Roscoe Pound & Friedrich Karl Von Savigny Mempengaruhi Politik Hukum Di Indonesia_II_Agung Yuriandi

8/9/2019 Roscoe Pound & Friedrich Karl Von Savigny Mempengaruhi Politik Hukum Di Indonesia_II_Agung Yuriandi

1/45

RE[KEG PEWOM ! ARCGMRCKD HJRI QEO [JQCFOS

LGLPGOFJRWDC PEIC]CH DWHWL MC COMEOG[CJ

Eigd >

JFWOF SWRCJOMC

[gheijd Pj{kj [jrnjoj Woqgr{c}j{ [wlj}grj W}jrj

Bcmjof [}wmc Ljfc{}gr Cilw Dwhwl

Lgmjo

2004

BJB C

PGOMJDWIWJO

:/ Ij}jr Bgijhjof

Peic}ch jmjijd pre{g{ pglbgo}whjo mjo pglbjfcjo hghwj{jjo

mjijl lj{sjrjhj} sjof jo}jrj ijco bgrvwnwm pre{g{ pglbwj}jo

hgpw}w{jo) hdw{w{osj mjijl ogfjrj/: Mwocj peic}ch }cmjh }grigpj{ mjrc

hghwj{jjo mjo vgvgojof pgofwj{j/

Lgowrw} K/ A/ [}reof) peic}ch dwhwl jmjijd cilw sjof lglpgijnjrc

}go}jof ogfjrj/ Ogfjrj lgrwpjhjo erfjoc{j{c hghwj{jjo hjrgoj mc

mjijl ogfjrj {gijiw hc}j nwlpjc pw{j},pw{j} hghwj{jjo) bjch mjijl

{wprj{}rwh}wr $}grngilj mjijl iglbjfj peic}ch mjo iglbjfj ogfjrj# mjo

coarj{}rwh}wr sjof lgicpw}c2 >

, Pjr}jc peic}ch8

: Vchcpgmcj/ Peic}ch/vvv/vchcpgmcj/erf%vchc%peic}ch/ 2004/2

[j}sj Jrcojo}e/ Hwlpwijo Lj}grc Hwicjd Peic}ch Dwhwl/ Prefrjl Pj{kj [jrnjojAjhwi}j{ Dwhwl Wocqgr{c}j{ Comeog{cj/ 2002/ d/ :/

:
http://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/politik.%202008http://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/politik.%202008http://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/politik.%202008


2/45

Pjr}jc peic}ch jmjijd erfjoc{j{c peic}ch sjof lgonjijoc cmgeiefc

}gr}go}w j}jw mcbgo}wh mgofjo }wnwjo hdw{w{/;

, Feieofjo hgpgo}cofjo8

Feieofjo hgpgo}cofjo jmjijd {ghgielpeh ljow{cj sjof bgr{j}w

j}jw lgofjmjhjo pgr{ghw}wjo hjrgoj jmjosj hgpgo}cofjo,

hgpgo}cofjo }gr}go}w bjch lgrwpjhjo hgpgo}cofjo wlwl j}jw

lj{sjrjhj} wlwl/=

, Feieofjo pgoghjo8

Feieofjo pgoghjo jmjijd {ghgielpeh ljow{cj sjof bgrfjbwof

lgonjmc {j}w joffe}j {wj}w iglbjfj hglj{sjrjhj}jo mgofjo

jh}cqc}j{ sjof }jlpjh hg iwjr {gbjfjc feieofjo sjof {grcof

lglpwosjc hgcofcojo wo}wh lgljh{jhjo hgpjmj pcdjh

pgofwj{j/7

, Jij} helwochj{c peic}ch8 mjo

Jij} helwochj{c peic}ch jmjijd lgmcj helwochj{c) helwochj{c

heo}jh ijof{wof) njrcofjo,njrcofjo coarj{}rwh}wr/1

, ]ehed peic}ch/

]ehed peic}ch jmjijd erjof,erjof sjof }gricbj} mjijl mwocj peic}ch

c}w {gomcrc) igbcd hgpjmj sjof }gricbj} hgpjmj {wj}w ogfjrj mjijl

dji pgosgigoffjrjjoosj/

; Vchcpgmcj/ Pjr}jc Peic}ch/ vvv/vchcpgmcj/erf%vchc%pjr}jcUpeic}ch/ 2004/= R/ Dg{}w Kcp}e Djomese mjo ]drg{cjo}c/ Feieofjo Hgpgo}cofjo% Co}grg{} Frewp/

d}}p>%%vvv/hjlw{dwhwl/kel%hjlw{dwhwlUgo}rcg{/pdp5Ufeieofjo'20hgpgo}cofjo'20%'20co}grg{}'20frewpU!cmgo}


3/45

Lgowrw} Ljdawm) peic}ch dwhwl jmjijd igfji peickssjof jhjo j}jw

}gijd mcijh{jojhjo {gkjrj oj{ceoji eigd Pglgrco}jd Comeog{cj sjof

lgicpw}c6 >

, Pgr}jlj) pglbjofwojo dwhwl sjof bgrco}chjo pglbwj}jo mjo

pglbjrwjo }grdjmjp lj}grc,lj}grc dwhwl jfjr mjpj} {g{wjc

mgofjo hgbw}wdjo8 mjo

, Hgmwj) pgijh{jojjo hg}go}wjo dwhwl sjof }gijd jmj }grlj{wh

pgogfj{jo awof{c,awof{c iglbjfj mjo pglbcojjo pjrj pgogfjh

dwhwl/

Mjrc hgmwj pgofgr}cjo }gr{gbw} }gricdj} bjdvj peic}ch dwhwl

lgokjhwp pre{g{ pglbwj}jo mjo pgijh{jojjo dwhwl sjof mjpj}

lgowonwhhjo {caj} mjo hg jrjd ljoj dwhwl jhjo mcbjofwo mjo

mc}gfjhhjo/4

Peic}ch mjo dwhwl {jofj} bgrdwbwofjo hjrgoj jmj co}grqgo{c

peic}ch }grdjmjp dwhwl) peic}ch hgrjphjic lgijhwhjo co}grqgo{c }grdjmjp

pglbgo}whjo mjo pgijh{jojjo dwhwl/3 Dwhwl mjijl jr}c pgrj}wrjo

lgrwpjhjo hrc{}jic{j{c mjrc hgdgomjh,hgdgomjh peic}ch sjof {jicof

bgrco}grjh{c mjo bgr{jcofjo/:0

Bgrbckjrj }go}jof peic}ch dwhwl) nchj mcicdj} jpj sjof mchj}jhjo

Re{keg Pewom dwhwl c}w bgrj{ji mjrc pglgrco}jd {gijonw}osj mcnjijohjo

6 Jfw{}cjo}e/ Peic}ch Dwhwl mjijl Gheoelc [sjrcjd/ d}}p>%%hj{gc,worc/erf%comgt/pdp5ep}ceo


4/45

eigd lj{sjrjhj}/ Bgrbgmj mgofjo Kjri qeo [jqcfos sjof lgofj}jhjo

bjdvj dwhwl c}w bgrj{ji mjrc ncvj lj{sjrjhj} $qeih{fgc{}#/::

2/ Pgrwlw{jo Lj{jijd

Mjijl {wj}w pgowic{jo ljhjijd) sjof pgriw mcpgrdj}chjo jmjijd

jpj sjof lgonjmc lj{jijd peheh pjmj pgowic{jo }gr{gbw}/ Bgrmj{jrhjo

wrjcjo sjof {cofhj} mc j}j{ ljhj pgowic{ mjpj} lgrwlw{hjo lj{jijd

{gbjfjc bgrchw} >

:/ Bjfjcljoj dwbwofjo jo}jrj dwhwl mjo peic}ch5

2/ Bjfjcljoj dwhwl c}w lgowrw} Re{keg Pewom ! Kjri qeo [jqcfos

nchj bgrbckjrj lgofgojc pglbwj}jo dwhwl mjo awof{c dwhwl

mjijl heo}gh{ peic}ch dwhwl5

;/ Bjfjcljoj pgrbjomcofjo }gerc dwhwl Re{keg Pewom mjo

Arcgmrckd Hjri qeo [jqcfos5

=/ ]gerc jpjhjd sjof mcfwojhjo mjijl pglbgo}whjo dwhwl mc

Comeog{cj5

BJB CC

DWBWOFJO PEIC]CH MJO DWHWL

::

Bc{ljr Oj{w}ceo/ Kj}j}jo Pgrhwicjdjo Peic}ch Dwhwl/ [gheijd Pj{kj [jrnjojWocqgr{c}j{ [wlj}grj W}jrj/ 2004/

=


5/45

Dwhwl lgrwpjhjo qjrcjbgi }grpgofjrwd {gmjofhjo peic}ch

lgrwpjhjo qjrcjbgi bgrpgofjrwd/:2 Dwhwl }gr}wic{ lglpwosjc hjc}jo

ijof{wof mgofjo ogfjrj/

Igfc}clj{c dwhwl lgijiwc hghwj{jjo peic}ch) {jijd {j}wosj

}grvwnwm mjijl pglbgrcjo {joh{c bjfc pgijoffjr dwhwl/ Dwhwl

mc}gfjhhjo eigd hghwj{jjo peic}ch lgijiwc jij},jij} peic}ch) lgijiwc jij},jij}

peic}ch ijco {gpgr}c peic{c) pgowo}w} wlwl) mjo pgofjmcijo/ Djrw{ mccofj}

bjdvj {g}gijd dwhwl lglpgreigd hghwj{jjo mjrc hghwj{jjo peic}ch }jmc)

dwhwl nwfj lgosjiwrhjo hghwj{jjo c}w pjmj lj{sjrjhj}osj/:;

Dwhwl jmjijd pgrco}jd mjrc pgofwj{j) mjijl jr}c pgrco}jd mjrc

lgrghj sjof lglcichc hghwj{jjo }gr}coffc j}jw sjof lglgfjof

hgmjwij}jo) {gpgr}c sjof mchj}jhjo Nedo Jw{}co/:=

Dwhwl mjo peic}ch lgrwpjhjo {wb{c{}gl mjijl {c{}gl

hglj{sjrjhj}jo/ Lj{cof,lj{cof lgijh{jojhjo awof{c }gr}go}w wo}wh

lgoffgrjhhjo {c{}gl hglj{sjrjhj}jo {gkjrj hg{giwrwdjo/ [gkjrj fjrc{

bg{jr dwhwl bgrawof{c lgijhwhjo {ekcji keo}rei:7) mc{pw}g {g}}iglgo}:1)

mjo {ekcji gofcoggrcof:6) j}jw coeqj}ceo/ [gmjofhjo awof{c peic}ch lgicpw}c

pglgicdjrjjo {c{}gl mjo jmjp}j{c ${ekcjic~j}ceo mjo rgkrwc}lgo}#)

heoqgr{c $rwig ljhcof) rwig jpickj}ceo) rwig jmnwmckj}ceo)

:2 [j}sj Jrcojo}e/ Ep/ kc}/ d/ 7/:; NN/ Jl{}reof [glbcrcof/ Dwbwofjo Jo}jrj Dwhwl mjo Peic}ch/

d}}p>%%frgj{s/kel%helpjr}j%dwbwofjoUjo}jrjUdwhwlUmjo/d}li/ 2004/:= Djlmjo ^egiqj/ Dwhwl mjo Peic}ch mjijl [c{}gl Dwhwl Comeog{cj/

vvv/djlmjo~egiqj/vermprg{{/kel / 2004/:7 [ekcji Keo}reijmjijd {c{}gl pgofgomjicjo {e{cji mjijl pgrkjhjpjo {gdjrc,djrc

mcjr}chjo {gbjfjc pgofjvj{jo eigd lj{sjrjhj} }grdjmjp njijoosjpglgrco}jdjo) hdw{w{osj pglgrco}jd bg{gr}j jpjrj}osj/ [eaj/ Heo}rei [e{cji/vvv/lj{{eaj/vermprg{{/kel/ 2004/

:1 Mc{pw}g [g}}iglgo}jmjijd pgosgig{jcjo {gofhg}j/:6

[ekcji Gofcoggrcof jmjijd rghjsj{j {e{cji/ Pgr}jlj hjic mckg}w{hjo eigdRe{keg Pewom }go}jof hgfwojjo dwhwl/

7
http://greasy.com/komparta/hubungan_antara_hukum_dan.html.%202008http://www.hamdanzoelva.wordpress.com/http://www.massofa.wordpress.com/http://greasy.com/komparta/hubungan_antara_hukum_dan.html.%202008http://www.hamdanzoelva.wordpress.com/http://www.massofa.wordpress.com/


6/45

co}grg{}jr}ckwij}ceo) mjo jffrgfj}ceo# mjo awof{c hjpjbcic}j{ $rgfwij}ca

gt}rjk}ca) mc{}rcbw}ca) mjo rg{peo{ca#/:4

Pgrmgbj}jo lgofgojc dwbwofjo dwhwl mjo peic}ch lglcichc jhjr

{gnjrjd pjonjof mjijl cilw dwhwl/ Bjfc hjijofjo pgofjow} jicrjo

pe{c}cqc{lg dwhwl {gpgr}c Nedo Jw{}co) dwhwl jmjijd }cmjh ijco mjrc

premwh peic}ch j}jw hghwj{jjo/ Pjmj {c{c ijco) pjomjofjo bgrbgmj mj}jof

mjrc hjijofjo jicrjo {gnjrjd mjijl cilw dwhwl) sjof lgicdj} dwhwl }cmjh

mjrc meflj}chj dwhwl mjo womjof,womjof {glj}j) jhjo }g}jpc mjrc

hgosj}jjo,hgosj}jjo {e{cji sjof jmj mjijl lj{sjrjhj} mjo {g}cjp

hgielpeh lgokcp}jhjo dwhwl sjof dcmwp/:3

J/ Jicrjo Pe{c}cqc{lg

Jnjrjo pe{c}cqc{lg dwhwl jmjijd lgofgojc hgsjhcojo) dwhwl

sjof jmj) dwhwl sjof bgrijhw {jj} coc) pjmj {jj} }gr}go}w mjo pjmj

}glpj} }gr}go}w/

Lgowrw} Jwfw{}g Kel}g {jijd {gerjof pgig}jh mj{jr aci{jaj}

pe{c}cqc{lg lglwokwihjo meh}rco bjdvj pgofjijljoijd sjof mcjoffjp

bgojr) hjrgoj mjpj} mcpj{}chjo $mc{gicmchc# mjijl hgosj}jjo lgijiwc cilw

pgofg}jdwjo) {gdcoffj mjpj} mc}go}whjo bjdvj {g{wj}w c}w jmjijd

{g{wjc hgosj}jjo $hgbgojrjo#/

Pjmj ~jljo ermg bjrw dwhwl mcfwojhjo wo}wh lgonjfj

hgpgo}cofjo prcbjmc hghwj{jjo prg{cmgo mjo feieofjo }cmjh pgmwic

jpjhjd c}w bgojr j}jw {jijdosj lerji mc mjijl womjof,womjofosj/

:4 Ehj Ljdgomrj/ Dwhwl mjo Peic}ch/

d}}p>%%vvv/fgekc}cg{/kel%RjcoAerg{}%Qcog{%;;16%ehj/d}li/ 2004/:3 Djlmjo ^egiqj/ Iek/ kc}/

1
http://www.geocities.com/RainForest/Vines/3367/oka.html.%202008http://www.geocities.com/RainForest/Vines/3367/oka.html.%202008http://www.geocities.com/RainForest/Vines/3367/oka.html.%202008


7/45

]g}jpc {gkjrj cmgjiosj lgowrw} }gerc coc) dji }gr{gbw} mc j}j{ }cmjh

beigd mcijhwhjo hjrgoj dwhwl c}w lgofjomwof joj{cr,joj{cr mjo

}grbgo}whosj dwhwl djrw{ bgrmj{jrhjo iefchj,iefchj dwhwl wo}wh

lglbwj} hjgmjd,hjgmjd $kie{gm iefckji {s{}gl#/ Dwhwl }grbgo}wh

djosj bgrmj{jrhjo iefchj dwhwl sjof }grigpj{ mjrc }ghjojo,}ghjojo/

]g}jpc nchj dwhwl }gr{gbw} }cmjh bghgrnj mgofjo bjch ljhj }cmjh jhjo njmc

lj{jijd/ Keo}ed > Mjijl RWW }go}jof premwh oj{ceoji/ Djrw{

lgoffwojhjo premwh mjijl ogfgrc vjijwpwo igbcd ljdji/ C}w }cmjh

lj{wh iefchj ljhj }cmjh beigd {gpgr}c c}w hjrgoj sjof iefchj erjof jhjo

lglbgic bjrjof lwrjd mgofjo hwjic}j{ bjch) bwhjoosj bjrjof ljdji

mgofjo hwjic}j{ ngigh/ Jmj hgpgo}cofjo sjc}w hgpgo}cofjo oj{ceoji/

[gbjb Ijdcrosj Pe{c}cqc{lg Dwhwl

Meh}rco }go}jof dwhwl jijl) hjijw hc}j lgokwrc ljhj djrw{

mcdwhwl/ ]jpc dwhwljoosj jpj) }cmjh jmj pjmj dwhwl jijl njmc sjof

lgofj}wr jmjijd pe{c}cqc{lg dwhwl }gr{gbw}/

Mchjrgojhjo Rjnj bgrbwj} {gvgojof,vgojof ljhj rjhsj} be{jo

mjo lgofcofcohjo {wj}w dwhwl sjof lglbj}j{c Rjnj }gr{gbw})

lwokwiijd jpj sjof mcojljhjo Ljfoj Kjr}j/20

Mwj Jicrjo W}jlj Pe{c}cqc{lg Dwhwl

Nedo Jw{}co $:630,:473#

20 Ljfoj Kjr}j jmjijd pcjfjl Coffrc{ }jdwo :2:7 sjof lglbj}j{c hghwj{jjoLeojrhc Coffrc{) }grw}jlj Rjnj Nedo) mjrc hghwj{jjo jb{eiw}/ Dj{ci mjrchg}cmjh{g}wnwjo jo}jrj Pjw{ mjo Rjnj Nedo mjo bjreoosj j}j{ djh rjnj > LjfojKjr}j lgofdjrw{hjo rjnj wo}wh lglbj}jihjo bgbgrjpj djh mjo lgofdjrfjcbgbgrjpj pre{gmwr igfji) mjo wo}wh lgogrclj bjdvj hgcofcojo rjnj mjpj}mcbj}j{c eigd dwhwl/ Ijofhjd pgr}jlj mjijl pre{g{ {gnjrjd sjof pjonjof

sjof lgownw hg pglbwj}jo dwhwl heo{}c}w{ceoji/ Vchcpgmcj/ Ljfoj Kjr}j/vvv/vchcpgmcj/erf%vchc%ljfojUkjr}j/ 2004/

6
http://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/magna_carta.%202008http://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/magna_carta.%202008


8/45

Ijv c{ j kelljom ea }dg ijv fcqgr$}gerc pgrco}jd bgqgi{}dgers#/

Dwhwl jmjijd pgrco}jd mjrc pgofwj{j sjof lglgfjof hghwj{jjo

}gr}coffc mjo bgrmjwij}/ J}wrjo dwhwl sjof mcbgrijhwhjo mc }gofjd,

}gofjd lj{sjrjhj} jmjijd j}wrjo sjof }gr}wic{ {gbjfjc pgofgnjvjo}jdjo

hgdgomjh mjo hgcofcojo pgofwj{j/ Dwhwl {gbjfjc pgrco}jd sjof

lgljh{j mjijl hgbgrijhwjoosj mjpj} {jnj jmci j}jw {gbjichosj/ Jmci

j}jw }cmjh jmci }cmjh pgo}cof mjijl pgogrjpjo dwhwl) hjrgoj dji }gr{gbw}

lgrwpjhjo hjncjo cilw peic}ch mjo {e{ceiefc/2:

Dwhwl mjrc {gfc {caj}osj mcheo{gp{chjo {gbjfjc {wj}w {c{}gl sjof

bgr{caj} iefc{) }g}jp mjo }gr}w}wp $kie{gm iefckji {s{}gl#/ Heo{gp coc

{gkjrj }gfj{ lglc{jdhjo dwhwl mjo lerji $sjof bgrhjc}jo mgofjo

hgjmcijo#/ Clpiglgo}j{c j}wrjo dwhwl mjijl lj{sjrjhj} }cmjh djrw{

lglpgr}clbjofhjo mjo lgocijc lgofgojc bjch mjo bwrwh) hjrgoj dji

}gr{gbw} bgrjmj mc iwjr hjncjo dwhwl/

Dwhwl sjof bjch {g{woffwdosj jmjijd dwhwl sjof lglwj}

hjcmjd pgrco}jd) ijrjofjo) {joh{c) hgvjncbjo mjo hgmjwij}jo/ ]jopj

hjcmjd }gr{gbw} {gbwjd j}wrjo }cmjh mjpj} mc{gbw} dwhwl }g}jpc djosj

bc{j mchj}jhjo {gbjfjc j}wrjo lerji/

Djo{ Hgi{go $:44:,:36;#

2:

Mjrnc Mjrlemcdjrne/ Peheh,Peheh Aci{jaj} > Jpj mjo Bjfjcljoj Aci{jaj} DwhwlComeog{cj/ Frjlgmcj Pw{}jhj W}jlj/ :337/ d/ ::=/

4


9/45

Heo{gp pgogrjpjo dwhwl djrw{ mgofjo pgomghj}jo lg}emg

oerlj}cqg,swrcmc{ sjof bgr{cd mjrc joj{cr oeo swrc{ {gpgr}c {e{ceiefc{)

peic}c{) dc{}erc{) mjo g}chj/ Pgrj}wrjo dwhwl {gijiw lgrwpjhjo dwhwl

pe{c}ca $}gr}wic{#/22

Heo{gp{c dwhwl pe{c}ca $}gr}wic{# jmjijd dwhwl mjijl hgosj}jjo

${eiigo hj}gfercg{# mjo bwhjo dwhwl sjof {gdjrw{osj j}jw sjof mckc}j,

kc}jhjo ${gco hj}gfercg{#/ [gerjof jdic dwhwl }cmjh bc{j bghgrnj mjijl

bcmjof {eiigo mgofjo heo{}rwh{c pglchcrjo mjo mwocj {gco/2;

Heo{gp{c dwhwl mjijl jnjrjo [}waago}dgers/ Oerlj mj{jr {wj}w

}j}j dwhwl jmjijd pgrj}wrjo sjof igbcd mjrc }j}j dwhwl {gbjfjc

pgrj}wrjo awomjlgo}ji mjrc bgrbjfjc oerlj }j}j dwhwl pe{c}ca/ ]gerc coc

hglwmcjo mchglbjofhjo eigd Jmeia Lgrhi sjof lgicdj} dwhwl {gbjfjc

{wj}w {c{}gl sjof }grmcrc mjrc {wj}w {w{wojo oerlj,oerlj sjof

bgrbgo}wh pcrjlcmj/2=

D/ I/ J/ Djr} $:306,:332#

Lgowrw} Djr} kcrc,kcrc pe{c}cqc{lg sjof }grmjpj} mjijl dwhwl

mgvj{j coc) jo}jrj ijco27 >

:/ Dwhwl jmjijd pgrco}jd mjrc pgofwj{j sjof bgrmjwij}8

22 Ljdlwi [crgfjr/ Lemwi Pgrhwicjdjo ]gerc Dwhwl > ]gerc,]gerc DwhwlPe{c}cqc{lg Dwhwl/ [gheijd Pj{kj [jrnjoj Wocqgr{c}j{ [wlj}grj W}jrj/Lgmjo/ 2004/

2; Cbcm/2=

Cbcm/27 Cbcm/

3


10/45

2/ ]cmjh jmj dwbwofjo sjof lw}ijh jo}jrj dwhwl mgofjo hg{w{cijjo

j}jw dwhwl sjof bgrijhw mgofjo dwhwl sjof {gdjrw{osj% mckc}j,

kc}jhjo8

;/ Dwhwl {gbjfjc {c{}gl iefchj }gr}w}wp mjo }cmjh lglpgrdj}chjo

}wnwjo {e{cji) peic}ch mjo whwrjo,whwrjo lerjic}j{8 mjo

=/ Wo{wr mciwjr dwhwl mchg{jlpcofhjo hjrgoj }cmjh bc{j mcbwh}chjo

bgrmj{jrhjo jrfwlgo}j{c iefchj $rj{ce#/

B/ Jicrjo [gnjrjd

Lgowrw} Icic Rj{ncmc) {g{gerjof }cmjh bc{j lgicdj} dwhwl c}w }jopj

lgicdj} {gnjrjdosj% ij}jr bgijhjofosj/ Mjijl bgrbjfjc ic}grj}wr {gnjrjd

c}w bgrwijof mjo lglcichc {chiw{/21

Pjmj jicrjo {gnjrjd coc) }cmjh }grigpj{ mjrc lj~djb dc{}erchji

swrc{prwmgo{c sjof mcpgieperc eigd Arcgmrckd Hjri qeo [jqcfos sjof

mcjoffjp {gbjfjc bjpjh {gnjrjd dwhwl {gbjfjc cilw pgofg}jdwjo/26

Jicrjo swrc{prwmgo{c {gbgojrosj }clbwi mjo }wlbwd {gbjfjc {wj}w

rgjh{c }grdjmjp24 >

, Rj{ceojic{lg pjmj jbjm TQCCC sjof lgonjmc mj{jr dwhwl jijl

mcljoj hghwj}jo kchji bjhji j}jw rj{ce mjo prco{cp,prco{cp mj{jr

sjof {glwjosj bgrpgrjo pjmj aci{jaj} dwhwl mgofjo }grw}jlj

lgofjomjihjo pjmj njijo pchcrjo mgmwh}ca/ ]jopj lglpgrdj}chjo

ajh}j {gnjrjd hghdw{w{jo,hghdw{w{jo oj{ceoji j}jwpwo heomc{c,

heomc{c {e{cji8 mjo

21 [jovjoc/ Kj}j}jo Pgrhwicjdjo [gnjrjd Dwhwl/ [gheijd Pj{kj [jrnjojWocqgr{c}j{ [wlj}jrj W}jrj/ Lgmjo/ 2004/

26

Cbcm/24 Ljdlwi [crgfjr/ Iek/ kc}/

:0


11/45

, [gljofj} Rgqeiw{c Prjokc{ sjof lgogo}jof hg{gvgojof,

vgojofjo mjo }rjmc{c mgofjo lc{c he{lepeic}jo/

Lj{jijd heohrc} sjof lgoclbwihjo pchcrjo mj{jr mjrc jicrjo

dc{}erchji swrc{prwmgo{c jmjijd lj{jijd hemgachj{c dwhwl Ngrljo {g}gijd

lj{j Ojpeigeo Beojpjr}g) {gerjof fwrw bg{jr pjmj Wocqgr{c}j{

Dgcmgbwrf) sjof bgrojlj ]rcbjw} {jofj} bgrpgofjrwd eigd hemgachj{c

dwhwl Prjokc{ mcljoj cj lgofjonwrhjo pwij jfjr mcjmjhjo hemgachj{c

dwhwl Ngrljo mcbgijhjof lj{jijd coc {gbgojrosj }grnjmc pgr}go}jofjo

ocijc,ocijc sjc}w jo}jrj ocijc }rjmc{c j}jw jhji mjo rj{ce {gnjrjd mgofjo

rgoeqj{c) mjo {g}grw{osj/23

Hg{clpwijo mjrc jnjrjo [jqcfos;0 >

, Dwhwl mc}glwhjo mjo }cmjh mcpgrbwj}/ Pgr}wlbwdjo dwhwl pjmj

mj{jrosj jmjijd lgrwpjhjo pgrhglbjofjo erfjoc{ sjof }cmjh

mc{gofjnj eigd hjrgoj c}w pgrj}wrjo pgrwomjof,womjofjo igbcd

rgomjd mjrc pjmj hgbcj{jjo j}jw jmj} c{}cjmj}8

, Eigd hjrgoj dwhwl jmjijd bgrhglbjof mjrc }jrja sjof {gmgrdjoj

hg }jrja sjof helpigh{ j}jw rwlc} {g{wjc mgofjo pgrhglbjofjo

lj{sjrjhj}/ Ljhj hg{jmjrjo dwhwl }grwofhjphjo lgijiwc jdic,

jdic dwhwl sjof lglbwj} aerlwij{c prco{cp,prco{cp dwhwl pjmj

lj{sjrjhj} {jrjoj mjrc hg{jmjrjo dwhwl lj{sjrjhj}8 mjo

, ]cmjh jmj dwhwl sjof bgr{caj} wocqgr{ji eigd hjrgoj dwhwl }clbwi

mjrc lj{sjrjhj} sjof lglpwosjc kcrc,kcrc sjof hdj{/ Mjijl dji coc

[jqcfos bgrpgfjof }gfwd pjmj jojiefc dwhwl mjo bjdj{j/

23

[jovjoc/ Iek/ kc}/;0 [jovjoc/ Iek/ kc}/

::


12/45

[gijonw}osj) mchj}jhjo bjdvj pglbwh}cjo qeihfgc{}jmjijd {gbjb

pgo}cofosj pgrhglbjofjo {gkjrj gqeiw{c mjrc qeihfgc{}}gr{gbw} lgijiwc

pgogic}cjo {gnjrjd sjof {jd/ [jqcfosj {jofj} bgrpgofjrwd pjmj {}wmc

dwhwl Reljvc sjof bgrhglbjof lgowrw} hgbw}wdjo lj{sjrjhj} mjo

bjrw mchemgachj{chjo {g{wjc mgofjo hgbw}wdjo lj{sjrjhj} }gr{gbw}/

Mgofjo mglchcjo ngij{ bjdvj mjijl dji coc [jqcfos lgofglbjofhjo

{gnjrjd dwhwl bjch {gkjrj lg}emg ljwpwo cilw pgofg}jdwjo/;:

Nchj bckjrj lgofgojc hg}grhjc}jo dwhwl mgofjo peic}ch) ljhj }cmjh

}grigpj{ mjrc 2 $mwj# erjof jdic dwhwl) sjc}w Re{keg Pewom mjo Arcgmrckd

Hjri qeo [jqcfos/ Bjb bgrchw} jmjijd pgonjbjrjo lgofgojc peic}ch dwhwl

mc Comeog{cj sjof mcpgofjrwdc eigd jdic,jdic dwhwl }gr{gbw}/

;: [jovjoc/ Iek/ kc}/

:2


13/45

Jbjm QCC

Jbjm TCQ

Jbjm TQCC

:4:3 :4=4

:47=

:477

:460

:430

:300

:3=0

:3=7

:3=3

:330

:334

2004

DH/JMJ]

DH/JMJ]J[IC (

DH/JMJ]J[IC (

DH//

DH/ JMJ]J[IC ( DH/DCOMW (

DH/ C[IJL( DH/

Mjijl pgrcemg {ghc}jr :;0 }jdwo $:4:3 :3=3#) pglgrco}jd Bgijomjlglbgrijhwhjo 6/000 pgrj}wrjo mc vcijsjd Dcomcj Bgijomj8

Lgowrw} pgogic}cjo Bjmjo Pglbcojjo Dwhwl Oj{ceoji $BPDO#) pjmj {ghc}jr}jdwo :332 lj{cd }gr{c{j {ghc}jr =00 pgrj}wrjo heieocji sjof lj{cd bgrijhw8mjo

:4=0

Lj{jIcbgrjic{l

]grnjmcrgqeiw{c

Grepj mjoBgijomj

lglbgrij

Pglbgrijhwjo RR

Pglbgrijhwjo C[

Pglbgrijhwjo

Lj{jPeic}ch G}c{

Pj{kj :300Prj :300Lj{j Hghwj{jjo Hgielpeh Wocqgr{jic{ L{/ Hghwj{jjo

Hip/ Icbgrji

Lj{jMgheieoc{

Lj{j

Rgaerlj{c

Prehijlj{c >

Pj{ji CC J}wrjo PgrjicdjoWWM =7 ${gbgiwlpgrwbjdjo# >[gfjij bjmjo ogfjrj

mjo pgrj}wrjo sjof

jmj lj{cd ijof{wofbgrijhw {gijlj bgiwlmcjmjhjo sjof bjrwlgowrw} WWM coc8

Fjlbjr C > HGLJNGLWHJO DWHWL MC COMEOG[CJ [GBGIWL JBJM QCC , 2004

:;


14/45

Pgogrjpjo dwhwl mc Comeog{cj mjrc {gbgiwl jbjm hg QCC {jlpjc

}jdwo 2004/;2 [gbgiwl jbjm QCC mc Comeog{cj lj{cd lgljhjc dwhwl jmj}

j{icosj) sjc}w dwhwl hgbcj{jjo mc lj{sjrjhj}/ [gpgr}c jpj sjof

mchj}jhjo eigd [jqcfos }go}jof dwhwl/ Pgosgig{jcjo {gofhg}j pjmj

jbjm coc lgijiwc pre{g{ jmj} sjof mchg}wjc eigd Hg}wj Jmj}/;; [c{}gl

pglgrco}jdjo lj{cd hgrjnjjo) hghwj{jjo }gr}coffc mcpgfjof eigd rjnj/

Jpj sjof mchj}jhjo eigd rjnj jmjijd bgojr hjrgoj rjnj jmjijd hg}wrwojo

]wdjo/;= Dji coc }grnjmc {jlpjc lglj{whc jbjm hg TQCCC mchjrgojhjo

lj{whosj Bgijomj mc Comeog{cj/

[g}gijd lj{wh Bgijomj pjmj jbjm hg TQCC bjrwijd dji }gr{gbw}

bgrhwrjof hjrgoj {wmjd mcbgrijhwhjoosj dwhwl Grepj mjo dwhwl

Hj}eich mc Comeog{cj/ Mjijl pgrcemg coc {ghc}jr :;0 }jdwo $:4:3,:3=3#)

pglgrco}jd Bgijomj lglbgrijhwhjo 6/000 pgrj}wrjo mc vcijsjd Dcomcj

Bgijomj/ Lgowrw} pgogic}cjo Bjmjo Pglbcojjo Dwhwl Oj{ceoji $BPDO#)

pjmj {ghc}jr }jdwo :332 lj{cd }gr{c{j {ghc}jr =00 pgrj}wrjo heieocji sjof

lj{cd bgrijhw8 mjo pjmj {jj} coc nwlijd }gr{gbw} {gljhco bgrhwrjo/;7

[giwrwd hgcofcojo Bgijomj djrw{ mcpgowdc }grbwh}c mgofjo jmjosj

hgrnj pjh{j sjof mcijhwhjo eigd Bgijomj hgpjmj lj{sjrjhj} prcbwlc

Comeog{cj) sjof mc{gbw} mgofjo remc/;1

;2 [j}sj Jrcojo}e/ Kj}j}jo Pgrhwicjdjo Peic}ch Dwhwl/ [gheijd Pj{kj [jrnjoj

Wocqgr{c}j{ [wlj}grj W}jrj/ Lgmjo/ 2004/;; [wojrlc/ Lemwi Pgrhwicjdjo [gnjrjd Dwhwl/ [gheijd Pj{kj [jrnjoj

Wocqgr{c}j{ [wlj}grj W}jrj/ Lgmjo/ 2004/;= Lwdjlljm Jrcaco/ Pgrjmcijo mc Comeog{cj/ Prjmosj Pjrjlc}j/ Kg}/ CCC/ Njhjr}j

Pw{j}/ :364/;7 [j}sj Jrcojo}e/ Ep/ kc}/;1 Pj{ji 16; HWD Pgrmj}j lgosgbw}hjo bjdvj > Hgrnj remcsjof }gijd mcjhwc eigd

pglgfjof hghwj{jjo }coffc }g}jp jmj8 hg}go}wjo,hg}go}wjo mjijl hc}jb coc }cmjhlglbjvj pgrwbjdjo }go}jof coc/ Pglgrco}jd bgrdjh lgofjmjhjo hg}go}wjo,hg}go}wjo igbcd ijonw} lgofgojc hgrnj remc) bcij dji c}w mcpjomjof pgriw/ [gpgr}c

sjof mckjo}wlhjo mc mjijl)/ [wojrlc/ Pgrhglbjofjo Dwhwl Pgrmj}j [gnjhHeieocji {jlpjc Hglgrmghjjo/ d}}p>%%icbrjrs/w{w/jk/cm%mevoiejm%ad%pgrmj}j,

:=
http://library.usu.ac.id/download/fh/perdata-sunarmi6.pdf.%202008http://library.usu.ac.id/download/fh/perdata-sunarmi6.pdf.%202008http://library.usu.ac.id/download/fh/perdata-sunarmi6.pdf.%202008http://library.usu.ac.id/download/fh/perdata-sunarmi6.pdf.%202008


15/45

Heo}cowc}j{ pgrhglbjofjo dwhwl mjrc dwhwl heieocji hg dwhwl

heieocji sjof mcoj{ceojic{j{chjo jmjijd pgomjsjfwojjo dwhwl wo}wh

hgpgo}cofjo pglbjofwojo Comeog{cj) jmjijd mgofjo dwhwl sjof }gijd

mcjhwc mjo bgrhglbjof mc hjijofjo bc{oc{ Co}groj{ceoji $bgrj{ji mjrc

dwhwl mjo prjh}gh bc{oc{ Jlgrchj#) pjrj jdic dwhwl sjof bgrprjh}gh

lglpgijnjrc dwhwl Grepj $Bgijomj#/ Mjijl dji coc) Lekd}jr

Hw{wljj}ljmnj bgrpgofjijljo iwj{ mjijl wo{wr,wo{wr dwhwl mjo

bc{oc{ co}groj{ceoji) }gijd lgijhwhjo pgofglbjofjo dwhwl oj{ceoji

Comeog{cj mgofjo mj{jr dwhwl heieocji sjof mchjnc wijof bgrmj{jrhjo

Frwomoerl Pjokj{cij jmjijd sjof mcpjomjof pjicof iefc{/ Mcljoj

dwhwl heieocji {gkjrj aerlci lj{cd bgrijhw mjo {gbjfcjo hjcmjd,

hjcmjdosj lj{cd lgrwpjhjo dwhwl pe{c}ca Comeog{cj bgrmj{jrhjo

hg}go}wjo pgrjicdjo) }gricdj} }grnjmc pgrfgrjhjo hg jrjd peij,peij dwhwl

Grepj $Bgijomj#) sjof lgofjmep{c mjrc dwhwl jmj}) dwhwl Jlgrchj

j}jw dwhwl Coffrc{) jhjo }g}jpc heoacfwrj{cosj% peij {c{}glj}ch mjrc Grepj

}cmjh mjpj} mcbeofhjr) dwhwl }j}j ocjfj j}jw dwhwl mjfjof $djomgi{

rgkd}{ qjo heepdjomgi#lglbgmjhjo dwhwl {gbjfjc pgrghjsj{j {e{cji

j}jw dwhwl gheoelc/;6

Pjmj grj Ermg Bjrw pgokjrcjo lemgi dwhwl oj{ceoji wo}wh

lglgowdc pjoffcijo ~jljo mjo wo}wh mcnjmchjo mj{jr,mj{jr w}jlj

pglbjofwojo dwhwl oj{ceoji) mcljoj lgofwhwdhjo dwhwl jmj} jhjo

bgrjr}c lgofwhwdhjo piwrjic{lg dwhwl sjof }cmjh bgrpcdjh hgpjmj

{wojrlc1/pma/ 2004/;6 ]clegr/ Pgrhglbjofjo Dwhwl mc Comeog{cj [gpjonjof Lj{j Pglgrco}jdjo

Ermg Bjrw/ d}}p>%%vvv/biefkj}jief/kel%frewp%bief,prele}ceo,

:%mc{kw{{%go}rs%pgrhglbjofjo,dwhwl,mc,comeog{cj,{gpjonjof,lj{j,pglgrco}jdjo,ermg,bjrw/ 2004/

:7
http://library.usu.ac.id/download/fh/perdata-sunarmi6.pdf.%202008http://www.blogcatalog.com/group/blog-promotion-1/discuss/entry/perkembangan-hukum-di-indonesia-sepanjang-masa-pemerintahan-orde-baru.%202008http://www.blogcatalog.com/group/blog-promotion-1/discuss/entry/perkembangan-hukum-di-indonesia-sepanjang-masa-pemerintahan-orde-baru.%202008http://www.blogcatalog.com/group/blog-promotion-1/discuss/entry/perkembangan-hukum-di-indonesia-sepanjang-masa-pemerintahan-orde-baru.%202008http://www.blogcatalog.com/group/blog-promotion-1/discuss/entry/perkembangan-hukum-di-indonesia-sepanjang-masa-pemerintahan-orde-baru.%202008http://www.blogcatalog.com/group/blog-promotion-1/discuss/entry/perkembangan-hukum-di-indonesia-sepanjang-masa-pemerintahan-orde-baru.%202008http://library.usu.ac.id/download/fh/perdata-sunarmi6.pdf.%202008http://www.blogcatalog.com/group/blog-promotion-1/discuss/entry/perkembangan-hukum-di-indonesia-sepanjang-masa-pemerintahan-orde-baru.%202008http://www.blogcatalog.com/group/blog-promotion-1/discuss/entry/perkembangan-hukum-di-indonesia-sepanjang-masa-pemerintahan-orde-baru.%202008http://www.blogcatalog.com/group/blog-promotion-1/discuss/entry/perkembangan-hukum-di-indonesia-sepanjang-masa-pemerintahan-orde-baru.%202008


16/45

dwhwl oj{ceoji wo}wh mcwocachj{chjo $mjijl vwnwm hemgachj{c#) }gricdj}

bjdvj dwhwl jmj} pij{}c{ mjo mcojlc{) {gr}j {gijiw bgrwbjd {gkjrj

hghji/ Cmg hemgachj{c mjo wocachj{c mcprjhjr{jc heieocji sjof bgrvjvj{jo

wocqgr{jic{}c{) mcljoj dwhwl jmj} jmjijd dwhwl sjof lglcichc pgrj{jjo

hgjmcijo lj{sjrjhj} iehji sjof piwrjic{}c{/ [gbjfjcljoj hc}j hg}jdwc

bjdvj dwhwl heieocji sjof bgr}go}jofjo mgofjo dwhwl jmj} jmjijd

lgrwpjhjo }wfj{ mjo helc}lgo Pglgrco}jd Ermg Bjrw wo}wh lgijhwhjo

wocachj{c mjo hemcachj{c hg mjijl dwhwl oj{ceoji/;4

Pjmj lj{j grj }jdwo :360) }gijd mcijhwhjo heo{eicmj{c mgofjo

mwhwofjo peic}ch lcic}gr mjo bgr}epjof pjmj {}rwh}wr {gkjrj leoeic{}ch

{gr}j lwmjd mcheo}rei {gkjrj {go}rji) lgofcofj} pgrjo dwhwl jmj}

mjijl pglbjofwojo dwhwl oj{ceoji {jofj} lgomg{jh sjof {gkjrj rcci

}cmjh }grkj}j} }grijiw bg{jr) }grhgkwjic hijcl jhjo hgbgojrjo lerji) pjmj

{jj} lj{jijd epgrj{ceojic{j{c mjo pgofgagh}cajo }grdjmjp pjdjl dwhwl

{gbjfjc pgrghjsj{j mc }jofjo Pglgrco}jd sjof igbcd gagh}ca/;3

[jofj} ngij{ }gricdj} bjdvj pjmj }jdwo :311 }gijd }grnjmc

pgrwbjdjo bg{jr,bg{jrjo mc bcmjof dwhwl mjo peic}ch) sjof lgsjhcohjo

bjdvj rgqeiw{c bgiwl {gig{jc) mcljoj WWM :3=7 mcnjmchjo ijomj{jo cmcci%

heo{}c}w{ceoji }grdjmjp {gfjij hgfcj}jo gheoelc) peic}ch) {e{cji) mjo

bwmjsj) mjo jo}c heieocjic{lg mjo jo}c clpgrcjic{lg }cmjh ijfc

mchwljomjofhjo }gijd bgrfjo}c {}rj}gfc oj{ceoji sjc}w hgpjmj lj{jijd

{eji hglc{hcojo mjo hg{wic}jo dcmwp gheoelc wo}wh mcpgkjdhjo sjof

bgrhjc}jo mgofjo pgomjpj}jo rjhsj) bw}j dwrwa) hg{gdj}jo) mjo

;4

Cbcm/;3 Cbcm/

:1


17/45

pgr}jlbjdjo pgomwmwh/ Mgofjo {chjp iev preacig mjijl peic}ch

co}groj{ceoji) mgofjo mc bjvjd heo}rei Pglgrco}jd Ermg Bjrw }grmjpj}

{wj}w comchj}er hgbgrdj{cijo pgrnwjofjo bjof{j sjof hglwmcjo mcjicdhjo

hgbgrdj{cijoosj mjijl pglbjofwojo gheoelc/=0

Mgofjo mchgiwjrhjoosj [wrj} Pgrco}jd [gbgij{ Ljrg} pjmj }jdwo

:316 mjo pjmj }jdwo :314) mcbgo}whosj hjbcog} bjrw mgofjoj {gbw}jo

Hjbcog} Pglbjofwojo sjof lgrwpjhjo {gbjfjc }c}ch jvji pgrwbjdjo

hgbcnjhjo pglgrco}jd {gkjrj lgosgiwrwd $mjrc hgbcnjhjo peic}ch

rgqeiw{ceogr {gbjfjc pjoficlj lgonjmc hgbcnjhjo pglbjofwojo gheoelc

{gbjfjc pgrnwjofjo Ermg Bjrw#/ [gmjofhjo pjmj bgrchw}osj jmjijd

{gbjfjc }jdjp lgofglbjichjo kc}rj Comeog{cj {gbjfjc Ogfjrj Dwhwl)

mcljoj pgrhglbjofjo dwhwl oj{ceoji pjmj grj Ermg Bjrw jmjijd

wpjsj lglwicdhjo hgvcbjvjjo dwhwl mjo }j}j dcrjrhc pgrwomjof,

womjofjo/ Sjof hglwmcjo pjmj }jdwo :311 }joffji 7 Nwic mgofjo

Hg}g}jpjo LPR[ Oe/ TT > }gijd lgog}jphjo {wlbgr }gr}cb dwhwl

Rgpwbich Comeog{cj mjo ]j}j Wrw}jo Pgrj}wrjo Pgrwomjof,Womjofjo

Rgpwbich Comeog{cj djrw{ lgijh{jojhjo WWM :3=7 {gkjrj lwroc mjo

heo{ghwgo mjo ljh{wm Hg}g}jpjo LPR[ }gr{gbw} jmjijd Pjokj{cij)

Prehijlj{c Hglgrmghjjo :6 Jfw{}w{ :3=7) Mghrc} 7 Nwic :373) WWM

Prehijlj{c) mjo [WPGR[GLJR :311/ =:

Mjo pjmj lj{j jvji Pglgrco}jdjo Ermg Bjrw) }gijd mcijhwhjo

pglbj}j{jo,pglbj}j{jo hghwj{jjo gh{ghw}ca) hjrgoj pjmj

Pglgrco}jdjo Prg{cmgo [eghjroe) hghwj{jjo gh{ghw}ca lgowomwhhjo mcrc

=0

Cbcm/=: Cbcm/

:6


18/45

hgpjmj Pclpcojo Bg{jr Rgqeiw{c) sjc}w mgofjo lgofg{jdhjo njbj}joosj

{gbjfjc Prg{cmgo [gwlwr Dcmwp $[jofj} gh{g{ca mgofjo mghrc},mghrc}

Prg{cmgo {gbjfjc hghwj}jo dwhwl sjof lgigbcdc hghwj}jo womjof,

womjof mjo Womjof,Womjof Peheh Hgdjhcljo Oe/ :3 ]jdwo :31= sjof

}gijd lglbgrc vgvgojojf hgpjmj Prg{cmgo wo}wh lgijhwhjo co}grqgo{c

pjmj pgrhjrj,pgrhjrj mc Pgofjmcijo#/ J}j{ mj{jr }gr{gbw}ijd Pglgrco}jd

Ermg Bjrw lgijhwhjo pglwicdjo hgvcbjvjjo dwhwl mjo lgogfjhhjo

}dg rwig ea ijv wo}wh }grkcp}josj {gr}j }grijh{jojosj hgfcj}jo

pgrgheoelcjo) mgofjo bjo}wjo iwjr ogfgrc mjo coqg{}j{c j{cof eigd

hjrgojosj djrw{ }g}jp }grnjlcoosj hgpj{}cjo bgrmj{jrhjo dwhwl/=2

Pjmj lj{j grj Ermg Bjrw) }gijd lgonjmchjo dwhwl

pglbjofwojo) bwdhjo dwhwl rgqeiw{c mgofjo }cmjh lglbgrijhwhjo

dwhwl heieocji $Bjrj} {gpgr}c mg{jhjo [jdjrmne mjo Vcrneoe#/

[gbjfjcljoj }gijd }grnjmc pgr}go}jofjo jo}jrj Hg}wj Ljdhjljd Jfwof

pjmj vjh}w c}w mcnjbj} eigd [egbgh}c $pjmj }jdwo :31;#) sjof lgogo}jof

iefchj dwhwl [jdjrmne mjo Vcrneoe) mcljoj mjijl pgijh{jojjo mjo

epgrj{ceojic{j{c hgfcj}joosj bjosjh sjof lgljh{jhjo pgosclpjofjo,

pgosclpjofjo sjof lgoclbwihjo pgr{c}cvj sjof mc{gbw} igfji fjp{

$pjrj swrc{ lgofdjmjpc bgrbjfjc pgrlj{jijdjo gheoelc) peic}ch) {e{cji)

bwmjsj) mjo jfjlj#/ Mcljoj pjmj Lj{j Ermg Bjrw j}jw Ermg

Pglbjofwojo) dwhwl mcpgrijhwhjo {gbjfjc {jrjoj mjo bjrw sjof

bgr}wnwjo pglbjofwojo) mjo bwhjo bgr}wnwjo wo}wh lgrj{ceojic{j{c

hgbcnjhjo,hgbcnjhjo Pglgrco}jd $hgbcnjhjo gh{ghw}ca#/=;

=2

Cbcm/=; Cbcm/

:4


19/45

Pre{g{ pglbjofwojo lgijhwhjo pgomghj}jo bjrw) sjof mjpj}

mcpjhjc wo}wh lgrgigqjo{c pgrlj{jijdjo dwhwl mjo awof{c dwhwl

mgofjo pgrlj{jijdjo ljhre sjof }cmjh djosj }grbj}j{ pjmj pgr{ejijo

oerlj}ca mjo icfc}j}ca/ Lgowrw} Lekd}jr Hw{wljj}ljmnj > sjof lgofjnjh

pjrj {e{ceiefch mjijl cilw dwhwl wo}wh lgrgigqjo{chjo dwhwl mgofjo

pgrlj{jijdjo pglbjofwojo {e{cji,gheoelc/ Mcljoj pjdjl jicrjo

{ekceiefckji nwrc{prwmgokg $igfji rgjic{lg#) sjc}w heo{gp Re{keg Pewom

jmjijd pgriwosj lglawof{chjo ijv j{ j }eei ea {ekcji gofcoggrcof) mjo

mgofjo mj{jr jrfwlgo Lekd}jr sjc}w lgofgojc pgomjsjfwojjo dwhwl

{gbjfjc {jrjoj wo}wh lgrghjsj{j lj{sjrjhj} lgowrw} hgpjmj {hgojrce

hgbcnjhjo Pglgrco}jd% gh{ghw}ca) sjof {jofj} mcpgriwhjo eigd ogfjrj,

ogfjrj sjof {gmjof bgrhglbjof/==

== Cbcm/

:3


20/45

BJB CCC

]CONJWJO WLWL ]GO]JOF ]GERC DWHWL RE[KEG PEWOM !

ARCGMRCKD KJRI QEO [JQCFOS MJIJL HEO]GH[ PEIC]CH

DWHWL

J/ Jicrjo [ekceiefckji Nwrc{prwmgokg

Re{keg Pewom jmjijd {jijd {j}w jdic dwhwl sjof bgrjicrjo

[ekceiefckji Nwrc{prwmgokg sjof igbcd lgofjrjdhjo pgrdj}cjoosj pjmj

Hgosj}jjo Dwhwl mjrcpjmj hgmwmwhjo mjo awof{c dwhwl mjijl

lj{sjrjhj}/=7

Hgosj}jjo dwhwl pjmj mj{jrosj jmjijd hgljwjo pwbich) njmc

}cmjh {ghgmjr dwhwl mjijl pgofgr}cjo ijv co beeh{/ [ekceiefckji

Nwrc{prwmgokg lgowonwhhjo helprelc sjof kgrlj} jo}jrj dwhwl }gr}wic{

{gbjfjc hgbw}wdjo lj{sjrjhj} dwhwl mglc }grkcp}josj hgpj{}cjo dwhwl

$ pe{c}cqc{l ijv# mjo icqcof ijv {gbjfjc vwnwm pgofdjrfjjo }grdjmjp

pgo}cofosj pgrjojo lj{sjrjhj} mjijl pglbgo}whjo dwhwl mjo

ercgo}j{c dwhwl/=1

=7 Ljdlwi [crgfjr/ Lemwi Pgrhwicjdjo ]gerc Dwhwl > ]gerc,]gerc Dwhwl[ekceiefckji Nwrc{prwmgokg/ [gheijd Pj{kj [jrnjoj Wocqgr{c}j{ [wlj}grj W}jrj/

Lgmjo/ 2004/=1 Cbcm/

20


21/45

Fjlbjr CC > Pgr{pgh}ca Mcjigh}chj Dgfgi

Pglbgo}whjo mjo Pgrhglbjofjo Dwhwl

Dwhwl sjof bjch mcbgo}wh mgofjo lglpgr}clbjofhjo bgrbjfjc

hgpgo}cofjo sjof jmj mjijl lj{sjrjhj} bjch hgpgo}cofjo wlwl

$}grlj{wh sjof w}jlj jmjijd hgpgo}cofjo ogfjrj#) hgpgo}cofjo comcqcmw

mjo hgpgo}cofjo prcbjmc/ Mgofjo mglchcjo pglbgo}whjo dwhwl djrw{

bgrwpjsj lgosgclbjofhjo bgrbjfjc hgpgo}cofjo }gr{gbw}/=6

Hgpgo}cofjo wlwl sjof }grw}jlj jmjijd hgpgo}cofjo ogfjrj

wo}wh lgicomwofc gh{c{}go{c mjo djhchj} ogfjrj mjo hgpgo}cofjo wo}wh

lgofjvj{c mjo lgljnwhjo hg{gnjd}grjjo {e{cji/=4

Pglbgo}whjo dwhwl djrw{ lglpgrdj}chjo dwhwl sjof dcmwp/

]grmjpj} pgrclbjofjo jo}jrj dwhwl }gr}wic{ mjo dwhwl }cmjh }gr}wic{/

Pgrhglbjofjo dwhwl {jofj} mcpgofjrwdc eigd heomc{c cmgeiefc) peic}ch)

{e{cji) mjo bwmjsj/ Njmc) }cmjh djosj {ghgmjr hgcofcojo pglgrco}jd/=3

=6 Cbcm/=4 Cbcm/=3

Cbcm/

PE[C]CQC[LG DWHWL

Jnjrjo [gnjrjd$Jo}c ]g{c{#

[ekceiefckji Nwrc{prwmgokg$[co}g{c{#

2:


22/45

Pgogrjpjo Dwhwl

Pgogrjpjo dwhwl djrw{ lglpgrdj}chjo pgrhglbjofjo

hgpgo}cofjo,hgpgo}cofjo mjijl lj{sjrjhj}/ Djhcl lgogfjhhjo dwhwl

mgofjo lgocijc hgpgo}cofjo ljoj sjof igbcd hwj} mjo hgpgo}cofjo ljoj

sjof igbcd igljd/70

Ocijc mjrc {wj}w hgpgo}cofjo }cmjh bgr{caj} }g}jp }g}jpc bgrwbjd,

wbjd {g{wjc mgofjo pgrwbjdjo {c{}gl,{c{}gl peic}ch mjo {c{}gl {e{cji/

Hgpgo}cofjo {jofj} mcpgofjrwdc eigd vjh}w mjo pgofjijljo

hglj{sjrjhj}jo $Jmjl Pemfergkhc ! Kdrc{}epgr Vdgijo#/7:

Eigd hjrgoj c}w mjijl pgogrjpjo dwhwl sjof bjch {jofj}

mcbw}wdhjo hg{jmjrjo pjrj djhcl lgofgojc ocijc,ocijc hgpgo}cofjo sjof

bgrhglbjof mc }gofjd lj{sjrjhj}/ Djhcl djrw{ lgoffwojhjo kjrj

sjof mcpgrfwojhjo pglbwj} womjof,womjof) sjhoc mgofjo lgijhwhjo

pgosgicmchjo }grdjmjp hgpgo}cofjo sjof bgrhglbjof mc mjijl

lj{sjrjhj}/ Djosj mgofjo lgljdjlc pgrhglbjofjo hgpgo}cofjo mc

lj{sjrjhj} djhcl mjpj} lgogrjphjo dwhwl {gkjrj bgojr mjo jmci

$Djhcl Kjrme~e#/ Keo}ed > Bc{ljr [crgfjr lgogrjphjo dwhwljo :7

}jdwo pgonjrj bjfc {gerjof pglgrhe{j) mchjrgojhjo cj lgijhwhjo

pgoc{}jjo }grdjmjp fjmc{ }gr{gbw} mjo lglbwj} hcij}jo sjof }cmjh

}griwpjhjo bjfc {c fjmc{/72

70 Cbcm/7:

Cbcm/72 Cbcm/

22


23/45

Awof{c W}jlj Dwhwl

Awof{c w}jlj dwhwl jmjijd wo}wh lgicomwofc hgpgo}cofjo sjof

jmj mjijl lj{sjrjhj}/ Lgowrw} Re{keg Pewom > jmj }cfj hgpgo}cofjo

sjof djrw{ mcicomwofc eigd dwhwl) sjc}w > pwbick co}grg{}8 comcqcmwji

co}grg{}8 mjo co}grg{} ea pgr{eojic}s/7;

Rcokcjo mjrc }cjp,}cjp hgpgo}cofjo }gr{gbw} bwhjo lgrwpjhjo

mja}jr sjof lw}ijh }g}jpc bgrwbjd,wbjd {g{wjc pgrhglbjofjo

lj{sjrjhj}/ Njmc) {jofj} mcpgofjrwdc eigd vjh}w mjo heomc{c lj{sjrjhj}/

Mja}jr hgpgo}cofjo }gr{gbw} {gijiw bgrwbjd mjo mc}jlbjd hjrgoj }cmjh

bgr{caj} lw}ijh lgowrw} Rwmeia Ngrcof ! Ngrgls Bgo}djl/7=

Jpjbcij hgpgo}cofjo,hgpgo}cofjo }gr{gbw} mc{w{wo {gbjfjc

{w{wojo sjof }cmjh bgrwbjd,wbjd) ljhj {w{wojo }gr{gbw} bwhjo ijfc

{gbjfjc {ekcji gofcoggrcof }g}jpc lgrwpjhjo pgrosj}jjo peic}ch

$ljocag{}e peic}ch#/77

]wfj{ W}jlj Dwhwl

]wfj{ w}jlj dwhwl jmjijd rghjsj{j {e{cji $ijv j{ j }eei ea {ekcji

gofcoggrcof) Re{keg Pewom#/ Dwhwl }cmjh {jnj mcbgo}wh bgrmj{jrhjo

hgpgo}cofjo lj{sjrjhj} }g}jpc nwfj djrw{ mc}gfjhhjo {gmglchcjo rwpj

eigd pjrj swrc{ {gbjfjc wpjsj {e{cji heo}rei mjijl jr}c iwj{ sjof

pgijh{jojjoosj mcercgo}j{chjo hgpjmj pgrwbjdjo,pgrwbjdjo sjof

mchgdgomjhc/71

7; Cbcm/7= Cbcm/77 Cbcm/71

Cbcm/

2;


24/45

Eigd hjrgoj c}w) {jofj} mcpgofjrwdc eigd helpeogo,helpeogo mc

iwjr dwhwl) ljhj pjrj pgogfjh dwhwl mjijl lgvwnwmhjo }wfj{ w}jlj

dwhwl djrw{ lgljdjlc {gkjrj bgojr iefchj) {gnjrjd) jmj}) c{}cjmj})

pgmeljo prcijhw sjof bgojr jfjr hgjmcijo mjpj} mc}gfjhhjo/76

Hgpw}w{jo dwhwl sjof jmci mjpj} mcfwojhjo {gbjfjc {jrjoj

wo}wh lgofglbjofhjo lj{sjrjhj}/ ]wfj{ w}jlj jmjijd {jrjoj

pglbjdjrwjo lj{sjrjhj} mjijl pglbjofwojo/74

Dwbwofjo Dwhwl mjo Gheoelc

Pjmj pgrhglbjofjo jbjm hg :3 mjo 20 dwhwl sjof {glwij

{jofj} bgrpgofjrwd eigd hgpgo}cofjo lj{sjrjhj} hglwmcjo bgrijonw}

mcpgofjrwdc {gkjrj hwj} eigd hgpgo}cofjo gheoelc/73

Pjmj }jdwo :330,jo pgomghj}jo dwhwl {gbjfjc {ekcji

gofcoggrcof mcigofhjpc mgofjo lglpgrdj}chjo pgrhglbjofjo

hgpgo}cofjo gheoelc co}groj{ceoji/10

Pgrjo [}rj}gfc{ Djhcl mjijl Pgr{pgh}ca[ekceiefckji Nwrc{prwmgokg

Hgdcmwpjo dwhwl {gbjfjc heo}rei {e{cji }grig}jh pjmj prjh}gh

pgijh{jojjo j}jw pgogrjpjo dwhwl }gr{gbw}/ ]wfj{ djhcl mjijl

lgogrjphjo dwhwl }cmjh lgiwiw mcpjdjlc {gbjfjc wpjsj {ekcji keo}rei

sjof bgr{caj} aerlji mjijl lgosgig{jchjo heoaich) }g}jpc {ghjicfw{

lgomc{jco pgogrjpjo dwhwl c}w {gbjfjc wpjsj {ekcji gofcoggrcof/1:

76 Cbcm/74 Cbcm/73 Cbcm/10 Cbcm/1:

Cbcm/

2=


25/45

]wfj{ swmc{cji djhcl }cmjh ijfc mcpjdjlc {ghgmjr {gbjfjc pgogrjp

womjof,womjof }grdjmjp pgrc{}cvj heohrc} $bgrwpj bgrbjfjc hj{w{ mjo

heoaich# j}jw {gbjfjc {ghgmjr kereof womjof,womjof $beokdj mg ij iec#

}g}jpc nwfj {gbjfjc pgoffgrjh {ekcji gofcoggrcof/12

Pjrj pgosgigoffjrj dwhwl djrw{ lglpgrdj}chjo j{pgh

awof{ceoji mjrc dwhwl sjhoc wo}wh lgokjpjc pgrwbjdjo) mgofjo

lgijhwhjo pgrwbjdjo dwhwl {gijiw mgofjo lgoffwojhjo {gfjij

ljkjl }ghoch pgoja{crjo $}gerc dwhwl awof{ceoji#/1;

B/ ]gerc Dwhwl Lgowrw} Re{keg Pewom

Ijv c{ j }eei ea {ekcji gofcoggrcof1=

Jmjijd jpj sjof mchj}jhjo eigd Re{keg Pewom }grdjmjp dwhwl

c}w/ [jlj {gpgr}c jpj sjof mchj}jhjo eigd Lekd}jr Hw{wljj}ljmnj)

dwhwl jmjijd hg{giwrwdjo j~j{,j~j{ mjo hjgmjd,hjgmjd sjof

lgofj}wr lj{sjrjhj}) }grlj{wh mc mjijlosj iglbjfj mjo pre{g{ wo}wh

lgvwnwmhjo dwhwl c}w hg mjijl hgosj}jjo/ Hgmwj jdic dwhwl coc

lglcichc pjomjofjo sjof {jlj }grdjmjp dwhwl/17

Mjijl rjofhj lgonjijohjo awof{c {gbjfjc {ekcji keo}rei dwhwl

{gbjfjc heo}rei {e{cji) dwhwl c}w lgowrw} Lckdjgi Djfgr mjpj} lgofjbmc

pjmj ; $}cfj# {gh}er) sjc}w11 >

:/ Dwhwl {gbjfjc jij} pgogr}cb $ermgrcof#8

12 Cbcm/1; Cbcm/1= Ijv c{ j }eei ea {ekcji gofcoggrcofjmjijd dwhwl {gbjfjc jij} rghjsj{j {e{cji/

Ljdlwi [crgfjr/ Cbcm/17 Bc{ljr Oj{w}ceo/ Ep/ kc}/ /11

[wojrlc/ Pgrhglbjofjo Dwhwl Pgrmj}j [gnjh Heieocji {jlpjc Hglgrmghjjo/Ep/ kc}/

27


26/45

Mjijl rjofhj pgogr}cbjo coc dwhwl mjpj} lgokcp}jhjo {wj}w

hgrjofhj bjfc pgofjlbcijo hgpw}w{jo peic}ch mjo pglgkjdjo

{gofhg}j sjof lwofhco }clbwi lgijiwc {wj}w dwhwl jkjrj sjof

bjch/ Cj pwo mjpj} lgig}jhhjo mj{jr dwhwl $igfc}cljks# bjfc

pgoffwojjo hghwj{jjo/

2/ Dwhwl {gbjfjc jij} pgonjfj hg{gclbjofjo $bjijokcof#8 mjo

Awof{c dwhwl mjpj} lgonjfj hg{gclbjofjo mjo hgdjrleoc{jo

jo}jrj hgpgo}cofjo ogfjrj% hgpgo}cofjo wlwl mjo hgpgo}cofjo

pgrerjofjo/

;/ Dwhwl {gbjfjc hj}jic{j}er/

[gbjfjc hj}jic{j}er dwhwl mjpj} lglbjo}w wo}wh lglwmjdhjo

}grnjmcosj pre{g{ pgrwbjdjo lgijiwc pglbjdjrwjo dwhwl $ijv

rgaerl# mgofjo bjo}wjo }gojfj mc bcmjof preag{c dwhwl/

[gpgr}c sjof mchj}jhjo eigd Re{keg Pewom) mjpj} mcicdj} lgijiwc

pglbwj}jo dwhwl mjo awof{c w}jlj dwhwl) sjc}w >

:/ Pglbwj}jo Dwhwl

Re{keg Pewom }grhgoji mgofjo }gercosj bjdvj dwhwl jmjijd jij}

wo}wh lglpgrbjrwc $lgrghjsj{j# lj{sjrjhj} $ijv c{ j }eei ea {ekcji

gofcoggrcof#/ Wo}wh mjpj} lglgowdc pgrjojoosj {gbjfjc jij} }gr{gbw})

ljhj Pewom lglbwj} pgoffeieofjo j}j{ hgpgo}cofjo,hgpgo}cofjo

sjof djrw{ mcicomwofc eigd dwhwl) sjc}w16 >

:/ Pwbick Co}grg{}8

16 Ljdlwi [crgfjr/ Iek/ kc}/

21


27/45

, Hgpgo}cofjo ogfjrj wo}wh lgonjfj gh{c{}go{c mjo djhchj}

ogfjrj8 mjo

, Hgpgo}cofjo ogfjrj wo}wh lgofjvj{c hgpgo}cofjo {e{cji

hglj{sjrjhj}jo/

2/ Comcqcmwji co}grg{}8 mjo

, Hgpgo}cofjo mjijl dwbwofjo rwljd }joffj $co}grg{}{ co

melg{}ck rgij}ceo{#8 mjo

, Hgpgo}cofjo lgofgojc djr}j bgomj $co}grg{}{ ea

{wb{}jokg#/

;/ Co}grg{} ea pgr{eojic}s/

, Hgpgo}cofjo pgricomwofjo co}gfrc}j{ bjmjocjd $pds{ckji

co}gfrc}s#8

, Hgdgomjh bgbj{ $arggmel ea vcii#8

, Rgpw}j{c $rgpw}j}ceo#8

, Hgjmjjo prcbjmc pgrerjofjo $prcqjks#8 mjo

, Hgbgbj{jo wo}wh lglcicd jfjlj mjo lgofgiwjrhjo

pgomjpj} $arggmel ea bgicgqg jom epcoceo#/

Njmc) jpj sjof mcijhwhjo eigd pglbgo}wh dwhwl jmjijd

lgosgclbjofhjo {gfjij hgpgo}cofjo sjof jmj mjijl lj{sjrjhj} mjo

pglgrco}jd/ Hgpgo}cofjo ogfjrj jmjijd djrw{ sjof pjicof }coffc% j}j{

mchjrgojhjo ogfjrj lglpwosjc hgpgo}cofjo oj{ceoji/ Hgpgo}cofjo

oj{ceoji }gr{gbw} djrw{ lgicomwofc hgpgo}cofjo ogfjrj hgljwjo ogfjrj

jmjijd hgljwjo pwbich/ Hjrgoj dwhwl c}w bwhjo {gpgr}c sjof mchj}jhjo

eigd }gerc,}gerc pe{c}cqc{lg dwhwl bjdvj dwhwl lglcichc {caj} }gr}w}wp/14

14 Ljdlwi [crgfjr/ Iek kc}/

26


28/45

Dwhwl {jofj} mcpgofjrwdc eigd cmgeiefc) peic}ch) gheoelc) {e{cji)

bwmjsj/ ]cmjh djosj {ghgmjr hgljwjo pglgrco}jd/ [wj}w iefchj sjof

}grbwhj) pgrhglbjofjo hgbw}wdjo lj{sjrjhj} {jofj} lglpgofjrwdc

pgr}wlbwdjo dwhwl mc mjijl lj{sjrjhj}/ Peic}ch {jofj} lglpgofjrwdc

pgr}wlbwdjo dwhwl mc mjijl lj{sjrjhj}/13

Dwhwl bgrj{ji mjrc pglgrco}jd mjijl dji coc lgowrw} Bc{ljr

Oj{w}ceo jpj sjof mc{gbw}osj mgofjo }ep mevo/60 Pglgrco}jd mc{coc

mjijl heo}gh{ bjmjo gh{ghw}ca/ Dj{ciosj jmjijd Womjof,Womjof)

Pgrj}wrjo Pglgrco}jd) Pgrj}wrjo Pglgrco}jd Pgoffjo}c Womjof,Womjof

$PGRPW#) Hgpprg{) Pgrprg{) Coprg{) Pgoprg{) Hgplgo% Pgrlgo) mjo

{gbjfjcosj/ Nchj hc}j icdj} mjijl heo}gh{ pglgrco}jd mjgrjd) dj{ciosj

sjc}w Pgrmj Prepco{c) Hgpw}w{jo Hgpjij Mjgrjd Prepco{c) Pgrmj

Hjbwpj}go% He}j) Hgpw}w{jo Hgpjij Mjgrjd Hjbwpj}go He}j) Pgrj}wrjo

Mg{j/6:

Dwhwl c}w bgrpgrjo wo}wh lgrwbjd hgjmjjo lj{sjrjhj} {gpgr}c

jpj sjof mccofcohjo dwhwl }gr{gbw}/ Dwhwl mjpj} lgijhwhjo pgrwbjdjo

{gkjrj pjh{j/ Jfjr lgokjpjh heomc{c sjof mccofcohjo eigd dwhwl/

Dwhwl mcpjh{jhjo hgbjvjd/ Keo}ed > Pgrj}wrjo Ijrjofjo Lgreheh)

bgrdgo}c lgreheh jmjijd hgpgo}cofjo lj{sjrjhj}/ Nchj ogfjrj lgljh{j

hc}j wo}wh lgrwbjd% lgijrjof hg jrjd sjof igbcd bjch/ Hjrgoj lgreheh

mjpj} lgrwfchjo hg{gdj}jo/ Cocijd sjof mc{gbw} {ekcji keo}rei/62

13 Ljdlwi [crgfjr/ Iek kc}/60 Bc{ljr [crgfjr/ Ep kc}/6:

[j}sj Jrcojo}e/ Ep kc}/62 Ljdlwi [crgfjr/ Ep kc}/

24


29/45

FJLBJR CCC > Ciw{}rj{c Dwhwl Bgrj{ji mjrc J}j{ $]ep Mevo#

Mjijl pre{g{ pglbgo}whjo pgrj}wrjo dwhwl eigd co{}c}w{c peic}ch

pgrjojo hghwj}jo peic}ch c}w {jofj} lgogo}whjo/ Co{}c}w{c peic}ch {gkjrj

rg{lc mcbgrchjo e}erc}j{ wo}wh lglbgo}wh dwhwl djosjijd {gbwjd

co{}c}w{c sjof qjkwl }jopj mcc{c eigd lgrghj sjof mcbgrchjo hgvgojofjo

wo}wh c}w/6;

2/ Awof{c W}jlj Dwhwl

[jijd {j}w lj{jijd sjof mcdjmjpc jmjijd lgoglwhjo {c{}gl mjo

pgijh{jojjo pgogfjhjo dwhwl sjof mjpj} lgongiljhjo awof{c dwhwl

mgofjo bjch {gpgr}c awof{c heo}rei {e{cji) awof{c lgosgig{jchjo

pgr{gic{cdjo) awof{c lgljmwhjo) awof{c lglwmjdhjo) awof{c

pglbjdjrwjo) awof{c hg{gnjd}grjjo mjo ijco,ijco/6=

6; Djlmjo ^egiqj/ Pgofjrwd [c{}gl Peic}ch mjijl Pglbgo}whjo Dwhwl mcComeog{cj/ d}}p>%%kdjpicgo66/bief{pe}/kel%2004%07%pgofjrwd,{c{}gl,peic}ch,mjijl/d}li/ 2007/

6=

Bjfcr Ljojo/ ]wfj{ Djhcl > Jo}jrj Lgijh{jojhjo Awof{c Dwhwl mjo ]wnwjoDwhwl/vvv/bjmcijf/og}/ 2004/

PGLGRCO]JD

LJ[SJRJHJ]

D W H W L

23
http://chaplien77.blogspot.com/2008/05/pengaruh-sistem-politik-dalam.html.%202005http://chaplien77.blogspot.com/2008/05/pengaruh-sistem-politik-dalam.html.%202005http://www.badilag.net/http://www.badilag.net/http://chaplien77.blogspot.com/2008/05/pengaruh-sistem-politik-dalam.html.%202005http://chaplien77.blogspot.com/2008/05/pengaruh-sistem-politik-dalam.html.%202005http://www.badilag.net/


30/45

Pjmj {jj} coc) pgrbgmjjo,pgrbgmjjo awof{c dwhwl }gr{gbw}) {grcof

hjic lgonjmc wo{wr sjof lgomereof }clbwiosj pgrbgmjjo lgofgojc

}wnwjo lgogrjphjo dwhwl/ Jmj sjof igbcd lgoghjohjo pjmj awof{c

heo}rei {e{cji) j}jw awof{c pgrwbjdjo) mjo ijco,ijco/ Hjijw lj{cof,lj{cof

pcdjh lgowo}w} lgowrw} hgcofcojoosj {gomcrc,{gomcrc ljhj sjof }clbwi

jmjijd pgrlj{jijdjo dwhwl bwhjo pgosgig{jcjo dwhwl/ Bjdhjo

lgoclbwihjo heoaich sjof bgrheoe}j{c {jicof lgosjijdhjo) {jicof

lgowmwd) mjo ijco,ijco/67

Awof{c w}jlj dwhwl jmjijd wo}wh lgicomwofc hgpgo}cofjo sjof

jmj mjijl lj{sjrjhj}/ [gpgr}c sjof mcbjdj{ pjmj }epch {gbgiwlosj

mjijl heo}gh{ hgpgo}cofjo lgowrw} Re{keg Pewom/ Rcokcjo mjrc }cjp,}cjp

hgpgo}cofjo }gr{gbw} bwhjo lgrwpjhjo mja}jr sjof lw}ijh }g}jpc

bgrwbjd,wbjd {g{wjc mgofjo pgrhglbjofjo lj{sjrjhj}/ Njmc) {jofj}

mcpgofjrwdc eigd vjh}w mjo heomc{c lj{sjrjhj}/61

Jpjbcij {w{wojo hgpgo}cofjo,hgpgo}cofjo }gr{gbw} mc{w{wo

{gbjfjc {w{wojo sjof }cmjh bgrwbjd,wbjd) ljhj {w{wojo }gr{gbw}

bwhjo ijfc {gbjfjc {ekcji gofcoggrcof }g}jpc lgrwpjhjo pgrosj}jjo

peic}ch $ljocag{}e peic}ch66#/

K/ Peic}ch Dwhwl Lgowrw} Arcgmrckd Hjri qeo [jqcfos

Arcgmrckd Hjri qeo [jqcfos sjof lgosj}jhjo bjdvj dwhwl c}w

}cmjh mcbwj} lgijcohjo }wlbwd mjo bgrhglbjof bgr{jlj,{jlj mgofjo

67 Cbcm/61

Ljdlwi [crgfjr/ Ep kc}/66 Ljocag{}e peic}ch jmjijd pgrosj}jjo peic}ch pjrj pgofwj{j/

;0


31/45

lj{sjrjhj}/ Heo{gp coc mcpgofjrwdc eigd jfjlj ${wprjoj}wrji#) {gpgr}c

djiosj sjof bgrijhw mc Comeog{cj $pgofjrwd lj~djb {gnjrjd# mgofjo

bgrijhwosj dwhwl jmj} sjof mc}go}whjo eigd hg{gclbjofjo ljfc{,

rgicfcw{ $he{lc{#/64

Bgrmj{jrhjo co}c }gerc Qeo [jqcfos > {glwj dwhwl pjmj lwijosj

mcbgo}wh mgofjo kjrj {gpgr}c sjof mchj}jhjo erjof) dwhwl jmj}) mgofjo

bjdj{j sjof bcj{j }g}jpc }cmjh }grijiw }gpj}) mcbgo}wh sjhoc bjdvj dwhwl

c}w lwijc,lwij mchglbjofhjo eigd jmj} hgbcj{jjo mjo hgpgrkjsjjo sjof

wlwl/ Bjrw hglwmcjo eigd swrc{prwmgo{c) njmc mcljoj,ljoj eigd

hghwj}jo mjijl sjof bghgrnj mcjl) }cmjh eigd hgdgomjh {gvgojof,

vgojof mjijl pglbwj}jo womjof,womjof/ Qeo [jqcfos lgoghjohjo

bjdvj {g}cjp lj{sjrjrjhj} lgofglbjofhjo dwhwl hgbcj{jjosj

{gomcrc) hjrgoj lglpwosjc bjdj{j) jmj} c{}cjmj} $}grlj{wh hgpgrkjsjjo#

mjo heo{}c}w{c sjof hdj{63/

[gpgr}c sjof mchj}jhjo eigd Kjri qeo [jqcfos) mjpj} mcicdj} lgijiwc

pglbwj}jo dwhwl mjo awof{c w}jlj dwhwl) sjc}w >

:/ Pglbwj}jo Dwhwl

Dwhwl bwhjo lgrwpjhjo heo{gp mjijl lj{sjrjhj} hjrgoj

dwhwl }wlbwd {gkjrj jijlcjd mjijl pgrfjwijo lj{sjrjhj} sjof ljoj

dwhwl {gijiw bgrwbjd {gcrcof pgrwbjdjo {e{cji/40

64 C Ljmg Jrsg W}jlj/ Dwhwl Icofhwofjo/d}}p>%%beeh{/feefig/ke/cm%beeh{5cm


32/45

Mgofjo pgrosj}jjo [jqcfos sjof mglchcjo c}w ljhj dwhwl mc

{j}w ogfjrj }cmjh mjpj} mc}grjphjo% mcpjhjc eigd ogfjrj ijco hjrgoj

lj{sjrjhj}osj bgrbgmj,bgmj bgfc}w nwfj mgofjo hgbwmjsjjo sjof jmj

mc {wj}w mjgrjd {wmjd pj{}c bgrbgmj pwij) mjijl dji }glpj} mjo vjh}w

nwfj bgrbgmj/4:

Peheh,peheh jnjrjo lj~djb dc{}erc{ sjof mcwrjchjo [jqcfos mjo

bgbgrjpj pgofchw}osj mjpj} mc{clpwihjo {gbjfjc bgrchw}42 >

, Dwhwl sjof mc}glwhjo }cmjh mcbwj}/ Pgr}wlbwdjo dwhwl pjmj

mj{jrosj jmjijd pre{g{ sjof }cmjh mc{jmjrc mjo erfjoc{8 eigd

hjrgoj c}w pgrwomjof,womjofjo jmjijd hwrjof pgo}cof

mcbjomcofhjo mgofjo jmj} hgbcj{jjo8

, Hjrgoj dwhwl bgrhglbjof mjrc dwbwofjo,dwbwofjo dwhwl sjof

lwmjd mcpjdjlc mjijl lj{sjrjhj} prclc}ca hg dwhwl sjof igbcd

helpigh{ mjijl pgrjmjbjo lemgro hg{jmjrjo wlwl }cmjh mjpj}

igbcd ijlj ijfc lgoeoneihjo mcrcosj {gkjrj ijof{wof) }g}jpc

mc{jnchjo eigd pjrj jdic dwhwl sjof lgrwlw{hjo prco{cp,prco{cp

dwhwl {gkjrj }ghoc{/ ]g}jpc jdic dwhwl }g}jp lgrwpjhjo {wj}w

erfjo mjrc hg{jmjrjo wlwl }grchj} pjmj }wfj{ wo}wh lglbgrc

bgo}wh pjmj jpj sjof cj }glwhjo {gbjfjc bjdjo lgo}jd

$hg{jmjrjo wlwl }jlpjhosj eigd [kdei}go mc{gbw} {gbjfjc

hg{jmjrjo dwhwl#/ Pgrwomjof,womjofjo lgosw{wi pjmj }cofhj}

4: ^wihjrojco/ Hrc}ch ]grdjmjp Pglchcrjo Dwhwl Lj~djb [gnjrjd/d}}p>%%icbrjrs/w{w/jk/cm%mevoiejm%ad%ad,~wihjrojco/pma/ 2004/ d/ =/

42 Vji}gr Arcgmljo/ ]gerc ! Aci{jaj} Dwhwl ]gijjd Hrc}c{ j}j{ ]gerc,]gerc Dwhwl

$[w{wojo C#/ Mc}grngljdhjo eigd Lwdjlljm Jrcaco/ Kg}/ CC/ P]/ Rjnj FrjacomePgr{jmj) Njhjr}j/

;2
http://library.usu.ac.id/download/fh/fh-zulkarnain.pdf.%202008.%20h.%204http://library.usu.ac.id/download/fh/fh-zulkarnain.pdf.%202008.%20h.%204


33/45

jhdcr8 eigd hjrgoj jdic dwhwl {gbjfjc pglbwj} womjof,womjof

rgij}ca igbcd pgo}cof mjrcpjmj pglbwj} womjof,womjof8 mjo

, Womjof,womjof }cmjh mjpj} bgrijhw j}jw mc}grjphjo {gkjrj

wocqgr{ji/ [g}cjp lj{sjrjhj} lgofglbjofhjo hgbcj{jjoosj

{gomcrc hjrgoj lglpwosjc bjdj{j jmj},c{}cjmj} mjo heo{}c}w{c

sjof hdj{/ [jqcfos lgoghjohjo bjdvj bjdj{j mjo dwhwl

jmjijd {gnjnjr nwfj }cmjh mjpj} mc}grjphjo pjmj lj{sjrjhj} ijco

mjo mjgrjd,mjgrjd ijco/ Qeihfgc{} mjpj} mcicdj} mjijl dwhwlosj

eigd hjrgoj c}w {jofj} pgo}cof wo}wh lgofchw}c gqeiw{c qeihfgc{}

lgijiwc pgogic}cjo {gpjonjof {gnjrjd/

FJLBJR CQ > Ciw{}rj{c Dwhwl Bgrj{ji mjrc Bjvjd $Be}}el Wp#

Njmc) dwhwl c}w bgrj{ji mjrc bjvjd hg j}j{/ Mjijl heo}gh{ bjvjd

coc mjpj} mcicdj} bjdvj dwhwl bgrj{ji mjrc lj{sjrjhj} sjof mcvjhcihjo

eigd Mgvjo Pgrvjhcijo Rjhsj} $MPR# {gbjfjc vjhci rjhsj} mc mjijl

pglgrco}jdjo/ Jpj sjof mccofcohjo eigd lj{sjrjhj} jhjo mcj{pcrj{chjo

PGLGRCO]JD

LJ[SJRJHJ]

D W H W L

;;


34/45

eigd MPR sjof {gijonw}osj mcbwj} womjof,womjofosj mgofjo j}jw }cmjh

pgr{g}wnwjo mjrc Prg{cmgo) hjrgoj MPR lglpwosjc djh coc{cj}ca mjijl

pglbwj}jo womjof,womjof sjof mjpj} mc{gbw} be}}el wp/4;

Ojlwo) coc{cj}ca MPR mjijl pglbwj}jo womjof,womjof }cmjh

lglgo}cofhjo hgpgo}cofjo rjhsj}) hjrgoj }cmjh jmj sjof be}}el wp/

]cmjh bgrclbjofosj pgrwlw{jo womjof,womjof jo}jrj Pglgrco}jd mjo

MPR) {gpgr}c sjof mchj}jhjo eigd Bc{ljr Oj{w}ceo/4=

2/ Awof{c W}jlj Dwhwl

Heo{gp ncvj lj{sjrjhj} mjijl }gerc [jqcfos }go}jof dwhwl coc

}cmjh mjpj} lgowonwhhjo {gkjrj ngij{ bjfjcljoj c{c mjo rwjof

icofhwposj/ [gdcoffj jlj} {wic} lgicdj} awof{c mjo pgrhglbjofjoosj

{gbjfjc {wlbgr w}jlj dwhwl lgowrw} }gerc coc/47

4; Bc{ljr Oj{w}ceo/ Ep kc}/4=

Bc{ljr Oj{w}ceo/ Ep kc}/47 ^wihjrojco/ Ep kc}/ d/ 4/

;=


35/45

BJB CQ

PGRBJOMCOFJO ]GERC DWHWL RE[KEG PEWOM MJO ARCGMRCKD

HJRI QEO [JQCFOS

J/ Pgr{jljjo

Pgr{jljjo jo}jrj }gerc dwhwl Re{keg Pewom mjo Arcgmrckd Hjri

qeo [jqcfos jmjijd }grig}jh pjmj kjrj pjomjof hgmwj pjrj jdic }gr{gbw}

lgofgojc dwhwl sjc}w {jlj,{jlj lgijiwc hjkj lj}j {e{cji sjof }cmjh

}grigpj{ mjrc lj{sjrjhj}/

B/ Pgrbgmjjo

Pgrbgmjjo jo}jrj }gerc dwhwl Re{keg Pewom mjo Arcgmrckd Hjri

qeo [jqcfos) mjpj} mcicdj} mjrc41>

j/ J{ji dwhwl) nchj Re{keg Pewom bgrpgomjpj} bjdvj dwhwl

c}w bgrj{ji mjrc j}j{ hg bjvjd $j}j{ mc{gbw} mgofjo

pgofwj{j) {gmjofhjo bjvjd mc{gbw} mgofjo lj{sjrjhj}#

{gmjofhjo [jqcfos bgrpgomjpj} bjdvj dwhwl c}w bgrj{ji

mjrc bjvjd hg j}j{ $bjvjd mc{gbw} mgofjo lj{sjrjhj})

{gmjofhjo j}j{ mc{gbw} mgofjo pgofwj{j#8

b/ Awof{c dwhwl) nchj Re{keg Pewom lgofj}jhjo bjdvj

awof{c dwhwl wo}wh lgicomwofc hgpgo}cofjo sjof jmj

mjijl lj{sjrjhj}) {gmjofhjo [jqcfos }cmjh mjpj}

lgowonwhhjo {gkjrj ngij{ bjfjcljoj pgr{sjrj}jo mjrc

41 Bc{ljr Oj{w}ceo/ Ep kc}/

;7


36/45

{wj}w ncvj lj{sjrjhj} c}w {gdcoffj lgosgbjbhjo }cmjh

mjpj} lgofglwhjhjo awof{c dwhwl }gr{gbw}/

;1


37/45

BJB Q

]GERC SJOF MCPJHJC MJIJL PGLBGO]WHJO DWHWL MC

COMEOG[CJ

Mj{jr dwhwl pglbgo}whjo pgrj}wrjo pgrwomjof,womjofjo mc

Comeog{cj mjpj} mcicdj} mjrc Womjof,Womjof Oe/ :0 ]jdwo 200= }go}jof

Pglbgo}whjo Pgrj}wrjo Pgr,Womjof,Womjofjo mjijl Bjb T

lgogfj{hjo jmjosj pjr}c{cpj{c lj{sjrjhj} sjc}w {gpgr}c sjof mcj}wr

mjijl Pj{ji 7;/46

Lgowrw} pgrj}wrjo pgr,womjof,womjofjo sjof mc{gbw}hjo mc j}j{)

hgosj}jjoosj lgowonwhhjo bjdvj pgofjrwd lj{sjrjhj} mjijl

lglpgofjrwdc pglbgo}whjo dwhwl) lgomjpj} }glpj} mjo jprg{cj{c

sjof bgfc}w iwj{/ ]gerc sjof mcpjhjc mjijl dji pglbgo}whjo dwhwl

jmjijd }gerc Arcgmrckd Hjri qeo [jqcfos $qeihfgc{}#/ Bjdvj womjof,

womjof mcbgo}wh mjrc ncvj lj{sjrjhj} hjrgoj lj{sjrjhj} mcchw}hjo

pjr}c{cpj{cosj wo}wh lgosjlpjchjo j{pcrj{cosj {gpgr}c sjof

mcpgrco}jdhjo eigd womjof,womjof/

Pglbgo}whjo dwhwl mc Comeog{cj {gijiw mcpgofjrwdc eigd {wj}w

hgpgo}cofjo,hgpgo}cofjo/ Hghwj{jjo peic}chijd sjof lglcichc

hgpgo}cofjo }gr{gbw}/ Hghwj{jjo peic}ch }gr{gbw} mwmwh mc mjijl co{}c}w{c

wo}wh lgijhwhjo igfc{ij{c hgpgo}cofjo/ Njmc) hghwj{jjo peic}ch mjpj}

lglpgofjrwdc dwhwl/ ]jpc) pgofjrwd hghwj}jo,hghwj}jo peic}ch mjijl

46 Pj{ji 7; Womjof,Womjof Oe/ :0 ]jdwo 200= }go}jof Pglbgo}whjo Pgrj}wrjoPgr,Womjof,Womjofjo sjof lgosj}jhjo bjdvj > Lj{sjrjhj} bgrdjh

lglbgrchjo lj{whjo {gkjrj ic{jo j}jw }gr}wic{ mjijl rjofhj pgoscjpjo j}jwpglbjdj{jo rjokjofjo womjof,womjof mjo rjokjofjo pgrj}wrjo mjgrjd/

;6


38/45

lglbgo}wh dwhwl mcbj}j{c rwjof fgrjhosj mgofjo bgrijhwosj {c{}gl

heo{}c}w{ceoji bgrmj{jrhjo kdgkh jom bjijokg{44) {gpgr}c sjof mcjow}

Womjof,Womjof Mj{jr :3=7 {g}gijd pgrwbjdjo/43

Mjijl dji coc pglgrco}jd sjof lglbwj} womjof,womjof wo}wh

mcnjijohjo lj{sjrjhj}) igbcd hgpjmj {wj}w rghjsj{j {e{cji/ Njmc) pjmj

hgosj}jjoosj pglbgo}whjo dwhwl mc Comeog{cj lgoffwojhjo }gerc

Re{keg Pewom ${ekcji gofcoggrcof# sjof }ep mevo/

Keo}ed Pgrj}wrjo Pgr,Womjof,Womjofjo

Mjijl dji coc mjpj} hc}j icdj} }grigbcd mjdwiw mgofjo }gerc Re{keg

Pewom ${ekcji gofcoggrcof#) sjc}w > Womjof,Womjof Oe/ : ]jdwo :36=

}go}jof Pgrhjvcojo/ Pjmj Pj{ji 6 Jsj} $:#/30 Pglgrco}jd lgijhwhjo

rghjsj{j {e{cji wo}wh lglpgrijlbj} ijnw pgr}wlbwdjo pgomwmwh mc

Comeog{cj mgofjo lgogo}whjo wlwr pgrhjvcojo/

3:

Nchj lgicdj} }gerc mjrc Arcgmrckd Hjri qeo [jqcfos $qeihfgc{}#) sjc}w >

Womjof,Womjof Oe/ 7 ]jdwo :333 }go}jof Ijrjofjo Prjh}gh Leoepeic

mjo Pgr{jcofjo W{jdj ]cmjh [gdj}/ Mc{coc lj{sjrjhj} }cmjh

lgofcofcohjo jmjosj leoepeic pgrmjfjofjo) njmc {gbjfjc

44 Djlmjo ^egiqj/ Kdgkh jom Bjijokg{ [s{}gl Mjijl WWM :3=7 Pj{kjPgrwbjdjo/ d}}p>%%djlmjo~egiqj/vermprg{{/kel%2004%::%04%kdgkh{,jom,bjijokg{,{s{}gl,mjijl,wwm,:3=7,pj{hj,pgrwbjdjo%/ 2004/ Kdgkh jombjijokg{ jmjijd {wj}w {c{}gl hg}j}jogfjrjjo mc Comeog{cj mjijl djipgofjvj{jo mjo pgrclbjofjo hghwj{jjo) lgofw}cp Ierm Jkh}eo kdgkh jombjijokg{ mc}grjphjo hjrgoj pglw{j}jo hghwj{jjo pglgrco}jdjo mc {j}wkjbjof jhjo lglpgrbg{jr hglwofhcojo }grnjmcosj pgosjijdfwojjohghwj{jjo mjo dgfgleoc j}j{ kjbjof,kjbjof hghwj{jjo pglgrco}jd ijcoosj/

43 Djlmjo ^egiqj/ Pgofjrwd [c{}gl Peic}ch mjijl Pglbgo}whjo Dwhwl mcComeog{cj/ Ep kc}/

30 Pj{ji 6 Jsj} $:# Womjof,Womjof Oe/ : ]jdwo :36= }go}jof Pgrhjvcojo)lgosgbw}hjo bjdvj > Pgrhjvcojo djosj mcc~cohjo nchj pcdjh prcj {wmjdlgokjpjc wlwr :3 ${glbcijo bgij{# }jdwo mjo pcdjh vjoc}j {wmjd lgokjpjc

wlwr :1 $gojl bgij{# }jdwo/3: Bc{ljr Oj{w}ceo/ Ep/ kc}/

;4
http://hamdanzoelva.wordpress.com/2008/11/08/checks-and-balances-system-dalam-uud-1945-paska-perubahan/.%202008http://hamdanzoelva.wordpress.com/2008/11/08/checks-and-balances-system-dalam-uud-1945-paska-perubahan/.%202008http://hamdanzoelva.wordpress.com/2008/11/08/checks-and-balances-system-dalam-uud-1945-paska-perubahan/.%202008http://hamdanzoelva.wordpress.com/2008/11/08/checks-and-balances-system-dalam-uud-1945-paska-perubahan/.%202008


39/45

pgrvjhcijoosj MPR lgofjnwhjo RWW }gr{gbw} wo}wh mc{jdhjo eigd

Prg{cmgo/32 Ojlwo) mchjrgojhjo Pglgrco}jd nwfj lglpwosjc hgdgomjh

sjof {jlj mjijl pgofjnwjo RWW }gr{gbw} ljhj WW Oe/ 7 ]jdwo :333

}go}jof Ijrjofjo Prjh}gh Leoepeic mjo Pgr{jcofjo W{jdj ]cmjh [gdj}

}gr{gbw} lgljhjc }gerc hgmwj pjrj jdic/

32 Bc{ljr Oj{w}ceo/ Ep/ kc}/

;3


40/45

BJB QC

HG[CLPWIJO MJO [JRJO

J/ Hg{clpwijo

Mjijl pgowic{jo ljhjijd coc) mjpj} mc}jrch hg{clpwijo jmjijd

lgowrw} Re{keg Pewom) dwhwl bgrj{ji mjrc j}j{ hg bjvjd $}ep mevo#/

J}j{ {jlj mgofjo Pglgrco}jd ijiw bjvjd {jlj mgofjo lj{sjrjhj}8

{gmjofhjo lgowrw} Arcgmrckd Hjri qeo [jqcfos) dwhwl bgrj{ji mjrc

bjvjd hg j}j{ $be}}el wp#/ Bjvjd {jlj mgofjo Mgvjo Pgrvjhcijo

Rjhsj} $MPR# mgofjo hj}j ijco {gbjfjc pgrvjhcijo rjhsj} ijiw j}j{ {jlj

mgofjo Pglgrco}jd sjof lgigfc}clj{c hgljwjo lj{sjrjhj} }gr{gbw}/

Dwhwl sjof mc}grjphjo mc Comeog{cj hgbjosjhjo bgrj{ji mjrc

bjmjo gh{ghw}ca }cmjh mjrc igfc{ij}ca) {gdcoffj dwhwl igbcd kgomgrwof

hgpjmj hgielpeh,hgielpeh sjof lglgfjof hghwj{jjo/

Hgbgrjmjjo dwhwl jmj} }cmjh pgrojd jhjo lwomwr j}jw }grfg{gr

mjrc pgrkj}wrjo peic}ch mjijl lglbjofwo dwhwl oj{ceoji) dji }gricdj}

mjrc }grvwnwmosj hg mjijl dwhwl oj{ceoji sjc}w mgofjo lgofjofhj}

dwhwl rjhsj}% dwhwl jmj} lgonjmc dwhwl oj{ceoji }gricdj} pjmj oj{hjd

[wlpjd Pglwmj pjmj }jdwo :324 bjdvj dwhwl jmj} ijsjh mcjofhj}

lgonjmc dwhwl oj{ceoji sjof lemgro/ Lgofwhwdhjo dwhwl jmj} jhjo

bgrjr}c lgofwhwdhjo piwrjic{lg dwhwl mjo }cmjh bgrpcdjh hgpjmj

dwhwl oj{ceoji sjof mcwocachj{chjo $mjijl vwnwm hemgachj{c# mjo cmg

hemgachj{c mjo wocachj{c mcprjhjr{jc heieocji sjof bgrvjvj{jo

=0


41/45

wocqgr{jic{}c{) mcljoj dwhwl jmj} jmjijd dwhwl sjof lglcichc pgrj{jjo

hgjmcijo lj{sjrjhj} iehji sjof piwrjic{}c{) mgofjo lgofcofj} bjdvj

dwhwl heieocji mcjoffjp {jofj} bgr}go}jofjo mgofjo dwhwl jmj}

jmjijd lgrwpjhjo }wfj{ mjo helc}lgo Pglgrco}jd wo}wh lgijhwhjo

wocachj{c mjo hemgachj{c hg mjijl dwhwl oj{ceoji }gr{gbw}/

Ijv j{ j }eei ea {ekcji gofcoggrcof) bjrw {cjp mgofjo rjlbw,

rjlbw pglbj}j{ mjo bgiwl {cjp mgofjo ji}groj}ca pe{c}ca sjof djrw{

mcvwnwmhjo) mcljoj dwhwl oj{ceoji djrw{ bgrmj{jrhjo dwhwl jmj}) mjo

nwfj {g{wjc mgofjo Pjokj{cij mjo WWM :3=7/

Cmg ijv j{ j }eei ea {ekcji gofcoggrcofjmjijd wo}wh lglawof{chjo

dwhwl fwoj lgrghjsj{j hgdcmwpjo gheoelc oj{ceoji {jnj mgofjo }cmjh

lgiwpjhjo dwhwl }j}j ogfjrj/

Dwhwl heieocji {gkjrj aerlci lj{cd bgrijhw mjo {gbjfcjo hjcmjd,

hjcmjdosj lj{cd lgrwpjhjo dwhwl pe{c}ca Comeog{cj bgrmj{jrhjo

hg}go}wjo pgrjicdjo) }gricdj} }grnjmc pgrfgrjhjo hg jrjd peij,peij dwhwl

Grepj $Bgijomj#/

]grnjmc pgr}go}jofjo jo}jrj dwhwl heieocji mgofjo dwhwl jmj}

jmjijd lgrwpjhjo }wfj{ mjo helc}lgo Pglgrco}jd wo}wh lgijhwhjo

wocachj{c mjo hemgachj{c hg mjijl dwhwl oj{ceoj) mcljoj bjmjo

hgdjhcljo mccmgjihjo lgonjmc djhcl sjof bgbj{ {gr}j pglbjfcjo

hghwj{jjo mjijl pglgrco}jdjo jmjijd djrjpjo {gbjfjc bjmjo sjof

ljomcrc mjo hrgj}ca wo}wh lgrco}c{ pglbjdjrwjo dwhwl igvj}

lgofjr}chwij{cjo dwhwl mjo lerji rjhsj}) }gijd lgijhwhjo heo{eicmj{c

mgofjo mwhwofjo peic}ch lcic}gr mjo }epjofjo bcrehrj{c sjof mc{}rwh}wrhjo

=:


42/45

{gkjrj leoeic}ch {gr}j lwmjd mcheo}rei {gkjrj {go}rji) lgfcofj} pgrjo

dwhwl jmj} mjijl pglbjofwojo dwhwl oj{ceoji {jofj} lgomg{jh

sjof {gkjrj rcci }cmjh }grkj}j} }grijiw bg{jr) }grhgkwjic hijcl jhjo

hgbgojrjo lerji) pjmj {jj} lj{jijd epgrj{ceojic{j{c mjo pgofgagh}cajo

}grdjmjp pjdjl dwhwl {gbjfjc pgrghjsj{j mc }jofjo Pglgrco}jd sjof

igbcd gagh}ca/

B/ [jrjo

Jmjpwo sjof cofco pgowic{ {jlpjchjo mc{coc jmjijd {gdjrw{osj

bjmjo igfc{ij}ca {gbjfjc pglbwj} womjof,womjof igbcd lgofw}jljhjo

hgpgo}cofjo lj{sjrjhj} $hgljwjo lj{sjrjhj}# mjrc pjmj hgpgo}cofjo

prcbjmc j}jw feieofjo) }grbwh}c mgofjo bjosjhosj womjof,womjof sjof

mcbwj} eigd MPR mcjnwhjo hg Ljdhjljd Heo{}c}w{c wo}wh mcwnc hglbjic/

=2


43/45

MJA]JR PW[]JHJ

Jbmwd) Lwdjlljm/ Lj}grc Pgrhwicjdjo [e{ceiefc Dwhwl/ [gheijd Pj{kj[jrnjoj Wocqgr{c}j{ [wlj}grj W}jrj/ 2004/

Jfw{}cjo}e/ Peic}ch Dwhwl mjijl Gheoelc [sjrcjd/ d}}p>%%hj{gc,worc/erf%comgt/pdp5ep}ceo%%vvv/hjlw{dwhwl/kel%hjlw{dwhwlUgo}rcg{/pdp5Ufeieofjo'20hgpgo}cofjo'20%'20co}grg{}'20frewpU!cmgo}


44/45

d}}p>%%vvv/hjlw{dwhwl/kel%hjlw{dwhwlUgo}rcg{/pdp5Ufeieofjo'20pgoghjo'20%'20prg{{wrg'20frewpU!cmgo}%%vvv/fgekc}cg{/kel%RjcoAerg{}%Qcog{%;;16%ehj/d}li/2004/

Ljojo) Bjfcr/ ]wfj{ Djhcl > Jo}jrj Lgijh{jojhjo Awof{c Dwhwl mjo]wnwjo Dwhwl/ vvv/bjmcijf/og}/ 2004/

Oj{w}ceo) Bc{ljr/ Kj}j}jo Pgrhwicjdjo Peic}ch Dwhwl/ [gheijd Pj{kj[jrnjoj Wocqgr{c}j{ [wlj}grj W}jrj/ 2004/

[jovjoc/ Kj}j}jo Pgrhwicjdjo [gnjrjd Dwhwl/ [gheijd Pj{kj [jrnjojWocqgr{c}j{ [wlj}jrj W}jrj/ Lgmjo/ 2004/

[glbcrcof) NN/ Jl{}reof/ Dwbwofjo Jo}jrj Dwhwl mjo Peic}ch/d}}p>%%frgj{s/kel%helpjr}j%dwbwofjoUjo}jrjUdwhwlUmjo/d}li/2004/

[crgfjr) Ljdlwi/ Lemwi Pgrhwicjdjo ]gerc Dwhwl > ]gerc,]gerc DwhwlPe{c}cqc{lg Dwhwl/ [gheijd Pj{kj [jrnjoj Wocqgr{c}j{ [wlj}grjW}jrj/ Lgmjo/ 2004/

[crgfjr) Ljdlwi/ Lemwi Pgrhwicjdjo ]gerc Dwhwl > ]gerc,]gerc Dwhwl[ekceiefckji Nwrc{prwmgokg/ [gheijd Pj{kj [jrnjoj Wocqgr{c}j{[wlj}grj W}jrj/ Lgmjo/ 2004/

[eaj/ Pgomghj}jo ]gerc}c{ mjo Peheh,Peheh Pgofgr}cjo Helwochj{cPeic}ch/ vvv/lj{{eaj/vermprg{{/kel/ 2004/

[eaj/ Heo}rei [e{cji/ vvv/lj{{eaj/vermprg{{/kel/ 2004/

[wojrlc/ Lemwi Pgrhwicjdjo [gnjrjd Dwhwl/ [gheijd Pj{kj [jrnjojWocqgr{c}j{ [wlj}grj W}jrj/ Lgmjo/ 2004/

[wojrlc/ Pgrhglbjofjo Dwhwl Pgrmj}j [gnjh Heieocji {jlpjcHglgrmghjjo/ d}}p>%%icbrjrs/w{w/jk/cm%mevoiejm%ad%pgrmj}j,

{wojrlc1/pma/ 2004/

==
http://www.kamushukum.com/kamushukum_entries.php?_golongan%20penekan%20/%20pressure%20group_&ident=1920http://www.kamushukum.com/kamushukum_entries.php?_golongan%20penekan%20/%20pressure%20group_&ident=1920http://www.geocities.com/RainForest/Vines/3367/oka.html.%202008http://www.geocities.com/RainForest/Vines/3367/oka.html.%202008http://www.badilag.net/http://greasy.com/komparta/hubungan_antara_hukum_dan.html.%202008http://greasy.com/komparta/hubungan_antara_hukum_dan.html.%202008http://www.massofa.wordpress.com/http://www.massofa.wordpress.com/http://library.usu.ac.id/download/fh/perdata-sunarmi6.pdf.%202008http://library.usu.ac.id/download/fh/perdata-sunarmi6.pdf.%202008http://www.kamushukum.com/kamushukum_entries.php?_golongan%20penekan%20/%20pressure%20group_&ident=1920http://www.kamushukum.com/kamushukum_entries.php?_golongan%20penekan%20/%20pressure%20group_&ident=1920http://www.geocities.com/RainForest/Vines/3367/oka.html.%202008http://www.badilag.net/http://greasy.com/komparta/hubungan_antara_hukum_dan.html.%202008http://greasy.com/komparta/hubungan_antara_hukum_dan.html.%202008http://www.massofa.wordpress.com/http://www.massofa.wordpress.com/http://library.usu.ac.id/download/fh/perdata-sunarmi6.pdf.%202008http://library.usu.ac.id/download/fh/perdata-sunarmi6.pdf.%202008


45/45

]clegr/ Pgrhglbjofjo Dwhwl mc Comeog{cj [gpjonjof Lj{jPglgrco}jdjo Ermg Bjrw/ d}}p>%%vvv/biefkj}jief/kel%frewp%bief,

prele}ceo,:%mc{kw{{%go}rs%pgrhglbjofjo,dwhwl,mc,comeog{cj,{gpjonjof,lj{j,pglgrco}jdjo,ermg,bjrw/2004/

Womjof,Womjof Oe/ : ]jdwo :36= }go}jof Pgrhjvcojo/

Womjof,Womjof Oe/ :0 ]jdwo 200= }go}jof Pglbgo}whjo Pgrj}wrjoPgr,Womjof,Womjofjo/

W}jlj) C Ljmg Jrsg/ Dwhwl Icofhwofjo/d}}p>%%beeh{/feefig/ke/cm%beeh{5cm

Documents

Roscoe Pound & Friedrich Karl Von Savigny Mempengaruhi Politik Hukum Di Indonesia_II_Agung Yuriandi