOLMNYHUDQWZRRUGH�FRQFOXVLHV�*HHQ�HYLGHQWLH�YRRU� HHQ�HIIHFW� LV�QLHW�KHW]HOIGH� DOV� HYLGHQWLH� YRRU� JHHQ� HIIHFW��'LWODDWVWH� LV� KHW� JHYDO� YRRU� SUHYHQWLH� YDQ� SRVWWUDXPDWLVFKH� VWUHVV�VWRRUQLVVHQ� HQ� YRRUSUHYHQWLH� JHULFKW� RS� URXZYHUZHUNLQJ� ELM� ZHGXZHQ� RI� ZHGXZQDDUV�� 9HHOEHORYHQG� LVSUHYHQWLH� JHULFKW� RS� YHU]RUJHUV� YDQ� KXOSEHKRHYHQGH� RXGHUHQ�� 3UHYHQWLH� JHULFKW� RSURXZYHUZHUNLQJ�ELM�MRQJHUH�ZHGXZHQ�HQ�RS�YHU]RUJHQGHQ�YDQ�HHQ�VFKL]RIUHHQ�JH]LQVOLGLV ZDDUVFKLMQOLMN�RRN�HIIHFWLHI��9RRU�GH�RYHULJH�GRHOJURHSHQ� LV�GH�HYLGHQWLH��QRJ��QLHWRYHUWXLJHQG��RIZHO�KHW�HIIHFW�QRJ�QLHW�DDQJHWRRQG�

��� 6HFXQGDLUH�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�GHSUHVVLH�ELM�RXGHUHQ��KHWDNWLHI�DDQELHGHQ�YDQ�EHKDQGHOLQJ�DDQ�RXGHUHQ�PHWGHSUHVVLHYH�NODFKWHQ3UREOHHPVWHOOLQJ+HW� JHEUXLN� YDQ� **=�YRRU]LHQLQJHQ� GRRU� RXGHUHQ� PHW� GHSUHVVLHV� LV� ODDJ�� LQYHUJHOLMNLQJ�PHW�KHW�JHEUXLN�GRRU�MRQJHUH�YROZDVVHQHQ��*RWWOLHE��������&XLMSHUV�HW�DO���������'UHPSHOV�ZDDUGRRU�RXGHUHQ�PLQGHU�YDQ�GH]H�YRRU]LHQLQJHQ�JHEUXLN�PDNHQ�]LMQRQGHU�PHHU�ZHHUVWDQG�YDQ�RXGHUHQ� ]HOI�� RQWNHQQLQJ�YDQ�KHW� EHVWDDQ�YDQ�GH� NODFKWHQ�JHIUDJPHQWHHUGKHLG�YDQ�GH�]RUJ��JHEUHN�DDQ�YROGRHQGH�GHVNXQGLJKHLG�ELM�KXOSYHUOHQHUVLQ GH�HHUVWH�OLMQ�HQ�KHW�VWLJPD�GDW�QRJ�VWHHGV�DDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�DDQGRHQLQJHQ�YHUERQGHQ�LV�)ULHGKRII�� ������� 'RRU� GH]H� GUHPSHOV� LV� HU� HHQ� DDQ]LHQOLMNH� RQGHUVLJQDOHULQJ�RQGHUGLDJQRVWLHN�HQ�RQGHUEHKDQGHOLQJ�YDQ�GHSUHVVLHV�ELM�RXGHUHQ��)ULHGKRII���������(U]LMQ YHUVFKLOOHQGH� PRJHOLMNKHGHQ� RP� GH� WRHJDQJ� YDQ� RXGHUHQ� WRW� GH� JHHVWHOLMNHJH]RQGKHLGV]RUJ� WH� YHUEHWHUHQ�� ]RDOV� GHVNXQGLJKHLGVEHYRUGHULQJ� YDQ� HHUVWH� OLMQVKXOSYHUOHQHUV�HQ�µFDVH�ILQGLQJ¶�SURMHFWHQ�ELQQHQ�ELMYRRUEHHOG�PLQGHUKHLGVJURHSHULQJHQ�)ULHGKRII�� ������� 9HUGHU� NXQQHQ� RRN� ]RJHKHWHQ� µRXWUHDFK¶�SURJUDPPD¶V� RQWZLNNHOGZRUGHQ�� ZDDUELM� YURHJWLMGLJH� EHKDQGHOLQJ� DFWLHI� ZRUGW� DDQJHERGHQ� DDQ� RXGHUHQ� PHWGHSUHVVLHYH� NODFKWHQ�� PHW� DOV� GRHO� GH� NODFKWHQ� LQ� HHQ� ]R� YURHJ� PRJHOLMN� VWDGLXP� WHEHKDQGHOHQ��$FWLHI�DDQELHGHQ�YHUORRSW�YLD�DDQNRQGLJLQJHQ�LQ�ORNDOH�PHGLD�HQ�RSURHSHQJHULFKW�DDQ�YHUZLM]HUV�� ,Q�1HGHUODQG�ZRUGW�PRPHQWHHO�GRRU�RQJHYHHU�GH�KHOIW� YDQ�GH5LDJJV�RI�JHIXVHHUGH�**=�LQVWHOOLQJHQ�GH�µRPJDDQ�PHW�GHSUHVVLH¶�FXUVXV�YRRU�RXGHUHQJHRUJDQLVHHUG��DOV�SUHYHQWLHYH�DFWLYLWHLW���0HQ�NDQ�GLW�]LHQ�DOV�HHQ�LOOXVWUDWLHI�YRRUEHHOGYDQ�]RUJJHULFKWH�RI�VHFXQGDLUH�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�SUREOHPDWLHN�

Page 133: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

,Q�KHW�KLHUQD�YROJHQGH�ZRUGW�HHQ�PHWD�DQDO\VH�JHSUHVHQWHHUG�YDQ�VWXGLHV�QDDU�GHHIIHFWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKRVRFLDOH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHULFKW� RS� GHSUHVVLHV� ELM� RXGHUHQ�� ZDDUELMRXGHUHQ�DFWLHI�XLW�GH�EHYRONLQJ�JHUHFUXWHHUG�ZRUGHQ��'LW� LV�HHQ�VDPHQYDWWLQJ�YDQ�HHQHHUGHU�GRRU�RQV�XLWJHYRHUGH�VWXGLH��&XLMSHUV���������:H�NXQQHQ�GDDUPHH�HHQ�LQGLFDWLHNULMJHQ�YDQ�GH�HIIHFWLYLWHLW� YDQ� µRXWUHDFK¶�SURJUDPPD¶V�ELM�GH]H�SRSXODWLHV��9RRU�HHQGHHO�JDDW�KHW�ELM�GHUJHOLMNH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RP�JHwQGLFHHUGH�SUHYHQWLH��ELM�RXGHUHQ�GLH�ZHOGHSUHVVLHYH� NODFKWHQ� KHEEHQ�PDDU� QRJ� JHHQ� GHSUHVVLHYH� VWRRUQLV�� HQ� YRRU� HHQ� DQGHUGHHO� RP� YURHJVLJQDOHULQJ� HQ� �EHKDQGHOLQJ� �ELM� GLHJHQHQ� GLH� ZHO� DO� HHQ� GHSUHVVLHYHVWRRUQLV�KHEEHQ��9UDDJVWHOOLQJ=LMQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS�GHSUHVVLHYH�NODFKWHQ�ELM�RXGHUHQ��ZDDUELM�RXGHUHQ�GLUHFW�XLWGH�EHYRONLQJ�JHUHFUXWHHUG�ZRUGHQ��HIIHFWLHI"0HWKRGH6HOHFWLH� YDQ� VWXGLHV� 9LD� HHUGHUH� PHWD�DQDO\VHV� HQ� UHYLHZV� HQ� YLD� HHQ� V\VWHPDWLVFKHOLWHUDWXXUVHDUFK�LQ�3V\FKOLW�HQ�0HGOLQH��YDQDI������WRW�������,QFOXVLHFULWHULD� 6WXGLHV�ZHUGHQ� LQ� GH�PHWD�DQDO\VH� RSJHQRPHQ� DOV� ]LM� ���� EHWUHNNLQJKDGGHQ�RS�HHQ�SV\FKRORJLVFKH� LQWHUYHQWLH�JHULFKW�RS�GHSUHVVLHYH�NODFKWHQ�ELM�RXGHUHQ����SOXVVHUV��� ���� HU� HHQ� DFWLHYH� ZHUYLQJVPHWKRGH� ZHUG� JHEUXLNW�� ���� HHQ� YRRU�� HQQDPHWLQJ� �HQ� YROGRHQGH�GDWD� SUHVHQWHHUGHQ�RP�GH�JHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGH� HIIHFWJURRWWH� WHEHUHNHQHQ��� ���� HHQ� FRQWUROHJURHS� HQ� ���� UDQGRP� WRHZLM]LQJ� DDQ� FRQGLWLHV� ZHUGHQJHEUXLNW�5HVXOWHUHQGH� VHW� YDQ� VWXGLHV� =LH� WDEHO� ���� ,Q� GH� DFKW� VWXGLHV� ZHUGHQ� ��EHKDQGHOJURHSHQ�YHUJHOHNHQ�PHW�HHQ�FRQWUROHJURHS��+HW�JLQJ�RP���JURHSVLQWHUYHQWLHV�� LQGLYLGXHOH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� HQ� �� PLQLPDOH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� �HHQ� ERHN� PHW� WHOHIRQLVFKHRQGHUVWHXQLQJ���,Q���VWXGLHV�YRQG�HHQ�GLDJQRVWLVFK�LQWHUYLHZ�SODDWV��+HW�PHUHQGHHO�YDQGH�UHVSRQGHQWHQ�ZDV�YURXZ�HQ�GH�JHPLGGHOGH�OHHIWLMG�ODJ�WXVVHQ�GH����HQ����MDDU��,Q��VWXGLHV� ZHUG� HHQ� ZDFKWOLMVWFRQWUROHJURHS� JHEUXLNW�� ,Q� WRWDDO� ZHUGHQ� LQ� GH� ��EHKDQGHOJURHSHQ�����UHVSRQGHQWHQ�YHUJHOHNHQ�PHW�����FRQWUROHVXEMHFWHQ�0HWKRGH� 0HWD�DQDO\VH�RS�EDVLV�YDQ�KHW�UDQGRP�HIIHFWV�PRGHO�5HVXOWDWHQ'H�JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�ELM�GH�QDPHWLQJ�ZDV�����������EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDO������ �� ������ = ������ S� �� �������� %LM� WHVWHQ� YRRU� KRPRJHQLWHLW� ZHUGHQ� JHHQV\VWHPDWLVFKH�YHUVFKLOOHQ�WXVVHQ�VWXGLHV�JHYRQGHQ��+HW�DDQWDO�VWXGLHV�GDW�JHYRQGHQ�]RXPRHWHQ�ZRUGHQ�RP�KHW�HIIHFW�WH�UHGXFHUHQ�WRW�G� �������EHGURHJ����(U�ZHUGHQ�DQDO\VHV�XLWJHYRHUG�RP�QD� WH� JDDQ�RI� HU� YHUVFKLOOHQ� JHYRQGHQ�NRQGHQZRUGHQ�WXVVHQ�VWXGLHV�ZDDULQ�ZHO�HHQ�IRUPHOH�GLDJQRVH�GHSUHVVLH�ZDV�JHVWHOG�HQ�VWXGLHVZDDULQ�GDW�QLHW�ZDV�JHGDDQ��'DDUELM�ZHUG�JHHQ�VLJQLILFDQW�YHUVFKLO�JHYRQGHQ�,Q�JHHQ�YDQ�GH�VWXGLHV�ZDV�ELM�GH� IROORZ�XS�PHWLQJHQ� �WRW� ]HV�PDDQGHQ��QRJ�HHQFRQWUROHJURHS� EHVFKLNEDDU� ZDDUGRRU� GH� ODQJH� WHUPLMQ� HIIHFWHQ� QLHW� GLUHFW� EHUHNHQGNRQGHQ�ZRUGHQ�� ,Q� HHQ� XLWJHEUHLGHUH� VHW� YDQ� YHHUWLHQ� VWXGLHV� �ZDDUYDQ� HU� YLMI� QLHW� LQWDEHO�����YHUPHOG�VWDDQ�RPGDW�]LM�JHHQ�FRQWUROHJURHS�KDGGHQ��PDDU�YHUGHU�ZHO�YROGHGHQDDQ� GH� DQGHUH� YHUPHOGH� LQFOXVLHFULWHULD�� ZHUG� GH� HIIHFWJURRWWH� EHUHNHQG� YDQ� GH

Page 134: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

YHUDQGHULQJ� WXVVHQ� GH� QDPHWLQJ� �GLUHFW� QD� GH� LQWHUYHQWLH�� HQ� GH� IROORZ�XSPHWLQJ�'DDUELM� ZHUGHQ� JHHQ� VLJQLILFDQWH� YHUDQGHULQJHQ� WXVVHQ� QDPHWLQJ� HQ� IROORZ�XSJHYRQGHQ�� 'LW� GXLGW� HU� RS� GDW� GH� YHUEHWHULQJ� RS� ODQJHUH� WHUPLMQ� EHKRXGHQ� EOLMIW� ELMUHVSRQGHQWHQ�GLH�LQ�HHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH�JHSDUWLFLSHHUG�KHEEHQ�&RQFOXVLHV%HODQJULMNVWH�EHSHUNLQJHQ� ����5HVSRQGHQWHQ�XLW�GH�EHYRONLQJ�GLH�SDUWLFLSHUHQ�DDQ�HHQRQGHU]RHN� ]LMQ� QLHW� QRRG]DNHOLMNHUZLMV� GH]HOIGH� UHVSRQGHQWHQ� GLH� DDQ� HHQ� UHJXOLHURXWUHDFK�SURJUDPPD�GHHOQHPHQ������5HODWLHI�NOHLQH�DDQWDO�UHVSRQGHQWHQ������(U�ZHUGHQYRRUDO� ZDFKWOLMVWFRQWUROHJURHSHQ� JHEUXLNW� �YHUVFKLOOHQGH� VRRUWHQ� FRQWUROHJURHSHQUHVXOWHUHQ�LQ�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�HIIHFWJURRWWHV��5RELQVRQ�HW�DO���������8LWNRPVWHQ� 'H�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�GH�RQGHU]RFKWH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�]LMQ�JURRW�HQ�YHUJHOLMNEDDU�PHWGH� HIIHFWHQ� YDQ� SV\FKRORJLVFKH� EHKDQGHOYRUPHQ� ELM� MRQJHUH� OHHIWLMGVJURHSHQ�� ,Q� GHPHWD�DQDO\VH� YDQ� 5RELQVRQ� HW� DO�� �������� ZDDULQ� ��� JHFRQWUROHHUGH� VWXGLHV� YDQSV\FKRWKHUDSLH�ELM�GHSUHVVLH�LQ�MRQJHUH�OHHIWLMGVJURHSHQ�ZHUGHQ�JHDQDO\VHHUG��ZHUG�HHQHIIHFWJURRWWH�YDQ������JHYRQGHQ�*H]LHQ�GH�HIIHFWLYLWHLW�YDQ�GH]H�LQWHUYHQWLHV�OLMNW�ODQGHOLMNH�LPSOHPHQWDWLH�RS�]LMQ�SODDWV�0RPHQWHHO�ZRUGW� YDQXLW� KHW�7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW� ��PHW� ILQDQFLHOH� RQGHUVWHXQLQJ�YDQ� KHW0LQLVWHULH� YDQ� 9:6� HHQ� LPSOHPHQWDWLHSURMHFW� XLWJHYRHUG� JHULFKW� RS� ODQGHOLMNHLQYRHULQJ�YDQ�GH�FXUVXVVHQ�µ2PJDDQ�PHW�GHSUHVVLH¶�YRRU�RXGHUHQ��'H�5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW/HLGHQ� YRHUW� LQ� VDPHQZHUNLQJ� PHW� KHW� 7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW� HHQ� RQGHU]RHN� XLW� QDDU� GHHIIHFWHQ�HQ�VXFFHVSUHGLFWRUHQ�YDQ�GH]H�LQWHUYHQWLH��$IURQGLQJ�YDQ�GLW�RQGHU]RHN�ZRUGWYHUZDFKW�LQ������

Page 135: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

7DEHO�������6WXGLHV�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�µRXWUHDFK¶�SURJUDPPD¶V�YRRU�RXGHUHQ�PHW�GHSUHVVLHYH�NODFKWHQ�6WXGLH &RQGLWLHV 1 6HVVLHV 7\SHLQWHUYHQWLH 'LDJQRVH *HP�OHHIWLMG �YURXZ 'URS�RXW 0HHWPRPHQWHQ 0HHWLQVWUX�PHQWHQ (IIHFW��G�

$UHDQ�HW�DO������� 3UREOHHP�RSORVVLQJ5HPLQLVFHQWLH:DFKWOLMVW������

�� JURHS � ���� �� �������� 3UH��3RVW���PDDQGHQ %',+56'*'6��������

%HXWOHU�HW�DO������� &*7D�� 3ODFHER&*7���IDUPDFRWKHUDSLH3ODFHER������

�� JURHS � ���� �� �������� 3UH��3RVW���PDDQGHQ %',+56' ��������

)U\������ &*7:DFKWOLMVW ���� �� LQGLYLGXHHO ± ���� � ���� 3UH��3RVW 003,�' ����

)U\������ *HVWUXFWXUHHUGH�UHPLQLVFHQWLH2QJHVWUXFWXU��UHPLQLVFHQWLH*HHQ�EHKDQGHOLQJ������

� LQGLYLGXHHO ± � ���� �� 3UH��3RVW %', ����

0F1HLO�HW�DO������� 6RFLDOH�FRQWDFWHQ:DFKWVOLMVW ���� �� LQGLYLGXHHO ± ���� � � 3UH��3RVW %', ����

6FRJLQ�HW�DO������� &*7��ELEOLRWKHUDSLH�$WWHQWLH�FRQWUROH�JURHS:DFKWOLMVW�����

� ELEOLR�WKHUDSLH ± ���� �� ���� 3UH��3RVW����PDDQG %',*'6+56'����

6FRJLQ�HW�DO������� &*7�ELEOLRWKHUDSLH*7E�ELEOLRWKHUDSLH:DFKWOLMVW������

� ELEOLR�WKHUDSLH ± ���� �� �������� 3UH��3RVW�������PDDQG +56'*'6 ��������

7KRPSVRQ�*DOODJKHU������ *7&*73V\FKRG\QDPLVFKH�WKHUDSLH:DFKWOLMVW

��������

����� LQGLYLGXHHO � ���� �� ������������3UH��3RVW +56'%', ������������

D���&*7��FRJQLWLHYH�JHGUDJVWKHUDSLH�E���*7��JHGUDJVWKHUDSLH�

Page 136: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh
Page 137: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

���� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�YHUVODYLQJVSUHYHQWLH��HHQ�RYHU]LFKW�YDQPHWD�DQDO\VHV$OJHPHHQ(U ]LMQ�GLYHUVH�YRUPHQ�YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV�RQWZLNNHOG�GLH�]LMQ�JHULFKW�RS�KHW�YRRUNRPHQYDQ� PLGGHOHQJHEUXLN� HQ� YHUVODYLQJVSUREOHPHQ� �URQG� DOFRKRO�� WDEDN�� VRIWGUXJV� HQKDUGGUXJV��� ZDDURQGHU� VFKRROJHULFKWH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�� PDVVDPHGLDOH� FDPSDJQHV�LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHULFKW� RS� RXGHUV�� HQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� ZDDULQ� PHHUGHUH� VRRUWHQ� LQWHUYHQWLHVWHJHOLMNHUWLMG� LQ� HHQ� DIJHEDNHQG� JHELHG� ZRUGHQ� XLWJHYRHUG� �GH� µFRPPXQLW\¶EHQDGHULQJ��9HUVODYLQJ�NDQ�PHQ�]LHQ�DOV�HHQ�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLV��,Q�GH�'60�,9��GDW�ELQQHQGH�**=�HHQ�GRPLQDQWH�SODDWV�KHHIW�YHUZRUYHQ�DOV�FODVVLILFDWLHV\VWHHP�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKHVWRRUQLVVHQ��]LMQ�DSDUWH�RPVFKULMYLQJHQ�JHJHYHQ�YRRU�DIKDQNHOLMNKHLG�HQ�PLVEUXLN�YDQPLGGHOHQ��]LH�GH�ELMGUDJH�YDQ�2UPHO�HW�DO��LQ�'HHO %��YDQ�GLW�UDSSRUW��9DQXLW�KHW�7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW�ZHUG�UHFHQW�HHQ�OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH�XLWJHYRHUG��ZDDULQRYHU]LFKWVVWXGLHV�RS�KHW�WHUUHLQ�YDQ�GH�YHUVODYLQJVSUHYHQWLH�ZHUGHQ�JHwQYHQWDULVHHUG�HQJHDQDO\VHHUG� �9DQ�*DJHOGRQN��&XLMSHUV��������� ,Q�GH]H� OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH�ZHUGHQ�QLHWGH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�NRUWGXUHQGH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�LQ�GH�KXLVDUWVHQSUDNWLMN�RQGHU]RFKW��RPGDW�GLWHHQ�RPYDQJULMN�RQGHU]RHNVWHUUHLQ�LV�HQ�GH�JUHQ]HQ�WXVVHQ�SUHYHQWLH�HQ�EHKDQGHOLQJ�KLHUQLHW� VFKHUS� ]LMQ�� 2YHULJHQV� LV� XLW� PHHUGHUH� UHYLHZV� HQ� PHWD�DQDO\VHV� EHNHQG� GDWVFUHHQLQJ� HQ� YURHJH� EHKDQGHOLQJ� YDQ� SUREOHHPGULQNHUV� LQ� GH� KXLVDUWVSUDNWLMN� HHQDDQ]LHQOLMNH� GDOLQJ� YDQ� KHW� DOFRKROJHEUXLN� WRW� JHYROJ� NDQ� KHEEHQ� �RQGHU� DQGHUH�3RLNRODLQHQ��������:LON�HW�DO���������%LHQ�HW�DO���������)UHHPDQWOH�HW�DO���������8LW� GH� OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH� YDQXLW� KHW� 7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW� EOHHN� GDW� DOOHHQ� QDDUVFKRROJHULFKWH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� YROGRHQGH� RQGHU]RHN� LV� XLWJHYRHUG� RP� XLWVSUDNHQ� WH� GRHQRYHU�GH�HYLGHQWLH�YRRU�SRVLWLHYH�HIIHFWHQ��YRRU�GH�ZHUNZLM]H�HQ�GH�JHKDQWHHUGH�FULWHULDYHUZLM]HQ�ZLM�QDDU�KHW�UDSSRUW���6FKRROJHULFKWH�YHUVODYLQJVSUHYHQWLH�LV�LQ�YHOH�WLHQWDOOHQVWXGLHV�RQGHU]RFKW��ZDDURQGHU�PHHUGHUH� WLHQWDOOHQ� VWXGLHV�YDQ�KRJH�NZDOLWHLW�� ,Q� GH]HNDGHUWHNVW�JHYHQ�ZH�HHQ�RYHU]LFKW�YDQ�GH� WLHQ�PHWD�DQDO\VHV�GLH� ]LMQ�XLWJHYRHUG�RYHUGH]H�VWXGLHV�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�VFKRROJHULFKWH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�9UDDJVWHOOLQJ=LMQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ��SUREOHPDWLVFK��JHEUXLN�YDQ�DOFRKRO��GUXJV�HQWDEDN�GLH�YLD�GH�VFKRRO�ZRUGHQ�DDQJHERGHQ�DDQ�MRQJHUHQ�HIIHFWLHI"0HWKRGH6HOHFWLH� YDQ� VWXGLHV� 9LD� HHQ� V\VWHPDWLVFKH� OLWHUDWXXUVHDUFK� LQ� 3V\FKOLW� HQ� 0HGOLQH������������,QFOXVLHFULWHULD� 6WXGLHV�ZHUGHQ�LQ�GH�V\VWHPDWLVFKH�OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH�RSJHQRPHQ�DOV�]LM���� UDSSRUWHHUGHQ� RYHU� HHQ� VWDWLVWLVFKH� PHWD�DQDO\VH� ���� JHULFKW� RS� SUHYHQWLH� YDQJHEUXLN�RI�PLVEUXLN�YDQ�DOFRKRO��WDEDN�HQ�RI�GUXJV�

Page 138: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

7DEHO������.HQPHUNHQ�YDQ�PHWD�DQDO\VHV�YDQ�VWXGLHV�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�VFKRROJHULFKWH�GUXJVSUHYHQWLH�SURJUDPPD¶V�

2QGHU� 1 1 3HULRGHE 0LGGHOHQ�F .ODVVHQE ,QFOXVLHFULWHULD6WXGLH ]RHNVJURHS�D VWXGLHV SURJUDPPD¶VE7REOHU������ 7 �� ��� ��������� 7�$�0 ���� � FRQWUROH��YHUJHOLMNLQJVJURHS7REOHU�������7REOHU��6WUDWWRQ������ 7 �� ��� ��������� 7�$��0�2 ���� � FRQWUROH��YHUJHOLMNLQJVJURHS� SUH�SRVW�WHVW(QQHWW�HW�DO������� 7 � � ��������� 7�$��0 F � 3URMHFW�'$5(���HHQ�VSHFLILHNH�LQWHUYHQWLH�

%DQJHUW�'URZQV������ 2 �� �� $�' ���� � JHHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH�FRQWUROH�JURHS� PDWFKLQJ�ELM�SUHWHVW%UXYROG��5XQGDOO������ % �� ����� $�7 � FRQWUROH��YHUJHOLMNLQJVJURHS5XQGDOO��%UXYROG������ % �� $�7 � FRQWUROH��YHUJHOLMNLQJVJURHS� VHOHFWLH�YDQ�GH�EHVWH�VWXGLHV%UXYROG������ % � � $�7 ��� � ,QWHUYHQWLHV�XLW�KHW�µ&DOLIRUQLD�VFKRRO�EDVHG�ULVN�UHGXFWLRQ�SURJUDP¶� FRQWUROH��YHUJHOLMNLQJVJURHS� SUH�SRVW�WHVW� YHUVFKLO�LQ�GURS�RXW�WXVVHQ�H[S�HQ�FRQWU�PLQGHU�GDQ����%UXYROG������ % �� �� ��������� 7 ���� � JHHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH�FRQWUROH�JURHS� VHOHFWLH�YDQ�GH�EHVWH�VWXGLHV5RRQH\��0XUUD\������ 2 �� ��� ��������� 7 ���� � FRQWUROH��YHUJHOLMNLQJVJURHS� �VRFLDO��RU��SHHU�W\SH��SURJUDPPD¶V� JHHQ�GLVVHUWDWLHVD��RQGHU]RHNVJURHS��7��7REOHU�HQ�FROOHJD¶V��%��%UXYROG�HQ�FROOHJD¶V��2��RYHULJH�RQGHU]RHNVJURHSHQ�E�� ��QLHW�JHVSHFLILFHHUG�F��PLGGHOHQ��7��WDEDN��$��DOFRKRO��0��PDULKXDQD��'��µGUXJV¶��QLHW�JHVSHFLILFHHUG���2��RYHULJH�PLGGHOHQ�

Page 139: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

5HVXOWHUHQGH� VHW� YDQ� VWXGLHV� =LH� WDEHO� ���� (U� ZHUGHQ� LQ� WRWDDO� �� PHWD�DQDO\VHVJHYRQGHQ��7ZHH�PHWD�DQDO\VHV�ZDUHQ�DOOHHQ�JHULFKW�RS�WDEDN��GULH�RS�WDEDN�HQ�DOFRKROHQ� GH� RYHULJH� YLHU� RS� WDEDN�� DOFRKRO� HQ� GUXJV�� $FKW� PHWD�DQDO\VHV� RQGHU]RFKWHQ� GHHIIHFWHQ�YDQ�VFKRROJHULFKWH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�HQ�LQ�ppQ�PHWD�DQDO\VH��7REOHU��������ZHUGHQRRN� DQGHUH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� RQGHU]RFKW�� 7ZHH� RQGHU]RHNVJURHSHQ� �URQG� 7REOHU� HQ� URQG%UXYROG��YRHUGHQ�PHHUGHUH�PHWD�DQDO\VHV�XLW��+HW�DDQWDO�VWXGLHV�GDW�LQ�GH�YHUVFKLOOHQGHPHWD�DQDO\VHV� ZHUG� RQGHU]RFKW�� YDULHHUGH� YDQ� �� WRW� ��� HQ� KHW� JURRWVWH� DDQWDOLQWHUYHQWLHV� GDW� ZHUG� RQGHU]RFKW�� EHGURHJ� ����� ,Q� DOOH� PHWD�DQDO\VHV� ZHUGHQ� DOOHHQVWXGLHV�RQGHU]RFKW�ZDDULQ�HHQ�FRQWUROH��RI�YHUJHOLMNLQJVJURHS�ZDV�JHEUXLNW��$OOH�PHWD�DQDO\VHV�RQGHU]RFKWHQ�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�PLGGHOHQJHEUXLN� LQKHW�DOJHPHHQ�HQ�QLHW�RS�KHW�DDQWDO�SUREOHPDWLVFKH�JHEUXLNHUV�0HWKRGH� 6\VWHPDWLVFKH�OLWHUDWXXUVWXGLH�5HVXOWDWHQ,Q�YLMI�PHWD�DQDO\VHV�ZRUGHQ�GH�JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWHV�YDQ�DOOH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�VDPHQJHSUHVHQWHHUG�� 'H]H� HIIHFWJURRWWHV� VWDDQ� VDPHQJHYDW� LQ� WDEHO ���� 7ZHH� YDQ� GH� YLMIPHWD�DQDO\VHV� �(QQHW� HW� DO��� ������ 5RRQH\� � 0XUUD\�� ������ VHOHFWHHUGHQ� HHQVXEJURHSHQ� YDQ� VWXGLHV�� =RDOV� XLW� WDEHO ���� EOLMNW� ]LMQ� GH� JHYRQGHQ� HIIHFWHQ� NOHLQ� WRWPLGGHOJURRW��*URWH�HIIHFWHQ� �G�!�������ZRUGHQ�DOOHHQ�JHYRQGHQ�YRRU�NHQQLV��(IIHFWHQRS� DWWLWXGH� HQ� GDDGZHUNHOLMN� JHEUXLN� ]LMQ� NOHLQ�� ,Q� ppQ� RXGHUH� PHWD�DQDO\VH� �7REOHU�������ZHUG�HHQ�PLGGHOJURRW�HIIHFW�RS� WDEDN�JHYRQGHQ�� ,Q�GH]H�DQDO\VH�ZHUGHQ�HFKWHUNRUWHUH�HQ�ODQJHUH�WHUPLMQ�XLWNRPVWHQ�JHFRPELQHHUG�ZDDUGRRU�KHW�QLHW�GXLGHOLMN�LV�RI�ZHGLW�PRHWHQ�LQWHUSUHWHUHQ�DOV�NRUWH�RI�ODQJH�WHUPLMQ�HIIHFWHQ�6OHFKWV� LQ� WZHH�PHWD�DQDO\VHV� �5XQGDOO��%UXYROG�� ������5RRQH\��0XUUD\������� ZHUGHQ� HIIHFWHQ� RS� ODQJHUH� WHUPLMQ� H[SOLFLHW� RQGHU]RFKW�� 5RRQH\� HQ� 0XUUD\�������YRQGHQ�GDW�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�VFKRROSURJUDPPD¶V�RS� URNHQ�ELM�GH�QDPHWLQJ� �G� ������YHUJHOLMNEDDU�ZDUHQ�PHW�GH�HIIHFWHQ�QD�ppQ� MDDU� �G� ��������5XQGDOO�HQ�%UXYROG�������YRQGHQ�GDW�GH�HIIHFWHQ�GLH�JHPHWHQ�ZDUHQ�ELQQHQ�GULH�PDDQGHQ�QD�DIORRS�YDQ�GHLQWHUYHQWLH�YHUJHOLMNEDDU�ZDUHQ�PHW�GH�HIIHFWHQ�GLH�ODQJHU�GDQ�GULH�PDDQGHQ�QD�DIORRSZDUHQ�JHPHWHQ�,Q� YHUVFKHLGHQH� PHWD�DQDO\VHV� ZRUGW� EHNHNHQ� RI� VSHFLILHNH� NHQPHUNHQ� YDQSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V� JHUHODWHHUG� ]LMQ� DDQ� GH� JURRWWH� YDQ� GH� HIIHFWHQ�� 'DDUXLW� NRPWQDDU� YRUHQ� GDW� ]RJHKHWHQ� OHHUOLQJJHVWXXUGH� SURJUDPPD¶V� JURWHUH� HIIHFWHQ� KHEEHQ� RSJHEUXLN� �G� � ������ GDQ� QLHW�OHHUOLQJJHVWXXUGH� SURJUDPPD¶V� �G� � ������� %LMOHHUOLQJJHVWXXUGH� SURJUDPPD¶V� VWDDW� SDUWLFLSDWLH� YDQ� OHHUOLQJHQ� HQ� LQWHUDFWLH� WXVVHQOHHUOLQJHQ� FHQWUDDO�� WHUZLMO� ELM� QLHW�OHHUOLQJJHVWXXUGH� SURJUDPPD¶V� YRRUDOLQIRUPDWLHYHUVFKDIILQJ�GRRU�GH�GRFHQW�FHQWUDDO�VWDDW�� ,Q�HHQ�DQGHUH�PHWD�DQDO\VH�ZHUGJHYRQGHQ�GDW�VFKRROSURJUDPPD¶V�JHULFKW�RS�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�URNHQ�KHW�PHHVW�HIIHFWLHI�]LMQDOV�]H�PLQGHU�GDQ����VHVVLHV�RPYDWWHQ��ZDW�ODQJHU�RYHU�GH�WLMG�]LMQ�XLWJHVSUHLG��JHEUXLNPDNHQ�YDQ�RQJHWUDLQGH�µSHHUV¶��PHGHOHHUOLQJHQ��HQ�LQ�GH�HHUVWH�NODV�YDQ�KHW�YRRUWJH]HWRQGHUZLMV�ZRUGHQ�XLWJHYRHUG��5RRQH\��0XUUD\��������

Page 140: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

7DEHO� ����� *HPLGGHOGH� HIIHFWJURRWWHV� JHUDSSRUWHHUG� LQ� PHWD�DQDO\VHV� YDQ� VFKRROJHULFKWHGUXJVSUHYHQWLH�SURJUDPPD¶V��6WXGLH $OOH�PLGGHOHQD 7DEDND $OFRKROD $QGHUV. $ * . $ * . $ *7REOHU������ ���� ���� ���� � � ���� � � ���� 6RIWGUXJV�JHEUXLN������+DUGGUXJV�JHEUXLN������(QQHWW�HW�DO������� ���� ���� ���� � � ���� � � ���� 0DULKXDQD�JHEUXLN�������%DQJHUW�'URZQV����� ���� ���� ���� � � � � � � �

5XQGDOO��%UXYROG����� � � � ���������E ���������E ���������E ���������E ����������E ���������E �

5RRQH\��0XUUD\����� � � � ���������F � � � �

D��.��NHQQLV��$��DWWLWXGH��*��JHEUXLN�E��JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWHV�RS�EDVLV�YDQ�YDQ�SRVW�WHVW�PHWLQJHQ�YDQ�PLQGHU�GDQ�GULH�PDDQGHQ�QD�DIORRS�YDQ�GHLQWHUYHQWLH�JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWHV�RS�EDVLV�YDQ�SRVW�WHVW�PHWLQJHQ�YDQ�PHHU�GDQ�GULH�PDDQGHQ�QD�DIORRS�YDQ�GHLQWHUYHQWLH�F��JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWH�GLUHFW�QD�DIORRS�YDQ�GH�LQWHUYHQWLH���JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�HHQ�MDDU�QD�DIORRS�YDQ�GHLQWHUYHQWLH�

&RQFOXVLHV%HODQJULMNVWH�EHSHUNLQJHQ� ����1LHW�DOOH�UHOHYDQWH�GDWD�ZRUGHQ�LQ�GH�SXEOLFDWLHV�RYHU�GHPHWD�DQDO\VHV� YROGRHQGH� GXLGHOLMN� JHUDSSRUWHHUG�� ZDDURQGHU� GURS�RXW� HQ� PHWKRGROR�JLVFKH� NZDOLWHLW� YDQ� JHwQFOXGHHUGH� VWXGLHV�� ���� 0HW� QDPH� GH� RXGHUH� PHWD�DQDO\VHVJHEUXLNHQ� PLQGHU� JHDYDQFHHUGH� VWDWLVWLVFKH� PHWKRGHQ� YRRU� PHWD�DQDO\VH�� ZDDUGRRURQGHU� DQGHUH� ����EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQWHUYDOOHQ� QLHW� YHUPHOG�ZRUGHQ�� ���� ,Q�PHHUGHUHPHWD�DQDO\VHV�ZRUGHQ�HIIHFWJURRWWHV�YRRU�YHUVFKLOOHQGH�IROORZ�XS�PHWLQJHQ�PHW�HONDDUJHFRPELQHHUG�� HQ� ����GH�HHQKHLG�YDQ�DQDO\VH�NRPW�YDDN�QLHW�RYHUHHQ�PHW�GH�HHQKHLGYDQ�UDQGRPLVDWLH�8LWNRPVWHQ� 2S� EDVLV� YDQ� GH� RQGHU]RFKWH� PHWD�DQDO\VHV�� ZDDULQ� HHQ� JURRW� DDQWDOJHFRQWUROHHUGH� HQ� JHUDQGRPLVHHUGH� VWXGLHV� ]LMQ� JHDQDO\VHHUG�� NDQ� JHFRQFOXGHHUGZRUGHQ�GDW�VFKRROJHULFKWH�GUXJVSUHYHQWLHSURJUDPPD¶V�NOHLQH�PDDU�VLJQLILFDQWH�HIIHFWHQKHEEHQ� RS� KHW� JHEUXLN� YDQ� WDEDN�� DOFRKRO� HQ� DQGHUH� PLGGHOHQ�� 2I� GHUJHOLMNHSURJUDPPD¶V� RRN� RYHUPDWLJ� RI� SUREOHPDWLVFK� JHEUXLN� �PLGGHOHQPLVEUXLN� RI� ±DIKDQNHOLMNKHLG�� YRRUNRPHQ� LV� LQ� GH]H� PHWD�DQDO\VHV� QLHW� RQGHU]RFKW�� (U� ]LMQDDQZLM]LQJHQ�GDW�GH�HIIHFWLYLWHLW�YDQ�SURJUDPPD¶V�GRRU�EHSDDOGH�SURJUDPPDNHQPHUNHQZRUGW�EHwQYORHG��'XLGHOLMN�LV�GDW�OHHUOLQJJHVWXXUGH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�HIIHFWLHYHU�]LMQ��9DQXLWRQGHU]RHN�QDDU�LQWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS�URNHQ�NRPHQ�GH�YROJHQGH�µVXFFHVIDFWRUHQ¶�QDDUYRUHQ��PD[LPDDO� ��� VHVVLHV�� RYHU� GH� WLMG� JHVSUHLG�� RQJHWUDLQGH� µSHHUV¶�� JHULFKW� RS� GHHHUVWH� NODV�� 9HUGHU� ]LMQ� HU� HQLJH� DDQZLM]LQJHQ� GDW� SURJUDPPD¶V� GLH� ]LMQ� LQJHEHG� LQEUHGHUH� µFRPPXQLW\¶� RI� ZLMNJHULFKWH� SURMHFWHQ� �ZDDULQ� PDVVDPHGLDOH� SURJUDPPD¶V�WUDLQLQJ� YDQ� KXOSYHUOHQHUV� LQ� GH� ZLMN� HQ� DFWLYLWHLWHQ� JHULFKW� RS� RXGHUV� ZRUGHQJHFRPELQHHUG��KHW�PHHVW�GRHOWUHIIHQG�]LMQ��9DQ�*DJHOGRQN��&XLMSHUV��������

Page 141: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW���������������GHHO�%� ������� ����SDJ������YDQ����

���� (IIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�ELMNLQGHUHQ3UREOHHPVWHOOLQJ*HGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�NRPHQ�ELM���WRW�����YDQ�GH�NLQGHUHQ�YRRU��*UHHQEHUJ���������+HW]LMQ� YDDN� YRRUORSHUV� YDQ� �SV\FKLDWULVFKH�� SUREOHPDWLHN� LQ� GH� DGROHVFHQWLH� HQYROZDVVHQKHLG�� ,PSXOVLYLWHLW�� VHQVDWLH�]RHNHQ� HQ� DJUHVVLH� ±� NHQPHUNHQG� YRRUJHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�VWRRUQLVVHQ�±�]LMQ�YRRUVSHOOHUV�YDQ�GHOLQTXHQWLH�ELM�DGROHVFHQWHQ��HQYHUYROJHQV�FULPLQDOLWHLW�HQ�PLGGHOHQJHEUXLN�RS�YROZDVVHQ�OHHIWLMG��:HEVWHU�6WUDWWRQ�HWDO���������7UHPEOD\�HW�DO���������'HWHUPLQDQWHQ� RIZHO� ULVLFRIDFWRUHQ� YDQ� JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ� NXQQHQ� ZRUGHQRQGHUVFKHLGHQ� RS� YHUVFKLOOHQGH� QLYHDXV� �� LQ� RQGHUOLQJH� VDPHQKDQJ� �� ]RDOV� ���� NLQG�YURHJH� DJUHVVLH�� YHUOHJHQ� HQ� WHUXJJHWURNNHQ� JHGUDJ�� ODJH� ]HOIZDDUGHULQJ�� LQDGHTXDWHVRFLDOH�HQ�SUREOHHPRSORVVHQGH�YDDUGLJKHGHQ������RXGHUV��JHVWRRUGH�RXGHU�NLQG�UHODWLH�JHEUHN�DDQ�RI� LQFRQVLVWHQWH�RXGHUOLMNH�GLVFLSOLQH��QHJDWLHYH�FRPPXQLFDWLH�� ���� VFKRRO�QHJDWLHYH�ZDDUGHQ�HQ�DWWLWXGHQ��ZHLQLJ�EHWURNNHQKHLG�HQ�LQWHUHVVH�YDQ�GH�OHHUNUDFKW�(U� ]LMQ� XLWHHQORSHQGH� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� RQWZLNNHOG� RP� JHGUDJV�SUREOHPHQ�VWRRUQLVVHQ� ELM� NLQGHUHQ� HQ� MHXJGLJHQ� WH� YRRUNyPHQ� RI� YHUPLQGHUHQ�� 'HLQWHUYHQWLHV�NXQQHQ�JHULFKW�]LMQ�RS�KHW�NLQG�HQ�RI�RS�GH�RPJHYLQJ��JH]LQ��VFKRRO��EXXUW��9RRUEHHOGHQ� YDQ� LQWHUYHQWLHV� ]LMQ�� RXGHUYRRUOLFKWLQJ� HQ� ±WUDLQLQJ� �WKXLV�� LQ� JURHSHQ�PHW�EHKXOS�YLGHR��HQ�VRFLDOH�YDDUGLJKHLGVWUDLQLQJ�YRRU�NLQGHUHQ�9UDDJVWHOOLQJ.XQQHQ� SUHYHQWLHYH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�VWRRUQLVVHQ� ELM� NLQGHUHQ� HQMHXJGLJHQ�YRRUNRPHQ�RI�YHUPLQGHUHQ"0HWKRGH6HOHFWLH�YDQ�VWXGLHV� 9LD�V\VWHPDWLVFKH�OLWHUDWXXUVHDUFK�LQ�3V\FKOLW�HQ�0HGOLQH�,QFOXVLHFULWHULD� ,Q� GH� PHWD�DQDO\VH� ]LMQ� VWXGLHV� RSJHQRPHQ� GLH� ���� LQWHUYHQWLHVEHWUHIIHQ� JHULFKW� RS� KHW� NLQG� HQ�RI� RS� GH� RPJHYLQJ� �JH]LQ�� VFKRRO�� EXXUW��� ���XLWNRPVWHQ� ±� JHPHWHQ�PHW� HHQ� JHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUG�PHHWLQVWUXPHQW�� UDSSRUWHUHQ� RS� KHWJHELHG�YDQ�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�VWRRUQLVVHQ�ELM�NLQGHUHQ�HQ�MHXJGLJHQ������JHEUXLN�PDNHQYDQ� HHQ� FRQWUROHJURHS� HQ� SUH�� HQ� SRVWWHVWGDWD� UDSSRUWHUHQ� �HQ� YROGRHQGH� UHVXOWDWHQSUHVHQWHUHQ�RP�GH�JHVWDQGDDUGLVHHUGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�WH�EHUHNHQHQ��5HVXOWHUHQGH� VHW� YDQ� VWXGLHV� (U� ]LMQ� LQ� WRWDDO� ]HYHQ� VWXGLHV�JHYRQGHQ� �]LH� WDEHO �����DOOH�PHW� HHQ� JHUDQGRPLVHHUG� GHVLJQ�� %LM� GULH� VWXGLHV� ]LMQ� GH� JHJHYHQV� YDQ� IROORZ�XSPHWLQJHQ� EHNHQG�� %LM� ppQ� GDDUYDQ� NXQQHQ� GH� UHVXOWDWHQ� YDQ� GH� SRVWWHVW� QLHW� ZRUGHQJHUDSSRUWHHUG��'H�PHHVWH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�]LMQ�JHULFKW�RS�ULVLFRJURHSHQ��-RKQVRQ��:DONHU������� 6DQGOHU� HW� DO��� ������ /RFKPDQ� ������ RI� RS� NLQGHUHQ� YDQ� ZLH� EHNHQG� LV� GDWJHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ� KHEEHQ� HQ�RI� � HHQ� KRJH� VFRUH� KHEEHQ� RS� HHQ� VFUHHQLQJVLQVWUXPHQWYRRU� JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ� �7UHPEOD\� HW� DO��� ������ ������ :HEVWHU�6WUDWWRQ� HW� DO�� �����:HEVWHU�6WUDWWRQ��+DPPRQG���������(pQ�VWXGLH�EHWUHIW�HHQ�VFKRROJHULFKWH�LQWHUYHQWLHYRRU�DOOH�OHHUOLQJHQ��'H�PHHVWH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�]LMQ�JHULFKW�RS�]RZHO�GH�RXGHUV�DOV�RS�KHWNLQG��HHQ�HQNHOH�RRN�RS�GH�OHHUNUDFKWHQ�

Page 142: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� �������5,90�UDSSRUW������������±�GHHO�%�

7DEHO�������6WXGLHV�QDDU�GH�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�ELM�NLQGHUHQ�MHXJGLJHQ�6WXGLH &RQGLWLHV 1 'RHOJURHS 5&7D 0HHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ GFWU

E GIXF

-RKQVRQ��:DONHU����� ��� RXGHU��HQ�NLQGWUDLQLQJ��� JHHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH ���� NLQGHUHQ�HQ�KXQ�RXGHUVXLW�0H[LFDDQVH��ODJH�6(6�JH]LQQHQ � $0/ - ����MDDU�G �����:HEVWHU�6WUDWWRQ�HWDO������� ��� LQGLYLGXHOH�YLGHRWUDLQLQJ��� LQGLY��YLGHRWUDLQLQJ����JURHSVGLVFXVVLH��� JURHSVGLVFXVVLH��� JHHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH��ZDFKWOLMVW�FRQWUROH�JURHS�

��������

RXGHUV�YDQ�NLQGHUHQ�PHWJHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�µPXOWL�SUREOHP�JH]LQQHQ¶� &%&/(&%,%HKDU�3%4

��� G �������� G �������� G �����-

+DZNLQV�HW�DO������ ��� RXGHUWUDLQLQJ�HQ�OHHUNUDFKWWUDLQLQJ��� JHHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH ������ OHHUOLQJHQ�RS�EDVLVVFKROHQ�HQ�KXQRXGHUV�HQ�OHHUNUDFKWHQ � &%&/ G� ������ -7UHPEOD\�HW�DO������������ ��� RXGHU�±�HQ�NLQGWUDLQLQJ��� JHHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH��FRQWUROH�JURHS�PHW�HQ]RQGHU�REVHUYDWLH�

����� NLQGHUHQ�PHW�GHVWUXFWLHI�JHGUDJ�HQ�KXQRXGHUV��XLW�ODJH�6(6�JH]LQQHQ � 6%4 G� �������� ��MDDU��G� ��������� MDDU��G� ��������� MDDU��G� ������6DQGOHU�HW�DO������ ��� RQGHUVWHXQLQJVJURHS��YDDUGLJKHLGVWUDLQLQJ�LQGLYLGXHOH�DGYLVHULQJ��� JHHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH��

��

NLQGHUHQ�YDQ�ZLH�HHQ�RXGHU�LVRYHUOHGHQ��HQ�KXQ�RXGHU � &%&/ G� ����� -

/RFKPDQ�HW�DO������ ��� VRFLDOH�UHODWLH�WUDLQLQJ��� JHHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH ���� NLQGHUHQ�GLH�GRRU�SHHUV��NODVJHQRWHQ�ZRUGHQ�DIJHZH]HQ � 7%& G� ������ ��MDDU��G� ������:HEVWHU�6WUDWWRQ�+DPPRQG�����

��� RXGHUWUDLQLQJ��� NLQGWUDLQLQJ��� RXGHU��HQ�NLQGWUDLQLQJ��� JHHQ�LQWHUYHQWLH���ZDFKWOLMVW�FRQWUROH�JURHS�

��������

NLQGHUHQ�PHW�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�HQKXQ�RXGHUV � &%&/(%&,%HKDU�3%4��� G ��������� G ��������� G ������

-

D��5&7��µUDQGRPL]HG�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO¶��ZHO�JHHQ�UDQGRP�WRHZLM]LQJ�DDQ�FRQGLWLHV��E��GFWU� JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�YDQ�H[SHULPHQWHOH�YHUVXV�FRQWUROHFRQGLWLH�ELM�SRVW�WHVW�F��GIX��JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�ELM�IROORZ�XS�PHWLQJ�

Page 143: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW�������������±�GHHO�%� SDJ������YDQ����

'H�LQWHUYHQWLHV�GLH�]LMQ�JHULFKW�RS�GH�NLQGHUHQ�EHWUHIIHQ�PHW�QDPH�KHW�DDQOHUHQ�YDQ�VRFLDOHYDDUGLJKHGHQ�� SUREOHHPRSORVVHQGH� YDDUGLJKHGHQ�� ]HOIFRQWUROH� HQ� RPJDDQ� PHW� PRHLOLMNH�VWUHVVYROOH� VLWXDWLHV�� 2RN� ELM� GH� VFKRROLQWHUYHQWLHV� VWDDQ� GH]H� YDDUGLJKHGHQ� FHQWUDDO�� GHOHHUNUDFKWHQ�ZRUGHQ�JHWUDLQG�LQ�KHW�DDQOHUHQ�YDQ�GH�JHQRHPGH�YDDUGLJKHGHQ�DDQ�GH�NLQGHUHQHQ� GDDUQDDVW� ZRUGW� DDQGDFKW� EHVWHHG� DDQ� KHW� VFKRRONOLPDDW� HQ� RQGHUZLMVYDDUGLJKHGHQ�LQWHUDFWLYH� WHDFKLQJ� PHWKRGHV��� %LM� GH� RXGHUV� EHYDW� GH� LQWHUYHQWLH� YRRUDO� GH� YROJHQGHHOHPHQWHQ�� RSYRHGLQJV�� HQ� FRPPXQLFDWLHYDDUGLJKHGHQ� �]RDOV� JUHQ]HQ� VWHOOHQ�� EHORQHQSRVLWLHI�JHGUDJ���VWLPXOHUHQ�YDQ�GH�RXGHU�NLQG�UHODWLH��KXLVZHUNRQGHUVWHXQLQJ�'H LQVWUXPHQWHQ�ZDDUPHH�GH� JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�ZRUGHQ� JHPHWHQ�� ]LMQ� XLWHHQORSHQGHQ�ZRUGHQ�DIJHQRPHQ�ELM�OHHUNUDFKWHQ�HQ�RI�GH�RXGHUV��=RQRGLJ�]LMQ�SHU�VWXGLH�GH�XLWNRPVWHQRS� GH� YHUVFKLOOHQGH� PHHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ� JHPLGGHOG�� 'H� VWXGLHV� ZDDULQ� KHW]HOIGHPHHWLQVWUXPHQW� ELM� ]RZHO� GH� YDGHU� DOV� GH�PRHGHU� LV� JHEUXLNW��ZRUGHQ� GH� JHJHYHQV� YDQ� GHPRHGHU�WH�JHEUXLNW��+LHUYRRU�LV�JHNR]HQ�RPGDW�����KHW�DDQWDO�PRHGHUV�LQ�GH�VWHHNSURHI�JURWHUEOHHN� WH� ]LMQ� GDQ�KHW� DDQWDO� YDGHUV� HQ� ���� LQ� GH�PHHVWH� RQGHU]RHNHQ�GH�XLWNRPVWHQ�YDQ�GHPRHGHU�ZRUGHQ�JHUDSSRUWHHUG�0HWKRGH� 0HWD�DQDO\VH�YDQ�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�LQWHUYHQWLHV�RS�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�RS�EDVLV�YDQ�KHWµUDQGRP�HIIHFWV¶�PRGHO�5HVXOWDWHQ0HW�XLW]RQGHULQJ�YDQ�GH�VWXGLHV�YDQ�7UHPEOD\�HW�DO���������������ZLM]HQ�DOOH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�LQSRVLWLHYH�ULFKWLQJ��YHUPLQGHULQJ�YDQ�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ��GDW�ZLO�]HJJHQ�RS�GH�SRVWWHVW�PLQGHUJHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�LQ�GH�µEHKDQGHOJURHS¶�GDQ�LQ�GH�FRQWUROH�JURHS�2S�EDVLV�YDQ�GH�]HYHQ� VWXGLHV�NRQGHQ� �RS�GH�SRVWWHVW�� WLHQ�FRQWUDVWJURHSHQ�ZRUGHQVDPHQJHVWHOG��PHW�HHQ�WRWDOH�VWHHNSURHIJURRWWH�YDQ�������'H�JHPLGGHOGH�HIIHFWJURRWWH�LV�����PHW�HHQ�����EHWURXZEDDUKHLGVLQVWHUYDO�YDQ������WRW�������=� �������S�����������(U�LV�VSUDNHYDQ� HHQ�PLGGHOJURRW� HIIHFW��'H� KRPRJHQLWHLW� YDQ� GH� VWXGLHV� LV�PDWLJ� DDQJH]LHQ� VOHFKWV� ��SURFHQW� YDQ� GH� YDULDQWLH� NDQ� ZRUGHQ� YHUNODDUG� XLW� VWHHNSURHIIOXFWXDWLHV�� 'DDURP� LV� HHQFOXVWHUDQDO\VH�XLWJHYRHUG�RP�WH�NLMNHQ�RI�HU�KRPRJHQH�VXEVHWV�YDQ�VWXGLHV�WH�RQGHUVFKHLGHQ]LMQ��+LHUXLW�EOHHN�GDW�GH�VWXGLHV�HHQ�KRPRJHQH�VHW�YRUPHQ�PHW�XLW]RQGHULQJ�YDQ�GH�VWXGLHYDQ� 7UHPEOD\� HW� DO�� ������� ������� ZDDULQ� HHQ� NOHLQ� QHJDWLHI� UHVXOWDDW� ZDV� JHYRQGHQ�� 'HUHVXOWDWHQ� YDQ� GH�PHWD�DQDO\VH� ZDDULQ� GH� VWXGLH� YDQ� 7UHPEOD\� HW� DO�� QLHW� LV� PHHJHQRPHQ�WRWDDO� DDQWDO� UHVSRQGHQWHQ�� ����� ZLMNW� QLHW� DI� YDQ� GH� UHVXOWDWHQ� PHW� DOOH� �WLHQ�FRQWUDVWJURHSHQ�� PDDU� GH� KRPRJHQLWHLW� LV� VWHUN� WRHJHQRPHQ�� +HW� SHUFHQWDJH� YDQ� GHVWHHNSURHIYDULDQWLH� GDW� GRRU� VWHHNSURHIIOXFWXDWLHV� ZRUGW� YHUNODDUG� LV� ����� 'H� JHPLGGHOGHHIIHFWJURRWWH�LV������PHW�HHQ�����EHWURXZEDDUKHLGV�LQWHUYDO�YDQ������WRW�������=� �������S��������� (U�]LMQ�WH�ZHLQLJ�JHJHYHQV�YDQ�IROORZ�XS�PHWLQJHQ�EHVFKLNEDDU�RP�HHQ�PHWD�DQDO\VHWH�NXQQHQ�XLWYRHUHQ�YRRU�ODQJH�WHUPLMQ�HIIHFWHQ�&RQFOXVLHV%HODQJULMNVWH�EHSHUNLQJHQ� 'H�VWXGLHV�]LMQ�YDQ�UHGHOLMNH�WRW�JRHGH�NZDOLWHLW��9DQ�*DJHOGRQN 5LJWHU��������PDDU�KHEEHQ�GH�YROJHQGH�EHSHUNLQJHQ����� KHW� DDQWDO� VWXGLHV� LV� NOHLQ�� ���� GH� VWXGLHV� YHUVFKLOOHQ� LQ� GH� ZLM]H� ZDDURS� KHW� FRQFHSWJHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ� LV� JHPHWHQ� GRRUGDW� YHUVFKLOOHQGH� �GHOHQ� YDQ�� PHHWLQVWUXPHQWHQ� ]LMQJHEUXLNW�� ELM� YHUVFKLOOHQGH� SHUVRQHQ� �RXGHUV� HQ� OHHUNUDFKWHQ��� ���� GH� GRHOJURHSHQ� YDQ� GHLQWHUYHQWLHV� ORSHQ� VWHUN� XLWHHQ�� PHW� QDPH� GH� PDWH� ZDDULQ� ELM� GH� NLQGHUHQ� VSUDNH� LV� YDQJHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ��HQ�����GH�XLWJHYRHUGH�PHWD�DQDO\VH�EHSHUNW�]LFK�WRW�GH�HIIHFWHQ�RS�NRUWHWHUPLMQ� �SRVWWHVW�� HQ� WRW� GH� JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ� YDQ� GH� NLQGHUHQ�� GH� HLQGGRHOHQ� YDQ� GH

Page 144: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� 5,90�UDSSRUW�������������GHHO�%�

LQWHUYHQWLHV�� %RYHQGLHQ� ZDUHQ� QLHW� DOOH� JHUDSSRUWHHUGH� JHGUDJVHIIHFWHQ� EUXLNEDDU� YRRU� GHPHWD�DQDO\VH�8LWNRPVWHQ�'H LQWHUYHQWLHV� KHEEHQ� JHPLGGHOG� HHQ�PLGGHOJURRW� HIIHFW��$OV� RQGHUVFKHLG�ZRUGW� JHPDDNWQDDU�GH�PDWH�ZDDULQ�GH�GRHOJURHS�RS�GH�YRRUPHWLQJ�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�KHHIW��GDQ�YLQGHQ�ZHORJLVFKHUZLMV�KHW�NOHLQVWH�HIIHFW�ELM�GH�LQWHUYHQWLH�JHULFKW�RS�DOOH��VFKRRO�NLQGHUHQ��G ������'H HIIHFWJURRWWHV� YDQ� GH� LQWHUYHQWLHV� JHULFKW� RS� NLQGHUHQ� GLH� ELM� GH� DDQYDQJ� DOJHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�KHEEHQ�]LMQ�JURRW� �G�ZDDUGHQ� WXVVHQ������HQ�������PHW�XLW]RQGHULQJ�YDQHHQ�QHJDWLHI�HIIHFW�LQ�HHQ�VWXGLH�YDQ�G ��������%LM�GH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS�NLQGHUHQ�PHW�HHQYHUKRRJG�ULVLFR�RS�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ��]LMQ�GH�HIIHFWHQ��G� ������HQ�G �������NOHLQHU�GDQ�ELMGH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�YRRU�NLQGHUHQ�PHW�UHHGV�DDQZH]LJH�JHGUDJSUREOHPHQ�PDDU�JURWHU�GDQ�ELM�GHLQWHUYHQWLHV�JHULFKW�RS�NLQGHUHQ�]RQGHU�YHUKRRJG�ULVLFR�

Page 145: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW�������������±�GHHO�%� SDJ������YDQ����

/LWHUDWXXU$EUDPRZLW]�,$��&RXUVH\�5'��,PSDFW�RI�DQ�HGXFDWLRQDO�VXSSRUW�JURXS�LQ� IDPLO\�SDUWLFLSDQWV�ZKR�WDNH�FDUH�RIWKHLU�VFKL]RSKUHQLF�UHODWLYHV���-�&RQVXO�&OLQ�3V\FKRO������������������$UHDQ�3$��3HUUL�0*��1H]X�$0��6FKHLQ�5/��&KULVWRSKHU�)��-RVHSK�7;��&RPSDUDWLYH�HIIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�VRFLDOSUREOHP�VROYLQJ�WKHUDS\�DQG�UHPLQLVFHQFH�WKHUDS\�DV�WUHDWPHQWV�IRU�GHSUHVVLRQ�LQ�ROGHU�DGXOWV��-�&RQVXO&OLQ�3V\FKRO��������������������$YLD�0'��5XL]�0$��2OLYDUHV�(��&UHVSR�0��*XLVDGR�$%��6DQFKH]�$��9DUHOD�$���������7KH�PHDQLQJ�RI

SV\FKRORJLFDO�V\PSWRPV��HIIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�D�JURXS�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�ZLWK�K\SRFKRQGULDFDO�SDWLHQWV��%HKDY�5HV7KHU����������������

$]ULQ�1+��%HVDOHO�9$��:LVRW]HN�,��0F0RUURZ��%HFKWHO�5��%HKDYLRUDO�VXSHUYLVLRQ�YHUVXV�LQIRUPDWLRQDOFRXQVHOLQJ�RI�MRE�VHHNLQJ�LQ�WKH�MRE�FOXE��5HKDELO�&RXQV�%XOO���������������$]ULQ�1+��)ORUHV�7��.DSODQ�6-��-RE�ILQGLQJ�FOXE��D�JURXS�DVVLVWHG�SURJUP�IRU�REWDLQLQJ�HPSOR\PHQW� %HKDY�5HV7KHU����������������%DQGXUD�$��6HOI�HIILFDF\��WRZDUGV�D�XQLI\LQJ�WKHRU\�RI�EHKDYLRUDO�FKDQJH��3V\FKRO�5HY������������������%DQGXUD�$���������6HOI�HIILFDF\�LQ�KXPDQ�DJHQF\��$P�3V\FKRO�����������������%DQJHUW�'URZQV�5/��7KH�HIIHFWV�RI�VFKRRO�EDVHG�VXEVWDQFH�DEXVH�HGXFDWLRQ��D�PHWD�DQDO\VLV��-�'UXJ�(GXF�����������������%DUQDUG�.(��0DJ\DU\�'��6XPQHU�*��%RRWK�&/��0LWFKHOO�6.��6SLHNHU�6��3UHYHQWLRQ�RI�SDUHQWLQJ�DOWHUDWLRQV�IRUZRPHQ�ZLWK�ORZ�VRFLDO�VXSSRUW� 3V\FKLDWU\�����������������%HXWOHU�/(��6FRJLQ�)��.LUNLVK�3�HW�DO��*URXS�FRJQLWLYH�WKHUDS\�DQG�DOSUD]RODP�LQ�WKH�WUHDWPHQW�RI�GHSUHVVLRQ�LQROGHU�DGXOWV��-�&RQVXO�&OLQ�3V\FKRO������������������%LHQ�7+��0LOOHU�:5��7RQLJDQ�-6��%ULHI�LQWHUYHQWLRQV�IRU�DOFRKRO�SUREOHPV��D�UHYLHZ��$GGLFWLRQ�������������������%RJDW��*$��-DVRQ�/$��$Q�HYDOXDWLRQ�RI�WZR�YLVLWLQJ�SURJUDPV�IRU�HOGHUO\�FRPPXQLW\�UHVLGHQWV��,QW�-�$JLQJ+XP�'HY�����������������%RVPD�0:0��&0+�+RVPDQ��3UHYHQWLH�RS�ZDDUGH�JHVFKDW��HHQ�VWXGLH�QDDU�GH�EHwQYORHGEDDUKHLG�YDQGHWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG��1LMPHJHQ��%rWD�ERHNHQ�������%URGDW\�+��*UHVKDP�0��(IIHFW�RI�D�WUDLQLQJ�SURJUDPPH�WR�UHGXFH�VWUHVV�LQ�FDUHUV�RI�SDWLHQWV�ZLWK�GHPHQWLD��%ULW0HG�-���������������������

%UXYROG�:+���5XQGDOO�7*��$�PHWD�DQDO\VLV�DQG�WKHRUHWLFDO�UHYLHZ�RI�VFKRRO�EDVHG�WREDFFR�DQG�DOFRKROLQWHUYHQWLRQ�SURJUDPV��3V\FKRO�+HDOWK���������������%UXYROG�:+��$�PHWD�DQDO\VLV�RI�WKH�&DOLIRUQLD�VFKRRO�EDVHG�ULVN�UHGXFWLRQ�SURJUDP��- 'UXJ�(GX������������������%UXYROG�:+��$�PHWD�DQDO\VLV�RI�DGROHVFHQW�VPRNLQJ�SUHYHQWLRQ�SURJUDPV��$P�-�3XEOLF�+HDOWK�����������������&DSODQ�5'��9LQRNXU�$'��3ULFH�5+��5\Q�0�YDQ��-RE�VHHNLQJ��UHHPSOR\PHQW��DQG�PHQWDO�KHDOWK��D�UDQGRPL]HGILHOG�H[SHULPHQW�LQ�FRSLQJ�ZLWK�MRE�ORVV��-�$SSO�3V\FKRO������������������&DUOLHU�,9(��*HUVRQV�%35��'HEULHILQJ��LQWHUYHQWLHV�QD�DFXWH�WUDXPDWLVHULQJ��,Q��*HUVRQV�%35��&DUOLHU�,9(�HGV����%HKDQGHOLQJVVWUDWHJLHsQ�ELM�GH�SRVWWUDXPDWLVFKH�VWUHVV�VWRRUQLV��+RXWHQ�'LHJHP��%RKQ�6WDIOHX9DQ�/RJKHP�������

&DUSHQWLHU�1��/HVDJH�$��*RXOHW�-��/DORQGH�3��5HQDXG�0��%XUGHQ�RI�FDUH�RI�IDPLOLHV�QRW�OLYLQJ�ZLWK�\RXQJVFKL]RSKUHQLF�UHODWLYHV��+RVSLW�DQG�&RP�3V\FKLDW����������������&DVHUWD�06��/XQG�'$��,QWUDSHUVRQDO�UHVRXUFHV�DQG�WKH�HIIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�VHOI�KHOS�JURXSV�IRU�EHUHDYHG�ROGHUDGXOWV��*HURQWRORJLVW������������������&ODUNH�*1��:�+DZNLQV��0�0XUSK\�HW�DO��7DUJHWHG�SUHYHQWLRQ�RI�XQLSRODU�GHSUHVVLYH�GLVRUGHU�LQ�DQ�DW�ULVNVDPSOH�RI�KLJK�VFKRRO�DGROHVFHQWV��$�UDQGRPL]HG�WULDO�RI�D�JURXS�FRJQLWLYH�LQWHUYHQWLRQ��-�$P�$FDG&KLOG�$GRO�3V\FKLDW������������������&ODXVHQ�-$��<DUURZ�05��HGV����7KH�LPSDFW�RI�PHQWDO�LOOQHVV�RQ�WKH�IDPLO\��-�6RF�,VVXHV��������� �����&RQVWDQWLQR�5(���������%HUHDYHPHQW�FULVLV�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�IRU�ZLGRZV�LQ�JULHI�DQG�PRXUQLQJ��1XUV�5HV������������������&RQVWDQWLQR�5(���������&RPSDULVRQ�RI�WZR�JURXS�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�IRU�WKH�EHUHDYHG��,PDJH�-�1XUV�6FK� �����������������&R]ROLQR�/-��*ROGVWHLQ�0-��1XHFKWHUOHLQ�.+��7KH�LPSDFW�RI�HGXFDWLRQ�DERXW�VFKL]RSKUHQLD�RQ�UHODWLYHV�YDU\LQJLQ�H[SUHVVHG�HPRWLRQ��6FKL]RSKUHQLD�%XOO������������������&XLMSHUV�3��6WDP�+��LQ�YRRUEHUHLGLQJ���'H�HIIHFWHQ�YDQ�SUHYHQWLH�YDQ�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ�ELM�NLQGHUHQ�HQMHXJGLJHQ�&XLMSHUV�3��1LHV�+��6XSSRUWLQJ�LQIRUPDO�FDUHJLYHUV�RI�GHPHQWHG�SHRSOH��SV\FKRVRFLDO�LQWHUYHQWLRQV�DQG�WKHLURXWFRPHV��,Q� -RQHV�*��0LHVHQ�%��HGV����&DUHJLYLQJ�LQ�GHPHQWLD��SDUW�,,��/RQGRQ��5RXWOHGJH� ������SS�

Page 146: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� 5,90�UDSSRUW�������������GHHO�%�

��������&XLMSHUV�3��3V\FKRORJLFDO�2XWUHDFK�3URJUDPV�IRU�'HSUHVVHG�(OGHUO\��D�PHWD�DQDO\VLV�RI�HIIHFWV�DQG�GURS�RXW��,QW- *HULDWU�3V\FK����������������&XLMSHUV�3��7KH�(IIHFWV�RI�)DPLO\�,QWHUYHQWLRQV�RQ�5HODWLYHV¶�%XUGHQ��$�0HWD�DQDO\VLV��-�0HQWDO�+HDOWK�����������������&XLMSHUV�3��%ORP�0��:HHUVLQN�/��3UHYHQWLHYH�LQWHUYHQWLHV�YRRU�RXGHUHQ�PHW�GHSUHVVLHYH�NODFKWHQ��0DDQGEODG*HHVWHOLMNH�YRONVJH]RQGKHLG��0*Y��������������������'DGGV�05��0F+XJK�7$��6RFLDO�VXSSRUW�DQG�WUHDWPHQW�RXWFRPH�LQ�EHKDYLRUDO�IDPLO\�WKHUDS\�IRU�FKLOG�FRQGXFWSUREOHPV��-�&RQVXO�&OLQ�3V\FKRO�������������������'DGGV�05��6SHQFH�6+��+ROODQG�'(��%DUUHWW�30��/DXUHQV�.5��3UHYHQWLRQ�DQG�HDUO\�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�IRU�DQ[LHW\GLVRUGHUV��D�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO��-�&RQVXO�&OLQ�3V\FKRO������������������'HOOHILHOG�.6��0F'RXJDOO�*-��,QFUHDVLQJ�PHWDPHPRU\�LQ�ROGHU�DGXOWV��1XUV�5HV������������������'HPHUV�$��/DYRLH�-3��(IIHFW�RI�VXSSRUW�JURXSV�RQ�IDPLO\�FDUHJLYHUV�WRW�WKH�IUDLO�HOGHUO\��&DQ�-�$JLQJ������������������'L[RQ�/%��/HKPDQ�$)��)DPLO\�LQWHUYHQWLRQV�IRU�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��6FKL]RSKUHQLD�%XOO�������������������'XLMQVWHH�0��'H�EHODVWLQJ�YDQ�IDPLOLHOHGHQ�YDQ�GHPHQWHUHQGH�RXGHUHQ��8WUHFKW��1,=:�������(QJHODQG�+�YDQ��'H�SUHPRUELGH�LGHQWLILFDWLH�YDQ�SRSXODWLHV�PHW�HHQ�KRRJ�ULVLFR��,Q��(QJHODQG�+�YDQ��/LQV]HQ'+��HGV����9URHJWLMGLJH�KHUNHQQLQJ�HQ�EHKDQGHOLQJ�YDQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH��3URFHHGLQJV�RI�D�V\PSRVLXP������2FW�����(GH��7ULFKW��6WLFKWLQJ�6FKROLQJ�3V\FKLDWULH������������

(QQHWW�67��7REOHU�16��5LQJZDOW�&/��)OHZHOOLQJ�5/��+RZ�HIIHFWLYH�LV�GUXJ�DEXVH�UHVLVWDQFH�HGXFDWLRQ"�$PHWD�DQDO\VLV�RI�3URMHFW�'$5(�RXWFRPH�HYDOXDWLRQV��$P�-�3XEOLF�+HDOWK���������������������)DOORRQ�,5+��.\GG�55��&RYHUGDOH�-+��/DLGODZ�70��(DUO\�GHWHFWLRQ�DQG�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�IRU�LQLWLDO�HSLVRGHV�RIVFKL]RSKUHQLD��6FKL]RSKUHQLD�%XOO�������������������

)DUUDQ�&-��.HDQH�+DJDUW\�(��0XOWL�PRGDO�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�VWUDWHJLHV�IRU��FDUHJLYHUV�RI�SHUVRQV�ZLWK�GHPHQWLD��,Q�/LJKW�(��1LHGHUHKH�*��/HERZLW]�%'��HGV����6WUHVV�HIIHFWV�RQ�IDPLO\�FDUHJLYHUV�RI�$O]KHLPHU¶V�SDWLHQWV�5HVHDUFK�DQG�LQWHUYHQWLRQV��1HZ�<RUN��6SULQJHU�������SS����������)UHHPDQWOH�1��*LOO�3��*RGIUH\�&�HW�DO��%ULHI�LQWHUYHQWLRQV�DQG�DOFRKRO�XVH��(IIHFWLYH�KHDOWK�FDUH���������������)ULHGKRII�$-��&RQVHQVXV�GHYHORSPHQW�FRQIHUHQFH�VWDWHPHQW��'LDJQRVLV�DQG�WUHDWPHQW�RI�GHSUHVVLRQ�LQ�ODWH�OLIH�,Q��6FKQHLGHU�/6��5H\QROGV�,,,�&)��/HERZLW]�%'��)ULHGKRII�$-��HGV����'LDJQRVLV�DQG�WUHDWPHQW�RIGHSUHVVLRQ�LQ�ODWH�OLIH��UHVXOWV�RI�WKH�1,+�FRQVHQVXV�GHYHORSPHQW�FRQIHUHQFH��:DVKLQJWRQ�'&��$PHULFDQ3V\FKLDWULF�3UHVV�������)U\�36��6WUXFWXUHG�DQG�XQVWUXFWXUHG�UHPLQLVFHQFH�WUDLQLQJ�DQG�GHSUHVVLRQ�DPRQJ�WKH�HOGHUO\��&OLQ�*HURQWRORJLVW��������������)U\�36��&RJQLWLYH�WUDLQLQJ�DQG�FRJQLWLYH�EHKDYLRUDO�YDULDEOHV�LQ�WKH�WUHDWPHQW�RI�GHSUHVVLRQ�LQ�WKH�HOGHUO\��&OLQ*HURQWRORJLVW���������������*DJHOGRQN�$�YDQ��&XLMSHUV�3��(IIHFWHQ�YDQ�YHUVODYLQJVSUHYHQWLH��2YHU]LFKW�YDQ�GH�OLWHUDWXXU��8WUHFKW��7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW�������

*DJHOGRQN�$�YDQ��5LJWHU�+��3UHYHQWLH�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�HQ�JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ��HHQ�EHNQRSW�RYHU]LFKW�YDQ�GH�VWDQGYDQ�ZHWHQVFKDS��'HQ�+DDJ��=RUJ2QGHU]RHN�1HGHUODQG�������*DJHOGRQN�$�YDQ��&XLMSHUV�3��'H�YHUVODYLQJVSUHYHQWLH��RYHU]LFKW�YDQ�KHW�RQGHU]RHN�QDDU�GHYHUVODYLQJVSUHYHQWLH�HQ�LPSOLFDWLHV�YRRU�RQGHU]RHN��EHOHLG�HQ�SUDNWLMN��8WUHFKW��7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW�������*RWWOLHE�*/��%DUULHUV�WR�FDUH�IRU�ROGHU�DGXOWV�ZLWK�GHSUHVVLRQ��,Q��6FKQHLGHU�/6��5H\QROGV�,,,�&)��/HERZLW]�%'�)ULHGKRII�$-���HGV����'LDJQRVLV�DQG�WUHDWPHQW�RI�GHSUHVVLRQ�LQ�ODWH�OLIH��UHVXOWV�RI�WKH�1,+�FRQVHQVXVGHYHORSPHQW�FRQIHUHQFH��:DVKLQJWRQ�'&��$PHULFDQ�3V\FKLDWULF�3UHVV�������*UHHQ�9/��0RQDKDQ�'-��7KH�HIIHFW�RI�D�SURIHVVLRQDOO\�JXLGHG�FDUHJLYHU�VXSSRUW�DQG�HGXFDWLRQ�JURXS�RQ�LQVWLWX�WLRQDOL]DWLRQ��*HURQWRORJLVW��������������������

*UHHQ�9/��0RQDKDQ�'-��7KH�HIIHFW�RI�D�VXSSRUW�DQG�HGXFDWLRQ�SURJUDP�RQ�VWUHVV�DQG�EXUGHQ�DPRQJ�IDPLO\FDUHJLYHUV�WR�IUDLO�HOGHUO\�SHUVRQV��*HURQWRORJLVW�������������������

*UHHQEHUJ�0$��'HYHORSPHQWDO�DQG�FOLQLFDO�PRGHO�IRU�SUHYHQWLRQ�RI�FRQGXFW�GLVRUGHU��WKH�)$67�7UDFN3URJUDP��'HY�3V\FKRSDWKRO�����������������*URVV�'��)RJJ�/��7XFNHU�6��7KH�HIILFDF\�RI�SDUHQW�WUDLQLQJ�IRU�SURPRWLQJ�SRVLWLYH�SDUHQW�WRGGOHU�UHODWLRQVKLSV�5HV�1XUV�+HDOWK������������������+DDV�*/��*OLFN�,'��&ODUNLQ�-)�HW�DO��,QSDWLHQW�IDPLO\�LQWHUYHQWLRQ��$�UDQGRPL]HG�FOLQLFDO�WULDO��$UFK�*HQ3V\FKLDW�������������������+DOH\�:(��*URXS�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�IRU�GHPHQWLD�IDPLO\�FDUHJLYHUV��$�ORQJLWXGLQDO�SHUVSHFWLYH��*HURQWRORJLVW�����������������+DOH\�:(��%URZQ�6/��/HYLQH�(*��([SHULPHQWDO�HYDOXDWLRQ�RI�WKH�HIIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�JURXS�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�IRUGHPHQWLD�FDUHJLYHUV��*HURQWRORJLVW������������������+DZNLQV�-'��&OHYH�(�YRQ��&DWDODQR�5)��5HGXFLQJ�HDUO\�FKLOGKRRG�DJJUHVVLRQ��UHVXOWV�RI�D�SULPDU\�SUHYHQWLRQSURJUDP��-�$P�$FDG�&KLOG�$GROHVF�3V\�������������������

Page 147: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW�������������±�GHHO�%� SDJ������YDQ����

+HGJHV�/��2ONLQ�,��6WDWLVWLFDO�PHWKRGV�IRU�PHWD�DQDO\VLV��2UODQGR��$FDGHPLF�3UHVV������+HOOHU�.��7KRPSVRQ�0*��7UXHED�3(��+RJJ�-5��9ODFKRV�:HEHU�,��3HHU�VXSSRUW�WHOHSKRQH�G\DGV�IRU�HOGHUO\ZRPHQ��ZDV�WKLV�WKH�ZURQJ�LQWHUYHQWLRQ"�$P�-�&RPPXQ�3V\FKRO������������������+RJDUW\�*(��$QGHUVRQ�&$��5HLVV�'-�HW�DO��)DPLO\�SV\FKRHGXFDWLRQ��VRFLDO�VNLOOV�WUDLQLQJ��DQG�PDLQWHQDQFHFKHPRWKHUDS\�LQ�WKH�DIWHUFDUH�WUHDWPHQW�RI�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��$UFK�*HQ�3V\FKLDW������������������-RKQVRQ�'/��:DONHU�7��3ULPDU\�SUHYHQWLRQ�RI�EHKDYLRU�SUREOHPV�LQ�0H[LFDQ�$PHULFDQ�FKLOGUHQ��$P�-&RPPXQ�3V\FKRO����������������.DKDQ�-��.HPS�%��6WDSOHV�)5��%UXPPHO�6PLWK�.��'HFUHDVLQJ�WKH�EXUGHQ�LQ�IDPLOLHV�FDULQJ�IRU�D�UHODWLYH�ZLWK�DGHPHQWLQJ�LOOQHVV� - $P�*HULDWU�6RF�������������������/DP�'+��3V\FKRVRFLDO�IDPLO\�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�LQ�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��D�UHYLHZ�RI�HPSLULFDO�VWXGLHV��3V\FKRORJLFDO0HGLFLQH�������������������/DPPHUHQ�3�YDQ��*HHOHQ�.� 9HUELWWHUHQ�RI�YHUEHWHUHQ��HYDOXDWLH�YDQ�HHQ�SURJUDPPD�WHU�YRRUNRPLQJ�YDQHHQ]DDPKHLG�HQ�GHSUHVVLH�ELM�RXGHUH�ZHGXZHQ��8WUHFKW��1F*Y�������/DQJHU�$��)DUQRW�8��*DUFLD�&�HW�DO��7KH�/DWLQ�$PHULFDQ�WULDO�RI�SV\FKRVRFLDO�VXSSRUW�GXULQJ�SUHJQDQF\��(IIHFWVRQ�PRWKHU¶V�ZHOOEHLQJ�DQG�VDWLVIDFWLRQ��6RF�6FL�0HG���������������������/D]DUXV�56��)RONPDQ�6���6WUHVV��DSSUDLVDO�DQG�FRSLQJ��1HZ�<RUN��6SULQJHU�������/HY\�/+��'HUE\�-)��0DUWLQNRZVNL�.6��(IIHFWV�RI�PHPEHUVKLS�LQ�EHUHDYHPHQW�VXSSRUW�JURXSV�RQ�DGDSWDWLRQ�WRFRQMXJDO�EHUHDYHPHQW��$P�-�&RPPXQ�3V\FKRO�������������������/LGEHFN�-��*URXS�WKHUDS\�IRU�VRPDWL]DWLRQ�GLVRUGHUV�LQ�JHQHUDO�SUDFWLFH��HIIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�D�VKRUW�FRJQLWLYH�EHKDYLRXUDO�WUHDWPHQW�PRGHO��$FWD�3V\FKLDW�6FDQG�����������������/LHEHUPDQ�0$��9LGHND�6KHUPDQ�/��7KH�LPSDFW�RI�VHOI�KHOS�JURXSV�RQ�WKH�PHQWDO�KHDOWK�RI�ZLGRZV�DQGZLGRZHUV��$P�-�2UWKRSV\FKLDW������������������/LQV]HQ�'��'LQJHPDQV�3��'RHV�-:�YDQ�GHU�HW�DO��7UHDWPHQW��H[SUHVVHG�HPRWLRQ�DQG�UHODSVH�LQ�UHFHQW�RQVHWVFKL]RSKUHQLF�GLVRUGHUV��3V\FKRO�0HG������������������/LQV]HQ�'+��/HQLRU�0��+DDQ�/�GH��'LQJHPDQV�30��(DUO\�LQWHUYHQWLRQ��XQWUHDWHG�SV\FKRVLV�DQG�WKH�FRXUVH�RIHDUO\�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��%ULW�-�3V\FKLDW������������������

/LQV]HQ�'+��$DQ�GH�SV\FKRVH�YRRUDI��'H�RQWZLNNHOLQJ�QDDU�SV\FKRVH�HQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH��,Q��(QJHODQG�+�YDQ�/LQV]HQ�'+��HGV����9URHJWLMGLJH�KHUNHQQLQJ�HQ�EHKDQGHOLQJ�YDQ�VFKL]RIUHQLH��3URFHHGLQJV�RI�D6\PSRVLXP�������2FW�����(GH��7ULFKW��6WLFKWLQJ�6FKROLQJ�3V\FKLDWULH�������SS�������

/LSVH\�0:��'HVLJQ� VHQVLWLYLW\��6WDWLVWLFDO�SRZHU� IRU� H[SHULPHQWDO� UHVHDUFK��1HZEXU\�3DUN��&$��86$���6DJH3XEOLFDWLRQV��,QF��������SS������/LWW�0'��1\H�&1��6KDIHU�'���������-�%HK�0HG������������������/RFKPDQ�-(��&RLH�-'��8QGHUZRRG�0.��7HUU\�5���������(IIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�D�VRFLDO�UHODWLRQV�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�SURJUDPIRU�DJJUHVVLYH�DQG�QRQDJJUHVVLYH�UHMHFWHG�FKLOGUHQ��-�&RQVXO�&OLQ�3V\FKRO��������������/RYHWW�6��*DOODJKHU�'��3V\FKRHGXFDWLRQDO�LQWHUYHQWLRQV�IRU�IDPLO\�FDUHJLYHUV��SUHOLPLQDU\�GDWD��%HK�7KHUDS\�����������������0DF&DUWK\�%��.XLSHUV�/��+XUU\�-�HW�DO��&RXQVHOOLQJ�UHODWLYHV�RI�WKH�ORQJ�WHUP�DGXOW�PHQWDOO\�LOO�,��(YDOXDWLRQ�RIWKH�LPSDFW�RQ�UHODWLYH�DQG�SDWLHQWV���%ULW�-�3V\FKLDW���������� ��������0DXULQ�-7��%R\G�&%��%XUGHQ�RI�PHQWDO�LOOQHVV�RQ�WKH�IDPLO\��$�FULWLFDO�UHYLHZ��$UFK�3V\FKLDW�1XUV����������������0F&XUU\�60��/RJVGRQ�5*��9LWLHOOR�09��7HUL�/��6XFFHVVIXO�EHKDYLRUDO�WUHDWPHQW�IRU�UHSRUWHG�VOHHS�SUREOHPV�LQHOGHUO\�FDUHJLYHUV�RI�GHPHQWLD�SDWLHQWV��$�FRQWUROOHG�VWXG\��-�*HURQWRO��������%����������0F*ODVKDQ�7+��-RKDQQHVVHQ�-2��(DUO\�GHWHFWLRQ�DQG�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�ZLWK�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��5DWLRQDOH��6FKL]RSKUHQLD%XOO������������������

0F*RUU\�3'��(GZDUGV�-��0LKDORSRXORV�&�HW�DO��(33,&��$Q�HYROYLQJ�V\VWHP�RI�HDUO\�GHWHFWLRQ�DQG�RSWLPDOPDQDJHPHQW��6FKL]RSKUHQLD�%XOO�������������������

0F1HLO�-.��/H%ODQF�(0��-R\QHU�0���������7KH�HIIHFW�RI�H[HUFLVH�RQ�GHSUHVVLYH�V\PSWRPV�LQ�WKH�PRGHUDWHO\GHSUHVVHG�HOGHUO\��3V\FKRO�$JLQJ�����������������0LWWHOPDQ�06��)HUULV�6+��6KXOPDQ�(��6WHLQEHUJ�*��$PELQGHU�$��0DFNHOO�-$��&RKHQ�-���������$FRPSUHKHQVLYH�VXSSRUW�SURJUDP��(IIHFW�RQ�GHSUHVVLRQ�LQ�VSRXVH�FDUHJLYHUV�RI�$'�SDWLHQWV��*HURQWRORJLVW�����������������0LWWHOPDQ�06��)HUULV�6+��6KXOPDQ�(��6WHLQEHUJ�*��$PELQGHU�$��0DFNHOO�-��(IIHFWV�RI�D��PXOWL�FRPSRQHQWVXSSRUW�SURJUDP�RQ�VSRXVH�FDUHJLYHUV�RI�$O]KHLPHU¶V�GLVHDVH�SDWLHQWV��5HVXOWV�RI�D�WUHDWPHQW�FRQWUROVWXG\��,Q��+HVWRQ�//��HG���3URJUHVV�LQ�$O]KHLPHU¶V�GLVHDVH�DQG�VLPLODU�FRQGLWLRQV��:DVKLQJWRQ�'&��$P3V\FKLDWULF�3UHVV�,QF��>$P�3V\FKRSDWKRO�$VV@��������SS����������0LWWHOPDQ�06��)HUULV�6+��6KXOPDQ�(��6WHLQEHUJ�*��/HYLQ�%���������$�IDPLO\�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�WR�GHOD\�QXUVLQJKRPH�UHSODFHPHQW�RI�SDWLHQWV�ZLWK�$O]KHLPHU�GLVHDVH��$�UDQGRPL]HG�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO� -$0$��������������������

0LWWHOPDQ�06��)HUULV�6+��6KXOPDQ�(��6WHLQEHUJ�*��0DFNHOO�-$��$PELQGHU�$���������(IILFDF\�RI�PXOWLFRSRQHQWLQGLYLGXDOL]HG�WUHDWPHQW�WR�LPSURYH�WKH�ZHOO�EHLQJ�RI�$O]KHLPHU¶V�FDUHJLYHUV��,Q��/LJKW�(��1LHGHUHKH�*�

Page 148: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� 5,90�UDSSRUW�������������GHHO�%�

/HERZLW]�%'��HGV���6WUHVV�HIIHFWV�RQ�IDPLO\�FDUHJLYHUV�RI�$O]KHLPHU¶V�SDWLHQWV��UHVHDUFK�DQGLQWHUYHQWLRQV��1HZ�<RUN��6SULQJHU��������SS����������0RKLGH�($��3ULQJOH�'0��6WUHLQHU�'/��*LOEHUW�-5��0XLU�*���������7HZ�0��$�UDQGRPL]HG�WULDO�RI�FDUHJLYHUVXSSRUW�LQ�WKH�KRPH�PDQDJHPHQW�RI�GHPHQWLD��-�$P�*HULDWU�6RF�������������������

0UD]HN�3-��5-�+DJJHUW\���������5HGXFLQJ�ULVNV�IRU�PHQWDO�GLVRUGHUV��IURQWLHUV�IRU�SUHYHQWLYH�LQWHUYHQWLRQUHVHDUFK��:DVKLQJWRQ��1DWLRQDO�$FDGHP\�3UHVV�������1,0+��1DWLRQDO�$GYLVRU\�0HQWDO�+HDOWK�&RXQFLO�:RUNJURXS�RQ�0HQWDO�'LVRUGHUV�3UHYHQWLRQ�5HVHDUFK�3ULRULWLHV�IRU�SUHYHQWLRQ�UHVHDUFK�DW�1,0+��%HWKHVGD��1DWLRQDO�,QVWLWXWH�RI�0HQWDO�+HDOWK�������1XVV�:6��=XEHQNR�*6����������&RUUHODWHV�RI�SHUVLVWHQW�GHSUHVVLYH�V\PSWRPV�LQ�ZLGRZV��$P�-�3V\FKLDW������������������2V�-�YDQ��=LQ�HQ�RQ]LQ�YDQ�GHWHFWLH�YDQ�SUH�VFKL]RIUHQLH��7LMGVFKULIW�YRRU�3V\FKLDWULH�������������������3RLNRODLQHQ�.��(IIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�EULHI�LQWHUYHQWLRQV�WR�UHGXFH�DOFRKRO�LQWDNH�LQ�SULPDU\�KHDOWK�FDUH�SRSXODWLRQV�

$ PHWD�DQDO\VLV��3UHY�0HG�������������������3RVQHU�&0��:LOVRQ�.*��.UDO�0-�HW�DO���������)DPLO\�SV\FKRHGXFDWLRQDO�VXSSRUW�JURXSV�LQ�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��$P�-2UWKRSV\FKLDW������������������5HLFK�-:��=DXWUD�$-��$�SHUFHLYHG�FRQWURO�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�IRU�DW�ULVN�ROGHU�DGXOWV��3V\FKRO�$JLQJ������������������5LGGHU�'�GH� 'HWHUPLQDQWHQ�YDQ�SV\FKLVFKH�JH]RQGKHLG��HHQ�YHUNHQQLQJ�YDQ�GH�OLWHUDWXXU��8WUHFKW��1F*Y������5LIH�-&��%HOFKHU�-5��$VVLVWLQJ�XQHPSOR\HG�ROGHU�ZRUNHUV�WH�EHFRPH�UHHPSOR\HG��DQ�H[SHULPHQWDO�HYDOXDWLRQ�5HV��6RFLDO�:RUN��������������5LJWHU�+��6FKUDPHLMHU�)��5LMN�&�GH��6RPDWLVDWLH��$DQ]HW�YRRU�HHQ�RQGHU]RHNVSURJUDPPD��'HQ�+DDJ��5DDG�YRRU

*H]RQGKHLGVRQGHU]RHN���������������5RELQVRQ�/$��%HUPDQ�-6��1HLPH\HU�5$��3V\FKRWKHUDS\�IRU�WKH�WUHDWPHQW�RI�GHSUHVVLRQ��D�FRPSUHKHQVLYHUHYLHZ�RI�FRQWUROOHG�RXWFRPH�VWXGLHV��3V\FKRO�%XOO�����������������5RRQH\�%/��0XUUD\�'0��$�PHWD�DQDO\VLV�RI�VPRNLQJ�SUHYHQWLRQ�SURJUDPV�DIWHU�DGMXVWPHQW�IRU�HUURUV�LQ�WKHXQLW�RI�DQDO\VLV��+HDOWK�(GXF�4XDUW�����������������5XQGDOO�7*��%UXYROG�:+��$�PHWD�DQDO\VLV�RI�VFKRRO�EDVHG�VPRNLQJ�DQG�DOFRKRO�XVH�SUHYHQWLRQ�SURJUDPV�+HDOWK�(GXF�4XDUW������������������5XZDDUG�'��.UDPHUV�3*1��9RONVJH]RQGKHLG�WRHNRPVW�YHUNHQQLQJHQ�������GH�VRP�GHU�GHOHQ��8WUHFKW�(OVHYLHU�'H�7LMGVWURRP�������6DQGOHU�,1��:HVW�6*��%DFD�/�HW�DO��/LQNLQJ�HPSLULFDOO\�EDVHG�WKHRU\�DQG�HYDOXDWLRQ��WKH�)DPLO\�%HUHDYHPHQW3URJUDP��$P�-�&RPPXQ�3V\FKRO������������������6FKUDPHLHU�)��6RFLDOH�VWHXQ��DQDO\VH�YDQ�HHQ�SDUDGLJPD��8WUHFKW��1F*Y�������6FKXW�+$:��6WURHEH�06��%RXW�-�YDQ�GHQ��,QWHUYHQWLRQ�IRU�WKH�EHUHDYHG��JHQGHU�GLIIHUHQFHV�LQ�WKH�HIILFDF\�RIWZR�FRXQVHOOLQJ�SURJUDPPHV��%ULW�-�&OLQ�3V\FKRO����������������6FKZDU]HU�5��0HWD�DQDO\VLV�3URJUDPV��%HUOLQ��)UHLH�8QLYHUVLWlW�������6FRJLQ�)��+DPEOLQ�'��%HXWOHU�/��%LEOLRWKHUDS\�IRU�ROGHU�DGXOWV��$�VHOI�KHOS�DOWHUQDWLYH��*HURQWRORJLVW�����������������6FRJLQ�)��-DPLVRQ�&��'DYLV�1��&RPSDUDWLYH�HIILFDF\�RI�FRJQLWLYH�DQG�EHKDYLRUDO�ELEOLRWKHUDS\�IRU�PLOGO\�DQGPRGHUDWHO\�GHSUHVVHG�ROGHU�DGXOWV��-�&RQVXO�&OLQ�3V\FKRO�������������������6PLWK�-9��%LUFKZRRG�0-��6SHFLILF�DQG�QRQ�VSHFLILF�HIIHFWV�RI�HGXFDWLRQDO�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�ZLWK�IDPLOLHV�OLYLQJ�ZLWKD VFKL]RSKUHQLF�UHODWLYH��%ULW�-�3V\FKLDW�������������������6RORPRQ�3��'UDLQH�-��$GDSWLYH�FRSLQJ�DPRQJ�IDPLO\�PHPEHUV�RI�SHUVRQV�ZLWK�VHULRXV�PHQWDO�LOOQHVV��3V\FKLDWU6HUY���������������������6RORPRQ�3��0RYLQJ�IURP�SV\FKRHGXFDWLRQ�WR�IDPLO\�HGXFDWLRQ�IRU�IDPLOLHV�RI�DGXOWV�ZLWK�VHULRXV�PHQWDO�LOOQHVV�3V\FKLDWU�6HUY���������������������6RQGHUHQ�(�YDQ��+HW�PHWHQ�YDQ�VRFLDOH�VWHXQ��*URQLQJHQ��5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW��SURHIVFKULIW�������6SHFNHQV�$(0��+HPHUW�$�YDQ��6SLQKRYHQ�3�HW�DO��&RJQLWLYH�EHKDYLRXUDO�WKHUDS\�IRU�PHGLFDOO\�XQH[SODLQHG

SK\VLFDO�V\PSWRPV��$�UDQGRPLVHG�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO��%ULW�-�0HG����������������������6WDPS�*(��:LOOLDPV�$6��&URZWKHU�&$��(YDOXDWLRQ�RI�DQWHQDWDO�DQG�SRVWQDWDO�VXSSRUW�WR�RYHUFRPH�SRVWQDWDO

GHSUHVVLRQ��$�UDQGRPL]HG�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO��%LUWK�������������������7KRPSVRQ�/:��*DOODJKHU�'��(IILFDF\�RI�SV\FKRWKHUDS\�LQ�WKH�WUHDWPHQW�RI�ODWH�OLIH�GHSUHVVLRQ��$GY�%HKDY5HV�7KHUDS\������������������7REOHU�16��6WUDWWRQ�++��(IIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�VFKRRO�EDVHG�GUXJ�SUHYHQWLRQ�SURJUDPV��D�PHWD�DQDO\VLV�RI�WKHUHVHDUFK��-�3ULPDU\�3UHY�����������������7REOHU�16��0HWD�DQDO\VLV�RI�����DGROHVFHQW�GUXJ�SUHYHQWLRQ�SURJUDPV��TXDQWLWDWLYH�RXWFRPH�UHVXOWV�RI�SURJUDPSDUWLFLSDQWV�FRPSDUHG�WR�D�FRQWURO�RU�FRPSDULVRQ�JURXS��-�'UXJ�,VVXHV������������������7REOHU�16��8SGDWHG�PHWD�DQDO\VLV�RI�DGROHVFHQW�SUHYHQWLRQ�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�UHVHDUFK��,Q��0RQWR\D�&��5LQJZDOW�%5�=LPPHUPDQ�5��HGV����(YDOXDWLQJ�VFKRRO�OLQNHG�SUHYHQWLRQ�VWUDWHJLHV��DOFRKRO��WREDFFR��DQG�RWKHU�GUXJV�6DQ�'LHJR��&$��8&6'�([WHQVLRQ��8QLYHUVLW\�RI�&DOLIRUQLD��������SS��������

Page 149: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW�������������±�GHHO�%� SDJ������YDQ����

7ROOHWW�-+��7KRPDV�63��$�WKHRU\�EDVHG�QXUVLQJ�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�WR�LQVWLOO�KRSH�LQ�KRPHOHVV�YHWHUDQV��$GY�1XUV�6FL���������������7RVHODQG�5:��/RQJ�WHUP�HIIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�SHHU�OHG�DQG�SURIHVVLRQDOO\�OHG�VXSSRUW�JURXSV�IRU�FDUHJLYHUV��6RF6HUY�5HY�����D��������������7RVHODQG�5:��5RVVLWHU�&0��/DEUHFTXH�06��7KH�HIIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�SHHU�OHG�DQG�SURIHVVLRQDOO\�OHG�JURXSV�WRVXSSRUW�IDPLO\�FDUHJLYHUV��*HURQWRORJLVW�����D��������������7RVHODQG�5:��5RVVLWHU�&0��/DEUHFTXH�06��7KH�HIIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�WKUHH�JURXS�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�VWUDWHJLHV�WR�VXSSRUWIDPLO\�FDUHJLYHUV��$P�-�2UWKRSV\FKLDW�����E��������������7RVHODQG�5:��5RVVLWHU�&0��/DEUHFTXH�06��7KH�HIIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�WZR�NLQGV�RI�VXSSRUW�JURXSV�IRU�FDUHJLYHUV�6RF�6HUY�5HY�����F��������������7RVHODQG�5:��6PLWK�*&��(IIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�LQGLYLGXDO�FRXQVHOLQJ�E\�SURIHVVLRQDO�DQG�SHHU�KHOSHUV�IRU�IDPLO\FDUHJLYHUV�RI�WKH�HOGHUO\��3V\FKRO�$JLQJ�����E�������������7UHPEOD\�5H��0F&RUG�-��%LROHDX�+�HW�DO��&DQ�GLVUXSWLYH�ER\V�KHOSHG�WR�EHFRPH�FRPSHWHQW"�3V\FKLDWU\�����������������7UHPEOD\�5(��9LWDUR�)��%HUWUDQG�/�HW�DO��3DUHQW�DQG�FKLOG�WUDLQLQJ�WR�SUHYHQW�HDUO\�RQVHW�RI�GHOLQTXHQF\��7KH0RQWUHDO�/RQJLWXGLQDO�([SHULPHQWDO�6WXG\��,Q��0F&RUG�-��7UHPEOD\�5(��HGV����3UHYHQWLQJ�DQWLVRFLDOEHKDYLRU��,QWHUYHQWLRQV�IURP�ELUWK�WKURXJK�DGROHVFHQFH��1HZ�<RUN�1<��*XLOIRUG�3UHVV�������SS��������7XGLYHU�)��+LOGLWFK�-��3HUPDXO�-$��0F.HQGUHH�'-��'RHV�PXWXDO�KHOS�IDFLOLWDWH�QHZO\�EHUHDYHG�ZLGRZHUV��UHSRUWRI�D�UDQGRPL]HG�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO��(YDO�+HDOWK�3URI�����������������9DJOXP�3��(DUOLHU�GHWHFWLRQ�DQG�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�LQ�VFKL]RSKUHQLD��6FKL]RSKUHQLD�%XOO������������������9LQRNXU�$'��3ULFH�5+��,PSDFW�RI�WKH�-2%6�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�RQ�XQHPSOR\HG�ZRUNHUV�YDU\LQJ�LQ�ULVN�IRU�GHSUHVVLRQ�$P�-�&RPPXQ�3V\FKRO�����������������:DUZLFN�+0&��&ODUN�'0��&REE�$0��6DONRYVNLV�30��$�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO�RI�FRJQLWLYH�EHKDYLRUDO�WUHDWPHQW�RI

K\SRFKRQGULDVLV��%ULW�-�3V\FKLDW�������������������:HEVWHU�6WUDWWRQ�&��+DPPRQG�0��7UHDWLQJ�FKLOGUHQ�ZLWK�HDUO\�RQVHW�FRQGXFW�SUREOHPV��D�FRPSDULVRQ�RI�FKLOGDQG�SDUHQW�WUDLQLQJ�LQWHUYHQWLRQV��-�&RQVXO�&OLQ�3V\FKRO�����������������:HEVWHU�6WUDWWRQ�&��.ROSDFRII�0��+ROOLQVZRUWK�7��6HOI�DGPLQLVWHUHG�YLGHRWDSH�WKHUDS\�IRU�IDPLOLHV�ZLWKFRQGXFW�SUREOHP�FKLOGUHQ��&RPSDULVRQ�ZLWK�WZR�FRVW�HIIHFWLYH�WUHDWPHQWV�DQG�D�FRQWURO�JURXS��-�&RQVXO&OLQ�3V\FKRO������������������:HVVHO\�6��5RVH�6��%LVVRQ�-��$�V\VWHPDWLF�UHYLHZ�RI�EULHI�SV\FKRORJLFDO�LQWHUYHQWLRQV���GHEULHILQJ���IRU�WKH

WUHDWPHQW�RI�LPPHGLDWH�WUDXPD�UHODWHG�V\PSWRPV�DQG�WKH�SUHYHQWLRQ�RI�SRVW�WUDXPDWLF�GLVRUGHU�&RFKUDQH�UHYLHZ���,Q��7KH�&RFKUDQH�/LEUDU\��2[IRUG��8SGDWH�6RIWZDUH��,VVXH���������

:LON�$,��-HQVHQ�10��+DYLJKXUVW�7&��0HWD�DQDO\VLV�RI�UDQGRPL]HG�FRQWURO�WULDOV�DGGUHVVLQJ�EULHI�LQWHUYHQWLRQVLQ�KHDY\�DOFRKRO�GULQNHUV��-�*HQ�,QWHUQ�0HG�������������������

:ROI�)0��0HWD�DQDO\VLV��TXDQWLWDWLYH�PHWKRGV�IRU�UHVHDUFK�V\QWKHVLV��%HYHUO\�+LOOV��6DJH�3XEOLFDWLRQV�������;LRQJ�:��3KLOOLSV�05��+X�;��:DQJ�5��'DL�4��.OHLQPDQ�-��.OHLQPDQ�$��)DPLO\�EDVHG�LQWHUYHQWLRQ�IRUVFKL]RSKUHQLF�SDWLHQWV�LQ�&KLQD��D�UDQGRPLVHG�FRQWUROOHG�WULDO��%ULW�-�3V\FKLDW�������������������<XQJ�$5��0F*RUU\�3'��0RQLWRULQJ�DQG�FDUH�RI�\RXQJ�SHRSOH�DW�LQFLSLHQW�ULVN�RI�SV\FKRVLV��6FKL]RSKUHQLD�%XOO������������������

=DULW�6+��$QWKRQ\�&5��%RXWHOLV�0��,QWHUYHQWLRQV�ZLWK�FDUHJLYHUV�RI�GHPHQWLD�SDWLHQWV��FRPSDULVRQ�RI�WZRDSSURDFKHV��3V\FKRO�$JLQJ������������������

=KDQJ�0��+HTLQ�<��&KHQJGH�<�HW�DO�(IIHFWLYHQHVV�RI�SV\FKRHGXFDWLRQ�RI�UHODWLYHV�RI�VFKL]RSKUHQLF�SDWLHQWV��$SURVSHFWLYH�FRKRUW�VWXG\�LQ�ILYH�FLWLHV�RI�&KLQD��,QW�-�0HQW�+HDOWK�����������������=LVRRN�6��6KXFKWHU�65��'HSUHVVLRQ�WKURXJK�WKH�ILUVW�\HDU�DIWHU�WKH�GHDWK�RI�D�VSRXVH��$P�-�3V\FKLDW���������������������

Page 150: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� 5,90�UDSSRUW�������������ELMODJHQ

'DQNEHWXLJLQJ(HQ�JURRW�DDQWDO�SHUVRQHQ�KHHIW�PHHJHZHUNW�DDQ�KHW�WRWVWDQGNRPHQ�YDQ�GLW�979�UDSSRUW��'HHLQGUHGDNWHXUHQ� ]LMQ� DOOHUHHUVW� GDQN� YHUVFKXOGLJG� DDQ� GH� DXWHXUV� YDQ� GH� 5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW*URQLQJHQ� �GH� KHUHQ� 1HHOHPDQ�� 2UPHO� HQ� :LHUVPD�� HQ� KHW� 7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW� �PHYURXZ2YHUWRRP�HQ�GH�KHUHQ�&XLMSHUV�HQ�YDQ�*DJHOGRQN��GLH�PHW�YHHO�LQ]HW�KHEEHQ�JHZHUNW�DDQ�GHDFKWHUJURQGUDSSRUWDJHV�±�GHHO�%��HQ�%��YDQ�GLW�UDSSRUW��]LH�ELMODJH����'DDUQDDVW�LV�HHQ�DDQWDO�H[SHUWV�XLW�KHW�YHOG�EHUHLG�JHYRQGHQ�RQGHUGHOHQ�YDQ�KHW�UDSSRUWWH�EHFRPPHQWDULsUHQ��PHYURXZ�GH�5LGGHU�YDQ�GH�8QLYHUVLWHLW�8WUHFKW��GH�KHHU�%HHNPDQ�YDQGH�9ULMH�8QLYHUVLWHLW�$PVWHUGDP�HQ�GH�KHHU�GH�+DHV��DINRPVWLJ�YDQ�GH�**'�5RWWHUGDP��]LHELMODJH�����2RN�]LM�ZRUGHQ�EHGDQNW�YRRU�KXQ�FRQVWUXFWLHYH�ELMGUDJH�DDQ�KHW�UDSSRUW�7HQVORWWH� KHHIW� HHQ� DDQWDO� SHUVRQHQ� ELQQHQ� KHW� 5,90� RQGHUGHOHQ� YDQ� KHW� UDSSRUWEHRRUGHHOG��GH�KHHU�5XZDDUG��GH�KHHU�9DQ�2HUV��GH�KHHU�6WRN[��GH�KHHU�*LMVHQ��GH�KHHU�YDQGHU� /XFKW�� PHYURXZ� YDQ� /HHQW� HQ� PHYURXZ� 7LMKXLV�� 2RN� ]LM� ZRUGHQ� EHGDQNW� YRRU� KXQRSERXZHQGH�FRPPHQWDDU�RS�GLW�UDSSRUW�

Page 151: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW�������������±�ELMODJHQ SDJ������YDQ����

%LMODJH�� 9HU]HQGOLMVW1. Dr HJ Schneider, 'LUHFWHXU�*HQHUDDO�9RONVJH]RQGKHLG��0LQLVWHULH�YDQ9RONVJH]RQGKHLG��:HO]LMQ�HQ�6SRUW2. Drs NC Oudendijk, plv Directeur-Generaal�9RONVJH]RQGKHLG��0LQLVWHULH�YDQ9RONVJH]RQGKHLG��:HO]LMQ�HQ�6SRUW3. Drs AAW Kalis, 'LUHFWLH�*H]RQGKHLGVEHOHLG��*=%���0LQLVWHULH�YDQ9RONVJH]RQGKHLG��:HO]LMQ�HQ�6SRUW�� 'KU�-&�.DDVMDJHU��DUWV��'LUHFWLH�*HHVWHOLMNH�*H]RQGKHLGV]RUJ��9HUVODYLQJV]RUJ�HQ0DDWVFKDSSHOLMNH�RSYDQJ��0LQLVWHULH�YDQ�9RONVJH]RQGKHLG��:HO]LMQ�HQ�6SRUW5. Prof dr JJ Sixma,Voorzitter van de Gezondheidsraad6. Drs RJ Beuse, Instituut GGD Nederland, Utrecht�� 'U�)+5�/HHQGHUV��**=�1HGHUODQG��8WUHFKW�� 3URI�GU�+�5LJWHU��7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW��8WUHFKW�� 'U�3�&XLMSHUV��7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW��8WUHFKW��� 'U�$�YDQ�*DJHOGRQN��7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW��8WUHFKW11. 'U -�1HHOHPDQ��Rijksuniversiteit Groningen��� 3URI�GU�-�2UPHO��5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW�*URQLQJHQ��� 0Z�GU�&&(�2YHUWRRP��7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW��8WUHFKW��� 'U�'�:LHUVPD��5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW�*URQLQJHQ��� 0Z�GU�'�GH�5LGGHU��8QLYHUVLWHLW�8WUHFKW��� 'U�$7)�%HHNPDQ��9ULMH�8QLYHUVLWHLW�$PVWHUGDP17. Dr WFM de Haes, GGD Rotterdam18. Depot Nederlandse Publikaties en Nederlandse Bibliografie,19. Directie RIVM20. Prof dr ir D Kromhout21. Prof dr ir JC Seidell22. Dr D Ruwaard23. Dr PGN Kramers24. Dr JAM van Oers25. Mw dr HF Treurniet26. Drs A van der Veen27. Ing WJJ Vrijsen28. Drs LJ Stokx29. Drs R Gijsen30. Dr F van der Lucht31. Mw ir HMJA van Loenen32. Mw ir SI Rutz33. Mw K Witte��� 0Z�GU�0$5�7LMKXLV��� ,U�-�-DQVHQ��� ,U�,$0�0DDV��712�3UHYHQWLH�HQ�*H]RQGKHLG��/HLGHQ37. SBD/Voorlichting & Public Relations38. Bureau Rapportenregistratie39. Bibliotheek RIVM40-55 Bureau Rapportenbeheer55-90 Reserve exemplaren

Page 152: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� 5,90�UDSSRUW�������������ELMODJHQ

%LMODJH�� /LMVW�YDQ�DXWHXUV�HQ�UHIHUHQWHQ

$XWHXUV'U��3��&XLMSHUV7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW��8WUHFKW'U��$��YDQ�*DJHOGRQN7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW��8WUHFKW,U��-��-DQVHQ5,90��&HQWUXP�979,U��,�$�0��0DDV5,90��&HQWUXP�979��WRW������������PRPHQWHHO�ZHUN]DDP�ELM�712�3UHYHQWLH�HQ�*H]RQGKHLG�'U��-��1HHOHPDQ'LVFLSOLQHJURHS�3V\FKLDWULH��5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW�*URQLQJHQ3URI��GU��-��2UPHO'LVFLSOLQHJURHS�3V\FKLDWULH��5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW�*URQLQJHQ0Z��GU��&�&�(��2YHUWRRP7ULPERV�LQVWLWXXW��8WUHFKW'U��'��:LHUVPD'LVFLSOLQHJURHS�3V\FKLDWULH��5LMNVXQLYHUVLWHLW�*URQLQJHQ

5HIHUHQWHQ0Z��GU��'��GH�5LGGHU9DNJURHS�.OLQLVFKH�HQ�*H]RQGKHLGVS\FKRORJLH��8QLYHUVLWHLW�8WUHFKW'U��$�7�)��%HHNPDQ9DNJURHS�3V\FKLDWULH��9ULMH�8QLYHUVLWHLW�$PVWHUGDP'U��:�)�0��GH�+DHV**'�5RWWHUGDP

Page 153: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

5,90�UDSSRUW�������������±�ELMODJHQ SDJ������YDQ����

%LMODJH�� $INRUWLQJHQ�HQ�GHILQLWLHV$INRUWLQJHQ$3= $OJHPHHQ�3V\FKLDWULVFK�=LHNHQKXLV$'+' $WWHQWLRQ�'HILFLW�+\SHUDFWLYH�'LVRUGHU&$' &HQWUXP�YRRU�$OFRKRO��HQ�'UXJKXOSYHUOHQLQJ'60 'LDJQRVWLF�DQG�6WDWLVWLFDO�PDQXDO�RI�0HQWDO�GLVRUGHUV,56 ,QIODPPDWRLUH�5HVSRQV�6\VWHHP1(0(6,6 1HWKHUODQGV�0HQWDO�+HDOWK�6XUYH\�HQ�,QFLGHQFH�6WXG\2&6 2EVHVVLHI�&RPSXOVLHYH�6WRRUQLV2**= 2SHQEDUH�*HHVWHOLMNH�*H]RQGKHLGV]RUJ3$$= 3V\FKLDWULVFKH�$IGHOLQJ�YDQ�HHQ�$OJHPHHQ�=LHNHQKXLV3766 3RVWWUDXPDWLVFKH�6WUHVV�6\QGURRP

'HILQLWLHV&%&/�VFRUH� DDQWDO�QHJDWLHYH�LWHPV�RS�GH�&KLOG�%HKDYLRUDO�&KHFNOLVW��HHQYUDJHQOLMVW� QDDU� JHGUDJVSUREOHPHQ� YRRU� NLQGHUHQ� YDQ� ����MDDU�&LUFDGLDDQ�ULWPH�� YDULDWLH�LQ�HHQ�GH�ZDDUGHQ�YDQ�HHQ�YDULDEHOH�RYHU�HHQ�HWPDDO����XXU��&RPRUELGLWHLW�� KHW� YRRUNRPHQ� YDQ� WZHH� VWRRUQLVVHQ� ELM� HHQ� SHUVRRQ�� 1LHWQRRG]DNHOLMNHUZLMV� WHJHOLMNHUWLMG�� LQ� HHQ� OHYHQ� LVOHYHQVFRPRUELGLWHLW��LQ�HHQ�MDDU�LV����PDDQGV�FRPRUELGLWHLW�&RKRUW�� HHQ� JURHS� SHUVRQHQ� GLH� RS� EDVLV� YDQ� HHQ� EHSDDOGHNDUDNWHULVWLHN� LV� VDPHQJHVWHOG�HQ�GLH� LQ�GH� ORRS�YDQ�GH� WLMGZRUGW�JHYROJG�&RQFRUGDQWLH�� KHW� SHUFHQWDJH� WZHHOLQJSDUHQ� ZDDUELM� GH� IDFWRU� �KLHUGHSUHVVLH�� ELM� WZHHOLQJHQ� YDQ� HHQ� SDDU� YRRUNRPW� RI� LVYRRUJHNRPHQ&RQFRUGDQWLH�UDWLR�� GH� YHUKRXGLQJ� WXVVHQ� KHW� ERYHQJHQRHPG� SHUFHQWDJH� LQPRQR]\JRWH�YHUVXV�GL]\JRWH�WZHHOLQJHQ�'60�,,,�,9�� 'LDJQRVWLF� DQG� 6WDWLVWLF� 0DQXDO�� YHUVLH� ,,,�,9�&ODVVLILFDWLHV\VWHHP�YRRU�SV\FKLVFKH�VWRRUQLVVHQ�*+4�VFRUH�� VRP� YDQ� KHW� DDQWDO� QHJDWLHYH� VFRUHV� RS� GH� *HQHUDO� +HDOWK4XHVWLRQQDLU�� HHQ� JHQHULHNH� YUDJHQOLMVW� QDDU� SV\FKLVFKHRQJH]RQGKHLG�+3$�DV�� K\SRWKDODPXV�K\SRI\VH�ELMQLHU�DV

Page 154: RIVM rapport xxxxxx xxx · 5,90udssruw ˆ ˘˘˘ ghho$ sdj ydq ˘ 9ronvjh]rqgkhlg 7rhnrpvw9hunhqqlqj 3v\fklvfkh rq jh]rqgkhlg˛gh whuplqdqwhqhqg hh iihfwhqydqsuhyhqwlhyh

SDJ������YDQ���� 5,90�UDSSRUW�������������ELMODJHQ

,QFLGHQWLH�� DDQWDO� QLHXZH� JHYDOOHQ� YDQ� RI� SHUVRQHQ� PHW� HHQ� EHSDDOGH]LHNWH�LQ�HHQ�EHSDDOGH�SHULRGH�,QWHUSHUVRRQOLMNH�VHQVLWLYLWHLW�� HHQ�YHUKRRJGH�SHUFHSWLH�YDQ�HQ�JHYRHOLJKHLG�YRRU�QHJDWLHYHVLJQDOHQ�YDQ�DQGHUHQ�WHQ�DDQ]LHQ�YDQ�GH�HLJHQ�ZDDUGH�2GGV�UDWLR��25��� GH� UDWLR� EORRWJHVWHOGHQ�QLHW� EORRWJHVWHOGHQ� ELM� SDWLsQWHQ�YHUJHOHNHQ�PHW�GLH�ELM�FRQWU{OHSHUVRQHQ�3UHYDOHQWLH�� DDQWDO�JHYDOOHQ�RI�SHUVRQHQ�PHW�HHQ�EHSDDOGH�]LHNWH�RS�HHQEHSDDOG�PRPHQW��SXQWSUYDOHQWLH��RI�LQ�HHQ�EHSDDOGH�SHULRGH�PDDQGSUHYDOHQWLH�RI�OHYHQVSUHYDOHQWLH��36(�VFRUH�� VRP� YDQ� GH� QHJDWLHI� JHVFRRUGH� LWHPV� RS� GH� 3UHVHQW� 6WDWH([DPLQDWLRQ�� HHQ� JHQHULHNH� YUDJHQOLMVW� QDDU� SV\FKLVFKHRQJH]RQGKHLG�5HODWLHI�ULVLFR��55��� GH� YHUKRXGLQJ� YDQ� KHW� ULVLFR� RS� HHQ� DDQGRHQLQJ� ELMDDQZH]LJKHLG�YDQ�HHQ�ULVLFRIDFWRU�WHQ�RS]LFKWH�YDQ�SHUVRQHQ]RQGHU�GH]H�IDFWRU�5HFLGLHI�ULVLFR�� NDQV�RS�KHUKDDOG�RSWUHGHQ�YDQ�HHQ�VWRRUQLV�9RRUVSHOOHQGH�ZDDUGH�� GH�]HNHUKHLG�ZDDUPHH�PHQ�XLWVSUDNHQ�NDQ�GRHQ�RYHU�GH�DDQ�RI� DIZH]LJKHLG� YDQ� HHQ� ]LHNWH� �RI� GH� NDQV� GDDURS� LQ� QDELMHWRHNRPVW�� ELM� SHUVRQHQ� LQ� GH� SRSXODWLH�� QDGDW� GH]H� HHQ� WHVWKHEEHQ�RQGHUJDDQ�RI�ZDQQHHU� HHQ�EHSDDOGH�GHWHUPLQDQW�ELMGH]H�SHUVRQHQ�DDQZH]LJ�LV�9HUORUHQ�OHYHQVMDUHQ�� DDQWDO�MDUHQ�GDW�SHUVRQHQ�GLH�]LMQ�RYHUOHGHQ�WHQ�JHYROJH�YDQHHQ�DDQGRHQLQJ�QRJ�JHOHHIG�]RXGHQ�KHEEHQ�ELM�DIZH]LJKHLGYDQ� GH� DDQGRHQLQJ�� WHQ� RS]LFKWH� YDQ� HHQ� JHNR]HQERYHQJUHQV��ELMYRRUEHHOG�GH�UHVWHUHQGH�OHYHQVYHUZDFKWLQJ��